Sacred Dissertations on What Is Commonly Called the Apostles’ Creed (1823), Herman Witsius · PDF

Dissertation VIII. On the Creation

I. The work ascribed in the Creed to the Father is that of Creation; on which we now proceed, concisely, to discourse. Let us begin with explaining the word. What the Latins call Creare, the Hebrews express by the term ברא (bara;) which signifies, to produce some new thing, solely, by one’s will and command, or nobly to effect and accomplish something by a surprising energy. Thus Moses says, “If the Lord make a new thing,”1 that is, produce a strange thing by his powerful word, causing the earth to open her mouth: and, likewise, Jeremiah, “The Lord hath created a new thing in the earth,”2 that is, hath commanded a thing to exist, nothing equal, or similar, to which was ever beheld.

II. We are not, however, to imagine, that the word ברא does uniformly, or by its own proper power, denote the production of a creature out of nothing. It is applied to those works which are expressly recorded to have been formed, during the first six days, from pre-existent matter.3 Though men are the offspring of their parents, too, by natural generation, God is denominated the Creator4 of every man; and this not merely with regard to the soul, which, indeed, he creates out of nothing, but with regard to the whole person, which owes its existence to his good pleasure, and is “fearfully and wonderfully made.”5 In like manner, it is said in the Psalms, “The people who shall be created shall praise the Lord;”6 and in Ezekiel, “I will judge thee in the place where thou wast created, in the land of thy nativity.”7

III. Besides, no one doubts, I suppose, that the new heavens and the new earth, for which, according to the promise of the Supreme Being, we look, are to be constructed out of the rubbish and ashes of the world which now exists. Yet God says of them, “Behold, I create new heavens, and a new earth.”8

IV. There is even a passage, where things which exist already, are said to be created, when new vigour is infused into them: “Thou sendest forth thy Spirit, they are created; and thou renewest the face of the earth.”9 From these instances it appears, that the word ברא is sometimes used in relation to things, which are, by no means, made out of nothing, and yet are so far created, that, by the will and command of God, they pass, in a certain respect, from a state of non-existence to a state of existence.10

V. Correspondent to the Hebrew ברא, is the Greek verb κτιζω; whence κτισις, creation,11 is derived; that is, an act which gives existence to a creature. But this word is also of extensive application, and signifies the producing of things in any way; as appears from the definition of Hesychius,12 and from the Apostle Peter’s denominating a magistrate divinely appointed for regulating the affairs of men, “an ordinance (a creature) of man.”13

VI. The Seventy Interpreters, also, have not scrupled to make use of this term in reference to the supreme Wisdom, and as our Divines are accustomed to explain it, in reference to the generation of the Word.14 The Chaldee Paraphrast, likewise, on the same passage, employs the word ברא. Some, too, derive from this Hebrew verb the noun בר, a son; the Latin word parere, (to beget;) and the Dutch word baren.15 But, as these words have now a different signification in the schools of theology, I deem it neither prudent nor safe, whilst the heretics discover so much perverseness, for any Divine to imitate that phrase, when discoursing of the Only-begotten Son of God, by calling him Created,16 in whatever sense the expression be used.

VII. It may be added, that the Latin verb creare, in like manner, does not signify, precisely, what we now usually intend by this term. It may even admit of a doubt whether the ancient Romans ever recognised this signification. With them creare is gignere, (to beget;17) to make in any manner;18 or even to appoint to any dignity, in which sense Consuls, Generals, and Magistrates are said creari, to be created.

VIII. Although it appears, then, that as well in sacred as in common use, the signification of these words is very vague and indeterminate; yet, because that mode of creation by which something is produced out of nothing is the most excellent and wonderful, it is usual in theological discourses, for an act of this sort to be strictly called Creation, and to be distinguished from generation, and other modes of producing.

IX. To pass, therefore, from an examination of the word to the illustration of the subject; Creation is that act of God, in which, by the all-powerful command of his will, he made out of nothing, and perfected, the whole universe, in the space of six days.

X. Before the Creation, nothing at all existed, excepting God:—No world such as this we now behold, which some have falsely supposed to have been co-eternal with God:—No shapeless matter, from which, by means of motion, other substances were formed by some imaginary Mind; according to the expression of Anaxagoras in Laertius, “All things existed in one irregular mass; then Mind came, and reduced them to order:”19—In fine, no spirits distinct from God, as, in opposition to Scripture, the adversaries of the eternal Divinity of Christ contend—But absolutely nothing.

XI. Satisfied with himself, with his own infinite perfections, and with the most ample knowledge, love, and enjoyment of those perfections, God found in himself the most consummate happiness, and happiness becoming his character; for which reason the Apostle Paul calls him, “the Blessed.”20 It pleased him, however, to display his attributes in certain works that are without himself,21 the form and image of which he had most wisely delineated in his mind from eternity. And since he needed no assistance from any, as nothing exists or even can exist independently of him, he commanded all things that are, to rise out of nothing, by the mere act of his sovereign will. “He hath made the earth by his power; he hath established the world by his wisdom; and hath stretched out the heavens by his discretion.”22

XII. While Reason, particularly as now vitiated by sin, and disposed to raise its clamorous voice against God, dictates these truths somewhat obscurely; Faith, relying on the Divine testimony, embraces them without hesitation. “Through faith, we understand that the worlds were framed by the word of God, so that things which are seen were not made of things which do appear.”23

XIII. By the expression τους ἀιωνας, the Apostle means the same thing that the Hebrew Doctors intend by עולמים, to wit, ages, or worlds. He uses the plural number, because they distinguished betwixt three worlds; the lowest, which is the residence of plants, animals, and men; the middle, which is the region of the stars; and the highest, which is the habitation of angels, and blessed spirits.24

XIV. In these worlds, there is a framing,25 a skilful arrangement of the parts, and an adaptation of every thing to purposes suitable to itself, and to the whole system. Whatever attention human reason may give to these matters, it is excited by faith to mark them more carefully, and to perceive them more distinctly. But faith supplies us, also, with further light and instruction, whether you consider the beautiful order and arrangement observed in the work of creation, which we learn only from Moses; or attend to the symmetry that is still discernible in the world, in which our carnal reason, from its arrogance and pretended wisdom, would presume to detect a variety of blemishes, were it not restrained by faith.

XV. This order and symmetry, thus recognised by faith, leads us to God, by whose word, that is, by whose command, the worlds were made; and so made that “the things which are seen,”26 that is, the things which exist,27 were made, μὴ εκ φαινομενων, “not of things which do appear.” This expression is employed, by an anastrophe,28 which was made use of principally by the Hellenists, instead of ἐκ μη φαινομενων, of things which do not appear. The meaning is, as Chrysostome judiciously remarks, “the things which exist were made of things not existing.”29

XVI. The word φαινεσθαι signifies originally, to be brought forth into light; and thence, simply, to exist: as when we read, “It was never so seen,” it never so appeared, “in Israel.”30 The multitude, who uttered these words, by no means intended that similar works had, in reality, been done in Israel, though they had not appeared; but simply, that nothing similar had ever happened. “Things that do appear,”31 are things actually existing, which stand in no need of the Divine call to cause them to be, or to appear. “Things which do not appear,”32 are nothing,—“things not existing,”33 which indispensably require to be called into existence by the power of God, before they can appear. Rom. iv. 17.

XVII. Schlichtingius, an erroneous interpreter, perverting, as usual, the sense of the Apostle, affirms that the things which do not appear, are those elements of things which were in a state of confusion at the beginning of the world. He infers from these words of the Apostle, what, he contends, is apparent also from the history of the creation of the world as recorded by Moses; that God, when he made this world, or when he began the creation described at the beginning of Genesis, did not make it absolutely of nothing, but of that mass which was without form, and covered with darkness. He quotes, too, this expression used by the writer of the book of Wisdom,34 ἐξ ἀμορφου ὕλης, “of matter without form;” which the Latin Translator renders ex materia invisa, “of unseen matter.” He affirms, at the same time, that no mention is made in holy writ of the creation of this matter. Volkelius reasons at great length in the same absurd style,35 and adds this observation; that in the Greek Version of the Old Testament, which the New Testament writers generally follow, the earth is called invisible36 in that passage, where, in the Hebrew, it is denominated void.

XVIII. The design for which these remarks are brought forward, is to make us believe that something besides God existed before the creation of the world, and to weaken the force of that argument in support of the true Deity of Christ, which our Divines are accustomed to derive from his existing before the world;—which, according to the language of Scripture, denotes eternity.

XIX. But the heretics miss their aim; for the Mosaic history expressly declares, that God made that earth which was “without form and void,”37 and covered with thick darkness. The words run thus: “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth. And the earth was without form and void.” The obvious meaning is, that the earth38 which God created was then, when first made, a mass without form and void. It was not, therefore, created out of a shapeless mass. Whence then was it created? What remains but—nothing?

XX. If they urge, that the first verse contains a summary of the whole work, and that, in the subsequent verses, it is particularly shown whence all other things were created; we answer, that, even allowing the first part of this assertion to be true, it was far from the intention of Moses to intimate that what in the first verse he calls “the heaven and the earth,” was formed of that matter which in the second verse he calls the earth “without form and void.” But, after he had comprehended all things under the denomination of the heaven and the earth, saying nothing further with regard to the highest heaven, in which God has prepared his throne, he shows, in the following verses, what was the state of the earth when it first proceeded from the hand of God, and in what manner and order all other things were formed out of it. Vatablus, to whom Volkelius appeals in this cause, expresses himself in the following terms: “You may clearly understand it thus; In the beginning, when God created the heaven and the earth, the earth was then without form, &c. By the heaven he intends the celestial bodies, and by the earth, the terrestrial. He sets forth, at first, the whole universe, that its Author may be known,—that it may be understood, both that the world did not exist from eternity, and also that God created something out of nothing.” Do writers who express themselves in such terms as these, agree with the heretics?

XXI. It is not necessary for us, besides, to admit that the first verse briefly comprehends all those works which are afterwards particularly detailed. The opinion of David Kimchi, in which a great number of Divines both ancient and modern acquiesce, appears to me to be highly probable. He considers the order of the creation as here propounded by Moses in this manner: That, first of all, God created the heaven, that is, the highest heaven with the angels; then the earth, the first appearance and condition of which are described in the second verse, and out of which other creatures were subsequently formed. And it is called “without form and void,” in opposition to heaven, which was immediately carried to its full perfection, and replenished with inhabitants.

XXII. Moses, indeed, mentions that the earth was at first covered with water, and involved in thick darkness; and the Greek Interpreters, failing to express properly the sense of the Hebrew term, have called it “invisible.”39 It cannot, however, be proved from any resemblance betwixt the expressions, which are considerably dissimilar, that the Apostle alluded to this passage. “The things which do not appear,”40 mentioned by Paul, and “the invisible earth,”41 mentioned by the Greek Interpreters, are, in reality, quite different from each other. When Paul speaks of “the things which do not appear,” he refers to the state of things prior to the creation.42 “The invisible earth,” on the contrary, does not signify a mass existing before the creation, but the second part of the universe, which, as well as the heaven, was created on the first day. Those who wrest these expressions to any other meaning, offer manifest violence, not only to the Mosaic history, but also to the whole tenor of Scripture. We have now spoken of the former; let us proceed to the latter.

XXIII. If this pretended matter of which the world was made, existed previously, I ask, was it previously made of nothing by God, or was it really self-existent, and co-eternal with God? The one or the other of these is unavoidable; but both are contrary to holy writ.

XXIV. The matter in question, was not made before the creation of which Moses gives an account: for the Mosaic creation took place “in the beginning;”43 and the beginning of something else prior to this universal beginning cannot be alleged, without contradicting the sacred historian. The Scripture, too, makes the pre-eminence of the Supreme Being above all others, to consist in this, that he existed “before the mountains were brought forth, ere ever the earth and the world were formed;”44 and God himself urges this as a proof of his Deity; “Yea, before the day was, I am he.”45 In short, whatever existed before the beginning, ere ever the earth was,46 existed before all time—according to the phraseology of Scripture, was eternal—was before the works of God—and could not have been made.

XXV. Besides, whoever denies that this matter was made, is not afraid to contradict the four-and-twenty Elders in heaven, who thus address themselves to God in their song of praise: Thou hast created all things.47 Nor does he scruple to contradict the Apostles John and Paul, who teach the same doctrine in John i. 3. Col. i. 16.—passages which, in defiance of truth, are applied by the heretics to the new creation of things by the Gospel. If these declarations of the Elders and Apostles are certain, as unquestionably they are, it is also certain, that this original matter of the world is either a mere figment, and indeed absolutely nothing, or that it was created by God.

