An Exposition or Commentarie upon the Catechisme of Christian Religion (1589), Jeremias Bastingius · PDF

Question 80

THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.

The Arg. An opposition of the Masse and the Supper of the Lord, and who ought & may come vnto the Supper, and whome Christ would haue to be kept from the Supper.

Question.

What difference is there betweene the Supper of the Lord, and the popish Masse?

Answere.

The Supper of the Lorde doeth witnesse vnto vs, that wee haue perfit forgiuenesse of all our sinnes, for that only sacrifice of Christ, which himselfe once offered vpon the Crosse: and then that wee are by the holy Ghost ingraffed into Christ, who now according to his humanity is only in heauen at the right hand of the Father; and will there be worshipped for vs.

But in the Masse it is denyed, that the quick & dead haue forgiuenesse of sinnes for the only suffering of Christ, vnlesse Christ be still euery day offered for them by the Priestes: And then it is taught, that Christ is bodily vnder the appearāce of bread and wine, and therefore ought to be worshipped in thē. And so the very foundation of the Masse is nothing else, but a denying of that only Sacrifice, and suffering of Iesus Christ, & a most cursed idolatrie.

The Exposition.

The refutation of the false doctrine, or transubstantiation is still continued, the absurdity whereof that it may the more appeare, it is compared with the true doctrine of the Lordes Supper, or rather is set directlie against it.

And1 for the worde Masse, the Romanistes as yet could neuer finde any fitte signification for it, although it maruelously pleaseth them, when some of them say, that it commeth of the Hebrew word Masse, which signifieth tribute, happily for that cause, (and not amisse) because by the benefite of the Masse they haue made both quicke and dead tributaries vnto them, which no tyrant euer durst to doe: or because the worde Masse commeth of Masas which signifieth to melt or dissolue, thereof the Masse also may haue the beginning, to wit, because by it all sound religion in the Church may seeme to bee melted and disolued.

But this is a neerer signification and better liked, that the word Missa, or Missa or Missa in the plurall number and neuter gender, all which signifie the Masse, doeth signifie sendings, or things sent and offered, which were bestowed to the glorie of God, for the celebration of that publike action, or last of all the saide worde came from hence: that the Priestes hauing ended the action vsed in these wordes, Ite, missa est, that is, depart, for you are dismissed: in stead of which words the Greekes did vse2 λαοῖς αφεσις εξω that is, the people may depart. Howsoeuer it bee, all these fitte it better, then that interpretation, which Innocentius the thirde Pope of that name giueth of these wordes Ite missa est,; for Ite dimissa est, est, that is, go, for it is sent away, to wit, their sacrifice, or hoste: but whither I pray you? they say into heauen, but we say into their belly, because their Pope will needes haue it sensually to be chammed with their teeth.

But that it may bee vnderstood what difference there is betweene the supper of the Lord, and the Popish Masse, the Catechist setteth down an opposition between them in manner as followeth.

First he declareth and knitteth vp in few wordes all those3 thinges, of which the supper beareth witnes vnto vs: Secondly he sheweth how these things are denied in the Masse, and finally concludeth these things beeing set downe, what we are to thinke of the sacrifice of the Masse, & what account to make of it.

The principall vse of the Supper is declared to bee that one, namely to put vs in minde, & assure vnto vs, that4 wee haue perfite remission of all our sinnes, for that onely sacrifice of Christ, which himselfe hath once offered vpon the crosse: For so the holy Ghost in the Epistle to the Hebrews comparing Christ to the high Priestes of Aarons order, saith that hee was a farre other manner of Priest5 then they were, because he needeth not daily, as those high Priests, to offer vp sacrifice first for his owne sinnes, and then for the sinnes of the people: for that (saith he) did he once when he offered vp himselfe: which hee repeateth in many places, that, Christ did once appeare in the end of the world to take away sinne by offering vp of himselfe: & was once offered to take away sinnes of many: to conclude, that, after hee had6 offered one sacrifice for sinnes, he sitteth for euer at the right hand of God, as he himselfe also had confirmed this vpon7 the crosse, when hauing receiued the vineger, hee said, It is finished.

Of this onely and perfite, and once offered sacrifice of Christ, the testimony and seale is the holy Supper of the Lord, as the words spoken of the broken bread distributed by Christ vnto his disciples doe shew, this is my body which is broken for you, and of the cuppe, this is my blood.

