Question 105
THE THIRD PART: Of thankefulnes.
The Arg. Of auoiding manslaughter, and howe many waies it is committed in the sight of God, the ende whereof is, that the safetie of euerie one ought to be commended to euery one.
Question.
What doeth God require in the sixt commandement.
Answere.
That neither by thought, nor by word, nor by gesture, much lesse by deed, either by my selfe, or by any other, I doe reueile, or hate, or hurt, or slay my neighbour: but cast away all desire of reuenge. Moreouer that I hurt not my selfe, nor wittingly cast my selfe into any daunger. And therefore also that murders might be auoided, he hath armed the Magistrate with the sword.
The Exposition.
In this answere is first declared, that God doeth forbid all manslaughter, that is, whether a man kill his neighbour or him selfe, whether hee doeth it by him selfe, or by another. Secondly, that euen to that ende that murders might be avoided, the Magistrate is armed with the sworde, and that the right and authoritie of the sworde belongeth to him.
That God forbiddeth manslaughter in this Lawe is thus shewed: God forbiddeth, that neither by thought, nor by worde, nor by gesture, we kil any man: and therfore we must beleeue that he doeth much more forbid vs by deede, and actually commit it.
And first because before manslaughter be committed, it1 must first bee conceiued and purposed in the minde, wee are taught out of the worde of GOD, that hee that doeth not purpose, that is, hauing conceiued in his minde such a mischiefe against his neighbour doeth allowe it, is before God alreadie guiltie of manslaughter, and2 is a very manslayer: for so saith Christ, From the heart come euill thoughtes and murder. For GOD looketh to the heart, which hee will haue to be pure, and inflamed with the loue of our neighbour, and therein he differeth from earthly Iudges, who iudge of the deede and looke to the handes: but he beholdeth the heart.
Secondly, he that by wordes and by his tongue doeth reprochfully3 hurt4 his neighbour, hee is also guiltie of this5 sinne before the Maiestie of God, as Christ also expoundeth it against the corruption of the Phariseis: Whosoeuer shall say vnto his brother Raca, shalbe worthie to be punished by a counsell, and whosoeuer shall say foole, shall be worthie to be punished with hell fire: in which sense also he that backebiteth his neighbour breaketh this Lawe, because a backebiter killeth thee as it were with one stroke, him selfe, and him that trusteth him, and him whome he hurteth by his backebiting, and therefore the Prophet6 denyeth that hee shall dwell in the holy mountaine, that backbiteth with his tongue.
Moreouer God forbiddeth gesture, or a soure countenance wherewith a man beholdeth his neighbour and7 threatneth him, as Cain looked vpon his brother Abell, to whome the Lord saith: Wherefore is thy countenance cast downe?
Lastly all desire of reuenge, when men of their owne head8 are caryed violently to reuenge an iniurie done vnto9 them, against which Christ saieth: But I say vnto you resist10 not euill. And Paul: Not avenging your selues beloued, but giuing place vnto wrath.
Nowe11 if the Lorde account euery one of these to bee manslaughter without doing any harme, much more must he detest the deede of murder it selfe: whether wee do it by our selues, or commit it by any other, which may be done three manner of waies. 1. By secret consent, or not expressed, as if a man had delight in seeing harme done to his neighbour, and doe not hinder it, if he beable12. 2. By counsaile: as when Saul by keeping their garments that stoned Steuen, did openly declare him selfe to allowe13 that murder, whereupon Luke saith: And Saul consented to his death: and as the multitude did: which cryed out against Christ, Let him be crucified, let him bee crucified.
Thirdely14 by commaunding and willing, as was that hainous15 sinne of Dauid against Vrias, who although hee were slaine in the battell: yet is pronounced by God to haue been slaine by the hand of Dauid: for so saieth the Prophet. Thou hast smitten Vrias the Chittite with the sworde, that thou mightest take his wife to thy wife, & thou hast slaine him by the sword of the Ammonite. Also as when Iezebel the wife of Ahab, by hiring false witnesse against Naboth the Iezreelite, commandeth him to be stoned till he die, that by that meanes her husbande may enioy the inheritance of his vineyarde.
And here is not onely a probibition that no man kill another, but also that no man hurt him selfe, or wittingly cast him selfe into any daunger: for so God him selfe speaketh16, For surely I will require your blood wherein your liues are, as the hand of euery beast will I require it, and as the hand of a man himselfe, and at the hand of a mans brother will I require the life of a man: and hee addeth a reason, because man was created to the image and likenes of God.
Hereupon it is rightly gathered: Hee that killeth him selfe17, killeth a man: If then it be not lawfull to kill a man, but by the authoritie of God, then neither may a man kill himselfe, but by the commandemente of God, and by the secret motion of the holy Ghost, as we reade that Sampson18 did: for in as much as life is the gift of God, it can not be desperately cast away without a great sinne, then hee that killeth himselfe doeth iniurie to mankinde, and the common societie of men: for hee taketh a citizen out of the common wealth: and if the Lawe forbid to kill his neighbour, much more doth it forbid him to kill himselfe: for that which thou mayest not do to another man, thou mayest not do to thy selfe, because the rule of charitie is to be taken from that loue, wherewith we loue our selues.
Then there is ingraffed in euery one by nature a certaine loue, to desire the maintainance and preseruation of his owne life, which when Satan knew, going about to perswade God, to make triall of his faithfull seruant Iob19, and to proue his constancy by afflictinge him in his bodie: All things (saith he) a man will giue for his life, and for his skinne, signifying that this affection was setled in the20 nature21 of man, to account his owne life more deere then all goods. Therefore it is not lawfull for a man to kill himselfe, because God hateth, and detesteth all that are void of loue.
