Dissertation XXII. On Christ’s Coming Again to Judgment
I. Eternal Judgment is numbered by the Apostle among the first principles and fundamental articles of our holy Religion.1 And since this is the last act of the reign of Christ, the brightest manifestation of his Divine glory, the anchor of Christian hope, a powerful antidote against carnal security, a check to raging lusts, and an incentive to conscientious piety,—we ought surely to examine it with no less care and diligence than all the other articles of the Christian faith.
II. There are four public and universal judgments of the human race, mentioned in Scripture. The First took place in paradise, when the common parents of mankind were judged;2 the Second was passed on the antediluvian world;3 the Third, on the nations assembled in the plains of Shinar, to carry into effect the daring enterprise of the tower of Babel.4 The Fourth, is the last Judgment, of which we now speak; which will be the most universal, extending to all men without exception, to the dead as well as to the living.5
III. That God will at last judge all mankind and every individual, may be collected, 1st, From the book of common Providence. The fortunes of good and bad are here blended together, and similar events befal them.6 Nay, whilst wickedness reigns and flourishes, virtue not only misses her rewards, but is even trampled under foot by the profane, and suffers the punishments due to vice.7
Those mis’ries dire, which guilt alone should share,
The guiltless often are condemned to bear.
Vice sits triumphant on a lofty seat,
And treads on Virtue, prostrate at her feet.Worth, that in public view might well have shone,
In darkest shades immers’d, remains unknown.
What strange confusion marks the present state!
The just man suffers the vile sinner’s fate.8
It is necessary, therefore, to the vindication of Divine justice, that sooner or later the state of things should be altered, and that a day should arrive which will demonstrate, in a light clearer than liquid fire, the vast difference betwixt the godly and the wicked. “Then they that feared the Lord spake often one to another: and the Lord hearkened, and heard it; and a book of remembrance was written before him for them that feared the Lord, and that thought upon his name. And they shall be mine, saith the Lord of hosts, in that day when I make up my jewels; and I will spare them, as a man spareth his own son that serveth him. Then shall ye return and discern between the righteous and the wicked; between him that serveth God, and him that serveth him not.”9 2dly, From the book of Conscience; which not only discharges its office of judging the guilty here, but also summons all of them to the tribunal of God, there to undergo another and a more severe and impartial judgment.10 3dly, From the book of Scripture; which exhibits the entire scene of the judgment, with its whole apparatus, prepared with a magnificence corresponding to the majesty of the Supreme Judge. Scripture discovers many circumstances of which nature is utterly ignorant, and others which it teaches but imperfectly and indistinctly.
IV. In treating this subject, the four following points demand our attention. First, The Judge. Secondly, Those that are to be judged. Thirdly, The Sentence. Fourthly, The circumstances of place and time.
V. With regard to the Judge, we may consider, 1st, His person. 2dly, His glory. 3dly, His attendants.
VI. God is the Judge—none of the Divine persons being excluded; whose knowledge, will, authority, and sentence, is one. “Know thou,” says Solomon, “that for all these things God will bring thee into judgment:”11 and, “God will bring every work into judgment.”12 Paul, too, mentions “the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God;”13 and speaks of “God the Judge of all.”14—God, for the precise reason that he is God, that is, a Being infinitely perfect, is the King and Lawgiver of rational creatures.15 He is, therefore, also the Judge, to take cognizance of the actions of men according to the law, and to distribute rewards or punishments conformably to its sanction. He “will render to every man according to his deeds.”16
