Question 7
THE FIRST PART OF MANS MISERY,
Question.
From whence then ariseth this corruption of mans nature?
Answere.
From the fall and disobeydience of our first parents Adam and Eue in Paradise: where our nature was so corrupted, that we are all conceiued and borne in sinne.
The exposition.
The blame of mans corruption being remoued from God, who in the beginning created man good, and according to his owne image, next is declared the cause of this corruption, to wit, the fall and disobedience of our first parents Adam & Eue: afterwarde is shewed also the effect of that fall, In the fall of man, two thinges are especially to bee considered, the truth of the historie of mans fall, and the blemish or foulenesse of his fal. The1 historie is to bee seene set forth in the booke of Genesis2, wherein the first place wee must marke the commandement of God: And the Lord commaunded man saying: thou shalt eat freely of euery tree in the garden, but of the tree of knowledge of good and euill thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day thou eatest thereof, thou shalt die the death. Here thou hearest the Lawe, thou hearest the punishment added to strengthen the Lawe: let vs nowe heare what man3 did. The woman (seeing that the tree was good for meat and that it was pleasant to the eies, and a tree to be desired to get knowledge) tooke of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gaue also to her husband, and he did eat with her.
By which description or narration of the fall of our first parents, it is easie to vnderstande what is meant by the fall or decay of man, to wit, the same which the Apostle calleth4 offence, which is ioined with transgression of5 the commandement which God gaue to man to keep, so6 that there seemeth to bee no difference, whether you say that this corruption of man did arise from our first parents, or that our first parents did sin, and in sinning did transgresse the commandement of God: for both of them come to one end,
Also out of the same narration, wee may very well frame a full definition of sinne in this manner. To the committing7 of sinne or transgression, these things must needes go before and meete: 1. A commandement or a Lawe, for where there is no Law, there is no transgression. 2. A threatning or paine added to the Lawe. 3. An inclination against the Lawe. 4. The acte it selfe which is not done without inclination going before. wee haue heard the commandement of the Law, thou shalt not eat: the paine was: In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt die: the inclination is signified in these wordes: The woman sawe that the tree was plesaunt to the eyes, and a tree to be desired for knowledge: the transgression or acte in these8 wordes, shee tooke of the fruite thereof and did eate: hereof may arise a perfect definition of sinne. Sinne is an inclination or acte against the Lawe of God, offending God, and deseruing the wrath of God or euerlasting death, vnlesse forgiuenesse be obtained by meanes of the Mediatour.
The9 seconde point to be vnfolded in the fall of man was the blemish or foulenesse of his fall, which is noted in the worde (disobedience) which conteineth all sinnes; the sinne of disobedience is amplified by circumstances, which the holy Ghost would haue to bee diligently receiued by Moses: as
1 That he despiseth the promise of God, whereby he was commanded to hope for euerlasting life, so long as he did eate of the tree of life.
2 That he despised the commaundement or the restraint thereof made to this ende, that Adam by obedience might testifie his readinesse to submit him selfe to the authoritie of God.
3 Hitherto, may be added the sinne of pride or ambition, whereby he would be equall vnto God.
4 Vnbeliefe, whereby he did not beleeue the threatning of God, which was, that if he did sinne, he shuld die.
5 His10 vnnaturall kindnesse, whereby hee did not consider, that as he had receiued so many benefites for him selfe and his posteritie: so also by sinning he was to loose them both from him selfe, and from his posteritie.
6 His foule Apostacie from God to the deuill, to whom, charging God with lying, with enuie, and with malice, hee did rather giue credite, then to his creatour: so that Augustine hath well obserued, that, In the first sinne11 of man may be discerned many sinnes, if that one be deuided12 as it were into his parts.
7 Last of all, that hee fell in Paradise, this also doeth increase his vnthankefulnes; for Paradise was the garden of Eden, that is, of pleasure, where man might haue aboundantly, not onely plenty, but also varietie of all sortes of daintie fruites.
