Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture XXXIX. The Power of the Keys

Thirty-first Lord’s Day

A suspicion has arisen, it is likely, in the minds of some of you who have pursued with us the study of our Catechism, that there are at least a few things treated of with too great particularity, since they are now fairly understood, and the true doctrine concerning them believed by the great body of evangelical Christians. It should, however, be remembered that the Catechism was written but a short time after our Reformed churches had come out from the idolatrous church (so called) of Rome, and that many of the anti-scriptural dogmas and pretensions of Popery and its ministers retained not a little power over the common mind, accustomed to an entire and unquestioning subjection for many centuries; and this especially, as they were proclaimed and insisted on by the advocates of Rome with all the art and ardor and strength of men skilled in argument and fond of rule, who felt that they were in great danger of losing their authority and its emoluments forever. Doctrines and practices, upon which a well-taught child in a pious family or Sunday-school can now pronounce correctly, were then subjects of angry and protracted dispute between learned and eminent men in halls of universities, and in councils summoned by princely and imperial command; and how partially truth prevailed over error, is shown by the fact that the greater part of Europe fell back from the alarm of controversy to a more servile awe of the monstrous superstition than before. At this hour the adherents to these destructive errors considerably outnumber all others who profess themselves Christians; and as some think sacred prophecy warns us of a desperate attempt again to subjugate the world by the iron yoke of their intolerant supremacy, it is, therefore, not wise for us so to overlook the falsity of such pretensions as to remain ignorant of the scriptural arguments by which they may be refuted, and our Protestant faith intelligently confirmed. These remarks are particularly applicable to the subject of our lesson for to-day.

A key being the instrument by which a door is opened or shut, he who has the key has the power of admitting or excluding. Hence, it is very naturally used as a figure to signify the prerogative of conferring or withholding privileges, as in a state or society. Of this we have a notable, though not solitary, example in Scripture, where our Lord says to the apostle Peter, after his memorable confession, “Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church; and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. And I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven” (Matt. xvi. 18, 19). It is upon this text, as you know, that the Papists ground their claim for the supreme and infallible dominion of the Pope, as the alleged successor of St. Peter in things spiritual, and, in truth, things temporal so far as they can be made contingent upon the interest of the church over which he presides. Peter, say they, was the rock on which Christ founded the true church. Peter was bishop of Rome; therefore each successive bishop of Rome derives the same fundamental relation to the church, and no one who does not so rest his faith on the authority of Christ so delegated to the Pope is a member of the true church. In like manner they argue, that, as our Lord gave to Peter the authority to admit into his kingdom, which is his church, and to exclude or expel from it, promising to ratify in heaven what the apostle did on earth, binding what he bound, and loosening what he loosed (that is, condemning for sin or absolving from sin), so the bishop of Rome, or Pope, being the successor of Peter, is the vicegerent of Christ on earth, whose sentences of absolution or condemnation, finally pronounced, have infallible authority in heaven. Now, if we allow their view of the text cited, their inference must be allowed, and we cannot, without fatal disloyalty to Christ, refuse entire subjection to the Pope.

But let us sift this interpretation and argument of theirs. In the first place, it is far from certain, nay, very improbable, that the apostle Peter was ever bishop of Rome. It is even doubted by many learned investigators that he ever was at Rome at all. The traces of his special presidency over the particular church of Rome, if there be any, are exceedingly obscure; whereas, if such stupendous interests depend on the alleged fact, it is fair to believe that God would have put it beyond doubt. Certainly, there is no allusion to anything of the kind in the Scriptures; on the contrary, the care of the church of Rome was presidentially assigned rather to the apostle Paul, as appears from his epistle to that church and his residence there after his appeal to Cæsar. Paul, also, declares that the gospel of circumcision was unto Peter, which implies that his mission was especially to the Jews, while the apostleship of the uncircumcision was committed to himself, that he should go unto the Gentiles (Gal. ii. 7–10), for which reason Paul, in the eleventh chapter of his Epistle to the Romans, says: “I speak unto you, Gentiles, inasmuch as I am the apostle of the Gentiles, I magnify mine office;” from which it would appear that any pretension of Peter to special authority over the Gentile church of Rome was an intrusion within the sphere appointed to the apostle Paul.

