Question 27
THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.
The Arg. Of Prouidence belonging to the common place of Creation, and of the vse of both.
Question.
What is Prouidence?
Answere.
The almightie & euery where present power of God, wherby he doth as it were beare vp with his hand, and gouerne the heauen & earth, with al creatures so that whatsoeuer groweth out of the earth, also raine and drouth, plentie and dearth meat and drink, health and sicknes, riches and pouertie, finallie all things that are, fall out not rashly or by chance, but by his fatherly counsell and will.
The exposition.
In the former diuision hath beene expounded the first article of our Catholicke faith, wherein mention was made of the creation of heauen and earth, and of the prouidence of God, whereby hee vpholdeth and gouerneth all creatures, to the definition whereof the Catechist now passeth, which that we may the better vnderstande, we shall do well to deuide this whole treatise into three parts. 1. To shew that there is Prouidence in God. 2. To shew out of the Scripture, what prouidence is, how many kinds thereof there be, & about what matters it is occupied. 3. What is the vse of it.
And first that there is Prouidence, this part may very well1 be fetched from that reason which teacheth there is a God, which being granted, we must needes also confesse that the world is ruled by his counsell.
Againe, either we must deny that there is a God, or else whosoeuer graunteth there is a God, must also confesse, that that God doth somewhat, and that some excellent thing: but there is nothing more excellent then the rule of the world: Therefore the world is ruled by the counsell or prouidence of God.
Thirdely, except it be so, there must needes bee some better thing and of greater might then God, whatsoeuer it be, whether it be some nature without life, or necessitie driuen on with great force, which bringeth these goodly workes to passe which we behold. But so the nature of God is neither most mighty, nor most excellent, in as much as it is subiect to that either necessitie or nature, whereby the heauen, the sea and the earth are ruled: but nothing is more excellent then God, therefore the world must needes be ruled by him.
For if wee graunt that God hath vnderstanding, wee graunt also that he hath prouidence, and that in the greatest matters: Therefore whether he doth not know what are the greatest matters, and how they are to bee handled, and maintained, or hath he no power whereby to sustaine and beare vp so waightie matters? but both to bee ignorant of any thinge is farre from the nature of God, and for weakenes not to bee able to sustayne so great a charge is farre from the maiestie of God, who both knoweth all things and is almightie: whereof is concluded that which we intend, that the world is ruled by prouidence.
And if there be in mankinde, vnderstanding, reason, counsell, and wisedome, from whence could these things come into the earth but from God? surely it must needes be, that whatsoeuer is in vs, God hath the same in more excellency and not onely hath it, but also doth here vse it in the greatest and best matters: but there is none of the inferiour Creatures either greater or better then the world, therefore it must needes be, that the world is ruled by the counsell and prouidence of God.
Hitherto belongeth that of Iob: Who hath put wisedome into the reynes, or who hath giuen the hart Vnderstanding? from hence I thus gather: If man deale prouidently in his matters, howe much more doth God, from whome man hath receiued his vnderstandinge and his reason, gouerne the worlde by his prouidence and certen counsell?
And that this is so, this goodly order of al things in the world doth speake aloude, by which order things of lesse excellencie are subiect to the more excellent, thinges without life to things hauing life, things without reason to things hauing reason: to conclude, things earthly to things heauenly, so that beeing most bewtifully linked togither, they doe one serue another, and all are neerely ioyned among themselues, & this order abideth alwaies and neuer faileth: There are aboue fiue thousande, fyue hundreth, foure score and fiue yeares since the world being created is preserued and abideth in this forme, beautie and perfection: therefore it must needes be preserued by some who hath care of the world, and who is able & can2 tell how to preserue it: for of it selfe it can not bee preserued. For if a ship, (as Chrysostome very aptly speaketh) be it neuer so strong and well furnished, yet is not able to continue in the waues without a gouernor, how much lesse may the whole worlde continue, without some to take the care and gouernement of it? And what other should or can there be, by whome the world is preserued, then he by whome it was made? for none is more mightie, more wise, and better then hee, who is willing, skilfull, and able to gouerne the world. Therefore it must needes be that God by his prouidence doeth rule and gouerne it.
