Lecture VI. Qualities of the Mediator
Sixth Lord’s Day
The lesson for the Fifth Lord’s Day set forth in the 12th Question and answer: The necessity of a satisfaction being made for our sins in order to our salvation; in the 13th: Our utter inability to make such satisfaction for ourselves; and in the 14th: The insufficiency of any mere creature to make satisfaction for us; which led to the 15th Question: What sort of Mediator and Deliverer must we then seek for? The answer given to which, is: “For one who is very man, and perfectly righteous; and yet more powerful than all creatures, that is, one who is also very God.”
But those who were attentive to our lecture on the Fifth Lord’s Day will remember the statement,—that the doctrine of the Mediator between God and man, which is opened in the 14th and 15th questions and answers, is more thoroughly discussed throughout those for the Sixth Lord’s Day; and that, therefore, for greater convenience, it was proposed to consider the whole subject under four heads:—
First: The impossibility of our salvation by our own works.
Secondly: The possibility of our salvation by or through the righteousness of a sufficient substitute.
Thirdly: The qualities necessary to a sufficient substitute or mediator for us with God.
Fourthly: The provision of such a substitute or mediator in our Lord Jesus Christ, as we learn from the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments.
The first two of these heads were then discussed at considerable length, leaving the third and fourth for discussion to-day; which, imploring divine help, we shall now pursue.
Thirdly: The qualities necessary to a sufficient substitute or mediator for us with God.
The answer to the 14th Question denies that he may be “a mere creature,” because, “first: God will not punish any other creature for the sin which man has committed; and, further, no mere creature can sustain the burden of God’s eternal wrath against sin, so as to deliver others from it.” The answer to the 15th Question asserts that “our Mediator and Deliverer” must be: “One who is very man, and yet perfectly righteous, and yet more powerful than all creatures, that is, one who is, also, very God.”
He must be “very man, and yet perfectly righteous,” says the answer to the 16th Question: “Because the justice of God requires, that the same nature which hath sinned should likewise (i. e. also) make satisfaction for sin; and one who is himself a sinner cannot satisfy for others.” He “must also in one person be very God,” says the answer to the 17th Question: “That he might, by the power of his Godhead, sustain in his human nature the burden of God’s wrath; and might obtain for and restore to us righteousness and life.”
This instruction of the Catechism is so full and clear as to render any prolonged commentary of ours needless; yet some more specific explanations may not be without use; and they will be given under two propositions:—
I. The Substitute and Mediator must be “very (or truly) man, and perfectly righteous.”
II. He must “also be very God in one person” with his human nature.
I. He must be “very man, and perfectly righteous.”
- No other mere creature can be accepted as a substitute for man.
A. “God will not punish any other creature for the sin which man has committed.”
a. God would not compel any other creature to suffer for man’s sin. If that creature be himself a sinner, he must suffer the punishment of his own sin, which he can never sufficiently expiate; and, therefore, no sufferings of his can be put to the credit of the sinner of another nature. There are various ranks of spiritual creatures, and we have reason to believe that among the angels who have fallen there are some of very high rank originally; but according to their original height has been the depth of their fall; according to the eminence of their duties has been the guilt of their rebellion. They suffer for themselves; they cannot be made to suffer more than they deserve; nor, if that were possible, would the infliction of any additional sufferings on them for man’s sake be just to them, or give any honor to the law which man has broken. Neither, if the other creature be innocent, would it be just to impose upon him sufferings which he does not deserve, that man might be relieved from sufferings which he does deserve. The authority of God could never be vindicated by such treatment of a creature who is entitled to reward for his obedience.
b. Nor, again, may such a creature, however highly exalted, voluntarily assume the place of man, either to endure man’s punishment for the sins he has committed, or to perform the duties which he has omitted, both being necessary to the satisfaction demanded. For every creature, from the fact of his creation, is a servant of God, bound to use all his faculties with the utmost energy of which he is capable in the sphere where God has placed him, and can never do more than his duty. To take man’s place, therefore, he must desert his own; to endure man’s punishment, to perform man’s duties, he must use faculties and time which already belong to God. The just authority of God would be aggrieved, not honored, by the disobedience of an angel to the law under which he is placed, that he might obey the law under which man is placed. A creature of God cannot change his sphere of duty any more than he can change his nature, for they are by the divine appointment necessarily relative to each other, not matters of the creature’s choice, but absolutely of the divine will.
