Expository Lectures on the Heidelberg Catechism (1864), George W. Bethune · PDF

Lecture XLV. On the Origin and History of Idolatry

Thirty-fifth Lord’s Day

The religious worship of any object other than the Infinite Supreme is so contrary to pure reason, and the prevalence of the monstrous error, where an immediate or a written revelation has not shed its divine light, so nearly universal, that the origin and history of idolatry should excite a grave curiosity in the mind of every thoughtful Christian. The evident proneness of our race to the deadly sin, and the deep moral degradation by which it is infallibly accompanied and followed, render the inquiry one of the utmost practical importance. There is the more need of thoroughly investigating the subject, from the fact, too little known, that the specious but deadly sophistries of infidel speculators, especially those of the French School during the last century, have been suffered to pervade the treatises of Christian students, and thence the opinions of Christians generally. We must refute and utterly repudiate their falsities before we can take the first step in the right direction; nor will the refutation be difficult if we meet them at their starting-point, and compare their imaginary data with the statements of Scripture, and the corroboration of those statements by reason and history.

The grand falsity of these philosophers, and the basis on which they have built all their scheme, is the assumption that barbarism and ignorance was the original state of man; and that, by the force of natural reason acting on the inconveniences and growing necessities of such a state, they have evolved the cultivation of the soil, the laws of property, general virtue, the combinations of government, in a word, the whole social system; nay, ignorant in a great degree of natural causes, and stimulated by a desire of happiness, which the least experience taught them was beyond their ability to secure, they sought the aid and deprecated the wrath of a higher power, and so constructed a religion in the worship, first, of perceptible forces, as, light, wind, the flow of waters, vegetation,—then, of imaginary beings, invisible but ever active, controlling those forces. These they represented to the eye by various forms, principally an exaggeration of the human, grotesque, or beautiful, according to their taste, clothing them with appropriate attributes and symbols. When knowledge increased, and cultivated reflection showed them the need of a yet higher authority to which men should feel themselves responsible, they attained the ideas of a Supreme Being and a future state of reward and punishment. The more atheistical of the anti-scriptural theorists ridicule all such efforts after religion as slavishly superstitious, and denounce religion itself as an imposture of priests and tyrants combining to hold the vulgar in subjection by visionary terrors; hence the atheism of revolutionary France; but those who are not willing to deny God a place in the universe, contend that all religion has been a legitimate, gradual discovery by the human soul seeking after truth, as the poet expresses it:—

“Through nature up to nature’s God.”

This scheme, as you see, finds man living apart in a wilderness, scarcely raised above the wild brutes, subsisting by the chase or fishing, and on vegetables of spontaneous growth,—then, as families increased, and these resources became inadequate, contriving the arts of life and the morals requisite for communities, of which religion is the highest. Two facts are thus admitted, which we note, because useful to our future argument and fatal to that of our opponents: first, that man had a beginning; secondly, that he has a natural tendency towards religion, as necessary to the development of his better condition. The human savage could not have sprung into being uncaused, and with filial instinct must have sought his author.

