An Exposition or Commentarie upon the Catechisme of Christian Religion (1589), Jeremias Bastingius · PDF

Question 114

THE THIRD PART: Of thankefulnes.

Question.

Are they able who are conuerted vnto God, to keepe these commandements perfitely?

Answere.

No truly: but euen they that are most holy, so long as they liue, haue onely some smal beginnings of this obeydience, yet so, that with an earnest and vnfeigned indeauour, they begin to liue not according to some onely; but euen according to all Gods Commandements.

The Exposition.

In the former parte of this booke, the question was asked, whether any man were able to keepe the Lawe of God, & all things that are therein commanded, but there the question was of men vnregenerate: but here the question is, whether they that are conuerted vnto God that is, borne againe by the Spirite of God, bee able to keep all the commaundements of the Law, & that because of some fantasticall spirits at this day, who dreame of I kuow not what perfection of man in this life, whose opinion and errour is soundly refuted in this answere out of the Scriptures.

And first is denyed that the Lawe of God can be exactly performed of them that are conuerted, and this is proued because the most holy men, so long as they continue in this mortall body haue onely some small beginninges of this obedience. Next is shewed, that although they are verye farre from this obedyence, yet they doe not therefore fainte, but so much the more pricke forwarde themselues, that they may earnestly & cheerfully begin to liue, not onely according to some, but euen according to all Gods Commandemeuts.

And1 for the former, that we may see the trueth thereof2, we must first, of all call to minde, wherein the perfit obedience3 of the Lawe of God consisteth, namely in this that4 a man bee able perfitly and constantly to keepe, and5 doe keepe all and euery commandemente of the lawe6, that is, that with his whole hart, affection, thought and all powers inwarde and outwarde hee so obey the lawe of God, that hee neuer faile in any one commaundement: from which perfection howe farre the moste holye men are, first is proued by their owne confession. such as that is in Esa: Wee are all as an vncleane thinge, and7 all our righteousnes is as filthy cloutes, and we all do fade like a leafe, and our iniquities like the wind haue taken vs away: and there is none that calleth vpon thy name, neither that stirreth vp himselfe to take holde of thee: for thou hast hid thy face from vs, and hast consumed vs because of our iniquities.

By8 which confession it is manifest, that if God woulde rigorously inquire into the very works of the best men, there can no other sentence be giuen of them, but that they are a meere defiling of Gods giftes, euen as oftentimes it falleth out, that a riuer being otherwise faire and cleere, is infected by the filth of some iakes, by which it runneth.

And that prayer of the Prophet is well knowne. Enter not9 into iudgement with thy seruant ô Lord, for there is no mā liuing10 righteous in thy sight: Again, If thou ô Lord count our iniquities, ô Lorde who shall bee able to stand before thee? And11 that of Salomon, who (as Ierom saith) freely protesteth12 and saith: There is no man that sinneth not: and in13 another place: surely there is none righteous vpon earth, which doeth good and sinneth not: and againe: who can saie I haue made mine hart cleane, I am cleane from my sinne?14.

And Christ biddeth his disciples praye: Forgiue vs our debts15.

The Apostle acknowledged as much when he said: I do not that good that I would, but the euil that I would not, that I16 doe: O wretched man that I am, who shall deliuer me from this body of death? He also confesseth, that he delighteth in the Law of God concerning the inner man, and hee saith, that the flesh lusteth against the spirit.

Secondely17 not onely the Saintes them selues do confesse their imperfection, but also the scripture confirmeth the same by examples of most holye men, who made foule slips.

Of18 Noah the holy Ghost beareth witnes, that he was a iust man19, & vpright in his generation, & that he did continue to walke with God, which notwithstanding afterward was drunken with wine: and lay vncouered in the middest of his tent.

Abrahams20 faith and religion towardes God is commended, & he, to saue his wife, did twise conceale the trueth, & staine himselfe with a lie, & brought his wiues chastity in hazarde.