XXVI. Further, if this matter both existed from eternity, and existed of itself, and thus was indebted to God for nothing it possessed, what right had God to it? or what title had he, to fashion it according to his pleasure? Basil says, “If it was, in reality, uncreated, it must be esteemed worthy of the same honours with God.”48 Our adversaries, on other occasions, contend that every right of God in relation to the creatures arises either from a favour conferred by him upon them, or from an offence committed on their part against God. According to the hypothesis, the first has no place here; of the last, brute matter is totally incapable.

Add to this, that it can hardly be conceived how the Creator took possession of that which might be considered not only equal, but in some respects superior to God. It was at least a thing of which he stood in need, and which supplied him with materials and facilities for his operations, and thus was greater than God who needed it; while this supposed matter stood in no need of him, or at least received nothing from him. But every one is dependent on him, whose assistance he needs to make use of; and every one, by employing what pertains to another, is inferior to him of whose property he avails himself. As the eloquent Vogelsangius has acutely observed,49 matter must have conferred a truly signal favour upon God, in furnishing him with the means, by which he might, to this day, be known, and acknowledged as Omnipotent. See an excellent discussion of this controversy by Dionysius, in Eusebius;50 and another, in the same historian, by Origen, who refutes at large that exposition which the Socinians have thought proper to adopt.

XXVII. Nor shall the heretics elude the force of this argument, by a counterfeit modesty, whilst they pretend that because sacred writ is silent with regard to the creation of this matter, they also determine nothing. Though they should not presume to determine this point, one of two suppositions is true; the matter in question was either created before the Mosaic beginning, or it was not. There is no room for a third hypothesis. But we have shown the falsehood of both these suppositions.

XXVIII. The passage of Paul, which we are now considering, ought not to be compared with Wisdom xi. 17. but rather with 2 Maccab. vii. 28, where the pious mother animating her son to suffer martyrdom, charges him to look upon the heaven and the earth, and all that is in them, and to consider that God made them of things that were not.51 This has been observed even by Grotius, for whom Schlichtingius, (according to the testimony of Lubieniecius, in his preface prefixed to his Posthumous Commentaries,) entertained the highest esteem, and of whom he was wont to say, “that the Christian world had waited for the appearance of such a man, for more than fifteen centuries from the days of the Apostles.”

XXIX. Volkelius objects that, in this passage of the Maccabees, the author intends a privative nothing, or matter destitute of that form which was to be superinduced: because what is affirmed of all other things, is here asserted concerning man in particular, that he was made of nothing; whereas, while it is certain with regard to several other creatures, it is peculiarly manifest with respect to man, that he was formed of the earth. But this exception has no weight. For, when that pious woman, in conformity with the sentiments of the Catholic Church, says, that all things, and mankind among the rest, were created of nothing, she refers to the first and universal origin of things; which were brought, not from a privative nothing, but from nothing in a negative and absolute sense. Although, when you consider every thing in detail, some are immediately, mediately, and others mediately, from nothing; yet ultimately, all things are made of nothing.

XXX. We might dismiss the expression adduced from the book entitled the Wisdom of Solomon xi. 17,52 with a short answer, by saying, that that author is not authentic either with us, or in the estimation of our adversaries; and that if he had imbibed this error from the dregs of heathen philosophy, it would have been proper to refute him from writers of undoubted credit, not to obtrude him as a sound interpreter of Moses or Paul.

XXXI. Yet I can scarcely bring myself to believe, that he held that opinion which the heretics impute to him. When he says that the almighty hand of God created the world of matter without form, he seems to speak not of the very first commencement of all things, but of the creation of terrestrial things of that matter which in Gen. i. 2, Moses takes notice of as made by God: For, in the ordinary language of men, the earth, with the things which it contains, is commonly called the world, in contradistinction to heaven. That the earth was, in reality, formed out of that shapeless or confused matter, is evident. That God created this matter, too, this writer by no means denies. He affirms, on the contrary, that “all things” were made by his word;53 and, in this very chapter, he intimates, that nothing could exist “which was not called by God.”54 This must be true, also, with regard to the “matter without form,” of whatever sort it is.

XXXII. But, according to the testimony of Jerome, it is affirmed by several ancient writers, that this pretended Solomon was Philo the Jew, who was called Moses Atticissans;55 and were this certain, we could nowhere collect the meaning of this verse, more decisively than from Philo. Now this writer, in his book on the Making of the World,56 expresses sentiments widely different from the hypotheses of the heretics.

XXXIII. Not far from the beginning of the treatise, he has the following words: “But the great Moses was of opinion, that what is uncreated, differs extremely from what is visible; for whatever is sensible, being capable of generation and liable to changes, never continues in the same state. To that which is invisible, therefore, and perceptible only by the mind, he attributes eternity, as allied and congenial to it; whilst he applies generation as a proper term for distinguishing the objects of sense.”

XXXIV. On these words, let it be remarked, 1st, That, conformably to the doctrine of Moses, Philo ascribes eternity, solely, to an invisible nature, which is perceived by none of the senses, but only by the mind, that is, to God. He does not, therefore, ascribe it to any original matter;—which no man, possessing the use of his reason, ever affirmed to be perceptible to the mind only, and not to the senses. 2dly, That he asserts that none of those things which are subject to change or alteration can be uncreated. But shapeless matter is, unquestionably, a substance of this sort. 3dly, To obviate a cavil which some might draw from the word, it may be added, that in Philo, as also in Moses,57 generation signifies the same thing which we commonly express by the term creation.

XXXV. When, therefore, he said a little before, “that in reference to things that exist, it is indispensibly necessary, that there be both an active cause, and something affected by the cause;” he did not intend by “something affected by the cause,” matter that existed before the creation, but matter which was formed by the creating God. This is clear from the words which follow; “There is no connexion between what is not made, and him who did not make it.”

XXXVI. The ancient nation of the Jews were evidently of the same mind. The great Rabbi Eliezer, accordingly, says; “Before the Almighty created the world, he and his name existed alone.” See Manasseh Ben Israel on the Creation;58 who shows that this opinion was received and approved by all the wise men of ancient times. As to the conceits which other Doctors advance about the making of another world before the present one, or the creation of many things before the world, they are cabalistical, mystical, and allegorical. Such also are the expressions of R. Eliezer, when he tells us, that heaven was made of the brightness of God’s garment, and the earth of the snow which is under the throne of his glory. Maimonides affirms, that these assertions are so strange and marvellous, that he does not recollect to have seen the like, in the writings of any of those who observe the Jewish law.59

XXXVII. It is necessary, mean while, to maintain the distinction suggested above. If we consider the first origin of things, all of them were created of nothing. Some, however, were made immediately of nothing, as the first works of the first day, and all spiritual substances: others, mediately, as the works of the subsequent days, which indeed were made of matter; but of matter that in itself was ill adapted to the purpose, that bore no resemblance to the things produced from it, and from which no such creatures could have been produced by any natural energy.

XXXVIII. This production of things was effected by the mere will and command of God, by his all-powerful will,60 as Clement of Alexandria expressed it; or, which is the same thing, by his word, or fiat. “God said, Let there be light, and there was light.”61 “He spake, and it was done; he commanded, and it stood fast.”62 “Thou hast created all things, and for thy pleasure they are, and were created.”63 The creatures existed merely because God willed them to exist, without further effort, without laborious exertion. “The creation of the world,” says the same Clement, “is the effect of his counsel alone:” and Philo agrees with him, saying, “It seems reasonable to think, that in the works which he performs, God exercises not only power and authority, but also wisdom and intelligence.”

XXXIX. It is still more remarkable, that Maximus Tyrius, a rural philosopher, and a stranger to recondite learning, should have taught the same truth in the following eloquent passage: “By the will of Jupiter, the earth, and whatever is nourished by the earth, was established; the sea, and whatever is produced by the sea; the air, and whatever is supported by the air; the heaven, and whatever moves in heaven. All these were created by the will of Jupiter.”64 A little before, too, he had said that all these are the works of him, “whose comprehensive and perfect mind is never divided, but with incredible rapidity, in the twinkling of an eye, accomplishes and perfects whatever it touches.” Truly Christian and pious expressions, had he said Jehovah instead of Jupiter.

XL. Since these statements are just, we utterly detest that bold tenet of the new Philosophy, by which it is maintained, “That, although God had, from the beginning, given no other form to the world than that of a chaos; yet if, after having established the laws of nature, he had assisted its operations by that concurrence which he usually affords, it may be concluded, without any prejudice to the miracle of the creation, that, by this ordinary concurrence alone, all things purely material would, in course of time, have attained the same state of perfection in which we now see them.” The consequence of such notions is, that the masters of the new Philosophy imagine, that by means of natural generation, according to the rules of motion, all natural things could by degrees have been produced out of chaos, established and adjusted, (one of them even says, supposing the ordinary concurrence of God, must have been produced,) in the same manner as they have now been produced, established, and adjusted by a supernatural creation; and, consequently, that there was no necessity for that miraculous work which is called creation.

XLI. These sentiments have a dangerous tendency.65 It ought not to pass without severe reprobation as an instance of arrogant temerity, that poor pitiful man should boast that he has discovered a way, by which, under the conduct of motion alone, all whose laws he, no doubt, has been able to ascertain, those wonderful works, which, as now created by the powerful word of God, command the astonishment of all the choirs of angels in common with the holy prophets, could, and even must have come forth from chaos of their own accord. God spoke, of old, to Job out of the whirlwind, saying, “Gird up now thy loins like a man; for I will demand of thee, and answer thou me. Where wast thou when I laid the foundations of the earth? declare, if thou hast understanding. Who hath laid the measures thereof, if thou knowest? or who hath stretched the line upon it?”66 &c. But these audacious men, according to their hypotheses, would find an answer to return to God; to wit, that, in all those works, there is nothing too wonderful, to have risen spontaneously out of chaos agreeably to their own rules of motion. Without doubt, however, they deserve the same reproof which God administered to Job, “Who is he that darkeneth counsel by words without knowledge?”67

XLII. Whatever may be pretended to the contrary, assertions of this kind are derogatory to the miracle of the creation. The most admirable circumstance in creation is, that, at the mere command of the Deity, all things rose into existence either out of nothing, or out of matter which was altogether inadequate, and bore no proportion to what was to be formed from it. But this wonder is, in a great measure, if not entirely set aside, when it is affirmed that, supposing the ordinary concurrence of God, all things would have come forth out of chaos in the same manner, of their own accord, or as Gregory of Nyssa speaks, “by a spontaneous concourse,”68 provided it had pleased God, who now accelerated the work, to have indulged motion and chaos with a certain period of time. According to this account, what is miraculous in creation, this only excepted, that it surpasses the ordinary production of natural things as to the degree of rapidity with which it is accomplished? The issue to which these notions gradually lead, is to cause the true doctrine of the creation of the world to be at last discarded with ridicule and disgrace. A certain raw disciple of this school, has not been ashamed, to deride that doctrine, in a book in which he makes this newfangled philosophy the interpreter of Scripture.

XLIII. Since it is manifest, then, from what has been said, that Creation is the production of things from nothing, and this by a mere command and volition, the natural consequence is that we must consider it as, indisputably, a work of the Divine omnipotence. Hence God ascribes it to himself alone, and disowns every other cause, whether co-ordinate or instrumental. “Lift up your eyes on high, and behold who hath created these things, that bringeth out their host by number: he calleth them all by names by the greatness of his might, for that he is strong in power; not one faileth.” “Hast thou not known, hast thou not heard, that the everlasting God, the Lord, the Creator of the ends of the earth, fainteth not, neither is weary?”69 “I am the Lord that maketh all things; that stretcheth forth the heavens alone; that spreadeth abroad the earth by myself.”70 Parallel to this is the following expression in Job;—“Who alone spreadeth out the heavens, and treadeth upon the waves of the sea.”71

XLIV. Pressed by testimonies so very clear, Socinus perfidiously objects, “that these passages do not prove that, in creating and forming the world, God made use of the services of none at all, but only of none that did not entirely depend upon himself, and that had not derived from him the power of doing something towards the creation of the world.” This is boldly to contradict the prophets and God himself; for since they expressly declare, that God stretcheth forth the heavens alone, they exclude every other cause of every sort; and since it is added that God spreadeth abroad the earth by Himself, we are taught that this is an immediate act, in which no cause, not even one that is instrumental, and that operates by power derived from another, has any place. The Rabbinical writers say,—“immediately, and without any concatenation of causes.”