The scheme is, however, contradicted by all history and the traditions of our race. We have no accredited instance of a people elevating themselves out of barbarism to civilization without foreign aid. Some plausible attempts have been made to adduce instances of the kind, as the ancient Mexicans and the Greeks, the civilization of both of whom have been claimed to be indigenous; but, putting aside other facts which our time will not allow us to cite, the great fact cannot be questioned, that there was civilization in the world antecedent to their rise. The source from which the Mexican sprang, and their early condition, are too deeply obscure to permit any theory of their growth, though the character of their monuments strongly savors of an eastern transoceanic kindred. But with regard to European, or, indeed, the whole of the old-world civilization, we can—unless we ignore the universal voice of classical antiquity, backed by proof in the names of places, rivers, mountains, and cities, fixing unalterably the main truth of their traditions—trace the transfer of grafts of civilization from the farthest east to the ultimate north. Greece avowed her derivation of culture from Asia and Egypt. The very names about the Athenian Acropolis perpetuate those of the Egyptian immigrants who introduced laws and arts among her aboriginal Pelasgi. From the beginning of her annals, down to the northern invasion, her people, philosophers as well as the illiterate, regarded the eastern lands much as we Americans regard Europe. Their religious system and ceremonies were to a great extent the same as the Egyptian. The most trusted oracle of all was that of Jupiter Ammon in the Libyan desert, and he was clearly the Osiris of Egypt and probably the Ham of the Ethiopians; while the Egyptians themselves frankly owned that they had derived their system, religious and philosophical, from a far more remote period. We all know the influence of Greece over Italy, and of Italy over northern Europe; nay, that maritime part of Italy about the modern Naples and eastward to the sites of Crotona and Lybaris, are full of evidences that Egyptian influences were there long before those of Greece. Similar, though not so distinct, traces of Phœnician emigration may be found in more northern Europe as in Southern France and in Ireland, or, if we credit acute ethnologists, in various other regions. From Europe civilization has come here to the western continent, and is now rolling back the tide over the decayed nations from which it originally flowed. All this, and in many ways we have no time to particularize, points backward and backward until we reach the acknowledged seat of the first human philosophy in Chaldea, close to the region which Scripture makes the second cradle of the race, where the great temple of Babel, or Baal, or Bel, or Belus, was built, and whence was the dispersion of the nations. We find the notion of man’s original barbarism nowhere in antiquity, but always the reverse,—a chief proof of which was the general traditionary belief in a golden age when man was fresh from the creating power, of which Hesiod, as old as Homer, or, as many think, older, gives a glowing description, accompanied with many other asserted facts corroboratory of our position. Allow us but the one fact, that man had a beginning, and his origin must be attributed to a creator,—then it is impossible to believe that the intelligent cause who gave him such a wonderful being, physically, intellectually, and morally, would have introduced his creature into the world a mere savage and without knowledge of Him “in whom his breath was and in whose hands were all his ways,” or, as the heathen poet, quoted by Paul on Areopagus, says, whose “offspring” he was.

It is remarkable also, and as susceptible of clear proof as it is remarkable, that men, so far from becoming more moral and religious as they descended from antiquity, actually grew worse and worse. This was seen in the history of their philosophy, as well as in that of the people; nor were they ever weary—philosophers, poets, historians, and moralists—of praising the ancient manners and regretting their decay. In the same manner we hear them always ascribing their religious habits to the example of the past, never claiming them as inventions of their own. One of the finest passages of Plato, respecting the existence of divine power and the duty of worship, is an indignant burst of astonishment that any could doubt the gods, when they all had been taught the elements of religion on their nurses’ laps and at their mother’s knee, and by the unanimous example of all people, civilized and barbarian, who worship in temples and bow down at the rising and setting of the sun. A clear acknowledgment that such faith was traditionary. Indeed, so universal was this reference to divinity, that all the older, more eminent legislators and teachers claimed the respect of the multitude on account of a divine inspiration. The founders of states boasted a divine lineage. Lycurgus in Greece, as Numa in Rome, asserted themselves to be the mediums of divine instruction. Pythagoras, at once the head of a sect and the founder of a philosophical republic, who drew his mystical doctrines from Egypt, was called by his disciples the Son of God, and assumed miraculous gifts. Plato, on whose infant lips a swarm of bees lovingly clustered, was on similar testimony virgin-born; and even the grave, good Socrates had, as he asserted, his guardian demon. The old poets, who were also the historians and the prophets of early times, readily received the epithet “divine” from their supposed inspiration. It were easy to cite a multitude of like instances, showing that the human mind has never been satisfied with mere human authority, but has always demanded divine testimonies to moral doctrines.

If, as we have shown, the common belief of mankind has been always against the idea that barbarism was man’s original condition, and that his progress has been toward refinement and religion, the books of the Scriptures contradict it even more positively. We see the two brothers near the gate of Eden,—one a tiller of the ground, the other a shepherd. The earliest work recorded of Noah after the deluge was the planting of a vineyard. The circumcised patriarchs, because pilgrims without a country, were migratory herdsmen, while the farthest records show us Egypt eminent for its agricultural wealth, and ruled by shepherd-kings. In vain do we search for a barbarous people in those remote ages. Barbarism was of a later date. Adam, who conversed with God, his Creator, as a child with his father, must have learned from his infinite Teacher the great truths of religion, and cannot be supposed to have forgotten them in his fall, but must have taught them to his multiplying descendants till the close of his long term. Between him and the calling of Abraham, we see that there were needed only three—Methuselah, Noah, and Shem—to hand down the primeval doctrines.

