Question 106
THE THIRD PART: Of thankefulnes.
Question.
Why, but this commaundement seemeth to forbid onely Murder?
Answere.
For the staying of murder, God teacheth, that he hateth the roote and originall of murder, to wit, anger, enuie, hatred and desire of reuenge: and doth account all these for murder.
The Exposition.
The former doctrine is here confirmed, by way of moouing of an obiection: for we being fleshly and grosse in the vnderstanding of heauenly thinges, when we heare the Law thou shalt not kil, straightway our mind conceiueth it according to the letter, that is, of outward and violent murder: therefore it was needfull more diligently and by degrees to lay open all the vices, that are forbidden in this commandement, and which may any way be the beginning and cause of harme and hurt, and which hinder humane societie from beeing delightfull and quiet.
And so in the first place is forbidden Wrath, not euery kind1 of wrath (for that which proceedeth of a iust cause & keepeth it selfe within due measure, & such as Christs was2, Mar.3.5. and such as Paule speaketh to the Ephes. is not found fault with in the worde of God) but that which is a fiery and hot boiling of blood, which desireth and seeketh after reuenge of iniury done vnto vs thereafter as we our selues doe value it: whereof Christ speaketh: But I say vnto you, whosoeuer is angrie with his brother vnaduisedle, is capable of iudgement: and the Apostle: Let all wrath be done away34: which also to the Galat.5 he reckoneth vp among the workes of the flesh.
And that this doth bring forth murder, it is manifest out of the holy history, which witnesseth that Abel was slaine by Cain6 his brother being angrie: for so before he went to his worke, Moyses reporteth that the Lord spake to Cain: Why art thou wroth? why is thy countenance cast downe? And Herode being angry (saith Matthew) commaunded7 the Infants in Bethelem and rounde about it, of two yeares old and vpward to be murdered: therefore well saith Iames: Let euery man be quicke to heare, and slow to speake, and slow to wrath: for the wrath of man doeth not accomplish8 the righteousnes of God.
And the verses of the Poet are well knowen;
Wrath9 is a short mad fitte: then rule thy affection, if not,
It rules thee: then raine it vp hard, lay fetter vpon it.
Secondly Enuie,1011 which is a grudging of the minde at another mans good, which bringeth vnto him either gaine or glorie: wherupon saith the same Poet: The man of enuie pines, when he viewes the wealth of another. Cain is an12 example hereof: who tooke an occasion of quarrell vpon this, that he saw God had regarde to Habels offering and13 not to his; and nothing else set on Iosephes brethren or take counsel first to kil Ioseph, then to sel him, but the14 plague of envie: and nothing else stirred vp Saul in the manner of an enimie to pursue Dauid, who had well deserued of the common wealth of Israel, but enuie: for all envious men are glad of other mens harmes, & reioyce at the mischances both of their equals, & of their superiours, whereupon they are easily thrust forwarde by the deuill to hurt their neighbour: therefore when God forbiddeth murder, hee will haue this as beeing oftentimes the originall and cause of murder to be farre from Christians, and to be earnestly auoided: therefore also saith the Apostle: Let vs not be desirous of vaine glorie, prouoking one another, envying one another, and writing of loue: Loue15 (saith the Apostle) enuieth not.
To these two former degrees is added a thirde, that is, hatred: which is nothing else but anger long kept and16 growen, which God forbidding in another place, saith, Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thine heart, but thou shalt17 plainely rebuke thy neighbour & suffer him not to sin. Nowe hatred is not onely a despising of our brother, but also a spitefull minde towards him, which when it hath long continued is called Rancour, because it is more hard and18 digested spitefulnes, whereupon Iohn saith: He that hateth19 his brother is a manslaier, and wee know that no manslaier2021 hath eternal life abiding in him: And Paul reckeneth hatred among the workes of the flesh, which whosoeuer commit, shall not bee heires of the kingdome of God.
To these is added priuate reuenge, which most men, yea almost all of vs are by nature sicke of: so that the poet truely saide.
Why but it is more sweete then life for a man to reuenge22 him: this God doth often and straightly forbid, when hee23 saith: Vengeance is mine, and I will reward: also: Say not, I24 will recompence euill for euill: and, See that no man requite25 euill for euill.2627
It is true indeed that all these sorts of murder are not set downe euery one by their names, which God did for this ende, partly that no man might pretende ignorance of the doctrine of the Law, either for the darkenesse or for28 the largenes of it (as men are very wittie & cunning to deuise such excuses) partly that when it is certen that these vices also, as wrath and hatred are accounted of God for secret manslaughter, wee may the better vnderstand how abhominable they are in the sight of God, by whose sentēce they are tangled with so horrible a sinne, and so being mooued by this iudgement, may be accustomed better to weigh the grieuousnes of those sinnes, which before seemed light: to conclude, may more abhorre from outward and violent murder, and may consider that we are placed together of God in this worlde, as in one familie, to the ende we should preserue among our selues peace and concord one with another, laying aside all quarelling, brawling, crying, with all maliciousnes, as the Apostle to the Ephesians most wisely teacheth.
1 Wrath.
2 Eph.4.26.
3 Mat.5.12.
4 Ephe.4.31
5 Gal.5.20
6 Gen.4.6.
7 Mat.2.16.
8 Iam.1.19.20.
9 Horat. epist. lib.1.2.ep.
10 Rom.1.19.
11 Ennie
12 Gen.4.5.
13 Gen.37.4.5
14 1.Sam.18.8.9.
15 1.Cor.13.4.
16 Hatred.
17 Lev.19.17.
18 Rancour.
19 1.Ioh.3.15.
20 1.Ioh.29.11.
21 Gal.5.26.
22 Iuvenal.lib. 5.Satyr.1.
23 Deut.32.35.
24 Heb.10.30.
25 Prov.20.22.
26 1.Thes.5.15.
27 1.Pet.3.9.
28 Why God in conceiuing the rules of his law set downe but some one part for all the rest.