Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture XVIII. Christ’s Death and Burial

Sixteenth Lord’s Day

Our lesson for the last Lord’s Day led us to consider carefully, and, as we trust, not without profit, the sufferings of our Lord, especially his condemnation under Pontius Pilate, and his bitter anguish on the cross. To-day we are called to behold the great Sufferer dead, and not only dead, but buried.

The doctrine of his death could not be separated from an understanding of his crucifixion, which was the mode of it, and, indeed, has been fundamental to all that we have hitherto been taught respecting the way of salvation; therefore, the Catechism simply reiterates the main truth under the 40th Question. With like brevity, the purpose of his burial is stated to be proof that his death was really accomplished (41st); and an inquiry as to the reason why we must die, notwithstanding his dying for us, is met by showing what the death of the Christian has become, through the propitiation of Christ (42d). Then follows a recital of some further benefits, or, rather, of some not as particularly dwelt upon before, derived from the cross (43d); after which is set forth the fulness of comfort to be found in the fact asserted of our Lord by the Creed, that he descended into hell.

There are so many interesting questions connected with the last point, that it requires a separate discourse; and we shall postpone its formal treatment, using it, however, as far as needed in our present study. The other matter of the lesson may be conveniently arranged under three heads:—

First: The necessity for our Lord’s humiliation even unto death.

Secondly: His burial, and the reasons for it.

Thirdly: The benefits which we receive from his death and burial.

First: The necessity for our Lord’s humiliation even unto death.

The infinite merit of our Lord’s vicarious sufferings having been already shown, the question now is: Why was it requisite that he should actually die? Were not those sorrows of his that wrung his heart all his life long, his terrible agony in the garden, his anguish of both body and soul on the cross, enough to testify the divine wrath against us without this extreme humiliation? If Enoch and Elijah were taken into heaven without having passed through the mortal agony, why might not the Father have assumed his well-beloved Son to his glory from the cross, in the sight of his enemies, as he did afterward from Bethany, from the midst of his adoring disciples? Would not the arrest of his passion by such majesty have vindicated the excellence of his atonement more than even his resurrection after the disgraces of the tomb? My brethren, if such thoughts arise in our minds, it is because we forget the penalty which the Mediator undertook to pay on behalf of his people. The sentence was explicit: “The soul that sinneth, it shall die;” “Without the shedding of blood, there is no remission.” The life of the sinner was forfeited; and, therefore, the life of the substitute was required. He had covenanted to die that they might live. We must believe that nothing less, nothing short of this, could have answered the broken, dishonored law. All the sacrifices in which the victims were slain outright, all the prophecies which declared that he should pour out his soul unto death, all his own testimonies respecting the decease which he should accomplish at Jerusalem, all the subsequent teachings of his apostles, show that his obedience was not complete until death, nor his expiation but in death. All his antecedent sorrows and pains and tortures were but precursors of his death: death was in them all, but not complete until, as in our death, his spirit was separated from his body, leaving the clay lifeless, and prone to mingle with the dust out of which it was taken. It was no seeming death, no deep trance nor syncope simulating death, from which he recovered on the third day; but an entire dissolution, so that he ceased to live until at his resurrection he began to live again. “Father,” said he, in the midst of the great darkness, as the vail of the temple was rent in twain, “into thy hands I commend my spirit! and, having said thus, he gave up the ghost,” or, as it is in the Greek, he expired: the breath went utterly out of his torn, exhausted frame; his body yet hung on the cruel nails, but his anguish was over; his blessed heart was still, his holy head drooped, his gentle eyes were closed; he had lived our life to its last pang; his soul had gone up to his Father; and Jesus of Nazareth was dead.

