Lecture XXIX. Justification by Faith: The Doctrine Opened
Twenty-third Lord’s Day
The lesson for to-day demands our best attention. It gives the only answer to that question which all religions have sought to solve: “How can man be justified with God?” (Job xxv. 4,) by setting forth concisely and clearly the great protestant, evangelical doctrine of Justification by Faith.
God, who devised and executed the gracious plan by which he is just, and the justifier of him which believeth in Jesus, alone could declare it. It is, therefore, purely a doctrine of revelation; and the business of reason is, simply to inquire what is taught concerning this way of mercy in the holy Scriptures, and especially to mark the relations which the several truths comprehended by it bear to each other.
In attempting this, the wide range of our subject requires us to imitate the conciseness of our instructor, and we shall, without farther preface, follow closely his order.
The Answer to the 59th Question declares The Fact that the believer is righteous before God.
The Answer to the 60th Question, The Reason why he is righteous before God to be, solely because “God, without any merit of his, but only of mere grace, grants and imputes to him the perfect satisfaction, righteousness, and holiness of Christ.”
And the Answer to the 61st Question, The Manner in which he becomes a partaker of the righteousness of Christ to be by faith only, “not that he is acceptable to God on account of the worthiness of his faith, but only “because he cannot receive and apply to himself” “the satisfaction, righteousness, and holiness of Christ” “in any other way than by faith.”
The whole discussion may then be conducted under two inquiries:
First: What is meant by being righteous before God? And
Secondly: How the Christian, though a sinner, is righteous before God?
First: What is meant by being righteous before God?
In order properly to understand the scriptural statement of the doctrine before us, it is necessary to remember that God is represented as dealing with the sinner in the character of a judge. Hence the language is that used to describe legal transactions, and the terms are to be taken in a forensic or juridical sense (i. e. as they are taken in courts of law). Not that God patterns his justice after that of men; for in the exercise of that attribute, as in everything else, his ways are infinitely “above our ways, and his thoughts above our thoughts”; but he graciously condescends to explain his truth by such words as are best adapted to our capacities and habits of thought. Hence man is said to be under “a law”; to be brought “into judgment” or trial, to be “condemned” or “justified,” to be “guilty” or “righteous.”
Justification, in this forensic sense, is the opposite of condemnation. Thus the apostle: “Who shall lay anything to the charge of God’s elect? It is God that justifieth. Who is he that condemneth? It is Christ that died” (Rom. viii. 33, 34). Justification does not make the person who has been under trial just or righteous. It is only the act pronouncing him just or righteous in the eye of the law, i. e. free from all charges against him.1 “Who shall lay anything to the charge of God’s elect? It is God that justifieth.” Yet was every one of that elect personally and really a sinner. So condemnation does not make the person who has been under trial, a sinner, unjust, or unrighteous. It only pronounces him liable to the penalties of sin, injustice, or unrighteousness. “Who is he that condemneth? It is Christ that died.” Which means, that “there is now no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus” (Rom. xii. 1), because, though they are actually sinners, Christ, by the interposition of his death, has satisfied the law on their behalf, and they are consequently free from the punishment to which they would otherwise have been condemned. So nothing is more frequent in Scripture than distinctions between justification by the law or by works, and justification by faith,—the righteousness which is of the law, and the righteousness of faith. Thus the apostle: “By the deeds of the law, there shall no flesh be justified in his sight” (Rom. iii. 20); and again: “Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law.” When using the term righteous, he says: “It is written, There is none righteous, no, not one” (Rom. iii. 10); and in Hebrews he speaks of Noah becoming “heir of the righteousness which is by faith” (xi. 7). In Philippians he declares his desire to be found in Christ, “not having his own righteousness, which is of the law, but that which is through the faith of Christ, the righteousness which is of God by faith” (iii. 9). To be righteous in the sight of God, as the term is used here by our instructor, does not mean to be actually righteous in one’s self, because he says “righteous in Christ,” but to be declared, accounted, and treated as righteous in the eye of the law by God.
Now the law of God is twofold. It forbids wrong deeds under severe penalties, and requires good deeds with promises of reward. Righteousness, therefore, in the eye of God’s law, is to be considered as twofold: negative, freedom from wrong-doing; and positive, the doing of right.
It is true that, in one sense, not to do right is to do wrong, and to do wrong is not to do right. Yet we mark the distinction between negative and positive righteousness, because, in order to the enjoyment of God’s favor, which is bestowed only in reward of righteousness, it is necessary that, besides the pardon of our sins, which but frees us from the penalties of the law, we should have a positive merit before God to entitle us to the rewards of the law. Thus our instructor bids the believer say, not merely that he is “righteous before God,” but also that he is “an heir of eternal life.”
