Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture XXXIV. Baptism. No. 3. The Subjects

Twenty-sixth and Twenty-seventh Lord’s Days

It remains for us to treat of, Fourthly: The subjects to whom Christian baptism should be administered.

From what has been said respecting the authority and design of this sacrament, it is clear that it should be administered to all adult believers who have not previously received the holy ordinance; but our church goes farther, and requires that the infant offspring of believers should also be baptized. This we hold in common with all Christians who practised baptism until comparatively modern times, and with the vast majority of Christians now.

The usage of infant baptism may be distinctly traced in Christian writers from the close of the apostolic age all the way down. Justin Martyr, who wrote his “Apology” about the middle of the second century after Christ, and when he must have been about fifty years old, speaking of those who belonged to the Christian church, says that among them were some “who had been made disciples of Christ from their childhood.” The term which he employs to signify their being discipled, is precisely that which we find in the original of our Lord’s command to his apostles: “Go ye, therefore, and teach all nations,” i. e. make disciples of all nations, “baptizing them” (Matt. xxviii. 19); and as the method prescribed was to baptize those who were discipled, we may safely understand Justin as asserting that the little children were baptized. Irenæus, the disciple of Polycarp, who was a disciple of the apostle John, writing nearly at the same time with Justin Martyr, says: “Christ came to save all who through him are re-born into God,—infants, and little ones, and children, and youths, and older people.” The expression “re-born into God,” without doubt was meant by him to signify baptized, such being his habit of language. Tertullian, about two hundred years after Christ, had some erroneous notions respecting the peculiar enormity of sins committed after baptism; and advises that infants, if they are likely to die, should be baptized, but otherwise that baptism should be delayed until as late a period of life as possible. In this opinion, it is evident from what he says himself, that he differed from his fellow-Christians generally, who practised infant baptism. Origen, in the former part of the third century, tells us, that the church “derived an order from the apostles to baptize infants”; and again: “According to the custom of the church, baptism is administered to infants, who would not need the grace of baptism, if there was nothing in them that needed forgiveness and mercy.” Cyprian, a contemporary of Origen, states that at a council, held in Carthage, A.D. 253, of sixty-six bishops or pastors of churches, one of their number proposed the question: Whether or not a child might be baptized before the eighth day after its birth, which was the time prescribed for circumcision? And the unanimous answer of the council was, “that the mercy and grace of God is to be withheld from no human being born; . . . that we ought not to debar any person from baptism and the grace of God, who is merciful and good to us all; and this rule, as it holds good for all, we think more especially to be observed in reference to infants, even to those newly born.” Surely, as Lord Chancellor King observes, “the unanimous voice of a synod, in such circumstances, denotes the common practice and usage of the church.” Chrysostom, toward the close of the fourth century, speaking of circumcision, says: “Our circumcision, I mean the grace of baptism, cures without pain, and procures for us a thousand benefits, and fills us with the grace of the Spirit; and it has no fixed time, as circumcision had; but one that is in the beginning of his age, or one in the middle of it, or one that is in old age, may receive this circumcision without hands.” Augustine, toward the beginning of the fifth century, says: “The whole church practises infant baptism. It was not instituted by councils, but was always in use.” Writing against the Pelagians, one of his most strenuous arguments is, that infants would not be baptized if they had no sin.” “They (the Pelagians) grant that infants must be baptized, not being able to resist the authority of the whole church, which was, doubtless, delivered by our Lord and his apostles.” In another place, speaking of the proper persons to offer the children for baptism, who he thinks are the parents, if they be pious, he speaks with approbation of those Christians who presented the infants of their slaves, or foundlings, or orphans. Similar declarations are frequent in his works. Pelagius, his great opponent, a native of Britain, who had travelled through southern Europe to Africa and Jerusalem, exclaims indignantly: “Men slander me by the charge that I deny baptism to infants.” “I never heard of any one, not the most impious heretic, who denied baptism to infants; for who can be so impious as to hinder infants from being baptized, and so born again in Christ, and thus make them miss of the kingdom of God?” Many other testimonies might be added; but let it suffice to say that no fact in the history of the first four Christian centuries is more firmly established than the universal practice of infant baptism, except by a few, who postponed it like Tertullian for the reason given, or still fewer (of any deserving at all the name of Christian), who thought water-baptism useless.

From the time of Augustine downwards, there is not the slightest trace of an individual, much less of a sect, who denied infant baptism until the year A. D. 1120, when Peter de Bruis, one of the Waldenses, preached against it; but his followers, called after him Petrobrussians, were very few, and disowned by all the rest of that pious people, who, preserving amidst their mountains the faith derived through their ancestors from apostles, practised, as they practise now, this edifying rite of the Christian church.