Contrariwise the Masse denyeth that the quicke and dead haue forgiuenesse of sinnes for the onely sacrifice of Christ, vnlesse still Christ be dayly offred for them by the Priestes.

By8 which opposition it may easily bee gathered, what the Masse of the Romanistes is and how great is the abomination thereof. Therefore the Masse is such a manner of action ordained by the Popes themselues to that end, that it might be a kind of pacification or oblation, whereby satisfaction may be made to God, for the quick and the dead, the onely sacrifice of Christ, being often & againe repeated by the Priestes.

In9 which definition there are many errours met together: for the first errour, and the first absurdity is that they make the Masse a sacrifice, so confounding Sacraments, and sacrifices, and making no difference between the one and the other, whereby it is manifest, that they haue scarce euer had any smattering in the doctrine of the Sacraments.

For Sacraments and sacrifices differ, because in sacraments we our selues receiue some thing, and God giueth vs and bestoweth vpon vs Christ with all his benefits, & merites,10 as the very words of the supper do sound: Take & eate: he saith not, offer: But the sacrifice of the Masse is imagined to pay a price vnto God, which hee receiueth for satisfaction: so that looke what ods there is betweene giuing and taking, so much differeth the sacrifice of the Masse from the Sacrament of the Supper.

For11 whereas the ancient writers (as they saie) haue often vsed the word sacrifice, & haue called the holy supper of the Lord by yͤ name, they did it in no other respect but as it was a memorial of that true and only sacrifice which Christ himself wrought vppon the crosse, who is (as they themselues euery where say our onely Priest: and that euen in this respect they called the holy supper a sacrifice of thankesgiuing, it is euerie where to bee seene out of their writings,

The12 second errour and absurdity is, that they make the Masse to be a sacrifice for the quick & the dead; the supper only serueth for the liuing, and the faithfull are commaunded while they liue, to keepe this supper in remembraunce of the death of the Lorde: for who can13 praise God in the graue, saith the Pprohet? Secondly as the word, so also the Sacraments, and all admonitions14 belong onely to this present life: to the intent that in15 this time a man may bee stirred vp by them vnto repentance16 and faith: for it is written, To day if yee will heare his17 voice: and, it is appointed to men once to die, & after that commeth the iudgement, but this errour of theirs came of this, that like wretched Idolaters they gaue so much the worthines of the very worke wrought, that they imagined that faithles worke of theirs was able to helpe the deade, and to saue the soules in Purgatory (which inuention of their18 owne pleaseth them well.)

The third errour is, that whereas in the Supper we are tought that Christ once offred himselfe for the sinnes of mākind, & that once vpō the altar of the crosse, by which offering hee deserued for vs full forgiuenesse of all our sinnes: the Romanistes teach, that euen at this day Christ doth not indeede offer himselfe, but is offered by the Priests vnto God his Father: not that he offered himselfe once by his euerlastinge Spirite, but that hee must daily be offered of them, to the end that wee may obtaine forgiuenes of sinnes, then which what can be deuised or spoken more grosse?

For what is it to crucifie Christ with the furious Iewes, and to call in question and ouerthrow his passion, if this bee not? or rather to blot and beate out of the remembrance of men his true and onely death? and not onely his19 death, but also the fruit, which was comming to vs by the death of Christ, which is altogether taken from vs by this sacrifice of the Masse? For who can thinke that he is redeemed by the death of Christ, when he findeth a20 new redemption in the Masse?

Moreouer21 when they call their vnbloodie sacrifice, they are contrary both to the scripture and to themselues, whereas that principle standeth sure, that vnto forgiuenes of sinnes is required shedding of blood. Besides they take away that honour from Christ, which the scripture hath giuen vnto him, namely that hee is a Priest for euer according to the order of Melchisedech, that he hath a Priesthood wherein none can succeed him, that is, whose onely offring once made, and his continual intercession for vs vnto God, can be translated to no other.

Adde22 to these the fourth blasphemy, that they giue Christ to the Father, whereas the Father hath giuen him to vs: which is so manifest, that it scarsely seemeth to neede any refutation: although those wretches beeing more sensles then the very bruit beasts, doe set their first & last stay of their saluation in this onely dānable gulfe.

The seconde part of the opposition consisteth in this, that23 in the Supper it is declared that wee are made partakers of Christ, and are ingraffed into him by faith and the holy Ghost. What doeth the Masse? It teacheth that24 Iesus Christ our Lorde true God, and true man, is truely25 and really, and substantially contayned vnder the appearance26 of sensible thinges, that is in bodie vnder shewe of breade and wine, and whosoeuer take vnto themselues those outwarde appearances, are made one with Christ and incorporated into him.

