Lecture XXXVIII. Against Transubstantiation
Thirtieth Lord’s Day
Having, in our expositions of the twenty-eighth and twenty-ninth Lord’s days, discussed at length the nature and purpose of the Lord’s supper, we need not now to dwell upon what is stated in the first part of the 80th Answer, but may give our whole attention to the extraordinary absurdity and idolatrous wickedness of the doctrine taught by the Papists, respecting the conversion of the bread and wine of the eucharist into the actual body and blood of our Lord, which they term transubstantiation, and also the offering of that bread and wine as a propitiatory sacrifice in the mass.
Let not any object to our proposed discourse as unnecessary, because the Papist belief is not worthy of serious refutation before a Protestant assembly; for, let it be remembered, that, a short time before the composition of our Catechism, the views we would condemn were held by nearly the whole of Christendom, and that they prevail over the larger part of it at the present time. The glorious Reformation, which, by making the simple Scriptures of God our only rule of faith and practice, greatly impaired the influence of opinions derived from decrees of councils and asserted through doubtful tradition, has not accomplished a complete victory; as we see in the dominance of the Papal system at this day; nor are we without painful proof that, while many are coming out from that region of the shadow of death into the purer light, there are those so weak in their religious judgment and conscience as to leave the open Bible, with its spiritual teachings, for the cunningly devised fables of a gross, carnal superstition. Therefore our church commands her ministers publicly to refute, from Scripture and the analogy of faith, these mischievous errors, which she will continue to protest against until the head of the old serpent is fatally crushed beneath the foot of our triumphant Lord.
The controversy on the points before us has been waged, as you doubtless know, for many centuries, having enlisted the logic and learning of the keenest, most disciplined minds, Papist and Protestant; so that it would be utterly impossible to handle, in a brief discourse, matter about which thousands of volumes have been written. Nor will it be necessary. Whatever difficulty they who have been sophisticated and crippled by false education and inveterate bigotry, may find when required to decide upon questions which have been tangled by Jesuitical art, we, who rely only upon the sword of the Spirit, can easily cut the knot. God’s holy word will make all plain to his “little children,” who would “keep themselves from idols.”
The word mass is not to be found in the Scriptures, original or translated; nor was it known in the church for the first four centuries. Its etymology is doubtful, but, among the many attempts to trace its derivation, the one generally received as the most probable is that given by the Romish doctors. May it not be a corruption from edere, to eat; comesa, comapa, an eating together? They say it is a corruption of the Latin word missa, and came into use from the sacrament being administered after the non-communicants were sent out of the church by the customary phrase, Ite, missa est,—i. e. Go, the congregation is dismissed. Strictly speaking, the mass signifies the prayers and ceremonies with which the Popish priests precede and accompany the eucharist. In process of time, as the corruption of the church increased, the mass came rather to mean the supposed transubstantiation of the elements and the offering of the body and blood of the Lord as a sacrifice for the sins of the living or dead, on whose behalf the service was performed. It would, however, be a wearisome folly for us to recite all the mummery and multifarious formalities prescribed by the highest ecclesiastical authority in the missal or mass-book. We shall take up only what is brought before us in the 80th Question and Answer.
The statement here made of the Popish doctrine has two parts: the first concerning the pretended offering of Christ’s body and blood, under the appearance of bread and wine, as a propitiatory sacrifice for sins unto God the Father; the second concerning the pretended conversion of the bread and wine of the sacrament into the real body and blood of Christ. But as the first error of the sacrifice properly follows or is dependent upon the second, of transubstantiation, we shall for that reason reverse the order.
