Question 56
THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.
Question.
What beleeuest thou concerning forgiuenes of sinnes,
Answere.
I beleeue that God for the satisfactiō of Christ hath quite put out of his remēbrance all my sinnes, & euen that corruption also, wherwith I must striue al my life long, & doth freely giue vnto me the righteousnes of Christ, so that I shal neuer come into iudgement.
The Exposition.
Hauing1 vnderstood what the Catholike Church is, and what is the qualitie thereof, and what we are to learne thereby: nowe followeth the recitall of those priuiledges, wherewith God hath graced it: of which forgiuenesse of sinnes, as being the chiefe treasure of the Catholike Church is set first in order: the definition whereof out of the wordes of the Catechisme is this, to wit a stedfast purpose and will of God, to lay aside al memorie of sinne, and the punishment thereof, and freelie to giue the righteousnesse of Christ, euen for his satisfaction, so that I shall neuer come into iudgemēt: in which definition wee are shortely to marke these principall pointes. 1, Who forgiueth sinnes, namely God alone. 2. Wherein this forgiuenesse of sinnes doth stand, & how farre it reacheth. 3. For what cause God forgiueth sinnes: and last of all, what is the fruite and effect of free forgiuenesse.
And for the first which maketh most of all for the confirmation2 of our faith, it belongeth onely to God to forgiue sinnes, and he onely hath authority to doe it, for he beeing the party offended, what Angell or man dare or may giue to any other any part of his right? the Prophet Dauid flyeth3 vnto God, when he had offended him by two grieuous sins: saying, against thee onely haue I sinned, because he knew that hee was to looke for forgiuenesse4 of sinnes from God: and againe, There is mercy with thee that thou maist be feared.
Secondly hee that shall forgiue all sinnes & so cleere the5 conscience, must be such a one as seeth the heart, and knoweth all things: but such a one is God alone: therefore God alone forgiueth sinnes, both of those that are committed against himselfe, and those that are committed against our neighbour.
Neither doeth it ouerthrow this, that Christ seemeth to giue that authoritie to the Church, or to his ministers: Whose6 sinnes soeuer ye forgiue, they are forgiuen in heauen. For7 they forgiue sinnes by reason of their ministerie, by preaching forgiuenes of sinnes to them that repent and beleeue8 in Christ, according to the commaundement of God: but God freeth from guiltines by his owne authoritie: euen as also in the Lordes prayer wee professe that we forgiue our debters, namely so far foorth as we lay aside all desires of reuenge, and forgiue the offence as much as in vs lieth; but God onely must needs absolue them.
Furthermore it bringeth vnto vs no small comfort, that wee perceiue with what affection God forgiueth sinnes vnto the faithfull: to wit, in such sort, that he layeth downe all remembrance of our sinnes, which are here set downe to be of two sortes, all actual sinnes, and euen that corruption wherewith wee must striue throughout al our life: that is, originall sinne: which notwithstanding he9 doeth so forgiue, that he doeth not altogeither purge vs from it, but so farre that it cannot condemne vs, and will also in his time quite deliuer vs from it.
Whereto belong the similitude which God vseth euery where in the Prophets, and doeth thereby prouoke the people of Israell to earnest repentance, promising that10 he will cast their sinnes behinde his backe, and into the bottome11 of the sea: whereby the godly King Ezechias doth comfort and lift vp him selfe, and receiueth courage being perswaded that God hath cast all his sinnes behinde his backe.
For God is not like vnto men who oftētimes in words forgiue them by whome they are offended: but as by nature they are corrupt and prone to reuenge, so doe they neuerthelesse oftentimes remember old iniuries done to them, but God, when he forgiueth sinnes vnto man, doth it from his heart, blotting out all remembrance of his12 sinnes, for so he saith in Ieremie: I will be mercifull to their iniquities, & will remember their sinnes no more.
To which grace of free forgiuenes is added also another that doth marueilouslie comfort, and confirme vs: namely that God doth not only forgiue vs al our sinnes,
but13 also doeth giue vnto vs the righteousnes of Christ, For both are required, that we may be able to stande before God, both satisfaction for our sinnes, and imputation of righteousnes & holines of Christ, according as the Apostle comprehendeth both the one and the other, whē he14 saith: Him that knew no sinne he made sinne for vs: that wee might be made the righteousnesse of God in him. And in15 the first to the Corinth, who was made vnto vs of God wisedome, righteousnes, sanctification and redemption.
