Question 8
THE FIRST PART OF MANS MISERY,
Question.
But are we so corrupt that we are not at al fitte to doe well, and are wee prone to all vice?
Answere.
Yea truely: vnlesse we be regenerated by the holy Ghost.
The Exposition.
Hauing declared the state of man before his fall, and then what is the cause of his corruption, and what be the effectes of his disobedience, it followeth to consider whether the force of hereditary corruption be1 such, that mā is altogether depriued of al power to do good, or whether he haue yet receiued some, though small and weake, abilitie, which indeed of it selfe alone can do nothing, but receiuing helpe from grace is able also to doe some thing of it selfe: which place is vsually called Free will: in Latine, Liberum arbitrium, whereby the opinion of the Schoolemē: the word Arbitriū must be2 referred to reason, whose office it is to discerne betweene good & euill, the word Liberum vnto will, which is flexible vnto eyther, whereof the Scripture teacheth in this manner.
1 That the natural or carnal man is both altogether vnfit to do well, & also prone to all vice, 2. That we can not doe well before we be regenerate by the holy Ghost.
First3 that the condition of man is such since hee was brought4 into the bondage of sinne, that he is in no sort able by nature to do wel. Iohn plainely teacheth. The light shineth in darknes but the darknes cōprehended it not :signifying that the sharpnes of mans vnderstanding touching the5 knowledge of God is meere darkenes.
If6 the light which is in thee be darkenesse, how great is the darkenesse? saith Christ. When hee calleth men darkenesse, he doeth thereby take from them all power of spirituall vnderstanding.
The78 naturall man, that is , who leaneth to the light of nature, doeth not perceiue those things that are of God, saith Paul. Also, We are not fit of our selues to thinke any thing of our selues, hereof I thus gather: If we be not fit to thinke, much lesse are we fit to doe well. The same Apostle willing to bring downe the pride of mankinde, dealeth by these testimonies: There is none righteous, no not one, there is9 none that vnderstandeth , here iudgement is denied to man10: There is none that seeketh after God , whereby is signified11 the backewardnesse of the will, which place, as also the rest, is in stead of a most cleare glasse, wherein wee may behold the image of our whole nature, for that the holy ghost with these thūderbolts striketh not at some certain men, but at the whole generation of Adams posteritie. But must clearely in the Epistle to the Ephesians12. And you also ( saith he ) hath he quickened , when you were dead in trespasses and sinne., signifying that as dead men are destitute of all strength, so that they are able to doe nothing to recouer life, and to execute the functions of life, so by nature the Ephesians were , and all men are till they be regenerated.
Nowe that man on the other side is prone to all vice, it is evident by as plaine testimonies of scripture: as first out of Moyses: And the Lord saw that the wickednes of man was13 great vpō the earth, & al the imaginatiōs of yͤ thoughts of14 his heart, were only euill continually, euen from his youth.
Hereupon15 Ieremy saith ,that the heart of man is wicked aboue16 all things, and Iob calleth a man abhominable, & filthie which drinketh iniquitie, like water.
And17 Christ saith: That which is borne of flesh, is flesh, whereupon is gathered, that not only the vnderstanding, but also the will is corrupted, wherto that also serueth. He that committeth sinne, is the seruāt of sin: & that which the18 Apostle often beateth vpon out of the Psalmes: They are1920 al gone out of the way, they are al togeither becom vnprofitable, there is none that doth good, no not one:where both abilitie to accomplish, and will to endeuour is remooued from all men.
Whereupon it followeth that this is a most true demonstration, that seeing these two powers of the soule, vnderstanding & will( which remaining sound & intire, man had been able to doe good ) are now perished and corrupted, he is therefore now vtterly vnfit to doe well, & prone to all vice: whereto belongeth that confession of Esay: All we like sheep haue gone astray, we haue turned euery one to his owne way: & that which Christ saith in the Gospel21; An euill tree can not bring forth good fruits.
Neither22 yet for all that doth the Scripture make man a blocke or a stocke, as if he had not any vnderstanding or23 will left , but onely affirmeth that by sinne hee was spoiled of all abilitie to vnderstand aright, or to will or doe aright: which S. Ambrose doeth expresse in a moste excellent sentence: Man by the deuill was spoyled not of his will24, but of the soundnes of his will, therfore that which in nature was good, in qualitie became euill, And Bernard, who teacheth that there is in vs all power to will, but to will well we had neede to profit better, to will euill we are able already, by reason of our fall.
