An Exposition or Commentarie upon the Catechisme of Christian Religion (1589), Jeremias Bastingius · PDF

Question 78

THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.

The Arg. Transubstantiation of breade and wine in the vse of the supper disprooued, and the true exposition and meaning of these wordes: bread is the body of Christ.

Question.

What then, are bread and wine made the very body and blood of Christ?

Answere.

No truly: but as the water of Baptisme is not turned into the blood of Christ, neither is the very washing away of sins, but only a token and pledge of those things which are sealed vnto vs in Baptisme: no more is the bread of the Lords Supper the very body of Christ, although after the nature of Sacraments, & the manner of speech which the holy Ghost vseth in speaking of these things, the bread is called the body of Christ.

The Exposition.

The Catechist1 now passeth to the popish doctrine of Transsubstantiation, which they gather and frame out2 of the words of Christ. This is my body, &c. but how falslie hee now sheweth: 1. by an argument taken from Baptisme,3 2. from the common manner of sacraments: And first hee saith, that there is no Transubstantiation of the bread & wine into the body and blood of Christ: which to be most true euen therby appeareth & is prooued, because in the scripture, euen after consecration (as the Romanistes them selues note in their Catechisme) the sacrament of the body of Christ is called bread: The bread which we breake, saith the Apostle, is the communion of the bodie of Christ: And: whosoeuer shal eat this bread &4 drinke this cup of the Lord vnworthilie, shalbe guiltie of the5 bodie & blood of the Lord: Let a man examine himself, & so6 let him eate of that bread & drink of that cup: to conclude we are all partakers of one bread.

Hitherto adde, that Christ calleth the wine after consecration, the fruit of the vine: I say vnto you, I wil not drink henceforth7 of the fruit of the vine, vntil I drinke it new with you in my fathers kingdome.

Surely a more significant, and strong testimony could not be giuen & alleadged, both for the bread, that in the vse of the sacrament it abideth bread indeed, or for the wine that nothing decayeth of the substance thereof, or any of the substance of the body and blood of Christ is by miracle added to either.

For8 this purpose it maketh, that the old writers haue defined a sacramēt to be a visible signe of invisible grace: therefore it beeing set downe and graunted that the bread is turned into the body of Christ, the definition of a sacrament shal be ouerthrowen, and the proportion or similitude, which ought to leade vs from visible or invisible things shal be quite taken away.

For the Lorde ordeined bread wherewith the bodie is fed, to signifie that his flesh is the true and holesome meate of our soule, which when the substance of bread is gone, & the accidents only remaine, how can it be sealed vnto vs by an empty appearance of bread? for our bodies must be nourished not with accidents, but with substance: yea by this meanes the flesh of Christ shall seeme to bee no true and sound meat, but onely phantasticall hauing no true nourishment in it.

Besides9 howe shall the bodie and blood of Christ bee saide to bee vnder the shew of bread and wine, when as accidents haue no substance of them selues but be in another, how, I say, can the bodie of Christ be hid vnder them.

Neither did Christ say, vnder this appearance or shew is my bodie, vnder this appearance is my blood, but this, that is, bread, is my body this , that is wine, is my blood of the new testament.

But that the Romanistes conceiued this errour of a miraculous transubstantiation of the bread into the body & blood of Christ came partely hereof, that they thought consecration of the signes in the Supper to be a coniuring kinde of inchantment, whereof should suddenly come a strange and a secret change of the signes.

Partly10 also that reading sometime in the fathers the worde, changing, to be vsed, they straightway drew it to their grosse imagination, as if the bread by this change were turned into the bodie of Christ, whereas the fathers vnderstood this chāging after this sort, to wit, that in the vse of the supper bread and wine are nowe otherwise to bee accounted of then common meates which are appoynted onely to feede the bellie, whereas in those signes the spiritual meat & drinke of the soule is offered.

2 Now that Transsubstantiation is contrary to the naturall meaning of Christ is confirmed in the Catechisme by reason of similitude taken from Baptisme: which it is a wonder that it could not deliuer the aduersaries from their errour.

For as there water is not turned into the blood of Christ,11 neither is the very washing away of sinnes, but onely12 a token and pledge of those thinges, which are sealed vnto vs in baptisme, so neither can the breade of the Lords supper bee called indeede the very essentiall body of Christ.