VII. But by special economy, judgment is attributed to Christ; which appears from numerous and striking testimonies both in the Old and New Testament. In Isaiah, the Messiah is described as “judging, and seeking judgment, and hasting righteousness.”17 To him I would refer also the following words: “The Lord is our Judge, the Lord is our Lawgiver, the Lord is our King; he will save us;”18 for all these characters pertain to Messiah the Saviour, who was anointed by God to be King of Zion, and who delivered in the audience of the whole congregation of Israel, that law, according to which he will judge Israel, and the whole world. In the book of Ezekiel, it is promised that he shall come “whose right it is,” or “whose is the judgment;”19—who has a right to the incorruptible and inalienable crown promised to the house of David, and being King, has also authority to exercise judgment upon all. The following expression in Micah, too, relates to no other person: “They shall smite the Judge of Israel with a rod upon the cheek.”20 It appears from the Gospel history, that Christ was in fact insulted in this manner; and who but he can be called the Judge of Israel that was smitten by the Jews, and for the avenging of whom, the destructive legions of Rome, referred to in this verse, subverted their polity? To him also these words in the Psalms must be applied; “Give the King thy judgments, O God, and thy righteousness unto the King’s Son.”21 Here the Chaldee Paraphrast, not altogether improperly, makes the following comment; To King Messiah, the Son of King David.22 But it is better to refer the expression to a more excellent name, so as peculiarly and eminently to indicate him to be King, who is not the heir of any man in his kingdom, but the Son of the true King, namely, God the Father. The same truth is very frequently inculcated in the New Testament Scriptures.23
VIII. The following declaration of Christ is particularly memorable: “The Father judgeth no man, but hath committed all judgment to the Son.”24 With this, however, these other expressions of our Lord seem not to agree; “I judge no man;”25 and, “There is one that seeketh and judgeth,” that is, the Father.26 This seeming contradiction is thus reconciled. The Father judgeth no man, 1. Separately from the Son. 2. In a visible form. 3. As, according to the economy of redemption, King of the Church. The Father, nevertheless, has not abdicated the whole power, or the whole exercise, of judgment; for the Son is come “in the name” of the Father;27 nor can he do any thing of himself, but what he seeth the Father do.28 The Father, therefore, judges by the Son; “He will judge the world in righteousness by that man whom he hath ordained,”29 and “God shall judge the secrets of men by Jesus Christ.”30
When Christ says of himself, that he judges no man, the expression must be thus understood. 1. He is not a minister of condemnation, such as Moses was;31 for “God sent not his Son into the world, to condemn the world, but that the world through him might be saved.”32 2. He doth not judge separately from the Father,—which is intimated by the words immediately succeeding; “And yet if I judge, my judgment is true, for I am not alone, but I and the Father that sent me.”33 Compare also what he adds in a subsequent verse; “I do nothing of myself, but as my Father hath taught me, I speak these things.”34
IX. It is necessary, also, to explain the reason why it pleased the Father to transfer the whole power of judging to the Son; which is expressed in these words: “And hath given him authority to execute judgment also, because he is the Son of man.”35 The following remarks will serve to illustrate the force of this reason. 1. Because the Son of God, by a voluntary humiliation, became man, that by his obedience and sufferings in the human nature he assumed, he might destroy the enemies of God’s kingdom, and obtain salvation for his people; it was consonant to reason and equity, that he should likewise judge those conquered enemies, and award to his people that salvation which he had purchased for them. Hence his conquering and his judging are mentioned together.36 2. Because the Son of God in the form of the Son of man, became subject to the law, and presented himself before wicked men to be judged and condemned, as guilty of having presumptuously arrogated to himself the Divine majesty; it is expedient that, by a wonderful reverse, he should be manifested to be the Lord of the law, and the Judge of his unjust judges—the glory of that Deity, his pretensions to which were by no means false, being vindicated and declared. Hence his challenge to his enemies, when he stood at the bar of the Jewish council, arraigned, and clothed with an humble garb.37 “He who stood under a judge,” says Augustine, “will sit as Judge. He who was himself falsely pronounced guilty, will condemn the truly guilty.”38 3. Because he is the Son of man, it will be possible for him to be beheld in that nature by all, and to administer judgment visibly and audibly. “Behold, he cometh with clouds, and every eye shall see him, and they also which pierced him.”39 “We read,” says Augustine, “that the Father judgeth no man, but hath committed all judgment to the Son: as if it were said; none will see the Father in the judgment of the quick and the dead; but all shall see the Son, because he is also the Son of man, so that he may be seen by the wicked.”40
X. Christ will exercise judgment according to both natures: the Divine nature displaying infinite majesty, knowledge, and power; the Human, performing the acts of judgment in a visible and audible manner.
