Question 85
THE SECOND PART: OF MANS DELIVERANCE.
Question.
How is the kingdome of heauen shutte & opened by Ecclesiasticall discipline?
Answere.
When by the commaundement of Christ, they who are in name Christiās, but in doctrine or life shew themseleus strangers from Christ, after they haue beene once or twice admonished, & wil not depart from their errours, or sinnefull liuing: are presented to the Church, or to those who are appointed to that office by the Church, and if they obey not their admonition, are by forbidding them the Sacraments, by them shut out from the assemblie of the Church, and by God himselfe from the kingdome of Christ: and again, and if they professe amendment, and doe indeede declare it, are receiued as members of Christ and of the Church.
The Exposition.
Of the former keye, to wit, of the Gospell, wee haue spoken in the former question: the other remaineth which they call the keye of discipline, or Ecclesiasticall correction, which is commonly called Excommunication or Banning: the definition whereof is laide downe in the text of the Catechisme, and the vse thereof both in shutting the kingdome of heauen against obstinate sinners, & again in opening it vnto the beleeuers that do repent.
Christ himselfe is declared to be the authour of this keye, as wel as of the former (wherupon it is called Christian, or Ecclesiasticall discipline) who ordained this key of the power to bind, and to loose, as Matthew reporteth it1 from the mouth of Christ, so that this is common to it with the former, that it hath the same commission and the same promise: but herein it differeth from the other that the other was of the preaching the Gospell, which the ministers haue committed vnto them, this because it perteineth to the discipline of excommunication, is also permitted to the whole Church.
Ecclesiasticall2 discipline is defined to bee a censure, whereby a brother that hath grieuously & opēly sinned, & hauing once or twise bene brotherly admonished, yet notwithstanding goeth obstinately forward, is not onely suspended from the vse of the Sacraments, that is, from the3 holy supper of the Lord, but also is solemnely pronounced4 worthy to be accounted as an heathen or a publicane,5 & vnworthie the company of the godly, as Christ and the Apostles witnesse, vntil he shew tokens of true repentance.
With which outward excommunication is also ioyned an inward, whereby such a one is withall shut out from the kingdome of God, by God him selfe, according to the threatning and sentence of Christ: Whatsoeuer ye bind on earth,6 shalbe bound in heauen: In which respect he is saide to be deliuered to Satan by the Apostle, who was excluded7 by the assemblie of the Church.
Now, the definition it selfe standeth of meere circumstances,8 whereof the first is against whome Christ commaunded Ecclesiasticall discipline to be vsed, to wit, against thē, who in name & title are Christians, but partly for doctrine, partly for manners, liue wickedly: for this discipline belongeth onely to those that be of the houshold of God, according to the vse of the Apostle: If any that9 is called a brother, be an whoremonger, or couetous person, with such a one eate not.
Wherby appeareth the difference betweene the manner of shutting & opening heauen, or the kingdome of God by Ecclesiasticall discipline, and that which is by the preaching of the Gospell, because this is more generall, and comprehendeth the whole body, or assembly of the hearers: that onely stretcheth to the verye members of the Church.
There are set down & alledged two sinnes, for correcting whereof this more sharpe remedie is to be vsed, the one is false doctrine, the other vngodlines of life.
And of false doctrine, that is, against the foundation, the Apostle speaketh: He that preacheth another Gospel, let him10 be accursed, where he shutteth out an hereticke, who bringeth erronious doctrine: & to Titus: Him that is an hereticke11 after one or two warnings auoid: And Iohn, If any man12 come to you and bringeth not this doctrine, receiue him not, neither bid him, God speed.
Of13 wicked life Paul speaketh to the Corinthes: But now I haue written vnto you, that ye companie not togither, if any that is called a brother be a fornicator, or a couetous person, or an idolater, or railer, or a drunkard, or extorcioner, with such a one, I say, eate not.
And to the Thess. If any man obey not our saying by our Epistle,14 note him, & haue no cōpany with him, that hee may be ashamed.