And yet in Baptisme the Fathers make also a maruelous change, when they say that of a corruptible element is made a spiritual water to wash the soule, and yet none of them euer denyed that water still remaineth,

For how can water be the very washing away, or forgiuenesse of sinnes, seeing that is in the minde and in the will of God, who forgiueth them to whome he will, and to whome hee hath promised? and secondly seeing forgiuenesse of sinnes is a gift or a qualitie imputed vnto vs, but water is a substance or corruptible element applied to our bodie.

But13 there is no such thing, say they, read in Baptisme, as that is in the Supper, This is my body, this is my bloode: therefore the water is not transsubstantiated, but they seeme14 not to remember that Paul saieth that those who are baptized with the water doe put on Christ, and are graffed into him by baptisme, and are made flesh of his flesh & bone of his bone.

Secondly I would aske them this question, whether they thinke it a greater thing to regenerate and to make a member of him, or with the flesh & blood of Christ as it were with meate and drinke to feede to sustayne, as if Christ for the more worthinesse of the thing signified had so spoken in the Supper rather then in Baptisme.

For there is the same matter of both Sacraments, baptisme and the supper, and they differ one from another, partly in their proper elements and ceremonies, partly not in the very thing signified, but in the qualitie of it: because the same Christ is offered vnto vs, in Baptisme at our first entrance into the Church to wash vs, in the supper15 as the heauenly foode of those that are entred: that is in Baptisme wee are first ingraffed into Christ, in the supper wee are fed in him; therefore Paul ioyned both togither, for he said, that we haue beene baptized by one Spirite into one bodie, & made to drinke into one Spirit.

3, Last16 of all that this manner of speaking, Bread is the body of Christ, is both agreeable to the nature of Sacraments, & vsed by the holy Ghost, whensoeuer the Scripture speaketh of Sacraments, is very well and truely saide by the Catechist.

The common maner of Sacraments is this, that to declare the force & truth of the signification of Sacramēts, the names of the very thinges are giuen vnto the signes.

So17 in the olde Testament Circumcision is called the Couenant,1819 that is, the signe or true pledge of the couenant,20 as Moses himselfe doth expound it: The sacrifices21 of the Lawe are called Reconciliation: the Sabbaoth, the22 couenant of God: the couer of the Arke, the mercy seat: the2324 blood of sacrifices, the blood of the couenant: the Arke, the25 king of glory and Iehoua: the two tables of the Lawe, the26 couenant of God, the cloud, the glory of Iehoua.

So27 the Lambe is called the Passeouer, where God forbid28 that any man should thinke that the Passeouer hath flesh29 and bones: therefore the Lamb is the Passeouer sacramentally,3031 because it figureth, signifyeth, or representeth32 the pasing ouer of him, who did slay the first borne.

As33 the rocke in the wildernes is Christ, because it did truely and effectually represent Christ, although his flesh were not yet in nature, so certen is the presence euen of things that are absent, which resteth vpon the word of34 God & faith: which Paule hauing respect vnto saith: that35 the fathers did ease the same meat, and drinke the same drinke, that is Christ: & Christ himselfe saith: Abraham saw36 my day & was glad: & Augustine vpon the 77. Psalme writeth, that there was the same meat and drinke in the mistery in the time of the Fathers and in our time, but the same in signification not in kind.

So in the new Testament, the cuppe is called the new Testament, that is, a certen and true token of the newe Testament, that was confirmed by the shedding of the blood of Iesus Christ.

And in Paul, the bread is called the cōmuniō of the body of Christ, & the cup the cōmuniō of the blood of Christ, because they are certen tokens & seales of our communion with Christ:37 So to conclude in our daylye custome of speech there is nothing more common, then to call monumēts, tokens, or pledges by the name of those things, which they doe represent or confirme vnto vs, as when the day of the Passeouer or ascention, is called the Passeouer or ascention of Christ, or when we call the right hand, or a ring, or any other token of faith giuen, by the name of faith, or the writing that declareth the laste will of the Testator, by the name of his Testament, or his will: euidences or bills by the name of house, land, rent, debt, or summe of money due.