XI. Christ will accomplish this work, not by a borrowed and delegated authority, as if he were the mere officer and interpreter of another; but by an authority belonging to himself, supreme, and independent. He doth all things indeed, as we have shown in the eighth Section, in the name of the Father; partly because he is the Son, and doth not work but from the Father, and principally because he has undertaken the discharge of the mediatorial office according to the united counsel of the Trinity—a counsel which has its origin from the Father, as the first person. Yet since the will, as well as the Deity of Christ, is the same with that of the Father, whatever Christ doth in the exercise of his office, is done also by his own authority, namely, that divine and supreme authority which he possesses in common with the Father. And certainly the work of which we now treat, implies or supposes Divine majesty; and can be performed by none that is not God. The inalienable glory of God is, without doubt, asserted in the following words in Isaiah: “I have sworn by myself; the word is gone out of my mouth in righteousness, and shall not return; that unto me every knee shall bow, every tongue shall swear.”41 But in the Epistle to the Romans, the Apostle applies these words to Christ, and to the judgment which Christ is to administer.42 “The Son of man is to judge,” says Augustine, “yet not by human authority, but by that of which he is possessed as the Son of God.” And again, “The Son of God is to judge, not however appearing in that form which belongs to him as God, equal to the Father; but in that which belongs to him as the Son of man.”43
XII. The glory of Christ when he comes to judgment, will be transcendantly great. It was great when he promulgated the law on mount Sinai.44 But it will be greater, when he appears to judge according to that law. “Whose voice then shook the earth; but now he hath promised, saying, Yet once more I shake not the earth only, but also heaven.”4546
XIII. This glory consists, First, In the splendour of the Divine Majesty, shining forth with the brightest effulgence even in the human nature. “When the Son of man shall come in his glory, - - - then shall he sit upon the throne of his glory.”47 And that none may imagine that his glory is inferior to that which is Divine and infinite, it is affirmed that Christ “shall come in the glory of his Father.”48 Not as if this glory were not his own, and were borrowed by him for a time from the Father; but it is a glory, which, owing to his having the same essence, he possesses in common with the Father, not thinking it robbery to be equal with God. Hence it is called his own glory and the Father’s;49 that is, the Father’s glory, so that it is his own also by an equal right. But that Divine glory “is to be revealed,”50 in the body which he has assumed; for it will be seen by every eye. “Hereafter shall ye see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven.”51 “All the tribes of the earth - - - shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven, with power and great glory.”52
XIV. Secondly, In the magnificence of the voice and trumpet, which will accompany his advent. “For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout,”53—by which he will at once command and oblige the living to attend, and prepare himself for the judgment.—With the voice of the Archangel, that is, with an energy enforcing his command, by which he will show himself to be the Prince of Angels, and bring Angels as his retinue. The Scripture speaks of no more than one Archangel; who is Christ, “the Messenger, the Angel, the Lord;”54 “the Head of all principality and power;”55 “by whom Angels were created;”56 of whom it is said, “Let all the Angels of God worship him;”57 and to whom, in fine, “Angels, and authorities, and powers, are made subject.”5859—With the trump of God; by which, as God, he will raise the dead.60
XV. This Trump is mentioned also in other passages.61 What we are to understand by it, is explained in different ways by men of profound erudition. Some view it in a proper and literal sense; in support of which they assign the following reasons. 1. We ought not to depart from the literal meaning without necessity. 2. The noise of a trumpet sounding “exceeding loud” was heard at the promulgation of the law.62 Why may we not suppose that the same circumstance is to take place, when judgment is to be passed according to the law? 3. The sound of the trumpet, agreeably to the Divine command, was heard at the destruction of Jericho.63 From this it is inferred as not improbable, that the same thing will happen, when the Jericho of this world shall be overthrown. Others are inclined to consider the expression metaphorical; while, however, they expound the figure variously. Some understand it of thunders, such as those heard when God speaks in the audience of a multitude;64 others, of an articulate voice to be formed by Angels in the air, resembling that which we have in the parable of the virgins; “Behold, the Bridegroom cometh, go ye out to meet him.”65
To us it appears most simple and most consonant to the style of holy writ, to understand this expression of the command of Christ, which will be most efficacious, pervading all, and displaying its energy in all. In the book of Revelation, a manifestation of the Divine attributes in works of judgment, to which men are obliged to attend with astonishment, is designated by the sound of a trumpet. Now the command of Christ is compared to a trumpet: 1. Because, as the sound of a trumpet, when blown by a powerful breath, is remarkably loud, so this command of our Lord will exert its efficacy far and wide, penetrating not merely through the whole extent of the world, but even to the receptacles of the dead, and the most inaccessible caverns of the grave. Hence, too, it is termed “the sound of a great trumpet.” 2. Because the whole assembly of Israel were accustomed to be called together by a trumpet;66 and all the inhabitants of the earth shall then be summoned. 3. Festival days also were proclaimed by a trumpet;67 and this will be an exceedingly joyful festival to the whole Church.