Yet must we not proceede alike in the one & in the other, but must vse a singular wisedome, & put a difference betweene those who erre in doctrine onely vpon ignorance, and that doe it onely of malice and wicked purpose to blaspheme sounde doctrine: Secondly, priuate sinnes are of one kind, and after one sort to be corrected, publike sinnes of another kinde, & after another sort to be dealt withall: according to the circumstances of one and15 the same sinne, as our chief Master Iesus Christ commaundeth16 in the Gospell, and as Paul hath very well made a difference of them in his former Epistle to Tymothy.
The seconde circumstance is of the degrees, which are earnestly17 and diligently to bee obserued before this part of discipline, that is, before the very act of excommunication, whereof one is, that he that is such a one in doctrine and in manners, bee first admonished brotherly, that is, with a zealous affection & with the Spirite of meekenes. And if neuerthelesse he abide as obstinate as before, and be18 not desirous to depart from his errours, & sinnefull life, then that hee bee presented vnto the whole Church, according19 to the same rule of Christ himselfe: And if hee refuse to heare thee, tell the Church: from whence Paul fetcheth this rule: If any man obey not our saying by our Epistle note him.
Another degree of discipline is, that hee be admonished by the Church, or by the Elders appoynted by the Church, & that once or twise: for that Christ ment, when he said: And if ye refuse to heare the Church, that is to say, beeing20 once or twise admonished by it, signifying that after21 all these remedies vsed, at the length such a brother beeing22 so obstinate, is to bee accounted as an heathen, or a publicane, that is, both a straunger from doctrine & faith, and of most wicked life and vnworthy the profession of a Christian man, such as in times past publicanes were accounted, who therefore did not belong to the Church of God, and tooke no part at the sacrifices.
Whereof wee conclude that Ecclesiasticall discipline hath two degrees, whereof the first is, admonition fitted according23 to the greatnes of that sinne, & the edification of the sinner: the seconde is excommunication, when neede so requireth, wherein these things seeme principally to be obserued.
The24 thirde circumstance is, by whome Ecclesiasticall discipline, and excommunication it selfe ought to be administred, to wit, by them, who are ordeyned thereunto by the Church; such as are ministers of the word, and Elders, the rest of the Church consenting thereunto; yet with25 this correction, that the multitude of the people doe not rule the action, but prouide as watchmen that nothing be done by a few, as they list themselues.
So Christ commaundeth to tell the Church and not onely26 the Minister, & Paul would not by his owne onely authority27 excommunicat the incestuous man, but by gathering28 the whole Church of Corinth togeither.
Hereupon29 Tertullian writeth; That, Censures are exercised30 in the Church with great authority, as before them who are sure of the presence of God, & that the preiudice of Gods iudgement is very great there, where the Seniors or Elders sit as chief, who haue obteyned this degree & honour, not by monie, but by good report, namely beeing approued both for their manners and for their life.
Whereby it is easie to see, that the right of excommunication neither is to bee giuen to any one certen man, neither belongeth to the false and Apostolike Church, such as is the Romish or Popish Church, but to the Eldership regularly and lawfully called.
And according to this order, if this whole action bee gouerned, it is most certen that the ratification of Iesus Christ31 is truely fulfilled: that what sentence soeuer is so pronounced vpon earth, the same is ratified in heauen.
The fourth and last circumstance is, when they may and32 ought againe to be receiued, who were before rightly and vpon iust cause excommunicated, namely when they do again professe their amendment, & do confirme it by their deedes; that then they bee agayne receiued as members of Christ, and of the Church.
For this excommunication is not exercised to that end, to barre the offenders for euer frō the vse of the Sacraments craments: but that both they are to be kept from the Supper, and their familiar company to bee auoyded vntill33 they doe repent, and shewe true fruites of repentance.
