An Exposition or Commentarie upon the Catechisme of Christian Religion (1589), Jeremias Bastingius · PDF

Question 113

THE THIRD PART: Of thankefulnes.

The Arg. That euē euery smallest desire cōtrarie to charitie ought to be put out of mens minds: 2. Of the proceeding of the godly in the obedience of the Law: 3. And what the vse of the law is in this life.

Question.

What doth the tenth Commaundement forbid?

Answere.

That our harts be neuer tēpted no not with the least desire or thought against any cōmandemēt, of God, but that alwaies from the heart we detest all sin, and contrariwise take pleasure in all righteousnes.

The Exposition.

The Lawgiuer hauing in the rest of the commandements1 dealt with those sinnes especially, which stand in deedes and are done of purpose, or with an aduised consent of the will (although there is no doubt but that the Lawe of restrayning concupiscence is implied, and included in all the former commaundements(nowe last of all in this last Law he dealeth with those sinnes which are called onely concupiscence, and doe conteine all inwarde stirring and conceit in the vnderstanding and affections against euery commaundement of the Lawe, and are as it were riuers boyling out of the fountayne of that originall sinne.

The2 Catechist declareth as much when hee teacheth that in this commaundement is forbidden euen euerie least desire and thought against any commandement of God: and contrariwise is commaunded a continual & syncere hatred of all sinne, and a loue and carefull imbracing of all righteousnes.

Whereupon3 Concupiscence is vsually defined all corrupt lust, or affection and inclination, whereby the heart of man is tempted to doe any thing that is contrarie to the commaundements or Lawe of God, that so it may be distinguished from naturall concupiscence, whereby wee desire those thinges which make for the preseruation of our selues and of our nature, by ordinary meanes, and according to the right iudgment of reason, which is good and necessary.

Moyses for the capacitie of the ignorant people, expoundeth this corrupt concupiscence, by those things which it desireth, & when he had saide, thou shalt not couet thy neighbours house, he reckneth vp the parts of it, beginning with the wife, & shutting it vp with these words, his oxe, his asse, or any thing that is thy neighbours, he sheweth that it is not only vnlawfull for vs to couet great matters, as house, nobilitie, and glorie, when they belong to another man, but euen small matters, as those are, whether they be things with life, or without life.

But4 Paul hauing to do with them that knew the Law, thought it sufficient to say shortly, thou shalt not Couet; that by this meanes he might shewe that there are not two diuerse commaundements deliuered togeither, but onely one commandement; as also in the same place hee declareth how necessary the vnderstanding of this commaundement5 is, when intreating of concupiscence he saith: I had not knowne concupiscence to be sinne, except the Law had said, thou shalt not couet.

And because hee felt in him selfe some stirring or passions of this concupiscence, (which was common to him with all Saints) therefore hee calleth the same concupiscence the Lawe of sinne: and Iames when he saith: Euery6 man is tempted, when he is ledde away and snared of his owne concupiscence, ascribeth vnto it two things: to wit: that it draweth away mans heart from good, and that it snareth mans affections, so that it ouertaketh him before he beware.

And7 Iohn according to the principall & such thinges as men most desire, as pleasure, ritches and honour, doth also distinguish the sorts of concupiscence, when hee saith8: All that is in the world, as the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes, & the pride of life, taking the differences from the first motiues that stirre vp lust, the more fully to shew the springs of all euill in the world.

To conclude, whatsoeuer concupiscence it bee, and whether it haue his beginning within a man, as the lust of the flesh, which is intised by the flesh it selfe, that is, the corruption whereby it is caried to those things that are9 sweet to the flesh, as pleasures in meats, and drinks, & venerie10, or whether it be stirred vp by any thing without a man, which commeth in by the eies, as the lust of the eies and the pride of life, which is conceiued by looking vpō & wondring at any thing, both sorts are condēned.

And not onely those kindes, but euen euery thought & fansie11 in the soule against the law of God is here forbidden, and all excuses are cut off, as that the first motions are not in mans power, and that fansies which roll confusedly in the minde, and at length vanish away, deserue not to be accounted for concupiscences, the seate whereof in the heart: for the Prophet also knewe that, and yet neuerthelesse he intreated God saying: Who vnderstandeth12 his fault,? O clense thou me from my secrete faults13: Next is to be marked that such kinde of fansies are14 here spoken of, which running in the minde, do withall bite & strike the minde with some desire, for as much as it neuer cōmeth in a mans minde to desire any thing, but the heart stirreth and leapeth at it.

And15 hereby appeareth the difference betweene ciuile lawes of men and Gods lawes for they are content with an outwarde discipline and good order, but these require aboue all the cleannesse of the hearte: likewise betweene the doctrine of the Church and Philosophie: for the philosophers blame concupiscence, but not that nice concupiscence, whereof wee here speake, but that grosse concupisence which is occupied about to much seeking16 after gold, which Plato calleth a beast with many heades: whereby this or that thing forbidden in the Lawe of God: is in deede and actuallie lusted for and desired: but the Apostle calleth it the roote of all euill.

