Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture XXVII. The Resurrection of the Body

Twenty-second Lord’s Day

Every careful reader of Scripture must be struck with the prominence given to the doctrine of the resurrection in the New Testament. Our blessed Lord taught it plainly in several emphatic passages, as when he said: “Whoso eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood hath eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day;” and when he comforted Martha at the grave of her brother: “Thy brother shall rise again. . . . I am the resurrection and the life;” and, more particularly, when he told the cavilling Jews: “Verily, verily, I say unto you, the hour is coming when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God, and they that hear shall live. . . . Marvel not at this; for the hour is coming, in the which all that are in the graves shall hear his voice and shall come forth; they that have done good unto the resurrection of life, and they that have done evil unto the resurrection of damnation.” All the apostles treat of it as not merely a pleasing expectation, but a radical truth of Christianity. They taught it to the multitudes of the Pentecost; for we find that the Sadducees were especially grieved because they “preached through Jesus the resurrection from the dead.” So Paul was mocked at by the Athenians, because “he preached unto them Jesus and the resurrection”; and, in defending himself before Felix, he professed that he believed “all things which are written in the law and in the prophets, and had hope towards God (which the Jews also allowed) that there shall be a resurrection of the dead, both of the just and the unjust.” He lays a like stress upon it in his epistles; as in Romans, where he speaks of “waiting for the adoption, even the redemption, of the body”; and in that noble chapter, the xvth of 1st Corinthians, where, having demonstrated and expounded it at great length, he adds, as the proper practical inference: “Therefore, my beloved brethren, be ye steadfast, immovable, always abounding in the work of the Lord, forasmuch as your labor is not in vain in the Lord.” So the other apostles united in carrying the faith of the churches forward to the grand consummation of the evangelical system, “the restitution of all things,” when the bodies of Christ’s saints would be fashioned “like unto his glorious body.” Indeed, such courage and comfort had the early believers from this article of our creed, that they exulted amidst the tortures of martyrdom; and their persecutors, on one occasion, burnt even the bones of those that had been slain for Christ, and scattered their ashes on the waters of a rapid stream,1 in vain attempt to take away the sublime hope from the surviving confessors.

Most gladly, therefore, should we avail ourselves of the opportunity and help afforded us by the lesson of to-day, in harmony with Scripture, to study this cardinal doctrine as fully as our time will permit.

Let us remember, however, first, that the resurrection of the body is purely a doctrine of divine Scripture. There is no trace of its ever having been held by any man who had not the aid of revelation. Many of the ancients, Egyptian, Greek, and Roman, had hopes, by no means clear or well assured, of the soul’s immortality, but the resurrection of the body was not dreamed of by any philosophical sect; and when proclaimed by “the gospel,” which “brought life and immortality to light,” it was received with ridicule on every side. We have seen that the Athenians mocked at it, and thought that “Jesus and the resurrection,” which Paul preached on Mars Hill, were two “strange” or new “gods.” Pliny, the celebrated naturalist, and foremost among the Latin writers on science, who flourished about the time that Paul preached at Rome, and probably was not wholly ignorant of this Christian belief, holds language most extraordinary: “The chief comfort man hath for his imperfections in nature is this, that even God is not omnipotent; and some things are beyond his reach. For neither is he able to work his own death, were he never so desirous of it, as man can do when he is tired of life (the best gift bestowed on him amidst so many miseries); neither can he endow man with immortality (everlasting life), nor yet recall, raise, and revive those that are once departed and dead.”2 Celsus, the bitter reviler of Christianity, laughs at it as “a hope of worms, a filthy and disgusting thing, which God neither can nor will bring to pass.” Julian, notorious as the Apostate, an elegant writer, and of no mean rank as a philosopher, in his frequent attacks upon Christianity, shows more spleen against this doctrine than any other. Justin Martyr sums up his argument on the resurrection (a fragment of which has reached us) in words like these: “We see that our blessed Saviour throughout all the gospel declares the salvation of our flesh. Why, then, do we hearken to the pernicious maxims of infidels, who impudently swerve from the truth by owning that the soul only is immortal and incorruptible, but the body corruptible and perishable. This we learned from Plato and Pythagoras before we knew the truth. If our Saviour has taught us no more than this, he has taught us nothing more than those philosophers. But he has made a new and wonderful revelation to mankind; for, truly, new and wonderful it is for God to promise, not only to preserve that which is incorruptible in incorruption, but to bestow also incorruption on that which is corruptible.” It is, therefore, to the word of God alone that we must go for our “lively hope,” humbly employing our reason to follow and acknowledge the wisdom from on high; for, though it was beyond the power of reason to discover the resurrection, it is fully within the province of that faculty to perceive and comprehend the truth of it.