Religion, therefore, was no discovery of reason, no gradual development. True religion was the original faith of men in the divine testimony. This is in accordance with the account given by the apostle Paul in the first chapter of the Romans, where he tells us: “The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness; because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shown it unto them; for the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead: so that they are without excuse: because that when they knew God, they worshipped him not as God, neither were thankful, but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened. Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, and changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man, and to birds, and four-footed beasts, and creeping things. Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness, through the lusts of their own hearts, to dishonor their own bodies between themselves: who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator, who is blessed forever. Amen.” Here the apostle, of his inspired wisdom, declares that the nations had originally a knowledge of the true God; but unwilling to retain a sense of his holy spiritual majesty, yet unable to banish all thought of divinity, they turned their worship to senseless images of man and brutes, and even reptiles; and, therefore, God suffered them to lose his true idea, and in consequence the most deplorable immoralities took the place of that virtue which the worship of a spiritual God enforces. Idolatry was not the attempt of a barbarous mind to seek divinity, but the departure of civilized, instructed mind from God, and barbarism itself the fall of mankind from original civilization.

The theory of the Bible is corroborated by the facts of history.

We mark, however, more particularly that it was the spirituality of the divine nature which offended the corrupted heart of man. A spiritual Creator, infinitely above the passions and appetites of corporeal life, and the pure ruler over the creatures he had made, held them in fear and restraint from the sensualities they desired to enjoy; and, therefore, they exerted their wicked ingenuity to darken their hearts against spiritual holy light. They could not do without religion altogether; the evidences of divine power were too strong, their dependence on power higher than their own, too manifest; the habit, grown almost instinctive, to pray and worship when calamities threatened or successes were doubtful, could not be repressed; and so they set up before their eyes symbolical images which they worshipped, not as they would have said had they been questioned, because they considered those senseless shapes to possess divine attributes, but because they suggested the ideas of God to their mind. It was the same error as that into which the Papist has fallen, who will tell you that he does not worship the crucifix he holds before him, but the Saviour whom the image brings eloquently to his remembrance. We have a striking illustration of this in the Israelites at the foot of Sinai; who, impatient of delay when the glorious sign of the divine presence, which had led them out of Egypt, rested long on the top of the mount, demanded of Aaron that he should make them gods which should go before them; and Aaron copied the Egyptian symbol of productive force, the agricultural ox, or, as our translators render it, a calf. That neither they nor Aaron considered the golden calf to be a conscious god, but only a symbol of divine power, is seen in the fact that Moses proclaimed a feast unto the Lord (Jehovah), the name of Israel’s covenant God.

The purpose of idolatry being to get rid of a spiritual divinity, from which moral attributes, condemning their sensual vices, were inseparable, but to retain the physical power of divinity for their selfish purposes, they set up images symbolical of the forces visible in nature. In other respects than superhuman power, they made their gods animal and subject to animal passions like themselves,—nay, like the brutes. The least acquaintance with heathen mythology proves the truth of Aristotle’s saying, that “such as men wish the gods to be, so they make them.” For the same reason not only did the imputed sensualities of the gods encourage similar impurities among their worshippers, but sensuality of the grossest character became prescribed parts of idolatrous worship; and not a few of their most observed festivals and ceremonies were most abominable imitations and representations of acts on the part of their gods of which, as the apostle Paul says in particular reference to them, it is a shame even to speak. The first chapter of the Epistle to the Romans is a history true to the letter of the Gentile idolatry.

They retained, as we have said, the idea of divine force—the motive power, if I may so speak—in their gods; and this is the key to the philosophy of idolatry; though in more ignorant nations, or where the corruption became most brutal, the traces of it are less distinct. Thus the first object of idolatrous worship was fire, or the great central fire, the sun. They were led first to this, no doubt, by the fact that God himself had made supernatural fire or flame or brightness, “glory,” as it is termed by the sacred writers, the symbol of his presence. But they soon went farther; and as they saw the sun, by his active heat, calling forth the fertility of the earth, they learned to worship productive force in that glorious sign and medium of divine power. The earth, for the reason that she bears the fruit of the sun’s genial influences, received the name of mother; and out of this marriage grew the widely extended worship of productive energy under masculine and feminine symbols, known as the Bacchic or Phallic system, the main elements of which exist to this day in the idolatries of India, and spread themselves from Egypt over the ancient historical world. Of this most popular, because most sensual of all idolatries, it is not becoming for us to say more; but could we detail its nature and its mystic ceremonies as they were practised by the classical nations, as well as many less cultivated, down to as late a period as the sixth century after Christ, all would bear out the statement we have made.

