Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture XXX. Justification by Faith Defended; or, The Doctrine of Good Works

Twenty-fourth Lord’s Day

The doctrine of Justification by Faith alone, as taught in the last lesson of our Catechism and in the Confessions of all the Reformed churches, has been vehemently objected to. It offends the pride of men by declaring that they are, not only destitute, but incapable of merit in the sight of God, and that, therefore, they cannot be saved except through his free and sovereign mercy. Besides, God, in his word and providence, has established a vital connection between holiness and happiness, so that his favor is ever the reward of righteousness. This is the eternal rule of his government, emanating from his perfect justice and the entire harmony of his perfect attributes. The great purpose of Christianity is to restore the sinner to righteousness, and fit him by a radical reformation for eternal blessedness in the presence of God; and the whole doctrine of the gospel is given to show that God is not merely merciful, but just, in the salvation of him which believeth in Jesus.

We are not, therefore, willing to suppose that it is only a cavilling, or even a self-righteous spirit, which requires demonstration of the consistency between these undoubted truths and salvation by faith alone. There may be an honest, though not an excusable, misunderstanding of the doctrine which it is our duty to sympathize with, and, so far as we can, correct. What is more natural than to ask,—

How is it that the gospel requires good works from us, and yet they make no part of our justification with God?

How is it, that the rewards of God’s favor in this life, but especially in the life to come, are promised to those who do good works, and yet those works are without merit in God’s sight?

Or, how can the promise of salvation to simple faith in Jesus Christ fail to encourage men in a careless and presumptuous way of life?

These questions ought to be answered. It ought to be shown that so important an article of our creed is consistent with itself and every part of the word of God. To do this, is the object of the lesson for to-day, and of our present discourse. Thus,

The answer to our 62d Question declares, that

Our good works cannot be a part of our righteousness before God.

The answer to our 63d Question, that

The rewards promised to good works are not because of merit in themselves, but of the grace of God. And the answer to the 64th Question, that

It is an essential property of saving faith to bring forth fruits of thankfulness in good works.

The first shows why good works are not insisted upon as a method of salvation.

The second, how our good works receive reward, though they have no merit in themselves.

And the third, what the genuine effect of faith in Christ is upon the heart and life of the believer.

We shall, by God’s help, attempt to discuss the three several propositions as they are laid before us in the lesson.

First: Good works cannot be a part of our righteousness before God.

This may be proved at once by the assertion of God, that “by the deeds of the law (and there are no good works which the law does not require) there shall no flesh be justified in his sight.” What God declares impossible cannot be.

It may be proved by the fact that God has provided in Christ an infinite righteousness for our justification, which would be manifestly unnecessary and superfluous if our own obedience could have availed in any way to save us. As the apostle says, “If righteousness come by the law, then Christ is dead in vain” (Gal. ii. 21).

And it may be proved by the extent of the salvation, which secures to the believer, though a sinner, a higher blessedness than was granted to man in innocence, and therefore, being out of all proportion to any supposable merit of ours, can only be accounted for by the infinite merit of Christ, the purchaser, and the principle of the gospel, that “where sin abounded, grace should much more abound” (Rom. v. 20). But let us add to these the conclusive argument of our instructor in the answer to the 62d Question, which is that

We have not, and cannot have, any good works, properly so called, to present before God.

“The righteousness which can be approved of before the tribunal of God must be absolutely perfect, and in all respects conformable to the divine law; and . . . our best works in this life are all imperfect, and defiled with sin.”

When we compare men with each other, it is not to be denied that we may find some bright contrasts to prevailing selfishness and wrong, yet it is from the prevalence of selfishness and wrong that most of what is accounted good in men has its seeming goodness. Among a nation habitually drunkards, one who drank to intoxication only several times a year, as the virtuous men of Athens at the feasts of Bacchus, would be considered a miracle of temperance, but among a nation habitually temperate, a single fit of drunkenness would stamp disgrace on the same person. In Christian countries it is most infamous for a man to treat with contempt and cruelty the wife of his bosom; in Hindoostan the reverse would be extraordinary. Cyrus, in refraining from the dishonor of his beautiful captive, won immortal praise, not because such an abuse of power would not have been in the last degree unmanly, but that such abuse was then universal. These are strong instances, but serve to show what false judgments may be formed from delusive circumstances. A man is liberal in his kindness to the poor, and he gets great credit for charitableness. But is not liberal kindness to the poor a duty binding upon all? Whence then such praise? Few are so uncharitable. Another pays debts, from which the letter of human law, but not equity, sets him free, and he is lauded for integrity. Is it not the duty of all men to pay what they really owe? Yes, but few are so honest. Another is distinguished for candor. Is not truth a universal duty? Alas! few are sincere. But who is there perfectly candid, perfectly honest, perfectly benevolent, perfectly pure? Where is there a character perfectly free from blemish? In a world of righteousness like heaven, the best patterns of what we here call human goodness would be strange deformities, and especially so were their inner motives and desires as apparent as their outward conduct.