2 Nowe for the effect of this fall and disobedience, it13 is the guiltinesse that was in our first parents, both in that the image of God after which they were created was14 foorwith blotted out, & also that God did lay this punishment15 vpon them, that in the place of wisedome, power16, holines, trueth, righteousnes (with which ornaments they had been clothed) should succeed most vile plagues, as blindnes, weakenes, falshood, and iniustice. For the posteriritie, the Catechist teacheth that our nature was then so cortupted, that from thenceforth we are all conceiued & borne in sinne, by which words he declareth that not onely Adam did susteine the punishment of his17 most foule fall, but also that he did wrap his posteritie in the same miserie, who because they were corrupted in him, it commeth to passe that we all for his offēce are18 conceiued and borne in sinne, whereupon it is vsually called originall sinne, and is commonly defined to be an hereditarie blemish and corruption of our nature, spread19 ouer all the parts of the soule, whereof it is that we20 are all borne children of wrath, and euerie man in his21 time bringeth foorth the wicked fruites of his corruption, which the Scripture calleth workes of the flesh.
Of this naturall infection and corruption of whole mankinde, these places following do giue testimonie: Behold I was shapen in iniquitie, & in sinne hath my mother conceiued22 me. So Moyses recordeth that Adam begatte a sonne23 after his owne image and likenes: that is, as by the fall in his own nature he was corrupted which was before created good, so hauing lost the image of God, he could not but gette children like vnto him selfe. Hitherto belongeth that which the Apostle saith: We are by nature the24 children of wrath, and that death went ouer all men, in him25, whome all men had sinned. And that which Iob cryeth26 out, Who can bring a cleane thing out of an vncleane? truely no man: whereupon it followeih that we all, who haue no discent from vncleane seede, are from our birth stained with the infection of sinne, yea before wee see the light of this life, are spotted and defiled in the sight of God.
Now, how is it possible, that we who had not then any being in nature when Adam sinned, should yet bee defiled in him, shall then euidently appeare vnto vs, when we shall haue shewed the difference betweene Adam and his posteritie, and so shall set downe that hee was27 as it were the roote, and his sonnes as branches, whereby it commeth to passe that as from a rotten roote doe growe branches like vnto it, which doe send their rottennesse into other twigges that growe out of them: so also from a corrupt parent, who was as the stocke of mankinde, came sonnes stained and corrupted, who afterward infected their posteritie, so that the fountaine of corruption being in the nature of Adam, was by continuall discent from the forefathers deriued to their posteritie, and by this meanes our nature not onely became sinnefull, but did also beget sinnes.
Which is to bee vnderstood, not onely of Adam nowe being corrupt and of his posteritie, but euen of the children that are borne of faithfull parents: for that which Dauid confesseth: That he was begotten in iniquity, & conceiued28 in sinne, being, as it is certen, not peculiar vnto him29, it followeth that the common condition of al mankinde, was by the holy Ghost noted vnder his example, And for that their children are called holy by the Apostle, we must vnderstand that this holinesse of the children is the special blessing of the people of God, which hindreth not the going before of that first and generall curse30 of mankinde: for the guiltines is by nature, but this sanctification is by grace aboue nature. Wherefore, as31 Augustine saith, Whether it be the guiltie vnbeleeuer, or the faithful person acquited from his guiltinesse, both of them begetteth children not acquited but guilty, because they beget them of a corrupt nature.
Last of all, how this corruption commeth from the fathers to their children, whether by traduction of the soule, or by the bodie, or by some other meanes, it auayleth not ouer curiously to enquire, so that be knowen, that God so ordained, that whatsoeuer giftes he had bestowed vpon the first man, he should haue them or loose them, aswell for his offspring as for him selfe.
These32 thinges being so, this our condition after the fall of Adam casting downe al our glorie and confidence in our selues, ought truly to humble vs being ouerwhelmed as it were with shame, & to stirre vp in vs a true hatred and misliking of our selues, and true humilitie, that wee may be set on fire with a new desire to seek after God in whom euery one of vs may recouer those good things whereof we are found altogether void and destitute.
