Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture XXXII. Baptism. No. I. Its Authority and Design

Twenty-sixth and Twenty-seventh Lord’s Days

The lesson before us includes the whole doctrine of Christian baptism, to a somewhat enlarged, though still concise exposition of which our thoughts will now be directed.1

It must be remembered throughout our study of the Catechism, that the person questioned is supposed to be a truly regenerate Christian, who has had in his own experience the proof of the divine truths which his answers set forth. This will account for the positive and assured manner of his claiming a personal concern in the several blessings of a Christian life.

For the sake of greater convenience in our analysis and explanation of the matter here treated by the church, let us arrange the whole under the following heads:—

First: The authority for our use of Christian baptism. Secondly: The design of Christian baptism. Thirdly: The mode of its administration. Fourthly: The subjects to whom it should be administered.

First: The authority for our use of Christian baptism.

Baptism, simply speaking, is the application of water, as in the act of washing or cleansing; Christian baptism is the application of water to a person “in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost.” “I indeed,” said John the Baptist, “baptize you with water, but one mightier than I cometh, the latchet of whose shoes I am not worthy to unloose; he shall baptize you with the Holy Ghost and with fire” (Luke iii. 16). This shows that the significance of baptism lies in the application of the element to the person, not of the person to the element. “Go ye, therefore,” said our Lord to his apostles, “and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost” (Matt. xxviii. 19). This shows that the pronouncing of the words prescribed, at the time of applying the element, is necessary to the sacrament; indeed, it were else utterly unmeaning. That water is the proper and only element to be used, we learn from many Scriptures, especially from that giving an account of the Ethiopian eunuch, baptizing (Acts viii. 36–38); and the question of Peter, the apostle, before baptizing the household of Cornelius: “Can any man forbid water, that these should not be baptized which have received the Holy Ghost as well as we?” (Acts x. 47.) The definition we have given may, therefore, suffice until we come to speak more particularly of the mode in which baptism should be administered. The authority for our use of this external baptism, or the propriety of our administering it, is not questioned by any known portion of such as call themselves Christians, except the Society of Friends; but, as we derive our warrant for any Christian custom only from the word of God, let us refer to that absolute and infallible oracle.

I. The command of our Lord, the head of his church, cited but a moment since, is positive. He enjoined upon his disciples to baptize, as certainly as he did to teach, all nations. This sacrament, therefore, with the preaching of the gospel, lies at the foundation of the Christian church. Wherever the word of Christ is proclaimed and men are “discipled,” or truly learn and believe the glad tidings, baptism is to be administered.

II. That the ordinance was not temporary, or only for the beginning of the church, is clear from the promise annexed, which shows the duration of the command: “Lo! I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world,” or the consummation of the present economy (Matt. xxviii. 20). Until all nations shall have been “discipled,” and the Redeemer’s kingdom on earth made complete by the universal triumph of his gospel, his word is to be preached and baptism continued with it. This is farther confirmed by

III. The inspired practice of the primitive church. The administration of baptism was not restricted to the hands of the apostles, but all the authorized preachers of the gospel appear to have baptized also. Thus Philip, first ordained a deacon, but afterwards, as we may suppose, advanced to be an evangelist, since the deacon’s office (purposely distinct from that of those who gave themselves “continually to prayer and the ministry of the word”) was the care of the poor (Acts vi. 2–4), baptized many in Samaria, the Ethiopian eunuch, and doubtless a multitude of other converts, under his successful ministry (viii. 27–38). Paul was baptized at Damascus (ix. 18) three years before he ever saw a brother apostle (Gal. i. 17, 18); and he afterwards speaks of the Corinthian Christians as having been baptized, although he himself had baptized none of them but Crispus, Gaius, and the household of Stephanas (1 Cor. i. 13–16); so he says to the Galatian converts and to all Christians: “As many of you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ” (Gal. iii. 27), implying that only they who had been baptized had put on Christ; which accords with Christ’s own declaration, “He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved” (Mark xvi. 16), and the command of the apostle Peter at the Pentecost, “Repent and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of the Lord Jesus” (Acts ii. 38). This practice of baptizing every person who desired to confess the Christian faith, thus indubitably observed during the apostolic age, was maintained by the whole Christian world, until the preaching of George Fox, about the middle of the seventeenth century; nor has it ever been questioned but by his disciples.2

Secondly: The design of Christian baptism.

