Question 112
THE THIRD PART: Of thankefulnes.
The Arg. That wee ought not to abuse our tongue to lying, slaundering, & false accusations of our neighbour, but rather to auouch the truth, & to maintaine and preserue the life and goods of our neighbour.
Question.
What doeth the ninth commaundement require?
Answere.
That I beare no false witnes against any man, that I falsifie or misconstrue no mans words, that I backebite or reproch no mā, that I condemn no man rashly or before his cause bee heard, but that I doe with all carefulnes auoid all kind of lying and deceit as the proper workes of the deuill, vnlesse I will prouoke the most grieuous displeasure of God against my self: that in iudgement: and other affaires I follow the trueth, & freely & constantly professe the matter to be euen as it is. Moreouer that as much as in me lyeth I defend, and increase the good name and credit of others.
The Exposition.
As the Lawegiuer hath before forbidden to hurt the life of my neighbour or to worke any thing against it, likewise, to take away another mans goods from him: so in this commandement he teacheth that it doth in no sort become vs to speake euill one of another, thereby to leaue vpon their name a blot or marke of infamy and euill report: which howsoeuer it be done of vs, it shall no doubt go for false witnes against another.
Where1 first it is to be marked that that is generally called witnes, whatsoeuer constantly is reported or affirmed concerninge another man to winne credite withal, whether it be good or euill, the vse whereof in the society of mankind being verie great if it swerue from the truth, a man may sinne it, verie harmefully and dangerouslie: for considering that there are manie thinges which wee knowe not, and to the knowledge whereof wee can not come, but wee must as it were vpon trust take them for true, in this case witnesses doe stande vs in stead.
Nowe2 heere we intreate properlie of false witnesses which is vttered against our neighbour, and to beare false witnesse, is to witnesse any such thing against our neighbour, as whereby wee may grieue him, or hurt him in his goodes, or by his honoure, whether it bee done in iudgement, or in common talke: which howe manie waies it is vsuallie done, and what bee the especiall kindes of false witnesses this is in the first place: and then howe wee ought to beare witnesse concerning our neighbour and to be careful of his credite, is taught in the second place.
And first3 the Lord doth straightly condemne and forbid the whol kind of it, as wel in iudges as in priuat men as: Ye shal not do vniustly in iudgement. Thou shalt not fauour the person of the poore, nor honour the persō of the mightie, but thou shalt iudge thy neighbour iustlie.
Agayne; If a false witnes rise against a man to accuse him of trespasse, then both the men which striue togeither shall stand4 before the Lord, euen before the Priestes and the Iudges5 which shall be in those daies: And the Iudges shal make diligent6 inquisition, and if the witnesse be founde false & hath giuen false witnesse against his brother, then shall yee doe vnto him as he had thought to haue done vnto his brother, so thou shalt take euill away foorth of the middest of thee.
The first sort hereof, as they are set downe, is Cauilling7, that is, that I doe not falsifie or cauill at any mans words: Cauilling is nothing else but a malicious construing of the meaning & wordes of our neighbour: for euery man is to bee esteemed the best expounder of his owne meaning and wordes: such was the dealing of those8 false witnesses against Christ: We heard him say, I9 wil destroy this tēple yͤ is made with hands: these wer false witnesses:10 (although it was true that Christ had so spokē, that is, had vsed such words) to wit because they wrested the wordes of Christ to another meaning, as if hee had spoken of the materiall temple, whereas he vnderstood it of his bodie which was as the true temple, wherin the fulnesse11 of the godhead dwelled: for hee was God manifested in the flesh.
Such was that also which the enemies of the Gospell vsed against Steuen, when they were not able to resist the wisedome12 and the spirite by which he spake: setting vp false witnesses against him, who said: This man ceased not to speak blasphemous words against this holy place, and the law: for we haue heard him say, that Iesus of Nazateth shall destroy this place, & shal change the ordinances which Moyses had deliuered vs.