I. That the Catechism does not represent the Popish doctrine unfairly, will be seen by reading the confession of the 17th article of the creed, which was established by the council of Trent: “I do likewise profess that in the mass is offered a true, proper, and propitiatory sacrifice for the living and the dead; and that the body and blood, together with the soul and divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ, are truly, really, and substantially in the most holy sacrament of the Lord’s supper; and that the whole substance of the bread is turned into the body, and the whole substance of the wine is turned into the blood; which change the Catholic church calls transubstantiation.” The council of Trent farther stated and established the doctrine of their church in the following articles: 1. If any one denies that there is contained in the most holy sacrament of the altar, truly, really, and substantially the body and the blood, together with the soul and divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ, and, consequently, the entire Christ,—if any one say, that he is contained therein only in a symbol or figure or virtue (grace), let him be accursed. 2. If any one says that there remains in the most holy sacrament of the altar the substance of the bread and wine together with the life and the blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, and if he denies that wonderful and miraculous transformation of the whole substance of the bread into the body, and the whole substance of the wine into the blood, while there remains only the form (species, appearance) of the bread and wine, which transformation is termed by the Catholic church transubstantiation, let him be accursed. 3. If there be any one who denies that there is contained in the venerable sacrament of the altar under both sorts, and, after division has been performed, under the single parts of both sorts [bread and wine], the whole Christ, let him be accursed. 4. If any one says, that, after consecration has been performed, the body and the blood of Christ is not in the miraculous sacrament of the altar, but that it is only during the tasting and not before or afterwards, and that there is not in the consecrated host [hostia, properly victim], or the particles, preserved or remaining after the celebration of the Lord’s supper, the true body of the Lord, let him be accursed. 5. If any one says, either that remission of sins be the principal effect of the sacrament of the altar, or that no other results spring from it, let him be accursed. 6. If any one says that the only-begotten Son of God is not to be adored by external worship in the holy sacrament of the altar, and not to be revered with particular solemnity; nor to be carried about in processions, after the praiseworthy and universal usage of the church; nor to be presented publicly to the people; and that those who adore him [that is in the host] are idolaters, let him be accursed. 7. If any one says that it is not permitted to keep the holy eucharist in the pyx, but that it must be distributed immediately after the consecration to the by-standers, or that it is not permitted to bear it reverentially to the sick, let him be accursed. 8. If any one says that the Christ offered in the eucharist is tasted only spiritually, and not sacramentally and really, let him be accursed. 9. If any one denies that all Christian believers of either sex, as soon as they are arrived at years of discretion, are bound, after the command of the holy Catholic church, to communicate, at least on Easter in each year, let him be accursed. 10. If any one denies that it is not permitted to the officiating priest to administer the sacrament to himself, let him be accursed. 11. If any one says that faith alone is a sufficient preparation for the enjoyment of the holy sacrament, let him be accursed.1
Were these not a close translation of the decrees solemnly adopted and issued by the council of Trent, you might well suspect that the statement made by our church was an exaggerated slander on the church of Rome; as it is, your Protestant reason can hardly believe that so large a body of people, professing to acknowledge the Scriptures of divine revelation, really consent to the most remarkable imposition on human credulity that has ever been attempted by designing or fanatical men. But the painstaking particularity with which the council puts forth the preposterous dogma allows no room for charity to plead that they mean otherwise than as they say.
Their doctrine is: 1. That at the moment the priest utters the consecrating words, the whole substance of the bread and wine is changed into the true, real, and substantial body and blood of Christ, containing his spiritual soul and adorable divinity.
That, notwithstanding the elements, as presented to our senses, remain to all perception the same as before their consecration, only their perceptible accidents remain, but none of their substance, the substance being the body and blood of Christ.
That the whole Christ is contained in each part of the sacrament, in that which was the bread and in that which was the wine; and this, also, in each subdivision or particle, however minute, of each of them.
That the body and blood, soul and divinity of Christ is contained in both parts of the sacrament from the moment of the priest pronouncing the transubstantiating words (Hoc est corpus meum), and so long as the elements retain their species, or appearance of bread and wine.
That the fact of the transubstantiation is in no way dependent on the faith either of the officiating priest or of the participator, but is accomplished solely by the virtue of the words Hoc est corpus meum, pronounced by the ordained priest, as prescribed by the ritual.
This whole doctrine the Reformed churches deny and protest against:
- Because it has no foundation in Holy Scripture.
The Papist asserts that, when our Lord, at the institution of the supper, took bread, and, having broken it, said, “This is my body broken for you,” and afterwards took the cup and said, “This cup is the new testament in my blood,” he meant that the bread was actually transubstantiated into his body, and the wine into his blood. The whole controversy, so far as we, who give no heed to mere church authority, are concerned, hinges on this point.
We deny that our Lord intended by the words in question anything more than that the bread and wine were significant representations of his true body and blood offered on the cross.
