Question 47
THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.
Question.
What then, is not Christ with vs as hee promised vnto the end of the world?
Answere.
Christ is true God & true man, therefore according to his manhead he is not now vpon earth, but according to his Godhead, his grace, and his spirit he is at no time from vs.
The Exposition.
Neither yet when we doe proue Christs true ascension1 into heauen by the scriptures, do we take away or deny those promises of Christ, whereby he auoucheth his2 perpetuall presence in the Church: such as these are: Behold3 I am with you alway vnto the end of the world: And, Where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the middst of them, but onely we make a difference betweene the two natures in Christ, and the properties both of his Godhead, and of his manhead, which difference being obserued, it is an easie matter to reconcile such speeches, to wit, after this manner.
Christ4 is true God and true Man, that is, hath the true nature of God, and the true nature of man, and the properties agreeing both to the one and to the other nature. Therfore when we meet with such sentences which doe prooue the presence of Christ vpon earth, such as those two propounded, then must wee see whither they are to be vnderstood of his godhead, or of his manhead, such as these places following are, beeing set against the former.
The5 poore ye haue alwaies with you, but mee yee shall not haue6 alwaies: I am come out from the father & am come into7 the world: Againe I leaue the world and goe to my father: which seeming at the first sight to bee contrary to those former places, cannot be reconciled but by vsing this distinction, that the former places cannot bee vnderstoode of Christs presence in the Church, but according to that nature, which is at no time absent from vs, that is, as hee is true & euerlasting God, I say, according to his godhead and his Maiestie, as on the other side the article of Christs ascention8 cannot be taken but according to his humane nature9, in which respect Christ saide that hee woulde leaue the world & go to his father, & that he would not alwaies be present in body: in which sence August.10 also spake and taught: After one sort we haue Christ alwaies according to the presēce of his maiestie, & according to the presence of his flesh, he said rightly vnto his disciples, but me yee shal not haue alwaies: For the Church had him according to the presence of the flesh, but a few dayes, now it holdeeh him by faith, it seeth him not with the eyes.
For11 his humane nature hath his properties, which it neuer leaueth, such as are to be onely in one place at one time, to haue a bodie included within certen compasse, a bodie that may be seene and felt, which beeing taken away it can by no meanes be a true bodie: as also the properties12 of the diuine nature are, to be euery where, that is in all places, to fill all things, to be almightie, to be euery where present, which he doth not impart with any creature13, because he will not giue his glorie to any other: therefore he saith I am with you, and not my humane nature is with you bodily & yet inuisibly (which two words are contrary one to the other) but I, as king and Mediatour, God and man, in my diuinitie and Maiestie am with you alwaies.
And14 this is that interchange of properties (the foundation whereof15 is that hypostaticall or personall vnion, whereof we spake before in the 35. question) wich is such a manner of speech, wherein the propertie that agreeth to one nature (as to be infinite belongeth to the diuine nature) is ascribed to the whole person, because of the hypostaticall vnion: this some expound by Synechdoche, by which trope both the whole is taken for the part, and the part for the whole, as the man Christ is infinite, and almightie16, to wit according to his diuine nature, or as Christ17 is so man, that hee is also God. And on the other side, God, or the Lord of glorie dyed and was crucified, that is, according to his humane nature, or rather that part, which could be crucified and die, that is, according to his bodie.
Besides Christ though in bodie absent, yet is also present with vs by his spirit, by the hope of whose comming he did comfort his disciples while hee was yet vpon the earth: I will not leaue you fatherles, but I will come againe vnto you, to wit, by my spirit, whereof hee spake before, And18; When he shall come, that is, the spirit of truth, he will leade19 you into all truth.
To conclude, Christ is also present in his humanitie by grace, yet so that he is absent in bodie: Whereupon Emissenus20 writeth, That Christ, because hee meant to conuey out of your sight the body which he had takē & to cary it into heauē, did consecrate the Sacrament of his body & of his blood21, that, that might dayly be worshipped by a mistery which was22 once offred for a ransome, that because there was a dayly and neuer failing redemption for the saluation of man, there might bee a perpetuall oblation of that redemption, & that that perpetual sacrifice might liue in remembrance, & might be alwaies present in grace.
The false doctrine.