2. Seeing then it is confessed that there is prouidence in God, and none but a plaine Godlesse person dare denie it,it shall be worth our labour to weigh and diligently to examine the definition of it.
It3 is defined to be the almightie and euery where present power of God: where it is to bee obserued that by this power is signified the very working whereby things are cared for and ruled of God, before which working goeth a foreknowledge of all thinges and of all necessities: then a wil & care to looke vnto them: which two things are in God euerlasting, & whereof consisteth prouidence so farre forth as it is in God, and as by his euerlasting ordinance hee hath decreed howe to bring euery seuerall thinge to his ende the execution of which ordinaunce and decree is this povver, which is properly called gouernement.
For albeit God is a most simple essence, yet, the better to teach, because wee can not otherwise conceiue of him according to our owne capacitie wee must needs consider in him a povver to vnderstand and to will, and also to execute whatsoeuer hee hath from euerlastinge foreseene, appointed, and ordeined: especially seeinge hereof it is called Prouidence by the Grecians προνοια, that is a power whereby things are foreknowne and προωρισμος wherby the same are foreordained and ruled, whereof we reade in the Acts: Against thine holy Son Iesus whome thou hast annointed, both Herod and Pontius Pilate with the Gentiles, and the people of Israel assembled themselues together, to do whatsoeuer thy hand, and thy comsell had4 before ordayned to be done.
Secondly, prouidence is called such a power, as is almightie and euery where present &c. the almightie power5 thereof the Psalmist setteth forth when hee saith: Our6 God is in heauen, he doth whatsoeuer he will: and Iob, I know that thou canst doe all things, & no man can let thee to bring thy purpose to passe. Of this presence in all places himselfe7 speaketh in the Prophet: Am I a God at hande, saith8 the Lord, and not a God a farre of? do not I fill heauen and9 earth? saith the Lord. Whereupon saith the wise man, He10 reacheth from end to end mightily, and disposeth all things profitably, which profite, although wee doe not alwaies marke, yet is it alwaies such as it maketh for the glorie of God.
Now how farre this power and facultie is extended, how mightie it is, and what thinges are conteined within the care thereof, the Catechist doth very well lay open, when he saith it is such and so great, as doth euen to this present,11 as it were beare vp with the handle and gouerne heauen and earth, and all creatures. &c.
And surely so it is: for the Scripture in these sentences a little before recited doth challenge vnto God, and will haue vs yeeld vnto him, a watchfull, an effectuall, a working and continuall doing omnipotencie: for therefore is he accounted almightie, not because in deede hee can doe all thinges, but sometime doth rest and take his ease, but because by his prouidence gouerninge heauen and earth, hee doeth so order all thinges, that nothing commeth12 to passe but by his counsell. Wherefore for more plainenes wee may very well put a difference betweene Generall prouidence in God, and that which is called Perticular, making the Generall, whereby euen vntill this present he preserueth & maintayneth the world & al things that are therein, or which are conteined within the compasse thereof, and this goodly order of nature, which himselfe did set at the first: Particular, that whereby hee hath13 a speciall care ouer euery one of his workes: euen as fathers purpose with themselues to looke vnto, first generally the whole housholde, next especially, their children, their wife, and their kinsfolke: thirdely their houshold seruants, then the verie bruit beastes: last of all whatsoeuer is in the house, and the house it selfe and all the parts of the house.
And first for the Generall prouidence whereby God standeth by the whole worlde, and ruleth it, euen this onely14 testimony is cleare to prooue it. That when God would punish the sinnes of the world with waters, that he might not vtterly destroy all mankind, he commanded an Arke to bee prouided wherein the seede not of mankinde alone, but euen of all liuing creatures might be preserued, that from thence not long after hee might bring againe, the increase of all sortes of liuing creatures into the world: and that not extraordinarily by creating new men and new liuing creatures, as hee was very well able to doe; but by an ordinarie way and alreadie prouided to keep male and female of euery sort.
