Lecture XXXV. The Sacrament of the Supper. Part I. Its Institution and Its Mode
Twenty-eighth Lord’s Day
Having carefully considered and expounded the doctrine and benefits of holy baptism, which is the ordinance initiatory to the church of Christ visible on earth, we shall now treat in full of The Holy Supper, which is the confirmatory ordinance of our faith and practice as members of the Christian church; for, as it is necessary to our salvation, not only that we should believe and profess Christ’s religion, but also should persevere in the duties of Christian practice even to the end of our lives, so it is necessary that not only we should be born again of the Spirit, but also that we should be nourished by the Spirit to a constant growth of our divine life until it is made perfect in glory. Hence the appointment of the holy supper, which, by its expressive emblems and frequent administration, represents and confirms to the believer the maintenance and increase of his Christianity from his communion and enjoyment of Christ, his only life, strength, and head. Before entering on our proposed discussion, let us remind ourselves of the definition which our church gives of the sacraments in the Twenty-fifth Lord’s Day, sixty-sixth question and answer of the Catechism: “The sacraments are holy, visible signs and seals, appointed of God for this end, that by the use thereof he may the more fully declare and seal to us the promise of the gospel, viz: that he grants us freely the remission of our sins, and life eternal, for the sake of the one sacrifice of Christ accomplished on the cross.” They are holy, for it is necessary that they be appointed of God; visible, for they are ordinances of the church visible: they are signs to represent invisible, because spiritual, realities; and seals, because they are granted to confirm the word of grace in the promises of the gospel; and they are intended to bring us to a more lively contemplation and appropriation of the salvation accomplished for us by the one sacrifice of Christ on the cross.
Not forgetting these fundamental facts and truths, we must consider this second sacrament, commonly called the Lord’s supper, under several heads:—
First: Its institution. Secondly: Its mode. Thirdly: Its purpose. Fourthly: Its participants.
This order is somewhat changed from that of the Catechism, but no more than is desirable for the sake of convenience.
First: The institution or appointment of the Lord’s supper.
Our blessed Lord, being by his human lineage and by his circumcision one of the Israelitish church, observed all its ordinances until their end was accomplished by his vicarious death on the cross. Of these ordinances, the Passover, or feast of the paschal lamb, was the principal. It represented two things: first, the salvation of the first-born of Israel from the angel who slew all the first-born of Egypt, and distinguished the dwellings of the chosen people by the blood of the lamb slain under divine command, which was sprinkled on their door-posts; secondly, the exodus of Israel out of Egypt by the miraculous deliverance and guidance of God, the covenanted Jehovah of their fathers. It was essential to the observance of this feast that a spotless firstling male of the flock should be slain (care being taken that not a bone of it was broken), and that each Israelite should partake of its flesh as their families were assembled in convenient numbers for the purpose. The time of its celebration was in the evening of the second day of the feast of unleavened bread, the lamb having been slain on the first.
Our Lord had observed the other passovers without special comment to his disciples; but the evangelists represent him as preparing for the last, which was on the night in which he was betrayed, with peculiar care and solemnity. “With desire,” said he, as he sat down with the twelve apostles, “I have desired to eat of this passover before I suffer.” The reasons for this are obvious. The passover, though commemorative, was in a higher degree typical. The event it commemorated was typical of the deliverance of his people from the death of the law, and their deliverance out of the bondage of Satan. The paschal lamb typified himself, at once the sacrifice for his people, and their deliverer. He was about to fulfil by his death on the cross, and by his resurrection, all the salvation God had promised by covenant and by sign. He, therefore, avails himself of the last opportunity before he suffered, and of the expressive rite itself, to ordain for his church in all ages a sacrament which should confirm their faith by a remembrance of his death and their deliverance. Three evangelists give an account of his action in nearly the same words. Matthew says: “As they were eating, Jesus took bread, and blessed it, and brake it, and gave it to the disciples, and said, Take, eat; this is my body. And he took the cup (for wine was always used at the paschal supper) and gave thanks and gave it to them, saying, Drink ye all of it; for this is my blood of the New Testament, which is shed for many for the remission of sins.” Luke’s version varies from those of Matthew and Mark by adding after the words “This is my body”—“which is given for you; this do in remembrance of me.” That our Lord meant thus to institute a perpetual ordinance is established by the manifest import of the words themselves, and the practice of the church on and after the day of Pentecost; but also put beyond doubt by the apostle Paul in 1 Cor. xi. 23–26: “For I have received of the Lord that which also I delivered unto you, That the Lord Jesus the same night in which he was betrayed took bread; and when he had given thanks, he brake it, and said, Take, eat; this is my body, which is broken for you; this do in remembrance of me. After the same manner, also, he took the cup, when he had supped, saying, This cup is the New Testament in my blood; this do ye, as oft as ye drink of it, in remembrance of me. For, as often as ye eat this bread and drink this cup, ye do show the Lord’s death till he come.”
