Question 60
THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.
Question.
Howe art thou righteous before God?
Answere.
By faith alone in Iesus Christ, so that although mine own conscience doe accuse me that I haue greuously offended against all the commandements of God, and haue not kept any one of them, moreouer also that I am prone to all euill, yet notwithstanding (so that I do embrace these benefits with true affiance of minde) without any merite of mine owne, of the
meere mercie of God, the perfite satisfactiō, righteousnes & holinesse of Christ is imputed and giuen vnto me, as if I had neither committed any sinne, neither were there any blotte or corruption cleauing vnto me: yea, as if I had my selfe perfectly performed that obedience, which Christ hath perfourmed for me.
The Exposition.
As in the former question wee haue shewed that wee are righteous before God in Christ: so here, howe we are righteous before God, that is to say, howe wee that are vnrighteous and vnworthie are accounted righteous, and withall the whole order of our iustification is plainely set downe: to which point wee must bringe so much the more care and heede, because the deuill hath gone about to darken and ouerthrowe this doctrine, which hee knew to bee the principall stay to vpholde religion.
And1 first wee must define iustification by faith, and then shewe the fruite of this doctrine, Iustification is nothing else but a reconciling of vs with God, who were by nature vnrighteous, consisting of two partrs: namely, the perfite forgiuenesse of all our sinnes, and the imputation of the most perfect satisfaction, righteousnes, and holines of Christ, made and giuen by the free mercy of God, without any merite of ours, and which is receiued of vs by faith alone.
From2 hence may an answere vnto this question, How I am righteous before God, that is, howe I am able to stand, to bee acquited, and accepted in the sight of God, and bee reconciled vnto God, (for so to be righteous, and to be iustified is here taken) most fitly be made: to wit. By faith alone in Iesus Christ.
In the beginning of the answere the Catechist setteth downe3, what we are of our selues, namely, sinners and vngodly4, as hauing grieuously offended against all the commandements5 of God, and kept none of them: and that if wee would denie or excuse this, our owne conscience can reproooue vs. Last of al, that euery one of vs is prone to all euill: all which he sheweth, doe not hinder vs from beeing iustified before God, so that with a true affiance of minde, wee lay holde vpon Christ, in whome wee haue certen and sure comfort against the greatnesse of our sinnes, and all temptations proceeding from our owne conscience and from Satan, whereof a little after we will speake more plainely.
This proposition that we are iustified by faith alone, and6 those that follow vpon it, are taken out of the Epistle of Paul to the Romanes: who hauing prooued by comparison7 of the Law, and the life of all men, that all men8 are sinners, and therefore worthie of condemnatiō, in9 the sight of God, by propoūding the example of Abraham, who was iustified out of him selfe through faith in Christ alone: and by the testimonie of Dauid, ascribing blessednesse vnto forgiuenesse of sinnes, doeth at the length10 conclude: Therefore being iustified by faith we haue peace1112 towards God, through Iesus Christ our Lord.
And13 in another place: By grace are ye saued through faith14, and that not of our selues, it is the gift of God.
As15 also he had taught before: Abraham beleeued God, and16 it was imputed vnto him for righteousnes.
And it maketh no matter, although the worde (onely) be17 not found in the Scriptures in so many sillables, seeing18 that freely, and without the workes of the Lawe, bee wordes19 importing as much. And the same Apostle doth professedly20 set those two propositions one against another21: By grace ye are saued through faith, and then, not of workes, least any man should boast. Moreouer also least any man should replie that the ceremoniall workes are shut out from iustification, hee doeth elsewhere bring these places to prooue this conclusion: Hee that doeth these things (meaning the commaundements of the morall Lawe) shall liue by them. And, Cursed is euery one that abideth not in all things that are written in the booke of the law to doe them: where no man will say that life is promised to the obseruers of ceremonies, nor that the curse is denounced onely to them that transgresse them. And if these places are to bee vnderstoode of the morall Lawe, there is no doubt, but the morall workes also are excluded from beeing able to iustifie: And then I pray you, if any righteousnesse may bee imputed vnto workes, why should any man shut out the ceremonies being rightly vsed? For certenly they are cōtained in the fourth commandement, and so they were rightly vsed, they were most excellent workes,
Yet wee must vnderstand that wee are so iustified by faith alone, that wee doe not ouerpasse him, who doeth iustifie vs: for although these questions be one vnder an other: Howe am I iustified in the sight of God, & who doeth iustifie me: yet they are also diuers questions, that so order may be obserued in the article of iustification.
Nowe hee that iustifieth vs, is God himselfe of his meere22 mercie, without any merite of ours, who here for order of teaching is set in the second place: Hee it is that23 hath saued vs, and called vs with an holie calling, not of24 workes, but of his owne purpose and grace: hee it is that first25 loued vs.
