An Exposition or Commentarie upon the Catechisme of Christian Religion (1589), Jeremias Bastingius · PDF

Question 63

THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.

Question.

How sayest thou that our good works deserue nothing, whereas God promiseth that he will giue vs a rewarde for them, both in this life, and in the life to come?

Answere.

That rewarde is giuen, not of desart, but of grace.

The Exposition.

Here is a further pressing of the former obiection: For I confesse, will some man say, that our good workes being compared with the righteousnesse of Gods Lawe, doe not attaine vnto it: yet not in vayne is there a rewarde promised vnto them: whereby it appeareth that they deserue somewhat in the sight of God: to which obiection the answere is very fitly made, that the cōsequence is not good from rewarde to merite, as they vse to speake in the Schooles.

Wherefore that we may also vntye this knot. 1. Let vs prooue out of the holy Scriptures, that there is a reward promised and giuen to good woorkes. 2. Let vs diligently consider howe the same is promised and giuen.

1. And first that there is a rewarde promised to those that1 are giuen to good woorkes, both in this present life, and in the life to come, Christe witnesseth in many places: as, Loue your enemies, and doe good vnto them, and lende,2 looking for nothing againe, and your rewarde shall be great,

Whosoeuer3 shall giue but a cuppe of colde water to any of these little ones, in the name of a disciple, verely I say vnto you, he shall not loose his rewarde.

Againe4: When thou makest a feast call the poore, the maimed, and the lame, and thou shalt be blessed: for they can not recompence thee, but thou shalt be rewarded in the resurrection of the Iust.

So5 saith Iohn. Looke to your selues, that wee loose not the thinges which we haue done, but that we may receyue a full rewarde.

And6 Paul: Who shall rewarde euery man according to his workes, to them that continue in well doing, glorie, honor, and immortalitie, that is, to them who seeke life euerlasting.

Last of all, Christ himselfe by this ioyfull sentence doeth confirme, that a rewarde shall bee certainely giuen to good workes: Come yee blessed of my Father, possesse the kingdome prepared for you from the foundation of the worlde: for I was hungrie, and you gaue mee meate, I was thirstie. and you gaue me drinke. &c.

2. By these and other like places it is apparaunt, that a rewarde is promised and giuen to woorkes: therefore nowe we must see and consider, in what sorte & in what respecte a rewarde is promised and giuen vnto them of God: to witte, not of merite and desarte, but of grace & fauour.

For first for the woorde (Meriting) it is certayne that the7 olde Latine Deuines did vse it improperly, for (to attayne) and the worde (Merite) for (good worke) which is no where founde in the holy Scriptures, so that hee did greatly hurte the synceritie of fayth, who did first applye it to mens workes being compared with the iudgement of God.

Secondly8, if you take Merite as the Schoolemen doe, for a iust proportion betweene the worke wrought, and the9 rewarde: or as Viguerius defineth it: Merite is called that which is a mans debte or recompence of his worke and labour, as it were a certayne rewarde ordeyned by God: in this signification, no creature can deserue any thing of God. Therefore10 saith the Psalmist: My well doing extendeth not to thee: that is, nothing can proceede from mee, which may pleasure thee, and much lesse deserue any thing, and least of all eternall life.

And11 the Apostle saith to the Romanes: Who hath giuen vnto him first, and hee shall be recompenced? If man did pleasure God in any thing, then might he be sayde to deserue or to deserue well of him, as by perfourming good turnes one to another, we endeuour to deserue wel one of another: but Paul saith playnely: Who hath giuen to him first, so taking from euery man all rewarde, recompence or merite. And in the first Epistle to the Corinthians12: What hast thou that thou hast not receyued? and if thou hast receyued it, why doest thou boast, as if thou hadst not receyued it?

But13 they obiecte, that the workes of the Regenerate haue and receyue power, and strength to deserue forgiuenesse of sinnes, adoption, saluation, and euerlasting life, not of themselues, but of Christ to whome they are regenerate, and from the holye Ghost, by whose renewing those workes are wrought. I answere14: what their power and strength is, wee must iudge not by such reasons as we can bring, but by the Scriptures. Secondly, The Lawe of sinne, which is in the members of the regnerate in15 this life, doth so fight against the Lawe of their minde, that they cannot bring to passe that good, which by the working of the Spirite they desire to doe.

