An Exposition or Commentarie upon the Catechisme of Christian Religion (1589), Jeremias Bastingius · PDF

Question 38

THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.

Question.

What reason was there, why he suffered vnder Iudge Pilate?

Answere.

That he an innocent being condemned before a ciuil Iudge might set vs free from the streight iudgement of God, which was to fall vpon vs:

The Exposition.

Besides that the name of Pilate the Iudge maketh for the trueth of the historie, it was also for that end diligently1 noted by the Euangelistes, because according to the Prophesie of the holy Ghost. Christ came then to suffer, when as the scepter was translated from the tribe of Iuda to the Gentiles, so that there was no more hope left2 to restore the outward kingdome. Whereupon Christ himselfe3 a little before his passion, Behold, saith he, we goe vp to Ierusalem, & al things shalbe done to the Son of man, which4 are writtē by the Prophets, for he shalbe deliuered vnto the Gentiles and shalbe mocked, and shalbe spitefullie intreated, and shalbe spitted on.

Howbeit that Christ was first pronounced innocēt by Pylate, and neuerthelesse condemned by him as guiltie, the Euangelistes with one consent doe teach: for this is his owne confession: Yee haue brought this man vnto mee, as5 one that peruerted the people, and beholde, I haue examined6 him before you & haue found no falt in this man of those7 thinges whereof ye accuse him, of his condemning Mat. thus8 speaketh: Then Pilate let loose vnto them Barrabas. & deliuered Iesus, when he had scourged him, to be crucified.

Both these fell out, or rather were directed by the prouidence of God. For first God would haue his sonne be the mouth of the Iudge to be pronounced innocent, that he might declare, that he was not to suffer for his owne sinnes, but for ours. Secondly he would also a little after haue his Sonne cōdemned by the same Iudge, & so be reckoned among the wicked, according to the prophecy, that hee might signifie, that he susteyned our person, & was set therein for vs, that whereas wee were to haue a curse awarded against vs at his heauenly iudgement seat9, hee by taking vpon him the condemnation which did hang ouer our heades, might deliuer vs from the same, & that his condemnation might be vnto vs for an acquitance10, to conclude, that so that which in the Psalme is11 figuratiuely spoken of Dauid, I paid that I tooke not, might12 be fulfilled in Christ, the true Dauid.

The false doctrine.

Seing Christ hath suffered only in humane nature, because the diuine nature cannot suffer, they are blasphemous against God, who make Christ to haue suffered in both natures for so Brentius hath in his writing: It cānot be denied, but that the diuine nature in Christ, was in his measure made partaker of his suffering and death, and Selneccerus where vniustly blaming Theodorete, because he saith that Christ as he was God could not suffer, saith, no man may or ought13 to say that God did not suffer and die, although this vnproper phrase, & not at all to be borne, be to bee found sometimes in Theodoretes dialogues: as he was God, he14 was not subiect to suffering, and as he was God Christ could not suffer, Much better then these men speaketh Chrysostome in an other place: Aske an heriticke whether God be afraid, and doe flie from, and feare death, & be said? if he saie, yea, depart from him hereafter, and set him beneath the Deuill, or in some lower place: for hee would not dare to say so.

Secondly, seeing the suffering of Christ is the onely sacrifice of reconciliation for the sinnes of the whole world, they wander from the right path of saluation, & do iniurie to Christ, whosoeuer not content with him and his sacrifice, do deuise to thē selues other meanes to appease God, and two wayes whereby to wipe away the punishmēt due vnto vs, to witt, the satisfaction of Christ15 and of Saints, which is to deny the blood of Christ to be only16 sufficient for forgiuenes of sinnes, for reconciliation, for17 satisfaction, vnles the want of it being as it were dried vp and spent, be suppled, and made vp by some other, as by Peter, Paul, & other Martirs, in whose blood the Popish pardons do put satisfactiō: again which robbing of God excellētly spake long18 ago Leo the B. of Rome: although yͤ death of the Saints hath bin pretious in yͤ sight of god, yet the slaying of no guilteles man was a sacrifice for the sins of the world: the righteous receiued19, they did not giue crownes, & examples of patience did grow of the couragiousnes of yͤ faithful not gifts of righteousnes: for their death were singular: nether did any of thē by his end20 pay any other mens debt: forasmuch as ther was one Lord Christ in whome all were crucified, all died, all were buryed all21 rose againe. And Augustine to the same effect: although (saith22 he) we die brethren for brethren, yet the blood of no Martyr is shed for forgiuenes of sinnes, which Christ dyed23 for vs: neyther did he bestowe this vpon vs that wee should followe him in it, but that we shoulde al of vs reioyce for it.

Thirdly, if Christ did suffer in body & soule, as certēly he did24, then haue the Apollinaristes erred, who said that Christ did25 take a bodie without a soule, and that the worde was in him26 in stead of his soule, whereof it would follow, that Christ if he had not taken a soule, were not perfectly our Mediatour, and Sauiour, seeing that our soule also was woūded with sinne both in the vnderstanding and in the will, and therefore had neede to be healed.

1 Why Christ suffered vnder Pilate.

2 Gen.49.10.

3 Esa.53.8.

4 Luk.18.31.

5 Luke 23.14.

6 Ioh.19.4.

7 The inconstant sentence of Pilate,

8 Matt.26.29.

9 Esa.5.3.8.

10 Psal.69.5.

11 2.Cor.5.31.

12 Gal.3.13.

13 Cont.Bul.fol.11.

14 In consu.ac cus.fol.192.

15 1.Ioh.2.2.

16 Rom.3.25.

17 The contrariety of popish pardons & of Christ.

18 See in Calv. Instit lib.3. Cap.5. Sect.2.

19 Viguer.Instit. ca.16.6.v.19 & 20.to the foure Ecclesiæ

20 Epist.ad.Paul. 18.

21 2.Cor.1.6.7.

22 Phil.1.2225.

23 1.Cor.1.13.

24 August. de hæres.cap.55.

25 Luke.23.46.

26 Iohn.12.27.