Question 5
THE FIRST PART OF MANS MISERY,
Question.
Art thou able to keepe all these things perfectly?
Answere.
In no wise: for by nature I am prone to the hatred of God and of my neighbour.
The exposition.
After the laying open and declaring of the perfection of the Lawe, which is altogether Spirituall, the next1 question is, whether we, who by nature are altogether fleshly, be able perfectly to keepe euery one of those things which are commaunded in the Law: And the meaning of the aunswere of the Catechist is.
1 That2 it is impossible for man, who is by nature corrupt, to keepe the whole Law perfectly, and that in this behalfe he remaineth a debter vnto God.
2 That man is so farre from louing God and his neighbour perfectly, that by nature he is prone to the hatred of God, and of his neighbour.
The3 former point the Apostle maintaineth, teaching that by the workes of the Law, no flesh shalbe iustified in the sight of God: hauing before alleaged out of the Psalmes: Ther is none righteous, no not one, they are al gone out of the way, they are al together become vnprofitable.
Againe4: The law entred that sinne might abound, signifying the corruption of mans nature to be such, that he still striuing, and being carryed to do that which the Law forbiddeth, becommeth so much the more guiltie: so farre is he from being able to keepe the Law, and to propound the same vnto him selfe as a rule to frame his life thereafter.
Besides5 we are by nature seruants of sinne & freed from righteousnes. From which testimonies I gather this most certen demonstration. Seeing that whatsoeuer issueth from an vncleane fountaine must needes be vncleane, it can not bee that from the vncleane nature of man should proceede pure obedience vnto God; and perfect loue towards man, and therefore the Law can perfectly be kept of no man, no not so much as one commandement of the Lawe.
2. Howbeit that doeth more open and conuince our corruption, that we doe not onely barely not obserue those things which are commanded vs in the Law of God: but also that by nature, that is according as now we are borne defiled and corrupted, we are vtterly carried to the hatred of God, (then which there is nothing6 more wicked) and to the hatred of our neighbour. For what meaneth that, that the Lord threatneth he will punish the sinnes of the parents vpon the children vnto the third & fourth generation of them that hate him? also, that Christ saith7, we are all by nature haters of him, and Paul, that we are haters of God, and that the wisedome of the flesh is enmitie against God? and that wee were in times past strangers and enemies, hauing our minds bent to euill workes?
And for our affection towardes our neighbour, the Scripture8 witnesseth, that we are all by nature ful of enuy, murther, debate, deceit, maliciousnesse, without naturall affection, such as can neuer be appeased, mercilesse.
The Apostle to Titus saith: We our selues also were in times9 past, vnwise, disobedient, deceiued, seruing the lusts & diuers pleasures, liuing in maliciousnes and enuy, hateful, & hating one another.
And surely both the points are prooued by the generall experience of all men, and by the priuate testimonie of conscience in euery man; for although all men professe that they loue God, and euen the most profane men thinke it a monstrous sinne to hate God: yet seeing there are so fewe that desire to drawe neere vnto10 God, and most men take pleasure in seruing sinne, and in the allurements of the worlde, and the greatest part of men doeth loath the worde of God, and euerie man vseth to sing this song to himselfe, I am nerest vnto my selfe: as certen is this generall experience, and this testimonie of conscience so sure, as it is certaine by experience that fire is whot, and that water is wet.
The false doctrine.
Therefore this errour of the schoolemen is to be corrected, who think that men vnregenerate are able notwithstanding11 to doe good workes of preparation, that is, such as go before the grace of God in vs, and yet that they deserue grace of congruitie, as they barbarously speake.
1 Rom.7.14.
2 That the lawe of God can be kept perfectly of no man in this corruption of nature
3 Rom.3.20. Psa.14.3
4 Rom.5.20. 1.Cor.15.56. Rom.4.15.
5 Rom.6.20. 1.Iohn.1.8.
6 Exod.20.5. Deut. 5.9.
7 Iob.15.18. Rom.1.29.30. Rom.8.7. Rom.5.6. Colos.1.21.
8 Rom.1.29.
9 Tit.3.3.
10 Rom 3.from the 10. verse to the 19.
11 Viguer.inst. c.9.3.ver.3.