And here againe first they are deceiued, in that they thinke the appearance onely, or shew of bread and wine to bee in the vse of the Supper, and not true breade and wine, so taking away the proportion betweene the signes and the thing signifyed, because there can bee no agreement betweene accidentes and substaunces, neither can whitenesse, rednesse, and roundnesse represent vnto vs thinges that haue substance, as the body and bloode of the Lord. Secondly, in that the Canon of their Masse doeth teach that Christ is bodily vnder these accidentes, and whitenesse of bread, and the tast of wine: which is not onely contrary to the trueth of Christes manheade, (for it is the propertie of a bodie, to be seene, to be felt, to be contained in place, which essentiall propertie, they who take away: doe take away the thing it selfe) but it is also contrarye to the Sacramentall coniunction of the thing with the signes, which resteth in the ordinance of God, and medleth not to declare any bodily or naturall situation, but onely hath respect hereunto, that we may know that after a spirituall manner, that is truely giuen vnto vs to be taken hold of by faith, which the signes doe truely signifie, that is, the bodie and blood of the Lord.

The thirde pointe wherein the holy Supper and the Masse27 are one set against the other is, that whereas the supper2829 putteth vs in minde to lift vp our hearts by faith into30 heauen, whether also the articles of faith doe leade vs,31 that from thence Christ may feede vs with his fleshe and with his body vnto life euerlasting, and that there we32 may worship him according to that saying. Lift vp your33 hearts. Contrariwise the Masse laying this false foundation that he is bodily vnder the appearance of bread & wine. 1. Doth shamefully enforce and faigne by a cursed forgerie, that the body of Christ goeth downe into our bodies. 2. will haue him there to bee worshipped, as he is offered by the Priest vpon the altar, contrary to the doctrine of Christ, and of the Apostles.

To which abuses other also may be added, as that whereas the bread and wine are Sacraments onely when they are vsed: the popish sort do carrie about their idole to bee worshipped. Secondly, whereas in the Supper the cuppe is commanded to bee reached to all that come to receiue, the Priestes deny it to the lay people. Thirdly, that whereas the holy supper is a Sacrament of the Communion or fellowship of the faithfull with Christ, and one with another, they haue turned this action into priuate Masses.

Which being so, what else can be thought of the Masse, then that as the holy Supper of the Lorde wee are led to the onely sacrifice of Iesus Christ once wrought vpon the crosse, wherein we haue forgiuenes of sinnes and life euerlasting: so the ground of that quite contrary is the denying of that onely sacrifice and passion of Iesus Christ, and consequently of saluation purchased by him: and therefore the masse is a most cursed Idolatrie.

The vse.

The vse of these things is, that wheresoeuer this horrible Idolatrie is exercised, wee auoide that assemblie, remembring this saying of the Prophet and of the Apostle: Come forth from the midst of them: forasmuch as Antichrist doeth there openly rule & holde his kingdome.

1 The orignal of the worde Masse.

2 Ite,missa est.

3 The diuision.

4 The vse of the Supper.

5 Heb.5.1.3.& 7.27.& 9.12. 26.28.& 10. 10.12.14.

6 Heb.10.10.12 14.

7 Ioh.19.30.

8 The definitio of the popish Masse.

9 Conc.Trid.sess. 22.1.can.23.

10 Wherein Sacraments and sacrifices doe differ.

11 Chrysost.homil. 24.1.Cor.super illud Calix bened.

12 Con.Trid.sess. 22.can.2.

13 Catech. Rom. par.2.p.206. cap.4.sess.63.

14 Psal.6.6.

15 Psal.95.7

16 Heb.9.27.

17 Heb.4.7.

18 Con.Trid.sess. 22.can.

19 Heb,19.12.

20 Psal.110.4.

21 Heb.7.21,24.

22 Esa.9.5.

23 1 Cor.6.18. and 10.16. and 12.13.

24 Ephes.3.17.

25 Conc.Trid.sess. 13.cap.2.3.

26 Catech.Rom. par.sest.38.

27 Heb.1.3.

28 Act.7.55.56

29 Col.3.1.

30 Phil.3.20.

31 Conc.Trid.sess. 13.cap.5.

32 Ioh.4.21.22. 23.24.

33 Tit.2.8.