Question 46
THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.
Question.
How doest thou vnderstand that: He ascended into heauen.
Answere.
That in the sight of his disciples Christ was taken vp from earth to heauen, and is yet there for vs, and shalbe till he come againe to iudge the quicke and the dead.
The Exposition.
To his resurrection is not vnfitly ioyned his ascending into heauen: for although Christ began more fullie to show his glorie and his power by rising againe, hauing put of the abiect and base condition of mortall life, and laide aside the shame of the crosse, yet did hee then indeede beginne his kingdome, when he ascended into heauen.
Now because the name of heauen hath many significations1, we must first of all shew of what heauē this article is vnderstood: for first heauen is taken for the firmament, which cōteineth whatsoeuer is sene in this visible world, in2 which firmament God hath set the Sōne & the Moone & the rest of the stars: Secondly therby is ment the aier, as when Christ saith the foules of heauen, that is, which flie3 in the ayer. Thirdly it is taken for a certeine place which4 in this life we cannot see, cōceiue nor vtter, where God5 dwelleth with the blessed Angels & spirits, & there sheweth6 himselfe to be seene face to face, as he is, filling his7 chosen children with wisedome, righteousnes, zeale, glorie89 and immortallity, such and so great, as neither eie hath10 seene, nor eare hath heard, nor euer entred into the hart11 of man.
This12 is called the seate, the throne, the house & dwelling of God, not that god is there shut vp, for he is infinite, and cannot be conteined in any roome, but because hee doth there more familiarly reueile his glory and his maiestie then vpon the earth: and of this heauen doe wee speake in this place, into which Christ did truely ascend, as Luke doth more at large set foorth his historie of his ascention in the actes, from which this exposition of the Catechisme is fetched, according to which we may rightly and most agreeably to the Scriptures define Christs ascention in this manner.
The13 ascention is a visible taking vp, and receiuing or lifting14 vp of Christs manhead from earth to heauen and aboue all heauens, where he is still for vs, and shall remayne, vntill hee come to iudge the quicke and the dead.
For so the Euangelistes and the Angels doe expound the15 worde (ascend) And when he had spoken these things hee was16 taken vp in their sight: So saide the Angels to the Disciples: Ye men of Galilie why stand ye gazing into heauen, this Iesus who is taken vp from you into heauen, shall so come as you haue seene him go into heauē: where the words of lifting and taking vp: doe expresse a true change of place, whereto belongeth the circumstance of the place, Out of the mount of Oliues, from whence they that were there might see round about whither the cloud that17 receiued him, did carrie him, namely vpward, or rather18 into very heauen, or the house of his father, as he had foretold a little before his death.
The same Luke deliuereth the same storie in the Gospel in other words to kike effect: And it came to passe that as he blessed them, he departed from them and was carried vp into19 heauen where the first word, departed, doth expresse a seperation from the place & persons, where and with whome he was before: the latter word sheweth the place whither: he was carried vpward, to wit, into the aier & into the clouds and from thence into very heauen, the seat of the blessed Angels and men.
Which afterwarde the Apostle did more plainely set forth, that no man might doubt of Christs ascention: Hee that20 descended is euen the same that ascended farre aboue al heauens, that he might fil al things: & vnles it were so, the admonition of Paul were vnsufficient, when he exhorteth the Colossians to seeke those things that are aboue, and to meditate of heauenly things taking his argument frō the21 ascention of Christ into heauen Seeke those thinges that are aboue, wher Christ sitteth at the right hand of God.
2. Moreouer as Christ did truely ascend into heauen, so it is certen that hee is still there for vs, according to his promise, I goe to prepare a place for you, and, I tell you the trueth22, it is expedient for you that I goe away, for if I go not away, that comforter will not come to you, but if I depart, I will send him vnto you.
Besides he shall bee and remaine there vntill he come againe to iudge the quicke and the dead, to which the words of the Angell had relation he shall so come as you haue seene him going into heauen: the meaning wherof Peter23 afterward expounded, saying: the heauens must conteine him24 vntil the time that all things bee restored, which shall then be, when he shall come againe to iudgement.
Hereof Paule, that we should not seeke Christ bodily vpon earth, commaunded the supper of the Lord according to his institution to be celebrated in remēbrance of25 him, vntill his comming agayne, signifiing that Christ, who according to his humanitie is in heauen, shall there remaine, vntil he come againe to iudgement. And Peter when he saith, whom the heauens must containe, vnderstandeth not that to bee with any inconuenience vnto Christ, but for vs, that is, for the great good of the elect.
