Lecture XLI. The Nature of True Conversion. First Lecture
Thirty-third Lord’s Day
In our lesson for the last Lord’s day we were taught that the consequence of our deliverance from misery by the grace of Christ through faith is our doing of good works as the fruits of a lively and constraining gratitude, and, therefore, that they who by their wilful continuance in wicked lives prove their not having been converted unto God, can have from the doctrine of the gospel no true hope of salvation. It follows, properly, that we should ascertain what true conversion of a sinner to God is, or, as the Catechism has it, in what true conversion consists,—the knowledge of which will discover plainly what a Christian means by good works. These two points are handled in the lesson which we are now to study.
First: The nature of true conversion. (88th, 89th, 90th Questions and Answers.)
Secondly: The nature of good works. (91st Question and Answer.)
First: The nature of true conversion.
I. The purpose of God in the gospel being to deliver “his people from the power” as well as the guilt “of their sins,” there must be wrought in all those who are partakers of that salvation, a radical change from a sinful to a holy life. This transformation will be complete in the fulness of the redemption, that is, when the believer is taken up to be with Christ, his Head and Forerunner; but on earth it is gradual, though surely progressive. This process we commonly call sanctification. There must, therefore, be a beginning of this transformation or sanctification, a time when the tide of the soul’s moral life is turned from its natural ebb towards eternal death and flows toward heaven. This act of change we call conversion.
Salvation being all of grace, the conversion of a sinner from sin to God’s service must be from a sovereign, divine power, exerted in the sinner’s soul, changing its principles and motives of conduct; but as the operation of grace is through the moral faculties of free agents, and not a mere force impelling us against our will and understanding, the sinner, called effectually by divine grace, turns himself by the divine strength so imparted to him. Conversion, therefore, is indeed accomplished by the grace of God, but it is also the act of the sinner himself. In the former part of the Catechism, on our Deliverance, we found conversion, or the change from the old to the new man, among the “benefits” which we “receive from the death and sacrifice of Christ on the cross” (Question 43d), and there we treated of it as the act of God. This conversion of the sinner by God is also called by Scripture regeneration, or the begetting again by the power of the Holy Ghost with the seed of the word (1 Peter i. 23), because it is an imparting of a new moral life to the soul, from which holy actings will proceed. Here we find conversion among the evidences of our thankfulness to God for having “delivered us from the power of darkness and translated us into the kingdom of his dear Son.” Hence, we are now to consider it as the act of the sinner under the influence of divine grace.
II. The Catechism declares this true conversion to consist in two parts. 1. The mortification of the old man. 2. The quickening of the new man.
Let us, before proceeding farther, ascertain the meaning of these terms. The contrasted expressions “old man” and “new man” are taken from Scripture. The apostle (Eph. iv. 22–24) says: “That ye put off concerning the former conversation [conduct] the old man, which is corrupt according to the deceitful lusts, and be renewed in the spirit of your mind; and that ye put on the new man, which after God is created in righteousness and true holiness” [holiness of truth]. Man, here, is put for our moral nature: “the old man,” for the nature we are born with,—whence it is also called “the natural man” (1 Cor. ii. 14); “the new man,” for the holy nature, which we derive from the Holy Spirit in regeneration,—whence it is also called “spiritual.” We inherit the first from the first Adam; we receive the second by faith from the second Adam, who is Christ. “Mortification” and “quickening” are also scriptural words. Mortification signifies, literally, slaying or putting to death, and hence, metaphorically, deadening. “If ye through the spirit do mortify [θανατουτε] the deeds of the body, ye shall live” (Rom. vii. 13). “Mortify [νέκρώσατε], therefore, your members which are upon the earth” (Col. iii. 5). Quickening is, literally, reviving, or making alive [ζωοποιέω], and hence may have the metaphorical sense of strengthening, or increasing, life. Strictly speaking, only God can kill the old man, or revive—make to life—the new man; yet here, and in close accordance with Scripture, the believer has a personal agency in mortifying the one and quickening the other. We are taught, also, that the mortification of our old nature and the quickening of our new nature are carried on by the believer simultaneously in the continuous process of conversion, or transformation; which shows, that, though the new life is implanted, it is not immediately, or without resistance, perfectly paramount in the soul, but is opposed and hindered by our old nature, not yet utterly killed, though it has had its death-blow. Conversion, therefore, on our part, is a struggle or conflict which the believer, animated by the grace of God in the new life, maintains against the power of sin “which still remaineth, against our will, in us”; and this conflict, though the new life must be ultimately victorious, is sharp and often with various alternations or vacillations to either side. It is the new life within our carnal nature, and, therefore, opposed and impeded by the lusts and infirmities of our fallen, or old nature. This the apostle describes (Rom. vii. 19–25): “The good that I would I do not; but the evil which I would not, that I do. Now, if I do that I would not, it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me. I find then a law [a principle] that when I would do good, evil is present with me. For I delight in the law of God after the inward man; but I see another law in my members, warring against the law of my mind and bringing me into captivity to the law of sin which is in my members. O wretched man that I am! Who shall deliver me from the body of this death? I thank God through Jesus Christ our Lord. So, then, with the mind I myself serve the law of God, but with the flesh the law of sin.” We are now prepared to inquire,
- What is the mortification of the old man? “It is a sincere sorrow of heart, that we have provoked God by our sins; and more and more to hate and flee from them.”