Let us take for our discussion the very natural order suggested by the answer to the 57th Question.

It speaks of what occurs “after this life”; that is, after what is commonly called death, when the soul is separated from the body. Now we ask,

First: What becomes of the soul?

Secondly: What becomes of the body?

Thirdly: What will be the final state of both body and soul?

First: What becomes of the soul “after this life”?

  1. It does not perish. It must continue to exist, because after death is the judgment; and exist forever, because from the judgment “the wicked go away into everlasting punishment, and the righteous into life eternal.” The words everlasting and eternal mean precisely the same, and translate one Greek word, so that if the righteous will be rewarded eternally, the wicked will be punished eternally; the souls of both, the wicked and the righteous, are imperishable; for, though the term “life” is put for the blessedness of the righteous, it does not follow that the punishment of the wicked is annihilation (which, indeed, would be the negation of punishment), since many Scriptures show, especially the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, that the wicked are conscious sufferers in a place of torment. Indeed, the whole Scripture declares this life to be a preparation for eternity, the seed-time of an everlasting harvest, the results corresponding to our actions here.

  2. The soul does not sleep until the resurrection, as some fanciful heretics have contended, for the parable just cited shows the contrary. Many Scriptures speak of the departed believer as in bliss: the writer of the Epistle to the Hebrews places “the spirits of just men made perfect” among the “innumerable” angels in “the heavenly Jerusalem”; and Paul counted it better “to depart and be with Christ,”—which he would not have thought if he knew that he was to be dormant on his leaving the scene of his great usefulness, as in such case he would have preferred to remain. It is the body of the Christian that sleeps in Jesus, not the ever active, sensible soul.

  3. Neither does the soul pass into another preparatory state, such as that the papists call purgatory. For, as to any purgatorial purification by fire, the notion is flatly contradicted by the apostolical doctrine that “the blood of Christ cleanses from all sin,” and that after Christ’s passion “there remaineth no more sacrifice for sin.” Nay, if such purification by fire be necessary, why do they pray and offer masses for the souls of the dead? We would not have them enter heaven unpurified, and neither prayers nor masses can take the place of fire.

  4. Nor does the soul go into any other state (sometimes called “intermediate”) than heaven or hell, where it remains until the resurrection. For, in the first place, (as was shown in the lecture on Christ’s “Descent into Hell,”)3 the Scripture does not speak of such a place.

Nor is such a place necessary. Heaven is the abode of blessed spirits, and hell of lost spirits; and there is no unfitness in a disincorporated soul for such an abode. Besides, what is a spirit? Does a spirit occupy space? Is heaven or hell an extent of space? These are questions not readily answered, on which the most ingenious minds have pondered without satisfaction. But we know that heaven is a state of happiness, hell a state of misery. Is the happiness of the justified soul, which lies in the enjoyment of God, so different from that of the holy angels, that they cannot enjoy heaven together? May not a miserable soul be miserable in hell? Christ has gone to heaven, and, therefore, when a Christian departs to be with Christ, he must go at once to heaven; while the wicked depart, accursed, “into the4 everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels.” Hence the Catechism makes the believer confidently say, “My soul, after this life, shall be immediately taken up to Christ its head.”

Secondly: What will become of the body after death?

The Catechism bids each of us answer: “This, my body, being raised by the power of Christ, shall be reunited with my soul, and made like unto the glorious body of Christ.”