The death-sentence passed upon man included far more than the mere mortality of the body: death was a name for the wrath of God upon body and soul; wrath eternal, because never could man have suffered sufficiently to expiate his sin, and, without the renewing grace of God, he would be continually incurring fresh condemnation by fresh offence: so that death implies all the torments of hell, as well as the penal effects of sin in this world; but the death which is the end of our course here, was a component, essential part of the death-punishment, besides being a most striking emblem and foreshadowing of the wrath which follows it. Our blessed Lord did suffer the wrath of God in his spirit, as well as his body: the very wrath which makes the hell of the wicked. “The sorrows of death compassed” him; “the pains of hell gat hold upon” him; or, as the Catechism says (44th), he was in inexpressible anguish, pains, and hellish agonies, during all his sufferings, but especially on the cross: as far as a pure, sinless spirit can suffer hell, he suffered it; but, so completely did he expiate our guilt, so fully satisfy divine justice, so utterly exhaust death by his sufferings, that he needed not to pass, after the article of dissolution, into the torments which await the wicked beyond this life. As he bowed his head and gave up the ghost, he said: “It is finished!” because, in that last submission, he bore the last pang of the curse, he drank the last drop in the cup of wrath, he felt the last stroke of the avenger, and the Father, in receiving his soul, accepted his atonement. Then was it apparent to the universe of observing intelligence that he died for us, as at his resurrection it was apparent that his death was infinitely sufficient for our eternal life. Hence we, after the example of Scripture, testify our belief in the redemption, by our confession of Christ’s death, and, obeying his own command, celebrate his death by a sacrament which symbolizes the breaking of his body and the shedding of his blood.

O beloved Christians, what strength and sweetness there is in this article of our faith! If Christ walked never so closely with us during all our previous temptations and sorrows, but turned away when the last enemy approached, shaking his fearful dart, how should we shrink back in terror, and cry, in his own “exceeding bitter cry,” “My God, why hast thou forsaken me?” But now that we have seen him dead, we know that he will not leave nor forsake us, but will be our guide even unto death; we mark the prints of his bleeding feet down every step into the valley dark as darkness itself, and know that he will go with us through the mystery. Then we fear no evil, because his rod and his staff shall comfort us.

Secondly: His burial, and the reasons for it.

41st. Why was he also buried?

Ans. Thereby to prove that he was really dead.

  1. This is a very important reason; for, on the reality of his death depends the perfection of his sacrifice, and the fact of his resurrection; and, consequently, the truth of all Christianity. It was at the third hour (nine o’clock in the morning) that our Lord was fixed on the cross, and about the ninth hour (three o’clock in the afternoon) that he expired. Many lived on the cross for days before they died; and it would seem that both the malefactors executed with him were alive toward the close of the day, for the soldiers brake their legs to kill them outright; but in six hours his sufferings were over, his spiritual agonies hastening the catastrophe. The next day was a Sabbath, a high solemnity,—one of the three Sabbaths of holy convocation, and immediately previous to the wave-offering (Lev. xxiii. 10, 11); so that the Jews, whose law forbade them to let any one remain on a tree over any sunset, were specially anxious that this notable Sabbath should not be defiled, and besought Pilate that an immediate end should be put to the sufferers. Strange bigotry, that could tolerate such malignant injustice as the crucifixion of an innocent one like Jesus, yet stickle at a form! Yet such is formality in religion: its scrupulosity in outward rules survives the spirit of piety. Pilate, easy to comply when it cost him nothing, commands the soldiers, not without witnesses from among the Jews, to fulfil their wish: but Jesus is so manifestly dead, that neither soldiers nor Jews doubt it; yet, to make all sure for us as well as for them, one of the Romans thrusts a spear into his side. The spear reaches his heart, or, at the least, gives a mortal wound; for out of the fissure flows not only “blood,” but what the evangelist calls “water,” or the serous fluid found within the sac encasing the heart (pericardium); though it is possible that it was from the effusion which great agony often sends into the pleura: but, in either case, the proof is clear that death had actually occurred. If there had been the slightest chance for denial, the Jews, after the resurrection of our Lord, would not have spared it; but, though they bribed the soldiers to say that his disciples had stolen his body in the night, they did not pretend to say he had not been really dead.