a. “A sincere sorrow of heart, that we have provoked God by our sins.” It is the believer who has this sorrow. Though he is now forgiven, and is enjoying the favor of God here, and the hope of eternal blessedness hereafter, he is for that very reason more sorrowful on account of his offences against God. He mourns his past sins and his present failures, not because he dreads, like a slave, the punishment he deserves and cannot escape from, but because he has done such grievous wrong against the holy God, who is so kind and merciful to his soul in Christ Jesus. He acknowledges his desert of hell, and shudders at the terrible danger he hopes to escape, but he rather sees in the agonies of the eternal death the infinite proof of God’s condemnation of such sins as he has committed,—the estimate God has of its abominable evil. He trusts for mercy through the righteousness of Christ, the ground of his atonement (or reconciliation) to God; but the infinite means provided, because necessary for his redemption in the humiliation, painful obedience, and more painful sufferings of Christ the Son of God incarnate, convinces him yet more of the guilt of all sin, while they increase immeasurably his love for the God he has offended, and, therefore, his sorrow of heart for his great sins against his heavenly Father and best friend. The holiness of God condemns him, the righteousness of God’s law condemns him, as very wicked and degraded; but the love of God and his unspeakable mercy in Christ Jesus, the deep humiliation and bitter sufferings of his Saviour, the long-suffering, patience, and successful perseverance of the Holy Ghost in bringing him, notwithstanding his obstinate, rebellious resistance, into salvation,—the consideration of these, I say, show him, in yet darker colors, his extreme baseness and utter inexcusableness. He sees that it was his sin, with that of others like himself, which brought the dreadful wrath of God upon Christ, his surety; that all his healing comes from the stripes which Christ bore in his stead, and all his hope of life from the exquisite agonies of his incarnate Lord dying the death man deserved to die. Therefore, when with true faith he looks upon Christ as his Saviour, and sees in his Lord’s glorified body the scars of the crucifixion, he remembers all that Jesus suffered because of his guilt, and he mourns and reproaches himself for all his sins. He sees, also, the great pains the blessed Spirit has taken for his conversion, in giving him the Holy Scripture, and all the other means of grace, with opportunities of repentance; in pursuing him by arguments and warnings and invitations and promises; in pressing the truth closely home upon his understanding and heart and conscience; in forcing, as it were, his way into his soul, enlightening his mind, turning his affections, and graciously overpowering his will, and now bringing him to repentance and dwelling within him, to move and strengthen him unto those good works which are the grateful evidences of his faith in Christ; and, therefore, he sees the enormous wickedness of those sins of his which insulted and grieved and wounded the Holy Spirit at the very time the Holy Comforter was striving to save him; the opportunities he despitefully misimproved; the obstinate resistances he made; the wilful breaking through of restraints which he was so often guilty of; and, even now, the feeble zeal of his renewed mind in seconding and carrying out to practice the religious purposes that grace has inspired him with. There is, thus, not a doctrine or fact or incident of the salvation he believes to be his, which does not enhance his sorrow for sin. This is the sorrow which is the sign of true conversion,—the sorrow for sins which springs from an apprehension (or trustful belief) of the mercy of God in Christ Jesus by the grace of the Holy Ghost. Such sorrow as springs only from a fear of God’s wrath on account of our sins, though it may mingle with more gracious motives to hate sin, is no proof of genuine repentance, because it is wholly selfish, and does not bring us back to the love of God. It is not necessarily sinful, nay, as we have said, it may aid in moving the sinner to repentance, but in itself it is no proof of our conversion, and in the absence of reliance upon Christ it is the reverse,—a sorrow that worketh death, because there is no submission of the heart to God. But the sorrow which comes from faith in Christ’s love kills in the heart our enmity to God, and bows us at the feet of God, weeping yet loving children.