Here we should note an unfortunate error in our translation of the Catechism, which is also found in the common English version of the creed. In all other versions of the creed, whatever be the language, it is “the resurrection of the flesh,” not “of the body.” The variation is to be lamented, as it defeats one design of the article, which was to assert the resurrection of our self-same bodies, in opposition to such heretics as, following Origen, contended that at the resurrection we shall receive phantasms or unsubstantial semblances of our present bodies, or forms in some way not the same. Our Catechism, in its original German, and also in the Dutch translation, preserves the word flesh;5 and, in the answer before us, it is, “This my flesh”; so the error is inexcusable.

I. The body after death is dissolved according to the original sentence: “Dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” This we know by too painful experience. What process the bodies of the wicked will go through while in dissolution, we are not told, though, doubtless, it will be a preparation for their endurance of punishment; but we have good reason to believe, that, during their long sleep in the grave, the bodies of the righteous will be purified from the corrupt accidents of their present mortality, and prepared for the “exceeding weight of glory” which shall come upon them at the resurrection.

II. For the body will be raised again at the last day.

The Catechism confines its answer to the resurrection of the believer, but as the article itself contemplates the resurrection in general, we shall make that our subject.

  1. As to the fact of the resurrection, the believer of Scripture can have no doubt. We have already seen how prominent a doctrine of the New Testament it is, and we trace it from the beginning of the Old, the light increasing until the coming of him who is “the Life.” The antediluvian world saw the bodies of men crumble into dust, but the translation of Enoch, body and soul, to God, proved that the whole nature of man was destined for immortality. Job, whose history is the most ancient of the sacred books, knew that his “Redeemer lived, . . . . and that, though after his skin worms destroy his body, in his ‘flesh’ he should see God.” The miracle of Enoch was repeated for the Jews under the law, by the translation of Elijah; besides which, there were several instances of actual resuscitation from death, as of the Shunamite’s child, the child of the widow of Sarepta, the dead man whose corpse touched the bones of Elisha,—and, perhaps, others. (See Hebrews xi. 35.) David avows the same glorious hope, when he says: “My flesh also shall rest in hope; for thou wilt not leave my soul in hell;” and again: “I shall be satisfied when I awake with thy likeness.” Isaiah prophesies of the uprising of the saints through the victory of Christ over the grave: “Thy dead men shall live; together with my dead body shall they arise. Awake and sing, ye that dwell in the dust; for thy dead is as the dead of herbs, and the earth shall cast out the dead.” Daniel is very explicit: “Many (i. e. the multitude) of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake; some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt.” But the great proof is the resurrection of our Lord himself, as “the first-fruits of them that sleep”; whence he called himself “the resurrection and the life.” The whole gospel turns on that cardinal fact as opening the kingdom of heaven; so the apostle says: “If there be no resurrection from the dead, then is Christ not risen; but if Christ be not risen, then is our preaching vain, and your faith is also vain.”

  2. The reason for the resurrection.

Omitting several minor arguments which have not a little force, we go at once to the main reason: The justice of God in distributing rewards and punishments. When God was proceeding to the creation of man, he said: “Let us make man in our image, after our likeness;” and so he “formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul,” or person. What the “image of God” was, it is not necessary now to determine; but we must believe that the man thus created consisted both of body and soul. His rational soul was not all of his humanity, but his flesh also was essential to it. Nay, his spirit, unlike that of an angel, was specially fitted to inhabit a body, and act through it and with it. Not that it cannot live and act when separate from the body, but that a union with the body is necessary to the completeness of its vigor and action. In a word, the man is not entire without body as well as soul. This is proved by the fact, that, when it pleased our adorable Lord to become man, or assume to his divinity our humanity, he took to himself not only a reasonable soul, but also a true body, “flesh and blood” like ours. All the dealings of God in the government of man had reference, therefore, to man thus compounded of body and soul. The rewards of life and the penalties of disobedience were proposed to man thus constituted, and not to him as a spirit only. It is true, that, as the body, when separate from the spirit, is not conscious or reasonable, it cannot be the subject of moral dealing except as it is connected with the soul. But it does not follow that God may not reach the soul with blessing or misery through the body, as, indeed, we know from our daily experience. For there are not a few exquisite pleasures, as well as pains, derived by the soul through our corporeal senses, and appetites, and faculties, and sensations. So also there are important duties, as well as gross crimes, which the soul cannot act out except through the body. It is, therefore, obviously fitting that man’s punishment or reward should be visited on both his soul and body. Not that the soul cannot suffer or enjoy without the body, but it cannot so much as when in the body. The man, that is the whole man,—man as he was created, man as he lives and acts in his present sphere,—must be the subject of God’s full judicial dealing.

