Lecture XXXIII. Baptism. No. II. The Mode
Twenty-sixth and Twenty-seventh Lord’s Days
Having, in our former discourse, shown, First: The authority for Christian baptism; and, Secondly: Its design; it now remains for us to consider, Thirdly: The mode of its administration; and, Fourthly: The subjects to whom it should be administered.
Thirdly: The mode in which Christian baptism should be administered.
We use the term mode here in a large sense, comprising by it everything connected with the administration of the sacrament, not treated under the other heads, as: I. The administrator. II. The circumstances. III. The formula. IV. The element to be used. V. The manner of applying it. In this order, as in our main arrangement, convenience is aimed at rather than a precise succession of thought.
I. The administrator, or the person who should officiate in conferring baptism.
The sacrament, being a sign and seal of divine grace, should be received as from the hand of God, represented by the officiating person. It is proper, therefore, that so solemn an act as affixing a seal in the name of God should be performed by no unaccredited agent; and as the ordinance is intended to confirm the word of God, a belief of which is the qualification for rightly receiving baptism, we easily infer that those who are officially authorized to preach the word are the proper persons to administer the confirming sacrament. So we find the command to baptize joined by the Saviour with the command to preach the gospel, in the great commission. The same persons are directed to do both. The holy apostles were, and their successors in the office of preaching the gospel are, styled by the Holy Ghost “ambassadors for Christ,” as though God spake by them (2 Cor. v. 20). They, therefore, have the delegated prerogative of confirming the truth which they are sent to proclaim. Hence, we have no recorded instance of any others administering baptism but authorized preachers of the gospel.
We have seen, also, that baptism is the open sign of admission into the church visible, and, therefore, the reception of the new member should be the act of one who by his office represents the church, viz: its bishop, i. e., according to the language of Scripture, the presiding presbyter.
The question has been much vexed, both before and after the Reformation, whether baptism administered in a case of necessity by a layman, though acknowledged to be irregular, should not be regarded as so far valid that a repetition of the rite would be improper. The extreme—very just reluctance felt by a large majority of Christians to dishonor a sacrament, and the erroneous supposition of many that baptism is necessary to the assurance of salvation—has led the greater part to decide that lay-baptism should not be rejected. Our Reformed church teaches the contrary, both in her confession of faith (Article xxx.) and in her form for ordaining ministers of the word, where the office of administering the sacraments is especially ascribed to them. Such was the opinion of the famous Ursinus, the author of our Catechism, as it is of the Westminster confession, and of nearly all the evangelical denominations.
The personal immorality or insincerity of the officiator does not affect the validity of the ordinance, if he be regularly officiating at the time, for the act is official, not personal; nor does the otherwise heretical character of a church impair their baptism, if it be administered according to the apostolical usage, and with an orthodox belief respecting the divine nature and unity of the three ever-blessed persons named in conferring the sacred seal.
II. The circumstances.
Baptism being the sacrament of admission into the visible church, it is meet that it should be administered openly before the assembled church; that the church may own and the baptized person declare the covenant between them and him. Hence, when the persons interested are not prevented by sickness or other causes (not a false shame, which is unbecoming pride) from attending in the proper place of public worship, the rite should be performed there and at the time of public worship. But if it be performed more privately, there should at least be more than one Christian person present to constitute a church; and the officiating minister should, if possible, have a ruling elder with him for the same purpose, although, being himself both bishop and presbyter, he may, in extreme cases, act alone.
Every care should be taken that the ordinance be administered with all the reverence due in so solemn a service, and attempts to make it an occasion of worldly festivity or show discouraged and forbidden.
