Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture XXXVI. The Lord’s Supper. Second Lecture

Twenty-eighth and Twenty-ninth Lord’s Days

Thirdly: The purpose of the sacrament of the supper.

The solemn and affecting circumstances of its institution by our blessed Lord, the peculiar stress laid upon its observance by the apostolical command, the great prominence it has, and has always had, in the religious services of the church, the comfort derived from partaking of it by believers of all ages, and the regard in which it is universally held as the most awful ceremony and august spectacle Christianity offers to the contemplation of both Christians and the world, all teach us the high importance of rightly understanding its design and purport, to both of which, as comprehended by one word, our thoughts must now be directed.

From the several considerations we have already had on the subject, we learn that, while the sacrament of the supper is an ordinance by which God in salvation addresses us, it is also an ordinance in the completion of which we are to take an active part. Hence, the purpose of the sacrament is to be looked for in two directions: first, as to what God intends by this sacrament to do for us; and, secondly, as to what he, by this sacrament, requires us to do for ourselves and for him.

  1. What God purposes by this sacrament to do for his people. (75th Question and Answer.)

a. To put us and keep us in remembrance of Christ’s love towards us, especially as it is manifested by his death on the cross for our redemption.

When our blessed Lord, at the institution of the supper, uttered the gracious, mandatory words, “This do in remembrance of me” (Luke xxii. 19), it was in close connection with his other declarations, “This is my body which is given [broken the apostle has it] for you,” and, “This cup is the new testament in my blood, which is shed for you.” So the apostle: “As often as ye eat this bread and drink this cup, ye do show the Lord’s death till he come.” It is essential to our Christian faith that we recognize the doctrines of Christ’s person, as the only-begotten Son of God incarnate, as our brother-man, and, also, that we consider that the vicarious work of Christ, through the merits of which we are saved, covered his whole life on earth; yet our redemption was not accomplished until he actually died on the cross. The shedding of his blood, the going out of his precious life there, was the act which gave value and consecration and acceptance to all that he had done and suffered before. That, as the writer of the Epistle to the Hebrews tells us, was “the blood of the covenant wherewith he was sanctified” (x. 29), and by virtue of which satisfying the law in room of our death, he rose from the dead (xiii. 20). Hence, “the death of Christ,” “the blood of Christ,” “the cross of Christ,” each is used in Scripture as synonymous with the whole work of Christ on earth for our salvation; and, therefore, as our church says in her form for this sacrament, “we see that” our Lord “directs our faith and trust to his perfect sacrifice, once offered on the cross, as to the only ground and foundation of our salvation.” The whole action and administration of the sacrament, the exhibition of the elements, the breaking of the bread and the extension of the wine, prove the same thing. Whatever other thoughts, edifying and comforting and hortatory to a Christian life, we may have in our minds, the main thought, and that which gives validity and meaning to all, is a faithful remembrance of Christ’s death on the cross; and the sacrament is perverted and abused from its purpose when the death of Christ on the cross is not made the special theme of our meditations and object of our faith. Not to use the sacrament for this its ordained end, is a crime against its authority, which cannot be too heavily censured.

Our blessed Lord, mercifully mindful of our infirmities, our temptations within and without, our liableness to err, especially in self-righteousness and the pride of a carnal ingenuity, which substitute other grounds for our salvation, appointed this sacrament to remind us continually of his death on the cross as our only hope. However at other times we may forget his love and gracious authority in the cares or pleasures of the world and the flesh, the sacrament, which exhibits Christ’s devoted love by lifting him up on his cross, as it were, before our very eyes, rebukes our ingratitude, and generously persuades us to live only for him. However at other times we may have listened to the voice of the tempter, teaching any other way of salvation, in whole or in part, than the expiation of Christ’s blood, the sacrament, by its simple and direct preaching, brings us back, humbled and thankful, to the foot of the cross. However we may have suffered from the sophisms of a base expediency, the doctrines of the cross to be for a time ignored and thrust on one side to give place to some man-invented scheme for carrying on the work of the Lord in the conquest of the evil that is in the world, the sacrament, by making the gospel of Christ’s death “the wisdom of God,” and “the power of God” “unto salvation,” rebukes our miserable policy as sin against the very essence of Christianity, and refutes it as folly in the light of God’s omniscience. In a word, the sacrament, rightly administered and received, is a full though brief compend of all the religion which Christianity teaches and enjoins; the most eloquent enunciation which God has given of what we are to believe and trust in and do, as his servants and children, through Christ; and the most clear, palpable refutation of all error in doctrine and practice, which the subtlety of the devil and the pride of human reason have endeavored to foist upon the gospel of God, and the church of his anointed.