The facts of the case show this. “In the day thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die,” was the threatening of penalty, implying the opposite reward of opposite obedience. Man sinned, and instantly the favor of God, which is life, was taken from the soul, and the body through its lusts and pains became at once its tempter and its tormentor. The death which, unless averted by the grace of Christ, is eternal, passed upon both body and soul. So, also, we find that when Christ undertook to expiate our guilt, by bearing our punishment, he suffered both in body and soul; for, being the substitute of man, he suffered as man; and, also, when his satisfaction was complete, he was rewarded with glory in heaven, ascending body and soul to the right hand of the Father. It follows inevitably, that those covered by his suretyship were redeemed both body and soul; not only their souls made heirs of heavenly blessedness, but their bodies also destined to be made like his own; while, on the other hand, death must have its eternal effect on both the bodies and souls of those out of Christ.

Thus the truth of God, neither in his threatenings nor his promises, can be fulfilled, if the soul alone is to exist forever, since the soul is not the man, and cannot alone enjoy the rewards or suffer the penalties which the man deserves. It may be said that in reality (the body without the soul being not conscious) it is the soul which enjoys or suffers, but the body certainly enhances either sensibility. God is omnipotent, and could make the soul independent of this relation; but in doing so he would change the nature of his creature so as to take from him his full humanity, which lies, not in his soul or in his body, but in the union of both. If the soul of the sinner exist forever to suffer eternal death, the body of the sinner must exist forever to suffer eternal death; if the soul of the believer shall exist forever to enjoy eternal life, so must his body; in a word, the whole man must exist forever. Since, however, the body on the soul’s leaving it does dissolve, we must believe that it is not annihilated, but will be raised again for the vindication of God’s infallible word.

If it be asked why the organization of the body is suspended between the time of the soul’s departure until the last day, and not cast at once into heaven or hell,—we answer, that such a disposition of it is evidently a part of that providential economy consequent of the mediatorial system in Christ, which began in our world with the first promise, and will terminate after the judgment. It is for Christ’s sake that we are spared to live in this world at all; and there are obviously many moral uses of natural death, intended for us to take advantage of, which could not appear, so far as we can see, were man removed at once body and soul out of the world. But when all these temporary ends shall have been reached, that justice of God, which Christ came to magnify and execute (for he is the judge of the world), requires that the bodies of the dead shall be raised, and the whole man receive the award of endless life or endless death. So the resurrection of Christ proves the final resurrection of all men. He, the mediatorial man, was raised from the dead that he might complete his mediatorial office, the consummation of which is the judgment of all men; and at his coming the trump of the archangel will raise the dead to stand before him for doom or bliss.

  1. The manner of the Resurrection.

a. It will be accomplished by the power of God. The texts in proof of this are so many and so direct, that we need hardly cite them. The reassembling and organizing and animating of the human body are equal to its creation; and therefore the sacred writers dream not of any other foundation for their belief in a future resurrection than the word and almightiness of God. “Why,” asks the apostle, “should it be thought a thing incredible that God should raise the dead?” That God has undertaken it is answer enough to all questions of its possibility. It is, however, worthy of remark, that, though according to the usage of Scripture when referring to the main acts of the mediatorial system, the resurrection of the body is attributed to each of the three persons of the Trinity (to the Father, Rom. vi. 4; to the Son, John xi. 25; to the Holy Ghost, Ephes. i. 20; Rom. i. 4), yet, like every other vitalizing prerogative, it is especially attributed to Christ as the mediator, or to the Holy Ghost, as his Spirit. It was part of his viceregal office to bestow life or inflict death upon those put under his authority, that, as he will be the judge, so he may be the executor of his own decisions. Thus: “Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God; and they that hear shall live. For, as the Father hath life in himself, so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself; and hath given him authority to execute judgment also, because he is the Son of Man. Marvel not at this, for the hour is coming in the which all that are in the grave shall hear his voice and shall come forth; they that have done good to the resurrection of life, and they that have done evil unto the resurrection of damnation.” The authority to judge men and the power to raise them from the dead go together.