XLV. By this work, too, the God of Israel discriminates himself from all the pretended gods of the Gentiles, and vindicates his own majesty in opposition to them. “All the gods of the nations,” says the Psalmist, are “idols; but the Lord made the heavens:”72 and we read in Jeremiah, “Thus shall ye say unto them, The gods that have not made the heavens and the earth, shall perish from the earth, and from under these heavens.”73 Nor is it impertinent to remark, that, whilst Jeremiah composed all his other writings in the Hebrew language, this verse alone is found in the Chaldee dialect; because it was proper that the faithful should be armed against the temptations of the Babylonians, and learn, in due time, what answer they should return to those idolaters, in their own tongue.

XLVI. The following words of Sophocles are not unlike this dictate of Divine revelation: “He who made the heaven and the extensive earth, is one God—truly one.”74 These lines of Pythagoras, or of Orpheus, quoted by Justin,75 bear a still closer resemblance to the language of Scripture.

“Say’st thou, I am a God, I am Divine?
Create a world like this, and call it thine.”76

XLVII. The Apostle also teaches, in Rom. i. 20. that ever since the creation of the world, the invisible things of God are clearly perceived, being understood by the things that are made, and, in particular, his eternal power and godhead. We have elsewhere vindicated this passage from the perverse interpretations of heretics.77 We only remark at present, that the reasoning of the Apostle would have no force, if any other Creator of the world besides the one eternal and omnipotent Deity either existed, or could exist.

XLVIII. Further, that the act of creating is so peculiar to God that no creature can be admitted to any share in it, may be demonstrated in the following manner. Creation is the production of a thing by the mere command of him that creates. If, therefore, we imagine that God communicates this privilege to any creature, that at his (the creature’s) command, a certain other thing may exist, that thing would either exist without any co-operation on the part of God for effecting its existence, either by willing or commanding it to be, and would be wholly indebted for its existence to the fiat of the commanding creature; or it would exist in consequence of God’s willing and commanding its existence, in concert with the creature which is supposed to create. Now, each of these ideas is most dishonouring to God, and involves a manifest contradiction. If the former is asserted, it is alleged that God wills that a creature may exist which does not depend upon himself in its operations, and that, by the mere and absolute command of this creature, something may exist even without his consent; than which, nothing more absurd can be conceived. If the latter is preferred, it is not properly the creature which is supposed to create, that would in reality create; since his command is not sufficient to give existence to the thing: but God would create at the command of that creature, upon whose willing the existence of something, God is supposed to will and command the same thing. This, however, is not only contrary to the hypothesis, but also makes God dependent, in his operations, on the will of a creature. Since these imaginations are extremely derogatory to the dignity of the Supreme Being, we must, of necessity, conclude, that the act and the power of creating are incommunicable to any creature.

XLIX. It is impossible, besides, even to imagine any kind of instrument of creation strictly so called. The reason is, not merely that every instrument requires some matter and subject on which it may operate in a way adapted to its capacity, while creation strictly taken supposes the absence of all pre-existent matter; but, chiefly, because creation is effected by the mere command and will of him who creates; which excludes every other concurring cause, whatever be its nature and kind, agreeably to the expression which we lately quoted from Isaiah: “I spread abroad the earth by myself.”78

L. From the preceding reasonings, it indisputably follows, that the same Godhead which belongs to the Father, belongs also to the Son and the Holy Spirit. Although, for reasons which we have elsewhere assigned, the creation is, in the Creed, attributed to the Father, the sacred writings ascribe it also to the Son and the Holy Ghost. Each of these persons, it is clear, is frequently styled God. But, if, while they are called God, they have not made the heavens and the earth, they must necessarily be numbered among those gods who “shall perish from the earth, and from under these heavens;”79—which it would be blasphemous to allege.

LI. No man of piety will deny, that the world which God has created, is a most extensive theatre erected for the display of the Divine perfections, and that mortal men are unable to ascertain its exact dimensions. “Who hath measured the waters in the hollow of his hand, and meted out heaven with the span, and comprehended the dust of the earth in a measure, and weighed the mountains in scales, and the hills in a balance?”80 “If heaven above can be measured, and the foundations of the earth searched out beneath, I will also cast off all the seed of Israel for all that they have done, saith the Lord.”81 Yet that the world is infinite, or, which is the same thing, that its extent is without bounds, no sober-minded person will affirm. God attributes to himself that power of measuring the waters and the heavens, which he denies to man; but the universe could not be measured even by God himself, unless its quantity had bounds and limits.

LII. The distinction betwixt infinite and indefinite might be admitted on this subject, provided it were ingenuously and properly explained. The world might be allowed to be indefinite with regard to us, as we are incapable of precisely assigning the bounds and measures of the universe; though we know in general, that it hath bounds and limits, and therefore is not infinite.

LIII. But, after you have affirmed, “that our understanding is able to conceive no bounds in the world, and that this is owing not to the weakness of the human mind, but to the positive idea of the world, in which we can imagine no bounds; and that, since this idea of the world has not arisen from our prejudices, and can be traced to no other quarter, it necessarily follows, that God has impressed it upon our minds, and consequently, that it is true, and gives a just representation of the nature of the world:”—After you have even said, “We know that this world, or this universe of corporeal substances, has no limits to its extent:”—After you have deliberately hazarded all these assertions, to subjoin, in order to escape the odium of so extravagant an opinion, “that you would rather call the world indefinite than infinite, that the term infinite may be reserved for God only,”—this is to amuse the reader in a manner contrary to all the laws of candour. If the idea of the world as having no imaginable limits be true, and be divinely impressed on our minds,—if we know that it has no bounds to its extent, why have we recourse to subterfuges? Why do we meanly resort to evasions? Why do we not give every thing its appropriate name? Why not speak as we think, and call that which has no bounds or limits, infinite? Why do we seek a dishonourable and cowardly retreat, in the word indefinite? Let us speak roundly and properly. “Nothing remains but sound, and the graces of language.”82

LIV. “That is infinite,” says Aristotle, “to which, whatever quantity is assigned it, you may always assign something further.”83 Now surely, the authors of the new philosophy give us an account of the world, which, this definition of what is infinite, exactly suits; for they affirm that whatever limits of the world be supposed, they always stretch beyond them, and conceive a further extension. Since, then, they boldly assert the thing, why do they, childishly and in a manner unworthy of men, cavil about the term infinite?

LV. Let us examine the thing itself. And, lest our arguments should be treated with supercilious contempt, because they are ours, let these candid gentlemen be obliging enough to allow us to make use, for a little, in this contest, of weapons with which we are furnished by the celebrated Cocceius, a name neither odious nor inconsiderable in their esteem. This writer reasons in the following manner.84

LVI. “Melissus the Samnian, a disciple of Parmenides, whom Aristotle refutes, affirmed, ‘that the world is infinite.’85 This doctrine is contrary to Scripture. The heaven and the earth are not infinite; for the earth has bounds, and the heaven, whether the aerial, the starry, or the third heaven, according to its position with respect to us, is not infinite, but finite. That to which infinitude is denied, is wholly finite. We indeed are unable to measure the universe, and it surpasses our conception. But God bounds, and ‘meteth out heaven with the span.’86 Extension belongs to all these parts of the universe; but the extension of things which are extended, has both a beginning and an end. If it has not, the same thing will at once have, and not have, a certain number of spaces and parts. It will not have them, because it is infinite; it will have them, because it has parts beyond parts. The human mind does not admit a number actually infinite; for there is no number, to which something may not be added,” &c.

LVII. Let those who contend that the arguments against the existence of a body actually infinite, are mere sophisms, now reply to this reasoning. Or if it seem too obscure, which to men of erudition it ought not to appear, I should be happy to learn what they have to oppose to this single demonstration, which is plain and easy. Every body has a certain quantity. Every thing that has quantity, has parts beyond parts. That which is infinite, cannot have parts beyond parts; and, therefore, it can neither have quantity, nor be a body. That what is infinite cannot have parts beyond parts, is proved thus. Each of the parts supposed, must be either finite or infinite. If they are infinite, each part is equal to the whole; which is contradictory. If they are finite, they cannot make a whole, actually infinite; for finite parts, to whatever extent they may be multiplied, still remain finite. Besides, it is a maxim of unquestionable certainty, that the whole is not greater than all its parts taken together. If, therefore, finite parts, even when all of them are taken together, still continue finite, the whole which results from them, is also necessarily finite.87

LVIII. As the world is finite with regard to Extent, it is also finite with regard to Duration. The Scripture everywhere teaches, that its existence had a beginning. It is said, “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth;”88—which intimates that the beginning of time, by which the duration of all created things is circumscribed, coincided with the creation of the world. We read, too, of “the beginning, ere ever the earth was, (the beginnings of the earth,89) when there were no depths;”90 and our thoughts are elevated to that eternity of God, which preceded “the foundation of the world.”91

LIX. The most shameless sophistry is employed by those followers of Socinus mentioned by Episcopius,92 who infer that the mountains and hills existed from eternity, because Jacob calls them “the everlasting hills.”93 Episcopius justly opposes to them the following passage in the Psalms: “Before the mountains were brought forth, ere ever thou hadst formed the earth and the world, even from everlasting to everlasting thou art God.”94 The Patriarch’s “everlasting hills,” hills of ages,95 are hills that existed from the beginning, and that are coeval with the world; for which reason they are called by Moses “ancient mountains.”96

LX. But, supposing that the creation of the world took place in time, which has now been evinced from Scripture, it is asked, was it not at least possible for the world to have been created from eternity? To this question, Athanasius appears to me to have returned an acute answer in the following words.97 “That although it may have been possible for God to produce works from eternity, yet it was impossible that the works made by him could have existed from eternity, if they really emerged from things that were not, and did not exist before they were made. But how could things which had no existence before they were made, be co-existent with God, who always existed?”

LXI. This demonstration may be thus elucidated. That all the perfections of God belonged to him from eternity, admits of no doubt. From eternity, therefore, he possessed the power to produce all things, whenever he pleased, by the mere act of his will. Yet as to the things to be produced, it is absurd to allege that they could exist from eternity; for that which is from eternity, exists necessarily, existed always actually, and at no time was merely possible. But with regard to that which God voluntarily effected without himself,98 so that, had he pleased, he might not have effected it—it implies a contradiction to say that it never was merely possible, and never only to be done, and consequently that it never was without an actual existence. Since these positions are sufficiently evident, I wish it had not been said by a learned man, “that it is difficult to refute those who hold, that the eternity of the world was possible.” See the ingenious and solid reasonings of Cocceius on this topic.99

LXII. It is disputed among chronologers, how many years have now elapsed since the creation of the world; and the matter still remains undecided. We consider this contest as hopeless, and take no part in it at present. Let it suffice to know in general, that the world has not yet reached the age of six thousand years.100

LXIII. It is somewhat easier to decide the question respecting the season of the year, in which the world was made; for those who refer the beginning of the world to the autumnal equinox, appear to support their opinion by the strongest arguments. 1st, It is certain that the civil year of the Israelites began in autumn, the first month of which is called Tisri,101 the beginning, an old Chaldean word from the root Sarah,102 to begin. See Exod. xxiii. 16. xxxiv. 22, on the use of this civil year. Now, according to Eusebius,103 Alexander Polyhistor informs us, that Abraham, having received this account of the year from Enoch, delivered it to his descendants, and introduced it into Egypt. 2dly, The same idea is confirmed by the Sabbatical years which commenced at the autumnal equinox, according to the command of God.104 For what could be more proper than that the beginning of those years should be the same with the beginning of the world, that there might not remain the space of six months, not pertaining to the Sabbatical years. 3dly, The maturity of every sort of fruit adapted to the use of man, serves also to show, that autumn was more probably the time of the creation, than any other season of the year.

LXIV. Further, though it would have been easy for God to create all things in full perfection, “in a single moment, and by a single act and movement,”105 he was pleased to employ six days in this work; as the Mosaic history, which ought by no means to be debased by rash and unnecessary allegories, expressly states. From this circumstance we learn, that we must not be superficial and hasty in our meditations on the works of God; that each of them ought, on the contrary, to be inquired into with attention and diligence; and that the whole period of our life should be devoted to this exercise, till, with an understanding perfect in vigour, we behold all things in a state of the highest perfection, in a most blessed Sabbath of rest.

LXV. A question has lately begun to be agitated with reference to the progress of the works of God on each of the days; to wit, whether each of the works of a day was perfected in a single moment, or in some period of time? This controversy, however, is not of very great moment; nor do the sentiments held on either side seem, hitherto, to be either supported or overthrown, by cogent arguments from Scripture.