Of13 this fault Iohn Baptist did earnestly warne the souldiers to beware: Accuse no man falselie, or, beare no false witnesse against anie man.
The second kinde of false witnes is backebiting14, which gnaweth vpon the credite and good name of our neighbour, and priuilie scattereth false surmises of those that are absent, and either reporteth false crimes by other men, or deprauech their wel doings, or maketh the worst of such things, as may well be excused: or scattereth abroad, and without measure amplifieth and maketh the most of other men slippes or faults, which ought rather to be couered, and that without the knowledge, who is thus euill spoken of behinde his backe.
Which15 fault how greatly it displeaseth God, appeareth by this, that among those grosse sinnes, which the Apostle reckneth vp to the Rom. hee nameth also whisperers & backebiters, a most shameful kind of mē, which in al ages & among al natiōs hath alwaies bin very badly spokē & thoght of, & hath alwaies bin disliked of al honest minds.
Whereupon also the Prophet, when he affirmeth that he shall dwell in the holy hil of God, who doth not slaunder16 with his tongue, doeth plainelie signifie, that backbiters haue alwaies beene hated of God: and God saith to Moyses: Thou shalt not walke about with tales among thy people17: thou shalt not stand against the blood of thy neighbour: I am Iehouah.
Such18 a one was Siba wrongfully slaundering Mephibosheth19 his lorde vnto the King, as though he had saide: To day will the house of Israell restore vnto me the kingdome of my father.
Such20 a one was Doeg the Edomite, who by his false accusation murdered fourescore and fiue Priestes of the Lorde, and the citie Nob, with all the men, women, and children that were in it.
Last of all, such a one was Haman, when he did maliciouslie21 informe Ahashuerosh the King against the Iewes, and by that meanes went about vtterly to destroy them.
And not only hee that backebiteth with his tongue is here condemned, but also hee that greedily receiueth slaunderous reportes against his neighbour, and giueth eare vnto them, which the verie heathen were not ignorant of, as it is reported of Simonides the Musitian, that when one said, many men complaine to me of thee, he answered, wilt thou neuer leaue to trouble mine eares with slanders? Likewise he, that although he do not willingly backebite another, or giue eare to them that doe it, yet doth not, when he may defend and answere for his friend being absent against a slaundering backebiter, but by his silence seemeth as it were to approue of his doing: the heathen Poet sawe this:
----. Who so bites his friend in his absence,22
Or speakes not for him, when he heares him blam’d by an other,
Or for backebiting or quipping loues to be laught at,
He that blabs mens faults, and telles of more then he knowes of,
This is a black mouth’d man him thou Romane beware of.
Neere of kinne to this vice is the disease of railing2324 or reueiling, which is an odious vpbraiding of another25 man, proceeding of euill will, and a peeuish licentiousnesse of slaundring, whether it be to a man by him selfe aparte, or in companie, and that without any respect of persons, This also God hath expressely forbidden in his Law26: Thou shalt not raile vpon the Iudges: nether speake euill of the ruler of thy people.
Such a one was that wicked railer Semei pouring out most vile reprochfull speeches against his lord the king: Come foorth, come foorth thou bloodie and wicked man: the Lord hath brought vpō thee al the blood of the house of Saul, in whose stead thou hast raigned, and the Lord hath deliuered thy kingdome into the hand of Absolon thy Sonne, and beholde thou art taken in the wickednesse because thou art a bloodie man. Of the same saith Paul, Let all euill speaking be27 put away from you. Neere vnto this come all scoffing and28 biting iestes, ioyned with nippes and tauntes towarde anie, which the Apostle calleth iesting, or scoffing.
Fourthlie29 is condemned al headlong and hastie iudgement pronounced against thy brother either by thy selfe or30 by thy consent. Such was the iudgement of the courtier Putiphar, master of Pharaohs gard, who when his wife had falsely accused Ioseph without hearing his cause, cōmaunded him to be put in prison: likewise the iudgement31 of King Dauid, condemning Mephibosheth before hee heard him, and bestowing his goods vpon him that had slaundered.