There1516 are besides notable places of this generall prouidence,17 whereby the whole worlde is gouerned at the18 becke and will of God, to be found in Iob, in the Psalmes,1920 in the Prophets, in the Gospell, which for breuitie21 I onely quote in the Margent.
Concerning2223 the particular prouidence of God, there are24 speciall testimonyes thereof reckned vp in the text of25 the Catechisme, as 1. those things that grow out of the2627 earth, of which that speach of Christ is well known: Learne28 of the Lillies of the field how they grow, they neither labour, nor spinne, and yet I say vnto you that Salomon in all his glorie was not arraied like one of these. Wherfore if God so cloath29 the grasse of the field, which is to day, and to morrow is cast30 into the ouen, will he not doe much more vnto you, O yee of3132 little faith? 2. The raine, which Moyses and the Apostle testifie33 to fall downe from heauen, and that by the blessing34 of God: Amos saith that God beeing displeased doeth withhoulde35 it, and causing it to raine vpon one cittie doth not cause it to rain vpō another, & that for the wickednes of mē.
3 But what more cleare argument of the speciall prouidence36 of God, can be giuen, then that of Elyas the Thisbite,37 foretelling by the commandement of God, that38 for many yeres there should be neither dew nor rain but according to his worde?
4 Likewise39 Plentie, that is, for the earth to bring foorth40 corne, dependeth also of the same prouidence of God,41 as when he saith: And it shall be in that day, I will heare the heauens, and they shall heare the earth, and the earth shall heare the wheat.
5 So42 hee pronounceth himselfe to bee the author of dearth,43 when he proclaimeth a famine for seuen yeares, and44 foretelleth that he wil take away all the staffe of bread and all the staffe of water.
6 And45 for meate and drinke, who gaue Manna and water to the Israelites in the wildernes: who fed Moyses fortie4647 daies and fortie nights without meate or drinke? who48 fed Elias by the rauen, by an angell, and by the widow49? Euen God by his fatherly prouidence, by whose will50 and counsell it came to passe, that the oyle of the widowe51 of Sarepta did increase, which God euen at this day also doth fill our hearts with meate and gladnes.
7 Besides,52 health and sicknes euen they also depend of53 God: I will appoint ouer you fearefulnes(saith the Lord) a54 consumption, & the burning ague to consume the eies, and make55 the heart heauie: so Christ did rebuke the feuer, & of the56 blind man he witnesseth, that neither he hath sinned, nor57 his parents, that he should bee borne blynd, but that the workes of God might be manifested in him.
Last58 of all, hee it is that maketh poore and inricheth, that doth humble, and doth exalt, that raiseth the poore out59 of the dust, and lifteth the begger out of the dunghill,60 whereupon Salomon saith: The rich and the poore meet togeither, the Lord is the maker of them all, and Mary in61 her song. He hath filled the hungry with good things, and the62 rich he hath sent empty away.
And63 what if not onely these outward thinges, which doe but befall man, but euen euery action of men both godly & vngodly, also their motions, & chiefly their will are64 subiect to the speciall prouidence of God? Lord thou hast proued me and knowne me, if these things be true in David,65 why are they not also in other men? I know (saith Ieremie) that the way of man is not in himselfe, neither is it in man to walke and to direct his steps.
And66 Solomon. The disposition of the heart is in man, but the answer of the tongue is of the Lord: and, the steps of man are67 ruled by the Lord, how then cau man vnderstand his own way?68and, The hart of the King is in the hand of God: which appeared69 in Esau louingly imbracing Iacob, whereas hee had70 set foorth against him altogeither with a purpose of defiance7172 and the Egyptians, among whome God gaue his73 people fauour, when they were now readie to depart, &74 last of all in Nabuchodonoser, who when he had resolued himselfe to vndertake a viage, and was now in his iourney, against the Amonits, yet would not go forward on his iourney, but was led by the Lord toward Ierusalē.