Besides16, this forgiuenesse of sinnes is so perfect, that it must bee vnderstoode not onely of the guiltines it selfe, but also of the forgiuenesse of the punishment: for God doeth not deale with vs in iest, or in sport, but he dealeth in earnest, euen as the creditour doeth then truely forgiue his debter, when he doth forgiue him, that he crosse out his debt and cancell his bonde: which goodnesse of God, Christ hath expressed by the parable of two debters, who when they had nothing to pay, their Lorde freely17 forgaue them the whole debt, for the creditour is not then saide to forgiue, when by his acquittance he witnesseth that his mony is paide him: but when without any payment, he doeth voluntarily of his owne liberality blot out the debt.
Nowe for that nothing is more harde then to beleeeue the18 forgiuenesse of sinnes, because nothing doeth lesse agree with the iustice of God, then to leaue sinne vnpunished, it is not without cause added in the text that God doeth it for the satisfaction of Christ, in respect whereof he19 doth both graunt pardon for our sinnes, and freely giue20 vnto vs the righteousnes of Christ.
The cause of which assurance is to bee fetched a little higher, namely from the very couenant of God, and the oth, which conteineth in it this poynte: (that God will remember21 our sinnes no more:) which couenant the Sonne of God22, then whome there can be nothiug vttered or conceiued to bee greater in heauen or in earth, hath confirmed by his death: and which most perfect ransome God hauing regarde vnto, saith in Ieremie: that he will remember the sinnes of his people no more, in which benefite the other also is ioyned, to wit, the imputation of the perfect obedience of Christ, and of his righteousnes.
And23 these two are very well reconciled, that although in respect of Christ, this forgiuenesse is for his desart, yet in respect of vs, our sinnes are freely forgiuen vs, because both God the Father hath giuen his Sonne vnto vs, & hee hath24 voluntarily satisfied for our sinnes.
Wherefore God in freely forgiuing vs our sinnes, doth nothing contrarie to his iustice, because Christ hath perfitely satisfied it: but he sheweth by this his free mercie, howe greatlie hee loueth vs in Christ his Sonne: and the Sonne him selfe chiefely by the voluntary abasing of him selfe, doeth declare his most perfect loue towarde vs.
Last of all, hauing vnderstood the article of free forgiuenes25 of sinnes, we must now weigh the fruit and effect thereof: which is, that we shall neuer come into iudgement, whereupon followeth saluation and euerlasting life26: as Christ witnesseth: For God hath not sent his Sonne into27 the world to condemne the world, but that the worlde by him28 might be saued: he that beleeueth in him is not condemned29. Againe, Verily, verily I say vnto you, he that heareth my30 word, & beleeueth him that sēt me, hath euerlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation, but hath passed from death to life. By which sentence is specially noted the free forgiuenes of sinnes for Christs sake, the effect wherof is saluation and blessednes.
The31 which obseruation of the affection and loue of God, which hee beareth towarde vs in Christ shall serue vs to this vse: first to make vs take heede, that no doubting of the mercie and goodnes of God, in forgiuing vs our sinne, doe at any time creepe vpon vs, as if God did not from his heart, & truly forgiue vs: Secondly to driue out all such security, wherby it vsually commeth to passe that men doe carelessely sleepe in their sinnes, considering that both sinne dwelleth in vs, wherewith wee must striue all our life long, & also that by this redinesse and goodnesse of God freely to forgiue vs our sinnes, we are the rather prouoked more carefully to auoide sinne, according to the doctrine of S. Iohn, who when hee had taught32, that, if we confesse our sinnes, the Lord is faithfull & iust to forgiue vs our sinnes, least any man might hereupon flatter himselfe in sinne, hee meeteth with it by this admonition: Little children these things I write vnto you, that you33 sinne not: as also Ezechiel, or rather God himselfe by the34 Prophet, speaketh most seuerely against such frowardnesse: When I say vnto the righteous man thou shalt surely liue, if he trusting to his owne righteousnes, commit iniquitie, all his righteous deedes shall not be remembred, but in that his iniquitie which he hath commited, he shall die.
The false doctrine.
Seeing it belongeth onely to God to forgiue sinnes, vpon the laying35 of this foundation the deuice of meritorious auricular36 confession falleth to the ground, wherein the poore people do giue that to their priestes to whome they make confession, which none but God alone is able to doe.
Secondly37 if God so forgiue sinnes, that hee casteth quite away all remembrance of them, and that for the satisfaction of Christ, who suffered in the flesh for our sinnes: the Romanists do38 greatly erre, who restraine that ransome of the Sonne of God, onely to deliuerance from euerlasting punishment, as if his39 death had not beene of that force, that it could also deliuer the faithfull from present punishments of this life, which God often times layeth vpon his children, partly for original sinne, and partly for actual sinnes, not that they should be in steed of any satisfaction, but for exercise of their faith, and of their patience, and to further their saluation.