LXVI. As to the importance of this question, I rank it amongst those doubtful points, which may be disputed among the reformed, without any prejudice to faith or charity; provided it be firmly and conscientiously held, that there is a vast difference between the first creation of things, which was accomplished by the command of God, (in a manner quite different from that order which was subsequently to be observed,) and natural generation, which proceeds gradually from suitable matter, according to the rules of motion. As the denial of instantaneous creation is a step by which some proceed to maintain that most absurd hypothesis respecting all things spontaneously rising into existence by mere motion, the ordinary concurrence of God being supposed,—I utterly detest the denial of such creation. In the solution of the question itself, to which we will immediately proceed, an excessive refinement must be carefully avoided.

LXVII. Those who apprehend that the different days were occupied by the different works of these days respectively, make use of this argument chiefly;—that, otherwise, it would have been said that on each of the days God rested the whole day excepting merely the moment alleged, whereas the Scripture only makes mention of God’s resting on the seventh day. But this reason is of no weight. If you understand by resting, ceasing from the production of a certain work till a new work be begun, God, no doubt, rested on each of the days. It is clear from the sacred narrative, that his works did not so rapidly succeed each other as to admit of no interval between them. When the work of each day was finished, God first approved of it, before he proceeded to other works; and mention is made of his uttering several distinct words, or commands, at the production of the different works. A remarkable interval, too, in which it may be truly affirmed that God rested, took place betwixt the creation of other animals and of man, and also betwixt the creation of Adam and Eve. But the rest of the seventh day is quite of a different kind; partly, as it consisted in God’s ceasing from the creation of new species of creatures; partly, as he beheld with complacency the fabric of the universe which he had now completed. Further, as to what is added respecting the single moment assigned to the work of creation on each of the days, it seems intended to excite an odium against the contrary opinion. Since several different works are ascribed to each of the days, no person, I apprehend, understands, that all those works were performed at once in a single moment of the day. This notion is expressly inconsistent with the account of the works of, at least, the first and the sixth day.

LXVIII. Those who hold, on the contrary, that the different works were done in different moments of time, support their opinion, principally, by the following argument. The creation, say they, is said to have been effected by the call and command of God; but God, when he enjoins any thing to appear, cannot be resisted, and at his command, all things must be present without delay. Neither does this argument, however, seem incontrovertible. Although, when God by his all-powerful command orders any thing to be present, it cannot refuse to come at his call; yet it is not necessary that it should appear, that very moment, in all its perfection. It is possible for God, to command it to come forward within some period of time. The Divine command is the cause of the existence of things; but the manner of their existing depends on the pleasure of him who commands them into being. If he command them to appear in a moment, in a moment they will assuredly appear. If he command them to go forward to perfection in some space of time, a space of time will consequently be requisite for this purpose. From the mere command of God, then, respecting the existence of creatures, nothing can be inferred as to the particular manner of their rising into existence. Some things, which are done at his command, are unquestionably accomplished in a continued space of time. For instance, the coming of the animals to Adam in order to receive their names from him as their lord, undoubtedly took place at the command of God, yet not without succession. Nor let it be objected, that the inclination to come was infused into the animals in a moment; for their coming itself, and not merely the inclination, was the effect of the Divine command.

LXIX. My judgment, therefore, is, that this question cannot be decided without making a distinction. Some things were certainly produced out of nothing, as the highest heaven, and the chaos of the earth, angels, and the souls of men. These could not be otherwise created than in a moment. Since no medium can be imagined between existence and non-existence, the transition from nothing to something does not admit of delay or succession.

LXX. Other creatures were formed of pre-existing matter by means of motion. “I apprehend,” said Gregory of Nyssa, “that all those things which appear in the creation, and which were brought into existence by the will of God, were produced by means of motion and rest.”106 We, for our part, are not inclined, at present, to adopt such unrestrained expressions. Some works, however, were certainly accomplished by means of motion; as the drying of the earth, and the collecting of the waters into one place, which the Psalmist celebrates in the following manner: “The waters stood above the mountains. At thy rebuke they fled; at the voice of thy thunder, they hasted away. They go up by the mountains; they go down by the valleys unto the place which thou hast founded for them.”107 This was probably the case, too, with regard to the division of the stars; which, being separated from the original globe of light, and formed into distinct parts, could not, without motion, be fixed in so widely distant regions of the heavens. Now, that motion cannot be performed in what is called a mathematical moment, excluding all succession, is thus demonstrated. The body would, in this case, be in several places at once; it would be, at the same time, in the place from which it departs, the place to which it is going, and the intermediate place. Nay, it would be, and would not be somewhere, at the same time; for it is implied in the very idea of a body being moved, that it ceases to be in the place whence it removes, and is not yet arrived at the place whither it is going.

LXXI. We must hold, nevertheless, that this motion was altogether extraordinary, and extremely rapid. It is by no means to be reduced to the ordinary rules of motion which are now observed; it owed its beginning, its progress, and its whole modification, to a Divine, and a special command.

LXXII. We ought not to imagine, that the production of herbs and trees from the ground, of fishes and reptiles from the waters, and, in fine, of all the animals from the earth, was performed in so rigid and laborious succession, that, the larger parts and the minutest particles being gradually prepared and arranged, the works, at last, with difficulty, attained their perfection, in the course of the day. But, at the command of God, the herbs, the trees loaded with their respective fruits, the fishes, the birds, and the other living creatures, suddenly came forth in full maturity;—each of them in a very short space of time, which, in comparison of the succession of months and years during which they now spring and grow up to perfection, may be regarded as a moment. “In a single instant of time,” says Eustathius, “those things which existed not before, sprung out of the earth, each distinguished by its own properties.”108 The glorious change of our bodies at the last day, exhibiting a kind of image of the first creation, will, in like manner, be effected “in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye.”109

LXXIII. Since, on each of the days, God performed various and highly magnificent works, and some of them posterior to others, (though most of them were accomplished in an exceedingly short time,) yet in such a manner that it is impossible for us to assign the moments of the commencement and termination of the works of each day to their own hours respectively,—Divines justly say, according to Scripture, that six days, not six moments, were employed in the creation of the world. It must not be thought that, like a workman restricted to his task or to his time, God laboured in the work from morning to evening.

LXXIV. There is only One world, this very world, of the creation of which we are now treating, which was made by Christ, into which Christ came, and which comprehends within its circuit all things that were made.110 To imagine a plurality of worlds, existing either at the same time or in succession, is the raving of men who are not afraid of “intruding into those things which they have not seen, vainly puffed up by their own fleshly mind.”111

LXXV. That God could have created more worlds, distinct and separate from this one, had it so pleased him,—it is reasonable for all to believe, who devoutly acknowledge the immeasurable and inexhaustible power of the Deity. As to the objection adduced by some, that this world is the universe,112 besides which nothing can be created without a contradiction, it is a childish cavil. This world is now called the universe, because all things which are created, are, in reality, contained within its compass: were another world created, this would cease to be the universe.

LXXVI. Nor is another reason alleged of greater force, namely, that there would either be something intermediate, or nothing; if there were nothing, they would not be really different worlds; if something, even this would serve to conjoin them. That things betwixt which no body intervenes, are not different, is not true. It is sufficient to make them different, that they do not approach, and are not in contact with each other. Nor is it material whether another body be actually placed, or it be merely possible to place it, between them; neither of the extreme bodies being removed from its own station.

LXXVII. But it excites our surprise, that they who contend that more worlds similar to this universe cannot be made even by the Divine omnipotence, admit without difficulty a plurality of particular worlds, or bodies resembling the earth that we inhabit, in which either men or other living creatures reside. Although, too, according to the modesty which they affect, they allege that on this point nothing must be either rashly affirmed or denied; they cannot restrain themselves from severely censuring those who, merely labouring under prejudices, and in a manner infatuated by self-love, imagine that we men are the sole delight of God, and that our earth is the most pleasant spot of the whole world;—which they suppose cannot be done without despising the other works of God. “We know not, indeed,” they add, “whether there be men or other creatures in the Moon; but if we intend to form any opinion at all, it seems more conformable to truth to affirm, than to deny, that it is inhabited by men.”

LXXVIII. I know not whether the very learned men derive these notions from the Commentaries of Lucian, or from the report of that man of strict honour and veracity, who, not long ago, flying on the wings of a goose, took an accurate survey of those upper regions, which have been hitherto unknown to other mortals that are sustained by the fruits of this earth. I cannot help recollecting on this occasion, what I long ago read on this subject in Lucian; and for the sake of my pupils, I will here repeat the substance of it in a few words. His story is as follows:113 After he himself, with his companions, had been carried through the air by a mighty whirlwind during seven days and an equal number of nights, he arrived in his ship on the eighth day at a certain great country in the midst of the air,—an island, which, having the form of a globe, glittered with a profusion of light. They found it both inhabited and cultivated. But that they might not wander hither and thither, ignorant alike of the men and the places, and not knowing under what part of heaven or into what region of the world they were thrown; it fortunately happened, that certain Horse-vultures,114 that is, men who rode on vultures instead of horses, and who were some of the King’s principal servants, conducted the extraordinary strangers to the palace. The King, having learned from their appearance and dress that they were Grecians, politely informs them that his name is Endymion, and also that the region into which they were conveyed, after having traversed so vast spaces of air, is called by the Greeks ΣΕΛΗΝΗ, (the Latins call it Luna,) the Moon. He told them that he was engaged in an arduous and dreadful war with the King of the Sun, (for that part of the world is no less fully peopled than the Moon,) and added many other stories of the same kind, which it would be improper now to rehearse.

The learned men, however, may choose rather, perhaps, to acknowledge themselves indebted to Kepler, the celebrated astronomer, who relates,115 that he saw through an optical tube, on the spotted face of the Moon, lofty mountains, great valleys, a vast number of deep ditches, also extensive forests, seas, and many other things closely resembling what is found in the earth which we inhabit. He alleges, too, that the Moon is inhabited, and that its inhabitants are short-lived, but of a stupendous size, fifteen times larger than the men of the earth, equal to whales; and that they build towns in situations exposed to the warm beams of the Sun. Lest doubts of the truth of this account should remain, Kepler conjectures that he saw the workmen employed in their labours.

LXXIX. But candidly to speak out what I think; I am fully convinced that it is not without exposing our holy religion to disgrace, that men devoted to the study of Theology thus contend for such notions; and that meteorologies of this sort furnish the profane, and the enemies of the Reformed Church, with copious materials for mockery and ridicule. Allowing that it appears from the observations of Hevelius, that there are in the Moon high and low places, similar to our mountains and valleys, what probable reason, I ask, have we to induce us to conclude, that it contains men, states, and commonwealths? Can even the slightest evidences of their existence be found, either in nature, or in Scripture?

LXXX. Nay, there are not a few passages of Scripture, that are contrary to this lunatic imagination. Moses, by the distinct account which he gives of the counsel of God respecting the creation of man, sufficiently shows, that at that time no living creature similar to him existed in the universe. Why should God be introduced, saying, “Let us make man in our image,” &c. as if he were preparing for the chief of his works, if, perhaps only two days before, he had peopled the Moon, or the Sun, or even the other stars with men? For what purpose is it related, that, having discovered, so to speak, that it would not be good for man to remain alone, he thought at last of forming a companion for him? These transactions indeed are related in terms which allude to human infirmity;116 but the expressions would be utterly void of propriety, and could afford no meaning worthy of God, if several pairs of the human kind had already existed elsewhere.

LXXXI. Add to this, that Isaiah ascribes it in a special manner to the earth, that it was not “created in vain,” but “formed to be inhabited.”117 Paul, too, whilst he affirms that “God hath made of one blood all the nations of men to dwell on all the face of the earth,”118 acknowledges no other race of men that has sprung up elsewhere, and that inhabits the face of the Moon.

LXXXII. Reason, too, gives its suffrage in our favour. If there were men in the Moon or in the other stars, they must either have retained their original integrity, like the good Angels; or fallen into sin, as we have done. But it seems probable that neither of these would have been passed over in total silence in holy writ; especially since so many proper opportunities of mentioning them occur. Whether our sin were to be aggravated, or the unbounded mercy of God towards us extolled, or the extent of that blessed society in which we shall rejoice in heaven, to be shown; it would have been worth while, at least briefly to notice so many myriads of saints from another globe. This argument has the greater weight, as frequent mention is made, on such occasions, of Angels; who are no less the inhabitants of another world than the men supposed, and whose affairs seem not to concern us so much as those of the other race, who are of the same species with ourselves.

LXXXIII. But, if the men inhabiting the Moon, or the Sun, or Mercury, are involved in the same misery of sin with us, it may be affirmed, either that they all remain eternally wretched, or that some of them are, in common with us, redeemed by Christ, or that another way of salvation is discovered to them. But no one of these suppositions is at all probable.