Therefore32 not without cause saith Christ: Iudge not, least33 ye bee iudged; and Nicodemus did deseruedly condemne34 this fault in the Elders, saying, Doeth our Law condemne a man before hee hath heard him and knowe what he hath done.
Moreouer35 all headie inclination to wrong iudgement36 is by the same Lawe forbidden, such as theirs was, who went vnto Christ to tel him of the Galileans, whose blood Pilate had mingled with their owne sacrifices, who did thinke, as by the wordes or answere of Christ it is like, that they were therefore slaine, because they were sinners aboue all the other Galileans: To whome Iesus answered and saide: Thinke you that these Galileans were sinners aboue all other Galileans, because they suffered such things? I tell you nay, but except you repent, you shall all likewise perish. Such is also that of Christes disciples asking of Christ, Master, who did sinne, this man or his parents, that he was borne blind?
To conclude, all ouertwhart suspicions, and euen all naughty naughty37 meaning of the minde is comprehended in this prohibition38, according to the saying of Paul, Loue thinketh not euill: so that Menander well said, that more cauillations rise vpon suspicions, then vpon verye deedes themselues.
Fiftly are condemned all kindes of lying and deceite, accordinge39 as the Lorde ioyneth them both together, both40 false witnesse and lying: Thou shalt not receiue a false tale41, neither shalt thou put thine hand with the wicked to be a false witnesse.
So42 lying and deceite are ioyned together: Lye not, neither deale falsely one by another. Nowe a lye is committed many waies. 1. By manifestly notwithstanding the trueth. 2. By telling a lye in iest, although no harme come thereby to my neighbour: for the Apostle commaundeth vs to absteine from all shew of euill. 3. By concealing a trueth, if a man bee asked of the trueth43 especially in iudgement, to perfourme a duetie to another man, to doe him good, especiallye to deliuer him from a most certaine daunger, because it is sinne whatsoeuer swarueth neuer so little from the Lawe, neither may euill bee doone that good may come thereof: but rather in such hard and straight cases, wee must trust vpon God, and not flie to deuising of lies: which whosoeuer doe, they declare that they had rather vse their owne wisdome, then put their trust in the prouidence of God.
Hitherto belongeth that generall admonition: Lye not one to another44, seeing ye haue put off the olde man with his works.
Although wee must make a difference betweene a lie in iest and a dutifull lie, and betweene that which is at a crosse fight with the Lawe of God, and commeth of a purpose to lie, to the intent to wronge our neighbour, least45 wee should thinke with the Stoikes that all sinnes are equall46: for the midwiues and Rahab did not so grieuouselie sinne in lying: as they that spake lies for their pleasure: in which Matrones, we ought to follow their faith and their feare of God, but not their dissemblinge of47 the trueth: for which vertues they are euen in the Scriptures so greatly commended, & the Lord did blesse them.
But48 of deceitfull & wilie dealing the Scripture affoordeth49 examples in Simeon and Leui the sonnes of Iacob, who contrary to their couenante made with the Sichemites, that if they did circumcise euery male, they would giue their sister to wife to the sonne of Hamor, vpon the thirde day, when the Sichemites were sore, taking euery man his sworde went into the citty, and without resistance slew all the males, and taking Dina out of the house of Sechem, went their wayes, against whome Iacob50 lying a dying speaketh thus: Simeon and Leuy brethren, instrumentes of violence are in their habitations, Let not my soule come into their secrete: my soule bee not thou ioined with their assemblies, for in their wrath they slew men.
