Lecture XLII. The Nature of Good Works. Second Lecture
Thirty-third Lord’s Day
Clear and sufficient as this definition must be to the evangelical believer, it is nevertheless true that the subject involves radical questions of moral philosophy which have engaged the greatest and keenest minds from the beginning of inquiry to the present day. The results of these long, large, and able discussions have not been satisfactory, for the war of opinions is as vigorous as ever. It does not consist with our purpose to occupy ourselves at any length with controversies which have lasted for more than two thousand years, while it would be the extreme of presumption to attempt a settlement of them except from the plain teaching of Holy Scripture; yet a slight notice of the more important points in dispute is desirable for our future expositions of the matter before us, and also to show how impossible it is, without the wisdom from on high, to find the path of truth and virtue.
What is right? This question meets us at the very outset of moral investigation. All are practically agreed, however they may differ in terms or modes of statement, that the doing of right is our highest duty and best wisdom. But what is right? or (for it amounts to the same thing), how shall we know what is right? From this point the leaders of opinion, with their several schools, widely diverge.
Right is a figurative term, synonymous with straight. But to ascertain whether or not our conduct is right or straight, we must have an undoubted, infallible, attainable rule by which to try it. Now, by what rule shall we try our moral acts? Some say, the rule is in our own souls. We are so constituted that the soul distinguishes right from wrong as necessarily and naturally as the eye perceives proportion or the ear harmony. Hence they give to what we ordinarily call conscience the name of moral sense. But, passing over some grave difficulties in this scheme, (as the imperfection of our moral nature which renders the judgment of our consciences untrustworthy, and the manifest fact of a diversity in the moral decisions of men,) we ask, if we be so constituted as to discern right and wrong, Who gave us this most eminent of all faculties? and, as the answer must be, God, we ask again, By what standard has he regulated all the consciences of men? Should we be answered, The fitness of things, (or the order of that constitution of things of which we form a part,) the difficulty is only moved a step farther back; for besides the impossibility of so comparing the innumerable parts of such a vast and complicated system as to ascertain what the fitness of things requires of us, we are forced to ask again, According to what rule did the Creator organize this constitution in which he has placed us? We, therefore, come inevitably to the question which has long been agitated by profound thinkers: whether right and wrong are determined by the simple will of God, or by an eternal rule antecedent to and independent of the will of God?
It would be more curious than profitable to relate the many extravagant and even ridiculous arguments and suppositions advanced by the disputants on both sides, especially during the three centuries after the middle of the 13th, when the two schools of Thomas Aquinas and Dun Scotus (Erigena) convulsed the religious world of Europe with their subtle polemics. The Thomists held with Aquinas, who, though a champion of the Augustinian doctrine of the Divine Sovereignty, taught that God always wills right, but that he wills it because it is right, and that it is not right solely because he wills it. Hence they assumed the name of Realists: intimating that they held to a real, not an arbitrary distinction between right and wrong. On the other hand, the Scotists held that what God wills is right, simply because he wills it, and that had he commanded the opposite, which is now wrong, it would have been right, and that which is now right would have been wrong. Hence they were called Nominalists, because they held that right was right, and wrong wrong only because God declared them so to be, and not from any original quality in either of them.
A modest searcher after divine truth, not intoxicated by metaphysical subtleties, shrinks from adopting either extreme. In the first place, though the terms antecedent and independent are used only in a logical sense, we are shocked by the doctrine that anything in morals is before God, or independent of him in any sense: which would be, in effect, reviving the heathen doctrine of fate controlling the divinity. Then, again, we are as much shocked by the bare supposition that God’s determination of right and wrong is merely arbitrary, so arbitrary that he might have ordained the reverse. Let us see if there be not a way of satisfying ourselves more in accordance with our reverence for the God of the Bible.