b. So, for the same reason, the time of the general resurrection will be the end of the world. We are careful to say general resurrection, because there have been, and possibly may be, particular instances of resurrection as proofs or preliminary samples of the great revival. It will be immediately previous to the final judgment, and when the execution of the mediatorial work is about closing. “I will raise him up,” said our Lord, “at the last day.” So the apostle: “At the last trump, for the trumpet shall sound, and the dead shall be raised incorruptible;” while they which “shall remain,” that is, be alive at the time (all of whom, we have reason for believing, will be just), “shall be changed,” and “caught up . . . to meet the Lord in the air” (compare 1 Cor. xv. 51, 52; 1 Thess. iv. 15–17). Again, the apostle (1 Cor. xv. 24) having spoken of the resurrection, says: “Then cometh the end, when he” (that is, the mediator) “shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father.” Thus we see that the resurrection of neither the righteous nor the wicked can take place until the end of the mediatorial kingdom.

c. The resurrection will be universal. This has been shown by each step of the previous argument. “All that are in the graves shall hear the voice of the Son of God, and they that hear shall live.” So the apostle, in the Revelation, “saw the dead both small and great stand before God.” It cannot be otherwise, as then the judgment would be neither universal nor complete. No objection to this can be taken from the silence of the apostle in the fifteenth of 1st Corinthians, respecting the resurrection of the wicked, as there he is treating specially of the victory over death vouchsafed to the righteous in Christ.

d. The order of the resurrection is, at least, suggested by the apostle, when he says: “Every man in his own order; Christ the first-fruits, afterward they that are Christ’s, at his coming.” It is thus probable that the resurrection of the wicked will follow that of the righteous; especially, as all the texts which speak of them both put the righteous first. If, however, the righteous have not the precedence, the resurrection of both will be simultaneous at the last day. There are those, however, who think that they discover in Scripture a coming of our Lord (in person) and a resurrection of the righteous previously to the end of Christ’s kingdom; and they cite in proof of their opinion a remarkable passage in the fourth, fifth, and sixth verses of the twentieth of Revelation: “I saw thrones and they that sat upon them; and judgment was given unto them; and I saw the souls” [or persons] “of them that were beheaded for the witness of Jesus, and for the word of God, and which had not worshipped the beast, neither his image, neither had received the mark of the beast upon their foreheads or in their hands, and they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years. But the rest of the dead lived not until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection. Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection; on such the second death hath no power, but they shall be priests of God and his Christ, and shall reign with him a thousand years.” That there is difficulty in reconciling this paragraph with other Scriptures, cannot with candor be denied; and if this were the only place where the resurrection was spoken of, or rather were there none declaring the resurrection of the righteous and the wicked, we might infer that the martyred confessors of the truth against the beast (for none others are named) were raised, and reigned with Christ for a period described as a thousand years in heaven, since it is not said that they reigned on earth. Yet then we should be troubled at the assertion that over them “the second death hath no power,” since that would imply that all who were not martyred for resisting the beast were liable to suffer from the second death, which cannot be true of Christ’s other most numerous people. No ingenuity, however, can rescue this passage from being highly figurative. The reference to the key and the chain, in the first verse, cannot be taken literally, and our ready inference is, that there is a mystical meaning here which the fulfilment of prophecy will make plain. The whole book of the Revelation is full of such mysticisms, and, though we catch glimpses of the truth from our knowledge of other Scriptures, no one has yet interpreted its prophecy, spiritually or literally, to the satisfaction of the evangelical church. Yet Scripture must be consistent with Scripture; and if we cannot open the meaning of this passage, we can at least be sure that the Scriptures which literally and plainly declare the time of Christ’s coming to judgment to be the time of the general resurrection speak absolute truth. So that it were not wise to give up the doctrine of texts which all unite in saying must be taken literally, to follow a doubtful interpretation of a few verses in the most mystical book of the whole Bible. All should agree that the plain text should be the standard of interpretation, not the mystical. It is not consistent with our present duty to enter upon questions urged by those who adopt the notion of Christ’s personal reign for a thousand years on earth before he comes to judge the world; it is enough for us now that the concurrent testimony of many Scriptures assert the resurrection of all the righteous and the wicked at the last day. For what saith Job? “Man lieth down and riseth not; till the heavens be no more they shall not awake, nor be raised out of sleep.” And what becomes of our Lord’s own words? “All that are in the graves shall hear the voice of the Son of God and shall live,”—manifestly all at the one and the same hour of which he speaks. The particular instances of resurrection, which have from time to time occurred for special reasons of providence, do not impair the general fact; but the uprising of such a multitude as the martyrs slain under the fury of the beast would deny it.