For whereas some doe obiect that the Supper of the Lorde hath a certen proper and essentiall forme of difference, which maketh that wee cannot thinke of it as of the rest of the Sacraments, & consequently, whereby it is distinguished from baptisme, & much more from those kinds of speech borrowed from common vse, that we do not deny: but wee say that essential forme hindreth not, but that the Supper may remaine a true Sacrament, and be vnder the Lawes of Sacraments: as that man hath an essentiall forme whereby hee differeth from other liuing things, this doth not exempt him from the common nature of liuing things.

Secondly if a difference or proper qualitie, did vtterly destroy the generall nature, how I pray you could the definition consist of the generall nature and the difference? how could the Supper be defined to be a Sacrament?

Which being so, this figuratiue interpretation, which we vse in the words of the Supper, is not deuised by vs or swaruing from the custome of the scripture, but altogither agreeing with the word of God, and with the nature of Sacramentes: as also the misterie of the Lordes Supper was neuer otherwise expounded of the ancient & sound writers of the Church.

Theodorite in deliuering of these misteries calleth the body3839 bread, & the blood wine: Our Sauiour hath changed the names to and fro, and hath giuen to the body the name of the signe, and to the signe the name of the body.

And a little after: He also hath honoured the signes that we see with the name of his body and blood, not chaunging nature, but adding grace vnto nature. Hee also called breade the figure, & the body the patterne of that figure: & in his third Dialogue. And if the flesh be changed into the nature of40 the Godhead, wherfore are they partakers of the signs that represent the body? for the figure is vaine, where the truth is denyed.

Macarius thus writeth: In the Church is offered bread & wine seruing as a figure to represent that flesh and blood.

The false doctrine.

To this errour of the Transsubstantiation of the breade into the body of Christ, the other errour of Consubstantiation commeth very neere, which was in vse euen in the time of Peter Lombard:41 for these are the words of Lombard: that the bodie of Christ which in it selfe is visible, lyeth hid and is couered vnder the appearance of bread after consecration. Againe, that the eating of the flesh of Christ is a Sacrament, & that contained vnder bread. Whereof in our time hath risen a false interpretation of sacramentall eating, and the same error is brought againe into the church of God, to wit, that the bread of the Supper abideth indeed the substance of a corruptible element, and earthly, but hath inclosed vnder it the body of Christ, and so is the Sacrament of eating Christes fleshe vnto saluation: which being flat contrarie to the nature of Christes body, is of vs vtterly to be abandoned.

For whereas the aduersaries say that it followeth of the words of Christ and the Apostle, whome wee must beleeue setting aside all scanning of the matter by Philosophy, we will grant it when they haue prooued that Christ setteth downe their meaning: which because they could hitherto neuer doe, but also doe ouerthrowe the articles of faith, and the truth of his body to mainetaine this their opinion, we do iustly reiect and abhorre it as being against all reason.

And as for the transsubstantiation of the Romanistes, their owne Canon doth disproue them, as when they sing.

Rei nulla fit scisura, Tantum signi fit ruptura. that is There is no renting of the thing. But onely of the signe breaking.

If the signe, that is, the bread, the token of Christes body bee broken, there must needes be no transsubstantiation.

1 Catech.Rom. p.2.Sect.34.

2 Con.Trid. sess. 13.cap.14.

3 Catech.Rom. pag.189.

4 1.Cor.10.27.

5 1.Cor.11,27.

6 1.Cor,10.17.

7 Mat.26.29.

8 The definition of a sacrament.

9 Accidents haue no substance of them selues.

10 The word changing.

11 Mat,26.29,

12 1.Cor.11.26

13 Obiect.

14 Gal.3.27.

15 1.Cor.12.13.

16 The names and properties of the things giuen to the signes.

17 Gen.17.10.

18 Exod.12.27

19 Act.7.8.

20 Exod.29.36.

21 Nom.28.30.

22 Exod,31.16.

23 Esay6.67.

24 Exod.24.8.

25 Leuit.16.10.

26 Psal.24.8.10.

27 Nomb.32.20.

28 1 Kiug.8.11.

29 Titus 3.5.

30 Act.22.16.

31 1 Pet.3.21.

32 1 Cor.10.1

33 Exod.12.11.

34 1 Cor.10.3.

35 Iohn 8.56.

36 August. in Psal.77.

37 Sacramental phrases expounded.

38 Ioh.6.35

39 Math.26. 26.

40 2.Dialog.&3.

41 Lib.4.sentenc. dist.11.& 12. & lib.4.adist.8