XVI. Thirdly, This glory of Christ will also include a numerous train of Angels. Accordingly, Enoch, the seventh from Adam, prophesied, saying, “Behold the Lord cometh with ten thousand of his saints;”68 and Paul speaks of the revelation of the Lord Jesus from heaven “with his mighty Angels.”69 That this illustrious retinue which shall surround our Lord, consisting of so many attendants of the heavenly court, will signally contribute to his glory, who can doubt? Our Lord himself, at least, would have us to think so. “When the Son of man shall come in his glory, and all the holy angels with him, then shall he sit upon the throne of his glory.”70 “The Son of man shall come in his own glory, and in his Father’s, and of the holy angels.”71
XVII. But they will also perform other services to Christ. 1st, In gathering together those that are to be judged. “He shall send his angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other.”72 Hence “the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ,” and “our gathering together unto him,” which is to be effected by the ministry of angels,73 are joined together.74 2dly, In making a separation betwixt them when assembled.—“So shall it be at the end of the world; the angels shall come forth, and sever the wicked from among the just.”75 3dly, In casting down the ungodly to the place of punishment. “The Son of man shall send forth his angels, and they shall gather out of his kingdom all things that offend, and them which do iniquity, and shall cast them into a furnace of fire.”76 4thly, In conveying the godly to heaven. “We, who are alive and remain, shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air; and so shall we be ever with the Lord.”77 That the bringing of the godly to the welcome tribunal of Christ in order to be judged, and to heaven after the judgment is over, is to be done by the ministry of angels, we collect from this consideration, that angels convey the souls of the godly to heaven, when separated from their bodies by death.78 Why may we not conclude, that they perform a similar office towards their entire persons?
XVIII. It deserves inquiry, whether holy men shall be assessors with Christ in this final judgment. Many are of opinion that they shall be so, because Paul has the following expressions: “Do ye not know that the saints shall judge the world? Know ye not that we shall judge Angels?”79 But we may be allowed to question the justness of the conclusion deduced from these words. I am far from wishing to have any controversy with those who affirm, that the saints shall judge the world, in a certain improper sense of the expression. It may be admitted, that they shall judge the world, 1. In Christ their Head; to whom they are united by the spirit and by faith; and whose glory is communicated, as far as possible, to the members.80 2. By their approbation of Christ’s sentence.81 3. By the example of their virtues;—in which way even the less guilty are to condemn such as are more wicked than themselves.82 4. By their own justification; for the acquittal of the pious will be the condemnation of the ungodly.83 The Scriptures, nevertheless, represent the saints, rather as persons whom Christ is to judge, than as his assessors in the judgment, or subordinate judges. It is often promised that they shall reign with Christ, but nowhere that they shall judge with him in the day of judgment.
XIX. It is not necessary to expound the passage just quoted from Paul, as referring to the last day, or the world to come. The saints judged the world, when Christians were appointed magistrates and judges during the reign of Constantine the Great, and in subsequent times. Since, at the period of the Apostle’s writing, this honour was reserved for the saints, it was unworthy of them to contend about frivolous matters before unbelievers. The Apostle, too, might speak of this future judging of the saints as well known, because Daniel had prophesied long before, that after the destruction of the four empires which oppressed the Church and the world by their grievous tyranny, “the judgment shall sit, and the dominion which is taken away from the last of the kings, with the greatness of the kingdom under the whole heaven, shall be given to the people of the saints of the Most High.”84 At what time this prediction may have been fulfilled, or is yet to be fulfilled, it is of no consequence to our present purpose to determine. It may suffice to observe, that a time is specified, in which the saints, under Christ their king and leader, are, in this world and under heaven, to judge, and to possess an extensive dominion. And most probably, the Apostle, when he wrote the passage in question, referred to this prophecy of Daniel.