From this collation of these several passages, we note several things: 1. That our Lord changed the Passover, which was a sacrament of the Old Testament, or covenant with Abraham, into the Lord’s supper, as a sacrament of the New Testament, or the covenant of God with Christ, as the head of his church. 2. That our Lord brake not the flesh of the paschal lamb, which was a sacrifice, but bread, which is an emblem of nourishment; and afterward represented his blood by wine, which is an emblem of joy, for the cup of wine which our Lord thus used was at the end of the Passover, and was called the cup of blessing, or praise, or of salvation (Ps. cxvi. 13); thus showing that there was to be no farther expiatory sacrifice or shedding of blood, but that the doctrine of the sacrament, as a commemoration of Christ’s death, was thenceforward to be the nourishment and joy of Christian souls. 3. That, as the sacrament was one of faith in the accomplishment of salvation by the death of Christ, and of thanksgiving for such inestimable benefits, it was to continue until Christ, who is not dead but risen, shall come from the right hand of the Father to receive his people unto himself. 4. That they who by true faith partake of the elements, bread and wine, thus ordained and consecrated, become united to Christ’s body, and so are made partakers of all the benefits which Christ, the head of the church, receives by virtue of the covenant of God the Father for the church, which is his body.
We also learn the reasons for the several appellations given to this sacrament: The Lord’s supper (1 Cor. xi. 20), because it was ordained at the paschal supper in the evening; the Lord’s table (1 Cor. x. 21), because the disciples were and are gathered around a table at the head of which he was, and by his spirit still is,—not an altar, as though it were a sacrifice, but a table, because it is a feast; the communion (1 Cor. x. 16), because those who receive it are made partakers individually and in common of the body of Christ, and so are confirmed in fellowship with him and with each other in him: “For we being many are one bread and one body, for we are all partakers of that one bread;” the eucharist, or thanksgiving, a name not given to it expressly by any Scripture, but with good reason adopted by the church, because it is a sacrament of praise and thanksgiving for the great benefits flowing from Christ’s meritorious death to all who truly receive him into their hearts. For we must remember, again, that our sacrament was not instituted until after the last passover, and the cup of wine was that which the Israelites were accustomed to partake of at the close of their feast, and was called by them the cup of salvation, or of thanksgiving. Thus all the circumstances of its institution by our divine Lord, and all the names by which it was known to the primitive church, show that this sacrament is not a sacrifice offered in hope of benefits to be obtained, but a thankful celebration and believing participation of benefits already purchased for us by Christ on the cross, and held for us as an open treasury of full supplies by Christ on his throne till he come again at the consummation of all things.
We are now prepared to consider,
Secondly: The mode of this sacrament.
- The elements, or the material signs. These are bread and wine.