The change in the bodies of those who shall be alive at Christ’s coming with the last trump will be simultaneous with the resurrection of the dead, being for the same purpose.

e. Our identical bodies will be raised; else would it not be a resurrection but a new creation, which would defeat the end of the resurrection. The Saviour’s identical body was raised, so shall ours be; for the one fact is inseparable from the other. According to Scripture, “our bodies,” “our vile bodies,” “our mortal bodies,” are to be “quickened,” “changed,” “raised.” So says the apostle: “it is sown,” “it is raised.” The self-same thing that is sown will be raised. “In my flesh,” says Job, “I shall see God.” Our Catechism is decided on this point: “This my body (or flesh), being raised, shall be reunited to my soul;” and so say the confessions of all orthodox or evangelical churches. How else can it be true that all that are in the graves shall come forth; and those that sleep in the dust shall awake: how that the dead shall be raised? The deadness is not predicated of the soul, and it cannot be of a new body. How does the believer triumph over the grave, when it retains its hold of his true body? An ancient doctor of the church truly says, that, to pretend to a belief in a resurrection with any other sense, is “a trick of words.” And Josephus (in a fragment imputed to him) remarks, as the belief of the Jews, that “the resurrection is not a migration of the soul from one body into another, but a raising up of the very same body.” Some have denied this. They say that the body is “changed.” But change does not imply substitution, unless when a thing is said to be changed for another, which is not so in this case. Our Lord’s body was “changed” on Tabor. The heart is “changed” by the regeneration. Change does not destroy identicalness, but only transforms to another fashion or appearance. Again, they say: “Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God;” but the very next phrase shows that it is corrupt flesh and blood: “Neither doth corruption inherit incorruption.” The corruptibleness must be taken away from the body, hence the necessity of the change: “For this corruptible must put on incorruption; and this mortal, immortality.” The soul is neither corruptible nor mortal; it must, therefore, be the body, now corruptible and mortal, which shall put on incorruption and immortality.

But the chief difficulty is as to the preservation of the body’s identity after its particles have been scattered, and many of them, it may be, made constituent particles of other bodies; and sceptics go the length of asserting that it is impossible in the nature of things. But let them first define what identity is, and show wherein it lies. So far as we can see, that which constitutes the identicalness of the body need not, and we believe will not, be lost. Our bodies are continually undergoing changes as to their particles; some, indeed, say that these are entirely changed in the course of years; yet are they not the same? Is not the body of a man of fourscore the same, or identical with that which he was born with? Is not the mighty oak, waving his branches over a wide space, identical with the little shoot that a hundred years ago peeped out of the acorn? nay, with the germ in the acorn itself? What, then, constitutes the actual essence of the body, and what its mere accidents? The accidents change, we know; but does the substantial essence change? If a man loses an arm, is his body not the same? If he loses eyes, ears, limbs, every part that he can lose without losing life, is he not the same man, and his body the same? The truth is, neither identicalness nor substance have ever been defined; and it is absurd to object undefinable terms to a plain fact of Scripture. The Jews, and the Mohammedans after them, have thought that the identity of the body lay in a certain indestructible portion of it,6 a germ or nucleus around which the accidental particles of the body were agglomerated; and which will be the germ or nucleus of the new body at the resurrection. The ingenious Drew, and some other eminent moderns, incline to the same opinion. This is, perhaps, unnecessary; yet, when we know how the future form of the plant is hidden in its tiny seed, or of the animal in the egg, we can see how very possible it is that from a very small portion of the former body may be evolved the resurrection body. In fact, there are processes every hour in nature showing exactly the Almighty skill and power which is required for the miracle of the resurrection. It is sufficient for us to be told that the body will be raised by the power of God. He will take care that its identicalness will be preserved, and that nothing will stand in the way of his purpose. “Why should it be thought a thing incredible that God should raise the dead?”