Therefore they also offend against this commaundement, who kill vp themselues by ryot, by tipling & swilling, and by lust: for willingly and wittingly they spoile and cast away them selues.
2. Nowe that we may abhorre all manslaughter, it is to bee obserued, that God to the ende that murders might not be committed, hath therfore armed the Magistrate with the sword: for so himselfe saith in Moses: He that22 sheddeth mans blood, by man let his blood be shed. Again, He2324 that smiteth a man, & he die, let him be put to death: & Christ Christ vnto Peter, Put thy sworde into his place, for whosoeuer take the sword, shall perish with the sword.
For25 as it is good for mans body betimes to cut off a rotten member, least the sound part be drawen to it: so it is profitable for the safetie of humane societie, to take out of the way noysome and hurtfull citizens, least the corruption of one, by little and little creepe into the whole26 bodie of the societie: although there is a difference27 to bee made betweene them that of purpose kill another28 man, and that doe it vnwares and ignorantly: of whome thus speaketh the Lorde in the Lawe: If a man29 hath not laid waite, but God hath offered him into his hand, then I will appoint thee a place whither hee shall flie: which places were chosen for two causes: One, that they30 might betake themselues thither, who were farre from the Magistrate, vntill the cause were tryed, least they might bee taken short by the auenger: another, that after their cause was knowen, they might there safely dwell vntill the death of the high Priest.
And to that ende, that is, against manslayers vpon hatred and malice, the Lord did of olde ratifie the Law of suffering like for like, and gaue the same to Iudges & Magistrates, appointing them keepers of the common peace, and executioners of his vengeance. Of which duetie of Magistrates, wisely speaketh the Apostle to the Rom.3132 He is the minister of god for thy good: but if thou doe euill, feare, for he beareth not the sworde for nought, for he is the minister of God to take vengeance on him that doeth euill.
Wherefore the Magistrate must indeauour, that seeing by the ordinance of God hee sustaineth this person, he do also faithfully discharge this his duetie, declyning neither33 to the right hand, nor to the left, either by sparing those that are guiltie and in fault, or by violently oppressing the innocent: Let him call to mind that hee must giue an account of his gouernment vnto him, who would haue him in his steade to beare rule vpon earth, yea34 that he himselfe is a manslayer before God, if he doe not35 punish those that are worthy of death, which vnfaithfulnesse the Lorde in times past did grieuously reprooue by his Prophets in Saul and in Ahab.
The false doctrine.
The Anabaptistes out of that place of Christ, where hee saith resist not euill,36 forbidding all priuate reuenge and desire of37 reuenge, doe gather that it is not lawfull for a Christian man to take this office vpon him, and that no man can discharge it with a good conscience, to whome Paule answereth, that the vse of the sword is giuen of God to the Magistrate, to make the wicked afraide, and to defende the good: also for the maintenance38 of priuate and publike peace, of religion, and honestie of manners39: but this is a godly worke and acceptable vnto God: Therefore it may be discharged and performed by a godly man & one that feareth God.
Besides, that calling, which God of especiall fauour, promised40 by the Prophets to the Churches of the new Testament, may also bee discharged by godly and faithfull men without offence, yea commendablie vnder the new Testament: But God promised that Kings shoulde be the nursing fathers41 of the Church: Therefore a godly and faithfull man may beare the office of a Magistrate, take vengeance of the wicked, & maintaine the good, as being in Gods steed, for that word of God is pepetuall: I haue saide you are Gods.42
In the historie of the Gospell, Ioseph is saide to haue beene a counseller, and is commended for a iust man: that centurion that came to Christ to heale his seruant, is commended43 for his excellent44 faith: Cornelius is accounted a godly man: and is saide to haue had godly souldiers: Sergius Paulus was a Deputy, and yet inlightened45 with faith, whome neither Christ, nor the Apostles46 did forbid to vse weapons, or perswaded them to giue ouer that kind of life as vnworthy of Christians, & to betake themselues to some more honest course.
1 By thought.
2 Mat.15.19.
3 By wordes
4 Math.5.22.
5 2.Sam.16. 9.10.
6 Psal.15.3.
7 By gestures.
8 By desire of reuenge.
9 Mat.5.39.
10 Rom.12.9.
11 By deedes and how many wayes,
12 Act.7.58. and 8.1.
13 Mat.28. 22.23.
14 1.Sam.12.19.
15 2.King.21.10.
16 Gen.9.5.6.
17 August.lib.1. de Civ.dei. cap.20.21.
18 Iud.16.29.
19 Iob.2.4.
20 Rom.1.31
21 2 Tim.3.3.
22 Gen.9.6.
23 Exod.21.12.14
24 The sanction.
25 A similitude.
26 Exod.21.13.
27 Numb.35. 13.14.
28 Deut.19. 45.46.
29 Iosu.20.1.2. 3.4.&c.
30 Why sanctuaries were graunted in the Lawe to manslayers.
31 Rom.13.4.
32 2 Pet.2.13.14
33 Psal.82.1.6. 7.8.
34 1 Sam.15.19
35 1King.30.42
36 Mat.5.39
37 Rom.12.19
38 Rom.13.1.2. 3.4.
39 1 Tim.22.
40 Vide Tractat Taffini, Gal. de officio Magist. Cap.3. 4.
41 Esa.49.23.
42 Psal.82.7.
43 Luk.22.50.
44 Mat.8.10
45 Act.10.1.7.
46 Act.13.12.