The bread, with which our Lord actually instituted the sacrament, being the bread of the Passover, was undoubtedly unleavened bread, which has, in ages past, led some to think that a careful conformity to our Lord’s example should require us to use no other in our celebrations of it. Indeed, there was a fierce dispute between the scholastic doctors of the Roman church and the doctors of the Greek church on this point: the Greeks calling the Latins opprobriously azymites (α, priv., and ζύμη, leaven), because they consecrated unleavened bread, and the Latins retorting angrily on the Greeks for having departed from the primitive usage. The Latins were, however, by no means unanimous in this respect, for the schoolmen met with stout opponents from among their own communion; and I believe the general sentiment of the Romish doctors is against the schoolmen. It is decided by learned men that the use of unleavened bread and wafers was unknown in the church, except among the heretical Ebionites, until the eleventh century at the earliest, the bread before that time being taken from the offerings of bread and wine brought by the communicants for the use of the poor,1 when of course the bread was leavened. Some of the early fathers (as Ambrose, De Sac. iv. 4) expressly say that the bread they used was common bread (panis usitatus).2 The only scripture bearing upon this point is that in 1 Cor. v. 7, 8: “For even Christ our passover is sacrificed for us; therefore let us keep the feast, not with the old leaven, neither with the leaven of malice and wickedness, but with the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth.” There is no reason, however, to think that the apostle there is giving directions about the eucharist, but that he only uses a striking figure to signify the purity and humility and unanimity which the church should maintain. There was a commemorative reason for the use of unleavened bread in the Passover, which commemorated the haste of the Israelites in escaping from Egypt, but it has no significance under the New Testament; and it should be rejected as a part of the painful services required under the now obsolete yoke of bondage. Bread in our sacrament is an emblem of strength and confidence, which the absence of leaven would impair. But it is essential to the sacrament that bread, not wafers,—substantial, home-like, every-day bread,—should be employed and partaken of, in order to our more complete realization of our constant dependence on Christ for the support of our Christian life. Indeed, we have reason to know that the early Christians not only celebrated the Lord’s supper often, but that they were wont to make an imitation of it when they sat down to their ordinary meal, especially when believers long parted, or from a distance, chanced to meet together.
Wine, in the second part of the sacrament or communion of the cup, is the element essential to its right administration. There can be no question that our Lord used wine; for not only was the cup of blessing at the close of the Passover filled with wine, but both Matthew and Mark tell us that immediately afterwards he said: “I will not drink henceforth of this fruit of the vine, until that day I drink it new with you in my Father’s kingdom.” The cup was an emblem of joy, which could not have been if it were filled with any other liquid. It was also significant of the manner in which Christ’s blood was pressed out of him by his agony, as the wine is pressed from the grapes. It was also in accordance with the prophecies, especially that remarkable one in Isaiah (xxv. 6), where he employs the figure of a feast to describe the evangelical dispensation: “And in this mountain shall the Lord of hosts make unto all people a feast of fat things, a feast of wines on the lees; of fat things full of marrow, of wines on the lees well refined.” Some say that the wine employed by the Saviour and drunk by the Jews at the Passover was not intoxicating wine, but a species of must; yet this is far from being ascertained, besides being contradictory to Isaiah’s description of it as wine on the lees well refined, and also destructive of the idea of joy or exhilaration. The plea for substituting some unfermented drink, such as water or milk, in the place of wine, that it encourages, perhaps suggests, intemperance, is profane, for it impeaches the propriety of our Lord’s example, as if it were not sufficient in all ages. Yet to such impious lengths has a superscriptural zeal for reform been carried by some who would be wiser than their infallible Lord! No wonder that their reform has been so greatly a failure; for the pleasure of him whose blessing alone can make efforts at good efficient must be withheld from measures which fortify themselves by disobedience to the divine command, and impeachment of Christ’s wisdom and exemplary virtue. Care should be taken that the wine is the genuine fruit of the grape, not the base mixtures which counterfeit; and pure wine can be obtained, if sufficient care be taken.
There can, however, be little doubt that the practice of mingling the sacramental wine with water obtained largely in the primitive church. It was based on the asserted custom of the Jews so to mingle the wine of the Passover with water, and also on the fact that when our Lord’s heart was pierced by the spear of the soldier, there flowed from it blood mingled with water. The more learned doctors, both Romanist and Protestant, are now mostly agreed in thinking the practice unnecessary. The wines of Palestine are strong and heady, so as to give a reason for their being reduced, which does not exist now, when light, pure wines may be readily obtained; and as to the water which flowed from the heart (or pericardium) of our Lord, he himself makes no allusion to it, but speaks only of the wine when appointing the cup as the sign of the New Testament. There can, however, be little objection made to the mingling of water with the sacramental wine, but there is no authority for it; and it is best not to go beyond what is written.