The will of God flows from his divine nature, which is self-existent, eternal, and infinitely perfect. This infinite perfection implies perfect consistency in all the divine thoughts, purposes, and acts. For if any one of these were contrary to, or discordant with, any one other, he would not be perfect, because one or the other of the differings would be an imperfection. Thus we should place the eternal rule of right not in any mere arbitrary will of God, because his nature being infinitely, therefore unchangeably perfect, his will must be in accordance with his nature. Therefore the eternal law of right can be found only in the self-caused nature of God, or, in other words, the entire consistency of God with himself. Thus, on the one hand, the will of God in determining right is not arbitrary because it is consistent with his infinite nature; and on the other hand, right is not antecedent to or independent on God, because he is self-existent and eternal. The holiness of a moral creature is his conformity to the divine character so far as a finite being can resemble the infinite; the holiness of God is his infinitely perfect consistency with himself. If this view cannot resolve the difficulty of the schoolmen, it will, at least, relieve the mind of the child-like Christian who can submit himself only to God. To repeat what we said in the beginning, we must have a rule by which to try our moral conduct; and that rule must be ascertained, simple, and infallible. We cannot delay our acts until we satisfy ourselves respecting the conclusions of general conscience, or the fitness of things; nor from what we have seen of men’s differences in sentiment and opinion, could we ever come to an undoubted conclusion. When the most learned and ingenious disagree so widely, the great mass of mankind cannot be expected to distinguish between right and wrong. But when we take the law of God for our standard, we conform ourselves to the infinitely wise will of him who has made us and all things, thereby placing us in relations to a system so harmonious and settled that any violation of his law would be a violation of fitness, and any violation of fitness a violation of his law. We must go farther. It is not enough that we conform ourselves to the law of God, but we must take it as our rule, because it is the law of God. In other words, we must obey, not the law, but God from whom the law proceeds. Our duty is to God; his law is the rule which he has prescribed for the rendering of our duty. It is incorrect to speak of our obligation to right, or of duty to law. Right and law respect the relations of moral beings, but are not themselves moral beings, and, therefore, cannot themselves be objects of duty. That goes beyond or through the law to the being or beings with whom we are in relation. This is clearly shown by the scriptural fact that love is the fulfilling of the law, and by the summary of the law in supreme love to God and love to our neighbor as ourselves. Such an affection cannot be rendered to a law, or a principle, but can be given only to another conscious moral being. We cannot keep the law of God without supreme love to him, and therefore our obedience is due to God who ordained the law, not to the law itself. It is, therefore, most unphilosophical to attempt a transference of our obedience from the will of God to a mere principle or rule,—an error they commit who would place our rule of right elsewhere than in the divine will. To tell me that I must do right simply because it is right, and not because it is the will of God, is to say that God should have no place in morals. It is true that God rewards those who do right, and punishes those who do wrong; but to put my obligation on that principle is to make God only a judge and an executioner. No; I must do right and avoid wrong, because I love him and it is his will that I should so order my conduct. Hence the Christian considers God to be the only object of all duty, our so-called duties to ourselves or our fellow-creatures being covered by our duty to him, because he has enjoined them upon us.
The ground of our duty to God is the fact that he is our Creator and the Creator of all things. All our faculties of soul and body were by him brought into existence out of nothing, and are by him maintained in existence. He, therefore, owns us and has a right to our entire service. As the Creator he is the Governor, Legislator, and Judge; every attribute of sovereignty is included by his creatorship. Our sense of obligation should be vastly enhanced by his infinite wisdom and goodness and holy excellence, and, above all, by the redemption in Christ Jesus; nay, it is by the exercise of these adorable attributes that our love to him is drawn out; but, nevertheless, the original basis of our moral obligation is our being his creatures. Does any one ask me here, If God were other than good or holy, should I be bound to love him? or, if he commanded me to do anything contrary to right, should I feel myself bound to obey him? I reply that such questions are profane absurdities. I cannot conceive of God without infinitely perfect attributes. They are essential to my idea of God. Without them the imaginary being you talk of would not be God. I cannot consent, even in supposition, to put my God out of existence. I can have no knowledge, no thought, no being, except from my Creator. To him I belong; therefore is his law the rule of my life. He is infinitely excellent; I only know of excellence but from him. He is my Father, my Saviour, my Sanctifier, my all; therefore do I love him, and am conscious that it is my duty to make his will my own.