The false doctrine,
By this doctrin of the hainousnes of mans fall, and of the effects33 therof, it appeareth that they are iniurious to God who indeuour to make the sinne of man seeme small, as if it had34 bin openly the intemperancy of the appetite: & that Pelagius doth erre grossely, when he teacheth that sinne was deriued from the first man only by imitation and not by natural discent, and so that Adam sinned only to his owne hurt, and did nothing hurt his posteritiy, by which subtility Sathā hath gone about by couering the disease to make it incurable: but both he and his schollers are plainly refuted both by the testimonies35 before alleadged, & also by experiēce it selfe in young children whose wickednes euen from the very cradle, & afterward36 the wages of sinne which is death, lighting vpon them also37, who haue not committed any sinne, do sufficiently shewe that we are not corrupted by learning wickednesse from any other, but that we bring with vs corruption bred in vs euen frō our mothers wombe. For whereas they think that maketh for them38 which we read in the Prophet, The soule that sinneth that39 shall dye, And, the sonne shall not beare the iniquitie of the father, as if it did hereof follow that Adam sinned not to our hurt, but to his own, nor that otherwise God shold be vniust and contrary to himselfe: or if Adam brought destruction vpon vs, that we are cast away by another mans fault, they are therin deceiued, that they vnderstand not how euery mans owne proper sinne is ioyned with that sin of Adam. For40 we are not condemned in Adam, as if we mere without sinne in our selues, but we are blemished by his sinne, nay (as Paul41 saith) We haue all sinned in him, in that we were all in his loynes, and so it cōmeth to passe that euery man beareth the punishment of his owne sinne. Howsoeuer it is we dye not guiltles, because euery man is conuinced, and found guiltie euen by the witnesse of his own conscience. And as for young children42, although there appeareth not yet in them any sinne, yet it lurketh in them, because they are guilty of condemnatiō before God. Wee are not able indeed to finde this by our senses, but we must consider how far more sharpe sighted God is then we. But the Prophet doth not speake in that place of the tender infant that commeth out of his mothers wombe, but of men growne, who would lay their sin both vpon other men, and vpon God himselfe, to make themselues guiltlesse, whose wicked peeuishnes, Ezekiel reprooueth, and sheweth that the childrē43 are not punished for their fathers sinnes, but for their owne44. The Romanists also are in an error, who doe exempt the Virgin Marie from sinne, for the Apostle declareth that all men are by nature the children of wrath, and that besides Christ4546 there is none priuiledged from this condition.
1 Gen.2.16.17
2 The historie of mans fall.
3 Gen.3.6.7
4 παράπτωμα
5 Rom. 5. 15.
6 What is meant by fal.
7 Rom. 5.13.
8 The definitiō of sinne.
9 The blemish and foulnes of the fall.
10 Gen 2, 17.
11 Enchirid. ad Laurent. c. 46
12 Gen. 3. 3.
13 The effect, & punishment of the fall.
14 Gen.2.17.
15 Rom.3.23.
16 Gal,3,22.
17 Rom.6.12.
18 The definitiō of originall sinne.
19 Rom.5.19.
20 Eph.2.2.
21 Gal.5.19.
22 Psal.51.7.
23 Gen,5.3.
24 Eph.2.3.
25 Rom.5.12.
26 Iob.14,4
27 Adam compared to a roote, and his sonnes to branches.
28 Psal.51.7.
29 How the children of the faithfull being corrupt by nature, are neuerthelesse called holy.
30 1. Cor. 7. 14.
31 Epist.157.
32 The vse.
33 August. de hæres. cap. 88.
34 That the sin of the first man is deriued to all mē, not by imitation of his manners, but by conceptiō of his seede.
35 See August. lib. hypognost. 2. contra Pela.
36 Rom. 5. 14.
37 Rom, 6. 23.
38 Eze. 18. 19. 20.
39 Deut. 24. 16.
40 Rom. 5. 12.
41 Heb. 7. 9. 10.
42 Whether infants be condemned for other mens sinne.
43 Ezek.18.2.
44 Concil. Trid. Ses. 5. cap. 1. de peccato originali.
45 Eph. 2. 3.
46 Heb. 4. 15.