- The formula, or, as our church expresses it, “words of the institution.”
As the church, having no right to ordain sacramental ceremonies, is bound to receive and observe those which our Lord and his apostles have appointed, the sacrament of the Lord’s supper is not validly administered except the authority and purpose of it be declared out of the word of God, by the solemn, formal recital of our Lord’s own language when instituting the supper, and that of the apostle Paul where he confirms and further enjoins it. Thus our church, in her “form,” or office, “for the administration of the Lord’s supper,” begins it by reciting the passage (1 Cor. xi. 23–30) in which the apostle Paul cites from the gospels the account of its appointment by our Lord himself; and, also, adds his apostolical declaration of our duty and meaning and responsibility rightly to observe it. Not satisfied with this, in a subsequent part of the form, and that we who faithfully commune may firmly believe that we belong to the covenant of grace, our church repeats the account from the gospels of the last supper of our Lord with his disciples.
From the necessities of our nature we may often partake of bread and wine in company with fellow-Christians, and like the early Christians we may see in our household meal parables of the body and blood of Christ; but it is obvious that the confusion of such ordinary meals with the divine sacrament of the supper would lead to licentious and impious abuse. The apostle, in the same chapter which enjoins the sacrament, evidently rebukes abuses of this sort when he says: “When ye come together, therefore, into one place, [this] is not to eat the Lord’s supper; for in eating, every one taketh before other his own supper; and one is hungry and another is drunken. What! have ye not houses to eat and to drink in? Or despise ye the church of God? What shall I say to you? Shall I praise you in this? I praise you not.” He then proceeds with the solemn words: “For I have received of the Lord Jesus that which also I delivered unto you,” &c. Hence we infer, that, as in the administration of baptism the formula appointed by our Lord, “In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost,” should be pronounced, so the administration of this sacrament is not valid, except the words which our Lord and his apostle used in its appointment and confirmation be reverently employed to distinguish it from all other feasts.
It does not follow, however, that the words of institution may not be accompanied by instructions and exhortations fitted to the service. On the contrary, such are highly desirable for the better acquaintance of the people with their duties and privileges. Experience has shown that, notwithstanding the revealed teachings on the subject, people are prone to misunderstand and misappropriate the sacrament; and, therefore, as preaching upon other Scriptures is no dishonor to their efficiency, but a specially appointed means of edification, so such exposition may be made, and with profit, of the Scriptures ordaining the sacraments. It has also been found, that, at the time of celebrating this very solemn rite, the hearts of the people are more than usually disposed to hear and receive instruction respecting the great facts and doctrines and duties of religion; and therefore it is most meet and desirable that such instruction should be carefully given. So important did this appear to our fathers of the Reformed churches, that they all (I am not aware of any exception in Great Britain or on the Continent) prepared, with great pains, forms, or offices, which should be used whenever the Lord’s supper was administered. This they did, evidently, from a consideration that, though a faithful and intelligent pastor would not administer the sacrament without a due exposition of it, yet, that there might be found pastors too careless or less qualified to expound it fully; and so, to secure the instruction of the people and to prevent errors or abuses creeping in, the churches took the duty into their own hands, so far as to require the reading or recital of a sufficient form which had their corporate sanction. Any reader of the disputes and difficulties which occurred then respecting the doctrine and manner of the supper, will see at once how necessary such appointed forms were; and any one who knows the deceitfulness of the human heart will acknowledge that what has occurred may occur again. Some of the Reformed churches, as the Presbyterian in Great Britain and this country, have allowed their ancient forms to become obsolete; but our church, like the churches of the Continent, has retained in her service-book the form prepared and appointed by our fathers. Its excellence, though somewhat marred by defects and errors in our translation, is so high, that it may without extravagance be pronounced the best uninspired commentary on the Lord’s supper, of equal length, in any language. Our church does not claim authority to dictate beyond the warrant of Holy Scriptures; but when she solemnly recommends, through the unanimous voice of her assemblies and presbyters and people for so many years, a form of sound words in full undoubted accordance with the articles of her faith, which we profess to believe, for the better and uniform administration of the sacrament, it seems only decent and just that such form should be used, except in such very extraordinary cases where it would be impracticable or burdensome. To allow each or any administrator of the sacrament to omit parts of the form at his option would be to risk the value of the whole, as he might omit parts in order to screen his own unsoundness of doctrine or discipline from the condemnation of the church. For one man, from his own personal judgment of its fitness or unfitness, to omit or amend the words of our united church, savors little of modesty and much of impertinent presumption. If the form be faulty, from the great length or for any other reason, let it be duly altered by the united, pious wisdom of the church; but it were painful to think of leaving her well-digested, venerable words to the rashness of every self-sufficient, egotistical meddler who sets himself up for a pope in his little sphere. As it is, if the form be faithfully and solemnly read, our Christian people are, at least four times a year, reminded and made to consider the doctrines and duties taught by the sacrament in a discourse or treatise so able and pious that there lives no single man, whatever be his intellect or attainments, who can write one as good, or amend it by omission or addition. Guard that precious form, beloved Christians, from corruption or garbling. If the united church sees fit to make changes in it, there is little doubt of their being judicious; but frown upon any attempt to touch its integrity by any individual.