But we go farther, and assert, on a collation of scriptural passages, that, so far from any primacy in the apostleship having been assigned to Peter, whatever prerogatives were given him were given to all the apostles in common. Thus, was Peter a rock on which Christ built his church? So were all, for Paul says (Ephes. ii. 20), that the church was built on “the foundation of the prophets and apostles,” “Jesus Christ himself” alone having a far excelling distinction as “the chief corner-stone”; and the apostle John, in the Revelation, describing the church as a city, says that the wall of it “had twelve foundations, and in them the names of the twelve apostles were written” (xxi. 14). Besides, the office of the apostles as the foundation, with the prophets, lay in their inspired testimony of the truth concerning Christ, and therefore ceased when their testimony ceased, so that in this respect the apostles had not, and could not have had, any successor at Rome, or anywhere. If Peter was sent of Christ with power of the keys, that is, to retain or remit sins, so were they all, for our Lord after his resurrection said to them: “As my Father hath sent me, even so send I you. And when he had said this, he breathed on them, and saith unto them, Receive ye the Holy Ghost: whosesoever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whosesoever sins ye retain, they are retained” (John xx. 21–23). Thomas, it may be observed, was not then present; but as he was afterwards with the other ten when they received the final and general commission of apostleship, we need not doubt of his having had the same authority as the rest. Nay, Paul was himself the first protestant against the primacy of Peter, when, asserting his prerogative to rule the Corinthian church, he says: “I suppose [or, I reason] I was not a whit behind the very chiefest apostles” (2 Cor. xi. 5); and on one critical occasion he “withstood Peter to the face, because he was to be blamed” (Gal. ii. 11). So shall we withstand any pretended successor of Peter, if he teach any other gospel than that which Paul, our apostle, taught. Peter had this precedency, and no more, that his preaching at the Pentecost was instrumental in adding the first converts from Judaism, and afterwards completing the organization of the Christian church by the addition of the Gentile elements, necessary to “the one new man” in Christ (Gal. ii. 11–16), when he baptized Cornelius (Acts x. xi. 18).

But, as we have hinted before, the apostles had no successors in the full degree of apostleship, nor can the words of the text under consideration be applied in anything like their full sense to any one after them in the church. Our Lord sent his apostles forth as he had been sent by his Father, which was with power on earth to forgive sins, and with extraordinary gifts of the Holy Ghost, including power to confer the grace of the Holy Ghost upon others. This commission to them was indicated and attested, as his commission from the Father, by the power of working miracles. Where this seal and evidence is wanting, it is clear that the full commission has not been transmitted by any succession. But as no pope or bishop or priest has this miraculous energy, none of them are fully successors of the apostles. It follows that our Lord’s address to Peter, or his subsequent commission to them all, embraced some powers not transmissible, for the exercise of which they were peculiarly fitted. Now, as they were appointed to lay the foundation of the church on the chief corner-stone, Christ Jesus, and they were governed from within by a peculiar degree of the Holy Ghost, they may very well be supposed to judge infallibly, when necessary, of what was in men, so as to make no error in admitting them to the church or excluding them from it, and in pronouncing, as our Lord did infallibly, the remission or retention of sins. Therefore it was literally true that whatever they, when exercising their apostolical authority, bound on earth, or loosed on earth, would be bound or loosed in heaven. Christ on his throne would certainly ratify what his Spirit in the apostles did on earth. But the same confirmation cannot be presumed of any uninspired men, claiming to be their successors. Any such claim for them is a blasphemous assumption of Christ’s discernment and authority. Hence the assumptions of the Pope to open and shut heaven, and to forgive or retain the guilt of sin, is worse than vanity and arrogance.

But a very urgent question here arises, which our church, professing to declare by the Catechism the full doctrine of Christ, is not at liberty to shun. Was Christian government and, especially, discipline, so restrained in the hands of the apostles, that, after their divinely directed office ceased on earth, it ceased to exist; or, if it continued, to whom was it committed? Volumes of dispute have been written in all ages of the church on these points, and with every variety of opinion; but all the inquiries properly refer for consideration in the premises to that striking passage in Matthew, (xviii. 15–20,) where our Lord, speaking of quarrels between brethren, and having enjoined first private and gentle methods of attempting reconciliation, adds: “Tell it unto the church, and if he (the other party in the case) neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee a heathen man and a publican. Verily I say unto you, whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven [the identical words, with the exception that the singular pronoun is changed to the plural, showing that the promise to Peter was not exclusive]. Again I say unto you, that if any two of you shall agree on earth as touching anything that they shall ask, it shall be done for them of my Father which is in heaven. For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them.” These two verses (19, 20) are evidently parts of the paragraph relating to discipline, and are to be considered in its exposition. We have here, then, three things to settle: First, To whom were these words addressed? Secondly, What is meant by the church? Thirdly, To what extent and in what manner (if any) are these promises applicable beyond the apostles?