B. “Further: no mere creature can sustain the burden of God’s wrath against sin so as to deliver others from it.”
Even if it were possible that another mere creature, however holy and exalted, could take our place, no amount of suffering on his part would be sufficient to make up for the sufferings we need to be released from.
a. The punishment appointed to the sinner is everlasting, because he can never, by any sufferings he is capable of, exhaust the penalty. Yet the distance in dignity between any other creature and man is, of necessity, limited; how, then, can our punishment, which is unlimited, be substituted by any sufferings of his short of eternal? The substitution, if undertaken, can never be accomplished.
b. Besides: the sinners to be redeemed are a great multitude, whom no man can number, and the substitute would have to bear in his single person the aggregate responsibility of them all; if, then, the punishment of one sinner be so heavy that he cannot exhaust it, but must suffer on forever, what mere creature could endure the imputed sufferings of the whole Church? A proper idea of the atonement will not tolerate for an instant the substitution of a mere creature to satisfy the wrath of God which we deserve.
- The character of our responsibility is such that it cannot be assumed except by one in human nature, yet himself guiltless.
A. “The justice of God requires that the same human nature which hath sinned, should likewise make satisfaction for sin.” (16th Ans.)
Even were another creature found capable of enduring the weight of our punishment, the circumstances of our sin are such that he could not assume its guilt or render a satisfactory obedience on our behalf; for—
a. The law which has been outraged was given to man, was adapted to his nature, and ordered for his sphere of service. Righteousness, it is true, must be ever and everywhere the same in its essential qualities. The same great principles of right must rule over all the subjects of God; yet, as the natures of those subjects are various, and different theatres of action are assigned to their different natures, it follows, that the manner in which the obedience is to be rendered must be peculiar to each class. The service demanded of a pure spirit, which has been created to live without a body, must be different from that demanded of a spirit created to live in a body; for example, the service of angelic spirit from that of a human being. Take the ten precepts of the law given to man, and you see that there are human duties which a holy angel cannot perform, as there are offences which a wicked angel cannot commit. Even one class of angels or unembodied spirits may have duties assigned them for which they are fitted, differing from those for which other classes of angels are fitted, each class being under its peculiar law, within its peculiar sphere, beyond which it cannot go. How much less can an angel, or unembodied spirit, come under the peculiar obligations of man? The law, given to man for his obedience on earth, can be obeyed or satisfied only by human nature on earth, or in man’s proper sphere. That law, imposed by the Creator on human nature, to be obeyed in his body on earth, man has broken; and the earth is full of his rebellion. Whatever laws, therefore, are obeyed, if the law given to man remain dishonored, the government of God is shaken. Whatever classes of his moral creatures are faithful, if man be a successful, unpunished sinner, the justice of God is uncertain. Whatever provinces of his empire are loyal and tributary, if in this world his authority be not vindicated, it ceases to be sovereign. Whatever decrees of his will are fulfilled, if the sentence against sinful man be not executed, his truth has failed. The satisfaction necessary for our safety must, therefore, we repeat, be made to the law appointed for us, in our nature and upon our earth. So we read that: “God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, made under the law, to redeem them that were under the law.”
b. The penalties denounced against sin are of such a nature that none but man can endure them so as to free us from guilt. The sentence pronounced on man is death,—death of body, and death of soul,—which we know includes all the sicknesses, pains, and corruption of the body, with all the sorrow, anguish, and degradation of spirit which is occasioned by the withdrawal of God’s favor and the weight of his wrath. This death of our entire human nature, temporal and eternal, is the punishment we deserve and must suffer, except we be delivered from it by a sufficient satisfaction rendered for us. None but man can know and feel the sorrows and agony of man in body and soul; none but man can suffer the pains and distresses of our mortal life, or our eternal death, the death “passed upon all men because that all have sinned.” So we read of our Redeemer: “Forasmuch, then, as the children are partakers of flesh and blood, he also himself took part of the same, that through death he might destroy him that had the power of death, that is, the devil; and deliver them, who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage. For, verily, he took not on him the nature of angels, but he took on him the seed of Abraham. Wherefore in all things it behooved him to be made like unto his brethren, that he might be a merciful and faithful high-priest in things pertaining to God, to make reconciliation for the sins of his people.”
