Question 57
THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.
The Arg. Of the resurrection of the flesh, and of life euerlasting, and of the fruite of both.
Question.
What comfort doth the resurrection of the flesh minister vnto thee?
Answere.
Not only that my soule shal straightway after it is departed out of the body, be taken vp vnto Christ the head thereof, but that this flesh of mine also, being raised vp by the power of Christ, shalbe vnited againe to my soule, & shall be made conformable vnto the glorious body of Christ.
The Exposition.
Next1 vnto the Article of forgiuenes of sinnes, followeth the resurrection of the flesh, or of this earthly lumpe, which is brought vnto dust againe, from whence it was taken, whereof first we must shew the certainty, & then the Comfort, which issueth from thence to the faithfull.
The trueth of the resurrection of the flesh is manifest2 out of the Scriptures: for that the holy Patriarkes, were so carefull in prouiding their sepulchers, they did not so for any superstition, but in a godly consideration of the resurrection of their flesh that was to be vnto euerlasting life, and that they might remaine among all posterity, as memorials of their faith concerning the raysing vp34 of the dead: for which end Abraham purchased of Ephron5 the Hittite for a certaine peece of money, part of a fielde6 to serue for himselfe and for his familie: and Iacob being ready to die commanded his sonnes to lay his dead corps in this monument, wherein were laide Abraham & Isac: last of all Ioseph conditioned with the Israelites, that when they were to depart out of Ægipt they should then carrie his bones with thē into the land of promise, which the historie of Iosua the captaine, witnesseth to haue been performed7,
Iob doth openly professe that hee looketh for the resurrection to come: For I am sure that my Redeemer liueth, and8 he shall stand the last on earth: therefore afetr I awake, although the wormes eate this bodie, yet shall I see God in my flesh: euen I my selfe shall see him and mine eyes shall behold him, & none other for me, after that my reines are consumed within me.
And9 Daniel: And many of them that sleepe in the dust of the earth shall a awake, some to euerlasting life, and some to shame and perpetuall contempt.
So Christ himselfe speaketh of the general resurrection: And10 they shall come foorth, that haue done good, to the resurrection of life, and they that haue done euill to the resurrection of condemnation.
The same resurrection Christ prooueth by an euident argument against the Sadduces. And concerning the resurrection of the dead, haue yee not read what God speaketh vnto11 you, saying: I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Iacob? God is not the God of the deade, but of the liuing.
And in Christ himselfe wee haue both an example of it, and as it were a ground: for so Paul speaketh: But now is12 Christ raysed from the dead, and is become the first fruites of them that slept: for by reason that by man came death, by man also came the resurrection of the dead: For as in Adam all men die, euen so in Christ shall all be made aliue.
2. Moreouer, as touching the comfort which the faithfull receiue by the resurrection of the flesh, the Catechist13 doeth set it downe soundely, first declaring the estate of the faithfull soules so soone as they are departed out of their tabernacle.
Now that is most certen, that our soule so soone as it is departed out of the bodye, is straitway taken vp vnto Christ the head thereof, which is not hard to proue by testimonies of scripture.
For14 the soule being a substance spirituall, without bodie and immortall, as it cannot dye, so neither can it be sayd to rise againe, but to remaine aliue after it is departed out of the bodie.
For vnlesse it were so; the Scripture should not rightly compare the bodie to a cottage, out of which it saith that15 wee depart when wee die, because it esteemeth vs by that part, which discerneth vs from bruite beastes, in which sence also Peter drawing neere vnto death, saith, the16 time is come wherein he must lay downe his tabernacle.
And as the soule of Christ was receiued into Para-
dise17, the same day that departure out of the bodie: so also must18 we thinke of the blessed spirits of the Saints, according to the promise made to the thiefe: This day shalt thou be with me in Paradise.
For19 there is the same condition of the members and of the head, so farre foorth, that wee must beleeue, that euen at this day also the soules of the godly, so soone as they depart out of the bodie, are forthwith taken vp vnto Christ their head.