So all the churches of the Reformation, though intent more or less upon stripping themselves of the corruptions which had obtained through popery, unanimously consented, as they now consent, to the propriety and authority of infant baptism, with the exception of the sect calling themselves rather arrogantly Baptists, originally known as Anabaptists (from their re-baptizing such as had been baptized when infants, or had been sprinkled), which arose amidst much extravagant fanaticism in the beginning of the sixteenth century.

Here, then, we have the opinion of the whole Christian world from the apostolic age, both before and after the Reformation,—the Baptists excepted, who only within a few years have attained any considerable numbers, on the side of infant baptism. Our opponents cannot show us the slightest evidence that the practice was introduced at any time, though, had it been an innovation, it would have been noted, and must have caused discussion. The utter absence of all proof, or even surmise to the contrary, indicates that it has come to us from the apostles themselves. Besides, as has been urged, and in my judgment with irresistible force, the ordinance of baptism must have been, according to the views of our (so-called) Baptist friends, entirely lost. For, if no one is a member of the visible church unless baptized by immersion at an adult age, and consequently no one not so baptized can administer baptism, there were no legitimately baptized persons at the time the Anabaptists arose, nor had there been during many centuries before.

But we readily admit as sound the Protestant rule of acknowledging no evidence sufficient to establish a rule of Christian faith or practice except that of holy Scripture. What we have adduced from uninspired ecclesiastical history, though strongly corroborative of our practice, has been rather introductory to our argument than part of it; and now we follow our Catechist to the word of God.

“Quest. 74. Are infants also to be baptized?

“Ans. Yes; for since they, as well as adults, are included in the covenant and church of God, and since redemption from sin by the blood of Christ, and the Holy Ghost, the author of faith, is promised to them no less than to the adult, they must, therefore, by baptism, as a sign of the covenant, be also admitted into the Christian church, and be distinguished from the children of infidels; as was done in the old covenant, or testament, by circumcision, instead of which baptism is instituted in the new covenant.”

So, also, in the form for the administration of baptism, the church says:—

“Although our young children do not understand these things, we may not, therefore, exclude them from baptism, for as they are without their knowledge partakers of the condemnation in Adam, so are they again received unto grace in Christ; as God speaketh unto Abraham, the father of all the faithful, and, therefore, unto us and our children (Gen. xvii. 7), saying: ‘I will establish my covenant between me and thee, and thy seed after thee, in their generations, for an everlasting covenant, to be a God unto thee, and to thy seed after thee.’ This, also, the apostle Peter testifieth with these words (Acts ii. 39): ‘For the promise is unto you, and to your children, and to all that are afar off, even as many as the Lord our God shall call.’ Therefore, God formerly commanded them to be circumcised, which was a seal of the covenant, and of the righteousness of faith; and, therefore, Christ also embraced them, laid his hands upon them, and blessed them (Mark x. 6). Since, then, baptism is come in the place of circumcision; therefore, infants are to be baptized as heirs of the kingdom of God and of his covenant.”

Here are the principal arguments for infant baptism distinctly stated, and we shall consider them, following the order of the Catechism.

The infants of believers should be baptized: 1. Because they are included by the covenant which God through Christ makes with his people. 2. Because they are of right members of the church on earth. 3. Because the promises of the gospel extend to them. 4. Because it is proper that they should be openly distinguished, as the children of the covenanted church, from the children of unbelievers. 5. Because baptism, having come in the place of circumcision, is the authorized method of marking such distinction.

  1. The infants of believers should be baptized, because they are covered by the covenant which God through Christ makes with his people.

The strongest, purest, and most lasting affection which God has planted in the human heart is that of the parent for the child. Passion and expected reciprocities of benefits mingle with the love of husband and wife; marriage is a contract between the espousing parties. Community of interest and habits of close association bind together brothers and sisters of the same family, the bond being often greatly weakened when they go forth into their separate walks of life. Children are trained to love their parents by a consciousness of dependence and gratitude for kindness received from them. But parental love is conceived and born with the child. The father, the mother, love their offspring as part, nay, as a dearer part, of themselves. Their regard is given, not indeed without hopes of their own happiness from their child’s happiness and duty, but without bargain, or stipulation, or requisition of pledges. It is free, liberal, unselfish,—an animal instinct dignified to a high and noble affection by a rational sense of obligation, the exercise of which is itself a delight; so that the parents live for the child, preferring its health, prosperity, and honor to their own ease or fortunes. Friendship may be turned into hate; the love of husband and wife may decay and cease; brothers and sisters may be estranged or quarrel; children may forget and requite with ill the parents who nurtured them up to adult years; but for a parent to forget, to call back love, or the fruits of love, from a child, is a thing deemed of all things the most unnatural, a moral insanity, showing a monstrous departure from the due course of the human heart.