Nowe the reason wherefore wee ought to detest such kinde of lying and deceitfull dealing, is diligently to bee marked51, namely because they are the workes of the Deuil proper vnto him, and whereby the most heauie wrath & displeasure of God is prouoked against vs: whereupon saith Salomon: Lying lips are abhomination to the Lorde, And52 Christ. Ye are of your father the Deuill, and the lust of your53 father ye wil do, he was a murtherer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, for there is no truth in him: when he speaketh a lye, then speaketh he of his owne: because he is a lyer, and the father of a lye.
Aquinus54 also hath noted as much, affirming that a lye is to be auoided for foure causes. 1. Because a lyer becommeth like vnto the deuil: for as by a mans speech it is knowen of what country hee is, and where hee was borne: so by lying a man is discerned to be of the Deuils kinred. 2. For the breach of humane societie, nay of Christian fellowship: for when God hath ioyned men amonge themselues to liue one with another, and to haue dealings one with another, howe can that bee, if making no account of the trueth, they take pleasure in lying, and accustome themselues vnto it? 3. Because hereby such a blot is brought vpon our credite, as neuer can be wiped away. For he that is accustomed to lie, at the length by this custome attaineth, that when he saith truth no man will beleeue him: as Ecclesiast. saith: Who can55 be clensed by an vncleane thing? or what truth can be spoken of a lyer? Last of all for the punishment, that is, the losse of the Soule: *The mouth that lyeth destroyeth the soul: Wisd.*1.11. Thus farre Thomas.
Adde to these flatterers, and such as can deuise any thing to please their Lords, & speake it to their face, then whom there is no more daungerous sort of men: so that one56 said wel, that it were better to light εις κόρακας, that is, among carion crowes, then εις κόλακας, that is, among, flatterers: because they can spoile but the bodie alone, but these are able to corrupt the very minde also: which notwithstanding at this day are the onely men of account, & bear al the sway in the courts of great Princes: by whom king Dauid, when Sauls court was full of such, was most of all hurt and laid at, by reason that Saul did too easily giue credite to their false accusations: as hee complaineth in the Psalmes: They speake deceitfully euery one with his neighbour, flattering with their lippes & speaking57 with a double hart: The Lord cut off all flattering lips, and the tongue that speaketh proud things: which haue said with our tongue we will preuaile, our lips are our own, who is Lord ouer vs.
Now because it is not sufficient for the keeping of this commaundement, to beare no false witnes against our neighbour, either by this, or by any other meanes, vnles we also know well what the Lawgiuer commaundeth vs, & what vertues he commendeth vnto vs in this Law, to exercise towards our neighbour: therefore wee must know that the Lorde doeth moreouer require that in iudgements, that is, if at any time I be demaunded by the Magistrate and by the iudges, and in all other affaires, to wit, in common life, if at any time my testimony be asked concerning another, I then follow the trueth, and honestlie and constantly professe the matter to bee euen as it is.
To folow or loue the truth (whereof is called true dealing58) is a vertue, or good disposition of the mind, whereby wee seeke after and imbrace true opinions, and doe wilwillingly and readily, with regarde of our duety, & likewise of persons, place and time, and other circumstances, professe and defende the same to the glory of God and the saluation of our neighbour: and herof he is properly called a true dealing man, who loueth the trueth, and59 as the Prophet saith, speaketh it from his heart, and laboureth for it, for the glory of God, and the saluation of his neyghbour.
The reason of this commandement is full of equity: for because God is true, wee also being his sonnes must bee60 true, and followers of our Father: which Pithagoras seemeth in part to haue vnderstood, who being demanded wherein a man came neerest vnto God, answered, In speaking the trueth.
But the Apostle vseth also another argument: Speake the trueth euery man to his neighbour, for we are members one61 of another: signifyinge that this is the right vse of the tongue, first to speak the truth, and then so much the rather to do it, because we are members one of another, and all of one body.
Next it is not sufficiente to professe and speake the truth62 of our neighbour, vnlesse we doe it singly and in plaine dealing, Plaine dealing is such a vertue, as when one, farre from all hypocrisie & counterfeiting, speaketh what hee thinketh, and whose talke agreeth with his hart, and who dissembleth nothing that may make for the knowledge and reueiling of the trueth for the benefite of our neighbour.