Had not divine Providence prevented it, the sacred body would have been roughly buried in the place appointed for executed malefactors, near the scene of the crucifixion; but, now that he had “poured out his soul unto death,” he is spared from farther indignities. Joseph of Arimathea, of whom we know little more than that he was “a rich man,” a Pharisee, “an honorable counsellor, which also waited for the kingdom of God,” “a good man and a just,” who “had not consented” to the decree against Christ, but was “his disciple, though secretly, for fear of the Jews,”—remorseful at having forsaken his Master, and impressed by the awful miracles attending his death, now goes “boldly” to Pilate and asks “that he might take away the body of Jesus;” and Pilate, willing to please a man of his rank, and all the while persuaded that our Lord had suffered unjustly, gives him leave. Joseph had a new tomb prepared for himself, hewn, as was the custom of the rich Jews, out of a rock in the midst of a garden; and there he determined to lay the precious remains. But Nicodemus, his brother counsellor, and like him in concealed discipleship (for it was the same that came to Jesus by night), now claims a part in the sad offices. The Jews, who abhorred burning, and the disembowelling necessary for the embalmment common among Eastern people, or any other mode of treating the bodies of their dead than burial,—yet craved the solace of fragrant obsequies, and were accustomed to wrap them with fine linen in spices, which were sometimes burned in great quantities. So, as Joseph had the honor of giving the tomb, Nicodemus brings the perfumes, not less than a hundred-pound weight of myrrh and aloes,—a costly, even magnificent provision,—such as would have been made for a person of highest rank; and together, the true-hearted Marys standing by if not assisting them, they wind the body in linen cloths with the spices, hoping to do it farther honor when the Sabbath had passed by. So they laid him in the rocky tomb, causing its door to be closed by a great stone rolled into its mouth; and there in a garden the second Adam rested in death, as in a garden death had come upon the first. But the wretched, persecuting Sanhedrim, though they could not oppose Pilate in his grant of Joseph’s request, are not satisfied; and the next day demand of the Procurator that the sepulchre should be made sure until the third day, lest his disciples might come and steal the body, and so claim that Christ’s own prophecy of rising on the third day was fulfilled. Pilate, out of patience with their wicked pertinacity, tells them to use their own watch-guard, which was a body of sixty soldiers assigned to guard the temple, and make as sure as they can. They, therefore, seal the stone, so that any movement of it might be detected, and set sentinels to prevent any entrance. It is not necessary to believe as some do (Theophylact and others) that the whole of the temple guard were put to the service; but the Jews had it in their power to employ all that was sufficient, and doubtless did. How did God, through their own act and intention to frustrate the truth of Jesus, thus provide for their discomfiture and our assurance!

The death of the Saviour is even yet more certain. How could he, even if his wounds were not mortal, have survived the enrolment of his head and person so closely?—or his confinement within the rock-bound cell whose entrance was so entirely sealed? Or how could his terror-stricken friends, against all these precautions, have abstracted the mangled body, and restored him to the full, vigorous life in which he appeared on the day of his resurrection?

  1. Neither, without his burial, would all the prophecies respecting his work for us have been fulfilled. Until then, though he had had his place with the wicked, he had rest with the rich in his death;1 neither was there opportunity for the Father to ransom his chosen from the power of the grave, and over the grave give him the victory. These prophecies are, however, so connected with what has been already said, and will be said hereafter, that we may refrain from farther reference to them now.

  2. But what comfort and hope is offered to our hearts as we linger with the weeping women before the door of the Saviour’s tomb! We need not be pilgrims to the Holy Land for this; our faith in the blessed Evangelists brings us to the scene. How calmly, how quietly, he rests within! They have done unto him whatsoever they listed, but they cannot reach him now with their savage cries, and brutal insults, and merciless tortures. They have driven him out of the world which he made for them, so fair and beautiful; out of his own Jerusalem, which he had loved so well, and wept over with so fond a pity; out of the mortal life which he had made so lovely by his innocence, and so beneficent by his miracles, and so eloquent of truth by his teachings, and so full of promise to the sorrowful by his tears, and to the penitent by his prayers. Oh, what a darkness was that when the sun hid his face from the murder of the Holy One, and the convulsed earth quaked in sympathy with her Maker! What a night was that when the stars looked down on the world, whose Saviour and Lord lay dead and buried. Think of the poor disciples, shrunk into hiding-places like timorous sheep whose shepherd is slain, and of the broken-hearted women, loving without hope, but faithful in their despair! Yet the sufferer is at rest. He sleeps. His labors are done, his pains are past, his enemies have accomplished their worst; his last cry was the escape of his spirit, and his dear, holy, mangled flesh awaits in peace a speedy awakening far beyond sorrow and ignominy, within the glory of his better world, where all the heavenly host will acclaim him an infinite homage, because the signatures of the cross attest him the Lamb that was slain. Odors, fragrant and rich, fill the air, as the spices breathe their honors around him, and the flowers of the garden are redolent through the dews. All is as sweet as it is calm. O faithful Master, thanks be to thee, that thou didst not refuse to lie down in the grave! The grave is gloomy and cold and sad,—the disgrace of our humanity, the hiding-place of our shame. Disguise it as we may, with marbles and epitaphs, and graceful trees, and summer-blooms, and evergreens, till it looks like a palace-garden, it is yet the place of silence, darkness, and corruption; nature revolts from the thought, nor can philosophy cure us of the shudder, for reason justifies it:—

“To lie in cold obstruction and to rot,
This sensible, warm motion to become
A kneaded clod— . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . ’t is too horrible!”