2 The25 Seconde part of the answere of this question was, that we are not fit to doe well, before we be regenerate by the holy Ghost, which is the third state of man, namely vnder grace, as they vse to speake.
To be regenerated, is for man to be made new, not as Nicodemus2627 thought, but by changing, renewing, and repairing the powers of the soule, that is the vnderstanding and the will , as it were spiritually to be borne againe.
This28 is the worke of God alone, who as in the beginning he created vs after his owne image, so also must hee regenerate29 vs according to the same , which hee doeth by the holy Ghost the third person in trinitie , one and the same euerlasting God together with the Father and the Sonne.
In this sense are to be vnderstood the places of Scripture following.
Except30 a man be borne againe of water and of the spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdome of God.
No31 man can receiue any thing, except it be giuen him from aboue.
Blessed32 art thou Simon the Sonne of Ionas, for flesh & blood hath not reueiled this vnto thee, but my Father which is in heauen : where Christ affirmeth that this is by speciall reuelation from his Father, that Peter doeth acknowledge him.
If the Sonne make you free , you are free indeede: And without me you can do nothing, that is, nothing that is acceptable33 vnto God, and maketh for the attainement of saluation34.
It35 is God that worketh in you both the will and the deede, according36 to the good pleasure of his will: also, where the spirit of the Lord is, there is freedome.
In the Prophet: I will take away the stonie heart out of your37 bodie, and I will giue you an heart of flesh, and I wil put my spirit within you, and cause you to walke in my statutes.
Paul38 to the Ephesians: The God of our Lord Iesus Christ, the father of glory giue you the spirite of wisedome, and of revelation through the knowledge of him, that the eyes of your vnderstāding may be lightened, that ye may know what the hope is of his calling: by which speach the Apostle giueth to vnderstand , that men doe not much profite by the worde39 of God, vntil he himselfe giue them eyes, or open their eyes , who is therefore called the Father of lights, because wheresoeuer hee shineth not with his spirit, all things are possessed with darkenesse.
For40 this cause commonly hee vseth to pray for the Churches41. We cease not to pray for you and to desire, that ye may be fullfilled with knowledge of his will, in all wisedome and spirituall vnderstanding, that ye might walke worthy of the Lord.
Augustine42 did so farre acknowledge this want of reason to vnderstand the things of God, that hee thinketh the inlightning of grace as necessary for the mind, as the light of43 the sunne for the eyes: and not herewith content, he calleth backe some of this, adding that we our selues do open our eyes to see the light but the eyes of the mind, vnlesse they be opened of God, remaine shut.
Out of all these this principle is gathered, that wee haue neede wholly of the grace of Gods spirit to preuent both our vnderstanding and our will, and to chaunge, helpe, and assist them to vnderstand, will and worke aright.
The vse and end of this knowledge and doctrin is this, not44 to increase in vs slouthfulnes, but that we vnderstanding, how by originall sinne wee are bereaued of al power to vnderstand , to will and to worke aright, and also hemmed in on euery side with most miserable necessitie, may learne notwithstanding to long after that good wherof we are void, & after that libertie which we haue lost45, and therefore to heare the word of God wherby our iudgement may be reformed, to craue the gift of the holy Ghost, that we may learne the cōmandements of God, and that he would make of our stonie hart a fleshly hart, and46 giue vnto vs strength, as Augustine very well aduiseth about this matter O man(saith he)by the commaundement know what thou oughtest to haue by correction, learne that by thine owne fault thou hast it not, by praier vnderstād from whence thou must receiue that which thou desirest to haue: So wil it come to passe that thy mind being inlightened shal iudg aright, thy hart being reformed by the hand of God shall be made willing, and man according to the measure of grace which he hath receiued, shal indeuour and apply all his powers, and all his strength vnto obedience.
The false doctrine.