But the Scripture, the more to expresse, that there is nothing75 done in the world, but by his appointmēt, doth shew that euen those things that seeme most casuall, are yet notwithstanding subiect to his ordinance: for what is more casual, then as a traueler passeth by, for a bough or an arme of a tree falling downe to kill him? but the Lord speaketh otherwise of it, who confesseth that hee hath76 deliuered him into the hand of the slayer: So saith Solomon77 that euen lots (then which nothing is more casual) are ruled and guided by God himselfe.
In78 which sense it is very trnelie saide by Basile: Fortune & Chaunce are the words of the heathē, with the signification whereof the mindes of the godly ought not at al to haue to doe,79 And of Fortune thus speaketh Plinie the writer of the naturall historie: Throughout the whole world and in al places, and at al houres, and in all mens speeches, Fortune alone is called vpon, shee alone is talked of, shee alone is accused and charged to be in all fault, shee alone is thought of, she alone is blamed and honoured euen with reuiling, thought of most to be chaungeable, yea and blinde and also wauering too & fro inconstant, vncerten, variable, fauouring the vnworthie. Trusting to her, men take great aduentures, & her mē thanke for all, and in all affaires of men shee alone is thought to haue all to doe. And those verses of the Poets are well knowen,
Graunt Prouidence, and no more Gods shall neede to be sought80 for.
But fonde men set Fortune aloft and make her a Goddesse.
Which opinion how wide it is from holy Scripture is hereby plainely prooued, because if all good successe bee the blessing of God, and calamitie and aduersitie be his curse, as we haue shewed, there is now no place left for fortune or chaunce in all the affaires of men.
Although81 in the meane time it cannot be denied, but that many things fall out by chaunce and by hap in respect of men, not because Fortune ruleth ouer the worlde and ouer men, and doeth disorderly tumble all thinges vpside downe, but because the order, the manner, the ende, the necessitie of all thinges that fall out doeth for the most part lie hid in the counsell of God, and is not attained vnto by the opinion of man, those things are as it82 were casuall, which most certenly doe proceede from the will of God: of which sort that is, that one in his simplicitie, that is, by hap, or by chaunce, thinking nothing, drew a bow and smote the King of Israel betweene the ioynts of his brigadine.
But83 in respect of God it is so true, that all things come necessarily84 to passe, that not so much as sinne it selfe is committed without his will, or beside his will, but euen according to his prouidence, yet so as that he is not therefore, neither ought to be accounted the author of sinne85. 1. Because sinne (as Iohn saith) is the transgression86 of the Law. But God neither can swerue from the strait8788 rule of his owne wil, neither doth putt wickednes into89 any man, which is of the deuill, and abideth in the vngodly90 them selues: therefore as the earth affoording sap91 as well to the euill trees as to good cannot be founde fault92 withall, because the euill tree bringeth foorth euill fruits,93 so much lesse can God be called either the author or cause of our sinnes, although by his prouidence hee mooueth all thinges, yea euen the vngodly, In him selfe (saith the Apostle) we liue and mooue, and haue our beeing, such94 as we are, such are we mooued by him, vnlesse he of his grace doe change and alter vs.
Secondly95 because God hateth sinne, and therefore hath96 forbidden, and condemned it in his Law: Thou hatest97 (saith the Psalmist) all them that worke iniquity. And the wise man, God hateth alike, both the wicked man & his wickednesse.
Thirdly, because the actions of God and the wicked haue9899 diuers endes, as when the wicked do euill, they doe it100 to satisfie their mindes, but God directeth their euill actions to another ende, as in the example of Iosephs brethren, Simei, and Iudas the traitour.