b. We learn that this sorrow is not a mere sentiment or emotion, a thing of sighs and tears and regrets, but that it operates as an energetic principle, making us “hate” all sin, and resolutely “to flee from it.” How can they who have seen how odious sin is in God’s sight, continue to offend him by wilfully committing it? How can they who have seen what their sins brought upon Christ, inflict fresh wounds on his love, and before the world “crucify, as it were, the Son of God afresh and put him to an open shame”? How can they who have seen that sin is a direct insult and resistance and grievance to the Holy Spirit in his gracious work upon our hearts, throw fresh injuries and obstacles in his merciful and sanctifying way? The believer, therefore, will turn from sins with abhorrence, he will hate them, he will resist temptation to them, he will fly from them as from disgusting, guilty, perilous enemies to God and his soul. The more he learns of God in Christ, the more he enjoys the comforts of his religion, the more will he hate sin and fly from it. Day by day, as his faith strengthens, will he “mortify” “the old man,” and show his gratitude to God in Christ by hating all that God hates, and avoiding all that God has forbidden.
- The quickening of the new man.
“It is a sincere joy of heart in God through Christ, and with love and delight to live according to the will of God in all good works.”
a. A sincere joy of heart in God through Christ.
If any, hearing us discourse of the sorrow and self-condemnations and painful strugglings, temptations within and without us, which accompany repentance, suppose that conversion to God is only a melancholy and grievous temper, clouding our life in gloom, and making our religious practice an afflictive penance, they need farther teaching in the blessed experience of a believing soul. As the “old man” and the “new man” are, so long as our Christian life is in the mortal body of sin, struggling for the mastery, and the old man, our worse self, must be resolutely “mortified,” we must feel the anguish and agonies of a death, an execution, or, as the Scripture more emphatically calls it, a crucifixion of our natural tendencies and desires. Therefore hate, a very strong passion, is sent to our aid, that we may set ourselves on our wickedness with the ardor of a combatant, who minds not his own sufferings in his determination to inflict death on his foe. But hate is not enough to bear us victoriously through. There is a stronger passion yet,—the power most prevalent and impelling in God or man,—love, which sheds through the faculties and affections of the human soul a delicious ardor, absorbing the whole nature to one purpose, and concentrating all its forces on one enterprise. Faith is strong, hope is stronger, but love is strongest in all the operations of the Christian life. It is the superlative of the three degrees of heavenly grace, the acme of the climax by which we ascend to God. Hence, in this most difficult work of our conversion, love alone is equal by divine grace to its accomplishment, and has the largest share in the process. God, from whom comes the divine life which assimilates us to himself, is love; and love to God is so identified with the new life, that we cannot distinguish it from the life itself. It can be engendered, quickened, nurtured, perfected only by love. It is the love of God in Christ which awakens love in our hearts. “We love him because he first loved us.” “The love of Christ constraineth us . . . to live not unto ourselves but unto him who died for us and rose again.” It is the perception, the persuasion, the apprehension, the bringing home to himself of the love of God in Christ, which transforms the believer by an all-pervading energy, thrilling, subduing, exciting all his senses into a willing, happy, obedient creature of Christ’s will. As in his life-giving miracle the prophet stretched himself on the body of the child, so does Christ by the Holy Spirit, in regenerating love, closely embrace the soul of his choice, warming it with his own divine warmth, breathing into it his own divine breath, until it returns the glow, the breath, the clinging embrace, and rises with him a new creature, conscious of eternal life.
The first effect of this love of God, through faith in Christ, is joy: joy, that we possess Christ as our own; joy in the great love he shows to us; joy in the delightful love we bear towards him; joy in the beauty of his holiness; joy that we may partake of that highest beauty; joy in our deliverance from the displeasure of him whose love is our greatest happiness; joy in the assured hope of a perfect, eternal consummation of such transcendent bliss; joy, that he will accept any returns of our gratitude; joy, that he enables us to make those returns by our own powers, poor in themselves, but vigorous from his imparted grace; joy, that we may give up our whole lives, all we are, all we have, now and forever, to “him whom” our “soul loveth.”