The reason why God has given such great strength to this affection is seen in the difficulty and importance of the duties which devolve upon parents. But for their constant, watchful, patient, tender care, the babe would perish; or, if nursed only through the helplessness of infancy, would seldom reach mature age through the inexperience of childhood and the novel temptations which throng upon the youth. Nothing short of the strongest love could secure even the physical nurture of their offspring; much more is it necessary for the mental and moral training which they need. It is the wise, fixed arrangement of Providence that parents should stand between God and their seed, as his agents to provide for their well-being in both these respects. Our heavenly father has proceeded upon this principle in all his dealings with our race, making parental affection an argument for parental fidelity, encouraging it by promises, and alarming it by threats. How true this was of the first covenant he made with man, the melancholy consequences of our first parents’ sin but too plainly declare; and it were strange indeed if children could be so deeply concerned with the fall of Adam, and yet no provision be made for their uprising with Christ. Their representation before their birth, in their primal ancestor, establishes beyond doubt the law of such representation in subsequent stages of our human history, though, for obvious reasons, not to the same extent. No one doubts that in the affairs of this life, children suffer or are advantaged by their parents’ conduct; and, in the order of civil society, the parent is ever recognized as the representative of his child until it is of age to assume its own responsibility. Thus God declares, that he is “a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate him”; but, also, that “his righteousness is unto children’s children, to such as keep his covenant and remember his commandments to do them.” Hence we find that parental anxiety has been assuaged, and parental responsibility enforced by every covenant made with man under the system of grace. The first revelation of mercy at the very gates of the lost paradise was to the parents through their seed, when God said in their hearing to the serpent-tempter: “I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel,”—a prophecy fulfilled in the triumphant passion of Christ, the son of a virgin; nor could the believers of that promise offer a sacrifice in faith without including the offspring through whom the deliverer was to come.

So in the covenant with Noah, after the deluge, God expressly declared: “Behold, I establish my covenant with thee and with thy seed.” To Abraham he said: “Behold, my covenant is with thee . . . . Behold, I establish my covenant with thee, and with thy seed after thee.” Nay, to show that this covenant included his seed from their early infancy, he appointed the sacrament of circumcision to be performed when the children were but eight days old. In this sense God continued to declare himself as the God of Israel, declaring the whole nation to be “his people”; and upon one remarkable occasion Moses required not only the men of Israel but their wives and their little ones to stand before the Lord “and enter into covenant with the Lord their God, and into his oath, which the Lord their God made with them that day” (Deut. xxix. 10–15). Such was the faith and practice of the ancient believers up to the time when the descent of the Holy Ghost at the Pentecost confirmed the church of Christ. Can we be made to believe that this gospel was less merciful to parental hearts than the older dispensation, and that they were refused the highly valued privilege, enjoyed by believers in all previous times, of dedicating their offspring openly to the Lord? No; for the apostle Peter, in the very hour when the spirit of God came down, proclaimed that the promise was unto them and their children, and to them that was afar off, even to as many as the Lord our God should call. So we read that the angel of the Lord commanded Cornelius, the Gentile centurion, to send to Joppa for Peter, who should tell him words whereby he and all his house should be saved (Acts xi. 13, 14); and Paul, in his exhortation to the jailer, said: “Believe in the Lord Jesus Christ and thou shalt be saved, and thy house.” The same apostle also declares, when speaking of those believers who were married to heathen: “The unbelieving husband is sanctified by the believing wife, and the unbelieving wife by the husband, else were your children unclean, but now are they holy” (1 Cor. vii. 14). Holy does not, we admit, in this passage signify personal freedom from sin, but fitness to be dedicated to God; yet, surely, the text has no meaning, if they might not be openly dedicated.

