An Exposition or Commentarie upon the Catechisme of Christian Religion (1589), Jeremias Bastingius · PDF

Question 48

THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.

Question.

And are not the two natures in Christ by this meanes pulled asunder, if the manhead be not wheresoeuer the Godhead is?

Answere.

Not a whit: for seeing the Godhead cannot bee conteined in any compasse, and is present in all places: it followeth necessarily that it is without the nature of man which it hath taken, and yet neuertheles is in it also, & remayneth personally vnited vnto it.

The Exposition.

Another obiection of the aduersaries is this: If the humane nature in Christ, which was taken of the Godhead to be one person with it, be not euery where present and in all places wheresoeuer the Godheade is, that then by this meanes the natures are diuided and pulled asunder, and the vnion of them taken quite away, & in a worde that nothing followeth thereon but this, that Christ in one onely place is both God and man, & in all other places is onely God, which, say they, is it not cleerly, openly, and plainely to make two persons and two Christes.

For fit answere to this obiection and this argument, we must first of all call to minde, that although we confesse and say that the body of Christ, by reason it is a true body, is contayned within a certain compasse, and is at once but in one onely place: yet wee do not denye, but that the Godhead of Christ in all places hath the manhead which it tooke, fast ioyned and vnseparablie knit vnto it: But yet it followeth not hereof, that therefore wheresoeuer the Godheade is, there also the manheade is, and that this stretcheth it selfe as farre as that, and much lesse that when we so thinke & speake, we meane to separate, or pull asunder the natures in Christ, or that by so speaking they can bee separated or pulled in sunder.

For1 the diuine nature is not contayned within any compasse, which is euery where present and is not in any one place, either as2 limited within the compasse of it as our bodies are, or3 beeing onely there, though not4 taking vp any space, as the Angels: but is wholly in5 all places essentially, and when it is present, it is not present6 as the word without flesh, but as the word incarnate, and the same Godhead which is present vpon earth, doth so beare vp his manhead which is in heauen, that it neuer forsaketh it, & that it hath no other beeing, but in the Godhead vnited vnto it. But yet the manhead is not therefore present vpon earth: for there is one manner presence of the Godhead, which is infinite, and another manner presence of the manhead, which is finite, and is contayned within some compasse of place, and whether it is present in substance, there the presence of tt is limited within a space: for example: the soule7 and the body are thinges vnited in man, of nature indeed vnlike, but yet both finite. But the soule in a moment by her thoughtes wandreth in the vttermost part of the worlde, where as the body is still contayned within the space of one certaine place, and yet must wee not imagine any separation, or pulling asunder of the soule from the bodie,

The light of the Sunne is vnseparably ioyned to the body of the Sunne, and yet it followeth not that the bodie of the Sunne reacheth as far as the light therof spreadeth, and yet for all that there is no separation or pulling asunder of the light and bodie of the Sunne.

And if it be true that no such separation followeth in things finite, and yet more neerely vnited one to the other: it is certen that it followeth much lesse in thinges of vnlike nature, whereof the one is of a compound matter and finite, the other most simple and infinite.

Wherefore seeing the humane nature in Christ is finite, & the diuine nature incomprehensible & infinite, what absurditie is it to say, that the diuine nature, as being not contayned in any compasse, and beeing present in all places, is indeed without the nature of man which it hath taken, but yet it is also in it, and remaineth vnited vnto it? no otherwise then the light of the Sunne, because it reacheth further then the bodie of the Sunne, and is spread ouer all the world, it may indeede be said to bee without the bodie of the Sunne, and yet neuerthelesse is in the bodie of the Sunne, and remayneth in the same, as being ioyned with it, so long as it shall so please the Creator.

Hereupon saith Athanasius in a certaine place: The8 word is not shut vp within the bodie, neither when it is present in the bodie, is it absent elsewher, neither whē it moueth the bodie are other things void of the power, the working, & the prouidence thereof: but which is greatly to be marueiled at, it being the word comprehendeth all things, & is comprehended of none.