To this end, the peculiar action, or, if I may be allowed the expression, the scenic arrangement of the sacrament, were devised by the holy, merciful wisdom of God. The divine Creator, in none of his dealings with the church, overlooks the fact of man’s double nature, corporeal as well as spiritual. The very incarnation of our Lord has a reference to this; and our adoption into the family of God, as human sinners saved by grace, is not complete until we shall at the last day be received, body and soul, into the kingdom on high, where Jesus, the incarnate Son of God, has for us entered, as the assurance that his people shall all be received there and be made like to him,—not only their minds and hearts like him in holy wisdom and love, but their bodies also transfigured into a likeness of his most glorious body. There we shall see him, hear him, sing to him, serve him, not only as we now perceive him by spiritual apprehension, but really with the senses and faculties of our bodies; yes, as really as the disciples, enjoying his presence on earth, heard his articulate voice, saw and looked upon his mortal person, and handled his palpable form; though with incomparably greater recognition of his gracious, adorable beauty and majesty and love, as he sits upon the throne of his Father, equal with God, beaming forth a brother’s sympathy with our joy in him, even as when, in our sorrows, he revealed his sympathy with our needs.

The weakness of our minds, and the disorder of our bodies, in consequence of sin, expose us to much temptation from our lower nature, so that Paul complained of his incorporated state as a bondage and captivity, crying out in his distress: “O wretched man that I am! who shall deliver me from the body of this death?” But, on the other hand, our corporeal faculties are of great use to us here in exciting, assisting, and obeying the Christian purposes of our souls. God, therefore, even while stripping from the simple truth the various visible, or, as the apostle calls them, “carnal ordinances” of the Levitical ritual, did not overlook the relation of the soul to the bodily senses, but ordained the visible sacraments, in each of which the spiritual thought is represented by a lively figure: in baptism, the cleansing of Christ’s blood by the application of water; in the Lord’s supper, the death of Christ in broken bread and poured-out wine; and his doctrine, the spiritual food of the Christian, by the eating of the bread and the drinking of the wine.

As was said before (twenty-fifth Lord’s Day), these palpable ordinances are very simple and few, to prevent our being led into formality and superstition; but, at the same time, they are most eloquently expressed. Thus, the celebration of the Lord’s supper in a right manner and in a right spirit, that is, when we “discern the Lord’s body” as represented by the elements, has always been found to be a great strengthener of our faith and incitement of our zeal. It brings us into the very presence of Christ, around his table, and among his brethren, to receive the grace he has promised to bestow. We behold him crucified before our eyes, and know that we derive our life and the joy of life from the offering of his body and the shedding of his blood. We feel that we are one with him and one with each member of “his church, which is his body, the fulness of him that filleth all in all”; and, looking forward to the blessed day when he, who was crucified and rose from the dead, shall come again to receive his people where he is in glory, we anticipate the blessed, consummate joy of sitting down with the church of all ages at the marriage supper of the Lamb in the upper sanctuary, amidst the holy perfections of the eternal Sabbath. Any attempt to add anything to the simplicity of the rite as Christ ordained it, is not only to impair its validity, and dishonor the wisdom of its institutor, but also to degrade and pervert it. If we are not edified by the rite as our Lord ordained it, no invention of man can improve it for us.

b. Again; it was the wise purpose of Christ to establish on earth a visible church which should be the outward form of his spiritual church. As he exhibited his power, his wisdom, his holy virtue, and compassionate grace before the world in his mortal life, so it is his will that his people should openly follow his blessed example, declaring his truth as their trust, and vindicating the divine energy of his saving grace by their Christ-like lives. For this end it was necessary that those who profess his religion should be visibly separated from the world, and, by appropriate, significant, public services, declare the doctrines and obligations of their faith. Hence baptism, or the washing away of sin, is the entrance of the sinner to the church; and the participation of the Lord’s supper, by the assembled church, is their avowal of themselves as his family, and their exhibition to the world of the gospel of the cross as the only hope of their salvation, and the only nutriment of their spiritual life. It is a frequent repetition, and with greater fulness, of the confession they made in baptism before the church and the world. Hence the use of the Lord’s supper is not for the communicant’s own personal benefit only, though that is largely found in the service, but for the benefit of the church, in the assurance of his fellowship with all her members, and for the benefit of the world, in his testimony from experience of the grace of Christ and the truth of the gospel. God, therefore, by the sacrament means to give us the great advantage of Christian fellowship, the honor of being witnesses for him before the world, the dignity and reward of being fellow-workers with Christ in the accomplishment of his merciful dominion over the whole earth.