Thirdly40 if God forgiue all sinnes, and euen that corruption wherewith we must striue all our life long, then are the same men also deceiued, in that they stretch the benefite of forgiuenesse of sins for Christs sake no further, then to the time that went before baptisme, but as for all the time that followeth after, they part stakes between Christ and their owne works, or merites, which is to ouerthrow the very foundation.
Fourthly they erre also in that they ascribe grace vnto the sacraments41, as if the holy Ghost & forgiuenesse of sinnes were shut vp in these signes & ceremonies, so that whosoeuer without vnderstanding and without faith come to bee partakers of them they are saued, euen by that worke wrought: whereas first and before all we must be reckened amonge the people of God, and be members of Christes bodie, if we will obtaine forgiuenesse of sinnes.
Fiftly42 by this article are refuted the Nouatians, who after a man hath once receiued forgiuenes of sinnes, and afterward sinneth of infirmitie, thought that after his fal he was to looke for no more forgiuenesse of sinnes, and that against the verie rule of Christ, who commandeth to pray for our dayly sinnes: Forgiue43 vs our debtes: and say to Peter, that he should forgiue his brother that repenteth, not only seuen times, but euen44 seuentie times seuē times, being deceued by these false principles45: that the Regenerate sinne not, and haue an Angelike perfection. Whose Bishop Ascesius the Emperor Constantine46 did iustly reprooue, saying: Set to the ladder, Ascesius, and get vp to heauen alone.
Sixtly47 & lastly: if they who haue once by true faith applyed vnto themselues forgiuenesse of sinnes, as God offereth it in the Gospell, shal not by the witnesse of Christ come into iudgemēt, whereto serueth the Romish purgatorie, wherein, of endlesse paine to deuise such a one as hath end, they wil needs haue vs so long to endure punishment, till our scortched soules be set free by meanes of our satisfactions before God? yea what a God shall this be, who doth so seuerely punish those that are without48 blame, that is, vntill they haue paide the vttermost farthing (for so they wrest the place in Math. to serue their purpose) who are indeede nothing at all in debt? For it being plaine that there is no debt, but in regard of sinne, if this be taken out of the way, the rule of Gods iustice requireth, that the punishment which is the reward of sinne should also of necessitie cease: but because they vse to flee to the authoritie49 of the Fathers, let vs heare what Ambrose witnesseth: He that here receiueth not remission of sinnes, shall neuer be there: (that is, in the Communion of Saints) and hee shall not be there, because hee could not come to euerlasting life, because euerlasting life is the forgiuenesse of sinnes50. And Cyprian: After we are departed hence, there is now no place for repentance, no worke of satisfaction, here life is either lost, or saued: here we prouide for euerlasting life by the seruice of God, and by the fruit of faith.
1 What is ment by forgiuenes of sinnes.
2 It belongeth onely to God to forgiue sinne.
3 Psal.51.1.
4 Psal.130.4.
5 1.King.8.39.
6 Iohn 20.25.
7 How the Ministers forgiue sinnes
8 Mat.6.12.
9 Rom.8.1.
10 Mich.7.19.
11 Esay.38.37.
12 Ier.31.34.
13 Two things are required to our reconciliation with God.
14 2.Cor.5.21.
15 1.Cor.1.30.
16 That God doth also forgiue the punishment due vnto sinnes.
17 Luke 7.40.
18 God doeth forgiue sins for Christs sake.
19 1.Ioh.2.2:
20 2.Cor.5.19.21
21 Ier.31.34.
22 Heb.8.12.
23 In what respect God doth freely forgiue vs our sinnes.
24 Esay 9.5.
25 The fruit and effect of forgiuenesse of sinnes.
26 Ioh.3.17.18.
27 Iohn 5.24.
28 Acts 16.31.
29 Psal.32.1.2.
30 Rom.4.7.9.
31 The vse.
32 1.Ioh.1.9.
33 1.Iohn 2.1.
34 Ezeck.33.13
35 Concil.Trid.sess.14.c.5.
36 Catech.Rom. pag.225. and 227.
37 The deuise of auricular confession.
38 Conc.Trid.sess.14.cap.9.
39 Of satisfactory workes.
40 Conc.Trid.sess.14.cap.8.
41 Conc.Trid.sess.3.cap.8.
42 Of the forgiuenesse of all sinnes, and euen of those that we dayly commit.
43 The errour of the Nouatians.
44 Mat.6.12.
45 August. de hæres.cap.38.
46 Mat.18.21.
47 Conc.Trid.Ses.25.Decreto de Purgat.
48 Mat.5,20.
49 Ambros.lib.de bon.mortis.
50 Contra Demetrium tract.1.