But God tries us by no rule so partial and shifting as human opinion. He brings us to the test of his holy law. That law requires all righteousness. It is not satisfied with an outward compliance, beyond which human authority cannot penetrate, but searches like his omniscient eye into the thoughts and intents of the heart. The obedience he insists upon is a perfect obedience, an entire conformity to all his precepts. Thus the apostle Paul says (Gal. iii. 10), quoting from Deuteronomy (xxvii. 26), “Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law, to do them.” The apostle James goes farther (ii. 10), and declares that “whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all”; because he is a rebel against the authority of the law. It matters not what obedience we may otherwise or at other times perform, a single act of transgression in thought, word, or deed not only impairs our obedience, but brings us under the penalty of the curse. This is the fact, indeed, with regard to human law. No one, convicted of a single theft or murder, is freed from punishment, because he did not steal ten purses, or murder ten men. It was his duty to refrain from stealing anything, or wounding any one. No previous or subsequent good conduct can expiate in the eye of justice any one act of crime. The law requires entire innocence. It is true, a generally good character may palliate, but never in strictness can atone for any offence. Repentance is not expiation, because all our time is demanded for perfect obedience.

Now, can we render such entire, perfect, constant obedience? Is there any one of our good works in its motive pure and unmingled with sin? Will all our conduct stand such a scrutiny? Is there any man that liveth and sinneth not? The word of God says No, and conscience echoes the negative. There is no one who has loved God with his whole heart, mind, and strength. There is no one who has loved his neighbor as himself. If one were to make a boast of such perfection, men would hoot at him for a hypocrite, and fear him as an arrant knave, who sought a confidence he would be sure to violate.

There is no hope from our own righteousness. We have not, and we cannot have, any good works, properly so called, to present before God. Our best works are too imperfect to deserve reward, and our actual sins positively condemn us.

But it may be said, that, if we sincerely endeavor to do the very best in our power, God will surely pardon the sins of our infirmities, and accept our service, imperfect as it may be. The justice of God warrants no such expectation. He says unequivocally, “The soul that sinneth, it shall die.” If he be so forgiving and tolerant, the reason must lie in his mercy; and that would be salvation by grace, not of works. God is merciful, and in his mercy does pardon the sins and accept the services, though unworthy, of all who truly humble themselves to accept his grace. But he is merciful only in Christ, and for Christ’s sake only he pardons and accepts the unworthy. If we seek salvation there, we shall certainly find it; but we cannot deserve it, and that is what we intended to prove.

Secondly: The rewards promised to our good works are not because of merit in them, but of the grace of God.

Rewards are certainly promised to the good works of God’s people in this life, and especially in the life to come. The texts of Scripture to prove this are so numerous and familiar, that we scarcely need to recite any. Even a cup of cold water given in the name of one of Christ’s disciples, shall not lose its reward (Matt. x. 42).

Good works are, indeed, essential to a warranted hope of heaven, as is clearly shown by our Lord in his parable of the builders (Matt. vii. 21–27), where the man who heard Christ’s sayings and did them not is likened to one who built his house upon the sand, and to whom the Lord will say, “I never knew thee;” and in his description of the judgment (Matt. xxv. 31–46), where he declares that none but those who have done good to their fellow-men in trouble, shall be received into life eternal.

The good works of Christ’s people follow them to heaven, and there determine the degree of glory which each believer shall receive. “Blessed are the dead which die in the Lord, from henceforth; yea, saith the Spirit, that they may rest from their labors; and their works do follow them” (Rev. xiv. 13). The precedence given in heaven to those who were faithful in great tribulations (vii. 14), and the spirit of the Scriptures throughout, show that in proportion to their fidelity shall be the reward of the redeemed, where there are different degrees of blessedness, as one star differeth from another star in glory, though all are bright.

Nay, we are permitted, in imitation of our Master, who, “for the joy set before him, endured the cross, despising the shame” (Heb. xii. 1, 2), to have “respect” as Moses had (xi. 26) “to the recompense of reward,” and to believe, as the apostle assures us, that God is not unrighteous to forget our work and labor of love. We are justified and encouraged in a noble ambition not to be the least in the kingdom of God, but to “lay up for ourselves treasures where neither moth nor rust doth corrupt, and where thieves break not through and steal” (Matt. vi. 20); and to secure a “great reward in heaven” (Matt. v. 12).

But all this value is given to our good works only in consequence of the grace of God in Christ.

  1. It is this grace which pardons and delivers us from our sins, which otherwise would condemn and destroy us, notwithstanding all our efforts to do well; for, certainly, until we be delivered from guilt in the past, we can do nothing to merit favor.