III. The formula, or form of words, to be pronounced in administering the baptism, should be that prescribed by our Lord to the apostles, without omission, addition, or alteration. It were profane presumption to attempt any improvement upon Christ’s prescription. But this does not forbid proper explanations, vows or prayers before, or thanksgiving with exhortations afterward, provided nothing be introduced that mars the solemnity of the ordinance or its primitive simplicity. The Reformed churches here explicitly reject signing the subject with the sign of the cross, because it has no apostolical authority; because the practice is derived from a superstitious communion, who attribute an unscriptural and idolatrous virtue to the use of that sign; and because, on the unauthorized pretence of increasing the impressiveness of the ceremony, it distracts attention and reliance from the simple baptism with water, as appointed by our Lord.
IV. The element to be used.
That this is pure water, has already been sufficiently shown from Scripture; and so all the Protestant churches use water alone; but the Papists most profanely and indecorously add oil and spittle and salt, which the Reformed churches protest against as an unseemly and idolatrous practice.
V. The manner of applying the water.
On this subject, you are aware, there has been much controversy, and therefore we are required to be explicit. Water may be applied to a person in three ways: by sprinkling, by pouring it upon him, or by plunging him in it. Our church states it to be “the dipping in or sprinkling with water”; yet, while it is admitted that baptism by dipping in is valid, the practice of the church is to baptize by sprinkling, as equally valid, and for many reasons far preferable. No candidate for the ordinance is forbidden to be baptized by immersion, or being dipped; but our ministers generally, if not universally, would decline administering the ordinance in that manner, lest they should encourage an undue scrupulousness on a point which they consider unimportant and contrary to our well-considered, established usage. Nothing need be said of pouring, or effusion, as the principle is contained in the application by sprinkling. Yet, while thus charitable in allowing those who prefer immersion, or dipping, to follow their own method, we are not met with equal consideration, as a large and highly respectable body of Christians deny the validity of any baptism but immersion.
We justify the practice of our church by several arguments: 1. The meaning of the original words which are rendered “baptize,” or “baptism,” by the translators of our Bible. 2. The sufficiency of sprinkling to signify the thing intended. 3. The greater convenience, and, therefore, expediency of sprinkling.
- The meaning of the original words which are rendered “baptize” and “baptism.”
If these words necessarily, and only, mean immersion, the question should be yielded by us at once. But such is not their necessary and only meaning. The primitive, or radical sense, we admit, is immersion; but, like many other words in all languages, they came, by a common use of speech, to have other significations as well as that which was the radical, and among them washing, or the use of water for the purpose of cleansing. Thus the evangelist Mark (vii. 1–4) tells us that the Pharisees were scandalized at our Lord’s disciples because they did not, according to the tradition of the elders, wash their hands before eating, i. e. cleanse them with water. If, however, it be argued that the verb here means immersion, because they would naturally plunge their hands into water, how shall we apply the term throughout the fourth verse? “And many other things there be, which they have received to hold, as the washing of cups and pots, brazen vessels, and of tables.” Cups may be dipped; so may pots and brazen vessels, if of a small size; but tables, or, more correctly, the couches on which the guests reclined around the table, were altogether too large to be dipped or plunged into water, and it would be difficult to imagine how they could have been cleansed in any other way than by the application of water to them. Besides, the washing there spoken of is clearly not an ordinary washing, such as takes place in every cleanly household, but a ceremonial custom to cleanse from ritual defilement the articles used; and we have seen already that such ceremonial cleansing might be effected, as it was in most cases, by mere sprinkling.