Lot21 is commended of Peter for a iust man, and one that22 did euery daye vexe his iust soule at the vngodlye deedes of wicked men in seeing and hearing them: the same Lot hauinge taken in wine too largely, by lying with his owne daughters, fell into foule dishonestie.

The scripture commendeth Iob for his singuler godlines, to whome there was none like vpon earth, an vpright and23 iust man and departing from euill, whose patience also was tried by the crosse & by the vexations of Satan: yet the same Iob afterward curseth the day of his birth, and contendeth against God for giuing him life, & maintayning him in the same.

Dauid a man according to Gods hart, & an example of rare faith, godlines and constancy: yet did he not grieuously24 fall and offend God by adultery & murder, & also25 numbring the people of Israel in the pride of his hart?

What befell Peter, who thought him selfe stronger and26 more constante, then the rest of his fellowe disciples? was he not dismayed, & as it were cast of from his stedfast standinge by a worde of a damsell, and moste shamefully denyed his maister? And the same Peter also beeinge afterwarde confirmed with more gifts of the holy Ghost, and more enlightened, was openly reprooued, yea and condemned by Paul at Antioche as not27 taking a right course, because by his dissembling he grieuouslie offended the beleeuers of the Gentiles, whose companie he refrained, so soone as he saw the Iewes.

Last of all, that valiant Champion of Christ, Paul, a man so notable and so spirituall, who (to vse Augustines wordes) did hunger and thirst after the very perfection of28 righteousnesse, had ouercome so many daungers, torments & other calamities, and had triumphed ouer all the enemies of Christ, had expelled the feare of death, finallie had renounced the world, yet had not altogeither subdued pride, yea hee him selfe writeth that there was remayning in him so doubtfull a conflict with it, that he could not get the victorie29 but with bearing away many buffets: There was giuen, saith he, to me a pricke in my flesh, a messenger of Satan to buffette me, that I should not be puffed vp aboue measure.

Thirdely30, not onely the examples of most grieuous sinnes and wants in the most holy men that euer were, doe shewe that there were onely some beginnings of obedience to the lawe in them, but also the fruites and effects of sinne in them, as all kindes of diseases, calamities, & death it selfe in all men that euer dyed, doe crie aloud that they were sinners, according to Pauls rule, The wages of sinne is death, & therefore died because they were sinners31. I let passe that euen those fantasticall men, who doe so farre vrge perfection, are oftentimes found to be the most imperfite of all, swelling with a conceit of holines, great setters by thēselues, ful of hatred & enuy, despisers of their neighbours: who I would to God they could learne to bee wise with Alexander the great, who when as the blood issued out of his thigh being woūded, turning to them that vsed cōmonly to call him God, with a smooth & chereful countenance said. This which you see is such blood & licour as vseth to runne from the gods, mocking32 at the lying vanity of his flatterers, whē the thing it selfe sheweth that he was no better then a man, I woulde to God I say that euen so they also by the corruption of their owne affections, of which they are oftentimes ouerouercome, or by the diseases and often inconueniences and infirmities of the bodie might at length be brought to a better minde, and beeing conuinced by the fruites of sinne would make an honest confession that they are miserable and great sinners, and not they alone, but because the like fruits of sinne are seene in other, though neuer so holy men, that there is no mortall man exempted from this condition of sinning.

But if they thinke wee doe them wrong, as if we were the first that condemne their opinion, let them heare Ierome33 thus earnestly speaking against them: For what other greater rashnes can there be, then for a man to challēge to him selfe not only to be like, but to be all one with God, & in one short saying, to conteyne the poysō of al heritiks, which haue issued from the fountayne of the philosophers, & especiallie Pythagoras, & Zeno the Prince of the Stoicks? For they affirme that those which the greeks cal παθη, & we Passions, as griefe & ioy, hope & feare: may be pulled out of mens minds, & that no string or roote of vices at all may bee remaining in men, through the meditation and exercise of vertue, which is to take man out of man, & for a man being in the bodie to be without the bodie.