These considerations, though perhaps more abstruse, and apparently more abstract than those which are ordinarily brought before you, are far from unprofitable. On a correct understanding of the great truth of our obligation to God alone depend our correctness of belief in many consequent doctrines; and if we have grace to hold it fast, it will be a clue to guide us out of many a labyrinth where we should otherwise wander “in ‘wildering mazes lost.’” If God be wrong, who shall tell us what is right? If God be right, what need of conjecture? We believe in God, and are not at liberty to make any question as to what is right or what is wrong from our own reason, but only to ascertain what he determines, and has declared by his law to be right or wrong. There alone can we rest.
Let us now turn to the exposition of the Catechism itself. The answer to the 91st Question defines “good works” to be “only those which proceed from true faith [and] are performed according to the law of God and to his glory, and not such as are founded on our imaginations or the institutions of men.”
It must be remembered that this definition occurs in an account of the new or converted man; and, therefore, that the phrase “good works” is used not in an absolute, but in the evangelical sense. To us sinners, who are acceptable to God only through the infinitely meritorious mediation of our Lord Jesus Christ, “that which is without faith is sin,” and our best deeds are offensive to God except as they are cleansed by the blood, covered by the righteousness, and presented by the intercession of our great Surety. It is also obvious that the Christian, who makes (as the Catechism goes on to say every converted man does) the word of God his only rule of right practice, must exercise faith in the truth of the Scriptures, which faith respects the justice of the divine commandments as well as the mercy of the divine promises, so that in proportion to the strength of our faith in the word of God will be our aim to comply with the divine will. Faith in Christ is necessary, therefore, not to the original or absolute goodness of a moral act, but to our recovery from the rebellion of sin, and the acceptableness of our imperfect obedience in the sight of God. Besides, every motion, desire, and endeavor to do right, which we have, is the effect of divine grace, “working in us both to will and to do of God’s good pleasure,” and this grace is ever given, and given only in answer to faith. Hence our Christian life can be maintained only by the exercise of a true faith, without which any good works on our part are impossible.
Those only are good works which “are performed according to the law of God.”
a. We are the creatures of God, and therefore belong to him; so that his will, as declared to us in his law, is absolutely sovereign over us; and the only question we have a right to make respecting our conduct is: “What doth the Lord our God require of us?”
b. We are bought with a price ransomed from the power of Satan and from everlasting death by the most precious blood of Christ; and he has bought us to himself, as a peculiar (his own) people, zealous of good works; for which reason we are, by the power of his Holy Spirit, “his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them.” If, therefore, we accept the redemption of Christ for our souls, we must, by divine help, assume the obligations which the purpose of the redemption implies, and walk (or order our practice) according to the rules ordained for us in the law of God. This should not be by any constraint of servile fear, but with the willingness which the most lively and paramount gratitude inspires. “The love of Christ constraineth us; because we thus judge, that if one died for all, then were all dead; and that he died for all, that they which live should not henceforth live unto themselves, but unto him which died for them and rose again.” Our whole life, in all its thoughts, affections, words, actions, and energies, is the thank-offering which we should render unto Christ for his unspeakable love in offering himself as a sacrifice to redeem us unto God.
c. Nay, more; God, accepting us in Christ his Son, accepts us as his children; and, as the proof and earnest of his Fatherly love, he sends into our hearts the spirit of his Son, which is the spirit of adoption whereby we cry “Abba, Father.” We, therefore, should be “followers of God as dear children.” As an affectionate child confides in his father’s wisdom and love, desiring nothing so much as to obey his father’s will, so the Christian, committing all that concerns him for life and death, time and eternity, to his heavenly Father’s disposition, asks only what that Father would have him to do, and does it with his whole heart.
- They must also be performed to the glory of God. This has been made evident by our previous considerations. The original and ultimate end of all things can be none other than the manifestation of the glory of their great Author; and as the moral creature is the greatest of God’s creatures, the obligation of all intelligent beings to manifest, by the beauty of obedient lives, the wisdom and holiness of the Creator’s moral law is proportionately great. But the highest glory of God is placed by himself in the redemption of sinful men by the atonement of Christ, and their elevation by the grace of the Holy Ghost from the depths of guilty depravity to the perfect eternal holiness of heaven. Therefore are we doubly bound by our creation and redemption, nay, trebly, since we add the dedication of ourselves to glorify God by our bodies and spirits which are his. This can be done only by an entire conformity to the will of God, as made known by his work. What virtue of our own invention we may pretend to, if it have any praise, would be to our glory; what duty we perform in obedience to the will of God, reflects glory on him. The light of the truth is our light only because it shines upon us from God; therefore does our Lord say, what is repeated in a thousand Scriptures: “Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.” The motive of the divine glory is, therefore, essential to any good work of the Christian.