It being the purpose of God in Christ to constitute his church visibly on earth, certain visible, palpable rites, or acted forms, became necessary, by which his gracious will concerning his people should be expressed on his part, and recognized on theirs. Such forms, in addition to the sure divine word of prophecy, were extensively provided under the Old Testament, by ordaining which God visibly prefigured the blessings of salvation, and by using which the true Israelite avowed his faith in the implied promises. They were, therefore, manifest seals of his covenant with them and of their covenant with him. The dispensation of the New Testament, or covenant, being eminently spiritual, and the way of salvation fully declared by the work of Christ, as set forth in the evangelical Scriptures, but more especially by the enlarged testimony of the Holy Ghost to our hearts, the rites commemorative of Christ were not required to be so many as those which, now done away by their fulfilment in Christ, had before prefigured him. Nay, though some such forms were necessary, our Lord was careful to teach us that his religion is not in form, but spirit, by ordaining (as has been shown, twenty-fifth Lord’s Day) only two, and those of the most simple character.

As, also, the gospel was first preached to the Jews, and the rites of the Old Testament were, though typical, eloquently illustrative of the gospel, our Lord in his condescending wisdom chose for his church such sacramental signs and seals as nearly resembled those of the obsolete dispensation. The two great sacramental types were circumcision and the passover: the first being the introduction of the new-born Israelite, or of the adult proselyte, to the blessings of the external covenant; the second, a personal confirmation of the covenant to and by the circumcised one. Circumcision signified “the putting away of the filth of the flesh” (1 Pet. iii. 21); but this was also signified by the “divers washings” (Heb. ix. 10), principally sprinkling of water and the blood of sacrifices. The passover, in which the sacrificed lamb, whose sprinkled blood saved the first-born of Israel from the destroying angel, was partaken of as food by the worshippers, typified Jesus, the Lamb of God, whose blood is the salvation of his people from the wrath of God, of which deliverance all who believe in him are partakers, as a family in common; but this redemption was also signified by all Levitical sacrifices of atonement. Thus, circumcision and the passover comprehended in their significance all the rites of the ancient economy, they together having in them the ideas of covenant, cleansing, redemption, and fellowship. The Lord’s supper, as we shall have farther occasion to show, was ordained in the place of the Paschal ceremony; our Lord having first stripped it of all pomp and unnecessary circumstance, according to the simplicity of his gospel, and made it as simple as a household meal, the beautiful sacrament of household love.

Baptism was ordained in the place of circumcision. That was a painful ordinance (Ex. iv. 25, 26), and, therefore, unsuited to the mercy of the gospel. Besides, while signifying the cleansing of the flesh, it had another meaning, rendered obsolete by the coming of Christ: the promise of the Messiah through the propagation of Abraham’s covenanted race. The other consentaneous sign of cleansing, washing, or more frequently sprinkling (water being commanded in the place of blood, because the sacrifice had ceased), was chosen as the primary sacrament. The idea of covenant was also preserved by this symbolical washing, as we read that Moses, after the giving of the moral law, “took the blood” “of peace-offerings” “and sprinkled it on the people, and said, Behold the blood of the covenant which the Lord hath made with you concerning all these words” (Ex. xxiv. 5–8). It is proper for you to mark here, though we shall speak of it again, how very simple and stripped of all other ceremony is the ordinance of baptism according to our Lord’s institution of it,—as simple as the washing or sprinkling with water.

We are now better prepared to see what was the end our Lord proposed in ordaining the sacrament of Christian baptism for the confirmation of our faith; and, following the order of our catechetical instructor, we shall first observe what it is, and then, what it is not.

