An Exposition or Commentarie upon the Catechisme of Christian Religion (1589), Jeremias Bastingius · PDF

Question 102

THE THIRD PART: Of thankefulnes.

Question.

Is it not lawfull to sweare by Saintes, and other creatures?

Answere.

No: for a lawful oth is a calling vpon God, wherein a man desireth, that he being the only beholder of the hart, wold giue witnes to the trueth, and punish the swearer, if hee deceiue wittingly: Now this honour agreeth to no creature.

The Exposition.

Hauing refuted the errour of the Anabaptistes, now he commeth to refute another error, which haue preuailed among the Romanistes, touching a peruerse manner of swearing by Saintes, and other creatures, the absurditie whereof is prooued from a definition of the lawfull1 right of swearing.

And first this is to be knowen, that as the Lorde doeth expressely cammaund and set downe, howe we ought in a godly manner to sweare by his name, so hee hath also forbidden2 vs to sweare by other Gods: for so he saieth in Iosua: Cōpanie not with these nations which remaine among you, nether make mention of the name of their gods, nor cause to sweare by them, neither serue them, nor bow vnto them.

And in another place hee is bitterly angrie with them, who sweare by other gods, and construeth that kinde of swearing3 to bee an argument of mainifest falling from God: Thy children haue forsaken me, & sworne by them that are no gods.

And4 in the same Prophet hee promiseth saluation to the Gentiles, if as they haue taught their people to sweare by Baal, so now they will sweare by his name, and account that manner of swearing by other gods to bee accursed.

The forme which God prescribed to the olde people doth5 euidently prooue the same: for hee cammaundeth them to sweare, The Lord liueth: & not Abraham, Isaac, and Iacob liueth.

Whereto6 also belongeth that which God foretolde to Esay of the consent of the people of the Old and Newe Testament, in the same religion, to witte, that it woulde come to passe, that euery knee should bee bowed before him, & euery tongue should confesse vnto him, not to Saints, or other creatures.

So7 the Psalmist professeth that hee will not take the names of Idoles in his lippes, which if it bee vnlawfull, much lesse it is lawfull to sweare by Saints.

Yea8 the Lorde threatneth by his Prophet destruction, to them, who sweare by the sinne of Samaria, and saye The Lorde thy God liueth which is in Dan, and the way of Beersheba9 liueth, And in Zophonie, I will destroy, saith the Lord, them that sweare by Malchom.

For10 whereas Moyses writeth that Ioseph did sweare by the11 head & life of Pharaoh, that othe fell from him, when by long company with idolaters, he had learned some of their manners: and custome of speaking, and therefore is not to bee followed: And then such kindes of speach are rather asseuerations, then othes, as, This is as sure as Pharao doth now truely liue, that is most sure.

2 Now why it is not lawfull to sweare by Saintes or creatures,12 it appeareth more plainely by the definition of an othe, which is, a calling vpon God, wherein a man desireth,13 that he beeing the onely beholder of the heart, would giue witnesse to the trueth, and punish the swearers, if hee deceiue wittingly: whereupon such a reason may bee framed: That honour which is onely due to God, is not to be giuen to any creature: but to sweare, which is to call God as the beholder of the heart to witnesse to a mans owne soule, the Scripiure challengeth onely to God; Therefore it is vnlawfull to sweare by creatures.

And that an othe is a calling vpō God, appeareth both by1415 the commaundement of God him selfe, who wil haue no16 man sweare but by his name, and by the examples of godly, who haue so sworne.

And it is such a calling vpon God, wherein hee that sweareth desireth two things at the handes of God: First, that he will be a witnesse of those things which are affirmed or denyed vpon othe, Secondly, that hee will bee a reuenger, if hee deceiue wittingly: for ignorance excuseth him that sweareth from periurie.

For the first: that is, to giue witnesse to the trueth, it is required, that hee which can doe it, be the beholder of the heart, and knowe all thinges; for otherwise howe can hee be a witnesse of those thinges, which hee knoweth not, whereof he doubteth, and him selfe is vncerten.

For the latter, that is, that hee may be able to punish him17 that swereth of subtilty, & set purpose to deceiue, he must be indued with such power, whereby hee can doe whatsoeuer he will, & will do whatsoeuer he threatneth in his worde: but neither the one honour nor the other agreeth to any creature, but onely to God: therefore it is not lawfull nor allowable to sweare by creatures.

For so God challengeth to him selfe alone the beholding of the heart, and power to punish the wicked, The heart is deceitfull and wicked aboue all things, who can know18 it? The Lord searcheth the heart & trieth the reines, euen to giue euery man according to his waies, and according to the fruit of his workes.

And Solomon: Thou onely knowest the heart of all the19 Sonnes of men.

Hereto may bee added, that in the fourth Councill of Carthage20 wee are forbidden to sweare by creatures: the words21 are: A clerke swearing by the creatures is most sharplie to be rebuked, if he persist in his vice, is to be excommunicated.

Last of all it is not from the purpose that the Apostle witnesseth, when he writeth, that men in their othes doe appeale to an higher then them selues, & that God, because22 hee hath no greater then his own glory did sweare by him selfe, whereof it followeth that he is then greatly dishonoured, when by manifest impiety we set in his stead his holy seruants swearing by them, because by that meanes the glorie of the Godhead is set ouer vnto them.

Which being so, it is a manifest errour of the popish sort, & a foule idolatrie, when they confirme their othes by Saintes, against the worde of God, and to the dishonour of them, who beeing vpon earth, them selues taught and did contrarie.

1 Whether it be lawfull to sweare by Saints.

2 Iosua 23.7.

3 Ier.5.7.

4 Ier.12.16.

5 Ier.4.2.

6 Esa.45.23.

7 Psal.16.4.

8 Amos 8.14.

9 Zoph.1.6.

10 Gen.42.15.

11 An obiection preuented,

12 What a lawful othe is.

13 2.Cor.1.23.

14 Ier.17.10.

15 Mat.5.34.

16 Iam.5.12.

17 Esa.43.13.

18 Ier.17.9.10.

19 1.King.8.39.

20 Can.4.

21 Can.16.

22 Heb.6.13.16.