Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture V. Necessity of a Mediator

Fifth Lord’s Day

Hitherto our meditations on the Catechism have been sad and bitter, though, I trust, not unprofitable or without glimpses of comfort. The shadows of the curse have been heavy, yet the morning light of the Sun of Righteousness has gilded the horizon. It is the method of Christ’s Spirit thus to humble that he may exalt us, and, by convincing us of our guilt, to prepare us for hearing with great joy the glad tidings of salvation; nor could we understand how we may be saved through the representative righteousness of Christ, did we not first see our ruin through the fall of our first father. “The law” is “our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we” may “be justified by faith.” Blessed be God, that when our sense of eternal danger makes us cry out: What must we do to be saved? He has himself given us the answer by his only begotten Son, our Elder Brother! Yea, blessed be his holy name, that he honors sinful men with the happy office of proclaiming the full and free salvation to their fellow-sinners! O that his grace would strengthen me, his most unworthy servant, this day and at all times of my ministry, to make known the methods of his mercy so clearly that all of you, my dear hearers, may by the same Spirit be comforted and built up in the faith of Jesus Christ, the only “name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved!”

Hereto assist us, the Almighty God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. Amen!

Having shown us our condemnation under the curse denounced against sinners, the Catechism leads us to ask if there be any way of deliverance from the irresistible wrath of God, and gives a gleam of hope in the answer to Question the 12th. “God will have his justice satisfied; and, therefore, we must make this full satisfaction, either by ourselves or by another.”

If, then, we may escape through a full satisfaction, for the dishonor we have done to the holy law of God, can we ourselves make such a satisfaction? This is declared to be impossible, in the answer to Question the 13th. “By no means; but, on the contrary, we daily increase our debt.”

But if we look for help to the creatures of God, is there any one of them all who could make such satisfaction for us? The Catechism replies, in the answer to Question the 14th, “None; for, first: God will not punish any other creature for the sin which man hath committed; and, further: no mere creature can sustain the burden of God’s eternal wrath, so as to deliver others from it.”

Thus denied all hope from mere creatures, what kind of a surety must we look for? Ans. 15th. “For one who is very man, and perfectly righteous; and yet more powerful than all creatures, that is, one who is also very God.”

This is our lesson proper for to-day; but if you glance over that of the Sixth Lord’s Day, you will see the doctrines of the 14th and 15th Questions and answers there more thoroughly opened, for which reason we shall now touch them but lightly, giving our attention chiefly to the 12th and 13th, comprising, however, the treatment of the whole doctrine in both Lord’s Days under the following heads:

First: The impossibility of our salvation by our own works.

Secondly: The possibility of our salvation through the righteousness of a sufficient substitute.

Thirdly: The qualities necessary to a sufficient substitute, or mediator, for us with God.

Fourthly: The provision of such a substitute, or mediator, in our Lord Jesus Christ, as we learn from the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments.

First: The impossibility of our salvation by our own good works.

This is taught us, according to Scripture, in the 12th and 13th Questions and answers: 1. “God will have his justice satisfied.” 2. “We cannot,” of ourselves, make such satisfaction, “but, on the contrary, we daily increase our debt.”

  1. “God will have his justice satisfied.” This, you will remember, we argued at length in our lecture on the Fourth Lord’s Day, when treating of the 10th and 11th Questions and answers; but we may, not unprofitably, repeat the main points.

a. The truth of God demands it; for he has expressly and repeatedly declared that “the soul which sinneth, it shall die;” “Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them”; and that he “will by no means clear the guilty.” It cannot, for a moment, be supposed that God will deny himself. What he has said, he will execute. Whatever sophisms the carnal heart may invent, “let God be true and every man a liar.”

b. The holiness of God demands it; for there is such a contrariety in sin to his own purity that he cannot look upon the sinner without abhorrence; and, as his infinite blessedness results from his infinite holiness, it must be that the result of sin will be misery.

c. The authority of God demands it; for if, as the Supreme Ruler, he has promulgated his law, and one of his subjects break that law, he is defied to his face, and, should he not execute the penalty incurred, the transgressor will seem to triumph, and the divine rule cease to be infallible, giving encouragement and immunity to sin.