As to the address, it will be seen on reference to the chapter that our Lord was speaking to his disciples, or his future apostles (compare Mark ix. 33; Luke ix. 46; xxii. 24–30; John xiii. 12–17), who were under the prejudice of Jewish notions concerning Messiah’s kingdom. The commands and the promises, therefore, were primarily to the inspired apostles; and upon this Paul acted in a case of discipline at Corinth (1 Cor. v. 1–5), where, though evidently claiming his apostolical authority, he yet directs the church to proceed to condemnation in his absence, he confirming their decision beforehand: “For I verily, as absent in body, but present in spirit, have judged already, as though I were present, concerning him that hath so done this deed; In the name of our Lord Jesus Christ when ye are gathered together, and my spirit, with the power of our Lord Jesus Christ,1 to deliver such a one unto Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus.” But though the address was primarily to the inspired apostles, we may believe, and in this all parties are agreed, that our Lord, in giving these directions to them as the founders of his church, intended to mark out the principles of action for the church in all ages; which view is strengthened by the fact of the apostle Paul’s association with himself of the church of Corinth in the case cited, as also by the address of the same apostle to the elders of Ephesus (Acts xx. 28), and of the apostle Peter to the elders generally, in both of which they are expected to take faithful care of the church, the oversight (undoubtedly including discipline) of which was committed unto them by the Holy Ghost.

What then is meant by “the church”? Church is a Greek term, and therefore had not been used by the Jews in their polity; and though under the inspiration of the Holy Ghost it was afterwards given to the flock of Christ, the Christian church was not formally established until after the descent of the Holy Ghost, the Jewish economy being still in force. Under that system we know that ultimate discipline of offenders was in the hands of the assembly of elders, or Sanhedrim, as they called it. Did our Lord refer his immediate disciples to that tribunal? The supposition is not monstrous, since he himself submitted to trial by the Sanhedrim, and protested only against the flagrant illegality of their proceedings. Or did he refer in advance to the future church, in language not understood by the disciples at the time, but which would be understood by that church for whose benefit in all ages his sacred words are recorded? This opinion seems not unreasonable, as our Lord shows a similar anticipation of phraseology when he exhorts his disciples, before they knew that he was to be crucified, to “take up their cross and follow him”; for although that expression probably was in proverbial use among the Jews, it had undoubtedly in our Lord’s mind a force which the whole church has subsequently given it, as sympathy with his death on the cross. We, therefore, hold that the counsel given to tell matters of dispute between Christian brethren, or of offence against the morals of our holy profession, should, when more gentle methods of composition fail, be told to the church, and submitted to them for decision;—not necessarily the whole church, or the whole of a particular church, (for we know that some, and, ordinarily, the larger portion of a church, are forbidden to speak in the church, and so have no voice in the church court,) but, as the Jewish church was represented by the court of elders, and as elders to “rule over” were appointed in the apostolical churches, this function of oversight, or government, may be very well committed to their hands, by which much confusion and unnecessary scandal are avoided; and, therefore, such a system of government and discipline, by a body of elders elected by the members of each church, has been adopted, and prevails in all our Reformed churches.

These points being settled, our third question recurs: To what extent and in what manner are the promises, primarily directed to the inspired apostles, applicable to the church, since their day, in its exercise of discipline? It is obvious that there must be some restraint of them, if not modification. For the apostles, when under plenary inspiration as the appointed and miraculously accredited ministers of Christ in the absolute government of the church, had such divine discernment and impartiality that their judgment was infallible; and, therefore, Christ certainly confirmed in heaven what they, by his authority and under his guidance, ordered on earth. But, though the grace of the Holy Ghost has been promised, and has been, as it will be, given to all Christians, and Christ has promised to be “in the midst of them,” especially when met together in his name, such inspiration is not plenary, or such guidance thorough, as in the case of the apostles. On the contrary, every Christian knows that, from the weakness of his understanding and heart, and the temptations of the world, the flesh, and the devil, he is constantly prone to error, misjudgment, and uncharitableness; nay, that the Holy Ghost does not preserve him from such ignorance and sin, except so far as he purifies his heart and, using all the means of grace, acts in the spirit of Christ, according to the word of Christ, and singly for the glory of Christ. This must also be true of the church or eldership of the church when administering Christian discipline. Christ will confirm in heaven whatever they do in accordance with his word and Spirit; but it is preposterous to say that he will confirm the erroneous or illegal acts of his servants, though they profess to act in his name. There must be, if I may be allowed the technicality, appeal from the fallible court below to the infallible judge on the throne of heaven. Yet, until that appeal be tried and pronounced upon, it becomes all good Christians to bow before the tribunal constituted by Christ on earth. So far, then, as Christian discipline is administered according to the law of Christ, by the church on earth, it will be confirmed by Christ, the only head of the church, in heaven.