  2. It is this grace which covers and pardons all the defects which, in despite of all our efforts, will cling to our best attempts at service. The works of the believer are washed in Christ’s blood, and adorned by his merits, and presented by his intercession. It is not because they are worthy, or that the worker is worthy, but because they are laid upon the altar Christ Jesus, that they are both acceptable to God. For consider, my friends, the greatness of reward promised. Is it possible that the best righteousness a man could accomplish during the longest life on earth can deserve such eternal and unspeakably glorious wages as are given to the servants of Christ in heaven? No; nothing less than the righteousness of Christ could deserve a reward so vast; and it is because that righteousness is reckoned unto the believer, and his works are accepted through that righteousness, he receives the promises and the fulfilment of them. And

  3. It is this grace which inclined the believer, once in “darkness,” (Ephes. v. 8,) and “alienated from the life of God through ignorance” (iv. 18) to good works. But for sovereign grace he had remained dead “in trespasses and sins” (ii. 1). And having inclined him, it is the same grace which enables him to do good works. For, says the Saviour, “without me ye can do nothing” (John xv. 5); and the apostle exhorts us to work out our salvation with fear and trembling, because it is God that worketh in us both to will and to do of his good pleasure (Phil. ii. 12, 13).

Since, then, it is grace that delivers us from condemnation, thus giving us the opportunity of doing good works, and grace which presents our good works, imperfect in themselves, but covered with Christ’s merits, which grace had provided; nay, since it is grace which inclines and enables us to do any good work, surely, the reward of our good works is not of their merit, but of grace alone.

Thirdly: It is an essential property of saving faith to bring forth fruits of thankfulness in good works.

“It is impossible,” says our instructor, “that those who are implanted into Christ by a true faith should not bring forth fruits of thankfulness.”

This will readily be seen, if we consider

  1. In whom the Christian believes. It is in Christ the Saviour from sin, who delivers from the necessary consequence of sin, which is misery, not only by expiating past sin, but by saving his people from sin itself. Thus the father of the Baptist, in his thanksgiving, says of God in Christ: “He grants unto us, that we, being delivered out of the hand of our enemies, (i. e. our sins,) might serve him without fear, in holiness and righteousness all the days of our life” (Luke i. 74, 75). If, then, the great end and work of the Saviour be to make us obedient and holy, it is impossible that any one can truly believe in him and embrace him as a Saviour, who is not truly penitent, heartily desirous of forsaking all sins, and of living according to all the commandments of God. Consider

  2. To whom faith unites the Christian.

By faith he is vitally united to Christ, as members of his body, he being the divine head (Ephes. v. 30); as branches to the stem, he being the living vine (John xv. 1–5); as living stones in God’s spiritual house, he being the chief corner-stone (Ephes. ii. 20; 1 Peter ii. 5). Now, as the foundation gives strength and sustenance to the building, as the stem sheds life and fruitfulness through the branches engrafted into it, as the members of the body are vitally united to the head, directed by it and inspired from it, so all who truly believe in Jesus are animated by a life superior to their own, even the Spirit of Christ, made fruitful by an energy superior to their own, even the grace of the Spirit, and sustained by a power superior to their own, even the strength of God; so it is impossible but that they will be animated, moved, and enabled to do good works. The absence of such, the proper effect, proves the absence of true faith, the cause. Consider

  1. Of whom the Christian learns by faith.

It is of God in Christ, to whom all the prophets and the law bear witness. The true believer in Christ, therefore, believes in all the truth of God, as taught in the Scriptures. All the doctrines, all the precepts, all the promises.

He believes in the infinitely glorious and holy attributes of God the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, and thus recognizes himself to be the responsible creature of the omnipotent, all-seeing, and just and good God. He carries this thought with him, and lives and moves and has his being in God.

He believes in the purity, exceeding breadth, and justice of the divine law; and thus is convinced of his sin, its enormity, and his imminent peril of eternal death, should he not be pardoned and delivered from his sins, but continue a wilful transgressor and rebellious creature.

He believes in the riches of God’s grace by Jesus Christ; the infinite mercy, which proposed to save sinners; the infinite mercy which sent the Son, of the Son who came, and of the Holy Ghost, who sanctified the Son incarnate as the Saviour; the infinite merit of that righteousness which the Son wrought for the salvation of sinners; and the infinite grace of the Holy Ghost, by which that righteousness is applied to and the salvation accomplished for and in the believer; and he believes in the infinite glory and blessedness of that life eternal, which is promised, from the Father by the Son and through the Spirit, to all who believe.

Now, my hearers, you cannot fail to perceive that such faith in Christ establishes in the soul of the believer, to incline and maintain him in good works, the three strongest principles of which our nature is capable: fear, hope, and love.