- The action.
It is not enough that the bread and wine be set forth to the eyes of the people, but essential to the sacrament that the very action of our Lord, when he presented the elements to his disciples, should be called to mind, and this by the action of the administrator; for as the sacrament is in every part a sign, so every part of the sign should be preserved and perpetuated, that thereby the things signified should be visibly, i. e. by visible forms, brought before the people for their spiritual edification. Therefore, the bread should be broken, and the wine poured forth or extended (for we do not read that our Lord did actually pour the wine into the cup when he consecrated it), the administrator at the same time declaring, in the words of Scripture, that the broken bread and the wine in the cup are separate by the communion, the one of the body, the other of the blood of Christ. For it is not the bread in the loaf, or the wine in the cup, which is the communion of Christ, but the bread and the cup, distributed and received by the communicants with their mouth. Hence the apostle says: “The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not the communion of the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, is it not the communion of the body of Christ?” which shows clearly that the action of our Lord is to be repeated by the officiator. The action of the sacrament is not complete, therefore, even with the distribution of the elements, but only when the believer actually receives them within his mouth, and both eats the one and drinks the other, so that there be a real participation. The administrator does not confer the grace of the sacraments; he but does his part in the use of the means, by extending the elements through which, according to the promise of God, Christ offers himself to our participation. The reception of the elements is the action by which the believer declares his appropriation to himself of the grace promised to those who in true faith use the sign which Christ has ordained. Hence, our Lord expressly commanded the disciples to eat the bread: “Take, eat;” and to drink the wine: “Drink ye all of it.” Hence, also, the apostle says: “As often as ye eat of this bread and drink of this cup, ye do show [proclaim, καταγγέλετε] the Lord’s death till he come.” The notion which some, who are unwilling to profess Christ before men, are fond of entertaining that they may spiritually partake of the things signified in the sacrament, though not actually partaking of the elements, is erroneous and dangerous. That such grace may be allowed in special cases, (as where fair opportunity has not been had to obtain admission at the table, &c.,) we cannot deny, for God is very merciful to our weaknesses; but the believer is bound to take his part in the open celebration, or, as the word “show” means, the proclamation or setting forth of Christ’s salvation, which he cannot do unless he actually partakes of the proffered elements.
- The posture.
There can be no doubt that our Lord intended by this sacrament to present before the church a lively representation of his church united as a household of God around a family table, partaking of the same spiritual food, and united to each other because united to Christ, the institutor and master of the feast. When our Lord ordained the sacrament, he was at the head of the table of the paschal supper, and administered the bread and the wine to his disciples,—they, like himself, being in the posture common to them at their meals. The idea of a family in the communion of a household feast, is wellnigh as essential to the sacrament as that of receiving by faith the body and blood of the Lord. But a table is essential to the representation of that sacred idea; and hence the apostle speaks by inspiration of “the table of the Lord”; and the Protestant church almost universally uses the term, “the Lord’s Table,” as synonymous with the sacrament of the supper. It is not a supper in common (or communion), except as we gather around a table, and that in the posture we ordinarily use on such occasions of common participation. Hence our church, in common with most of the Reformed churches, sets before the people a table crowned with the holy elements, and invites the true disciples of Christ to separate themselves from the world, and gather themselves together about the table that they may sit together as a family of God.