In process of time this productive energy came to be divided among many new inferior gods who were, to the minds of the common people at least, the controllers of various departments in nature and art and intellectual exercise. The sea, the winds, the farm, poetry, wisdom, peace, war, all had their tutelary or peculiar deities, while each mountain, stream, and tree had its guardian nymphs.

The primeval faith had left traces on the traditionary conscience of mankind too deep to be eradicated, and accordingly we find a general acknowledgment that vice provoked the anger, and virtue had the approbation of the powers that rule human destinies. There are passages in the philosophical writings and the tragic poems containing sentiments and truths which approach in purity and sublimity the inspired Scriptures; but the philosopher painfully felt the lack of evidence on which to base a confident trust, and the strain of the highest poetry places retributive justice above the gods themselves, and even ruling them as by eternal fates. Every scholar is familiar with the mysterious destiny which, through all the tragic and heroic poems, is made to pursue with calamitous vengeance, yet as a blind necessity, the perpetrators of greater crimes and their descendants. This does not, however, deny the fact that the aim of idolatry in transferring worship from a spiritual supreme to sensible, material objects, was to deprive divinity of moral attributes. They dreaded divine justice, and when conscious of guilt, sought to avert its wrath by sacrifices and purifications, but they never adored it as a venerable claim on their homage and trust. The prayer of the people never was for purity of heart and strength of virtue; in a word, there was no love of holiness in all their worship, no practical recognition of it in all their religion; and this, we repeat, was the reason why the morals of heathenism were so abominably depraved, their very gods, because of their own vices, becoming so low and contemptible as to be made the butt of satirists and farce-writers. Even while they persecuted to death teachers who, like Socrates, endeavored to restore the moral authority of heaven over the popular theogony, and while the altars of magnificent temples were deluged with the blood of hecatombs, amidst the smoke of the costliest perfumes, the audience in the theatre roared in laughter at the scurrilous jokes of Aristophanes or Plautus, who were never so witty or recklessly bold as when ridiculing the inhabitants of Olympus, from the father of gods and men down to sooty Vulcan.

The object of this discourse will have been gained, if its argument, for obvious reasons more brief than another occasion might allow, has served to show the immense practical importance of our Lord’s divine doctrine: “God is a spirit, and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth.” There is in our natures, even when renewed, but as yet imperfectly sanctified, a constant struggle between the spirit and the flesh, which prompts men to substitute external, visible forms for a spiritual religion. The tendency to such a corruption of worship is not peculiar to heathenism, so called, but has exerted its baneful sway under the name of Christianity, as the rites of the Papists, and those who imitate them, too plainly show; nor is it altogether absent from the straitest sects of Protestantism. It is the vice of our fallen nature against which we have all constantly to struggle, and shows itself in every attempt to have the form of godliness while we deny the power thereof. Religion, to be true, must be a spiritual worship of the infinite Spirit. His authority searching our inmost thoughts, his love ruling our moral affections, alone can control the practice of our lives. Hence a godly life is throughout the Scripture a spiritual life, and is begun, continued, consummated by the Spirit of God dwelling in and bearing witness with our spirits, thereby enabling us by a divine strength to resist and overcome the degrading tendencies of our carnal natures. Hence faith, the main instrument of the Holy Ghost for our sanctification, is a belief of God’s moral truth, discerning things invisible and eternal. Such belief alone can make us closely acquainted with God, purge our souls from the grossness of sensualism, and overcome the world by the infinitely transcendent attractions of eternal fellowship with God. Hence the first commandment of the law demands of us faith in the absolute supremacy of the one only God; the second insists on an equal recognition of his spiritual essence, and forbids all practices springing from a desire to rid ourselves of the moral restraints which his spiritual nature imposes upon all who fear and adore him. It is only in this broad light that we can see the full meaning of the second commandment and its true object in forbidding all idolatry.