Hauing23 declared the sounde & true doctrine concerning the vnion of the two natures, & interchanging of the properties, let vs now weigh the formall differences of the hypostatical vniō24, which the Vbiquitaries do alledge, & it shal appeare how vnreasonable things, vnreasonable I say, & cōtrarie to faith, and to the Scriptures doe follow thereupon: for first25 they define the personall vnion by being euery where, and this also they giue vnto the Saints, when they expound to be in heauen, to be euery where and to fil al things. And no man doubteth but the saints are in heauen, wherfore also they must needs be euery where, & fill all things: Therefore if being euery where maketh the personal vniō, Christ in this differeth nothing from the saints, and can no more be called God then Peter and Paul, but shal remaine in the estate of the Saints, seeing the saints in this respect, by their iudgement, are equal vnto him. Another difference of the hypostatical vnion they set down to be the shedding forth of the maiestie of God vpon the nature of man, or the imparting of al the properties: The difference say they of Christ from Peter, is not to bee taken simplie from the dwelling of the Sonne of God in him, but from the imparting of his properties: For the Sonne of God although by his substance he fill Peter, as also the man Christ, yet doth hee not impart with Peter all his properties, but onely some: But he doth beawtifie the Sonne of man taken of the Virgin Marie, not with some, but with all gifts, and doth impart with him al his properties: In which opinion of theirs that is first to be found fault withal, that Christ is made to bee no better then the saints: for if the vniō cōsist in imparting of gifts, the saints also shalbe after a sort Gods, vpon whom God bestoweth many & large gifts: Neither is this a sufficient difference, that the saints haue receiued their gifts by measure, & Christ without measure, for so they should not differ in kinde, but onely in more26 and lesse: but that dwelling of God in the Saints and in the man taken of the Virgine differeth in the whole kinde. Moreouer this vnion by shedding foorth of gifts is not truely personal, for by this means the nature of Man shold be vnited not to the person of the word, but to the whol Trinity, because the imparting of gifts is the commō work of the whole Trinity27: Thirdly that real shedding forth of the properties of the diuine nature vpon the humane nature, is nothing else but a confusiō of natures: for it is the propertie yͭ deuideth nature frō nature: also the propertie or essentiall differēce of nature is that which maketh the nature, and without which the nature whose propertie it is cannot stand: & if al the properties of the diuine nature bee shed vpon the humane nature, how then are the natures distinguished? and how can the difference of natures remaine whole, if the properties wherby they are distinguished be really shed from one nature vpō another? Fourthly they erre in this, that they put no difference beetweene the imparting of giftes & the imparting of properties. It is out of doubt that God bestoweth sundry and most large28 gifts vpon men, and that the humanity of Christ was in it selfe bewtified with most excellent gifts aboue al other creatures, no man maketh question, but these gifts are created & finite, but whether the infinite & euerlasting properties of the Godhead were shed vpon the humane nature, so that it hath them in it selfe, hereof is the controuersie. Which absurdity being granted, others follow without number: from hence groweth the turning of Christs bodie into an apparition of a body, when they are not ashamed to wryte and to teach, that one and the same body of Christ, which was visibly & locally in29 Ierusalem, when hee preached in the temple, or hanged vpon the crosse, was with the Godhead at one time at Rome, at Athens, and in heauen, & wheresoeuer it were without all places inuisibly, and not being in any place: in which wordes they make one and the same body to be visible and inuisible, in place, and out of place, finite and infinite, which are one against another, and do fight with the properties of a true bodie for if you take away from a body compasse of place and measure of bignes, it must needs leaue of to be a true body: as Augustine very well saith: Take from bodies the space of place30, and they shalbe no where, and beeing no where, they shall not be at all.
1 Obiect.
2 Mat.28.20.
3 Mat.18.20.
4 The properties of both natures must be distinguished in christ.
5 Mat.26.11.
6 Ioh.16.28.& 17.11.
7 Act.3.,28.
8 Iohn.14.3.
9 Mat.26.11.
10 Tract.in Ioh. 50.
11 The properties of the humane and diuine natures.
12 Esa.42.8.
13 The manner of Christs presēce in earth.
14 Idiomatum. κοινωνία.
15 What is ment by communication of properties.
16 1.Cor.2.8.
17 August. Epist. 57. ad Dar.
18 Ioh.14.17.18.
19 Iohn 16.13.
20 Emissen.in Ser de cor. & sang. Domini.
21 Gal.3.1.
22 Ephe.4.10.
23 How the Vbiquitaries doe define personal vnion.
24 What they mean by being in heauē.
25 Brent.in lib. de Mai.p.24.& Parsimonias discipulus eius in concion: sua argum.6.
26 An obiection presented.
27 What a propertie is.
28 Communication of gifts and communication of properties differ.
29 Brent.de personali vnione. pag.12.
30 August.ad Dard.cap.57.