There are other and most important reasons why the Mediator should be very man, which we may not now enter upon, but hope to consider fully when they are brought before us by subsequent sections of the Catechism. Yet we may ask: How may sinful man dare approach unto God; how may he know that God will again dwell with men; that his fallen nature may again enjoy the felicity of his presence and the light of his love, unless he saw one made in the likeness of his own sinful flesh holding intimate communion with God, glorious himself from communications of the divine glory, and standing before us as the medium through whom we may look upon God and not die,—unless God be again with man on earth, as he was once in Paradise, speaking to man as to his dear child?
B. The Mediator in our human nature must be “perfectly righteous,” because “one who is himself a sinner cannot satisfy for others.” This point is so clearly stated, that no argument of ours is needed to make it clearer; but it is stated so distinctly to prepare us for faith in him who has been constituted by God as our Mediator and Substitute. The perfect righteousness of the man who is our surety must be twofold; innocence and active obedience.
a. Innocence.—He must be without sin. If he had committed sin, his own guilt would be upon him; and he would be rejected by God in his own person, much more as a mediator for his fellow-sinners. So we read of our Lord and Saviour, that “he did no sin, neither was guile found in his mouth.”
b. Active Obedience.—The satisfaction for us required by God, is not merely a sufficient suffering in room of that which we deserve on account of our transgression, but an honoring of the law by an active obedience sufficient to be substituted in room of that which we are bound to render, and which is necessary, according to the divine justice, for our re-admission within the divine favor, vouchsafed only to those who are righteous in his sight. Such positive, energetic righteousness, no sinner, whose faculties have been depraved by the corruption of human nature consequent upon the fall, can render. “He made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin, that we might be made the righteousness of God in him.”
The inference from this is, that the mediator or substitute we need must be man, partaker of all other human characteristics, but not of sin; and, therefore, as all our race are fallen in Adam, guilty of overt, personal sins, and utterly without moral strength to honor God by keeping his law, the mediator or substitute for us in human nature, must be man after some extraordinary method which excepts him from the otherwise universal entailment of guilt and corruption, while he inherits all our weaknesses which are not sinful. Our guilt and corruption are derived from Adam in the same manner that our being is derived from him; “Adam begat his ‘children’ in his own likeness;” we are “conceived in sin and brought forth in iniquity;” that cannot be human nature, which is not born of woman; that cannot be sinless human nature which is begotten by man; hence, our surety in human nature must be conceived from some “extraordinary generation,” conceived without sin, brought forth without iniquity, yet, because his flesh and blood are derived from woman, having the physical weaknesses of humanity, being subject to all those infirmities, but without sin. So we read of our Lord’s miraculous conception, in the words of the angel to the Virgin Mary (Let “all generations call her blessed!”) “The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee; therefore also that holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of God.” The germ of the body was in the woman, and in her womb it grew till its birth, and from her bosom was it nourished after its birth, but the impregnating power was of God, and, therefore, was the flesh and blood of the “child wonderful” holy; of the seed of Adam, Abraham, Judah, and David, through his mother, but sanctified in the first beginning of his human nature by the energy of the Holy Ghost.
II. Our Mediator and Substitute “must also be very God in one person” with his human nature.
For this two reasons are given by the Catechism (17th Ans.)
“That he might by the power of his Godhead sustain in his human nature the burden of God’s wrath;” and
“Might obtain for and restore us to righteousness and life.”
- “That he might, by the power of his Godhead, sustain in his human nature the burden of God’s wrath.”