Out of all which without controuersie it is gathered that Christ did verily ascend into heauen, where he was not before in bodie, aboue & without this visible world, & that he is no more to be sought according to his manhead, & bodily vpon this earth: for for that cause, after he was taken vp, did a cloude receiue him from the eyes of his disciples, that for euer after they might knowe that they ought to reach into heauen with the eies of faith,. & that they were to bring the mouth of faith vnto the holy supper, that they might effectually and vnto saluation be made partakers of his flesh and bloud.
Now26, if any man not content with this sinceritie and simplicity of doctrine, do inquire, whether Christ bee in a certen place, & where, & after what sort hee is in heauen27, and whether we assigne vnto him any certen region of heauen: Let him heare Augustine thus aunswering: Where and after what sort Christs bodie is in heauen, forasmuch as it is ouer curious, & needlesse to enquire, wee must onely beleeue that it is in heauen: for it is not for our weakenes to dispute about the secrets of heauen, but it belongeth to our faith to bee wise with sobrietie in the high knowledge of the excellency of the Lords bodie.
The false doctrine.
With this article of Christs ascending into heauen doth fight, first that the Vbiquitaries do confound his ascension with his incarnatiō for so one of their captaines speaketh: What neede we speake of the time of Christs resurrectiō, &28 ascensiō seeing that euē frō the beginning in the very momēt of his incarnatiō he did inuisibly ascēd into heauē, & did sit at the right hand of God his father? Secondly that the same mē wil needs haue Christs body to be yet in the earth, & that in the bread, vnder the breade, and with the bread the bodie of Christ is giuen to them that are partakers of his supper: for how29 can he be in the bread of whom Peter saith, Whom the heauens must containe? how can he inuisiblie lie hid vnder bread, of whom the Angels witnessed, that he shold not return but30 as his Apostles had seen him going vp? but he ascended visibly, and so shall he return, say those witnesses of al other most true. To conclude, how can hee be dodily in the supper, in remembrance of whom the supper was by himselfe ordayned? & of whom Paule saith, vntill his comming againe? But this their31 errour ariseth hereof, that these men turne his ascension32 into a vanishing out of sight, and thinke of heauen as of some33 deuised thing, and that there is no such thing indeede, contrarie to the doctrine of Christ, I go to prepare a place for you, & of Paul: He ascended aboue all heauens: also that think heauen to be euery where: which absurditie being granted, heauen & earth are confounded, Satan, and hell are in the kingdome of heauen, wicked men and deuils are in the house of the Lord, & which is horrible, Christ, the Angels, & the elect are in hell: finally this shift is openly confuted by the Scripture distinguishing & separating heauen from earth: in the Psalms: Who is like vnto the Lord our God, who hath his34 dwelling on high, who humbleth himselfe to behold things in heauen and in the earth?
And35 : The heauens, euen the heauens are the Lordes, but he36 hath giuen the earth to the sonnes of men: and Ecclesiastes37: Be not rash with thy mouth, nor let thine hart be hastie to vtter a thing before God, for God is in the heauens, & thou vpon earth.
Esay38: Thus saith the Lord, heauen is my seat, & earth is my footstoole, And if heauen it selfe, and the heauen of heauens containe not God, heauen cannot bee there wheresoeuer God is.
1 Three significations of heauen.
2 Gen.1.1.8.
3 Psal.8.9.
4 Mat.6.26.
5 Eph.6.12.
6 Mat.18.10.
7 1.Cor.13.12.
8 2.Cor.12.2.
9 1.Iohn 3.2.
10 Psal.103.19
11 1.King.18.30.
12 Iohn 14.2.
13 The ascention of Christ.
14 Eph.4.10.
15 Act.1.9.11:
16 How the Euangelists doe expound the word ascend.
17 Mar.16.19.
18 Ioh.14.1.2.
19 Luk 24.51
20 Eph.4.10.
21 Col.3.1.
22 Iohn 14.2 Iohn 16.7. Heb.4.24. & 7.25.
23 Act.1.11.
24 Act.3.11.
25 1.Cor.11.25. 26.
26 Whether Christ be in heauen as in a certē place.
27 De fide & symbolo, cap.6.
28 Brent, de vnione person.p.25
29 Consubstantiation.
30 Musc. in artic. de cena dom. quos Ecclesiis & scholis Marchionatus obtrusit.
31 Brent. recog.p. 149. & 150.
32 Iohn.14.2.
33 Ephes.4.10.
34 Psal.113.5.6.
35 Psal.115.16
36 Eccl.5.1.
37 That heauen is not euery where.
38 Esa.66.1.