And in the same Epistle against Pelagius, a little after he discouereth the hypocrisie of the perfectistes, bringing a most shamefull example of their sect: Priscilliane in Spaine was in part a Manichee, for whose dishonestie thy disciples like thee very well, who challenging vnto thē selues the name of perfection and knowledge, are close shut vp alone with women alone, and in the middest of their companying and clasping together vse this song, premising this watch word to their schollers:

Both sweare and forsweare, thy secret looke thou bewray not.

Tum34 pater omnipotens, fœcundis imbribus æther / Coniugis in gremium lætæ descendit, & omnes / Magnus alit magno commixtus corpore fœtus.

that is,

Then Iupiter like vnto the ayre that showres in abundance / Into the lap of his wife doth fall, that longs to receiue him / And so medled with her doeth set all fruits on a growing

Which Priscillian afterward (as Ierome addeth) was condemned both by the secular sworde, and by the authoritie of the whole worlde, and last of all he concludeth most wiselie and truelie, This is the only perfection that men can haue, to know them selues to be vnperfite.

Fourthly35 to the former arguments is added, that the Apostle affirmeth that the gift of tongues and prophecie, whose ende is, that we may euery day goe more and more forwarde in the knowledge of God, and of saluation36, are proofes of our imperfection in this life, because they shal cease, when that which is perfite is come: wherof I thus gather: If our faith & the knowledge of God him selfe, the increase whereof wee are commaunded dayly to begge of God, and the helpers whereof are the vse of tongues and prophecie, be vnperfect in vs, it must needs be that that obedience also, which wee performe to the Lord according to his Lawe, is also imperfite, as being a fruite of our faith, and which must needes proceede of faith: But the former is true: and therefore the latter also is true.

The former I thus prooue: Whosoeuer must be continually37 praid for, that they may be filled with al acknowledgment o sthe wil of God, with al spiritual wisdom & vnderstanding, in them before they be filled with such gifts, must needes remayne much want both of knowledge and of wisedome. But Paul professeth in the Epistle to the Colossians, that he maketh that prayer for the faithful without ceasing, saying: We cease not to pray for you &c. prescribing vnto them by his owne example what they also ought to doe: Therefore because the faithfull are commanded to pray continually that they may be filled with al knowledge, which he afterward expoundeth, that they may grow in the knowledge of God: it followeth, that the perfite fulfilling thereof is neuer ended in this life, and that the Saints haue indeede a true faith, but yet vnperfite, so long as they liue in this worlde, and that they shall be filled with all Spirituall wisedome in the life to come, which is the drift of the Apostles exhortation38, as other-where hee witnesseth of him selfe39, whereupon also Ierome saith well: He that alwayes forgetteth getteth things past, and longeth for things to come, sheweth that he is not content with the present.

Hereupon wee reade that by the same Apostle are set downe two degrees of the faithfuls profiting, before they come to the top of perfection, the one is of Childhood, that is, a very weake state, when we doe as yet altogether stagger and wauer: the other is of youth, to wit, a middle state and a stedfast proceeding vnto perfectiō: both these are in this life strengthened by the vse of the ministerie: the third is of mans state, called of Paul a perfect man according40 to the measure of the age of the fulnesse of Christ, whē we shal al come to the vnitie of faith: which raigneth indeed among the children of God euen from the beginning, yet not so perfitely that they are met all togeither, which if it were here fulfilled, they should bee all perfite41, as euery one of vs shall be in the worlde to come, when God shalbe all in all, where also Christ at that time shal42 present his Church glorious, not hauing spot or wrinckle, or any such thing, but as holie and vnblameable.

In this middle state, (I meane of youth) so long as wee are43, all of vs both are ignorant of many thinges, and offende in many things as Iames saith: and hereof is that of44 Paul concerning the faithfull in generall to be vnderstood: We know in part, and we prophecie in part. And of himselfe, Here I knowe in part, but then I shall know according as I shalbe taught.