I. The first question may be met by saying that Christian baptism is a sign, a seal, and a profession: a sign, as it is significant of certain truths; a seal, as it is an assurance of certain benefits; and a profession, as the recipient on his own part makes a profession to the church, and the church by baptizing him makes a profession to him on behalf of God.

  1. Christian baptism is a sign, being significant of certain truths.

What these truths are, we gather from the Answers to the 69th and 70th Questions:—

“How art thou admonished and assured by holy baptism, that the one sacrifice of Christ upon the cross is of real advantage to thee?”

“Thus: that Christ appointed this external washing with water, adding thereto this promise, that I am as certainly washed by his blood and spirit from all the pollution of my soul, that is, from all my sins, as I am washed externally with water, by which the filthiness of the body is commonly washed away.”

“What is it to be washed with the blood and spirit of Christ?”

“It is to receive of God the remission of sins freely, for the sake of Christ’s blood, which he shed for us by his sacrifice upon the cross; and also to be renewed by the Holy Ghost, and sanctified to be members of Christ; that we may more and more die unto sin, and lead holy and unblamable lives.”

The whole may be summed up as declaring the acceptableness of believing sinners to God the Father, through the merits of Jesus Christ, by the grace of the Holy Spirit. So we are baptized in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. For, although our eternal life comes from the Godhead, each of the persons constituting, in our blessed Trinity, the one God, has his peculiar office, according to the plan of redemption: the Father representing the authority and honor of the Godhead; the Son, as the incarnate mediator, making the atoning provision for the acceptance of his people; and the Holy Ghost, by his almighty energy, applying to the elect the benefits purchased by the Son, and conferred by the Father.

a. Christian baptism signifies the acceptableness of believing sinners to God the Father. Believers in the gospel receive “power (or the prerogative) to become the sons of God” (John i. 12). This adopted sonship is a restoration, though in a higher degree, of the sonship to God which man had before he fell. That relation he lost by sin; consequently, when his sin is expiated, pardoned, or washed away, he is restored to his place in the family of God. Hence, baptism is said to be, or rather it signifies, [for, strictly, the expression of the apostle Paul (Titus iii. 5) refers to the grace, and not the sacramental sign,] “The washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost.” The penitent is introduced to a new life, eternal life, having been begotten and born again by the power of God to be his Son; so he receives the washing to signify the change from the sin which made him offensive, to the righteousness which makes him acceptable, in the sight of God. All the advantages of adoption are promised by the adopting act; so the church says in her baptismal form: “When we are baptized in the name of the Father, God the Father witnesseth and sealeth unto us that he doth make an eternal covenant of grace with us, and adopts us for his children and heirs, and, therefore, will provide us with every good thing, and avert all evil, or turn it to our good.”

b. Christian baptism signifies the shedding of Christ’s blood in his one sacrifice on the cross for the remission of sins. The life of the sinner, being forfeited to the law, could be redeemed only by the life of his surety or substitute, for the penalty must be satisfied. Hence, Christ died for us; and as, according to the Scripture, the blood is the life (Lev. xvii. 11), the shedding of his blood is put for the offering of his life, that is, for his death. Thus, all the typical sacrifices of atonement were sacrifices of life, for “without the shedding of blood there is no remission” (Heb. ix. 22). The blood of the offered victim was, in the great sacrifice of atonement, sprinkled upon the propitiatory or covering of the ark which contained the broken law, “for an atonement,” “because of the uncleanness of the children of Israel, and because of their transgressions in all their sins” (Lev. xvi. 16). Where the sacrifice was for an individual, the blood of the victim, poured out upon the altar, was specially sprinkled by the priest on the person of the sinner. Thus baptism brings to mind both the pouring out of Christ’s blood before God as a propitiation to the broken law, and the special benefit of that blood to each individual penitent. Guilt (or liableness to punishment) is throughout the Scripture considered as defilement; so the taking away of guilt is aptly expressed by washing, to represent which, simple sprinkling was considered, under the Old Testament, sufficient, as the Reformed churches hold it to be under the New. From the sacrificial substitution of Christ for his people flow all the benefits obtained by his representative work; hence, the church in her baptismal form says: “When we are baptized in the name of the Son, the Son sealeth unto us that he doth wash us in his blood from all our sins, incorporating us into the fellowship of his death and resurrection, so that we are freed from all our sins and accounted righteous before God.”

c. Christian baptism signifies the gracious operation of the Holy Ghost.