d. The care of God for the welfare of his subject-creatures demands it; since his law was given to guard the happiness of each from the injurious encroachment or remissness of any, and sin is a positive and wide-spreading injury, any tolerance of sin on his part would be to allow of wrong being done by the sinner against his fellow-subjects, who should have the divine protection.

e. The moral instruction of God’s rational subjects demands it; for, only from his revelation of his will in his word and works can we know what he requires of us, the distinction in his sight between right and wrong, and the estimate he sets upon righteousness and upon wrong-doing. If, therefore, he allow sin to pass without punishing the sinner, how can we or any observer of his doings know the way of right and reward from the way of wrong and punishment?

Thus we see that the escape of a single sinner from punishment, though he may have committed but a single sin, would cause a fatal doubt of the divine truth, of the divine holiness, of the divine authority, of the divine goodness, and of the divine will. Truly, therefore, asserts the Catechism: “God will have his justice satisfied,” and until that satisfaction be rendered, we cannot escape punishment. As certainly as God is unchangeable, the unjustified sinner must die.

  1. “We cannot, of ourselves, make satisfaction to the divine justice; but, on the contrary, we daily increase our debt.”

Debt, though now commonly used for pecuniary obligation, really signifies that which is due, whatever it be. Our debt to God is twofold: The penalty we have incurred, and the constant obedience required; both the discharge of that penalty, and the rendering of that obedience, are necessary to the satisfaction of the law to which we are subject; but in neither part can we render satisfaction to divine justice.

a. Not by discharging the penalty. For, as has been shown, the guilt of man, that is, his desert of punishment, God considers so great that no suffering of man can ever expiate it, and hence his punishment will be so long as any guilt of his remains; which, consequently, if man be left to himself, will be perpetual or eternal. We should be continually enduring punishment, but never finishing the payment of the penalty; and our expiation, being ever imperfect, would be prolonged forever.

But some may ask: Will not God allow us to atone for our past offences by future obedience, or, in other words, make up for past transgressions by our repentance and faithful service after this? The answer must be in the negative. When a penalty has been deserved it must be suffered. No remorse can destroy the sinful act done or its consequences. The law has been broken, the authority of God has been insulted, the evil against our fellow-creatures has been wrought, the sentence has been pronounced; no regrets can annihilate the past. Is it not so under human law? Is remorse ever considered an expiation of crime, or accepted in lieu of the penalty? The thief goes to prison, the murderer to the gallows, though they weep never so bitterly or promise never so well. Sometimes, indeed, the penalty may be mitigated, but it would be only because the moral sensibility displayed by the culprit shows that his guilt was less, not that his tears had washed it away. Is it not so under God’s natural laws? Can the remorse of the sensualist repair the peace he has destroyed? or the tears of the drunkard restore to him the health and vigor he has wasted? And shall a few pangs of the sinner’s soul, caused rather by dread of suffering than honest sorrow for crime, suffice to hide from the holy God all trace of his offences against wise, good, and just law? Let it once be admitted as a principle, that sorrow for sin atones for it, and the value of law is at an end. Again: The law of God is so broad that it requires all our service at all times. Every thought, every word, every act, every moment of our lives belong to God. All our mind, all our heart, all our soul, all our might, belong to God. We cannot, without sin, alienate our strength for a single moment from the duty which belongs to that moment. If, therefore, we have at any time failed to render an entire obedience, we can never compensate for it; because, even though we should afterward render an entire obedience, it is no more than what we owe to God at the time, and there can be no excess or surplus of service which may be put to the supply of the former deficiency. This principle is acknowledged in the administration of human laws; for they, requiring good conduct at all times, admit no previous or subsequent virtue as an expiation of crime. Though a man be honest all the rest of his life, if he, in any one moment, steal, he is punished as a thief; if he commit but one murder, he is executed. The penalty may sometimes, through a merciful policy, be mitigated, but can never, in strict justice, be remitted.