This interpretation is fully confirmed by the Epistle to the Hebrews (ix. 10–14), where the ceremonial cleanness is said to have “stood only in meats and drinks and divers washings, and carnal ordinances.” Now, it is notorious that the larger part of those ceremonial “washings,” or baptisms, consisted of sprinklings, or effusions of water or of blood. The writer is evidently speaking comprehensively of all the lustrations; not the few in which immersion was required, but the many in which sprinkling was sufficient to represent washing; for he goes on to say: “But Christ, being come a high priest of good things to come . . . neither by the blood of goats and calves, but by his own blood, he entered in once into the holy place, having obtained eternal redemption for us.” Certainly, here is a continuation of reference to those of the “divers washings” with blood, which accompanied the entrance of the Levitical high priest to the Holy of Holies, all of which were performed by sprinkling; and the argument goes on: “For if the blood of bulls and of goats, and the ashes of an heifer sprinkling the unclean, sanctifieth to the purifying of the flesh; how much more shall the blood of Christ, who, through the eternal Spirit, offered himself without spot unto God, purge your conscience from dead works to serve the living God.” Now, here we see that not only the term “baptism” includes the “sprinkling” under the law, but that baptism and sprinkling are used interchangeably, particularly when cleansing by the blood of Christ (which is signified in Christian baptism) is spoken of.1 If sprinklings under the Old Testament are called baptisms, why may not sprinkling be considered baptism under the New? This is all we contend for, and the passage cited proves it fully. We may, however, add a proof or two more. John the Baptist, or baptizer, says: “I, indeed, baptize you with water, but one mightier than I cometh . . . he shall baptize you with the Holy Ghost and with fire.” Now, if the word baptize be rendered immerse in the former part of the verse, the latter clause should read, “He shall immerse you in the Holy Ghost and in fire,” which is not according to fact. Christ, as the head of his church, was baptized with the Holy Ghost as he came up from being baptized with water by John; but was it by immersion into the Holy Ghost? On the contrary, the Holy Ghost descended in a bodily shape “like a dove (i. e. with a fluttering motion like a dove when alighting), and lighting upon him” (Matt. iii. 16); so when he himself baptized his disciples at the Pentecost, we read that, “There came a sound from heaven as of a rushing mighty wind, and it filled all the house where they were sitting; and there appeared unto them cloven tongues like as of fire, and it (i. e. the appearance like fire) sat upon each of them, and they were all filled with the Holy Ghost, and began to speak with other tongues, as the Spirit gave them utterance” (Acts ii. 2–4). Here we see that, like their Master, they were baptized, not by being immersed into the Holy Ghost and the fire, but by the Holy Ghost being poured out or descending upon them, and in the form of fire resting upon them. This is in accordance with prophetic language, as the apostle Peter quoted it at the time (from Joel ii. 28–32): “It shall come to pass in those days, I will pour out of my Spirit upon all flesh.” The prophet Isaiah also speaks of the primary baptism of Christ as an anointing (lxi. 1), which we know was done by pouring oil upon the head. If immersion were necessary to baptism, the disciples at the Pentecost were not baptized with the Holy Ghost, for the fire only sat upon them. If it be answered, that the Holy Ghost “filled all the house where they were sitting,” we rejoin that it was the sound “as of a rushing mighty wind” that filled the place, not the wind; the visible element of the baptism was the appearance like fire, which did not fill the place, but only rested in forms like cloven tongues of fire. Supernatural fire was, as you know, the sign or emblem of present divinity; and the expression “with the Holy Ghost and with fire” is a Hebraistic duplication or parallelism to express the same thing, while the purifying grace of the Holy Spirit is also brought into view. If, however, the immersionists insist upon it that the Holy Ghost, like a wind or vapor, filled the house, it does not relieve them from their embarrassment, but increases it; for to imitate exactly (as they say we should) the mode of this baptism, it were necessary, not simply to immerse the subject, but to pour water upon him until he is completely covered with the element, which I have never heard of their doing.
That baptism (the word) is not necessarily synonymous with immersion, is clear from 1 Cor. x. 1. “Moreover, brethren,” the apostle there says, “. . . all our fathers were under the cloud, and all passed through the sea; and were all baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea.” As to the cloud,—doubtless the cloud of the divine presence,—all we read in the account of Moses is, that it removed from before the camp of Israel, and stood behind it, between them and the Egyptians (Ex. xiv. 19, 20). In so doing we may suppose it to have passed over the host of Israel. In Numbers (x. 34), we are told that it “was upon them by day,” and (xiv. 14) that it stood “over them.” Some think that the cloud sent forth rain; but the conjecture is far-fetched, for it was not a cloud of moisture, being a pillar of fire by night; nor do the texts, quoted to sustain the idea, bear upon the subject. It was, no doubt, like a thick smoke, hanging over them, or before or behind them like a cloud. But will any one pretend that the Israelites were lifted up and plunged into it, which the immersionists say is necessary to baptism? On the contrary, even if it enveloped them, must it not have descended upon them, which we, in our baptism, make the water do? As “to the sea,” we are expressly told that they went through it dry-shod, wet, at the utmost, merely by a sprinkling of spray from the rolled-back floods. If being wholly under water is necessary to baptism, the Egyptians only were baptized; the Israelites were not. Surely, no immersionist would consider it baptism to pass through a dry reservoir, or the dry bed of a stream which once had been full of water.