As has been stated, it is the doctrine of Scripture that the blessings of redemption are applied to the soul by the personal agency of the Holy Ghost. Thus the apostle, speaking of the whole church, says: “By one Spirit are we all baptized into one body,” i. e. the body of Christ (1 Cor. xii. 13); again: “Through him (Christ) we both (Jews and Gentiles) have access by one Spirit unto the Father” (Eph. ii. 18). The regeneration, by which the sinner becomes a child of God, is the work of the Spirit: “Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God” (John iii. 5–7). The washing away of sins with the blood of the cross is by the Holy Spirit. “Ye are washed, ye are sanctified, ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus and by the Spirit of our God” (1 Cor. vi. 11). The blood of Christ is the instrument of the washing; the Holy Spirit is the agent, or the washer. The Holy Spirit seals, or marks as set apart or sanctified, to God, those who believe. “In whom (Christ), after that ye believed, ye were sealed with that Holy Spirit of promise, (or promised Spirit,) which is the earnest of our inheritance” (Eph. i. 13, 14). Besides the washing of remission, by which the guilt of Christ’s people is taken away, there is also a washing away by the Spirit of the pollution which sin leaves upon the soul, ordinarily and technically called sanctification. The consequence of this latter cleansing, joined to the regenerating, enlightening, and strengthening influences of the Spirit, is the production and gradual but sure growth of all those graces or virtues of religion which constitute the Christian character, until it is complete in glory; which graces are, therefore, called “the fruit of the Spirit” (Gal. v. 22, 23). All these several operations of the Spirit are signified in baptism. “I indeed baptize you with water; but one mightier than I cometh, the latchet of whose shoes I am not worthy to unloose; he shall baptize you with the Holy Ghost and with fire;” fire expressing the intense energy of the Spirit to purify (Luke iii. 16). The baptism of John was (imperfectly) Christian baptism, because it referred to Christ; but it was not Christian baptism complete or in full, for it did not refer to the Holy Ghost. Hence the apostles and those with them in the chamber of the Pentecost, who, doubtless, had received the preliminary baptism of John, were not baptized again with water, because they had the baptism of the Holy Spirit itself; but, as we read in Acts xix. 1–5, those, who had received John’s baptism and not the Holy Ghost, were baptized again. So the apostle Peter said to the mixed multitude: “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ, for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the Holy Ghost, for the promise is unto you and to your children, and to all that are afar off, even as many as the Lord our God shall call” (Acts ii. 38, 39). The promise, in order to receive which they were to be baptized, was that of the Holy Ghost (compare 33d with 16–18): “It shall come to pass in those days that I will pour out my Spirit upon all flesh” (Joel ii. 28). A similar promise of the Spirit, as represented in baptism, was given by Isaiah (xliv. 3): “I will pour water upon him that is thirsty, and floods upon the dry ground; I will pour my Spirit upon thy seed, and my blessing upon their offspring;” and also by Ezekiel (xxxvi. 25–27): “Then will I sprinkle clean water upon you, and ye shall be clean; from all your filthiness and from all your idols will I cleanse you. A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you; and I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh; and I will put my Spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes, and ye shall keep my commandments and do them.” Thus, in the application of the water is the pouring out or sprinkling seen. Hence the church in her baptismal form says: “When we are baptized in the name of the Holy Ghost, the Holy Ghost assures us by this holy sacrament, that he will dwell in us, and sanctify us to be members of Christ, applying unto us that which we have in Christ, namely, the washing away of our sins and the daily renewing of our lives, till we shall finally be presented without spot or wrinkle among the assembly of the elect in life eternal.”