Our Lord, adopting the usages of human speech, was accustomed to illustrate spiritual truths by figures; and to insist upon our taking such blessed words of his literally, would be to make his teachings utterly ridiculous and incomprehensible. Thus, when he told Nicodemus that he must be born again, and Nicodemus, with a Papist-like stupidity, asked, “How can a man be born when he is old?” he explained it by giving the spiritual meaning of the new birth. So when he said at another time, “If any man will come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me,” it is admitted on all hands that the follower of Christ is not required actually to carry a cross on his shoulders, but to bear faithfully the reproach of Christ before the world. He said to Peter: “Thou art Peter, and on this rock I will build my church;” by which the Papists understand that the church is established on the supremacy of Peter, but by no means suppose that Peter’s person was transubstantiated into a rock, or that the church rests actually on him. For elsewhere he said unto Peter: “Get thee behind me, Satan;” which, if the words be taken literally, would be to assert that Peter was changed into Satan, and, therefore, that their church was built on the devil,—a fact, probable enough, but one they would be far from admitting. At the well of Sychar he offered unto the woman “living water,” and added, in reply to her wondering question, “Whosoever shall drink of the water that I shall give him shall never thirst, and the water that I shall give him shall be in him a well of water springing up into everlasting life.” “Living water” is running water; yet will the Papist assert that our Lord gave the woman running water, or that the Christian’s heart is actually an eternal fountain of running water? The Baptist pointed him out to his disciples as the Lamb of God; but was he actually a lamb? or was that word used to declare him the sacrifice appointed for sin? He calls Christians his sheep; are they actually sheep, or only like him in his meekness, and the objects of his peculiar care? He calls himself “the door of the sheep,” and “the true vine”; was he transubstantiated into a door or a vine? Each of these assertions are as positive as his saying, “This is my body;” and if this last must be taken literally, so must they all.
In the sixth chapter of John, which is especially relied on by the Papists to prove their dogma, he said, “I am the bread of life;” was he at that moment transubstantiated into bread? Again, he says of himself that he was “the bread that came down from heaven”; did he come down from heaven in the substance of bread? If then, because he said “This is my body,” the bread was transubstantiated into his body, it follows that, because he declared himself to be bread, his body was transubstantiated into bread; yet the Papist anathematizes those who do not deny that any substance of bread remains in the host. So again our Lord said, “This cup is the new testament in my blood;” not the cup, the wine in the cup; and if we must take his words literally, the cup was transubstantiated into his blood, or rather into the new covenant, of which the blood of Christ was the meritorious cause. Into such absurdities does the Papistical rule of understanding our Lord’s words literally betray us.
But the apostle Paul, in the tenth and eleventh chapters of 1 Corinthians, in effect denies the transubstantiation of the elements; for he says: “The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not the communion of the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, is it not the communion of the body of Christ?” Again: “As often as ye eat this bread and drink this cup, ye do show the Lord’s death till he come. Wherefore, whosoever shall eat this bread and drink this cup of the Lord unworthily, shall be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord.” Here the first element is called bread, and the second the cup, or wine, after what the Papist considers the moment of transubstantiation, that is, the utterance of the formula Hoc est corpus meum; because he speaks of the bread broken and both elements partaken of by the communicant. Now, says the council of Trent: “If any one says that there remains in the most holy sacrament of the altar (i. e. in the elements) the substance of the bread and wine together with the life and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ;” and “if any one says that, after consecration has been performed, the body and the blood of Christ is not in the miraculous sacrament of the altar, but that this is only during the tasting, neither before nor afterwards, . . . let him be accursed.” But the apostle Paul calls the elements bread and wine after the consecration and during the tasting, therefore the apostle is anathematized. Our Lord himself, after distributing the cup, said, “I will drink no more of the fruit of the vine, until that day that I drink it new in the kingdom of God.” This is contrary to the council of Trent. Will they anathematize our Lord? The Papists lay great stress upon our Lord’s words in John vi. 53–57: “Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, ye have no life in you,” &c. But what does our Lord add to these declarations: “This is that bread which came down from heaven; not as your fathers did eat manna, and are dead; he that eateth of this bread shall live forever.” Here our Lord himself contradicts the council of Trent by calling his body, of which the communicant is to eat, bread. He adds still further: “It is the Spirit that quickeneth; the flesh profiteth nothing; the words that I speak unto you, they are spirit and they are life.” What, then, can be clearer than that, when our Lord calls the bread and wine of the sacrament his body and blood, he means that, in receiving these elements, we receive spiritually by faith the blessings purchased by his atonement, and that through such faith we derive life?
The doctrine of transubstantiation is thus opposed to the whole tenor of Scripture, which declares that we are saved through faith in the truth of the gospel, and that all external acts are valueless, except so far as they are manifestations of such inward faith. Even were the abhorrent thing possible that we should eat the actual flesh of Christ, and drink his actual blood, it could not benefit or in any way reach our souls, which can be affected only by truths received and held in a spiritual faith. We are not to look for Christ in any corporeal presence on earth, but to “lift up our hearts,” or “set our affections on things above, where Christ sitteth at the right hand of the Father.”