f. Our bodies will be changed. The apostle (1 Cor. xv. 35, 44) illustrates this by the ordinary process of vegetation. “That which thou sowest is not quickened except it die.” Properly, the germ does not die, but the husk, and other substance of the seed about it, corrupts and forms, as it were, the manure for the vital particle. So, “thou sowest not that body which shall be,”—i. e. you do not put into the ground the stalk with its leaves and head,—“but bare” or naked “grain,” or seed; “but God,” after it has been sown and has germinated, “gives it a body as it has pleased him, and to every seed its own body.” That is, according to the arrangements he has prescribed for himself, each different kind of seed produces its peculiar plant. A grain of rye does not produce a wheat-stalk, or a grain of wheat a barley-stalk. “So also is the resurrection of the dead.” The body sown in the grave will produce its kind, or, rather, by the power of God, reproduce itself, but in a more enduring form. The transformation of the wicked is not described; but that of the righteous is depicted at length in the aforesaid chapter of Corinthians, and elsewhere. The key to the whole, as stated by the Catechism, is to be found in the fact that the body of the believer shall be “made like unto the glorious body of Christ.” “Our conversation is in heaven, from whence we look for the Saviour, who shall change our vile body that it may be fashioned like unto his glorious body, according to the working whereby he is able to subdue all things unto himself.” The body of the redeemed will be like the body which Christ now has glorified on the throne of heaven. His body was planted in the grave, wounded, dishonored, lifeless; it was raised from the grave to immortal glory. As is the first-fruits, “so shall be” all “that are Christ’s at his coming.” What his body was to be in glory, the Lord showed to the three apostolical witnesses when they beheld him transfigured in glory on the top of the holy mount Tabor; to which Peter and John always refer when they speak of having “beheld his glory.” So again the apostle Paul: “As we have borne the image of the earthy (the first Adam), we shall also bear the image of the heavenly (the second Adam).” The celestial body will differ from the terrestrial body correspondently as the sphere of its celestial activity differs from that of its terrestrial life. Christ was like us in all points except sin, and, because he had no sin, and because he had expiated sin, his body “did not see corruption;” but in every other respect we shall be changed from what we are to what he is. So the apostle: “It is sown in corruption, it is raised in incorruption; it is sown in dishonor, it is raised in glory; it is sown in weakness, it is raised in power; it is sown a natural body, it is raised a spiritual body.”

Let us resume these particulars: “It is raised in incorruption.” The curse of sin being taken away, and the body fully purged of its mortal tendencies, shall never more know pain or sickness or decay, but shall live immortally pure and fresh. “It is raised in glory.” Death is a dishonor, the proof of cursedness; but glory, the full presence, favor, and light of God, will be the portion of his children ransomed from shame by the merit of Christ. “It is raised in power.” All its former weakness shall be left behind in the grave, and in their place it shall be endowed with untiring vigor and a divine energy. “It is raised a spiritual body.” The phrase is at first sight contradictory of itself. Spirit seems to be the opposite of matter. Yet the body continues substantial while it becomes spiritual. The apostle’s meaning, however, evidently is, that, losing the grossness which it has by our present nature, it partakes, in ethereality and purity, of spirit. As in the transfiguration of Christ the Divine Spirit within him shone through his physical frame, pervading it with heavenly lustre, and making it like itself in a common glory, so the body of the believer, no longer a prison-house, hindering, oppressing, and animalizing the soul, shall be permeated, filled in every part, and beaming outwardly with the Godlike Spirit.