A. Because the burden of God’s wrath is too great for human nature, unsupported, to endure.
It is the wrath of God against the sinner. The sentence denounced against the sinner is death, which we have seen to be the utter withdrawal of the divine favor and the actual infliction of his vengeance. The moment that this sentence comes upon the sinner in its full execution, he must be crushed—he must die. There can be in him no vital energy left, no recuperative force—the weight presses him down forever. The substitute must be man, because it is the penalty of the law given to man. But if he were mere man, though himself righteous, the weight of the imputed guilt of a single sinner would crush him in death forever. He could never react from under it; his power would be lost; he would be dead. Nor could the strength of any creature avail for his help in so extreme an emergency. How, then, shall the one mediator be enabled to sustain the otherwise intolerable burden? All the wit of men and angels could never resolve the difficulty; we must go for our answer to the revelation of the Gospel. “God” is there “manifest in the flesh.” Man still stands forth the substitute of man, to receive upon his head the terrible curse; one person is still to meet it alone; but that Person is not merely man; by an ineffable mystery, the coequal Son of God assumes that humanity to himself, so that the Son of God and the son of the woman, very God and very man, their natures still distinct, yet in their distinctness united, constitute one Person, the Substitute of the sinner. The Son of God thus makes the human nature of the Son of man his own. The wrath divine comes not on the Son of God, for divinity can in no sense suffer or be put to shame; it falls on the human nature alone, because the justice of God requires that the nature, which has sinned, should bear the penalty of the sin; but the divinity in the person of the mediator sustains by its almightiness the humanity in the person of the mediator to bear up under the curse, and, while fully satisfying the wrath of God, yet to retain a vital energy sufficient for its recovery from the imputed death. The human nature alone endures, but endures by the strength of the divine, to which it is personally associated. Thus, the apostle speaks of the “Church of God which he hath redeemed by his own blood;” i. e. by the blood of the human nature which through his incarnation he made “his own.” “God sent forth his Son” (elsewhere called his only begotten Son, therefore Divine, as the begotten is of the nature of the begetter)—his Son must have existed before he sent him forth—sent forth his preëxistent Son “made of a woman,” that is, united to the Son of man as the Saviour of sinners. So again, we read, that Christ Jesus, “being in the form of God (i. e. existing as God) thought it not robbery to be equal with God; but made himself of no reputation, and took upon him the form of a servant and was made in the likeness of men; and, being found in fashion as a man, he humbled himself and became obedient to (until) death, even the death of the cross.” Great as must have been the wrath of God which came on the human nature of our Substitute, the strength of God could enable that human nature to bear it.
B. Because the merit of no suffering endured by a mere man would be sufficient for the redemption of the Church, saved through the Mediator.
If the wrath of God against a single sinner be so intolerable, how could a single man, as their substitute, sustain the wrath due to such a multitude?
A ready answer is, that the divine strength of the Immanuel could uphold his human nature under any degree of penal suffering; but the reply goes not far enough, for it will be asked again, Upon what principle of justice can one man be accepted in the room of many? If he be a mere man, how can the divine law be magnified by his suffering, let him suffer never so much, so that many sinners may escape by his substitution? It is obvious that where one stands forth as a substitute for very many, he cannot be accepted unless he has in his single person a dignity, or worth, far excelling that of a private individual man, and commensurate to the vast representativeness which he would assume. It is true, that by one man, Adam, condemnation to death came on our whole race; but Adam acted not merely as a private individual; nor became he man by ordinary generation; he was created immediately by God, so that the sacred genealogist hesitates not to call him “the Son of God” (“Enos, which was the son of Seth, which was the son of Adam, which was the son of God,” Luke iii. 38); and, deriving his nature in this extraordinary way, he was constituted in the dignity of head of his race. He could justly represent all human nature, because all human nature was in him. All his descendants fell with him; all are under the condemnation which he brought upon them: where, then, among those guilty descendants can one be found of competent worth to take the place of a second Adam, the headship of a new race, the Redeemer of sinful men who are represented by his sufferings expiatory of their offences? It is obvious, again, that the Second Adam, like the first, must be the Son of God, of sufficient dignity to be constituted, and actually constituted by God, Head or Representative of all who are to be redeemed through him. There must also be such a worth, or legal value, in his sufferings, as fully to vindicate the justice of God in accepting them on behalf of the sinners saved. But we have seen from our previous reasoning that no mere creature could be accepted to bear, or could bear, if accepted, the sufferings due to us. How, then, shall this difficulty in the way of a just mercy be met? (O the matchless wisdom of divine love!) The Only Begotten, eternal Son of God himself, becomes incarnate as our Elder Brother; he assumes to himself, out of a woman’s flesh and blood, a perfect human nature, begotten by the Holy Ghost, and by thus uniting it with his own divinity in one person, not only sustains the humanity under all the suffering of imputed guilt, but presents a surety of infinitely sufficient worth to represent all the redeemed. Therefore, was “laid upon him the iniquity of us all;” therefore, did it please the Father to bruise him, and put him to grief; therefore, did he forever “put away sin by the one sacrifice of himself,” and by that “one offering perfect forever them that are sanctified.” Our sufferings on account of sin would have been everlasting, because no sufferings of ours could ever have satisfied the penalty due to the sinner; but such is the incalculable merit of our Surety’s sufferings for us, that in a portion of three days, the law was fully vindicated, and the whole Church absolved. Adam was made in the likeness of God, so far as a creature could reflect the likeness of the Creator, yet was he sustained only by a creature’s strength, and he fell; but in our Second Adam dwelt “the Lord from heaven,” the Son of God himself; the first Adam was made “a living soul;” the Second Adam is a quickening Spirit, for in him is not only a life derived, but he is the Life-giver. Therefore did he, “through death, destroy him that hath the power of death,” and become the Author of eternal salvation unto all them that obey him.”