Wherefore by these arguments of the corruption of our nature, it appereth that the sect of Philosophers long ago did not thinke nor teach aright of the knowledge of man, which they placed in him if hee perfectly knew his owne ex- cellencie and dignitie, wherby he might swel with vain confidence, & be puffed vp with pride: to which end they vsed that common precept, Know thy selfe: and this saying also, That man47 had sufficient in himself to make himself happy, that it is Gods gift, that we liue, but our owne that we liue wel and holily. And that this is the iudgement of all men, that wee must begge good successe at Gods hand, but that euery man is to receiue wisdome from himselfe: wher as in deed there is nothing our own but sin, & whatsoeuer good we haue, proceedeth frō God. And hereby also it is apparent that both the Latine & the Greeke writers did too much extoll, & did teach too arrogantly48, the one their Free will, as if man yet stood vpright: the other49, Their absolute power , as if man were wholly in his own power: whom the Romanistes following haue also more declined50 from the word of God, & contrary to so many expresse places of scripture, out of the parable of the mā left half dead by51 the theeues, haue deuised that there remaineth somewhat sound as yet in our nature, the Apostle directly auouching the contrarie52, whē he saith that we are dead in sins & trespasses: euen as they also for the maintenance of this their opinion, do corruptly think that the word Flesh belongeth only to the sensual53, not to the better part of the mind. For if it be true that mā must be born again because he is flesh, Christ did not command him to be born again in body alone, & he is not born again in soul, whē some part of it is reformed, but whē the whole is renewed. Secondly, the spirit is so compared to the flesh, that there54 is no middle thing between them. Thirdly Paul expounding5556 Christs meaning, willeth vs to be renewed in the spirit of our mind: as also in another place he willeth vs to be changed by the renewing of our mind, But these mē, if they wil not beleeue57 the scripture, yet let thē harken to Augusten reasoning in this sort: What is he able to work that is but a lost man, but so farre forth as he shalbe freed from perdition ? Can his free will do any thing? God forbid we should say this. For mā abusing his free wil lost both himselfe & it: for as he that killeth himself, doth in deed by liuing kil himselfe, but by killing himself doth not liue, neither whē he hath killed himself, can restore himself to life again. So when we sin by free will, sin getting58 the vpper hand, free will is lost: for of whomsoeuer a mā is ouercome, to him also he is brought in bondage.
Last59 of all, if we be so corrupt, that we are vtterly vnfit to do well, & prone to all vice, as we haue shewed, where is then the merit of cōgruity, which proceedeth of free wil, wherof the Schoolemen60 of the Romanists speake so much ? whereby it appeareth that those Doctors knew not so much as the first principles of religion, which they might learne euen of children, if they had not shewed thēselus long since not meet to be taught, and indeede very stubburne.
1 What free will is
2 Thom. part. 2. quest. 83. art. 3
3 The diuision,
4 That man is by nature wholly corrupt & prone to all vice.
5 Iohn. 1. 4.
6 Math. 6. 23.
7 1. Cor. 2. 14.
8 2. Cor. 3. 5.
9 Rom. 3. 10. 11:12.
10 Psa. 14. 33
11 Esay. 59. 7.
12 Eph. 2. 1
13 Gen. 6. 3.
14 Gen. 8. 21.
15 Ierem. 17. 9.
16 Iob, 15. 15.
17 Ioh. 3. 6.
18 Ioh, 8. 34.
19 Psal. 14. 3.
20 Rom. 3. 12.
21 Esay. 53. 6.
22 Math. 7. 18.
23 An obiection preuented
24 Lib. 11. de Vecat. gent. c. 2. & 3.
25 The thirde state of man vnder grace
26 Ioh, 4. 4.
27 What it is to be regenerate.
28 What it is to be regenerate.
29 See August. Hyp. quæst. lib. 3. de libero arbitri ante lapsum & post lapsum.
30 Ioh. 3. 5.
31 Ioh. 3. 27.
32 Mat. 16. 17.
33 Ioh. 8. 36
34 Iohn. 15. 5
35 Philip. 2. 3.
36 2 Cor. 3. 17.
37 Ezek. 36. 26.
38 Eph. 1. 17. 18.
39 Iam. 1. 17.
40 Coloss. 1. 9.
41 Phi. 1. 4.
42 Lib, 2. de pec. mer. remiss, cap. 5.
43 How necessarie the grace of illumination is:
44 The Vse.
45 Psal. 119. 34.
46 Lib de corrept. & gratia.
47 Seneca. Cic. 3. de Nat. Deorum.
48 Liberum arbitrium.
49 Concil. Trid. sess. 6. c. 5
50 αὐτεξούσιον Damas. Orth. fid. lib. 2. c. 25.
51 Luk. 10. 30.
52 Eph. 2. 1.
53 The word Flesh doeth signifie also the superior part of the soule.
54 Iohn. 3. 6.
55 Eph. 4. 23.
56 Rom. 12. 2.
57 August. in Eucharist. cap. 29.
58 Iohn. 8. 34.
59 The refutation of the merite of congruity.
60 Viguer. cap. 9. v. 3.