c. God purposes, by this sacrament, to remind us of his gracious willingness to maintain and support our Christian life by the power of the Holy Ghost through the truths therein signified. As the disciple says in the Catechism: “He feeds and nourishes my soul to everlasting life with his crucified body and shed blood, as assuredly as I receive from the hands of the minister, and taste with my mouth, the bread and cup of the Lord as certain signs of the body and blood of Christ.”

So in the 19th Question and Answer: “Christ speaks thus [i. e. calls the bread his body and the cup his blood] not without great reason, namely . . . . to teach us, that, as bread and wine support this temporal life, so his crucified body and shed blood are the true meat and drink whereby our souls are fed to eternal life.”

Our blessed Lord, after his miracle of feeding the multitude with five barley loaves and two small fishes, as a parable of his power and willingness to meet the wants of all those who trust in him, was followed by many people anxious to share the benefits, not of his teaching, but of his temporal bounty; to whom he said: “Labor not for the meat which perisheth, but for that meat which endureth unto everlasting life, which the Son of man shall give unto you.” A little afterwards he says: “I am the bread of life; he that cometh unto me shall never hunger, and he that believeth on me shall never thirst.” From this it is plain that he speaks of his truth, or his doctrine, as the true bread of the Christian life, which endureth forever; and, also, that the manner of partaking of that spiritual food is by going unto him and believing on him, for personal faith in Christ is the only way by which we can receive sanctifying grace unto our souls. He is, however, yet more particular, for he again adds: “I am the living [spiritual or eternal] bread, which came down from heaven; if any man eat of this bread, he shall live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world.” The Jews were astonished at this, and, supposing that his language was to be taken literally, asked wonderingly, “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?” To which he answered (as he did to Nicodemus when he asked, “How can a man be born when he is old? Can he enter the second time into his mother’s womb and be born?”) by repeating the assertion more strongly: “Verily, verily, I say unto you, except ye eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, ye have no life in you. Whoso eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, hath eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day. For my flesh is meat indeed, and my blood is drink indeed. He that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me, and I in him. As the living Father hath sent me, and I live by the Father, so he that eateth me shall live by me.” The disciples themselves secretly murmured at this, and said, “This is a hard saying; who can hear [or receive] it?” To which the Master replied: “Doth this offend you? What and if ye shall see the Son of man ascend up where he was before? It is the Spirit that quickeneth; the flesh profiteth nothing; the words that I speak unto you, they are spirit and they are life.” From all which it is evident, that it is especially the doctrine of his passion and death for us which is the food and drink of the Christian soul, assuring him of his oneness with Christ and of the resurrection of his body at the last day to enjoy the life and immortality which are brought to light by the gospel; and, also, that this benefit is confirmed unto us by no carnal participation of mere material elements signifying Christ’s body and blood, for “the flesh profiteth nothing,” and “it is the Spirit that quickeneth”; but that “the words,” or the truths which he speaks concerning his incarnation and death for us, when received into our souls by an intelligent, appropriating faith, become our true meat and drink of life eternal.

The parallel between these passages in the sixth chapter of John and those giving the institution of the supper, is so obvious that we believe none deny it; and, if so, our Lord’s commentary on his own words in the one case serves equally well for the other. Our church, from this, rightly infers, that the sacrament signifies, by the elements and our participation of them, our spiritual nourishment, or the religious life of our souls received by faith in the spiritual doctrines, which are thereby set forth and illustrated. We, therefore, deny and reject the abominable heresy of the Papists, who insist that our Lord’s words must be taken literally and that the bread actually becomes the body of our Lord and the wine his blood; for, says the Catechism (78th Question and Answer): “As the water in baptism is not changed into the blood of Christ, neither is the washing away of sin itself, being only the sign and confirmation thereof appointed of God; so the bread in the Lord’s supper is not changed into the very body of Christ, though, agreeably to the nature and properties of sacraments, it is called the body of Christ Jesus.” Even if the abhorrent idea were true and the bread and wine were so changed, our eating and drinking of them could not, our Lord being witness, profit us anything. “The flesh profiteth nothing,” he himself says in reference to his own assertion of the bread and the wine being his body and blood; “the words that I speak unto you, they are spirit and they are life”; which is equivalent to what he said before: “I am the bread of life; he that cometh unto me shall never hunger; and he that believeth on me shall never thirst.”