But the saints judge Angels also. This they do, 1. When they demonstrate that those whom the nations had hitherto served, are neither Gods, nor good Angels; but malignant spirits, or mischievous demons. 2. When, by their testimony, and their blood, they overcome them, and restrain their power.85 3. When, by their prayers, they expel them from the bodies of those whom they possessed.86 That this miracle continued in the Church long after the age of the Apostles, we have shown elsewhere.87
XX. But is not the dignity of being assessors with Christ in the last judgment to be attributed at least to the Apostles; since our Lord himself says,—“In the regeneration, when the Son of man shall sit on the throne of his glory, ye also shall sit upon twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel?”88 But even here the expression seems not to refer to the general judgment, since only the tribes of Israel are mentioned. Ever since his ascension to heaven, too, our Lord has already sat on the throne of his glory at the right hand of the Father; and the time of his taking possession of the kingdom and pouring out the Spirit, is justly styled “the regeneration,” as it is the beginning of a new age in which “new heavens and a new earth are created,”89 and “all things are made new.”90 Nor is it necessary to take the word judge in the most strict and proper sense; for by the figure termed metalepsis, it has often the same meaning with govern; because governors are generally occupied in the administration of justice: and hence, as Grotius has learnedly observed, a government is called Medinah91 by the Hebrews. The meaning, therefore, is, ye shall possess the honour next to me who am King. There is an allusion to the ancient state of the kingdom of Israel, in which the chiefs of the tribes were nearest in dignity to the royal majesty, and in public assemblies sat in chairs of state hard by the throne; whilst the first places were allotted to the princes of Judah and Joseph; to which Zebedee’s wife very probably alluded, when she solicited those places for her sons. Compare the parallel passage in Luke,92 where another circumstance is added, namely, that they are to sit at the royal table—a privilege which was usually reserved for the most distinguished nobles. The dignity of the Apostles, therefore, as surpassing all other Israelites, both in the kingdom of grace and in the kingdom of glory, is here figuratively described.93 See Moulin,94 and Hammond,95 who have many learned observations to this effect. If you are disposed, however, to urge the proper sense of the term judge, I will not deny that the expression denotes the powerful efficacy of the apostolical ministry, for the full conviction of the unbelieving and refractory. For as, according to the doctrine of the Apostles preached in the name of Christ, judgment was executed on the rebellious nation of the Jews, which seems here to be intended; so, according to the same Gospel, all mankind shall be judged at the last day.9697
XXI. Let us now pass on to the second head, which relates to those that are to be judged. Here both persons and works must be considered. The persons are rational creatures, Angels and Men. Some of the Angels being good and others of them bad, it is inquired with regard to the former, whether or not they are to be judged at the last day. Now, I dare not affirm that they are to be judged. 1. This is nowhere taught in Scripture. 2. They are every where represented as the attendants and servants of the Judge. 3. They are already judged, and confirmed in a state of consummate blessedness; which, with respect to themselves, seems incapable of increase; except in so far as they shall behold the glory of God more illustriously displayed in the works of glory, than it had previously been in the works of nature or of grace.