Which2021 faith Steuen the first Martyr firmely holding, as hee was in dying committed his soule to Christ to bee kept, as to the faithfull shepheard and Bishop of our soules: Lord Iesus receiue my spirit.
In regarde whereof also the Apostle saith: I desire to be22 dissolued, & to be with Christ: & speaking of the faithfull23 after he had said: when our earthly house shalbee dissolued24, we haue a building in heauen, hee addeth, that we are absent as it were in a straunge countrie frō the Lord, so lōg as we abide in the bodie, but do desire the presence of God, by remoouing out of the bodie: vnlesse the soules did remayne aliue after the bodies, and did reteyne their substance, what is that that hath God present, after it is departed from the bodie?
Nowe25 what and howe great that heauenly glorie is which the Spirite of the blessed doe enioy, it is rashnesse to enquire further then God giueth vs leaue to knowe. Let vs be content with these bounds set vnto vs by God, that26 the soules of the godly being discharged of the labour of their warfare doe depart into blessed rest, where they receiue both comfort, and peace, and securitie of cōscience, & with happie reioycing do looke for the accomplishment of the glorie promised vnto them, vntill Christ their redeemer do appeare.
The27 expectation of which seconde and better life, as it deliuereth the godly from all feare of death: so on the other side, the reprobate and vnbeleeuers are horribly afraide with thinking of their vnhappie estate after death,28 whose lotte without doubt is the verie same which29 Iude in his Epistle assigneth to the deuils, that they are kept boūd in chayns, till they be drawen to yͤ punish-
ment, whereunto they are appoynted.
Furthermore30 the comfort which the faithfull receiue by the resurrection of the flesh that is to come, is conteined in these wordes: That this flesh of mine, also beeing raysed vp by the power of Christ, shall againe be vnited vnto my soule, & be made like vnto the glorious body of Christ.
So31 also the resurrection of the flesh is verie rightly defined, to wit, a raysing vp of that very flesh which did fal: Euen as it is described by Damascene: The resurrection is the32 second standing vp of that which fell: or the resurrection is a conioyning againe of the soule and bodie together, and a secondarie restoring of that liuing creature which was dissolued, and did fall.
And that the same flesh of mine which fell, shall rise againe,33 what more certeine proofe can I haue, then Christ himselfe, who after his resurrection said to Thomas: Put thy finger here and see my handes, and put foorth thy hand and put it into my side: and to his disciples: Behold mine3435 handes and my feete, for it is I my selfe, handle me.
Whereupon Paule calleth Christ the first fruites of them that rise againe, because as hee rose againe in no other36 bodie but his owne, so also we, who belong vnto Christ, shall euerie one of vs rise againe in our owne flesh.
Whereto also may bee added that which the Apostle in the same place witnesseth: This mortall must put on immortality, and this corruptible must put on incorruption: for, if37 euery seede in nature receiue his owne proper bodie surelie it were against reason, that the same bodie of man which is sowed, shoulde not rise againe: which is also to be vnderstood of the soule, namely, that that very soule which was before vnited to the bodie, shall bee restored vnto it againe.
For this were contrarie to the righteousnes of God, if38 the same bodie, wherein the Martyrs suffered for the Name and doctrine of Christ, shoulde not ryse againe to glorie and immortalitie: if neither that soule, that bodie, that tongue, nor that hande which haue dispitefully vsed39 Christ and his members, should come vnder euerlasting40 torment and paines: likewise, if that soule, where-
with holy men haue glorified & called vpon God, should not be blessed with euerlasting glorie.
Hereto may bee added that the Apostles saying, that Christ shalbe the Iudge of the worlde, alledging the testimony41 of Esay: I liue, saith the Lord, and euery knee shal bowe vnto me: where he doth openly declare that they whom hee speaketh vnto shall come before him to giue an account of their life, which could not be true, if there should new bodies come to appeare at the iudgement seat of God.
And euen very children doe so vnderstand the words of rysing and raysing againe: for we will not say that that riseth againe which is now first created, neither could yͤ saying of Christ stand: Whatsoeuer my Father hath giuen me42, it shall not perish, but I will raise it vp at the last day.