  1. Christian baptism is a seal, as it is an assurance of certain benefits. A seal is added and attached to a written deed, as an attestation of the covenant. A sacrament does not reveal the benefits of grace; that is done by the word; but it confirms the testimony of the word. A sacrament is not itself a covenant; that is already made; but it is a seal or assurance of the covenant (twenty-fifth Lord’s Day); thus the apostle, speaking of Abraham, says: “He received the sign of circumcision, a seal of the righteousness of the faith which he had, yet being uncircumcised” (Rom. iv. 11). The covenant was made with him while yet uncircumcised; then circumcision was added as a seal or visible assurance. But a seal without a covenant has neither value or meaning; so, except there be first a covenant with God, baptism, though externally applied, assures nothing. It is a seal only of the righteousness of faith. But when there is faith to apprehend the covenant, then baptism is a sure seal and pledge of the benefits covenanted. Hence the Christian disciple in our Catechism, believing the promise of the gospel covenant, hesitates not to say: “I am as certainly washed by the blood and Spirit of Christ from all pollution of my soul, that is from all my sins, as I am washed externally with water.” So, also, in the baptismal form, the church, taking for granted faith in the covenant, says: “Baptism is a seal and undoubted (rather indubitable) testimony that we have an eternal covenant of grace with God;” and in the thanksgiving, after the baptism of the infants of believers, bids us say: “Almighty God and merciful Father, we thank and praise thee that thou hast forgiven us and our children all our sins through the blood of thy beloved Son, Jesus Christ, and received us through thy Holy Spirit as members of thy only-begotten Son, and adopted us to be thy children, and sealed and confirmed the same unto us by holy baptism.” All these enumerated blessings are promised unto faith: if we have faith, baptism seals them unto us; if we have not faith, we have no right to the baptism, which supposes a previous covenant; for, in such case, baptism is unmeaning and valueless, as a seal without an instrument or deed.

What baptism seals has been shown in what it signifies; for the seal and the sign are for the same things.

a. When we are baptized in the name of the Father, it seals to us our adoption by God as his children.

b. When we are baptized in the name of the Son, it seals to us the remission of our sins through his blood.

c. When we are baptized in the name of the Holy Ghost, it seals to us all the gracious influences of the Holy Spirit.

  1. Christian baptism is a profession, or formal, open declaration of the truths thus signified and sealed.

As the church is visible, so the profession must be visible. Thus,

a. The recipient of baptism openly professes, not only his faith in the covenant of God to him, but his covenant to God, that he will be (1.) a child of God in all holy obedience; (2.) a follower of Christ’s doctrine and example; and (3.) a zealous cultivator of the Spirit’s grace, without which he is nothing, and can do nothing. In brief, he avows himself to the church, and before the world, to be a Christian. As the church, in her sacramental form, says: “Whereas, in all covenants, there are contained two parts, therefore are we by God, through baptism, admonished of and obliged (i. e. put under obligations) unto new obedience: namely, that we cleave to this one God, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost; that we trust in him, and love him with all our hearts, with all our souls, with all our mind, and with all our strength; that we forsake the world, crucify our old nature, and walk in a new and holy life.” This is our profession in receiving baptism.

b. The church, on the other hand, as in the place of God, professes unto the person baptized before the world, that he is received among the children of God, the followers of Christ, and the saints of the Holy Ghost,—that is, into the visible company of Christian believers.

Hence baptism has been universally regarded to be the initiatory rite to the Christian church, as circumcision was the rite initiatory to the former covenant.