2. And as all corrupt desire or thought is forbidden, so the same Lawe GOD commaundeth vs alwaies and from the hearte to detest all sinne, and contrariwise to take pleasure in all righteousnesse which is a most present remedie to put to flight all lustes; And to the ende wee may bee able to performe that first thing, it will bee necessarie for vs, that beeing cleere of all hypocrisie, wee doe not winke not so much as at the least fault, and that wee so doe continuallie and constantlie: for when the Lorde saieth by the Prophet17: hate euill and doe good: and, thinke not euery man euill in18 your harts, for all these are the things that I hate, hee signifieth that as him selfe alwayes and perfitelie doeth hate19 euerie euill thing, so it is our parte to detest, whatsoeuer is contrarie to his most holie lawe, which also20 Christ ment to point at by cutting of hands & feet, &c. And this is one poynt: The second thing that the Lorde requireth of vs is, to take pleasure in all righteousnesse: For when hee forbiddeth euill and commandeth good, if it bee our duety to hate all euill, it is our duety also to loue all righteousnes, and to delight in all holines, to bee continually occupied in the studie of the Lawe of God, & the practise of the same, and especially to preferre God himselfe, who is the soueraigne good, and the loue of him euen before those, who are neerest & dearest vnto vs, & euen before our life.

Which being so, who seeth not that in this last commandement is required and contained the perfite obedience of the whole lawe? for how commeth it to passe that wee sinne against euery commandement, but because this corrupt concupiscence is in vs? without which we should of our owne accorde, with our whole minde & body striue to attaine to the onely good, altogether without any contrary thought or mammeringe: but so long as it cleaueth vnto vs, it cannot be but that we shal all21 offende both very often, & in many thinges, & shall eftsoones grone and lament with the Apostle, saying: O wretched man that I am, who shall deliuer me from the body of this death?

The false doctrine.

Wherefore seeinge that euen the least desire or thoughte is22 condemned of the Lorde, that decree of the Tridentine Councill23 is blasphemous and wicked, which I haue set downe worde for worde as it was taken from thence. Hanc concupiscentiam, quam aliquando Apostolus peccatum appellat, sancta Synodus. declarat Ecclesiam Catholicam nunquam intellexisse peccatum appellari, quod vere & proprie in renatis peccatum sit, sed quia ex peccato est, & ad peccatum inclinat: si quis autem contrarium senserit Anathema sit: that is, This concupiscence, which the Apostle sometime calleth sinne: the holy Synode declareth that the Catholike Church did neuer vnderstande to bee called sinne because it is truely and properlie sinne in the regenerate, but because it commeth of sinne, & inclineth vnto sinne: if any man thinke the contrary, let him be Anathema or accursed: wherein they both decree agaynst the Apostle himselfe: But I see another Lawe in my members rebellinge against24 the Lawe of my mind, and leadinge mee captiue into the Lawe of sinne which is in my members: and they gainesay themselues: for if this concupiscence boyle out of originall sinne as out of a fountayne, and that is damnable, because (as Viguerius writeth) for this sinne wee are called the children of wrath, & consequently are guiltie of death and condēnation, it followeth that cōcupiscence also is sinne before God, & doth deserue condemnation. But in the25 regenerate, they say it is venial or pardonable. I answere, that this is an vndoubted principle, that all sinnes are mortall according to Paules rule, but that the sinnes of holy men are venial they haue it not of their owne nature, but attaine it by the mercy of God. And it is well said of Augustine. In weighing of sinnes let vs26 not bring deceitful balances, wherein to weigh that we wil, and howe we wil, saying as we list our selues, this is heauy, this is light, but let vs bring Gods ballance out of the holy scriptures as out of the Lords treasures, therein let vs weigh what is heauier, or rather let vs not weigh, but acknowledge them as there they are weighed.

1 The difference betweene the tenth commaundement and the former.

2 The deuision.

3 What concupiscence is.

4 Rom.7.23.

5 Rom.7.23.

6 Iam.1.24.

7 Diuers sorts of concupiscenses.

8 1.Ioh.2.16.

9 Mat.5.27.

10 Rom.8.6.

11 What fansies are condumned & why

12 Psal.19.13.

13 Mat.5 27.

14 Rom.8.6.

15 The differēce betweene the doctrine of the Church & Philosophie.

16 1.Tim.6.10.

17 Amos 5.16.

18 Zach.8.17,

19 Mat.12.37. 39.

20 Mat.5.30.

21 Rom.7.24.

22 Sess.5.ca.1.de pecc.Orig.

23 Rom.7.23

24 Inst.c.11.23

25 Rom.6.21.

26 Lib.2. de bapt. cap. 2.