The inseparable companiō of plain dealing, & which it63 is not meet to haue parted from it, is boldnes or libertie, which is a vertue, whereby so farre as time, place, & necessitie doe require, wee doe freely, without feare and constantly professe the truth, & neither by feare of danger, nor by respect or authority of persons can be drawn from it: so that Plato may bee our frende, and Socrates our friend, but the trueth more friende to vs then all.
Therefore by this it is euident, that to the end we may not be found false witnesses before God, first that beinge demaunded wee should plainely and freely professe the truth concerning our neighbour: but besides by the same Law is required also of vs such a loue to the truth, that although64 we bee not requested, we neuer be wanting to another, but alwaies desire to maintayne him & his good name and credite, according to the rule of our Master, Whatsoeuer yee would that men shoulddoe vnto you, euen so do yee vnto them.
Forseeing65 that God hath regard of our credite, and a good name is more pretious then all treasures, & therefore the losse is as great to a man to bee robbed of his good name as of his goods, it ought by good reason to mooue vs to preserue and maynteine the good name of our neighbor. Hitherto belong the verses a little before alleadged out of the Poet.
Last of all wee may not ouerslip the punishment and vengeance of false witnes bearing and lying, which God threatneth in the scriptures, shutting out from his companie66 and from dwelling in his kingdome those that do such things. Hereupon saith the Psalmist: Thou destroyest them that speake lies, the bloodthirstie and deceitfull man the67 Lord doth abhorre: And Salomon in the Prov. A false witnesse shall perish.
And Iohn in the Reuelation: But without shalbe dogges and68 inchanters, and whooremongers, and murtherers & idolaters69, and whosoeuer looueth or maketh lyes
Mans punishment to bee administred by the Magistrate, is to reward like for like.
1 What witnes is.
2 What it is to beare false witnesse.
3 Lev.19.15.
4 Deut.19.16.
5 1.King.21.1.
6 2.Sam.11.15.
7 Cauilling.
8 Mar.14.57.
9 1.King.21.1.
10 Ioh.2.21.
11 Colos.2.9.
12 Act.6.10.
13 Luk.3.14.
14 Backebiting.
15 Rom.1.30.
16 Psal.15.3.
17 Leuit.19.16.
18 2.Sam.16.3.
19 1.King.21.1.
20 1.Sam.22.9.
21 Hest.3.9.10.
22 Hor.Sat.4. lib.1.
23 Railing.
24 Exod.22.28.
25 Act.23.5.
26 2.Sam.16.7.
27 Eph.4.36.
28 Eph.5.4.
29 Hastie iudgement.
30 Gen.39.20.
31 2.Sam.16.4.
32 Math.7.1.
33 Luke 6.7.
34 Iohn.7.51.
35 Luk 13.1.
36 Iohn.9.2.
37 1 Cor.13.
38 See Sentent. Græcor.
39 Lyes of all sorts.
40 Exod.23.1
41 Leuit.19.11.
42 1 Thess.5.22.
43 Rom.3.8
44 Col.3.9.
45 Exod.1.20.
46 Ios.2.12.
47 Hebr.11.31.
48 Prou.12.22.
49 Gen,34.23.
50 Gen.49.5.
51 Gen.3.5.
52 Gen.3.3.
53 Iohn 8.44.
54 Thom.in opusc. Theol.de lege
55 Eccles.34.4.
56 The saing of Diogenes.
57 Psal.12.2.3.4
58 What true dealing is,
59 Psal.15.12.
60 Eph.5.2.
61 Eph.4.25.
62 Plain dealing
63 Liberty.
64 The maintayning of another mans good name.
65 Eccles.7.1.
66 Psal.5.7.
67 Prou.6.17.18. 19.&21.28.
68 Reuel.22.15.
69 Deu.19.16.17