II. What Christian baptism is not.

This second point of our proposed inquiry may be thought to have been sufficiently met in discussing the first; but the 72d and 73d Questions, with their Answers, show that our instructor means to rebuke the error of those who consider the outward sacrament of baptism a real washing away of sins and a regeneration by the Holy Ghost; or (what is nearly the same thing) that the graces of remission and regeneration certainly accompany the outward sign. That no one may so abuse their souls, or pervert the language of our church, let us consider:

  1. That “the blood of Jesus Christ His Son cleanseth us from all sin,” and the grace of the Holy Spirit alone renews the soul. The cleansing and the renewal are both spiritual and internal; nor can they possibly be effected in the soul by an outward application of water to the body.

  2. That the sacrament, being only a sign and a seal, does not confer the blessings, either by itself or by accompanying grace, but supposes the blessings to have been already conferred by a covenant already entered into.

  3. That the texts of Scripture usually quoted to sustain these heterodox opinions, are misinterpreted. Thus:

a. The text is cited from the epistle to Titus: “Not by works of righteousness which we have done, but according to his mercy he saved us, by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost” (iii. 5). Our instructor rightly supposes that baptism, here meant, is referred to only as figuratively signifying, and, to the believer, sealing the grace of the Holy Ghost; but that the form does not confer the grace, is strongly asserted by the apostle when he says that we are saved only according to the “mercy” of God, and “not by works of righteousness” (by which the usage of Paul was to designate ceremonial compliances) which we have done or can do.

b. The second text cited is in the address of Ananias to Saul (Acts xxii. 16): “Arise and be baptized and wash away thy sins, calling on the name of the Lord.” By this is meant that he should, in receiving baptism, give open token that he believed his sins to be washed away, and so be confirmed in his faith by the sign and the seal. If the expression be taken as absolutely literal, he was commanded to wash away his own sins by the sacramental waters,—a stretch of interpretation few are willing to take, as our sins are washed away only by the Holy Ghost with the blood of Christ, and as no one washes himself in baptism, but the recipient is washed.

c. Our Lord’s words to Nicodemus are sometimes quoted in this connection: “Except a man be born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God.” There are good doubts whether baptism (outward) is here referred to at all; but assuming that it is, there are two births spoken of: of water and of the Spirit; and it by no means follows that he who is born of water is necessarily born of the spirit, or that he who is born of the spirit is necessarily born of water. He must be born of each and of both. It is nowhere said, that he who is born of water has certainly entered the kingdom of God; but it is everywhere asserted, that to be born of the Spirit is to enter the divine kingdom. He who wilfully refuses to enter the kingdom of God upon earth by baptism, may well fear being refused admission to the kingdom above; but he who is truly born of the Spirit, is as truly a child of God and an heir of eternal life. One may be deprived of baptism by uncontrollable circumstances; but if he be born of the Spirit, his “record is on high.”

d. One more text: “He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved” (Mark xvi. 16). This is not asserting that a baptized person is necessarily a believer; on the contrary, it is added: “he that believeth not shall be damned,” i. e. whether baptized or not. Faith certainly saves; baptism does not, except it be received in faith.

Let the apostle Peter sum up the matter: “Baptism now doth save us [not the putting away of the filth of the flesh (or the external cleansing), but the answer of a good conscience toward God] by the resurrection of Jesus Christ” (1 Peter iii. 21). Reliance upon any external form is going back to the unspiritual, self-righteous superstition of the Jews under the old law; reliance on the grace of the Spirit in the gospel is the saving faith of the New Testament.

May God make us worthy partakers of his Spirit, and keep us faithful to our baptismal obligations! Amen.

1 We take these two sections together, because, though divided for the convenience of recitation on successive Lord’s Days, and the subject requires more than one discourse, we cannot treat of it properly without referring to the matter contained in both at each stage of the exposition.

2 This statement needs some qualification, if we allow the Valentinians and Manicheans to have been Christians. There was also a Carthaginian woman, Quintilla, who preached that baptism was useless, and who had some followers. The Messalians, a small absurd sect, are thought by some to have rejected baptism, but it is not certain. See Wall, Part II. ch. 5.