The asserted transubstantiation is contrary to reason and the evidence of our senses. This the Papists admit, but assert that it is to be received as a matter of faith; for with God all things are possible; and, therefore, when our Lord declares the bread and the wine to be his body and blood, we are bound to believe him, the testimony of our senses and the judgment of our reason to the contrary notwithstanding. To this we answer, that there are certain things which are impossible with God, because they would be inconsistent with himself. Thus, “it is impossible that God should lie,” or that he should deceive, which he must be supposed to do in the case of transubstantiation; for it demands that we should believe a thing which has every accident, quality, or property of bread or wine, to be another thing, the flesh or blood of Christ, when it has no accident, quality, or property of flesh or blood. How do we know any one to be that particular thing, and not any other thing, but by its accidents or qualities or properties? Thus we know bread and wine to be bread and wine by their form, color, taste, and effects. Take these all away from them, and they cease to be bread and wine; nor can that be flesh and blood which has not the particular qualities of flesh and blood, but appears with the particular qualities of bread and wine. In other words, it is no blasphemy to deny that God can make one thing, while its distinctive properties are retained, to be another thing. The Papists’ reply to this is, that the substance of the bread and wine is changed, but their properties or perceptible qualities are not changed; and that it is not bread and wine, but the body and blood of Christ; not under the form (species) of flesh and blood, but under the form (species) and with the perceptible qualities of bread and wine. What do we know of substance, except as that undiscernible essence in which the qualities of a thing subsist? Hence we can know of the substance of a thing only by the discernible qualities of that thing. If we perceive the peculiar qualities of bread and wine, we are compelled by the nature God has given us to believe that they subsist in the substance of bread and wine. If we do not perceive the peculiar qualities of flesh and blood, we cannot believe that the substance of flesh or blood is there; because the perceptible qualities are the peculiarities by which God orders that we should distinguish things from other things.
But, say they, it is a miracle and a mystery, and must be received by faith, not by corporeal sense or reason. We answer, it is not a miracle, but a contradiction. A miracle is a divine work submitted to the evidence of our senses, as when the water was turned into wine. There was then an actual change of the qualities of the water into the qualities of the wine. Had there been no such change of qualities, there would have been no miracle, because there was no submitting of the work to the senses. So it is not a mystery. A mystery is a fact, the reality of which we know, but the mode of which is above our understanding. The doctrine of the Trinity is a mystery, because it concerns the mode of God’s infinite being. The fact of the subsistence of three divine persons in one God, we know from divine testimony; but the mode of such subsistence is infinitely above our reason. In transubstantiation, the object is perfectly within our capacity of observation, while the asserted fact is contrary to every rule of evidence by which God requires us to try such facts. Can God contradict himself, by requiring us to believe that which is contrary to what he has taught us to believe?
There are other absurdities. The flesh and blood, or body of Christ, is a human body. A human body is, as to its essence and qualities, finite, and limited to a certain portion of space, that is, it cannot be in two separate places at the same time. Is it, then, possible that one and the same human body can be, at the same moment, in heaven and in earth? nay, in ten thousand different places on earth widely apart?—and that it is infinitely multiplicable, so that each minute particle of what was once bread and wine is its whole self, the actual, perfect body of Christ? Can they avoid the absurdity that there are as many bodies of Christ as there are particles of broken bread, or portions of distributed wine? That the divinity of Christ is everywhere present, we know from its infiniteness; that the humanity of Christ cannot be in more than one place at the same time, we know from its finiteness. The more astute Papists have attempted to meet this by asserting of his body a miraculous or “supernatural” manner of existence, by which, being without extension of parts rendered independent of space, it may be one and the same in many places at once, and whole in every part of the symbols, and not obnoxious to any corporeal contingencies.2 What ridiculous self-contradiction! Independent of space, yet occupying space in many places; separate as particles, yet whole in each particle; continuing as a corporeal substance, yet subject to no corporeal contingency! A human body, without any properties of a human body! The fact of our Lord’s human body, or body in all points like our own, having been raised from the dead and translated into glory, is full of comfort to us, because it assures us of his sympathy; but that comfort is all taken away when his body ceases to be like a human body, by being freed from corporeal contingencies.
- The doctrine of transubstantiation is most abhorrent to our moral sensibilities.