b. Neither can we satisfy divine justice by a constant obedience; which is the other part of the debt we owe to God. Granting, for the sake of argument, that all the penal consequences of our past sins were removed from us, and we were allowed to begin anew our probation, we could not, if left to ourselves and our present nature, satisfy the requirements of the divine law, but, “on the contrary,” should “daily increase our debt;” for, as has been shown in our previous lessons (particularly on the Second and Third Lord’s Days), the natural consequence of sin is the depravity of our moral disposition and faculties, so that we are from our very birth “wholly incapable of doing any good, and inclined to all wickedness,” “except we be regenerated by the Spirit of God.” Upon this depravity of our nature we have already argued so fully that no farther proof need be adduced. It is clearly a doctrine of all Scripture, especially that which declares, on the one hand, that by the deeds of the law no flesh can be justified, and, on the other, that sincere repentance and its fruits of a Christian life are wrought in the believer by the grace of the Holy Spirit, converting and sanctifying his soul. The Holy Spirit is the Spirit of Christ, and the grace of the Spirit is bestowed only upon those who by faith receive Christ as their Saviour because the Saviour of sinners. If reformation does occur, it is only through the operation of faith in the Gospel which reveals the atonement, and is, therefore, consequent on the atonement. Even then the reformation is never complete in this life, and the more a penitent receives of divine grace, the more is he convinced that “it is God who worketh in” him “both to will and to do of his good pleasure.” Without the Spirit of Christ we are utterly unable to render any of that service which the law requires for our justification; and if we be regenerated so that we lead good lives, the credit is due, not to us for our justification, but to him, whose is the only righteousness which God will accept as sufficient to honor the law under which we live and by which we shall be tried.

Thus we see that in no sense are we able to satisfy for ourselves the justice of God, but are daily increasing our debt, and heaping up for ourselves wrath against the day of wrath. Such would be our miserable condition in this world, and such our terrible fate in the world to come, were there no method provided for our salvation, other than that originally proposed to man: our personal innocence and obedience. But, blessed be God, we are not so cut off from hope; for we learn:

Secondly: The possibility of our salvation through the righteousness of a sufficient substitute.

“God will have his justice satisfied, and, therefore, we must make this full satisfaction either by ourselves or by another.” (Ans. 12th.)

The necessity of satisfaction having been shown, and, also that we cannot make it of ourselves, a new question arises: Will God accept of satisfaction rendered for us by another?

The whole evangelical Scriptures, and our Church in all her confessions according to Scripture, answer: Yes. We freely admit that no such method of salvation could have been discovered by the reason of men; but contend that, having been revealed to us by God himself, the infinitely wise and holy Sovereign, it is perfectly consonant with the highest reason.

  1. God has declared that the righteousness of Christ, when accepted by the faith of the sinner as offered on his behalf, is accepted as a sufficient ground of his justification; as says the apostle: “All have sinned, and come short of the glory of God; being justified freely by his grace, through the redemption which is in Christ Jesus; whom God hath set forth to be a propitiation through faith in his blood, to declare his righteousness for the remission of sins that are past through the forbearance of God; to declare, I say, his righteousness; that he might be just and the justifier of him which believeth in Jesus.” This puts beyond doubt the fact, that God does justify the believing sinner on the ground that a sufficient righteousness has been offered on his behalf by another. We may not, therefore, deny the propriety of such an arrangement without impeaching the justice of God. But,

  2. It is also perfectly consonant with sound reason. The design of God in the denunciation of penalties on the breaking of his law, certainly was not the destruction of his subjects, but to maintain the divine authority of his law and to deter man from transgression. Now, if by the provision of a sufficient substitute for the sinner, three things can be secured, God is just in receiving the sinner again into favor. Those three things are: a. The honor of the divine law. b. The maintenance of the divine authority, so that no encouragement is given that sin will go unpunished. c. The reformation of the transgressor, so that he returns to obedience.

a. For the first: The honor of the divine law; it is necessary that God should show his infinite estimation of its excellence. This is done by the perfect submission and obedience to the law of the sufficient Surety, that in the greatness of his service, the dishonor which we have done the law may be covered by a transcendent glory. And what greater honor could God have given to his law than by sending forth his only begotten and coequal Son to become in our nature its faithful servant, and obey all its requisitions, actual and penal, on our behalf? Must not the spectacle of the divine Lawgiver himself condescending to fulfil all its demands as a voluntary servant, yield in the sight of all holy creatures a testimony to its excellence and invest it with a glory infinitely higher and more convincing than the obedience of our whole race, or of myriads of worlds like ours?