XXII. As to bad Angels, it is evident from Scripture that they will be judged.98 Having been cast down from heaven for their rebellion, and shut up in hell as in a prison, they are even now “reserved in everlasting chains of darkness.” These chains may be fitly understood to denote, not only the power of an angry God, by which they are kept bound so that they cannot escape his wrath; but also the wretched necessity they are under of acting wickedly, arising from their vehement love of falsehood and unrighteousness, and from their invincible hatred of God and man; to which is added, their continual horror of conscience, trembling at the scourge of God.99 The chains are called everlasting, because wherever they are, they miserably press them at all times and on every side, and because they will last till the day of final judgment, not to be taken away in that day, but rendered still more intolerable. They are denominated chains of darkness, because there is no light in them—not the smallest spark of probity or happiness. But whereas they still continue to set no bound or measure to their crimes, they will at last be summoned to the tremendous tribunal of a rigorous Judge, and doomed to suffer a most righteous punishment. And after sentence is pronounced, they shall be constantly confined to hell, from which, by the singular forbearance of God, they are now suffered to escape for a time; and, deprived of that frantic pleasure which they derive from injuring the saints, and from creating disorder amongst the works of God, they shall, without intermission, through eternity, experience and most acutely feel the incredible severity of the Divine wrath. They are not ignorant that this awaits them; and hence that complaint: “What have we to do with thee, Jesus thou Son of God; Art thou come hither to torment us before the time?”100 Consider also what we read in the Apocalypse: “And the Devil that deceived them was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are, and shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever.”101
XXIII. Beside angels, men, even all men, are to be judged. This appears, 1. From the note of universality. “We must all appear before the judgment-seat of Christ.”102 2. From the use of collective nouns—“all the earth,”103 “the world.”104 3. From the distribution of mankind into particular classes. God shall judge “the righteous and the wicked,”105 “the small and great,”106 “the quick and the dead.”107
XXIV. The things respecting which they shall be judged are, in general, all the actions of all.108 Deeds109—Words;110 “idle words,”111 that is, words utterly unprofitable, having no tendency to promote either the glory of God or the edification of our neighbour; as well as “hard speeches,”112 that is, arrogant and severe expressions,113 whether against God,114 or against our neighbour.115 Finally,—Thoughts.116
XXV. Some think proper here to inquire, whether the sins of the godly, who shall inherit eternal life, are to be published in the judgment, as well as the sins of the wicked. But truly it is easier for us to propose than to decide this question. Plausible arguments are not wanting on each side. On the affirmative, the following proofs are adduced. 1st, The expressions of Scripture to which we have just referred are general, extending to all the works of all men. 2dly, The justice of the Judge seems to require the examination of all circumstances relating to the cause—of those that make against them, no less than of such as tend to their advantage. 3dly, The memory of the sins of the godly is perpetuated in the records of the Sacred Volume: why may they not also be mentioned again in the last judgment? 4thly, Let it be considered in particular, that the publication of their sins will tend the more abundantly to celebrate the mercy of God and the merits of Christ, to the virtue of which it is owing that persons who were polluted with the stain of crimes so numerous and so great, are not merely admitted to favour, but also made partakers of the kingdom. 5thly, Nor will this tend to the disgrace of the godly, who cheerfully ascribe their salvation to the Divine mercy, and esteem nothing glorious to themselves, which is separated from the glory of God, in which all their ambition is entirely absorbed. 6thly, As this opinion, in fine, powerfully stimulates to piety, and deters from sin; so the contrary seems, at least indirectly, to afford encouragement to carnal security.
XXVI. The other side of the question, however, is not unsupported by arguments. The following things make for it. 1st, The account of the judicial procedure in Matth. xxv. where no mention is made of the evil deeds of the saints, but only of the good works which they have performed. 2dly, The promise of God that he “will remember our sins no more,”117 and will “cast them behind his back,”118 and “cast them into the depths of the sea.”119 Now if he has removed them out of his own sight, how is it possible that he can choose to expose them to the view of angels and men, of friends and enemies? Or, after having once been pleased to bury them under all the waters of the ocean, with what appearance of propriety can he draw them up thence, and proclaim them to all in a most numerous and solemn assembly of the whole universe? 3dly, The office of Christ. He is the “propitiation,”120 the mercy-seat or covering; he will not then expose their sins. He is their “Advocate;”121 and doth not unveil the crimes of his clients. He is the “Friend” of his people; and it is the office of love to cover sins.122 4thly, The rule of judgment will not be the Law, which discovers sins; but the Gospel, which covers them. 5thly, It can hardly be conceived, how such a publication of their sins, should not overwhelm the saints with shame; or in what way it can suit that glorious state of the Church, in which she shall be presented to God, holy, and without blemish, not having spot or wrinkle, or any such thing.123
XXVII. Thus the reasoning on both sides is ingenious and plausible. Yet, as considerations are not wanting to diminish the force of the arguments of each, it appears safest and most consistent with Christian humility and modesty, to defer the determination of this question, till that day which will make all things manifest.
XXVIII. We proposed, in the third place, to speak of the Sentence. In relation to this, three things fall to be considered. First, The examination of the cause. Secondly, The pronouncing of the sentence. Thirdly, Its execution.