To be perfectly righteous in the sight of God is, to be free from all the penalties, and entitled to all the rewards of his holy law. We are now prepared for our second inquiry: How the Christian, though a sinner, is righteous before God?
And under this head we shall consider
The reason; and
The manner of his being righteous before God.
The reason.
A. It is not because of any righteousness personally his own; for he acknowledges that his righteousness or justification is “notwithstanding his conscience doth accuse him of having grossly transgressed all the commandments of God and kept none of them, and his being still inclined to all evil, so that he has no merit of his own.”
We shall not stay here to show the entire absence of all righteousness from the soul of every living child of Adam, and our entire corruption in sin. This has in former discourses been argued fully before you. It is sufficient now to repeat that God has declared, “There is none righteous, no, not one;” and that “by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight.” Christ Jesus came “to seek and to save the lost,” “to call not the righteous but sinners to repentance.” The magnitude of that provision of mercy which has been made in the mediation of Jesus Christ, the Son of God, incarnate and suffering for us, is clear proof that there can be no salvation for us by our own merit; for “if righteousness come by the law, then is Christ dead in vain” (Gal. ii. 21). Our great apostle Paul knew nothing of salvation out of Christ. He had some dreams of the kind while yet an unbelieving pharisee, but when he came to see the full force and wide extent of the law of God, all hope of saving himself died within him (Rom. vii. 9); and after he had been long a preacher of that faithful saying, “Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners,” he still acknowledges himself “the chief of sinners” (1 Tim. i. 15). Those, therefore, who desire and think to be saved by their own righteousness, must go elsewhere than to the gospel for a warrant of their hope. They have neither part nor lot in Christ’s salvation. The Bible has nothing to do with them but to condemn them; “for he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God” (John iii. 18).
B. It is because of the merit of Jesus Christ.
Thus the instructor says, “God, without any merit of mine, but only of mere grace, grants and imputes to me the perfect satisfaction, righteousness, and holiness of Christ; even so as if I had never committed any sin; yea, as if I had accomplished all that obedience which Christ hath accomplished for me.” And that this language is in agreement with Scripture, is clear from what the apostle says (Rom. iii. 21–28): “Now the righteousness of God without the law is manifested, being witnessed by the law and prophets: Even the righteousness of God which is by faith of Jesus Christ unto all, and upon all them that believe: for there is no difference: For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God: Being justified freely by his grace, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus; whom God hath set forth to be a propitiation through faith in his blood, to declare his righteousness for the remission of sins that are past, through the forbearance of God: To declare, I say, at this time, his righteousness; that he might be just and the justifier of him which believeth in Jesus. Where is boasting then? It is excluded. By what law? of works? Nay, but by the law of faith. Therefore, we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law.”
We have seen, that, to be righteous in the sight of God, is to be free from all the penalties and entitled to all the rewards of his holy law. But such a righteousness the Christian can never obtain for himself, because, as a sinner who has come short of the glory of God, he has not only forfeited all claims to the rewards, but has become obnoxious to all the penalties of the law; which, as they include eternal death, it is impossible for him ever perfectly to exhaust. Except, therefore, some other method of justifying him than his own righteousness be provided, his salvation is impossible. Here, (blessed be the name of Jehovah, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost!) the wisdom and power of the mercy of God comes to our help.
Christ, the Son of God, incarnate in our nature, condescends, according to covenant with the Father, to become the Saviour of the sinner. In accomplishing this blessed work, he offered himself to bear the penalties of the law which the sinner had incurred. The sacrifice was accepted by God when he took the life of Jesus upon the cross. Besides this, during the whole of his life upon earth, he honored the law of God by a perfect obedience, and thus became entitled himself to all the rewards of righteousness. Christ Jesus, therefore, as the Saviour, and in the place or room of the sinner, made himself perfectly righteous in the sight of the law: negatively righteous, inasmuch as he had discharged fully all the penalties of the law; and positively righteous, as by a perfect obedience he earned all the rewards of the law. Now the doctrine of the Scripture and the argument of the Catechism is, that God accepts and acknowledges this whole righteousness of Christ in place of, or as a substitute for, that righteousness which the believer ought to have rendered in his own person, but could not; so that in Christ, or through Christ, the believer, though himself a sinner, becomes perfectly righteous in the sight of the law, being set free from all its penalties and entitled to all its rewards. Thus the Catechism: “God grants and imputes to me the perfect satisfaction (that is the expiation), righteousness (that is the obedience), and holiness (that is the acceptableness) of Christ, even so as if I had never had nor committed any sins (because all his sins have been expiated), yea, as if I had fully accomplished all that obedience which Christ hath accomplished for me.”