LXXXIV. Not the first: For it may be gathered from Psalm lxxxix. 48. that God would have created all those sons of men in vain, if none of them are to adore his perfections, and celebrate his praise. On this supposition, too, Paul would have had a singularly apt opportunity of inculcating the same thing, in that passage where he makes mention of Christ’s not taking hold of angels, but of the seed of Abraham.119 He would, beyond question, have highly commended the love of Christ towards us, if he had chosen to add, that not merely angels that sinned, but also whole worlds of men of the same nature with us, were passed by, that so amazing an act of kindness and grace, might be done to the men of this earth alone, which is perhaps the least of them all.

LXXXV. The second supposition is equally void of probability. For since Christ has not assumed a human nature of the same blood with those men, he is neither their Brother, nor their Goel.120 Since he has neither lived nor suffered, nor taught in their world; since in fine, he has appeared in it neither in a humble nor in a glorious form, nor is to appear in it at the consummation of all things;121 it is not probable that the salvation which he has obtained for us only by his appearing amongst us, is obtained for them without an advent of Christ to them. I might also mention the preaching of the Gospel, of which the Apostle testifies, that its sound went into all the earth, and its words unto the ends of the world;122 but he has not ventured to assert that it has reached the inhabitants of the Moon or of the other stars. Is it likely, too, that nothing would have been said respecting them, in those passages which describe that glorious judgment which is to be conducted with incredible solemnity at the last day? It will redound greatly to the honour of the Lord Jesus, without doubt, if he is to be the Judge not only of this world, but also of other worlds of mankind, as well as of angels.

LXXXVI. Nor is the third supposition admissible. For neither is there salvation in any other;”123 nor would it become a Most Holy God to admit sinful men to communion with himself, without a satisfaction to his justice. Such a satisfaction, besides, can be made by none but a person who is God-man; which it is unnecessary to consider more fully here, as we have elsewhere proved it at large.124 Indeed new schemes of Divinity widely different from that which our churches maintain, must be framed for the benefit of the men inhabiting the Moon; as has been avowedly done of late, for the sake of his Pre-adamites,125 by him who has been the first to discover their existence.

LXXXVII. Since these things are so, it is truly surprising that men of intelligence and discretion could have allowed themselves, amidst so much light and learning, publicly to affirm in their writings, that they who think that the Moon is inhabited by men, hold a more probable opinion than those who choose rather to believe that it is uninhabited. I should have deemed the puerile rant of these writers quite unworthy of a serious confutation, were it not that it seemed proper to avert from our churches the reproach of so monstrous opinions.126

LXXXVIII. Our plan does not lead us to speak particularly of the different works of each of the days. Let us only take a brief view of the order which God observed in creating. First of all, he made the heaven, the throne of his majesty, with the angels, his attendants, and the witnesses and spectators of his other works; as may be inferred from some expressions in Job.127 He then prepared these lower abodes for the accommodation of the animal life; that we might be taught always to give the first and highest place in our esteem to divine and heavenly objects.

LXXXIX. At one and the same time he began, and finished the heaven of his glory, and replenished it with glorious inhabitants. But to other things, he, in the first instance, gave rude beginnings, and perfected them by degrees; demonstrating his power and goodness, first, in the imperfection and weakness, and, then, in the perfecting of the creature. Of this sort was the producing of the world without light, that light might arise out of darkness: From which, too, we ascend, in delightful meditation, to the procedure of God in forming the new world of grace;128 where also, commencing with slight beginnings, he gradually perfects his design, till, in the blessed day of an eternal Sabbath, he calmly acquiesces, with entire approbation, in the consummated work.

XC. After all his other works, he made man; after man, nothing. This teaches us, that the rest of the creatures were made for man, the highest heaven itself, with its angels, not excepted; but that man was made for God only, to worship and obey him; since nothing was made posterior to man, to which as his superior he might do homage.

XCI. Nor must this observation be omitted, that God rested in none of his works, how magnificent soever, till he had made man; but when man was created, immediately “he rested, and was refreshed.”129 Macarius elegantly says; “Man is a creature of high dignity. Behold the heavens and the earth, the sun and the moon, and consider how great they are. Yet it did not seem good to the Lord to rest in these works, but in man only. Man is, therefore, more exalted than all the other creatures.”130 This instance of the Almighty’s acquiescence in man, intimates that it gives greater delight to God that he has man to hallow and glorify his name, than that he made heaven and earth, and a vast number of creatures, which, though otherwise admirable, are incapable of knowing and enjoying him.

XCII. Thus we are gradually led to the Improvement of this article; which consists chiefly in these three exercises. First, That we attentively meditate on the works of God. Secondly, That by them, as by a ladder, we ascend to God. Thirdly, That we descend to ourselves. The Psalmist has comprised all these in a few words:131 “When I consider thy heavens,” (behold the soul attending to the works of God) “the work of thy fingers; the moon and the stars which thou hast ordained;” (behold the mind ascending to God) “What is man that thou art mindful of him,” &c. Behold man descending to himself.

XCIII. Faith certainly requires, in the first place, that we contemplate and meditate on the works of God.132 It is the characteristic of beasts, or of drunkards, who are worse than beasts, that “they regard not the work of the Lord, neither consider the operation of his hand.”133 Even heathen philosophers often professed that they could experience no sweeter pleasure in life, than the contemplation of the stupendous works of nature; on which you may consult Seneca’s Preface to his Questions on the Works of Nature.134 Yet they were unable to discern in those works what faith causes us to perceive; to wit, the excellencies of God, not merely as an omnipotent Creator, but also as our most gracious Father. It is certain, too, that man was created for this very purpose, that he might be, as Gregory Nazianzen calls him, “the spectator of the visible, the priest of the intelligent, creation.”135

XCIV. Now we ought to perform this duty, 1st, With care and attention. “Lift up your eyes on high, and behold who hath created these things.”136 We should hold a kind of conference with the creatures, and examine each of them respecting their admirable properties. “Ask now the beasts, and they shall teach thee, - - - or speak to the earth, and it shall teach thee.”137 2dly, With admiration. “Marvellous are thy works,” says the Psalmist.138 “O Lord, how manifold are thy works! in wisdom hast thou made them all: the earth is full of thy riches.”139 3dly, With joy and exultation. “Thou, Lord, hast made me glad through thy work; I will triumph in the works of thy hands.”140 This has been the exercise of angels even from the beginning. “When the corner-stone of the earth was laid, the morning stars sang together, and all the sons of God shouted for joy.”141

XCV. Further, we should ascend by the creatures, as by an erect ladder, to God the Creator; who exhibits himself in them, not only to be seen, but also to be felt,142—whose glory the heavens declare,143 and to whom the brute animals of the earth, and the dumb fishes of the sea, bear witness, that they proceeded from his hand.144

XCVI. Nor is a general acknowledgment of this sufficient. But those perfections of God which he has brightly displayed in the work of creation, ought to be particularly observed:—that infinite Power, at whose command all things rose into existence:145—that unbounded Goodness, to which alone the creatures must own themselves entirely indebted for whatever portion of good is in them:146—that unsearchable Wisdom, which has arranged every thing in so beautiful an order, that it appears no less admirable in the least than in the greatest works:147—that amazing Philanthropy, in fine, which he has shown towards man, not only adorning his body by so exact a proportion of all its parts, which has beyond measure astonished Hippocrates and other anatomists; but also suspending in his soul, as in the golden vault of the temple, an image of himself and a representation of his own holiness; and at the same time, granting him dominion over the rest of the creatures.

XCVII. “God,” as Philo eloquently observes, “by endowing man with reason, having admitted him to communion with himself, which is the best of his gifts, by no means withheld other blessings; but prepared for him, as the most nearly related and the most dearly beloved of his creatures, all that the world contains. Having determined that he should be destitute of nothing conducive either to his living, or to his living happily, the Creator made provision for the one, by the rich abundance of comforts that were given him to enjoy; and for the other, by the contemplation of heavenly objects, with which when the mind is affected, it is inspired with an ardent desire of the knowledge of them.”148

XCVIII. We should endeavour also to rise in our meditations, by the way of eminence, as it is called, from the greatness, the beauty, and the excellence of the creatures, to the consideration of the greatness and the beauty of God. I cannot better illustrate this than in the words of the truly Great Basil. “Let us glorify the adorable Author of nature, who has formed all things with consummate wisdom and skill. From the beauty of the things that are seen, let us learn his transcendant beauty; and from the magnitude of these sensible and limited bodies, let us infer the infinite and immeasurable extent of his greatness and power, which no created understanding is able to comprehend.”149 Hence it follows, that it is our duty to esteem the Creator above the creatures; by no means to acquiesce in the creatures themselves, whose goodness is finite and circumscribed, and which are, consequently, incapable of imparting full satisfaction to the mind; and not even to rejoice in the creatures, except in so far as we observe the excellencies of their Maker manifested in them, that thus our delight may be placed, not so much in the creatures, as in and through them, in God the Creator.150

XCIX. In fine, we ought continually to honour the glorious Artificer of the universe with our praises and thanksgivings. The sweet Psalmist of Israel, unable to satisfy himself with so ample and so choice a collection of hymns for this purpose, solicits the assistance of all creatures in the discharge of this duty.151 The exhortation of Epictetus152 to celebrate the praises of God as the Creator, is truly admirable; and I should have added it here, were it not that I recollect I have given it elsewhere.153

C. But we should also descend to ourselves. 1st, That we may learn to fear and venerate the great Creator. “Fear ye not me, saith the Lord? Will ye not tremble at my presence, who have placed the sand for the bound of the sea?”154 All creatures are in his hand, to employ them either for us, or against us, according to his sovereign pleasure; and it is in him alone, too, that we ourselves live, move, and have our being.155

CI. 2dly, That we may render the worship and service due to Him, whom every kind of animals both in the earth and in the sea obey. When we behold all creatures hearkening to his word according to the laws of nature,156 truly we ought to be ashamed and blush, if we who are enriched and distinguished above the rest by so many benefits, and who alone, in common with angels, are privileged with reason, are found rebellious against him, without whom we can do nothing; and against whom, in consequence, it is highly criminal for us to form one hostile purpose or thought. Hence God frequently makes use of the irrational creatures, to reprove and put to shame the rational.157

CII. 3dly, That whilst we sincerely discharge these duties of piety, we may comfort ourselves, in various ways, in God our Creator. 1. If that God, who is the omnipotent Creator, be our God, he will certainly provide for us all that is necessary to our welfare. “The earth is the Lord’s, and the fulness thereof; the world, and they that dwell therein.”158 Since “he giveth to the beast his food, and to the young ravens which cry,”159 how much less will he suffer men who so far excel other creatures, and who call upon him as their Father, to lack what is necessary?160

CIII. A memorable instance of this care of Providence occurred to me to-day, when reading the Monody of Gregory Nazianzen upon Basil the Great.161 He relates, that when Maximian’s violent persecution was raging with its utmost fury, the ancestors of Basil escaped with a few servants to a certain cave in a mountain. Continuing there upwards of seven years, and dwelling in the open air, they lived on bread alone; nor did they, like the Israelites in the wilderness, utter any complaint on that account. God, who fed the Jews in the desert with manna and with quails, supplied them with provisions which they neither prepared nor expected—deer in good condition, which came of their own accord, no man pursuing them; and of which they killed what were immediately necessary, and dismissed the rest, reserving them as in a storehouse, ready to appear when required for future use. “The young lions do lack, and suffer hunger; but they that seek the Lord shall not want any good thing.”162

CIV. 2. If the Almighty Creator be our God, nothing is so wonderful but he is able and willing to effect it on our behalf. Jeremiah, accordingly, reasons thus: “Ah! Lord God, behold thou hast made the heaven and the earth by thy great power and stretched out arm, and there is nothing too hard for thee;”163 or, as our Dutch translators have well rendered the expression, “there is nothing too wonderful for thee,164—nothing which thou canst not easily perform in favour of thy people. He will govern all the creatures, too, in such a manner that none of them can hurt his people,165 but all of them, on the contrary, shall serve to promote their salvation.166

CV. 3. To conclude, how great is this felicity of the saints, that it is given them to inherit not merely the creatures,167 but also the Creator himself! “The Former of all things is the portion of Jacob;”168 and our “Maker is our Husband;”169 in whom we are not only allowed to repose our confidence through the whole course of our lives,170 but to whom, also, in our dying moments, we may “commit our souls as to a faithful Creator.”171

Notes

Note XLVI. Page 183.