This101 also saith Peter, is the will of God, that is his decree, that ye suffer for well doing. But hee that doeth well cannot be hurt without sinne, therefore it is good in respect of God, who willeth, that is, ordeineth that there should be persecuters of the Church, vpon whome notwithstanding he doeth afterward take vengeance most seuerely, as vpon sinners against his will, that is, doers of that which he alloweth not.
Which102 Augustine did very well vnderstand, whose answere will alwaies satisfie any sober wit: When the Father deliuered his Sonne, and Christ his bodie, and Iudas his master, why in this deliuerie is God iust, & man sinneful, but onely because in all one thing, which they did, there is not all one cause, for which they did it.
Wherevpon the same Augustine cryeth out in another place: Great are the works of the Lord: being sought out according103 to all his wills, insomuch that by a marvellous and vnspeakeable manner, that is not done beside his will, which yet is done against his will, because it should not be done, if he did not suffer it, neither doth he suffer it against his will, but with his will, neither would hee being good suffer euill to bee done, vnlesse being also almightie he were able vpon euill to worke well.
The false doctrine.
To let goe Protagoras, Melius, and others, who either denied, or at the least doubted, whether there were a God or no, and104 therefore whether there were any Prouidence or no; to let goe also Democritus and Epicurus, who thought all things to haue been made, and daily to be done by chaunce, & by fortune, we must reforme the errors 1. Of them, who make prouidence to be nothing else but a bare foreknowledge wherby God being himselfe idle beholdeth from heauen, what thinges are done in the worlde, whereas on the other side he as it were holding the sterne guideth the falling out of all matters, so that his handes doe as much as his eyes, and by his incomprehensible wisedome he doeth direct and dispose euery thing to his ende. 2. We must also remooue out of the way the doting of the Stoickes, who deuised such a necessitie by the perpetuall105 tying of causes together, & as it were by a naturall106 chaine hauing on linke within another, that they gaue all to the second causes, and left it not free to God to chaunge the order of them at his owne will, and to worke euen agaynst the107 second causes. For Prouidence being in God an almightie power108109.
He can make the sunne to stay the flight of his horses.
He110 can make the streames on a heape to stande as a mountaine.
And111 no lesse fouly are they deceiued, who said that Prouidence in God doeth112 reach euen to singulars, but yet that man is113 excepted in those thinges, which are said to be in our power, as beside other Cicero had rather take away Prouidence altogether,114 then to make mans freedome, that is, freewil subiect to the necessitie thereof, which Augustine did worthily iest115 at, saying that Cicero while he would make men free, made116 them robbers of God.
Wherein117 Damascene did grossely slippe, who after he had concluded that God had care of all thinges, excepted those thinges, which (as he will haue it) are in our power: I meane (saith he) that all thinges are subiect to the Prouidence of God, which are not in our power: For those things that are in our power, are not subiect to Prouidence, but to our own free wil: which surely we haue before shewed to be contrary to the holy Scriptures, and namely a litle before out of the Prouerbs.
Fourthly it is plaine, that they also are in no small errour, who118 haue written, yͭ although God haue care of other things, yet he meddleth not with the smalest things, as with som base liuing creatures, and other such like thinges, and hitherto they applie that: Hath God care of oxen? whereas it is euident dent out of the scriptures, that al liuing things look vp vnto119 God, that he should giue them food in due season: & his120 Prouidence reacheth euen to the small sparrowes, so121 that none of them falleth vpon the grounde without him.
Last of all those also among the Philosophers were in an errour, who thought God should not be happy, if he were troubled to122 care for mens matters, whereas the more things God doeth and meddleth in, the more his power and goodnesse doeth on euery side appeare: wherefore wickedly said Plinie: That indeede123 is meete to bee laughed at, that that soueraigne God, whatsoeuer it be, should take care for mens matters. Can we thinke, or can we doubt, but that he must needes be defiled with so sad and so manifold a busines?
1 Whether there be any prouidence in God.
2 Ad Eph. hom. 19. See. Lact. lib. 3. c. 19: de falsa sapientia.
3 The definition of Prouidence.
4 προώρισε.