But on this point we shall be required to dwell with greater particularity, when we come to consider what our church teaches in the 80th Question and Answer of the Catechism.

Now let us learn of God by this sacrament, that not only at the beginning of our Christian life we are brought into his kingdom by faith in the blood of Christ for the remission of our sins (which is shown in baptism), but that we continually need the grace of the Holy Ghost through the truth to maintain in our hearts the principles, and in our lives the practice, of the holy religion which we profess. As the Israelites were fed in the wilderness by manna from heaven, and drank the water from the rock, and only in the strength they derived from that bread and water they were able to continue their pilgrimage to the promised land, so the Christian draws all his ability to follow Christ, “walking as he also walked,” to heaven, from the doctrines of Christ’s incarnation and death.

So, also, is this sacrament often repeated to remind us at once of our continual need and his continual willingness to supply our wants. We are to go in the strength of one Lord’s supper unto another, and so “from strength unto strength,” until we “appear before God in Zion,” the heavenly Jerusalem. This is the meaning of the apostle when he says, “Ye do show the Lord’s death till he come;” for until he comes and takes them unto himself in glory, his followers will need the nourishment of soul, which can be drawn only from faith in his body broken and his blood shed for us, the warrant and assurance of our eternal redemption.

Nor is it only while we are at the Lord’s table that such blessing is extended and received. We are to keep the feast “in remembrance of him.” The celebration is to prevent our forgetting him, to quicken our thoughts of him, and so to pervade our minds at all times with those blessed doctrines in whose strength we go forward. It were strange perversion of the sacrament to allow ourselves in the ungodly thought, that, because we are to remember Christ’s death in the celebration, we may cease to remember it during the intervals of its occurrence. No, believers, the Christian should be conscious of a continual crucifixion of Christ, a continual feeding on his precious body and blood, a continual strength derived by faith from his gracious work and promises. We should “desire to know nothing else save Jesus Christ and him crucified.”

d. There is another doctrine which God in the Lord’s supper proposes for the confirmation of our trust in him: The incorporation of the believer with the body of Christ.

This the Catechism asserts and explains in the 76th Question and Answer: where we learn that “to eat the crucified body and drink the shed blood of Christ” is . . . “to become more and more united to his sacred body by the Holy Ghost,” who dwells both in Christ and in us; so that we, though Christ is in heaven and we on earth, are, notwithstanding, “flesh of his flesh and bone of his bone”; and that “we live and are governed forever by one Spirit, as members of the same body are by one soul.” Again, in the 79th Question and Answer: “Christ speaks thus, [i. e. calls the bread his body and the cup his blood,] . . . more especially by these visible signs and pledges, to assure us that we are as really partakers of his true body and blood (by the operation of the Holy Ghost) as we receive by the mouths of our bodies these holy signs in remembrance of him, and that all his sufferings and obedience are as certainly ours as if we had in our own persons suffered and made satisfaction for our sins to God.”

When our blessed Lord assumed our human nature, he condescended to represent in his sacred person all true believers, even his church which he redeemed by his most precious blood. As the great sacrifice of atonement, under the Levitical law, was substituted for the people, whose sins were laid on its head, so, bearing our sins in his own body on the tree, he represented us in the expiation. The typical victim perished wholly, because it could not take away sin; but our Redeemer rose again from the dead, because his death was a complete satisfaction of the law for his people, and his mediatorial person, with its entire humanity, body and soul, entered heaven, as our forerunner, and sat down at the right hand of God. In the Lord’s supper we show forth his death, and the elements symbolize to us his crucified body and shed blood. But we “show the Lord’s death till he come.” While, therefore, we remember a crucified Saviour, we declare our trust in a living Saviour, who rose from the grave to complete our redemption by his intercession, authority, and grace; as the apostle says: “If, when we were enemies, we were reconciled to God by the death of his Son, much more, being reconciled, we shall be saved by his life.” The representation of his people is as true and perfect in his resurrection and glory as it was in his death and shame. The sacrament shows him to us in both aspects, that is to say, in his sacrifice for our sins, and in his glory as our head.