Our Author’s interpretation of the expression in Heb. xi. 3, rendered worlds, is clearly just, and coincides exactly with the remarks which other men of erudition have made on the term. Michaelis, for example, referring both to Heb. i. 2, and ch. xi. 3, has the following observations upon it. “Ὁι ἀιωνες is constantly used by the Greek writers as a word expressive of time, or as denoting a succession of ages. But in the present instance, the context requires for it a different sense, namely, that of worlds. Now the Jews used their עולם in both senses; for though it literally denotes sæculum, (an age,) yet they frequently applied it in the sense of mundus, (the world.) For instance, they called the earth השפל עולם, that is the lower world; to the middle regions they gave the name of עולם התיכון; and the upper regions or the heavens they denoted by עולם העליון. In no other instance,” he adds, “either in the New Testament or in the Septuagint, is this word used in the sense of worlds.”172 Dr Owen173 gives a similar account of the expression, and in confirmation of the Jewish distribution of the worlds, refers to Kimchi’s comment on Isaiah vi. 3; in which that Rabbi thinks proper, fancifully enough, to remark, that it is with a reference to the three worlds that the word Holy is three times repeated by the Seraphim. Grotius and others have strained the term worlds, at least in Heb. i. 3, to signify the new creation, or the Church renewed by the evangelical dispensation. But the futility of this Socinian gloss is irrefragably proved by Owen, Whitby, and Dr Magee.174

Some writers, it may be noticed in fine, appear to consider οἱ ἀιωνες in Heb. xi. 3. as comprising not merely the whole system of the universe, but also the revolutions it has experienced, and the events of which it is the scene. Accordingly, Parkhurst on this Greek word observes, that “it seems in Heb. xi. 3. to denote the various revolutions and grand occurrences which have happened to this created system, including also the system or world itself.” The system itself, however, is the subject at least directly intended; and this was, without question, the opinion of Macknight, to whom Parkhurst apparently refers as friendly to his own comment. “Τοῦς ἀιωνας,” says that author,—“literally secula, the ages. But the subsequent clause, so that things which are seen were not made of things which did appear, determines its signification to the material fabric of the worlds, comprehending the sun, moon, stars, and earth (called by Moses the heaven and the earth, Gen. i. 1.) by whose duration and revolutions, time, consisting of days, and months, and years, and ages, is measured.”175

Note XLVII. Page 205.

The philosopher to whom our Author chiefly alludes in his discussion relative to the infinite extent which has been ascribed to the world, is no doubt Des Cartes. Of this celebrated man it has been justly said, “he obtained immortal honour by overthrowing the philosophy of Aristotle; but no doubt he indulged himself in a freedom of speculation not sufficiently restrained by a becoming regard to the dictates of revelation, or the principles of common sense.” Dr Reid gives the following account of the manner in which he was led to entertain the idea of the world’s infinity.

“It was probably owing to an aversion to admit any thing into philosophy of which we have not a clear and distinct conception, that Des Cartes was led to deny that there is any substance in matter distinct from those qualities of it which we perceive. We say that matter is something extended, figured, moveable. Extension, figure, mobility, therefore, are not matter, but qualities belonging to this something which we call matter. Des Cartes could not relish this obscure something, which is supposed to be the subject or substratum of those qualities; and therefore maintained that extension is the very essence of matter. But as we must ascribe extension to space as well as to matter, he found himself under a necessity of holding that space and matter are the same thing, and differ only in our way of conceiving them; so that wherever there is space there is matter, and no void left in the universe. The necessary consequence of this is that the material world has no bounds or limits. He did not, however, choose to call it infinite, but indefinite.”176

A similar conclusion has been deduced by some men of science from a very different set of premises. The astonishing discoveries supplied by the telescope have so delighted and overwhelmed them, that they can hardly find terms sufficiently strong to express the extent of the creation. Dr Halley, for instance, has advanced what he says seems to be a metaphysical paradox, namely, that the number of fixed stars must be more than finite, and some of them at a greater than a finite distance from others. Addison, after stating that Huygenius “does not think it impossible there may be stars whose light has not yet travelled down to us since their first creation,” makes the following remark; “There is no question but the universe has certain bounds set to it; but when we consider that it is the work of infinite power, prompted by infinite goodness, with an infinite space to exert itself in, how can our imagination set any bounds to it?”177

A living Preacher, who has pursued this lofty speculation with splendid eloquence and uncommon ardour, expresses himself in the following terms.—“The contemplation has no limits. If we ask the number of suns and of systems—the unassisted eye of man can take in a thousand, and the best telescope which the genius of man has constructed can take in eighty millions. But why subject the domains of the universe to the eye of man, or to the powers of his genius? Fancy may take its flight far beyond the ken of eye or telescope. It may expatiate on the outer regions of all that is visible—and shall we have the boldness to say that there is nothing there? that the wonders of the Almighty are at an end, because we can no longer trace his footsteps? that his omnipotence is exhausted, because human art can no longer follow him? that the creative energy of God has sunk into repose, because the imagination is enfeebled by the magnitude of its efforts, and can keep no longer on the wing through those mighty tracts which shoot far beyond what eye hath seen or the heart of man hath conceived—which sweep endlessly along, and merge into an awful and mysterious infinity?”178

The arguments which Witsius adduces against the hypothesis of Des Cartes, who attributed to the creation an absolute infinity, have doubtless very great weight; and the reader who wishes to learn what a profound philosopher is able to advance on the same side of the question, may consult Locke’s “Essay on the Human Understanding.”179 Dr Watts’ “Philosophical Essays” also contain discussions on the nature and extent of space, the perusal of which will prove at least an entertaining exercise to those who take pleasure in abstract speculation.

Note XLVIII. Page 207.

The learned Author, in the short allusion which he makes to the disputes of chronologers regarding the number of years that has elapsed since the creation, obviously refers to that diversity of opinion upon this point amongst the friends of revelation, which has arisen in a great degree from the discrepancies betwixt the Hebrew copy of the Old Testament Scriptures, the Samaritan, and the Septuagint. The Hebrew copy, which Christians for good reasons now consider as the most authentic, appears to date the creation of the world 3944 years before the birth of Christ. The Samaritan Bible fixes it at 4305. The Septuagint makes it 5270. The calculations of historians and chronologers differ considerably from each other. Josephus, according to Dr Wells and Mr Whiston, makes the period between the creation and the Christian era 4658 years. M. Pezron extends it to 5872. But Archbishop Usher, whose chronology is generally received, makes it 4004.180

It is a curious fact, that nearly all the celebrated writers in the Christian Church, both in the East and West, neglected the Hebrew computations and adhered to the Greek, till in the century before last some of the Roman authors adopted the Hebrew computations,—not because they were Hebrew, but because they tallied with the Latin Vulgate authorised by the Council of Trent. Jerome and Augustine were the only ancient writers of the Church who computed otherwise; and among the moderns, Beza was the first that questioned the correctness of the Greek chronology. For farther information respecting this controversy, in so far at least as it relates to the interval betwixt the creation and the deluge, and for an account of the manner in which Cappel has attempted to reconcile the difference between the Hebrew copy and the Septuagint, the reader may consult Shuckford.181

Witsius, justly acquiescing in the Hebrew computations, lays it down as a fixed principle, that at the date of his writing this Treatise, viz. in the year 1681, the world had not reached the age of 6000 years. According to the received chronology, more than 170 years are still necessary to complete that period. But a far higher antiquity, it seems proper to mention, has on various pretexts been assigned to the world; and sceptics have, in consequence, urged the contracted limits of the Mosaic chronology, as a strong objection against the Divine inspiration and authority of Scripture. Voltaire, for instance, affirms that the sacred oracles are liable to a great degree of ridicule, because they represent the creation of the world, as having happened only 7000 years ago, while the Chinese trace it back to a much greater number of millions. Halhed, too, the Translator of the Code of Hindoo laws, after detailing the monstrous figments of the Indian Brahmins relative to their four Yugs, or grand periods of the world’s existence, and the prodigiously long lives ascribed to their Menus, thus exclaims; “Computation is lost, and conjecture overwhelmed, in the attempt to adjust such astonishing spaces of time to our confined notions of the world’s epoch: to such an antiquity the Mosaic creation is but as yesterday, and to such ages the life of Methuselah is but a span.”182

The absurd superstition and ridiculous vanity of several nations, as of the Egyptians and Chaldeans, as well as the Indians and Chinese, have strikingly appeared in their bold pretensions to an astonishing antiquity. The degree of credit they have met with from some men of science in modern times, is a mortifying proof of human weakness and the power of prejudice. In several instances, however, individuals who were once disposed to admit such pretensions, have at last become ashamed of their credulity, and candidly acknowledged their error. Accordingly, Maurice, in his History of Hindostan,183 after alluding to the admiration which Mr Halhed had at one time expressed for the Hindoo chronology, proceeds to say of that gentleman, he “has long been convinced of the futility of the claim to unfathomable antiquity of the presumptuous Brahmins.” “It is by his immediate request,” he adds, “that I announce to the public his altered sentiments on this point.” The elaborate work of Maurice, from which this notice of Halhed’s change of sentiment is taken, contains an ample refutation of the Brahminical pretensions; and the Author shows particularly that their romantic calculations sprung from astronomical allegories, and that those allegories appear to be founded upon the basis of ancient facts, recorded by Moses, but distorted so as to suit their superstitious purposes. Sir William Jones, too, in his “Dissertation on the Chronology of the Hindoos,” proposes the question, “Whether it is not in fact the same with our own, but embellished and obscured by the fancies of their poets, and the riddles of their astronomers?” He inquires also, whether the story of the seventh Menu be not one and the same with that of Noah? whether Menu comes from Nuh, the true name of that patriarch? and whether the first Menu be Adam?”184—Bishop Pearson has refuted, briefly indeed, but with ability and spirit, the claims of the Egyptians and Chaldeans, and brought forward cogent arguments for what he calls the novity of the world.185 A passage of Shuckford also, in which he institutes a comparison between the Mosaic accounts and the short notices of ancient events, supplied by profane historians, as Berosus the priest of Belus at Babylon, Sanchoniatho the Phenician, and Manetho the Egyptian, deserves to be perused.186

As one specimen of the success with which the annals of Moses are vindicated, and vain pretensions to an extravagant antiquity confuted, the following quotation from an excellent little work in defence of revelation may be here presented to the reader.—“The Chinese have carefully, from the earliest times, observed the motions of the heavenly bodies, and recorded in their calendars remarkable eclipses, and very singular conjunctions of the planets, as having happened in such and such an Emperor’s reign. Now in this enlightened age, you know, we can calculate back and tell the year, day, hour, and minute and second when these eclipses, conjunctions, &c. happened at Pekin; and from hence we evidently perceive, they have made many great and palpable mistakes in their so much boasted chronology. One in particular has been most satisfactorily demonstrated by the famous Cassini, from a very singular and most remarkable conjunction of the sun, moon, and several planets, mentioned in their annals as having happened almost at the very origin of their history. This celebrated astronomer, anxious to know the truth of this, calculated back, and from hence discovered an error in their chronology of only 500 years; and proved to demonstration, that such an extraordinary conjunction of the planets actually did happen at China on the 26th day of February, 2012 years B. C. i. e. in the fourth century after the flood, in the days of Noah and his sons, a little after the birth of Abraham. From all which it is clear that the boasted antiquity of the Chinese is forced, from proofs of its own recording, to contract itself within the compass of the Mosaic history, and to bring an additional proof of the veracity of the sacred records.”187

The futile claims of nations to an extreme antiquity are not the only pretexts which scepticism has employed for the purpose of disparaging the chronology of Scripture. It has eagerly resorted also to various phenomena which the earth itself presents in its inferior strata or external productions; and which a vain philosophy readily misunderstands, or daringly perverts. Who has not heard, for instance, of the cavil of the Canon Recupero, somewhat lightly adverted to in Brydone’s “Tour through Sicily and Malta?” When digging a pit in the vicinity of Jaci, the canon informs us, he discovered no less than seven distinct layers of lava, each of which was covered with a bed of rich vegetable earth. He points out also a bed of lava, which he conceives to have been deposited about the time of the second Punic war, so thinly covered with soil as to be still unfit for producing either corn or vines. If a period of 2000 years, therefore, be required for converting lava into soil, 14,000, he alleges, must have elapsed since the formation of the lowest bed of the pit at Jaci, and consequently the mountain must have existed at a period still more remote.

The weakness of this argument has been clearly shown in a celebrated work. “Moses,” says the writer of the article referred to, “professes to give an account of the history of mankind from the earliest period, and describes the manner in which the earth was prepared for our habitation, but he nowhere pretends to give the date of its formation. The earth therefore may have existed, and undergone various revolutions, previous to the period at which the Scripture narration commences.” “But lest this mode of removing the difficulty,” continues the writer, “should appear to some of our readers not altogether satisfactory, we shall now examine the argument itself. Its whole force seems to depend upon two circumstances; upon the accuracy of the fact respecting the bed of lava which is said to have flowed from the mountain about the time of the second Punic war; and upon the correctness of the general assumption that all lavas require the same number of years to fit them for supporting vegetable life. With regard to the first point, we have no means of ascertaining what degree of credit is due to the opinion of Recupero. He indeed speaks of it as a matter clearly made out, but does not inform us from what principle he derived his conclusion.