For this being onely sought in excommunication, that a sinner may bee brought vnto repentance, and euil examples taken out of the way, least either the name of Christ bee euill spoken of, or others prouoked to doe the34 like: Now when a sinner giueth testimonie of his repentance,35 & by this testimonie as much as in him lieth, blotteth36 out the offence that was giuen, he is no further to be vrged, the Apostle so aduising: It is sufficient to the same man that he was rebuked of many: so that now cōtrarywise we ought rather to forgiue him, & confirm him, least yͤ same should be swallowed vp with ouer much heauines: for the end of excommunication is not the destruction, but the saluation37 of a sinner, that at the least he being ouercome with shame may repent, and his flesh beeing tamed by this remedie may learne to liue by the Spirit.
Wherefore they sinne against the Law of charitie, who strayght wayes blot them out of the number of the Elect, who are driuen out of the Church, or doe dispayre of them, as alreadie cast away: for it is a farre other thing to bee bound in heauen, then to be cast out of that true kingdome of heauen, which neuer happneth to anie of the elect: for that principle of Christ standeth sure, that he shall neuer be cast out of doores, whome the Father hath giuen vnto the Sonne.
Wee may indeede account them straungers from the Church, and therefore from Christ, but onely for that time, wherein they continue in the diuorcement But after they haue truely repented, then ought they to be receiued againe, and admitted to the communion of the Church, and to be accounted as members thereof, and thankes are to bee giuen to God for them: that so they may feele in their soules and in their mindes, that they are againe restored and reconciled to God and to the Church.
The false doctrine.
Whereas38 some imagine that Iurisdiction of the Church to haue been appoynted to continue but for a time, while the Magistrates were yet estranged from the profeision of our religion, they are therein deceiued, that they doe not marke how great a difference and vnlikenesse there is, betweene the Ecclesiasticall and ciuill power. For the Church hath not the right of the sword to punish or to correct, nor authoritie to compell, or prison, nor any such other punishments, which vse to be awarded by the Magistrate. Secondly it doeth not intende that hee who hath sinned, should be punished against his wil: but that by voluntary chastisement he should professe repentance. Therefore the case is farre diuerse, because neither the Church taketh any thing vpon it, which is properly belonging to the Magistrate, neither can the magistrate doe that which is done by the Church.
Whereby againe the Romanistes may bee refuted, who by the example of Moyses challenge vnto themselues the right of both swordes togeither. For first they were to consider: that for Moyses to beare both at once, it was done by a rare miracle. Secondly that it was but for a time till thinges were better set in order, Lastly that Christ would bare the ministers of the word from ciuil Lordship and earthly authority: for so he speaketh to his disciples being ambitious and desirous of rule. The Kings of the nations beare rule ouer them, but you shall not doe so: So that Ambrose said very well. To the Emperour belongeth his Court, to the Priest his Churche.
The end of the Commentary vpon the second parte of the Catechisme, which is of mans deliuerance out of misery.
1 Mat.18.15.
2 The definition of Ecclesiasticall discipline, wherof excommunication is a part.
3 Mat.18.17.
4 2.Thess.3.14.
5 2.Ioh.20.
6 Mat.18. 18.
7 1.Cor.5.4.5.
8 Against whō the keye of discipline ought to bee vsed.
9 1.Cor.5.12.
10 Gal.1.8.9.
11 Tit.3.10.
12 2.Ioh,10.
13 1.Cor.5.11.
14 2.Thes.3.12.
15 Mat.18.15.
16 1.Tim.2,25.
17 The degrees of exercising discipline.
18 Gal.6,1:
19 2.Thess.5.14.
20 Mat.18.15. 16.17.18.
21 1.Cor.5.5.
22 2.Ioh.10.12.
23 Two degrees of ecclesiastical discipline.
24 By whome the degrees of discipline ought to be administred.
25 1.Cor.12.21.
26 Mat.18.17.
27 1.Cor.5.4.
28 Rom.12.8.
29 1.Tim.5,27.
30 Tertul.in Apologet.
31 Mat.18.17.
32 When the excommunicate are to be receiued agaiust.
33 1.Cor.5.5.
34 2.Cor.2.6.
35 2.Thes.3.14.
36 1.Cor.5.5.
37 Ioh.6.37.
38 The vnlikelies between the ecclesiasticall & ciuil power.