It is to be regretted that our houses of worship are not often so constructed as to allow the setting of a table sufficiently large for all the communicants to seat themselves at. Those who have had an opportunity of being present at a communion where that method was employed will confess that the solemnity and instructiveness of the rite were greatly increased. But since this, from the narrowness of our church aisles, is not often feasible, painful expedients, somewhat opposite in character, have been resorted to. The Scotch churches and some others, for instance, unwilling to diminish the significance of the table, bring forward the communicants in successive groups suited to the size of the table, administering the elements to each group by themselves. But in so doing they lose the perhaps equally necessary idea of communing together and at the same time as one family. They may, it is true, commune together in spirit, but the outward visible form of the communion is not fully maintained. As the apostle says: “Every one taketh before other his own supper.”
Some other churches, as our own, have adopted the opposite and scarcely less offensive plan of gathering as many as may be conveniently brought around the table, and allowing the rest to occupy the ordinary seats of the church, trusting that in their own minds they will consider themselves as at the table, while communing with their brethren and sisters there. Still the significance of the Lord’s table is greatly impaired. Nor do we hesitate to say that the expedient is the reverse of edifying. Certainly, it should not be resorted to except by necessity. The table should be as large as possible, and no other seats occupied, but when it is filled. The aged or infirm may very well be allowed to keep their previous places, for the gospel requires no painful ordinances; but others have no such excuse, and ought not to lose any benefit of the instructive figure. If the table be not large enough for all, those who cannot find places at it should at least change to others, that they in outward act as well as in thought go to the holy table.
Let it not be said that mere form is of little account, so that the heart be right. What is the external administration of the Lord’s supper but a form? and ordained for the very reason that, in the wisdom of God, form is necessary to the exhibition of the Christian church to the world and to itself? and that the appointed sacraments, as outward visible forms, or signs or seals, are highly edifying, by the grace of the Holy Ghost, to those who profess Christ? The same argument that would do away with one part of the form would do away with the sacrament altogether; which is the case with the Friends or Quakers, who reject the outward sacraments, because, as they say, they spiritually receive the truths which those forms signify.
The Puritans, with all their other virtues and services to Christianity, did the cause of religion much harm by stripping the outward church of associations, which, from our human nature, God has mercifully and wisely employed for the edification and comfort of his people while yet in the body of flesh. As the Quaker rejects all colors but drab, though God has scattered variegated beauty on every side, so the Puritan rejected all but straight lines, though the graceful curve is seen in every leaf and wave and form of living creature. We may not, from our own fancy or taste, attempt to improve on the forms which God has appointed, or introduce superscriptural novelties; but we should retain all the illustrations of truth he has given us, especially in the sacraments. We are weak creatures, wholly dependent on God’s Holy Spirit through the means of grace for our upholding; and the church is compared to a vine which has not strength of its own to stand erect; but the vine clasps the supporting elm or trellis-work by its curling tendrils,—tendrils because they are tender,—not by its trunk or stronger branches only. So every association of the sacrament has its uses to help the tender faith and clinging affections of the lowly-minded communicant, conscious of his own weakness, but clasping the strength of Christ. We are not Puritans, but of the Reformed churches.
You see by these observations that our church rejects those customs, in observing the Lord’s supper, which have greatly assisted the abominable perversions of the Popish mass, as we shall have occasion farther to show. Adopting the profane and absurd belief that the bread and the wine were actually transubstantiated (or changed in substance) to the actual body and blood of our Lord, the adherents of a heathenish compound with Christianity soon came to believe that the eucharist was also an actual repetition of our Lord’s one meritorious sacrifice on the cross. Hence they were so fond as to consider the officiating minister a priest or sacrificer, contending that when he pronounced the words “This is my body,” and “This is my blood,” the bread and the wine not only underwent in his hands the transubstantiation, but also became the victim which he (the priest) had sacerdotal power to offer meritoriously to God for the remission of sins. Hence, also, the holy table came to be regarded as the altar on which the sacrifice of the mass was offered; and as they were taught that the divinity of Christ was actually in the bread and wine, they were required to kneel in adoration.