All26 (saith the Apostle) haue sinned, and are depriued of the27 glorie of God: and are iustified freely, namely, by the grace of28 God, where you haue the originall, and the first fountaine, namely; that God imbraced vs with his free mercy.
Thirdely, least any man should thinke it to be against reason, that God who hateth all vnrighteousnesse, doeth so29 easily acquite any man from sinnes, especially for that Salomon30 pronounceth him to bee abhominable in the sight of God, who iustifieth the vngodly: not without cause31 is that so expounded by Paule, that wee are iustified32 by faith alone, but in this respect that it layeth holde vpon33 Iesus Christ.
For we must alwaies haue recourse to that principle, that the wrath of God lyeth vpon all men so longe as they continue to be sinners, which Esay hath very elegantly signified in these words: The Lords hand is not shortened that it cannot saue, nor his eare heauie, that it cannot hear, but your sinnes haue separated betweene you, and your God, and your iniquities haue hid his face from you that hee will not heare.
We heare that sinne is the separation betweene man and God, and the cause that turneth away the countenance of God from a sinner: and it cannot otherwise be, forasmuch as it is farre from his righteousnesse to haue any thing to doe with sinne: whereupon Paule teacheth that man is an enemie vnto God, til he bee restored into fauour by Christ, who is the materiall cause, and also the34 worker and minister of our reconciliation with God. And35 to the Rom. he saith of Christ: Whome God hath set foorth36 to bee a reconciliation through faith in his blood, to declare37 his righteousnesse by the forgiuenesse of the sinnes, that38 are passed: not because none but the sinnes that are passed39 are purged by the death of Christ, but because vnto the death of Christ there was no raunsomme, whereby God might be appeased, therefore the Apostle speaketh40 in this sort, contayning also neuerthelesse all sinnes, which41 shall bee committed in time to come: for Christ is not42 a mediatour after one sort at one time, and after another43 sorte at another time. And Peter in the Actes saith: To him giue all the Prophets witnes, that whosoeuer beleeueth in him shall receiue remission of sinnes through his name. And agayne, By him (meaning Christ) is preached vnto you forgiuenesse of sinnes, and from all those things from which ye could not be iustified in the law of Moses, whosoeuer beleeueth in him is iustified.
For although God alone bee the fountaine of righteousnesse, and we are not otherwise righteous but by hauing part with him, yet because by an vnhappye breach wee are become estranged from his righteousnesse, wee must44 needs descend to this inferiour remedie, that Chist by the power of his death & resurrection may iustifie vs,
Which45 is, when vnto them that beleeue their sinnes are forgiuen. 1. For the merite of Christ, or for his perfect satisfaction. 2 When the righteousnesse and holinesse46 of Christ is imputed vnto them, both wich benefits as necessarie to iustification, and which hauing attained wee are then fully iustified, are set downe in the very text & with al the word Imputation is expounded, namely such a benefite of the Father, whereby hee vouchsafeth to account all that obedience of Christ to bee ours, as if we our selues had fulfilled the lawe, & made satisfaction for our sinnes, & it is added, that it is giuen vnto vs without47 any merite of our owne, that is, freely to take away48 al opinion of satisfaction frō vs. For seeing the whole Scripture beareth witnesse vnto Christ, that by his name we obtayne remission of sinnes, and shutteth out all other names, it vnderstandeth that we bring nothing, neither can pretend any thing of our owne, but doe leane onely vpon the commendation of Christe, euen as Paul affirming49 that God was in Christ reconciling the world vnto himselfe, (for his sake not imputing to men their sinnes) straightway setteth downe the way and the meanes, because hee was made sinne for vs who was without sinne.
Which50 two partes of iukification, to witte, forgiuenes of sinnes, and imputation of the righteousnesse and holinesse of Christ, are therefore to be marked, lest any man shoulde51 confounde regeneration with iustification, and make52 it a part of it: considering that regeneration, whereof53 good workes are the fruite, is imperfect in vs, whereas to our iustification is required a full persourmance of all the righteousnesse of the Lawe, which because Christ alone hath done, therefore for that cause properly faith looketh vnto him alone, as to the Mediatour.
Which being so, and seeing by all these proofes it standeth54 out of doubt that we are righteous by faith onely in Christ,55 of the meere mercie of God, we receiue from hence this most assured comfort, namely that we are altogether out56 of doubt of our saluatiō & of euerlasting life, neither can be shaken, and as it were throwen from our standing, by any temptation of the deuill, which surely is a most notable fruite of the doctrine of iustification by faith.