The feast of the Paschal Lamb commemorated the complete deliverance of Israel from Egypt, therefore all Israel were permitted and enjoined to partake of the flesh, which was forbidden to them in the case of the sacrifices of imperfect expiation. They were commanded to eat of the Paschal Lamb, because they shared in the salvation it commemorated; they were forbidden to eat of the other victims, because their sins were yet in the flesh of them. The true passover having been sacrificed for us, no victim of blood could afterward be offered, so our Lord substituted bread as the emblem of his body; and as we live by his doctrine, through the grace of our reigning Intercessor, so the bread, which broken represents his expiation for us on the cross, also, as the emblem of nourishment, represents our nourishment and strength unto eternal life.

When, therefore, we partake of the sacramental emblems, we make a double profession, of union to him in his death, and union to him in his glorified life. Our church, in her communion service, declares this: “For by his death he hath taken away the cause of our eternal death and misery, namely, sin, and obtained for us the quickening Spirit, that we, by the same (which dwelleth in Christ as in the head, and in us as his members), might have true communion with him, and be made partakers of life eternal, righteousness, and glory.” This intimate union with Christ is described by very strong language in the New Testament Scriptures. Every believer is a member of Christ’s body, and the aggregate church is the body of Christ, he being its divine head. “Now,” says the apostle, “ye are the body of Christ and members in particular”; and again, he is “head over all things to his church, which is his body, the fulness of him that filleth all in all.” We become thus united to him by faith; and every one who believes in him, that is, accepts and relies upon his mediatorial suretyship, is a member of “his body, of his flesh, and of his bones.”

Our eating and drinking of the sacramental emblems strikingly and naturally illustrate this participation of Christ’s body and union with it. We receive (as the Catechism says) with the mouths of our bodies these holy signs. They are thus incorporated with us; Christ (symbolically) enters into us, and makes us one with him: one with him in his sufferings; one with him in the glory which has followed the sufferings. We partake of his true body and blood, not in a gross or carnal sense, for it is by the operation of the Holy Ghost, and, therefore, spiritually through faith; yet we are by the sacrament assured that we were actually represented by his true personal body on the cross, and are now represented by his glorified body in heaven. As he, by his vicarious expiation, took away the cause of death, which was sin, and we through him receive pardon, so he, having been accepted for us by the Father, derives from the Father life for his people, even the grace of the Holy Ghost, and we live by that life which is in him as our head. So the apostle Paul: “I through the law am dead to the law that I might live unto God. I am crucified with Christ, nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me; and the life I now live in the flesh I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.” Thus each believer becoming a member of Christ, the whole church is his body, animated in all its members by the same life which is in him, the divine head, even the Holy Ghost which is the Spirit of Christ. We are, therefore, made certain that Christ’s love and care of his church, and of each particular member of it, is constant, close, and personal. He loves his church as his own body; its safety and its glory is identical with his own. So the apostle: “No man ever yet hated his own flesh, but nourisheth and cherisheth it even as our Lord the church, for we are members of his body, of his flesh, and of his bones.” The gracious wisdom of God could go no farther in asserting the full salvation of all who, by a true faith, are united unto Christ.

It follows immediately from this, that, being united to Christ, we are, by the same act of faith, united to his true church, which is his body, and to each of all the members of his church. We have one life, one hope, one strength, one nourishment, with them. Their interest is our interest, their growth our growth; our interest their interest, our growth their growth. So our Church, in her communion service: “We by the same spirit may also be united as members of one body in true brotherly love, as the holy apostle saith: ‘For we being many are one bread and one body; for we are all partakers of that one bread.’ For as out of many grains one meal is ground and one bread baked, and out of many berries, being pressed together, one wine floweth and mixeth itself together, so shall we all, who by a true faith are engrafted into Christ, be altogether [all together] one body, through brotherly love, for Christ’s sake, our beloved Saviour, who hath so exceedingly loved us; and not only show this in word, but in very deed towards one another.” So again the apostle: “Holding the Head, from which all the body by joints and bands having nourishment ministered, and knit together, increaseth with the increase of God” (Coloss. ii. 19); and in the parallel passage of the twin epistle: “Speaking the truth in love, [we may] grow up into him in all things, which is the head, even Christ: from whom the whole body fitly joined together and compacted by that which every joint supplieth, according to the effectual working in the measure of every part, maketh increase of the body unto the edifying of itself in love” (Ephes. iv. 15, 16).