There is scarcely anything more shocking than the eating of human flesh or the drinking of human blood. Cannibalism is the most degrading vice of the most brutal savages, and is scarcely resorted to by educated people even in the last extremity of famine. Yet the Papist, when partaking of the sacrament, is required under pain of anathema to believe that he actually breaks with his teeth and swallows the most holy body of our divine Lord, which, under the mumbling of a priest, has been made out of the bread and the wine. There is nothing in the worst rites of heathenism so horrible as this. Nay, the council of Trent teaches that the spiritual soul and proper divinity of our Lord is contained in the sacrament so that we take, with the sacrament, the spiritual soul and divinity of our Lord into our mouths and thence into our bodies.
They contend, also, that the body and blood of the Lord remain in the elements so long, and only so long, as they retain the species or form of bread and wine. Portions of the host may remain in the pyx after the communion, yet continue the body of Christ. But the wafer retaining the properties of the bread, though not its substance, is therefore liable to corruption, by which it is dissolved; so that corruption is the method by which the miracle (so called) is limited and the body of the Lord destroyed; even that sacred body of which the Holy Ghost has twice said, it shall not see corruption. The portions that are eaten, each containing the whole Christ, pass into the bodies of the participants, and then are subject to the process by which all food and drink lose their species and are changed into different substances; and this process destroys or dissolves the most sacred and glorified body of our divine Lord. These are the disgusting consequences which inevitably result from the desperate perversions of Popery. We adore that one day, which to-morrow is changed into corruption. We adore that at one moment, which in another we eat and swallow.3
Dear brethren, how sad is the superstition, in the honest exposure of which we are compelled to mingle with our most precious thoughts such painfully offensive associations!
This argument will suffice to establish our denial of transubstantiation, and we may be glad that the disagreeable, though necessary, duty is over. We now pass to treat, as proposed in our order, of
II. The oblation of the sacrament as a sacrifice for sin.
The Papist holds that the priest, having instrumentally, by using the words Hoc est corpus meum, transubstantiated the elements into the body and blood containing the soul and divinity of our Lord, offers that body and blood, or the whole Christ, as a sacrifice of adoration, thanksgiving, merit, and expiation to God on behalf of both the dead and the living. It follows, therefore, that if, as we have shown, there be no transubstantiation, there can be no offering of Christ, as pretended, in the mass. Yet we add a few other suggestions in accordance with the teachings of our Catechism.
The sacrament cannot, in any proper sense, be a sacrifice, because, according to our Lord’s institution of it, it is an ordinance commemorative of his death for our sins, on the cross. “This do,” said he, “in remembrance of me.” “As often as ye eat this bread and drink this cup,” says the apostle, “ye do show the Lord’s death till he come.” But the mass pretends to be a repetition, not a memorial. Our Lord said not a word of its being a sacrifice to God, but treats it altogether as a service of faith, profitable to our own souls, because it carries back our thoughts to his atonement, made and finished on the cross. So throughout the apostolical writings there is not a word of trust in anything else but the cross of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ; whereas the Papist would have us put our reliance on another sacrifice of Christ, as they pretend, in the oblation by the priest. What Christian can allow such a denial of the sufficiency of the great atonement?
If Christ enter the sacrament to be offered, it is necessary that he should come from heaven to earth; which is contrary to his own and the apostolical declarations. For our Lord told his disciples that his going away was expedient for them, because, if he went not away, the Comforter would not come; but that he would come again to receive them unto himself in the places he had prepared for them; whence it is clear that his coming is to be at the time he would so take them with him into heaven. He cannot, therefore, come to us personally in the sacrament, and will not until he comes to his final triumph; which the apostle means when he says we “show the Lord’s death till he come.” During the interval between his going away in his ascension, and his return in his great glory, we receive his blessing from the grace of “the Comforter which is the Holy Ghost.” So, also, the writer to the Hebrews makes our “sure and steadfast” hope to enter “within the veil, whither the forerunner is for us entered, even Jesus, made an high priest forever after the order of Melchisedek.”