- Our Mediator must also be “very God in one person with his human nature,” that “he might obtain for and restore to us righteousness and life.”
Here are two offices of the Mediator for which his Divinity is necessary:—
The obtaining for us righteousness and life; and the restoring of righteousness and life to us.
A. The obtaining for us righteousness and life.
It is the part of the Mediator to act for us with God, and, therefore, is it requisite not only that a sufficient satisfaction be made to the law under which we are condemned, but that such satisfaction be duly presented and pleaded before God; and our justification, with its consequence, our readmission to the divine favor, acknowledged and secured. This justification and divine favor are meant by the terms “righteousness and life,” used by the Catechism; for, according to the method of grace, the sinner who believes is not personally, that is, through his own merit, righteous, but considered and treated as righteous or justified solely on account of the satisfaction rendered to the law for him by his substitute; and the favor of God, which is life, goes out to him again only through his substitute, with whom, as the atoning representative of the sinner, God is well pleased. Is it not, then, clear that only he, who could make the satisfaction, can plead its merit before God and claim its reward? Who less than divine can thus speak with God? Who less than divine can take into his grasp such great blessing as life for all the host of the redeemed? If nothing less than divine strength could sustain the humanity of our surety under the wrath due to his people, an equal capacity is needed to contain the immensity of favor vouchsafed by the love of the reconciled Father to all his ransomed family. So reasons the Apostle of our glorious Mediator: “For it pleased the Father that in him should all fulness dwell; and having made peace through the blood of his cross, by him to reconcile all things unto himself;” and again: “For in him dwelleth all the fulness of the Godhead bodily. And ye (all believers) are complete in him, which is the head of all principality and power.” And in the same strain, John the Baptist testified of our Lord: “Of his fulness have all we received and grace for grace.” All the grace we need we receive of Christ; therefore all fulness dwells in Christ, and that he might contain all this fulness, in him dwells the fulness of the Godhead. It was necessary that the divine nature should sustain the humanity of the substitute, in the work of atonement; so it is necessary that after the merit of the work is provided, the divine nature should qualify the Mediator to obtain and receive by his intercession eternal redemption for us.
B. The restoring of righteousness and life to us.
It is the part of the Mediator to act for God with us; therefore is it requisite that not only the justification of the sinner, and the consequent life be obtained for us, but, also, that those benefits be actually conferred, and we restored to the enjoyment of all we have lost through sin. Who less than God can accomplish this in us? Who can justify where God has condemned, but God himself? Who can give life back, but the Lord of life? Who less than God can visit the hearts of all the Church, and by the Holy Spirit incline them all to receive by faith the pardon God extends, and strengthen them all for the new obedience which God requires? If our Mediator be not divine, how can he be omnipresent to hear every prayer of each one of all his people; omniscient, to know their every thought and every need; omnipotent, to sustain them all against every temptation, under every duty, amidst sorrows innumerable, and throughout time to a glorious eternity? God adopts the penitents, but it is Christ who “gives power to as many as believe,” to become the sons of God;” God strengthens them with all might, but it is through Christ strengthening him that the believer can do all things; God assures comfort, but the comfort reaches us only through him, who, having been the man of sorrows, is now the Lord of joy; God has prepared unspeakable glories for them that love him, and they are kept by his power unto salvation; but Christ who is the Author, is also the Finisher of their faith, and when they enter the full blessedness of heaven, it is into the joy of their Lord. Christ is the beginning, Christ the continuance, Christ the end; Christ first, Christ always, Christ last, Christ all in all. He is the Way, and the Truth, and the Life; no man cometh unto the Father but by him. Who but the Son of God, can lie in the bosom of God? From that bosom he came to be our Surety in human flesh; to that bosom he has returned, but with our flesh about him, to be our ever prevalent Advocate, and the accomplisher of our redemption; for where he is glorified, our humanity is glorified; and where the Son of God dwells, there dwells his body the Church, the fulness of him that filleth all in all.