Question 98
THE THIRD PART: Of thankefulnes.
Question.
But may images be suffered in Churches to be in steed of bookes to the ignorant multitude?
Answere.
No, in no wise: for it becommeth not vs to bee wiser then God, who will haue his Church taught not by dumbe images, but by the liuely preaching of his word.
The Exposition.
Because1 the superstitious sort do alwaies seek som shift when they are taken, so as they cannot escape, but must needes be conuinced, that by this commandement is condemned all worshipping of images, they demand again, whether it bee not lawfull at least to haue them in Churches, to serue in steed of bookes for ignorant multitude, wherby they may be put in mind to worship God.
Where first they sinne in that in a mocke, & reprochfully they terme them idiotes or lay men, whome the Lord acknowledgeth for his disciples, and to whom hee vouchsafeth to reueile his heauenly philosophie, and whom he will haue instructed in the wholesome mistery of his kingdome.
Secondly this is a very false rule, although it bee set downe by a great authour, that images are to bee suffe-2 in Churches, that they may serue the ignorant people in steede of bookes: Against which let vs set that one saying3 of the Apostle, which is most sufficient to controll it: What agreement hath the Church of God with images? which although it be vnderstood of the Spirituall temple of the faithful, to wit, of their hart, yet seeing his meaning is to haue all Christians generally farre from all shew of idolatrie, it may also not vnfitly be applied to this present argument.
Which also may euen hereby bee confirmed, that before Paule, Ieremie the Prophet in his time called a carued4 peece of wood, or an Idole, a doctrine of vanitie, & Habacuk5 a molten image, a teacher of lies: from whence may6 be gathered this generall doctrine, that it is but vaine and lying, whatsoeuer men learne of God by images, so farre are they from seruing in steed of bookes: whereas on the other side experience it selfe is witnes: how easily earthly and fond conceites of God doe come into the mind of man, by these outward images, which it is hard afterward by long preaching to pull and roote out of their mindes: so that Augustine said very well: Images7 are more able to corrupt the poore soule, by reason they haue mouths, eies, ears, & feet, then to reform them, because they speake not, neither see, nor heare, nor walke: as also it is by8 him very well obserued out of Varro, an excellent learned Romane, that the Gods were worshipped of the Romanes aboue an hundreth and seuentie yeares without any image, and addeth out of him: Which if it had continued, the Gods should be more purely serued. and afterward: that they who first set vp before the people images of the gods, they did both take away all feare and reuerence out of their cities, and also bring in errour.
Last of all, for this maketh that, which was decreed against images in the Eliberine Conncil. Cap. 36. in this9 sort: It was thought good to haue no pictures in Churches, least that which is serued and worshipped should bee painted vpon the walles.
2. But why images ought not to be suffered in Churches for that ende, this reason is alledged in the Catechisme: That it is not meet for men to go about to bee wiser10 then God himself, who hath ordained not idoles, & dumb images, such as are described by the Prophets, but the liuelie preaching of the Gospell to instruct his people.
Surely he himselfe knew better then we how we were to be instructed vnto saluation, and therefore meant to preuent11 this superstition, and gaue vs the Scripture, and the liuely12 preachinge of the Gospell to direct vs in his seruice: Therein it is taught that Christ dyed to beare our curse vpon the crosse, to satisfie for our sinnes by the sacrifice of his body, and to wash them away by his blood, finally to reconcile vs vnto God the Father: to what purpose then was it to haue euery where in Churches so many crosses set vp, of wood, of stone, of siluer & gold: whereas by Christ alone painted out in the preaching of the Gospell, and in a manner crucified before our eyes, and by hearing and reading of the Scripture, and meditation in the worde, & by the vse of the Sacraments, wee might learne more, then out of a thousand crosses of wood or stone?
Surely Paul glorieth that hee did notablie paynt out Christ13 before the Galathians, not in images, but in the preaching14 of the Gospell, & in the sacraments: the same Apostle to the Corinthians, would know nothing but Iesus Christ, and him crucified: which manner of teaching if15 they, who afterward had the rule of the Churches, had followed, surely it had gone better with the Church of God, and the saluation of men, then when their teachers resigned the office of teaching to idols, after them selues waxed dumbe, and so they became blinde leaders of the blinde.
Last of all, if we consider to what vse Churches were allotted, it seemeth altogeither a disgrace to their holynesse to receiue any other images, then those liuely and most significant images, which the Lord hath sanctified by his word, to wit, Baptisme, & the Lords supper with other ceremonies, wherewith it is meete that our eyes be both more attentiuely held, and more liuely affected, then that they should require any other, framed by the wit of man, with which onely images the olde Church for the space of aboue fiue hundreth yeares, when religion and sounde doctrine did most of all flourish, was content: in so much that idoles were then first admitted for16 the beautifying of the Churches, when the sinceritie of the ministerie had somewhat swerued, and Epiphanius worthily cōmended, that seeing in a certain Church a hanging, hauing painted in it the image of Christ or of some Saints, hee rent it, and wrote to the Bishop of the place, not to suffer such images in Churches.
The Vse.
Which being so: First, the Ministers of the worde hereby are17 admonished, wherein they ought principally to labour, when they liue among those, who as yet reteyne Idoles in their Churches, namelie in this, to cast the idoles out of the mindes of men as much as may bee by the preaching of the Gospell. Secondly, the people, whose duetie likewise it is not to flie vnto idoles, but to the Ministers and true seruauntes of Christ, out of whose mouth they may heare howe God will be serued, forasmuch as the Scripture is the onelie booke both for the learned and for the lay people: from whence wee may continually18 drawe that which may suffice for our instruction and doctrine. Last of all, the Magistrate himselfe, as the keeper of the Lawe of God, ought by his authoritie to prouide that images may be taken away, after the example of Godly Kinges, as Ezechias, and Iosias, &c. who are for this matter commended in the Scriptures.
1 That images are not to be suffered in Churches and why.
2 Greg.ep.109. l.7. Item ep.l.9.
3 2.Cor.6.16.
4 Ier.10.3
5 Habac.2.18
6 An idole is a doctrine of vanitie.
7 August.in Psal.113.
8 Lib.4.de Ciu. dei.l.9.31.
9 Canon. Conc. Tom.1.
10 Psal.1.15.5
11 2.Tim.3.16.17.
12 2 Pet.1.19.
13 Gal.3.1.
14 1.Cor.2.2.
15 Math.19.14.
16 Epiph.epist.ad Ioan.epis.Ierosolomi.
17 2.King.13.1.2.3.
18 2.King.18.4. & 23.4. Deut.7.5.& 12.3.