5 Psal. 115.3.
6 Iob. 42.2.
7 Ier.23,23.24.
8 Heb. 1.2.3.
9 Wisedome.8.1.
10 Se Damascen. lib. 2. Orth. fid. cap. 29.
11 Heb. 1. 3.
12 A distinction of Prouidēce in God.
13 A similitude.
14 Gen. 7. 1.
15 Mat. 6. 28. 30
16 Psal. 124. 27.
17 Iob. 9. 5. 14. 15
18 Iob. 34. 13.
19 Psal. 147. 4.
20 Esa. 45. 6.
21 Prov. 15. 3.
22 Exod. 4. 11.
23 Mat. 10. 29.
24 Act. 17. 24.
25 Iohn, 5. 17.
26 Eph. 1. 11.
27 Grasse.
28 Mat. 6. 28. 29 30:
29 Raine.
30 Deut. 28. 12.
31 Leu. 26. 3.
32 Act. 14. 17
33 Amos 4. 7.
34 Mat. 5. 45.
35 Ierem. 5. 24.
36 Drouth.
37 3.King.17.1.
38 Iam.5.17.
39 Plentie.
40 Hose.2.21.22.
41 Deut.28.11.
42 Barennes.
43 2.King.8.1.
44 Esa.3.1.
45 Meate and drinke
46 Gen.29.31.
47 Exo.16.14.15.
48 Exod.17.6.
49 1.King.17.14.
50 1.King.19.7.
51 Act.14.17.
52 Health and sickenes.
53 Lev.26.16.
54 Deut.21.22.
55 Ioh.1.21.2.10.
56 Luk.4.39.
57 Ioh.3.9.
58 Pouertie and riches.
59 1.Sam.2.7.8.
60 Psal.75.8.& 113.7.
61 Prou.22.2.
62 Luke.1.53.
63 The will of man &c.
64 Psal.139.1.
65 Ier.10.23.
66 Tōgue, hart, & al are ruled by God.
67 Prou.16.1.
68 Prov.20.24.
69 1.Chron.5.26.
70 Ezra.1.1.1.
71 Prov,21,1.
72 Gen.33.4.
73 Exod.3.24.
74 Eze.21.19.20, 21.22.23.
75 Casual things are also subiect to the prouidence of God.
76 Exod.21.13.
77 Prou.16.
78 Basil. in Psa. 22.
79 Plin. natur. hist. L.2.c.7.
80 Iuuenall.
81 How we must vnderstand that some things come to passe by chaunce and by hap.
82 August. Retract. lib. 1. c. 1.
83 1.King.22.34.
84 Sinne is not committed but by the decree of God.
85 Iohn.8.44.
86 1.Iohn.3 4.
87 Nom.23.19
88 Tit.1.2.
89 Heb.6.18.
90 1.Iohn.1.5.
91 Iam.1.13.
92 Osee 15.9.
93 A similitude
94 Acts 7.28.
95 Psal.5.6.
96 Wisd.14.9.
97 Prou.6.16.
98 Gen.50.19.20.
99 2.Sam.9.10.
100 Math.26.48.
101 1.Pet.3.17.
102 Epist.48 ad Vincent.
103 Psal.111.2.
104 The errour of Democritos and Epicurus
105 Senc. lib. de Prouident.
106 What is ment by Stoicall destinie.
107 Ios.10.12.13.
108 Stigelius.
109 Exo.13.21.22.
110 Lib.2. de Diuinatione.
111 Ierem.10.23
112 Poru.16.1. and 20.24.
113 De ciuitat. Dei, lib.5. cap.9.
114 Lib.2. Orth. Fid, cap.29.
115 quest.8
116 Psal 139.1.
117 Psal.107.40.
118 Ierom. in cap. 1. Haback.
119 1.Cor.9.9.
120 Psal.104.27.
121 Math.10.26.
122 Plut. de plac. philos. cap.7.
123 C.Plin. nat. hist.7.cap.7.