“But admitting that this particular bed of lava did flow from the mountain about 2,000 years ago, and that it is still scarcely fit for the purposes of vegetable life, does it follow that all lavas are equally refractory? If we were entitled to decide upon the qualities of lava from what happens in the parallel case of iron slag, we might, without hesitation, affirm, that lavas become fertile at very different periods, according to the nature of the substances from which they are derived, the consistency of their parts, the position of the bed, and their degree of exposure to those agents which produce a disintegration of their parts. But, fortunately, on this subject we are not under the necessity of having recourse to the doubtful argument of analogy. It is a fact well ascertained, that volcanic ashes and pumice vegetate much sooner than compact solid lava. But even lavas apparently in similar circumstances are covered with vegetable mould at very different periods. Chevalier Gioeni informs us that he found, in 1787, lavas which had been projected only twenty-one years before that period, in a state of vegetation; while others much more ancient remained barren. - - - - -

“The argument derived from the appearance of the pit at Jaci has no force, unless it can be demonstrated, that the thickness of the beds of vegetable earth corresponds exactly to the period betwixt the eruptions. But it must appear perfectly nugatory, if it can be shown that an appearance exactly similar has been produced within the limits of authentic history. The ruins of Herculaneum furnish us with a fact of this kind. The eruption which overwhelmed this once flourishing city is known to have happened in the reign of Titus, little more than 1700 years ago. Upon examining the ruins, it is found, that six different eruptions have occurred since that period, and that each of the strata of lava is separated by beds of rich soil.”188

Note XLIX. Page 221.

The decided terms in which Witsius condemns and ridicules the opinion of those who deem it probable that the moon and the planets are the abodes of animal and intellectual life, may appear strange to some of his readers. But our surprise will cease, when we reflect that he flourished more than an hundred years ago, that the modern discoveries in astronomical science were then in their infancy, and that the most pious and learned members of the Protestant Churches were at that time almost universally hostile to a theory which struck them as at least seemingly repugnant to Scripture, and which was warmly espoused by a class of philosophers, some of whom in other respects discovered very little reverence for the authority of Divine revelation. The judicious Mastricht may be mentioned as furnishing another example of the unfavourable sentiments with which even well-informed Christians at first regarded the system maintained by the celebrated Newton (who, by the way, was a decided believer of the Scriptures) with his predecessors and followers. That excellent Theologian, when taking notice of the system of the world, has the following observation; “The Reformed ascribe the lowest place to this earth, which, according to the uniform tenor of sacred writ, is contradistinguished from the heavens and the stars, and which, being in a manner the centre of the universe, remains immoveable, Eccles. i. 4.”189 Even at the present time there are not wanting individuals of learning and worth who are invincibly attached to the exploded philosophy; or who, although they may perhaps admit the Newtonian doctrine so far as it relates to the revolutions performed by the earth and the other planets around the sun, are far from embracing the idea that the Moon, Mercury, Venus, and the other planets are inhabited, or that there are innumerable other systems of planets, peopled in like manner with worlds of intelligent beings. The late Mr Parkhurst makes the following remark: “The כוכבים, whether planets or fixed stars, were ordained by God to govern and enlighten the night. And the modern philosopher, who imagines the moon and planets to be inhabited worlds, and the fixed stars, suns to other systems, may perhaps find enough to awaken him from this amusing but delusive dream, in the excellent Mr Baker’s Reflexions on Learning, ch. viii. (Compare Keill’s Astronomy, sect. 10. towards the end) or in the learned Calcott on the Creation, p. 20,” &c.190

In order to prevent misconceptions of the venerable Author’s meaning, it seems proper to make the following remarks on the passage to which this Note refers. 1st, He allows that the existence of a plurality of worlds is not, in the nature of things, impossible, and even reasons (sect. 75, 76.) in opposition to them who rashly affirmed that more worlds similar to this universe could not have been created by the Divine omnipotence itself. 2dly, Since the opinion, that the planets are the habitations of rational beings, how probable soever it may be deemed, is by no means demonstrably certain, our Author is right in so far as he impugns the hypothesis of those philosophers, if any such there were, who contended for its absolute certainty. Notwithstanding the overstrained expressions quoted from Kepler’s Selenographia, it does not appear that the most powerful telescopes hitherto formed have enabled any astronomer positively to affirm, whatever conjectures he might entertain, that he actually saw inhabitants in the moon, or in any of the planets, exhibiting the natural symptoms of life and rationality. The reasonings on this point too from analogy, it is obvious, however specious or forcible they may seem, do not amount to demonstration. With regard to an express Divine testimony, in fine, in support of the opinion in question, it is confessedly wanting. 3dly, It was proper to combat the sentiments of those who asserted that the supposed inhabitants of the moon and the planets are not merely rational beings but men—creatures of the same or nearly the same nature with ourselves, though perhaps of a gigantic size. Whilst we profess to exalt the creative energy of God, why should we venture, with the same breath, to prescribe limits to his power? The amazing diversity of forms, instincts, and capacities, by which he has distinguished the numerous classes of animals in the various compartments of our own world, is calculated to give us the most elevated conceptions of the infinitude of his wisdom and might—of the versatility, if we may use the expression, of his plastic hand. Admitting that there is some general and even striking resemblance between the imagined inhabitants of other planets and ourselves with regard to rationality, moral agency, the social impulse, immortality, and capability of endless improvement, who can tell with what singular material organs or intellectual faculties, of which we can now form no idea, these distant families of the universe may have been endowed; what visible and beneficial shades of difference may subsist betwixt them all; and what characters of marked peculiarity may be traced in each by those angels, or other spirits, who are permitted to fly like lightning from world to world, in order to contemplate the mighty works of Jehovah, and minister to the happiness of his countless offspring? 4thly, Witsius, in fine, is quite correct in holding, that this earth has been the theatre of a most astonishing display of the Divine perfections and character, and that its inhabitants have been the objects of the most distinguishing goodness and love.

In justice to our Author, these explanatory remarks have now been suggested. Nevertheless, when, conformably to the prevailing sentiments of the Christians of his own age, both illiterate and learned, he expressly denies the existence of intelligent beings in the moon and the planets, and reprobates the opinion of those who maintain its probability as monstrous, and disgraceful to the Protestant religion, it is frankly conceded that he proceeds too far. His arguments, however plausible, are not sufficient to justify his decided condemnation of that opinion. From the profound silence of the sacred volume with regard to the existence, character, circumstances, and history of beings resident in certain regions of the wide universe, it doth not at all follow that those regions are utterly unpeopled, or that any one of them is abandoned to perpetual solitude. The Bible was not intended to furnish us with a system of universal knowledge, but only to afford that portion of intelligence which was requisite to enable us to attain the great end of our creation. Although the Almighty has, for purposes worthy of his wisdom and goodness, made us in some degree acquainted, by means of the Scriptures, with the nature, capacities, condition, and employments of Angels, both the holy and the fallen, it cannot justly be inferred that it would have been either proper or necessary to give us in our present mortal state an equal measure of information, or any information at all, relative to every other class of intelligent beings that may exist in the planetary orbs, whether innocent or degenerate. Even on the supposition that some of those orbs contain multitudes of rational creatures that have deviated from their original integrity, it is not for us to inquire minutely into the course of the Divine procedure towards them, lest we be found “intruding into those things which we have not seen, vainly puffed up by a carnal mind.”191 But what should hinder us from imagining, that whatever be the extent of the universe, and however numerous and varied its intelligent population, devils and men are the only parts of the offspring of God, that have ever cast off their allegiance to the Father of all, and that the rest have universally persisted in the paths of obedience? And what right have we, at the same time, to demand or expect explicit information relative to those numberless classes of rational and immortal beings, which may exist in unsullied innocence and consummate bliss? Whatever advantages might appear to us likely to accrue from a Divine communication on the subject, it does not become us peremptorily to conclude that such a communication could not have been withheld.

The enemies of Christianity, it is well known, have urged the magnitude of the visible creation as a powerful objection to the truth of the Scriptures, and in particular to their leading doctrine—redemption by the obedience and sufferings of incarnate Deity. That the Creator of innumerable worlds would lavish his goodness on this insignificant planet to such a degree as is taught in the Gospel,—that in the person of his Son he would assume the nature of its degenerate inhabitants, and shed his blood on the cross for their redemption,—they are pleased to represent as doctrines utterly incredible. On this topic there are some just remarks in a short essay by an anonymous Author, entitled, “The Philosophy of Divine Revelation no argument of imposture,” and published in the year 1734. The subject has, however, been more copiously and satisfactorily discussed in later productions. Dr Chalmers’s able “Discourses on the Christian Revelation viewed in connexion with the Modern Astronomy,” have been extensively read and highly admired. There is also a chapter in Fuller’s “Gospel its own Witness,”192 entitled, “The consistency of the Scripture doctrine of redemption, with the modern opinion of the magnitude of the creation,” which has been justly esteemed by many competent judges,193 a concise, solid, and masterly refutation of the objection referred to, as it is plausibly stated by a certain notorious deistical writer.

“All the reasoning,” says Mr Fuller, “in favour of a multiplicity of worlds inhabited by intelligent beings amounts to no more than a strong probability. No man can properly be said to believe it. It is not a matter of faith but of opinion. It is an opinion, too, that has taken place of other opinions which in their day were admired by the philosophical part of mankind as much as this is in ours. - - - Now before we give up a doctrine, which if it were even to prove fallacious has no dangerous consequences attending it, and which if it should be found a truth, involves our eternal salvation, we should endeavour to have a more solid ground than mere opinion on which to take our stand.—But I do not wish,” he adds, “to avail myself of these observations; for I am under no apprehension that the cause in which I engage requires them. Admitting that the intelligent creation is as extensive as modern philosophy supposes, the credibility of redemption is not thereby weakened; but, on the contrary, in many respects is strengthened and aggrandized.”

After adverting to the dignity of man as a creature destined to immortality, and to the incalculable importance of the salvation of one soul, Mr Fuller states and illustrates the following observations in proof that there is nothing in the Scripture doctrine of redemption, which is inconsistent with the modern opinion of the magnitude of creation. 1st, “Let creation be as extensive as it may, and the number of worlds be multiplied to the utmost boundary to which imagination can reach, there is no proof that any of them, except men and angels, have apostatized from God. - - - 2dly, Let creation be ever so extensive, there is nothing inconsistent in supposing that some one particular part of it should be chosen out of the rest as a theatre on which the great Author of all things would perform his most glorious works. - - - 3dly, If any one part of God’s creation, rather than another, possessed a superior fitness to become a theatre on which he might display his glory, it should seem to be that part where the greatest effort has been made to dishonour him. - - - - 4thly, The events brought to pass in this world, little and insignificant as it may be, are competent to fill all and every part of God’s dominions with everlasting and increasing joy. - - - An intellectual object requires only to be known, and it is equally capable of affording enjoyment to a million as to an individual, to a world as to a million, to the whole universe, be it ever so extensive, as to a world. - - - 1 Pet. i. 12. Eph. iv. 10. Ps. ciii. 22.”

Having made these observations, the writer goes forward to vindicate the silence of Scripture, which neither teaches the doctrine of a multitude of inhabited worlds, nor affirms the contrary; and to defend the popular style in which the Bible is written as best adapted to its great end. And he concludes his discussion by offering evidence in a series of particulars, that the Scripture doctrine of redemption is even strengthened and aggrandized by the supposed magnitude of creation. But instead of abridging these excellent remarks, it seems best to refer the reader to the work itself.

Κόσμον ἴσον τοῦτῳ στήσας εἰπεῖν, ἐμὸς οὗτος.

A learned man has translated this distich into Latin thus:

*Qui Deus affectat dici, producere mundum*

*Huic similem tentato, suum quem dicere possit.*























































































































































To this remarkable quotation, Witsius adds the following reflexion. “O how well calculated is this devout discourse, this pious counsel of a heathen, to make us ashamed of our backwardness and indolence! Doth a pagan philosopher speak and act in this manner; and how do we Christians conduct ourselves?” T.





“If we were truly wise, what else would be our business both in public and in private but to magnify, to praise, and render thanks to the Deity? Should we not sing this Hymn to God, whilst we

1 בריאה יברא Num. xvi. 30.

2 ברא יהוה חדשה בארץ Jer. xxxi. 22.