He says, God “grants” this righteousness, because it was of mere grace that God provided this righteousness; it was his purpose to save which led him to the provision of that righteousness; and having provided it, he may bestow its benefits upon whom he will, although he promises and offers those benefits to all who will believe. They who believe become entitled to the righteousness through grace of the promise, for God will keep his word; and becoming entitled to the righteousness, they receive then, as a matter of justice to Christ and mercy to them, all the consequences of that righteousness, even deliverance from the punishment which was due to them because of the sins which Christ expiated, and the rewards due to those good works which they could not do, but which Christ did for them.
He says, also, “God imputes this righteousness.” By which is meant that God reckons or accounts to the believer the righteousness of Christ as his own. For this is the proper and the scriptural sense of impute. “Blessed is the man to whom the Lord imputeth not iniquity,” or does not charge with iniquity (Ps. xxxii. 2), which the apostle declares (Rom. iv. 6) to be the imputation of “righteousness without works,” or the imputation of a righteousness which he had not wrought out for himself; for in a verse a little before he had said (4, 5): “Now to him that worketh is the reward not reckoned of grace but of debt; but to him that worketh not, but believeth on him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted (the same Greek word, λογίζομαι) for righteousness.”
Understand, if you please, precisely what we mean here. God, by imputing the righteousness of Christ to the believer, does not make the righteousness of Christ the personal righteousness of the believer. That is impossible. The personal acts or qualities of one cannot by any process be made the personal acts or qualities of another. The very idea is absurd. But in imputing the righteousness of Christ to him, God gives to the believer the legal consequences of Christ’s righteousness; he has the benefit of it as much as if it were his own. He is freed from the penalties of the law because Christ has borne them in his stead. He receives the rewards of Christ’s obedience as if he had obeyed himself.
This, then, is the reason why the believer, though himself a sinner, is righteous in the sight of God. It is because God grants and imputes to him the righteousness of Christ.
It is possible that some may object to this merciful arrangement of God in accepting a vicarious or substituted satisfaction, because, in the first place, the law requiring righteousness from all, the righteousness of one cannot be the righteousness of many; and in the second place, the law requiring personal obedience, no vicarious or substituted obedience can in any way be accepted. Now we might answer such objections by the express declaration of the apostle, that “by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous” (Rom. v. 19). Where God justifieth, who shall condemn? But we ask the objector to consider both the dignity of the substitute, Christ Jesus, and the end of the sanctions added to the law.
The substitute is the man Jesus, in whom God the Son was incarnate. The merit, therefore, of his righteousness, both in expiation and obedience, is infinite, and can, therefore, cover the defects and sins of as many sinners such as we are as he chooses to give the benefits of his righteousness unto.
The end of sanctions to a law (that is, penalties and rewards) is to maintain its authority over the subject. And we ask, by what method could God declare his determination to vindicate the honor of his law in its forbidding of sin better than by refusing to pardon any sinner before he had exacted from his son Jesus Christ the full penalty due the sinner for sin? Or in what manner could he testify his appreciation of righteousness so fully as by causing his own son to become incarnate that he might honor the law upon earth, and then bestowing the unspeakably rich reward of eternal life upon his people for that righteousness’ sake?
We grant that in human law such substitution could not be admitted, though something of the kind (yet not in strict justice) has occurred. But there can be no parallel between the human law and the divine. The human law ought to be but a transcript of the divine, and therefore the human judge has no alternative but to execute it strictly. God is the author of his own law, and the sovereign offended. He, therefore, has the right to justify and pardon a transgressor in such a way as he is satisfied that his authority receives no detriment.
Besides, the thing is impossible among men; for where could such a substitute as Jesus be found? Where all are subjects, the law requires the obedience of all; and, therefore, no one could so abstract himself from his own duty as to prepare a supererogatory righteousness, which might be imputed to the benefit of another. The Son of God obeyed for us a law to which he was not himself subject, and therefore he has a right to bestow the rewards of his righteousness upon whom he will.
The manner in which the sinner becomes righteous in Christ.
It is by faith;2 as the instructor says, “I cannot receive or apply the same to myself in any other way.”
I need not stay to cite proofs from Scripture of the necessity of faith in order to our justification and salvation. The whole tenor of the book shows that he only who believeth can be saved; and this very righteousness is called “the righteousness which is of faith” (Rom. x. 6), or “by faith” (Heb. xi. 7).