For57 first, if my conscience (that is, that feeling of Gods iudgement58 which is as a witnesse within vs, not suffering vs to hide our sinnes, but drawing vs as guiltie before the iudgement seate of God) doe beare witnesse against me, that I haue grieuously sinned against all the commaundementes of God, & haue kept none of them, and therefore that I am vnworthie to be saued, & worthy to be cast away, especially because God is most righteous, and a deadly59 enemie and a reuenger of all sinne, foorthwith commeth60 this answere in the way, that Christe hath performed6162 both, who on my behalfe hath both offered him-
selfe to be punished by the Father, and most perfectly obeyed the Law, and therefore it cannot be that mine iniquities shoulde dismay my minde, as being wholy rased, and blotted out with the bloud of Christ.
If63 Satan yet lay to my charge: Although in Christ Iesus64 thou hast satisfied the punishement which thy sinnes deserued, and hast put on his righteousnesse by faith, yet thou canst not deny but that thy nature is corrupt, so that thou art prone to all ill, and thou hast in thee the seede of all vices: against this tentation this answere is sufficient, that by the goodnesse of God, not onely perfect righteousnes, but euen the holinesse of Christ also is imputed and giuen vnto me, as if I had neyther committed any sinne, neither were there any blot or corruption cleauing vnto me:65 wherto belongeth that of the Apostle: Him that knew no sinne he made sinne for vs, (that is, guiltie of sinne in our stead) that we might be made the righteousnes of God in him. Againe,66 To him that worketh not, but beleeueth in him that iustifieth the vngodly, his faith is imputed for righteousnesse. And,67 Blessed are they whose iniquities are forgiuē, & whose sinnes are couered, blessed is the man to whome the Lord imputeth no sinne.
By these thinges that haue bene spoken of iustification by fayth, namely, that God doeth iustifie by forgiuing, two errours of Osiander no lesse false then vngodly, are confuted68: the one is, that he thinketh it will be reprochfull to God, and contrarie to his nature, if he iustifie thē, who69 remaine in deede sinners: not distinguishing betweene70 the grace of iustification and Regeneration, as if it were all one to be iustified, & to be regenerated vnto newnesse of life, whereas this seconde, God so beginneth in his chosen children, and doeth by little and little in the whole course of their life, & sometime slowly go forward therein, that because euen in the most righteous there alwayes remayne some reliques of sinne, euen they also are alwayes subiecte to the sentence of death before the iudgement seate of God: but he doeth iustifie them not in part, but so, as being clothed as it were with the purity of Christ, they may boldly appeare in heauen: for otherwise some portion of righteousnesse would neuer appease our consciences, vntill it be set downe for a certaynty that we do please God, because we are without all exception, righteous in his sight.
The seconde errour is, that he imagineth vs to be substantially righteous in Christ, as well in essence as in qualitie deriued vnto vs from him, so that God as it were conueying himselfe into vs, maketh vs part of himselfe: which if it be true, the obedience of the crosse, whereby hee satisfied for our sinne, & the obedience of the Lawe, which the Lorde imputeth vnto vs that beleeue, was vnprofitable and not necessarye, which no man may say without blasphemy.
The false doctrine of the Romanistes.
The Romanistes make two kindes of the Iustification of a man in the sight of God*: the one they call the* First, which is imperfect, & goeth before al good works, which is a chaung of qualities in vs, through the mercie of God chaunging vs from vnbeleefe to the faith of Iesus Christ, that is, when a man which before was an vnbeleeuer is inlightened with the grace of God, and indued with fayth in Iesus Christ.
The other they call the Seconde iustification, which is as71 it were the perfection of the former, which is not simple free, but consisteth partly of the grace of God and fayth, partly of good works working together with faith, which are auaileable and helpefull vnto vs for our iustification, which doctrine of theirs is flatte contrarie to the doctrine of the Apostles, & of the true Church.
And that accusation of theirs hath no better colour, then when we affirme that a man is iustified by fayth only, we adde any thing to the worde of God, against the Law in Deuteron. Adde72 nothing to the word which I command you: whom73 we woulde haue to take this answere, that this is not onely to be accounted for the worde of God, which is to be found therein expressed in so many syllables, but also which is in effecte all one, and is necessarily gathered out of the Scriptures.
So the Fathers haue consonantly to the true fayth reteined these names Trinitie, Coessentiall, Person, Sacramentes, whom we following doe no lesse rightly affirme that we are iustified by faith alone, then we may say that which is very commonly founde, that we are iustified freely and without workes.