It is not denied that at an early date some Christian writers called the communion table the altar,—but Θυσιαστήριον, never βωμός; which latter word is used only once in the New Testament (Acts vii. 23); but it is certain that, until the rise of transubstantiation, they employed the term as synonymous with the sacred table. The New Testament nowhere assumes even this, and, therefore, no usage can justify it.
Rejecting, as the Reformed churches do, the whole doctrine of the mass, the transubstantiation, and the sacrifice, and regarding the sacrament as a commemorative and illustrative supper or feast, we also reject the word priest, other than as applied to Christ, the High Priest, or to every Christian who offers thanks unto God; we also reject the word altar, believing that Christ in heaven is the only altar of his church, and we sit at the Lord’s table as guests of Christ, and do not kneel in idolatry of what we believe to be mere emblems.
There are Protestant churches in which the terms priest and altar, with the kneeling posture at the eucharist, are retained; but they are remnants of a superstition which should be considered exploded, and guarded against accordingly. Luther, though he rejected the priesthood of the clergy, and the repetition of Christ’s sacrifice, yet clung to the Popish doctrine so far as to claim for the elements a consubstantiation, as he termed it, with Christ’s real person. So his followers retain the term altar, and kneel at it when receiving the sacrament. During the Reformation in England, under Henry VIII. and Elizabeth, the court politicians, and some clergy only half-converted from Rome, were anxious to conform the Protestant church as much as they could to the old superstitions, that the prejudices of the people might not be shocked by too great a change of ritual. Hence, in spite of vigorous remonstrances from more determined reformers in the new English church, they forced upon it many things which had better have been abandoned, and among them the terms priest and altar, and this kneeling at the eucharist. No doubt, many pious people among them kneel around the altar without any remnant of idolatrous superstition, contending that kneeling is a most solemn posture, fitted for so solemn an act. But as it destroys the idea of communion at the table of the Lord, kneeling, though a fit posture in other devotional acts, has no fitness at the holy communion. It is a variation from our Lord’s own method, and it gives favor to gross errors.
- The administrator.
As was said in treating of baptism, the proper person to administer the Lord’s supper is the ordained minister, the bishop settled or acting for the time being, of the church,—that is the pastor, who, from his very name, is to feed the flock of Christ. At every feast some one sits at the head of the table; and Christ is spiritually at the head of his own. But as it is a sensible rite, it is proper that the Master should be visibly represented, which can be by none so properly as by one of those whom he has appointed to proclaim his word, and whom he has set as overseers of his house. Hence we find that no sect or denomination of Christians who acknowledge an ordained ministry allow the administration of this sacrament to any other hands than theirs. As they have succeeded the apostles in the office of preaching, so they succeed the apostles in this.
As helpers are required to distribute the elements among the people, our church commits the service not to the elders, who are joined with the minister in the oversight of the church, but to the deacons, whose very name signifies servants, and who were appointed to serve tables. This service, it is true, was for the poor; but are we not all poor, and do we not receive the Lord’s bounty at his holy table? Who so proper, then, as the servants of the Lord’s poor to minister of his bread and wine to us?
- The times of observance.
It appears from Scripture that the celebration of this sacrament was, at the beginning, part of every Lord’s day’s service, as we read (Acts xx. 7): “Upon the first day of the week, when the disciples came together to break bread, Paul preached unto them.” Nay, it would seem that during the great joy of the Pentecost it was celebrated every day; for they, “continuing daily with one accord in the temple, and breaking bread from house to house, did eat their meat [food] with gladness and singleness of heart.” The probability is, that, greatly needing divine consolations in their trials, and being prevented by their persecutors from assembling regularly as they would wish, they availed themselves of every opportunity to enjoy the blessings of sacramental communion. Some of the early sects continued to celebrate it every day; and it is quite certain from ecclesiastical history that it was not omitted on the first day of the week for at least three centuries after Christ, so that Chrysostom calls the Lord’s day, dies panis, the Day of Bread.