It may, however, be asked here, whether or not this motive of the divine glory should exclude from our hearts all motive of our own good, so that our obedience to God shall be perfectly disinterested. We answer that, so far from this being the case, such disinterestedness is not only not required, but from the nature of the case, impossible. God has from the beginning implanted in the moral creature a love of happiness and religion, instead of eradicating this strong motive-principle, addresses it by the strongest arguments, and directs it by the divine commandments. When God says, “Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself,” he, by making it the measure of our love to our neighbor, recognizes our love of ourselves as just, and shows that without it we cannot know how to obey God in loving our neighbor. The sanctions of the divine law—life in reward of obedience, death in penalty of disobedience—can have no force except as self-love has power in our hearts. So we find our blessed Lord opposing the motives which worldly men have to sin, and hypocrites to an external form of piety, by saying that they have their reward, but that our heavenly Father himself will reward openly all those who serve him out of a sincere heart. According to which principle Moses acted when “he had respect unto the recompense of reward”; nay, our Lord himself, the “great pattern of a Christian life,” when “for the joy that was set before him he endured the cross, despising the shame.” We do not lose our will when we make the will of God our own; nor do we lose our happiness when we seek the glory of God which lies in the best happiness of his children. If I am bound to serve the welfare of my fellow-man because he is God’s creature, I am bound for the same reason to seek my own welfare, since I am equally God’s creature. Besides, the Christian cannot isolate himself. He belongs to a system, each part of which receives, as well as gives, influences for good or evil. God in Christ, and, before the necessity of redemption, God the Creator, is the head of the system from whom all the vital influences for good proceed, as to him the issues of praise return. We cannot, therefore, obey God without receiving our share of the benefit which our obedience works in the system. We cannot, therefore, and ought not to ignore our interest in doing the will of God, any more than we should seek to isolate ourselves from the constitution of things in which God has placed us. The glory of our heavenly Father is the blessedness of his children; therefore should we seek our own good in the way of his commandments, from the very desire we have for his glory.
If our foregoing demonstrations have been sound, the remaining part of the answer before us needs none.
The law of God being our only and sovereign rule, we have no right to mingle with it, or oppose it by, any imagination or thought of our own. It is not permitted us to do what we suppose or what seems to us right; we must do only that which God declares in his blessed word to be right. The settlement of what is right or wrong is infinitely above our faculty. We must take the rule only from him who alone knows. Therefore we ought most religiously to guard ourselves from the temptation of acting from our impulses, our feelings, or opinions; for all these come out of a sinful heart, which is deceitful above all things. Our duty is to obey God, not ourselves; and this we do only when we rule our hearts and lives by the commandments he has given us in his holy word.
If we are not to obey our own imaginations, neither are we to obey the imaginations of other men, whether they come to us in traditions or decrees of churches, or dogmas of associations, or public opinion. Nothing is our duty but what God has commanded; and we, in effect, transfer our allegiance from him to the authority of sinners like ourselves, when we adopt any article into our creed, any ceremony into our worship, or any rule into our morality, which God has not expressly given. There is a strong tendency even in conscientious people to go astray here. They cannot resist the influence of those whom they think good or wise, nor refuse that which is plausibly expedient. So we find the Jews of our Lord’s time following the traditions of the elders. Afterwards the Papal church tyrannized in the same manner over the consciences of the people; and among Protestants of our own day, methods of worship and reform, wholly from the inventions of men, are made paramount to the plainest dictates of Holy Scripture. Dearly beloved brethren, be not so deceived. You can render the God of the Bible no divided allegiance. If the opinion of men be your god, serve it; but if God who gave us the Bible be your God, serve him alone. The Scripture was given that the man of God might be thoroughly furnished unto all good works; and nothing is a good work which is not founded on “thus saith the Lord.”