But oh, how sad it is when we are forced to carry there and put deep within its shades, away from our touch, and sight, and care, the dear forms in which the beloved of our hearts,—the good, the kind, the true, have lived but live no longer; the pleasant faces through which their souls shone on us, the bosoms that yearned for us, the hands that ministered to our comfort, the limbs active in serving our faintest wish,—to lie out amidst loathsome damps, under the beatings of the storm, and the winter’s snows, because they are dust and to dust they must return! Yet, how changed is the sepulchre since we have followed in his funeral, and seen the place where the Lord lay! He is not there now,—he is risen; but he has been there; the fragrance yet fills the tomb; the garden still blossoms around it: as, in the beginning, he, by his own rest, made the Sabbath a rest for our souls, so has he, by his own burial, made the grave a rest for the bodies of his people. There the wicked cease from troubling them; there they have a refuge from temptation, from tears and sin; there the High Priest of our profession has set a company of the guard from the heavenly temple to watch their sleeping dust—his own seal is on the door—and in his own time, when all the mortality, and dishonor, and corruption, and weakness, have crumbled away, will he roll back the stone from its mouth, and they shall come forth immortal, glorious, incorruptible, and full of power, to enter upon the kingdom where he is now gone to prepare places for them. Oh! now we know what our church means when it bids us say that, though Christ has died for our sins, we must also die. Death and the grave are no longer the penalty and the disgrace of our nature. Christ hath taken out the sting from death, the victory he has wrested from the grave; and now death to all who believe is the abolishing of sin, the grave a passage to eternal life. The pious dead are not lost: they only sleep in Jesus,—a blessed sleep from which he is coming to awake them. He has taken up their spirits now to the Father who took up his; and he will once more descend in the latter day to the earth, that he may restore their full humanity to paradise,—far more lovely than that the tempter entered, where no enemy nor ill can reach them forever. O spirit of the Holy One, who didst anoint Christ with grace for his death and burial, prepare us for ours, that we may follow him with the countless train of those who, through faith and patience, inherit the promises! Then shall death be to us a gain unspeakable, and the grave a welcome rest. We need rest, O Lord, for we are often weary; and, if it please thee, we would not bear our burden long.

“We would not live alway, thus fettered by sin,
Temptation without, and corruption within;
Where the rapture of pardon is mingled with fears,
And the cup of thanksgiving with penitent tears.

We would not live alway—no, welcome the tomb;
Since Jesus hath lain there we dread not its gloom;
There sweet be our rest, till he bid us arise,
To hail him in triumph descending the skies.”

But we had wellnigh anticipated what we proposed to treat of—

Thirdly: The benefits we receive from Christ’s death and burial.

The Catechism says “further benefits,” because it has already made us dwell largely on the benefits of Christ’s sacrifice; but we shall briefly recapitulate, and add to these stated in the present answer (43d), those given in the 44th, as taught in our Lord’s descent to hell.

  1. Christ as our infinite surety has borne the wrath of God for all who believe on his name. When the Father accepted the substitute, he did it under covenant to release those whom Jesus represented. He took the guilt of their sins from them in the very act by which he laid it on the sinless elder brother. So, when he paid the penalty, they paid it; when he was stricken of God it was with their stripes; when he was crucified they were crucified with him; when he died they died in him; when he was buried he sanctified the grave for them; and so, also, when the Father received his spirit, and raised him from the dead, in sure token that justice was satisfied and heaven opened for the atoner, the Father accepted them, adopted them as his sons and daughters, assured them of deliverance from eternal death, set open wide the gate of heaven for their spirits when they leave the body, and for their bodies after the purification of the grave which Christ has made fragrant with holy peace. How certain, then, is the salvation of the Christian, since justice and mercy with interlinking arms stand pleading for him before the throne on which the Lamb that was slain sits at the right hand of God!