The asserted repetition of the sacrifice in the mass is a denial of perfectness or sufficiency in our Lord’s sacrifice of himself on the cross, which is a direct contradiction of apostolical testimony. For in the Epistle to the Hebrews the writer deduces his strongest argument to prove the superiority of Christ’s priesthood over the Levitical from the fact, that, while they needed often to repeat their sacrifices, our Lord offered but one, which was himself. These are his words on this point: “Such an high priest became us, who is holy, harmless, undefiled, separate from sinners, and made higher than the heavens; who needeth not daily, as those high priests, [or, we may add, as the Romish priests,] to offer up sacrifice, first for his own sins, and then for the people’s: for this he did once when he offered up himself.” Again: “For Christ is not entered into the holy places made with hands, which are the figures of the true; but into heaven itself, now to appear in the presence of God for us. Nor yet that he should offer himself often, as the high priest entereth into the holy place every year with the blood of others; for then must he often have suffered from the foundation of the world; but now, once in the end of the world hath he appeared to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself; and, as it is appointed unto all men once to die, but after this the judgment, so Christ was once offered to bear the sins of many; and unto them, that look for him, will he appear the second time without sin unto salvation.” Again: “By the which will [the will of God in Christ] we are sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all. And every priest standeth daily ministering and offering oftentimes the same sacrifices, which can never take away sins: but this man, after he had offered one sacrifice for sins forever, sat down on the right hand of God; from henceforth expecting till his enemies be made his footstool. For by one offering he hath perfected forever them that are sanctified.” It was in anticipation of this one perfect and perfecting atoning offering of Christ on the cross that Daniel prophesied: “After threescore and two weeks shall Messiah be cut off, but not for himself; . . . . and he shall confirm the covenant with many for one week, and in the midst of the week he shall cause the sacrifice and the oblation to cease.” And this also is the meaning of our Lord on the cross, when he said, “It is finished.”
The Papists, however, contend that the oblation of Christ’s body and blood, the whole Christ, in the sacrament, is most pleasing to God. This again is contrary to Scripture, which, in a thousand places, declares that it is faith in Christ’s cross which is well pleasing to God; for, says the Psalmist in his most penitential psalm: “Thou desirest not sacrifice, else would I give it; thou delightest not in burnt offering. The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit; a broken and a contrite heart, O God, thou wilt not despise.”
They, also, attempt to justify their dogma by asserting that, as our Lord was High Priest after the order of Melchisedek, and Melchisedek “brought forth bread and wine” when he blessed Abram, so Christ must offer a similar bloodless sacrifice of bread and wine, which he did not offer on the cross, and can be said to offer only in the bread and wine of the sacrament. The citation itself defeats them; for, setting aside the obvious probability that the bread and wine brought forth by Melchisedek were nothing more than refreshments offered by him to Abram, there is either blood in the sacrifice of the mass, or there is not. If there be blood, it is not a sacrifice of bread and wine; if there be not blood, it is not an expiatory sacrifice, because “without the shedding of blood there is no remission.” But if the doctrine of transubstantiation be true, there is both the body and blood of Christ in the mass, and it is, therefore, wholly changed from the bread and wine of Melchisedek’s example; and they incur the anathema of their chiefest council when they assert it to be a bloodless sacrifice or a sacrifice of bread and wine. They try to evade this by saying that it is in appearance bread and wine. What avail is the mere appearance, when the substance is flesh and blood?
No, my brethren, we do indeed present an acceptable offering to God, sufficient to cover all our sins, when in our faith we plead the perfect sacrifice of Christ, once offered for us on his cross; and Jesus is our Melchisedek when he sets before us the holy bread and wine as emblems of his atoning passion.
No reference has been made in our foregoing discussion to the opinions of the church, ancient or modern, because, as protestants, we reject every other rule of faith beside the Scriptures; but it is fair to add that, antecedently to the council of Trent, very many Papists, and not the least learned among them, denied the transubstantiation of the mass. Dun Scotus, the great opponent of Aquinas, hesitated not to oppose it with all the vigor of his eminent abilities, in which he was sustained by others less able only than he. Some, who held the doctrine, denied that it was taught in Scripture, contending that it should be received as a dogma of their infallible church.
We learn from the whole subject the danger of departing from the simple word of God, and the simple doctrine of the cross. There is no pitch of absurdity and heresy, even idolatry, that we may not reach if we give ourselves up to the guidance of men, even of a church.
Very thankful should we be that God by his unmerited goodness has not permitted us to be educated in such superstition.
And earnestly should we pray that those, who are now in that region of the shadow of death, the so-called church of Rome, may, by the same grace, be brought to the true light.
1 This translation is copied from the article Mass in the “Encyclopædia Americana,” to which it was furnished by a Roman Catholic. It is inelegant, but correct.
2 Gother, as cited by Fletcher.
3 That we have not misstated the Romish views on this subject, may be seen from the fact, that the priest about to officiate and the communicant intending to participate in the sacrament are required to fast from twelve o’clock of the night before, lest any other substance might mingle in their digestion with the host.