From this clearly established principle of the representation of children in the believing parent, it follows,—

  1. That they (the children of believers) are of right members of the church on earth.

Such, we have seen, was the fact and the practice of the church under the Abrahamic dispensation. Every Israelite was by birth entitled to membership of the church, the sign of which was circumcision of the male infants. That the Christian church is a continuation of the Abrahamic, the apostle puts beyond all reasonable doubt when he asserts that “they which be of faith are blessed with faithful Abraham” (Gal. iii. 9), to whom God preached the gospel when he said: “In thee shall all nations be blessed” (8, v.); and again: “If ye be Christ’s, then are ye Abraham’s seed, and children according to the promise” (29, v.). It is vain to say that the covenant of God with Abraham, into which the newly born Israelite was brought by circumcision, had reference only to temporal blessings; for the apostle often asserts that circumcision was a seal of the righteousness of faith, though certain temporal blessings were also secured by it to his natural posterity. If, then, infants were admitted as members of the church under the old dispensation, how can it be denied that they are not to be admitted under the new? If it were right in the one, it must be right in the other case, because the fundamental constitution of both is the same: justification by faith. Where we ask, is there any proof in all the New Testament writings that the right of believers to church-membership is taken away? Where is there a single text to show that the Christian believer may not dedicate his child as the Jewish believer was privileged to do? On the contrary, we find four instances of entire households being baptized: that of Cornelius, that of Lydia, that of the jailer, and that of Stephanas. If it be objected to this, that we do not know whether there were any but adults capable of personal faith in these households, we answer that one could scarcely take four families at random without finding some infants among them; and, besides, the promise in the case of the jailer was to him as the head of his house: “Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved and thy house.” Not, “If thy house also believe, they shall also be saved”; but, “Believe thou, and thy house shall be saved with thee.” The same thing is intimated to Cornelius by the angel: “He (Peter) shall tell thee words, whereby thou and all thy house shall be saved.” So Peter at the Pentecost: “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ, for the remission of your sins, and ye shall receive the Holy Ghost; for the promise is unto you and to your children, and to all that are afar off (i. e. the Gentiles), even to as many as the Lord our God shall call.” There the promise and baptism go together; and if the children were included by the promise, they had also the privilege of receiving the baptism which was the sign of the promise.

We are aware of the cavil against this view, that the reception of baptism is a profession of faith, and, therefore, as infants are not capable of faith, they are not capable of receiving baptism. Circumcision was a sign of faith, as much as baptism is; the infant Israelite received it on the faith of his parent; so may the child of the Christian believer receive it on the faith of his parent. Besides, it savors of strong impiety to say that infants may not be members of Christ’s church, when he himself took special pains to declare that “of such is the kingdom of heaven.” Nay, when he rebuked his disciples for keeping back the mothers who pressed forward to lay their little ones in the Saviour’s arms: “Suffer little children to come unto me, and forbid them not.” How can children be brought openly to Christ as members of his kingdom, but by Christian baptism, in the initiatory rite ordained by himself? How can we lay them in his arms, but by committing them to the embrace of his church?

  1. The promises of the gospel extend to the infants of believers.

This we have already seen; but under the Old Testament the parents were required to claim the promise for their offspring according to the external rites of the law; so are believers under the New Testament to testify their belief in the promise of God respecting their children by the rite of the gospel. It is not enough for a man that he believes; he must be baptized in token of his belief; so it is not enough that the parent believes in the promise to his child; he must present his child for baptism in token of his belief; nor can he claim the blessing of the covenant except he avails himself of its seal. Thus, it is a sin on his own part, and injustice toward his unconscious child, not to ask the blessing for it according to the manner which God has ordained.

This is the more important,

  1. Because it is proper that the children of believers should be distinguished openly from the children of unbelievers.

The church is the visible representative of the kingdom of God upon earth. As the children of a citizen inherit, of course, the citizenship, so does the child of a church-member, by actual descent, become entitled to church-membership until he forfeits it by his own conduct. It is, therefore, a privilege of the believer to enroll his offspring among the openly covenanted people of God. It is a duty which he owes to the world, that he may show his high sense of the Christian name. It is his duty to his child thus to put him in the position which will remind him, when of years to understand, that he is of the covenanted seed. Volumes might be filled with the blessed consequences of such faith and such open avowal of it. And were Christians more faithful in following up the vows and obligations they assume, and in impressing upon their children the obligations under which they rest, the numbers of such blessed consequences would be greatly enlarged.

  1. Because baptism is come in the place of circumcision, it is the authorized method of marking the distinction between the children of the covenanted church and those of unbelievers. That baptism has come in the place of circumcision, we have already proved. Circumcision was the initiatory rite of the old dispensation. Baptism is that of the new. Circumcision has been done away, baptism remains; therefore is it in the place of circumcision. The objection that circumcision was confined to the males, and therefore cannot be succeeded by baptism which females are also to receive, is preposterous. All who are in Christ are to be baptized; but in Christ there is neither male nor female, and therefore all are to be baptized without distinction of sex. If our other arguments in favor of infant baptism are valid, it must be administered to all the infants of believers, as the more gracious sign of a new and better dispensation.