Wherefore that neuerthelesse God promiseth a reward, and is said to recompence our good workes, that doth rather commende his mercie, that he vouchsafeth to giue the name of a rewarde to a recompence that is not due vnto vs, but is giuen of meere fauour in Christ: to which effecte there is a notable saying of Augustine, which that holy man doubted not often to rehearse, as most worthie to be remembred. God is faithfull who hath made himselfe16 a debter vnto vs, not by receyuing any thing at our handes, but by promising all thinges vnto vs.

Which17 manner of Gods dealing with his children, by one example out of the Scripture shall plainely appeare: Before18 Isaac was borne, there was a seede promised to Abraham,19 in whome all the nations of the earth shoulde be blessed, and an increase of seede, that shoulde be like the starres of heauen, the sande of the sea, and other such like things: many yeeres after as he was commaunded by oracle, he addressed himselfe to sacrifice his sonne: hauing perfourmed this obedience, he receyued the promise: By my selfe haue I sworne, saith the Lorde, because thou hast done this thing, & hast not spared thine onely begotten sonne, I will blesse thee, and will multiplie thy seede as the starres of20 heauen, and the sande of the sea, and thy seede shall possesse21 the gates of their enemies, and in thy seede shall all the nations of the earth be blessed, because thou hast obeyed my voyce. What heare wee? Did Abraham at this time deserue that blessing by his obedience, of which hee had receyued a promise before that commaundement was giuen? No truely: But rather without going about the bushe, wee holde that God doeth rewarde the woorkes of the faithfull with those giftes, which hee gaue them before they had once thought of or intended those woorkes: hauing as yet no cause, why he should doe them good, but onely his22 owne mercie: the like argument to this the Apostle handleth to the Romanes, by opposing workes and fayth, grace and rewarde of debt, when he speaketh of the same Abraham.

To the same end Christ propoundeth a parable, wherein23 hee sheweth himselfe to be the goodman of the house, who whomesoeuer hee meeteth, hee sendeth them to labour in his vineyarde, some at the first houre of the day, some at the seconde, some at the thirde, some also at the eleuenth, and at night he gaue vnto them all equall wages, to witte, that euen they who haue sweate with long trauaile, receyuing no more then they that came last in, may vnderstande that they haue receyued a gifte of grace, and not a rewarde of workes.

Whereby24 it is manifest, that when a rewarde is giuen to25 good workes, it is not because they deserue it, but because26 the bountifulnesse of God hath of it selfe set them this rewarde: for what coulde they deserue of whome Christ affirmeth: When you haue done all thinges, say, we are vnprofitable seruauntes, wee haue done that wee ought to doe? To say it in the sight of God, is not to fayne, or lye, but to set downe that whereof thou art certaynely perswaded with thy selfe.

And27 if good woorkes deserue any thing, howe is the kingdome of heauen called not the wages of seruantes, but the inheritance of children, which they onely doe enioy, who are adopted of the Lorde to be his sonnes? And in this sorte Abraham the father28 of the faithfull, whose rewarde29 God saide he would be, was iustified: whereupon Peter30 also said well, yͭ euerlasting life is the reward of faith.

Besides31 we must looke into the drifte of the holy ghost, for what cause he saith that God doeth recompence that vnto good workes, which he gaue freely before workes, which by no meanes is to puffe vs vp, or to encourage vs by an opinion of merite, but by this meanes to meete with our weakenesse, which otherwise woulde straightwayes faynt, and fall downe, vnlesse it did vpholde it selfe by this expectation, and by this comfort did asswage the many prouocations that it hath to be wearie.

For where as there can be nothing deuised more harde then to forsake and denye not onely all that a man hath, but him selfe also (with the which first schooling notwithstanding Christ doeth enter his disciples, that is, all the godly, and so doth teache them all their life long vnder the discipline of the crosse, that they shoulde not set their heart, either to desire, or to trust in the goodes of this life, briefely he doeth so intreate them, that whithersoeuer they cast their eyes throughout this wide worlde, they see nothing before them but matter of despaire) in these32 so great straightes that we shoulde not faint, and be discouraged, God doeth comforte vs with promise of rewarde, and withall admonisheth vs to lifte vp our head, and to cast our eyes farther off, to finde that blessednesse with him, which in the worlde we can not see, which blessednesse he calleth a reward and recompence, not weighing the desart of our workes, but signifiyng that it is a recompence for our suffrings, our afflictions and reproches.