Hereupon Augustine prooueth by strong reason, that we45 doe neuer in this flesh yeeld that honour to God that wee owe. Loue, saith he, doth so follow knowledge, that no man can perfitely loue God, who doth not first know his goodnesse to the full: we so long as we are straungers in this worlde, see by a glasse and in a darke speech: therefore it followeth that our loue is vnperfite.

Wherefore seeing that first by the confession, and then by the life of most holy men, and also by the punishments and fruits of sinne, last of all by the imperfection of euery mans faith and knowledge, it is aboundantly to bee seene that there are onely some small beginnings of obedience to the Lawe in them, so farre are they from being able to get vp & to attaine to the top of perfection in this life, the perfectistes doe vainely glorie of that which was neuer founde in auy mortall man, except Christ.

For if not so much as the outwarde obedience of the Lawe is persourmed by the most holy men, but that they are in daunger to be dashed sometymes vpon this, sometimes vpon that commaundement: what will they answere to GOD the searcher of the hartes, and reines, who principally requireth the purity of the heart and of all affections, and how will they be able to stande before his iudgement seat?

But46 when the aduersaries see themselues so hampered with these arguments, that they sticke fast, they flie to the almightie power of God: But wee answere that wee doe not denie but God can perfitlie regenerate vs in this life, if he will: but why he doeth it not, he hath many causes, and among others chiefely these: first, that we47 may diligently consider with our minds, how great the power of sinne is, and what effect it hath in man, which we see cannot be destroyed in vs but by little and little, and that by the speciall grace of the Spirite, and therefore that we may bee so much tee more afraide of it48. 2. That49 when we feele daily more and more increase of the gistes50 of the Spirite in the rysing againe of the new man, may make very much of this his goodnesse towarde vs, who were vnworthy to haue powred into vs, one droppe of his regenerate grace. 3. That whē in this life we find no ende or stay of the conflict betweene the flesh & the Spirit, we may haue so much the greater longing of that blessed life, wherein we shall appeare before God perfitly regenerate and holy, For if God shoulde out of hande renewe and sanctifie vs, the dignity that hee bestoweth vpon vs, should not be in so great acccount with vs: but now when hee doeth by little and little bringe to passe the mortifying of the olde man, the perfection thereof is so much the more deere vnto vs, and the more regarded51 and set by. Last of all, for this cause also God52 doeth not here perfitely regenerate vs, that his power53 may be made perfite in our weakenesse, and when wee are saued by meere grace and not of workes, hee that reioyceth may reioyce onely in the Lord.

For if we did here fulfill the Law, and performe perfite obedience thereunto, why might not a man by it be iustified, and attaine life and saluation? but this were contrary to the former doctrine of iustification by faith, and the merite of Christ alone, who by this means shoulde not bee vnto vs wholly and properly a Sauiour, but onely an instrument to set vs in that forwardenesse, that we might be able afterwarde to iustifie our selues by our owne righteousnesse, which is a most foule and detestable errour of the Semipelagian sophisters, and therefore to be abandoned.

Besides they doe obiect, that it is one thing to haue onely54 some small beginning, of obedience to the lawe, and another thing not to bee able perfitely to keepe the Lawe of God. For the Catechist seemeth to graunt lesse to a man regenerate, then the scripture giueth vnto him, which ascribeth not onely some beginninges, but euen perfection to the godly: as, so many of vs therefore as are perfite55, &c. Whereupon the Apostle him selfe writeth that hee striueth to attaine to pefection: I answere: 1. That when Paul reckeneth himselfe among the perfite, he speaketh not of such a perfection of faith or mortification in vs, as that new sect of perfectistes doth imagine: for otherwise he should gainesay himselfe, as hauing before confessed, that he hath not attained vnto it: but he speaketh of the perfection of knowledge, in respecte56 of the onely foundation of our saluation Iesus Christ when casting away confidence in all thinges, wee reioyce in the onely righteousnes of Christ, and setting all other things aside to attaine to the fellowship of his sufferings, which may bring vs to the blessed resurrection.