Much stress has been laid by immersionists on that passage of the apostle Peter, where he says, referring to the ark of Noah, “wherein few, that is, eight souls, were saved by water: The like figure whereunto, even baptism, doth also now save us; (not the putting away of the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience toward God,) by the resurrection of Jesus Christ” (1 Pet. iii. 20, 21). The inference is, however, wholly on our side. How did the water save Noah and his family? By literally covering them all over? Certainly not; but by bearing up the ark in which they were, so that the waters did not touch them, except perchance in the descending rain or the dashing spray. The sinners of the old world were so immersed or covered with water, and were drowned in consequence. The truth is, the apostle does not speak of the mode at all, but only of the grace signified by baptism.
This last remark is equally applicable to those passages which speak of Christians as having “put on Christ” by baptism (Gal. iii. 27); being “buried with him by baptism into death” (Rom. vi. 4), and rising with him again (Col. ii. 12). There is more poetry (and not good poetry either) than logic in running a fanciful parallel between going under the water, to come out of it in a moment, and the burial of Christ in a rock, until his resurrection on the third day. Dramatically, death on a cross is but remotely represented by death under water. The scriptural doctrine is, that the believer by faith is united to Christ as his representative, and, therefore, is “crucified with Christ,” “risen with Christ,” “glorified with Christ.” The reception of baptism declares his faith, and seals him with the outward sign of Christ’s people, no matter in what manner the sacramental emblem be applied.
For the same reason we regard as of little importance the precise mode in which baptism was administered by John or the early ministers of Christ, whether by immersion or sprinkling. A mode may have been convenient for them, which is very awkward, and sometimes dangerous, for us. It is enough that we use water sufficiently as a sign. Yet we are far from admitting that baptism was then, at least, always administered by immersion. It is notorious that the Greek prepositions rendered “into” and “out of” (the water) may also be rendered to and from. Yet, even were they confined to the former meaning, it does not prove that the subject was immersed; as, had they been baptized by sprinkling, it would have been more convenient both for the administrator and the subject to gather up their loose garments from their lower limbs, and putting off their sandals,—the only covering they wore on their feet,—step a little way into the water, especially when, as was the case with the Jordan, the banks were steep. This is the way in which baptism is represented by some old pictures, and certainly must have been more pleasant in that warm climate than is a plunge through the ice, on a winter’s day, in ours. As to the duty of following our Lord into the water, it is a mere play upon words; for we do not follow our Lord in John’s baptism, but in his baptism by the Holy Ghost, which he received after coming up from the water.
Yet, should we grant that John baptized only by immersion, it does not follow that all the Christian baptisms spoken of were administered in the same way.
At the Pentecost three thousand persons were baptized in one day, and that between the third and ninth hours (Acts ii. 15; iii. 1). Can it be believed that so many were plunged under water within six hours, even were the Twelve assisted by the Seventy, of which we have no account? We are told that John baptized “in Ænon near to Salim, because there was much water there” (John iii. 23). Much water was necessary, say our immersionists, because he baptized by plunging; but had he only sprinkled them, a little water would have sufficed for never so great a multitude. But was there much water in Jerusalem? It was tolerably well supplied for ordinary purposes from cisterns and a few pools; but is it probable that the new sect would have been permitted to defile all the water in the city by dipping in it such a multitude? or that the multitude, both men and women, were prepared (as our friends on the other side always take care to be) with dry garments and even water-proof boots, for the officiating minister, and convenient places to change their garments after their plunge? Baptism by sprinkling could have been administered with decent solemnity, but what indecent confusion must have resulted from dipping so many. Is it not strange that we have no account of the place or places where the rite was administered, if the precise mode were so important?