Seeing then that the holy Ghost hath respecte to this in such promises, we must imagine nothing lesse, then a mutuall relation betweene desart and rewarde, wherein the Sophisters doe importunately sticke, against the33 meaning both of the Scripture and the Fathers: for so saith Augustine34 in a certayne place: Let mans merites here keepe silence35, which are lost by Adam, and let the grace of God raigne by Iesus Christ. Againe, The Saintes giue nothing to their owne merites, they will giue all to thy mercie, O God.

And36 Bernard: For what shoulde the Church be carefull for merites, which hath a more sound matter of reioycing, & more voyde of care, to witte, of the purpose of God: God can not deny himselfe, he will doe that he hath promised.

The false doctrine.

Therefore37 it is a vayne and ridiculous deuice of the schoolmen, who make two sortes of merites, the one of congruitie, the other of condignitie, and doe applye the merite of congruitie to these workes, which of their owne nature deserue not saluation, but so farre as promise is made vnto them by the goodnesse of God, and such they will haue to be all morall workes done before Iustification. And the merite of condignitie they define to be that, for which a rewarde is wholy due, & such38 they will haue those workes to be which the faythfull doe after regeneration: which distinction of theirs they haue drawne out of a place of the Apostle misvnderstoode by them, when he speaketh of the persecutions which the Martyrs of Christ did endure: The sufferinges of this present time are not worthie of the glorie which shalbe reueyled: for Paul doeth not there compare the worthinesse of the crosse & glory as they meane, but onely doeth mittigate the grieuousnesse of the crosse, by comparing it with the greatnesse of glorie, and that to confirme the mindes of the faythfull with patience. And for the merite of Congruitie, as if the promises of God were only therein regarded, and not the worthinesse or nature of the woorke, what hath God euer promised to those woorkes which are done out of the faith & religiō of Christ: as though the Scripture did lye when it saith, all they are in death, who haue not taken possession of the Sonne: If they be in death, howe can they bring forth matter of life: as though that sentence were in vayne: whatsoeuer is not of faith, is sinne, or as though an euill tree coulde bring foorth good fruites. Besides39, that is a fonde manner of speaking, for to whome in right40* and sounde iudgement any thinge is due of congruitie, they*41* are to be iudged worthie thereof.*

1 That a reward is promised to good works

2 Luk.6.35.

3 Mat.10.42.

4 Luk.14.14.

5 2.Iohn 8.

6 Rom.2.6.7.

7 The latine diuines haue improperly vsed the word of Meriting.

8 What merite is.

9 Viguer.cap.9. Inst.55.3,1. and 55.v.1.

10 Psa.16.2.

11 Rom.11.35.

12 1.Cor.4.7.

13 Obiect.

14 Answer.

15 Rom.7.23.

16 In Psal.132. 109.& often elsewhere.

17 An example.

18 Gen.17.1.

19 That good workes deserue nothing although God promise them a rewarde is prooued by three notable arguments and by the fathers.

20 Gen.21.3.

21 See Caluin institut.lib.3. cap.17.s.2.3.

22 Rom.4.4,5.

23 Mat.20.1.

24 Mat.25.24.

25 2.Tim.4.8.

26 Luk.17.10.

27 The kingdome of heaueu is the inheritance of Sonnes.

28 Ephes.1.18.

29 Gal.4.30.

30 Gen.15.1.

31 Rom.4.4,5. 1.Pet.1,9.

32 1.Cor.15.9.

33 De Predest. Sanctor.

34 In Psal.88.

35 vid.Ang.in hom.50.hom. 14.

36 Sup.Cantic. Serm.68.

37 Viguer.cap. 93.v.3.

38 The definition and refutation of the merite of congruitie. See Muscal locis lib. de Merit.pag.255. Rom.8.18. 2.Cor.4.17.

39 1.Ioh.5.12.

40 Rom.14.23.

41 Mar.7.17,24