And not without cause it is againe expressed & repeated in the Catechism, that the deuine nature is personally vnited to the humane nature of Christ, that so there may a difference be shewed between the dwelling, wherby the deuine nature dwelleth in Christ, and whereby it dwelleth in vs, & in all the godly & elect. For the aduersaries doe vrge, that except we graunt aswell the manhead, as the Godhead of Christ to bee euery where, that there will bee no difference betweene Christ, and vs that are the godly. But it hath beene shewed that the essentiall difference, whereby the vnion of the true natures of Christ is discerned from all other maner of Gods presence, or inhabiting or coniunction, standeth not in the equall and ioynt extending and stretching of the humane nature as farre as the deuine: but in this, that those thinges, which belong onely to one nature beeing considered9 in him selfe, are by the figure Synedoche ascribed to the whole person, not respecting the diuersitie of natures, and that by reason of the meere vnion of both natures the one with the other: for the Godhead is10 vnited vnto the manhead bodily, that is, personally: so that Christ God and man is one person, and of those two natures ioyned togeither becommeth one Christ, which is not so in the godly. For they become not one person with God (for Peter is one, and God is another: but in Christ there is not one, and another) but he dwelleth in them onely as a working, gouerning, and sanctifying cause: but of Christ being one it is saide, that in him alwayes and continually, as it were in the proper house (for so is the worde dwell vnderstood) doeth the fulnes of the Godhead dwell bodily: as Paul speaketh to the Colossians.

And therefore it followeth very well in the text, that the11 deuine nature both is in the humane nature, to wit, keeping12 and sauing to ech nature his owne properties13, and doeth also remayne personally vnited vnto it: for as this persō the WORD is euerlasting, so is it afterwarde impossible, that this masse of the flesh taken vnto the Godhead, shoulde not likewise remayne with it: as Damascene truely saith: The nature of man, which the worde hath once taken, it neuer forsaketh.

The false doctrine.

Out of this doctrine of ours concerning the two natures in Christ, & their properties not confounded, who seeth not that we abhorre the herisie both of Nestorius, and Eutyches, which our aduersaries doe as it were call backe agayne from the dead? of Nestorius (I say) imagin Christ to haue two persons: & those being seperated & asunder, and not only to haue14 two natures: and therfore that the Sonne of God is seuerally and apart in Christ, and the Sonne of God is one, & the Sonne of Marie another, and not onely another nature.

Next of Eutyches: whose opinion what it was, appeareth out of his owne words and answere, which being questioned withall, he made in the Council of Chalcedon: I know that Christ15 was of two natures before they were vnited: but after the vniting of them, I know and acknowledge but one nature in him: whereupon the same man, also saide, that after the taking of yͤ flesh the properties of both natures were confounded, which indeed followed of the former. Therefore the Council of Chalcedon plainly and euidently to condemne both the errours, did say that Christ being one & the same person did consist not of two substances alone, but of two natures, without confounding of the natures, without changing the one into the other, without parting or pulling of them in sunder: for the fathers did vse the word Nature to shew yͭ not only the substances themselues, that is, the Godhead and the manhead remained in Christ after the vnion of thē, but also that their seueral properties remained, and were neither lost, nor chaunged: To this errour that of the Vbiquitaries commeth neere16, who confound nature and person, man and the nature of mā, and make it all one to say, Man and manhead, God and Godhead.

1 How the diuine nature is euery where.

2 Circumscriptiue.

3 Definitiue.

4 Ierem.22.24.

5 2.Paral.2.6.

6 Act.7.49.& 17.28.

7 A similitude.

8 Athan. de humanitate verbi.

9 How God dwelleth in Christ and how in the elect.

10 Coloss.2.9.

11 Rom.1.3.

12 1.Pet.3.18.

13 Iohn 3.13.& 1.15.

14 Nestorius. See Theod. Presbyt.Rhas tens.aduersus hereses.

15 Euag.lib.2. cap.16. Eutiches.

16 See Colloq. Mulb.excus. Tubing.