We should here add, by way of cautionary inference, that such prerogative of ministerial judgment, having been committed to the church, as the kingdom of Christ which is not of this world, the jurisdiction of the church is positively restricted to matters purely spiritual, all others being left to extra-ecclesiastical authorities, or what the apostle terms “the powers that be.” Our Lord, it will be remembered, refused to settle a matter of inheritance, saying, “Who made me a judge or divider over you?” And when asked to decide a political question, refused to answer farther than to say, “Render unto Cæsar the things which are Cæsar’s, and unto God the things that are God’s”; while on another occasion, though privately protesting the right of “the children” to be “free,” he wrought a miracle to procure means for the payment of tribute to the foreign oppressor who, in divine providence, held rule over his country. It is, therefore, clearly against the example of our divine head to bring questions of property or temporal politics into church courts. They have no right to adjudicate them.

So, also, Christians, in their private capacity, or otherwise than for the administration of Christian discipline, are debarred from the exercise of open censure or personal condemnation of their brethren, and are liable in attempting such annoyance to condemnation themselves by him who has said, “Judge not, that ye be not judged.”

But it equally follows that the prerogative of judgment in religious matters belongs to the church alone, and that neither the civil power nor any body of men (not a church) have anything to do with such matters; and if any such presume to take them into their hands, they are guilty of profanely obtruding themselves on the kingdom of Christ. No greater mischiefs have happened to church and to state than have arisen from such unchristian and wicked confusion of things spiritual with things temporal,—things ecclesiastical with things political. In this country, for the first time since history began its records, the providence of God has ordered that constitutional law should unite with the word of God in severing the religion of Christ from the civil government; and it behooves all true disciples of Christ to be very careful how, on their part, they do not transcend their sphere, lest, as will inevitably be the case, they provoke the world to interfere with the rights of the church.

We can now see how and why the section for the present Lord’s Day was introduced by the authors of the Catechism, especially as they were so rudely pressed at the time by the advocates of Popery. The Pope, as the successor of St. Peter, claimed supreme and sole dominion over the church, and bore embroidered on his vestments two keys, as the badge of his power. Where, asked the Papists of the Protestants, is the right of ecclesiastical government? Who has the mystical keys which open and shut the kingdom of heaven? To this the Reformers replied, as in the answers before us: That the right of government was in the church, constituted and governed according to the word of Christ; and that the two keys were also in the hands of the church: the one, the preaching of the gospel, by which those who believe are made heirs of heaven, and those who refuse to believe are forever excluded from its glorious blessedness; the other, Christian discipline, which, in excommunicating the gross sinner from the church on earth and in restoring the penitent, if administered according to the word and spirit of Christ, must be according to the will of Christ in heaven. The language and reasoning of the whole section are so very plain that we may leave them without farther comment.

  1. How infinitely important it is that the gospel be preached faithfully, purely, and fully! It is the voice of the great God and our Saviour Jesus Christ, declaring unto sinful men the principles on which the Judge of all will determine our eternal state. Those who come within the sound of the preacher, have a right to hear the gospel as God has sent it; because their eternal salvation or damnation depends on the manner in which they regard the revelation of mercy. If the preacher be faithful in delivering the message, as an ambassador for Christ, he is free from the blood of all men; if he be faithless, the blood of his hearers’ souls, dying impenitent, God will require at his hands. This thought, but for the assurance of God’s grace, would have overwhelmed the apostle Paul; how should it make his uninspired successors humble, reverent, and zealous! Hear what he says: “For we are unto God a sweet savor of Christ, in them that are saved, and in them that perish; to the one we are the savor of death unto death, and to the other the savor of life unto life. And who is sufficient for these things? For we are not as many, which corrupt the word of God; but as of sincerity, but as of God, in the sight of God speak we in Christ.”

How vast is the responsibility of those who hear the gospel so proclaimed! Upon their treatment of the word hangs their everlasting condition. Every time the gospel is preached, the gate of heaven is flung open and they are invited to enter; every time they turn away unbelieving, the gate of heaven is shut against them. Dear friends, “take heed how you hear.”

  1. How important that Christian discipline be faithfully and religiously maintained! The officers of the church are charged to vindicate the character of the Christian name before the world. They are, therefore, bound to disown those whose lives are in open contradiction to the law of God. The duty is difficult, much more so than people are apt to think. The rule of Christ requires at least two witnesses; and as church courts have not the power to compel the attendance of witnesses, trial is often impossible even where the scandal is more than suspected. But so far as in them lies, they are bound in fidelity to Christ, to the offender, and to the world, for an unshrinking, impartial, and merciful discharge of their sacred function.

And all of us should regard such an oversight by the church authority as a blessing, cheerfully yielding ourselves to faithful admonition, and submitting ourselves to the decision of those who are set over us in the Lord, by the paternal love of God and the grace of Christ. Amen.

1 It may be questioned whether the phrase “with the power of our Lord Jesus Christ” refers to the whole assembly, or to the spirit of the apostle. I incline to the latter opinion.