With43 this hope was Iob comforted, when he was more like a dead corps, then a man, because hee knew that hee should be clothed againe with his skinne, and that hee should in his flesh see God, euen he and none other for him.
The44 ground of this our comfort is twofold. 1. The power of Iesus Christ. 2. His trueth, who can neither deceiue nor lie.
For45 seeing that Christ is not onely man, but also God, and46 therefore almightie, as hee was able to rayse vp himselfe47, so shall it be easie for him, to quicken our bodie, after it be brought to dust: and he hauing all the elements ready at his becke, no difficultie can let him, but that he may commaund the earth, the water and the fire to restore, whatsoeuer seemeth to haue beene consumed by them.
And wheras it was saide euen now, that for proofe of the resurrection, soules must bee directed to the infinite power48 of Christ, Paule doth briefly teach the same when he saith, that we do looke for Christ from heauen to make our vile bodie like to his glorious bodie, according to his mighty power, wherby he is able to subdue all things vnto himselfe.
So that they indeede doe very grossely, who doe here respect, what may naturally be done, where there is laid before vs an incomprehensible miracle, which by the greatnes thereof doeth euen swallow vp our sences, whome49 the Apostle doeth verye deseruedly scorne at.
Last of al to know in what state the same flesh of ours shall be, maketh not a little for the comfort of all the godly, namely, Like vnto the glorious bodie of Christ.
The same flesh: for substance, shall rise againe: but the qualitie50 of it shalbe changed: for it shall be beautified & indued with a new excellency, brightnes and glorye, and shall be indeede altogether glorious, and that not only because it shalbe incorruptible, but chiefly for some more51 excellent chaunge: as when Christ saith, that in the52 resurrection we shalbe as the Angels in heauen: and in53 another place hee compareth the righteous to the shining54 of the Sunne: a tast whereof he gaue in his owne bodie vpon the mountaine, when hee was transformed before his disciples, and his countenance did shine like the Sunne.
The55 Apostle intending to shew the same change saith: It is sown a naturall bodie, it riseth a spirituall body: &, as we haue borne the image of the earthly, so shall wee beare the image of the heauenly: signifying that in the resurrection our bodies shalbe spirituall and heauenly: not that the matter of our bodies shalbe brought to nothing, but because after the resurrection, they shall liue no more a naturall life, but a spirituall life: they shall not be nourished, they shall not beget: they shalbe inflamed with the quickening Spirit, and shalbe altogether glorified, & yet determined within some place.
And56 by this excellency shall the bodies of the righteous differ from the bodies of the vnbeleeuers, which shall also rise againe by the power of Christ, but as of a Iudge, and shalbe indeed incorruptible and immortall, in respect that they shall neuer die: but these things as all other things shall turne to them for a curse, so that they had rather a thousande times die, then to liue so miserable in paines that neuer shal haue end.
Last of all that which the Apostle saith, that our vile bodies must be made like vnto his glorious body, is not so to be taken, as if both should be in equall glorie, but accoraccording to the measure of the gift of Christ: for it is meete that the head should haue some preheminence aboue the members.
Wherefore57 seeing wee haue this grounde of the resurrection of our flesh, from hence is ministred vnto vs that comfort which is necessarie. 1 To take away all heauynes which we conceiue for the dead, according to Pauls doctrine: I would not haue you ignorāt, brethren, concerning those58 that sleep, that you sorrow not as others yͭ haue no hope? For if ye beleeue that Iesus dyed and rose agayne, so also shall God bring with him those that are laid asleepe in Iesus. 2. To driue away all feare of death by the hope of a better life, to59 which wee shall come by the resurrection, in respect of which60 end Tertullian doubted not to call the resurrection of the flesh, the confidence of Christians. 2. To incourage vs61 vnto good workes, not to deserue any thing, but because62 life is promised to them that doe well. Last of all, that by remembrance the resurrection to come, wee may be hindred from euill doing, euen because of the punishment then threatned to euil doers.
The false doctrine.