Secondly it is also true by comparison, that is, if you compare persons with persons, that there is more vertue and more knowledge to be founde in one man then in another, and that one man hath attained an higher degree then another. So the Apostles well instructed and grounded on Christ were called petfite in respect of them, who beeing too much set vpon ceremonies of the Lawe, were pulled a sunder from the bodie it selfe, that is, Christ.

So for his life Noah is said to haue beene iust, a perfit or vpright man in his generation, and to haue walked stedfastly with God: So the regenerate man in respect of diuers qualities which are in him is saide both to sinne and57 not to sinne, to keepe himselfe that the wicked touch him not. Why? Not because he is pure and free from all sinne58, but because hee sinneth not with his whole will, but in that parte wherein hee is not regenerate, or because the children of God doe so sinne, that they are not caried away by their affections, and all feelinge of godlynes, beeing vtterly quenched, yeelde them selues wholly to the Deuill and to the flesh: which perfection of theirs notwithstanding, howe great soeuer it be, is but onely a beginninge of obedience in respect of that highest perfection which God requireth in his Law, & which at the last we shall attaine in heauen, when we shall be altogether without sinne, in which case Christ alone was here, and therefore hee was able to fulfill the Lawe and none other.

To59 conclude, whereas neuerthelesse Iob, Iehosaphat, and60 Iosias and many whose names the Scripture is full of61, as Zacharie and Elizabeth are commended for righteous, vnto this Ierome very well answereth, that they are so called, not because they are without all fault, but because they are commended with verye many vertues: Otherwise both Zacharie is condemned by takinge away his speech, and Iob is reproued in his talke, and Iehosaphat & Iosias which without doubt were called righteous, are reported to haue done such thinges as displeased the Lord, of whome the one did ayde a wicked man and62 was reprooued by the Prophet, the other against the commaundement of God by the mouth of Ieremy, went against Necho the king of Ægypt, and was slaine, and yet both are called righteous: Thus farre Ierome.

2. Moreouer although the case thus stande with the godly63 in this life, yet so farre off is it, that this imperfection doeth make them slothfull, that rather it stirreth them vp the more to indeuour, to attayne to perfection, and to liue here not onely according to some, but according to all Gods commaundements: that whereas in this life they are not able to hit the marke, yet in the other life they may surely come vnto it. And therefore they doe euery day goe stedfastly forward in the race of their calling64 and doe striue with the Apostle, If by any meanes they65 may attain to the resurrection of the dead and may comprehend that, for whose sake also they are comprehended of Christ Iesus..

Hereto belongeth that sweet similitude of his, which he66 vseth in the former Epistle to the Corinth. know ye not that67 they which runne in a race do all runne, but one receyueth68 the pryse, so runne that yee may obtaine.

This69 marke of the faithful Iames hauing an eye vnto, doth expressely warne that wee must labour to keepe not one, but all the commaundementes, because whosoeuer keepeth the whol law and offendeth but in one poynt is guilty of all: and for this zeale are Zacharie and Elizabeth commended70 in the gospell, because they were both iust before God, and walked in all the commaundements and ordinances of God without reproofe.

The false doctrine.

Which71 being so, that Canon of the Tridentine councill is directly against this doctrine of the imperfect obeydience of men regenerate and iustified. Can. 18. Sess. 6. If any man say that72 the commaundementes of God are impossible to bee kept euen of a man iustified, and abiding vnder grace, let him bee accursed: For whereas they alledge for themselues the authority of the Fathers forbidding vppon paine of curse to vse this speach: That anye impossible thing is commaunded vnto man by God: we haue already prooued by many testimonies of Scripture, that there was neuer any of the Saintes, who beeing compassed about with this body of death, was able to attaine to that perfection of loue, that hee could loue God with all his heart, with all his minde, with all his soule, and with all his power: and againe that there was neuer any that was not troubled with concupiscence: And if we must needes striue with the authoritie of the fathers: wee set against the Romanistes those worthy Fathers Ciprian and Augustine: for thus saith Augustine, where he writeth73 against the Pelagians, who contended that there are or haue beene in this life some righteous, not hauing any sinne at al: With what presumption doe they openly gainsay the Lords prayer, wherein all the members of Christ doe crie with a true hart and daylie74 voice, Forgiue vs our debts?