b. For the second: The maintenance of the divine authority; it is necessary that God sternly require the penalties which we have incurred to be fully endured by a sufficient Surety, in such a manner as will show beyond a doubt the displeasure of God against sin and his determination not to allow it to go unpunished. And how could God more plainly indicate his just will that no sin shall be tolerated with impunity, and display his deep abhorrence of transgression, than by requiring the penalties which we have incurred to the uttermost from his own beloved Son, when incarnate as our representative? Could the eternal suffering of all our race, of myriads of worlds like ours, exhibit the divine wrath against the sinner, in any degree approaching the terrible anguish of body and soul which the innocent holy Jesus endured under the displeasure of the Father?

c. For the third: The reformation of the sinner who is pardoned on account of the substituted righteousness, so that he returns to obedience; it is necessary that the same grace which pardons should inspire him with a new life, with desire, and strength to keep the law he before has broken; else the pardon would be to let loose a rebel unsubdued, and an evil-doer unreclaimed. And how wisely and certainly has God secured the repentance and sanctification of the ransomed transgressor, by making the same faith which admits him to a discharge from condemnation effectual, by the grace of the Holy Ghost, to purify his heart, to work in him love, and to strengthen him for overcoming the world. For Christ saves none from wrath whom he does not save from the power of sin; none have the grace of faith without the grace of repentance; none have a part in Christ who do not receive the Holy Ghost to dwell in their souls; and none are admitted to heaven without being first made holy and pure. Where can be found such generous and persuasive arguments to cease from sinning and do the will of God, as are forced upon the soul by the mercy of God through the devoted love of Christ? Who, that has a heart at all sensitive to grateful emotion, would wilfully insult his deliverer that died for him? How are we encouraged, notwithstanding our weakness, and the pressure of temptation from within and without, to attempt the difficult path of duty, when we are assured that God, for Christ’s sake, will work in us “both to will and to do of his good pleasure;” that all power is in the hand of Christ to overrule all circumstances for the safety of his people; and that heaven, with all its benedictions and felicities, is before us as an eternal recompense for our brief trials, an exceedingly glorious reward of our perseverance in the footsteps of Christ?

While presenting to you this condensed argument for the vindication of divine justice in redeeming the penitent sinner, we should be far from the thought that we have all the divine reasons for such an arrangement. There are depths in the divine purposes which no created mind can fathom, as there is a range of the divine operations which no created mind can comprehend. Divine truth, so far as it is revealed to us here in our present state, must be communicated through the medium of human language, which has been framed (a very few words excepted) with reference only to things of this world, and all illustrations of the divine working must be taken from facts of which we are conversant. Thus, the Scriptures (and our Church according to the Scriptures) exemplify the juridical proceedings of our divine Sovereign by the methods of human jurisdiction; borrowing from them its terms, as debt, penalty, guilt, pardon, justification, atonement, and the like; or, at the farthest, we look for explanations to what we can discover of the divine administration in providence over this present economy. But what is the narrow sphere of this little world, so petty a province considered by itself, to the vast empire over which our God sways his sovereignty? What is the brief time of the earth’s few ages to the eternity past and future, through which the omniscient purposes of God are carried on by the mighty working of his omnipresent will? What is the aggregated fortune of all our race, if separated from the rest of the spiritual creation, to the moral well-being of the countless families, who depend on our God for all that constitutes the life of life? Of what we can discover respecting God’s dealings here and among men, though we push our inquiries to the utmost limit, we must say with the adoring patriarch: “Lo! these are parts of his ways; but how small a portion is heard of him?” The full doctrine, or, if the expression be allowed, the complete theory of the atonement; the reasons for its methods; the extent of its purposes; the variety of its results; the number and character and condition of the moral beings that are and are to be affected by its consequences, can be understood only by the Infinite Author of the scheme. There must, after all our study and reasoning out of the Scripture and the analogies of providence, remain mysteries in the plan of salvation utterly above our reach; and our best illustrations fall infinitely short of the vast idea.