  2. The sympathy of our Lord with his people is entire. “In that he himself hath suffered, being tempted, he is able to succor them that are tempted.” He has not only the power but the knowledge from experience to apply the power; and as, in the language of the New Testament, temptation and trial are synonymous, one word in the original representing both, his sympathizing grace covers all the experience of the Christian; for there is no form of trial through which the Christian can be made to pass that he did not pass through on his way to victory and rest.

All that we ordinarily call temptations,—the motives, arguments, and provocations to sin, to which we are exposed during our mortal life in this world, he knew; we have a notable example of this in the conflict he had with the devil immediately after his unction by the Holy Ghost. All that we ordinarily call trials,—our sicknesses, our pains, our persecutions, our wrongs from the false judgments, and slanders, and oppositions of men, our sorrows for those we love in their sicknesses, and deaths and burials,—we know that he knew from the record of the evangelical witnesses.

So far as his innocent spirit could feel the anguish and self-abhorrence and shame of sin, he knew what the penitent suffers when, under the thunderings of the law, he trembles and avows his guilt; for all his Israel’s sins were gathered around his soul, compassing his spirit about, hiding his Father’s face from him, causing him to shrink with horror from the vile contact, and pressing on his mediatorial conscience the fact that the punishment he bore was just. Nay, those very doubts which oftentimes assail the believer’s mind, causing him to shrink from duty, to fear the future set before him, and even to think that God has forsaken him, assaulted the humanity of Jesus. “Now,” saith he, at one time, “is my soul troubled, and what shall I say? Father, save me from this hour.” What else was that agony in the garden, when he prayed: “Father, if it be possible let this cup pass from me!” and “there appeared an angel unto him from heaven strengthening him?” And how else can we understand that bitter cry out of the thick darkness, “My God! my God! why hast thou forsaken me?” There could not be a single form of pain, or anguish of body or soul, that follows sin, of which the Redeemer, who took the cup filled with our deserts, did not taste; and this is what the Catechism declares when it says (44th), that “our Lord Jesus Christ, during all his sufferings, but especially on the cross, was plunged in inexpressible anguish, pains, terrors and hellish agonies,” that he might deliver us from the anguish and torments of hell.

Here then, believer,—tempted, afflicted, weak and trembling, is there full comfort for you. The Master knows your trials and your infirmity. Only imitate his steadfastness,—be faithful to him as he was to you; and he who received a gift of strength from on high to go through his passion, will send you strength according as your day.

  1. For there is here a promise of sanctification. He crucified our old nature when the body he took on him, out of the flesh and blood of the Virgin Mary, was crucified. There in his death, the tyrannous power of sin, by which the devil holds captive the impenitent, was broken from his people; and in his grave he finally buried the mortal flesh that he might raise it in newness of life, holy and eternal. Thus has he promised to quicken from their death in trespasses and sins, all who by faith are crucified with him, with him die, and with him are buried. As he was raised up to heaven, so shall they, even in this life, be raised up to sit with him in heavenly places: privileges so like heaven, that the apostle can give them no less an epithet than “heavenly.” Yet, this grace is only vouchsafed to those who, relying on the working of God in them, work out with fear and trembling their own salvation. But, believer, what a motive as well as encouragement is here? What so separates a man from the world as death and burial? Yet so, by our profession of representation in Christ, do we profess to have died with the world of sin, and to have put off our old man with its affections and lusts. We are not dead with him, if we be not buried with him. We have not been buried with him, if we be not risen with him. Our true life, our Christian life, now lies on the other side of the grave as to its affections and aims and delights. “If ye, then, be risen with Christ, seek those things which are above.” All our motives and rules must be brought by us from heaven, “into which the Forerunner has for us entered.” “Truly,” says an apostle, “our conversation is in heaven.” Yes, beloved brethren, this is the grace into which we profess to stand, who profess by our Lord Jesus to have received the atonement. We cannot go back to the world except we trample over the grace of Jesus, and reject the arguments of his cross.

O Son of the Highest, remember us on thy throne! Thou hast vanquished sin for us in the atonement of thy death; now vanquish sin in us by the intercession of thy life!

1 A grave was appointed for him with the wicked, but with the rich man was his tomb (high place).—Is. liii. 9.