For, consider how this body will be derived: not from physical generation, but from the immediate power of God. How it will be sustained: not by food and drink, but the immediate favor of God. How it will be employed: not in labor, as here, consequent upon its natural necessities, but in the holy service of God. Hence the nature of the spiritual change. They “neither marry nor are given in marriage, but are as the angels of God, being the children of God.” They “hunger no more, neither thirst any more.” They are never weary, and “no night” curtains them from the resplendent moon. Their activity is perpetual, and they feed on the “angels’ food” of divine truth and love and service, and they drink of the Holy Spirit, “the pure river of the water of life,” flowing in perpetual tide from the throne of God and the Lamb. Swift as angels, strong as cherubs, ardent as seraphs, glorious as Christ, there shall be no bound to their action, no limit to their aspirations, no measure to their energy but the nature of God, in whom they “live and move and have their being.”

If the bodies of the saints be fashioned after the body of Christ, after what fearfully opposite fashion shall be the bodies of the wicked? If everything be taken from the righteous that can hinder or annoy the jubilant soul, how must the flesh that has been abandoned to sin become the instrument of its own punishment!—strong, only to be more sensitive of pain; indestructible, only that its anguish may be eternal. We shrink now from the slightest bodily pain, and in extremity of suffering look to death as a relief; but no death blesses the damned immortal. See in the pains of men here the fruit of sin, in the diseases and deformities that follow intemperance and lust,—how vice reacts upon the transgressor; yet here God is long-suffering and waits to be gracious. What must that death, that pain, that disease be, which shall punish the sinner, when God withdraws his restraining hand and gives the retribution full sweep! O who among us can lie down in everlasting burning? “Where their worm dieth not, and the fire is not quenched!”

First: The doctrine of the resurrection should fill the believer with lively joy. So it affected all the apostles. Then only do they enter upon the full fruition of eternal life, and obtain a perfect victory over sin and death and hell. We do believe that “the souls of the righteous at their death immediately pass into glory”; but the soul is not all of man, and his body is necessary to his completeness. We are forced to complain of the body now as a clog, a temptation, and a tormentor; but it is so only because it is a “body of sin and death.” The body was intended as a servant and helpmate to the soul, to aid its perceptions, to minister to its pleasure, to act out its purposes. Man is thus more wonderful than the angel, and of larger and more varied sphere; for he unites in his own person the two grand departments of creation,—spirit and matter. He was formed to derive his happiness and his means of glorifying God from both. He can neither know God, nor serve him, nor enjoy him so well, without his body as he can with it, if sin and its effects be taken away. Therefore should we earnestly desire and long for that blessed day when our bodies shall again be made pure, more glorious than in their first creation, and safe in their spiritual youth forever. Like the apostle, we should pray for deliverance from the “body of sin and death”; but also, like him, “expect with uplifted head” the full restoration of our humanity to the image of God; as Paul says, after speaking of our transitory afflictions and the “far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory”: “We know, that, if our earthly house of this tabernacle (σκηνὴ, tent, as of a pilgrim) were dissolved, we have a building (οἰκοδομὴν, an edifice, or permanent structure) of God (ἐκ Θεοῦ, from God), a house not made with hands, eternal in the heavens; for in this we groan, earnestly desiring to be clothed upon with our house which is from heaven, if so be that being clothed we shall not be found naked. For we that are in this tabernacle do groan, being burdened; not for that we would be unclothed but clothed upon, that mortality might be swallowed up of life.” So in another: “We ourselves groan within ourselves, waiting for the adoption, to wit, the redemption of the body.” The resurrection completes the adoption, because only then the whole man is restored in blessing to his Father’s heavenly house. Thanks! Thanks! “Thanks be unto God, who giveth us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ!” But oh! how careful should we be to preserve from shame and pollution here the temple of the Holy Ghost, which is destined to such glory hereafter!

What a glorious assembly will surround the throne of our once crucified but now exalted Redeemer! What a horrible crowd of sufferers there will be of those who served to the evil pleasures of the flesh!

Gather us, O God of love, with thy people. Amen!

The third head is included by the next article, “The Life Everlasting,” and will be treated in our study of the 58th Question and Answer.

1 The Rhone. Eusebius, l. 1 c. 1.

2 Nat. Hist. b. 1, c. vii.

3 Which see, Vol. I. p. 395.

4 The article is definite.

5 Mijn vleesch. Ger., mein fleisch.

6 This the Jews called the bone, Liet (separation?) and it corresponds to the os coccygis, or cuckoobill-shaped termination of the sacrum.