As the church through her superstitions relapsed into coldness, the necessity of frequent communion was less insisted on. Whereas, first, the Christian professor was censured for omitting the communion on any one Lord’s day, he was then required to commune once at least in three weeks, then once a month, then four or three times a year, then once a year. Yet, notwithstanding such latitude to the people, the church of Rome, as the Eastern church, celebrates the sacrament, however improperly, every Lord’s day for such as are willing to receive it. It is remarkable also that Calvin, among other censurers of the church of Rome, and of those partly, though not entirely, out from under its influence, reprobates the infrequency of communion as a “most certain invention3 of the devil,” and says that “at least every week the table of the Lord should be spread for assembled Christians.”
Whether or not our church is wholly right in celebrating the communion only four times a year (it was at first six times, that is, every other month4), may not be without question. The plea for such infrequency, however, is, that more frequent communions have a tendency to render the sacrament less duly regarded, and degenerates into formality. In days of persecution and martyrdom, Christians were more lively, and had a stronger appetite for the holy bread and wine; whereas now it is necessary to stir up their minds to the duty by special appeals and preparation, which could not be done so thoroughly if it were more often administered. This only acknowledges the remissness of the church, instead of justifying her present practice; and we must believe that if the church were more awake to the great benefits of the Lord’s supper, we should recur to the primitive usage.
It is not my part, however, to condemn the practice which our church chooses to maintain, though I am bound in treating of the sacrament to give the facts. I may not venture to say more, but I have not dared to say less.
It may, however, be added that, though the Scriptures distinctly prescribe the manner of the celebration, they nowhere prescribe the times or the frequency of it; and, therefore, latitude is allowed to the judgment of the church and the conscience of the individual Christian. Still, as the declaration is, that “as often as we eat of this bread and drink of this cup we do show the Lord’s death till he come,” the latitude allowed cannot be great to the Christian who desires to grow in grace and the knowledge of his Lord.
Some Christians, though comparatively few, have deemed it necessary to imitate the first communion so closely as to insist upon its celebration in the evening, that it may be actually a supper; and it would appear that the breaking of bread spoken of in Acts xx. 7 was in the evening, for Paul preached “until midnight.” In the days of persecution, also, it would be the safest time to engage in religious exercises. But it savors of too great rigidness to contend that the sacrament should not be administered at the time of day most convenient for the assembly of the people; and, no doubt, there was, and might be again, much licentious evil suspected of, and even occasioned by such late meetings. The apostolical injunction, “Let all things be done decently and in order,” sufficiently justifies our present practice, which others may vary from, if they choose, as is their right. It should be observed, however, that the Greek term rendered supper (δεῖπνον) may be used for any meal, even the first of the day, though perhaps more frequently signifying the principal meal, which was in the afternoon.
Some churches, Protestant as well as Papist, allow the administration of the eucharist to sick and dying persons. Our church has not taken any formal order on the subject, but the general, though not universal, sentiment among us is against it, because very liable to superstitious and rash abuse. The sacrament, by its very name of communion, is a public ordinance intended for the whole church, and not for the edification of the individual believer except in union with the assembled church, nor can it be partaken of privately without diminution of its purpose. It were better, therefore, to avoid the danger; and in this opinion a conscientious Christian would coincide, even at the loss of some personal comfort.
1 We know from Acts ii. 44, 45, that, during the great Pentecostal blessings, the early Christians held all their means for the relief of their poorer brethren “as every man had need.” It would be, therefore, natural and likely that they would bring offerings for the poor when they came to the Lord’s table, which offerings might be in kind, as bread and wine, or in money. Certainly, from the earliest times, gifts to the poor were accompaniments of the sacrament; and the custom in our churches of making a collection for the poor of the Lord’s house at the communion table has thus come down to us from the Pentecost, and should never be omitted. It is part of the eucharistical, or thanksgiving, service.
2 See Bingham, Ecc. Ant. Vol. V. p. 196, et seq.
3 Certissimum inventum diaboli. Instit. Lib. iv. 17, 60.
4 Vectii Disputa, Vol. IV. p. 761.