Suppose, for example, that the Allwise Father were himself teaching his heavenly servants the doctrine of the redemption provided for man, would he employ the terms and the analogies with which the Holy Spirit in the Scriptures condescends to teach us? Must we not believe that he would uplift the attention of those apt, long-disciplined intelligences to great principles of the divine government, but partially revealed to us because we are capable only of partially understanding them?

We cheerfully and with devout reverence admit, nay, would earnestly contend, that the principles of the divine government on which the atonement is based, as it is revealed to us, must be the same throughout all its extent—and, especially, that main principle of justification for the believing penitents of our human race through the substituted obedience and suffering of the Son of God in our nature as our representative; but what we mean to assert is, that that very principle is and can be only partially, very partially understood by us even through the revelation God has given of it to us, because from the condition we are in, the revelation must be confined within comparatively narrow limits. Thus the Apostle Paul speaks of “the unsearchable riches of Christ,” and of “the love of Christ which passeth knowledge;” and again with the same reference he exclaims: “O, the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! how unsearchable are his judgments and his ways past finding out!”

This is certain, the testimony of Scripture being so clear as to allow no doubt, that the influence of the plan of redemption extends far beyond the Church which it translates from the depth of condemnation to the height of heavenly glory; nay, we may believe that the radiance of the Sun of Righteousness sheds fresh magnificence over all the spiritual universe of God’s creation. The Apostle Peter declares that “the angels desire to look into the things of redemption;” and Paul that “principalities and powers in heavenly places” will be taught and are now taught “by the church (that is, by God’s dealings with the church) the manifold wisdom of God.” Jesus is declared to be the observed “(seen) of angels;” and the Lamb that was slain will be eternally in the midst of the throne; the eternal object of admiration, adoration, and praise to all the angelic hosts, who will alternate their responsive hallelujahs with glorified believers, and join with them in the unanimous, unending choruses of acclaiming homage before the throne of God and his Christ. What the effects of the evangelical scheme on other worlds may be, we know not and dare not conjecture; but this we are certain of, that it reveals to all his holy creatures who contemplate the divine character, its very highest glory, his most manifold wisdom and love and power. It is “to the praise of the glory of his grace that he has made us accepted in the Beloved.”

God has manifested the glory of his majestic attributes in many ways, some of which we know, but more of which we cannot understand; yet it may without irreverence be asserted, that were it not for the shining of his glory in the face of his Son Jesus Christ, the full beauty and the most attractive charm of his infinite love would not be known. His holy servants would forever have adored his several excellences, but could not have perceived their admirable harmony as now they behold his wisdom devising and his power executing the wonderful plan of salvation for the sinner, in which justice and goodness combine to reveal mercy. The justice of God, had it taken its unqualified course in punishing the sinner,—the goodness of God, had its bounties been confined only to the deserving and guiltless,—would indeed, have received and been worthy of all praise from all holy creatures. Still those most glorious attributes are naturally essential to the divine Sovereign; we could not imagine the Holy Father of intelligent creatures otherwise than just and good. The exercise of those divine qualities is necessary to the idea of God; but that they could meet in blessing on the souls of guilty sinners, no created mind could ever have conjectured or believed to be possible had not God made it manifest. His mercy surprises and startles the moral universe with a mild and exquisite glory, transcending all other emanations from the light unapproachable in which the mystery of his being dwells. It is brighter than justice, softer than goodness; for it is justice and goodness blending their beams in mercy,—his choice, his delight, the good pleasure of his sovereign will.

Now, dear hearers, let us learn and carry away with us the practical inferences, from the doctrine thus far developed.

First: Our utter helplessness under our deserved condemnation.

God will have his justice satisfied. Who of us can escape from his hands, or bear the fiery vengeance of his curse? O, vain and impious is the expectation of the sinner from the goodness or pity of God, while his justice with flaming sword stands between to execute the sentence of the law.

Secondly: Our certain salvation, if, with penitent hearts, we accept of the suretyship of Christ.

It is the method God has provided, because he delights to save. It is the method which magnifies his justice infinitely more than our eternal death. It is the method by which we may be transformed from deep corruption into holy servants of his will forever.

Thirdly: Our gracious obligation to spread the knowledge of this mercy among our fellow-sinners, for their immortal good; the joy of angels; our own reward, and the glory of God our Saviour.