Similar difficulties belong to other instances, as we are not told, on any of the several occasions, where the new converts were or could have been plunged. In the case of the Ethiopian eunuch, we know that the only water along his route through the desert of Gaza was the little stream now called Wel-Hary, which, though it may have been swollen during the rainy season, must have been, at the time he crossed, too shallow to allow the immersion of a man, to say nothing of the minor, but really awkward, difficulty attending the saturation of his clothes, unless he was dipped naked, a fashion followed by none in these days (Acts viii.). The jailer and his family were baptized in the prison after midnight, and could hardly have been immersed, unless we allow our Baptist friends to put a tank within the walls of a heathen jail, as they do in their convenient churches, for the purpose of baptism. As to their having gone to the river Strymon to baptize them, the distance from the city renders the supposition absurd (Acts xvi. 33). Is it not strange, we ask again, that the immersionist has not been supplied by the Scripture on a point he deems so momentous?
What means Peter’s question, when about to baptize the household and friends of Cornelius: “Can any man forbid water that these should not be baptized?” (Acts x. 47.) Is he not asking that water should be brought in for the purpose? Would not an immersionist have said: “Can any man forbid that we should go to the water and baptize them?”
But enough of this. The thing is too puerile for the gravity of a Christian pulpit; and the discussion can be tolerated only because some good people have been strangely led into troubles of conscience on the subject.
- The sufficiency of sprinkling to signify the thing intended.
For this we have the highest authority in Scripture. Baptism will, I trust, be acknowledged a symbolical washing or cleansing. Such symbolical cleansing was always, under the Old Testament, ordered to be performed by sprinkling. I do not quote, because the citations would be innumerable. There is not a single instance of any person being required to be immersed throughout the whole of the older Scriptures, except Naaman, who was neither a Jew nor a proselyte. The priests, before entering upon the special solemnities of the temple, were ordered to wash themselves thoroughly; but that was for personal cleanliness rather than a symbolical purification, else they would have been baptized often in a year. All the ceremonial cleansings were performed in our way. Great stress is laid by some upon the Jewish mode of baptizing proselytes, which was by immersion; but we deny that they had any divine authority for it. The Rabbins cite for the purpose Jacob’s direction to his proselyted household: “Put away the strange gods that are among you, and be clean, and change your garments” (Gen. xxxv. 2); and that of Moses to the Israelites, that they should “wash their clothes” (Ex. xix. 10); but neither of these orders the immersion of their bodies. A third text they quote is one where the people were sprinkled (Ex. xxiv. 8), and that with blood. Shall we allow a tradition of pharisaical elders to bind the free church of God?