3 Gen. i. 21, 27.

4 בורא Eccles. xii. 1.

5 נוראות נפלא Ps. cxxxix. 14.

6 עם נברא יהלל יה Ps. cii. 18.

7 נבראת Ezek. xxi. 30.

8 הנני בורא Is. lxv. 17.

9 תשלח רוחך יבראון Ps. civ. 30.

10 מאין ליש, as Kimchi speaks.

11 2 Pet. iii. 4. Mark x. 6.

12 Κτίσαι est ἱδρύσαι, οἰκησαι, ἀρξασθαι. Κτισμα, ποιημα, οἰκοδὸμημα.

13 Ἀνθρωπίνην κτίσιν. 1 Pet. ii. 13.

14 Prov. viii. 22.

15 The Scottish word bairn, (a child,) may, with equal probability, be traced to the same Hebrew origin. T.

16 נברא, κτισθεις, creatus.

17 As in Virgil, Sulmone creatos, begotten, or born, at Sulmo: and in Horace, Fortes creantur fortibus; The brave are begotten by the brave.

18 Ennius accordingly says, Dicitur Vesta hanc urbem creavisse; Vesta is reported to have created, that is, founded, this city.

19 Πάντα χρήματα ἠν ὁμοῦ· ἐιτα νοῦς ἐλθων, ἀυτα διεκόσμησε.

20 Ὁ μακαριος. 1 Tim. vi. 15.

21 Extra se.

22 Jer. x. 12.

23 Πιστει νοουμεν κατηρτίσθαι τοῦς ἀιῶνας ῥήματι Θεοῦ, ἐίς τὸ μη εκ φαινομένων τα βλεπόμενα γεγονέναι. Heb. xi. 3.

24 See Note XLVI.

25 Καταρτισμὸς.

26 Τα βλεπὸμενα.

27 The Hebrews, whom the Apostle imitates, call such things הנמצאות, τα ἑυρισκόμενα, the things which are found.

28 An anastrophe is “a figure, whereby words which should have been precedent, are postponed.” T.

29 Τα ὄντα ἐξ ὀυκ ὄντων.

30 Mat. ix. 33.

31 Φαινομενα.

32 Μη φαινόμενα.

33 Τα μη ὄντα.

34 Ch. xi. 17.

35 De Vera Relig. lib. ii. cap. 4.

36 Ἀόρατος.

37 תהו ובהו:

38 הארץ with the demonstrative particle ה.

39 Ἀόρατος.

40 Τα μη φαινομενα.

41 Γῆ ἀόρατος.

42 Creationis terminus a quo.

43 בראשית:

44 Ps. xc. 2.

45 Is. xliii. 13.

46 Prov. viii. 22, 23.

47 Rev. iv. 11.

48 Hexaem. Hom. ii.

49 Disput. Physica de Mundo, sect. viii.

50 De Præp. Evan. lib. vii. cap. penultimo: περι τοῦ μη ἀγεννητον ἐιναι την ὑλην.

51 Γνῶναι ὁτι οὐκ ἐξ ὄντων ἐποίησεν ἀυτα ὁ Θεὸς.

52 The entire verse from which the expression is quoted, is as follows: “For thy almighty hand, that made the world of matter without form, wanted not means to send among them a multitude of bears, or fierce lions.” T.

53 Chap. ix. 1.

54 Τὸ μη κληθεν ὑπὸ τοῦ Θεοῦ, ver. 25.

55 That is, Moses imitating the language of Athens. T.

56 De Opificio mundi.

57 Gen. ii. 4.

58 De Creatione, Probl. iii.

59 More, Part ii. cap. 27.

60 Παντοκρατορικῷ βοῦλήματι.

61 Gen. i. 3.

62 Ps. xxxiii. 9.

63 Rev. iv. 11.

64 Dissert. xxv.

65 Πονηροῦ κομματος, i. e. literally, are of a bad stamp. T.

66 Job xxxviii. 3, 4, 5.

67 Verse 2.

68 Ἀυτοματῳ συντυχία.

69 Is. xl. 26, 28. See also verses 12, 13, 14. Ch. xxxvii. 16. xlii. 5.

70 Is. xliv. 24.

71 Job ix. 8.

72 Ps. xcvi. 5.

73 Jer. x. 11.

74 Ἑῖς ταῖς ἀληθείαισιν, ἑῖς εστι Θεος, ὃς οὐρανὸν τὲτευχε και γαῖαν μακρὰν.

75 Lib. de Monarchia.

76 Ἔι τῖς ἐρεῖ, Θεός εἰμι παρὲξ ἑνὸς, οὗτος ὄφειλει

77 The Author here refers to what he had formerly said, Dissert. iv. Sect. 16. et seq. T.

78 Is. xliv. 24.

79 Jer. x. 11.

80 Is. xl. 12.

81 Jer. xxxi. 37.

82 Τα δ’ ἀλλα κομπος, και λογων ἐυμορφίαι.

83 Natur. Auscul. lib. iii. cap. 9.

84 In Gen. i. sect. 16.

85 Ἀπειρον εἶναι τὸ πᾶν.

86 Is. xl. 12.

87 See Note XLVII.

88 Gen. i. 1.

89 קדמי ארץ

90 Prov. viii. 23, 24.

91 Ephes. i. 4. John xvii. 5.

92 Conci. vi. in Joh. xvii.

93 Gen. xlix. 26.

94 Ps. xc. 2.

95 נבעות עולם

96 הרי קדם Deut. xxxiii. 15.

97 Contra Arianos, Orat. ii.

98 Extra se.

99 In Gen. i. Sect. 39. et seq. Itemque Disputat. Select. xxvii. Sect. 29, &c.

100 See Note XLVIII.

101 תשרי

102 שרה

103 De Præpar. Evang. lib. ix. cap. 4.

104 Levit. xxv. 9.

105 Ἐν μια καιροῦ ῥοπῇ, μιατε ὁρμῇ και κινήσει.

106 De hominis Opificio, cap. i.

107 Ps. civ. 6, 7, 8.

108 Hexaem. This sentiment occurs in nearly the same words in Basil. Homil. iv.

109 1 Cor. xv. 52.

110 John i. 3, 10.

111 Col. ii. 18.

112 Τὸ παν.

113 Primus verarum historiarum Liber.

114 Ἱππογύποὶ; in Latin, Equivultures.

115 In Selenographia sua.

116 Ἀνθρωποπαθῶς.

117 Is. xlv. 18.

118 Acts xvii. 26.

119 Heb. ii. 16.

120 Goel, which is translated Redeemer, is a striking designation given to Christ in Job xix. 25. Is. lix. 20. and various other passages. It denotes the near relation in which he stands to us as “the man Christ Jesus,” and his consequent right to accomplish our redemption. It exhibits him as the antitype of the Goel, or near kinsman who by the Mosaic law was entitled to redeem an inheritance, and also was permitted to avenge the death of his relation, by killing the slayer if he found him out of the cities of refuge. T.

121 Acts iii. 21.

122 Rom. x. 18.

123 Acts iv. 12.

124 The Author here alludes to a discussion in the Economy of the Covenants, Book ii. chap. 4. T.

125 Men whom the writer alluded to represented as having existed before Adam. T.

126 See Note XLIX.

127 Chap. xxxviii. 6, 7.

128 2 Cor. iv. 6.

129 ינפש Exod. xxxi. 17.

130 Homilia xv.

131 Ps. viii. 3, 4.

132 Νοοῦμεν, Heb. xi. 3.

133 Is. v. 12.

134 Prefatio Quæstionum Naturalium.

135 Ἐπόπτης της ὁρατης κτίσεως, μύστης της νοουμενης.

136 Is. xl. 26.

137 Job xii. 7, 8.

138 Ps. cxxxix. 14.

139 Ps. civ. 24. See also xcii. 5, 6. Job xxvi. 14.

140 Ps. xcii. 4.

141 Job xxxviii. 6, 7.

142 Acts xvii. 27.

143 Ps. xix. 1.

144 Job xii. 9.

145 Jer. xxvii. 5.

146 Ps. cxlv. 9.

147 Ps. cxlvii. 5.

148 De Opificio Mundi, p. 12.

149 Homil. i. in Hexaem. circa fin. Quoted from the original Greek, and from the Latin Version of John Argyropilus.

150 Ps. lxxiii. 25.

151 Ps. cxlviii. handle the spade and the plough, and whilst we partake of our food? ‘Great is that God, who has afforded us those implements, with which we cultivate the ground. Great is that God, to whom we are indebted for hands, and for the power of swallowing and digesting our food; who causes us to grow imperceptibly, and to breathe when asleep.’ These instances of the Divine goodness ought to be particularly celebrated; and we should praise him in the noblest and most sacred songs, because he has given us faculties by which we perceive them, and are capable of employing them aright. What then? Since we are generally blind and stupid, ought not some one to discharge this office, and to celebrate the praises of God on behalf of all? And what else can I do, who am old and lame, but show forth his praise. Were I a nightingale, I would act the part of a nightingale; were I a swan, I would act the part of a swan. But since I am a rational creature, I ought to praise God. This is my work; this I will perform; nor shall I desert this honourable employment, while I am permitted to pursue it. And I invite you to unite with me in the same song.”

152 Vide Arriani Dissert. lib. i. cap. 16.

153 The Author gives the passage from Epictetus to which he here alludes, in the 17th section of his 8th Dissertation on the Lord’s Prayer. As the reader may wish to see a quotation so highly commended by Witsius, it is here subjoined in English.

154 Jer. v. 22. Ps. xxxiii. 6–9.

155 Acts xvii. 28.

156 Ps. cxlviii. 8.

157 Is. i. 2. 3. Jer. viii. 7.

158 Ps. xxiv. i.

159 Ps. cxlvii. 9.

160 Ps. xxxvi. 7. Mat. vi. 26–34.

161 Monodia Gregorii Nazianzeni in Basilium Magnum.

162 Ps. xxxiv. 11.

163 לא נפלא ממך כל דבר Jer. xxii. 17.

164 Nulla res mirabilis tibi erit.

165 Is. xliii. 2. Dan. iii. 17, 27, 28, 29. vi. 22, 23.

166 Rom. viii. 28.

167 Rom. iv. 13. 1 Cor. iii. 21, 22.

168 Jer. x. 16.

169 Is. liv. 5.

170 Ps. xxxvii. 5.

171 1 Pet. iv. 19.

172 Marsh’s Translation of the Introduction to the New Testament by the late John David Michaelis, Professor in the University of Gottingen, Vol. iv. p. 235.

173 Exposition of the Epistle to the Hebrews, Ch. i. 2.

174 Discourses and Dissertations on the Scriptural Doctrine of Atonement and Sacrifice, vol. i. Note 1. On the Pre-existence of Christ, and the species of arguments by which this article of the Christian Doctrine has been opposed, pp. 78, 79.

175 A new literal Translation, &c. on Heb. xi. 3. Note 1.

176 Dr Reid on the Intellectual Powers of Man, Essay ii. ch. 8.

177 Evidences of the Christian Religion, &c. pp. 85, 86.

178 A series of Discourses on the Christian Revelation viewed in connexion with the Modern Astronomy, by Thomas Chalmers, D. D. Ser. i.

179 Book ii. ch. 13. “Of space and its simple modes;” and ch. 15. “Of duration and expansion considered together.”

180 See Encycl. Britan. Art. Creation.

181 The Sacred and Profane History of the World connected, &c. Vol. i. Book 1.

182 Quoted by Dr Tennant in his “Indian Recreations,” Vol. i. sect. 16.

183 Vol. i. ch. 2.

184 See Dissertations and Miscellaneous Pieces, relating to the History and Antiquities of the Arts, Sciences, and Literature of Asia, Vol. i. pp. 279, 325. Vol. iii. p. 418.

185 Exposition of the Creed, Art. i. pp. 58–63.

186 Vol. i. Book 1.

187 Major Gen. Burns’ “Christian Officer’s complete Armour,” Dialogue i. p. 31.

188 Edinburgh Encycl. Vol. i. Art. Ætna, pp. 184, 185.

189 Theologia, lib. iii. cap. vi. sect. 19.

190 Parkhurst’s Hebrew Lexicon, on the word כבב, iii.

191 Col. ii. 18.

192 Part ii. ch. 5. p. 204. et seq.

193 See the Christian Repository, Vol. ii. p. 560. where, at the close of a spirited review of Dr Chalmers’s Discourses, the writer pronounces a warm encomium on this chapter of Fuller’s work, and refers to a testimony in its favour, “by one who from a Deist has become a Christian and a Minister of the Gospel, in the Retrospect, No. vi. p. 59.”