How will one, who believes in the awful holiness and terrible justice of God, dare knowingly to persevere in the commission of wrong or the neglect of right? What can restrain irregular desire and passion if an habitual sense of the divine presence and scrutiny do not?

And when faith shows in strong contrast to the cares and pleasures and gains of this passing life the bright eternity of rest and joy and glory which awaits God’s true and zealous servants, when she points to the increased richness of their reward who have been more true and faithful, will not the hope of that heaven and its distinction be as an anchor to the soul of the tempted, a solace to the sad, and a cheerful argument to endure patiently, and work steadfastly, even to the end?

But above all, when the believer thinks of all the love of God in Christ to his soul, his atonement, his intercession, his power, and his long-suffering,—when he remembers Jesus in the manger, in the desert, in Gethsemane, on the cross, and then looks up to him upon his throne,—when he reads the precious promises bought by his Master’s blood, and secured by his Master’s Spirit,—will not his sinful, selfish thoughts give way before a gushing tide of love for Christ and God in Christ? Can he choose but live for his cause who died and rose again that he might give eternal life to as many as would receive him?

Nay, my brethren, so vital is the connection between true faith and good works, that faith is the great instrument by which the Holy Spirit sanctifies the heart of the Christian. It is, in fact, itself a part of the sanctification, and the good works which it produces, the beginning and progress of the very salvation which Christ has promised to the believer.

Thus we argue that it is an essential property of saving faith to bring forth fruits of thankfulness in good works. And in this we see the harmony of the apostles Paul and James, when the one says, “A man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law” (Rom. iii. 28); and the other, “that by works man is justified and not by faith only” (James ii. 24), because, as James says (17, v.), “Faith, if it hath not works, is dead being alone;” and (26, v.) “as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also.” The true faith which engrafts a sinner into Christ is ever fruitful in good works; that seeming faith which does not produce such sanctifying consequences is not saving faith any more than a dead body is a man.

It is true, faith does not at once perfectly sanctify the repentant sinner. That is not the order of God’s grace. But the work is begun with faith, and faith maintains a fight with the world, the flesh, and the devil, until at last it gains a consummate victory.

Let us learn from the whole subject,

  1. Humility.

Pride in good works, or self-righteousness, is most inconsistent with a Christian temper; because all that makes a difference in light or practice between one sinner and another is of grace, and because when the best Christian compares his best works with the only true standard, the law of God, he must find them to be in themselves utterly unworthy to appear before his Judge. Hence the best Christians are always the most humble, and prove it by being the most charitable in the judgment of others. It was not the pharisee who thanked God that he was not as other men, whom God justified; but the publican, who cried, “God be merciful to me a sinner.” “Take heed,” my brethren, “and beware of the leaven of the pharisees.”

  1. Encouragement.

The requirements of the divine law are very great, and the duties of a Christian life very difficult. When in our weakness we contemplate them, we are afraid and say, “Who is sufficient for these things?” “Who can be saved?” How shall we dare bring before God such a poor and imperfect service as the best we can render must be? Yet, my brethren, poor as our best service may be, it can be made better by divine grace. That “grace is sufficient for us”; and if we offer it unto God by faith in Christ Jesus, his righteousness can cover every defect and make meanness, glory; and poverty, abounding riches; while his blood washes away every stain. Oh, what a blessedness to lay our unworthy deeds of service upon the altar of Christ’s worth, and see them transmuted into precious beauty, acceptable and welcome to God his Father; and to know that not one kind act, or word, or thought, for Christ’s sake and the gospel’s, shall ever be lost, but will meet us in heaven, and be our joy and reward and decoration forever among the angels of God! So the best believer is ever the most zealous worker in good to God’s cause and his fellow-men.

  1. Caution.

If there be no salvation without true faith, and no true faith without good works, it is wise in us most carefully to examine ourselves, whether we have this faith or not. Do we account ourselves orthodox and strong in faith? We are deceiving ourselves, except we be at the same time earnest lovers of God and man, zealous in their service, and ready to devote all we have for their sakes. The three worst signs in a professing Christian are pride, sloth, and covetousness. I know not which is the worst, for they grow like the trefoil on one stem. But this is certain, covetousness is the least easily cured.

But, at the same time, let no one condemn themselves as wanting in true faith because they are not satisfied with the degree of love and zeal they have. It is faith which shows us our defects; and if we be truly sorry for them and make hearty endeavors to live according to the commandments of God, we may be sure that God accepts us in Jesus Christ, because such desires and efforts are the fruit of faith alone. Faith in Christ’s cross is nothing except we follow him; nor can we follow him except we have faith in his cross; so that a true following of Christ proves a true faith in Christ.

Which faith, fruitful in good works, may God grant to us all for Jesus Christ’s sake. Amen.