If the soules of the godly after they are departed out of the bodie63, are straight way receiued into euerlasting tabernacles, and gathered vnto Christ their head: contrariwise the soules64 of the wicked vnto the deuill, that which the Romanists trifle about yͤ paines of Purgatory, must needs be a meere forgerie.
Such65 is also the fancy of those who are called Psychopānychites, or rather ψυχοκτονοι, that is, soule killers, but without66 wound, who say that the soules do sleep, or else die, vntill the day of iudgement.
Thirdly67, if the same flesh for substance shall rise agayne, which did fall, wickedly thought the Manicheis, both old and new68, (as the Anabaptistes*) who imagined that the soules should haue new and other bodies, because it is not meete that the flesh which is vncleane, shoulde rise againe: as if ther were no vncleannes of the soule: forgetting the Apostles doctrine, that* flesh and blood shall not possesse the kingdome of God, that is, that in the resurrection our bodies shalbe deliuered from all infirmitie.
To whom they also may be added, who said that the resurrection69 was past alreadie, as long ago Hymeneus and Philetus, and at this day many fantastical men, imagining the resurrection to be I know not what allegorie.
Last of all, their error also is here described, who haue by strange70 deuises darkened the doctrine of the resurrection, as the Pythagoreans long since, and others, who haue brought in the returning of mans soule into the bodies of beasts, to bee borne againe: against whom Augustine hath written, lib. 22. de Ciuitate Dei, Cap, 28.
1 Gen.2.7 and 3.19.
2 That there shalbe a resurrection of the flesh.
3 Gen.23.19.20
4 Gen.33.19
5 Gen.49.29.30
6 Gen.50.25.
7 Iosu.24.34.
8 Iob.19.25. 26.27.
9 Dan.12.2.
10 Iohn 5.29.
11 Mat.22.31.32
12 1 Cor.15.20. 21.22.
13 The state of the soule after the depra.ture thereof out of the bodie.
14 What the soule is.
15 2 Cor.5.1.
16 2. Pet 14.4.
17 Luke 23.42.
18 Phil.1.21.
19 That the soules of the faithful do depart out of the bodie vnto Christ
20 Act 7.59.
21 1.Pet.1.25,
22 Phil.1.2.3.
23 2.Cor.5.1.
24 That the soules reteine their substance after they are out of the bodie.
25 That it cannot be knowen what glorie the soules haue in heauen.
26 Luke 16.9. and 21
27 What is the condition of the wicked after death
28 Luke 16.23.
29 Iude.6.
30 The comfort of the faithfull by the resurrection of the flesh.
31 The definition of the resurrection.
32 Orth.fid.lib.4. cap.28.
33 That the same flesh of mine and no other shall rise againe.
34 Iohn.20.27.
35 Luke.24.38.
36 1.Cor.15.23.
37 1.Cor.15.56. and 55.54
38 That the same soule of mine shalbe ioyned againe to the bodie.
39 Acts 7.59.
40 Iohn 16.9, 22.
41 Esa.45.23
42 Iohn 6.34.
43 Iob.19.25.26.
44 By whose power the resurrection shalbe wrought.
45 Rom.1.4.
46 Rom.8.11.
47 1 Cor.15.21.
48 Philip.3.20.21
49 1. Cor.15.39.
50 What māner of flesh we shall haue in the resurrection.
51 Mat.22.30.
52 Mat.13.34.
53 Mat.17.17.
54 1 Iohn 3.2.
55 1 Cor.15.49
56 What maner of bodies the vnbeleeuers shall haue after the resurrection.
57 The Vse.
58 1.Thes.4.13.4.
59 2.Cor.5.1.2
60 Tertullian.
61 Rom.2 7.10
62 Iohn 5.29.
63 Concil.Trid. sess.6.cap.30.
64 Purgatorie refuted.
65 The errour of the Psychopannychits.
66 Epiph.l.2.tom.2.cap.56.
67 That there is vncleannes in our soules
68 1.Cor.15.50.
69 The errour of Hymeneus & Philetus. 2.Tim.2.17.
70 The errour of the Pythagoreans.