Whereunto adde that argument and reason which alwaies, & chiefly they are wont to vse out of 1.Cor.13.13. If fayth doth iustifie, then much more charitie, which is called greater, for so saith the Apostle: And now abideth fayth, hope & charitie: I answere that the reason is not good, because charitie is greater, that therefore it is more auaileable to iustifie men, no more then if a man shoulde reason thus: The King can holde the plow better then the husbandman, and make a shoe better then the shoemaker, because he is more noble then them both: Likewise a man can runne faster then a horse, & carry more then an Elephant, because he is more excellent thē they both: or the Angels can better giue light to the earth, thē the Sunne and the Moone, because they are more glorious. If the74 force of Iustifiyng depended of the merite or worthinesse of faith, peraduenture they sayde true: but we will shewe in the next question, that faith doeth not iustifie because it is the more worthie, or in the greater degree of honour, but because it receiueth righteousnesse being freely offered in the Gospell, Therefore it is a deceitefull reason vpon the aduantage of the worde: for charitie is there called by Paul the greater, if eyther wee consider the excellencie of it by the effectes, which there75 the Apostle reckoneth vp: or else if we regarde the vse and long continuance of it: for euery mans faith and hope profiteth himselfe, but his charitie and loue reacheth to others: faith and hope are belonging to this our estate of imperfectiō, but charitie shall abide euen in our perfite estate. For if wee examine all the effects of fayth and compare them, faith shall be76 founde to haue the vpper hande in many thinges: moreouer charitie it selfe, as the same Apostle witnesseth, is an effect of faith,77 but the effect without all doubt is inferiour to the cause thereof78: beside, what greater cōmendation of faith can there be,79 then when Iohn commendeth it to be our victorie, whereby80 we ouercome the world, by which we are borne agayne, are made the Sonnes of God, doe obtayne euerlasting life, and whereby Christ dwelleth in vs?
Which being so, who will maruaile, that when the Papists doe not rightly vnderstande the doctrine it selfe of Iustification, they can receyue no comforte thereby? For if with the true & sound fruits of iustification by faith, we compare the fruits of workes and of merite whereof they boast, truely there would appeare great diuersitie: For seeing that euen by their owne Iudgment, their workes are vncleane and vnperfect, for they are neuer certaine when they haue done good woorkes ynough: hereupon they are in a continuall wandring and doubting of Gods fauour toward thē, & of the certainty of their owne saluation, whereas all our saluation, & all the peace of our consciences depēdeth of this iustificatiō which we haue by Christ.
1 what iustification by faith is.
2 Faith is a meanes whereby wee apprehend iustification.
3 What we are all by nature,
4 1.Iohn 3.20.
5 Rom.7.23.
6 Rom,2,12, 17,18.
7 Rom.3,22,23
8 Rom,4,6,7,
9 Rom,5,1.
10 Eph.2.8.
11 Gal,2,16,
12 Phil.3.9.
13 Gene 15,6.
14 Rem.4,3,
15 An obiection preuented
16 Rom,3,21, 22,23,24,
17 Eph.2.8.
18 Leuit,18,5
19 Deut,27,26,
20 Gal,3,12,
21 Not onely the ceremoniall workes are excluded from the power to iustifie but also morall works
22 Who doeth iustifieth vs.
23 2.Tim.1.9.
24 Tit.3.5.
25 1 Iohn 4.10.
26 Deut.9.10.
27 Ezek.36.22.
28 Rom.3.13.
29 Prou.17.15;
30 1King.8.32. 30.
31 Eeut.25.1.
32 Exod23.7.
33 Esa.59.1.
34 Rom.5.8.
35 Esa.63.11
36 Act.3.11
37 Rom.3.25.26.
38 Heb.9.15.
39 What Paule meanneth by the sinnes that are passed.
40 Act.10.43.
41 1Iohn 2.1.2
42 Iohn 1.22.
43 Iohn 20.31.
44 Two parts of iustification.
45 The formal cause of our Iustification.
46 What is meant by imputation.
47 Ioh.20.31.
48 What is mēt by this name of Christ.
49 2.Cor.5.19.
50 Regeneration is no part of iustification.
51 Rom.7.25.
52 Gal.5.17.
53 Ioh.3.16.
54 Rom.3.24.
55 Ephes.2.8.
56 The finall cause & fruite of iustification by faith.
57 1.Obiect.
58 What conscience is.
59 Rom.3.9.
60 1.Ioh.2.20.
61 1.Ioh.2.2.
62 Mat.3.15.
63 2.Obiect.
64 Rom.7.23.
65 2.Cor.8,19.
66 Rom.4.4.
67 Rom.4 5,7.8.
68 The errour of Osiander in iustification.
69 Rom.7.24.
70 Rom.8.32.
71 Con.Trid.sess. 6.cap.5,6,8 & cap.9.11.
72 Deut.4.2.
73 What is ment by the word of God.
74 Howe loue is greater then faith.
75 1.Thes.1.3.
76 Wherin faith is aboue loue.
77 1.Ioh.5.4.
78 Ioh.1.12.
79 Ioh.3.16.
80 Ephes.3.17.