And Cyprian: We haue, saith he, a combate with couetousnes nes, with vnchastitie, with wrath, with ambition, wee haue a dayly and troublesome wrastling with the corruption of the flesh and with the inticements of the worlde; the minde of man being besieged: and on euery side intrenched by the noisome assaults of the deuil, scarcely meeteth with euery one of them, and hardly resisteth. If couetousnesse be vanquished, lust riseth vp, if lust be suppressed, ambition commeth in place, if ambition bee contemned, wrath galleth, pride puffeth vp, drunkenesse allureth, enuy breaketh agreememt, wickednesse cutteth of frieudship, thou art constrained to curse which Gods law forbiddeth, thou art constrayned to sweare, which is not lawfull. Thy minde suffereth euery day so many persecutions, thy heart is oppressed with so many dangers, and here it pleaseth a man to stande long among the snares of the deuill, whereas wee ought rather to desire and wish to make hast vnto Christ, death comming speedilie to succour vs.

1 Deut.27.26

2 Mat.15.16.

3 Rom.7.14.

4 Ma..5.28.

5 Mat.22.37

6 1 Argument from the confession of the Saints.

7 Esa.64.6.7

8 What the Saints works are in Gods sight.

9 Psal.143.2.& 130.3.

10 Da.9.5.6.7. 8.9.10.11

11 1 King.8.46

12 Eccles.7.21

13 Prou.20.9

14 Mat.6.12.

15 Gal.5.17.

16 Rom.7.19.24 22.

17 2. Argument frō examples

18 Gen.6.11.

19 Gen.9.21.

20 Gen.12.12.& 20.2.

21 2 Pet.2.8.

22 Gen.19.33.34

23 Iob.1.1.2. & 3.2.3.

24 2 Sam.11.4. 15.

25 2. Sam.24.2

26 Mat.26.70, 72.

27 Gal.2.11.12.

28 August.l.3. contra.pelag. cap.7.

29 2.Cor.12.7.

30 3. Argumentes of the effects of sinne.

31 Rom.6.23.

32 Alexandri apophtheg.

33 Aduersus Pelagium ad Ctesiphontem: Where also he meeteth with all their shifts.

34 Eras. in Schol. in Epist. Ierom.

35 4. Argument from the imperfection of knowledge and faith.

36 1.Cor.13.8.

37 Colos.1.9.

38 Phil.3.12.

39 Ad Ctesiphont. aduers. Pelag.

40 Eph.4.12.

41 1.Cor.15.21.

42 Eph.5.27.

43 Iam.2.3.

44 1.Cor.13.9.

45 De Spir.& litera.

46 1 Obiect. See Caluin lib. 2. Instit.c.7.

47 5 argument.

48 Rom.7.24.

49 Rom.6 12.

50 1 Ioh.3.2.3. Why God doth not by and by perfitly regenerate the faithfull.

51 2 Cor.12.9

52 1 Cor.1.21.

53 Gal.2.16.

54 2 Obiect.

55 Poil.3.15

56 Phil.3.13

57 2 Iohn 3.9.& 5.18.

58 See August. l.de Nat.& gra.cap.62.

59 Iob 1.1.

60 2 King.22.1

61 Luk.1.6.

62 2 King.23.29.

63 3 Obiect.

64 Mat.3.15.

65 Phil.3.11. 12.13.

66 1 Cor.9.24.

67 Mat.10.22

68 2 Tim.2.5.

69 Iam.2.10.

70 Luk.1.6.

71 See Sess.c.6.11

72 See Expos. Sim. ad Dam. 4.tom. Ierom. Whereof Erasmus denyeth Ierom to be the author

73 Contra duas epist. Pelag. lib. 4. cap. 10.

74 Cypr. epist. de mortalitate.