Christian joy, joy springing from such a source, must be more than a lively passion or a rapturous sentiment. It inspires the soul with a divine energy, and gives a tone of vigorous health to all its faculties. “The joy of the Lord is your strength,” saith the Holy Ghost by the prophet to Israel. Therefore the Catechism, in its definition of conversion: “With love and delight to live according to the will of God in all good works.” The believer, rejoicing over his deliverance, is filled with gratitude to his deliverer, and ardently gives himself up to God’s service. His inquiry is, What can I do to please him, my Father, my Saviour, my Sanctifier? It is now his delight to obey the divine will. His heart is turned from sin because it provokes God; he hates it and would fly from it. So when he discovers what God’s law requires, he not only assents to its requirements, but rejoices in them, and delights to do what he loves for the sake of him whom he loves. Far from considering those commandments grievous, they are to him a perfect law of liberty, for he delights in the law of God after the inward man; and as he feels the new life and love and joy in God through Christ filling and animating his soul, he gladly gives all his strength to every good work which Providence lays to his hand. It is no longer a spirit of bondage, making him a reluctant servant through fear of wrath, but the cheerful, earnest obedience of a child loving his Father, God, and loving the work his Father gives him, that he may become more and more like Christ, with whom the Father is well pleased, and through whom the Father is well pleased with all who endeavor to follow in his steps.
Such is the nature of true conversion.
It is accompanied by strong emotions,—sorrow, and joy, and hate, and love, anguish and delight. Yet it is a fatal mistake that mere excitement of feeling, even though it be about religious things, is a proof of conversion. Religion does not lie in heats of devotion or exaggerated passion. The heathen are so excited in their idolatries, as were the Israelites before the golden calf. We must carefully examine whence these feelings come: whether they spring from our having offended God or not; whether from joy in God or not; whether our hearts are converted from sin to the service of God or not.
We have described the converted heart under strong terms, setting it forth in the manner which, were grace perfect in us, it would manifest itself. Still we must not despair of God’s mercy, or doubt his renewing grace, if we come far short of these high sensibilities and of the holy practice which the law of God requires. Conversion is a change begun, it is true, in regeneration, but not consummated until the believer enters into heaven. He hates sin and flees from it more and more; he loves God and delights to do the will of God in good works. Yet the corruption is still within him, though against his will; and grace is still in conflict with the corruption. Nay, the conflict rouses the corruption to a desperate resistance. Before, his eyes were blinded, his conscience inert; he did not see or feel the vileness and misery of sin, and knew not how great a sinner he was. Now, his sense of sin is keen. He compares himself with the law of God, the claims of God’s love on his heart; and in proportion as he desires and endeavors to obey, he discovers, to his shame and grief, his evilness of heart, his shortcomings, his failures, his lapses. He mourns that he hates sin so little; that he loves God in Christ so little; that he sins so often; that he does so few good works, and those so feebly. But the very sharpness of the conflict proves the activity of grace; and while he suffers that his spiritual life is so weak, he should thank God with joy that he is no longer dead. It is a great change which only the grace of God could work, that the current of his life has been turned from love of sin to love of holiness, from enmity against God to delight in the way of God’s commandments.
Hence the main and only sufficient evidence of our conversion lies in our principles. If the old man reigns over us, and we yield our desires and our affections and our acts to its corrupt will, we are yet dead in our sins; but if the new man be established in our hearts, and we yield to its godly will our desires and affections and acts, sincerely endeavoring after new obedience, we are children of grace. This is what our church says in her office for the holy communion, which is the profession and covenant of our faith in Christ: “We do not come to the supper to testify thereby that we are perfect and righteous in ourselves; but, on the contrary, considering that we seek our life out of ourselves in Christ, we acknowledge that we lie in the midst of death. Therefore, notwithstanding we feel many infirmities and miseries in ourselves, as namely, that we have not perfect faith, and do not give ourselves to serve God with that zeal as we are bound, and have daily to strive with the weakness of our faith and the evil lusts of our flesh, yet, since we are, by the grace of the Holy Ghost, sorry for these weaknesses, and earnestly desirous to fight against our unbelief, and to live according to all the commandments of God, therefore we rest assured that no sin or infirmity, which still remaineth against our will in us, can hinder us from being received of God in mercy, and from being made worthy partakers of the heavenly meat and drink.”
Lastly: We see how vain are all endeavors after repentance before faith in Christ. It is only the love of God in Christ that can change the enmity of our hearts to love. It is only our love to God in Christ that can constrain us to live not unto ourselves but unto him. Therefore, the contemplation of God’s love to us in Christ is the grand means of cultivating our repentance and accomplishing our conversion. It is as we look up to our crucified Forerunner on his throne, that the light of heaven streams down on our souls, and the attraction of God’s holy love overcomes the attraction of earth and sin. Look to Jesus, your Saviour; believe in him and hope in his promise; then shall you run with patience the race set before you, and at last come to perfect rest, in the perfect enjoyment of his love.