But it will readily be seen that even the scheme of salvation by the imputed righteousness of Christ cannot be reconciled to the holiness of God, unless the cheerful and unqualified submission of the sinner, who is pardoned, to the justice and excellence of the law be secured, and also his reformation from sin unto holiness. This is done by requiring faith from him.
His submission; for by accepting Christ’s work in his behalf he not only submits to be saved in the way which God appoints, but he acknowledges that he ought to have rendered the righteous obedience which Christ has rendered for him, and deserved to have suffered the penalties which Christ suffered for him. Nay, he rejoices that he has an opportunity of fully honoring the law of God, which he loves, by presenting through his faith the perfect expiation and obedience of Christ. It is his highest satisfaction to believe not only that he is pardoned and accepted of God, but that it is in such a way as reflects the greatest glory upon God and his law, while it humbles himself as utterly destitute of merit, and saved by grace alone.
His reformation is secured because the proper effect, by the power of the Holy Ghost, is to purify the heart, to work by love, and to overcome the world. So that it is certain that when God justifies he sanctifies, because he justifies only those who believe. Indeed, faith is itself a part, as well as the instrument of sanctification, for no one can truly believe in Christ without being, in the very act of faith, turned from sin unto God. It is, therefore, most false to assert, as some errorists do, that the doctrine of justification by faith encourages or tolerates licentiousness of life. Scripture, experience, even reason show that the very reverse is the case, and that the requisition of faith, in order to salvation, is the very best means of securing the hearty repentance and obedience of the sinner. But upon this we shall have occasion to discourse more at large in our exposition of the next Lord’s Day.
We must, however, be careful to remember that there is no merit of any kind in faith itself. The only merit which justifies the believer is that of Christ, as the Catechism says: “Not that I am acceptable to God on account of the worthiness of my faith, but only because the satisfaction, righteousness, and holiness of Christ is my righteousness before God.” No merit of ours can be mingled with his. Nor can there be any merit proper in merely believing. Faith is necessary to our justification, because, in order to the righteousness of Christ being applied to us, it must be accepted; and as the Catechism says: “I cannot receive and apply the same to myself in any other way than by faith only.” It may be necessary to the pardon of a rebel that he kneel and stretch forth his hand to receive the certificate of it from his sovereign; but there is no merit in either the posture or the act. So there is no merit in our humbly and gratefully accepting the pardon of God in Christ. The apostle does, indeed, speak of “faith” being “counted” or “imputed for righteousness”; but then he means not the faith itself, but the object of it, the righteousness which is of God. For if he means otherwise, he overthrows the main doctrine which he would establish, that we are saved by no merit of our own, but only by the merit of Jesus Christ.
Thus, my brethren, you have before you the glorious and most comforting doctrine of Justification by Faith.
It teaches us that
- Salvation is provided for the lost and ruined sinner.
However sinful we may have been, still are, and feel that we shall yet be, because of the corruption within us, we ought not to despair of mercy, seeing that God offers pardon and favor to us through Christ his Son. We are in most awful peril if we be not saved through Christ, because God offering to us mercy declares us to be lost and undone in ourselves; yes, so utterly lost and undone that we can be saved only by the infinite merit of the Son of God.
But this salvation is certainly ours, if with true and penitent hearts we simply accept the offer made to us in the gospel, and rely only upon the merits of Jesus Christ, our very faith being the evidence of our pardon and favor with God.
- The salvation is all of grace.
Grace contrived the plan; for God was not constrained, except by his infinite mercy, to save sinners who have so richly deserved his wrath.
Grace provides the righteousness necessary for the salvation of the sinner, and which none but God incarnate could have wrought out in our stead.
Grace bestows the salvation upon the sinner, because the faith by which he receives the benefits of Christ’s righteousness is wrought in him by the power of the Holy Ghost.
- The salvation demands our entire submission to God in Christ.
We must abjure all trust in our own merit, and accept it only as a free gift of God’s mercy.
We must penitently acknowledge our sins which needed such an expiation, and rejoice in the honor done to the divine law by the obedience of Christ in our stead.
We must receive with the pardon the grace of the Holy Ghost, that we may live to the glory and for the cause of him who saves none from hell whom he does not save from sin.
Christians, give all glory to God, who saves from such condemnation; who promises so blessed an eternal life; and who saves us from hell, and makes us heirs of heaven at such infinite cost, and by such infinite power.
Oh, the misery of those who are out of Christ! They are condemned already. They add to their sin the guilt of despising the mercy of God, the righteousness of Christ, and the grace of the Holy Ghost. They have no true hope of entering heaven, but, except they repent, must go away into everlasting punishment.
1 See Booth’s Reign of Grace.
2 For Faith, see Seventh Lord’s Day.