The Psalmist says: “Purge me with hyssop, and I shall be clean; wash me, and I shall be whiter than snow” (li. 7). Here, according to Hebrew parallelism, the idea of the first clause is repeated in the second; and he asserts that if purged with hyssop he would be thoroughly cleansed. But how was purification by hyssop performed? It was used in applying the blood of the paschal lamb to the lintels of the door-post. “Ye shall take a bunch of hyssop, and dip it in the blood that is in the basin, and strike the lintel and the two side-posts with the blood . . .” (Ex. xii. 22); in the purification of a restored leper (Lev. xiv. 6, 7), and of a house that had had the plague (51); in the preparing of the water of separation (Num. xix. 6–21); and in each of these cases, that is to say, whenever hyssop was used, sprinkling was the method of application; so that a thorough cleansing was symbolized to the Psalmist’s mind by sprinkling. In the Epistle to the Hebrews (ix. 18–22) we read that Moses “took the blood of calves, and of goats, with water, and scarlet wool, and hyssop, and sprinkled both the book and all the people, saying, This is the blood of the testament (or covenant) which God hath enjoined unto you.” If sprinkling were sufficient to signify the application of the blood of the Old Testament, is it not enough to signify that of the New? And, again, referring to the ceremonies of the high priest on the day of intercession, the writer of the same epistle says: “Let us draw near with a true heart, in full assurance of faith, having our hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience, and our bodies washed (not dipped, mark you) with pure water” (x. 22). The washing here is certainly baptism, argues the immersionist. Grant that it be so; then to baptize means to wash. But, in fact, there is a parallelism here between the purification of the sinner’s conscience and the sanctification of the outward person, by which we should understand, according to a New Testament idiom, the conduct of our lives (Rom. xii. 1; 1 Cor. vi. 20). If sprinkling be sufficient to signify the thorough purifying of the conscience, it is enough to signify the washing of the body. So, again, we read (Heb. xii. 24) that we are come “to Jesus, the mediator of the new covenant, and to the blood of sprinkling, which speaketh better things than that of Abel”; and the apostle Peter (1 Pet. 1, 2) speaks of the saints as elect, unto “the sprinkling of the blood of Jesus Christ.”
This is in accordance with the language of prophecy: “Then will I sprinkle clean water upon you, and ye shall be clean (If God says that we may be made clean by sprinkling, does it not savor of impiety to deny it?) from all your filthiness, and from all your idols, will I cleanse you (i. e. by sprinkling clean water upon them); a new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you; and I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh” (Ezek. xxxvi. 25, 26). Here is everything signified in baptism represented by sprinkling. Are we too bold in claiming the text as a literal prophecy of Christian baptism administered after the proper mode? The prophet Isaiah (lii. 15) also says of the Messiah: “So shall he sprinkle many nations,” alluding to the blessings of salvation, as represented in baptism; and it is remarkable that the Ethiopian probably read this text just before he was baptized, as he asked Philip to explain the seventh verse after it. In another place, the same prophet says in the name of the Lord: “I will pour water upon him that is thirsty, and floods upon the dry ground” (xliv. 3); that is, he will rain down his blessings as from a full, over-hanging cloud. Thus, you see, whenever the blessings of salvation are spoken of in the Old or New Testament, whether typically, prophetically, or figuratively, they are said to be conferred by the symbolical act of sprinkling, or, in a few places, pouring. We may challenge the immersionists to bring an instance of its being represented by plunging, except, perchance, the somewhat doubtful reference of the pool of Bethesda. The figure of a “fountain opened,” employed by Zechariah (xiii. 1), does not necessarily imply plunging, as one may wash at a fountain without going in it all over. According to the unanimous language of the sacred writers, sprinkling is not only significant, but by far the most significant mode of representing in baptism the blessings of salvation; nor is it consistent with Christian simplicity to force upon the church a form derived from the unauthorized traditions of the Jewish elders, the only source to which we can trace baptism by dipping. We are too charitable to deny that baptism by immersion is valid, inasmuch as water is used for the symbol; but we insist upon being permitted to follow “a more excellent way.”
- The greater convenience, and, therefore, expediency of sprinkling.
The greater convenience of our mode is so obvious, that I need not argue on it. Indeed, our Baptist brethren do not hesitate to consider immersion a cross, and reproach us for not being willing to bear it. But we believe that we are called unto liberty, and that the cross of the Christian life lies in the self-denying practice of Christian virtues,—not in bodily exercises, which profit nothing, while they are apt to puff up with pride.
Therefore we practise, as most expedient and most consonant with the merciful character of the gospel, that method which is least trying to the health and modesty of administrator and subject, which may be practised at all times and in all countries, and with the most decency and ease, and which, above all, is the very method which a crowd of Scriptures recommend.
1 The same may be said of the other two instances in verse 19, and verses 24, 25, of same chapter.