XXIX. The examination of the cause will not be difficult or laborious; owing, 1st, To the omniscience of the Judge.124 2dly, To the light of conscience, which will suffer nothing to be hid from men. By these means, “God will bring to light the hidden things of darkness, and will make manifest the counsels of the hearts.”125
XXX. The pronouncing of the sentence is two-fold, including the sentence of absolution, and that of condemnation. The former is mentioned as that which is to be first in order. 1st, To show that the Judge is more inclined to acquit than to condemn. 2dly, To heighten the joy of the elect, who, after having been themselves absolved, will behold the remaining transactions with the greater security and pleasure. 3dly, To sharpen the anguish of the wicked.—Each sentence will contain a public commemoration of the works, whether good or bad, as well as an assignation of the reward or the punishment.
XXXI. The sentence of absolution will be entirely gracious according to the Gospel strictly so called. “The Lord grant unto him that he may find mercy of the Lord in that day.”126 This is manifest, 1st, From the consideration of the works,—which, though stained by numerous blemishes, will receive so high a commendation from the Judge, that the saints themselves will not hear it without being astonished, that God should put so great a value on services which to themselves appeared so very inconsiderable. 2dly, From the consideration of the reward,—which is not founded on any worthiness either of the works or the persons, but on election, the love of the Father, and adoption, which are all gratuitous. 3dly, From the consideration of the connexion betwixt the good works of believers and the reward. Their good works will be mentioned, 1. As proofs of the faith of believers, their union to Christ, their adoption, their friendship with God, and of that holiness without which no man shall see the Lord. 2. As evidences of that activity and earnestness with which, undervaluing the advantages of this world, and despising the pleasures of the flesh, they have sought the kingdom of God and his righteousness. A pursuit so worthy of God, it is not worthy of God to disappoint. 3. As effects of Divine grace, with which, according to a proportion most wisely adjusted, the communication of Divine glory will correspond, when he shall come to crown his own gifts.
XXXII. The sentence of condemnation will be pronounced in conformity to the exact justice of the law. “For as many as have sinned without law, shall also perish without law; and as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law.”127
XXXIII. It is inquired, and not without reason, why no works are mentioned here but those of compassion towards Christ, whilst many thousands of men have never heard any thing of Christ, and never had opportunity of doing offices of kindness to him in his members; to whom, consequently, it seems impossible that either the performance of such works can be ascribed to their honour, or the neglect of them imputed to their shame. To several, both of the ancients and moderns, this difficulty has appeared so great, that they have thought proper to deny that this discourse of Christ contains a delineation of the general judgment. Our opinion is as follows. The express words of the thirty-second verse evince, that the general judgment is here described: “And before him shall be gathered all nations.” The Scripture, besides, mentions only one judgment to be transacted at the last coming of Christ; and that this judgment will be completely universal, we have proved above by incontrovertible evidence. We are no where taught, that one tribunal is to be erected for those to whom the Gospel was preached, and another for those to whom it was not preached. On the same day of the revelation of the righteous judgment of God, a recompence will be rendered to every one according to his works,—to those that have sinned without law, as well as to those that have sinned in the law.128 Yet every thing relative to the general judgment cannot be learned from this single discourse of Christ. Other testimonies of Scripture must be compared with it, and from all of them taken together, we are to collect the whole of that information which the Spirit of God has been pleased to give us regarding this topic. The things noticed by our Lord in this passage are probably specified merely for the sake of example. For who can suppose that in the general judgment nothing is to be inquired into even amongst those to whom the Gospel was preached, except the performance or neglect of offices of charity towards afflicted saints? Christ’s giving so prominent a place to duties and omissions of that sort, appears to take its rise from the forms of instruction which were in use amongst the ancient Hebrews; of which some traces remain in the Chaldee Paraphrase on Ecclesiastes, chap. ix. verse 7th. “It shall come to pass,” said Solomon, by the Spirit of prophecy from the presence of the Lord, “that the Sovereign of the universe will say to each of the righteous before an assembled world; Go thy way, eat with joy thy bread which is reserved for thee, for thy bread that thou gavest to the poor and afflicted who were hungry; and drink with a merry heart thy wine which is reserved for thee in paradise, in place of thy wine that thou didst mingle for the poor and afflicted who were thirsty.” Our Lord delighted, as learned men have proved by a copious induction of instances,—to make use in his discourses of those formularies which the lovers of piety had long before received from the lips of their wise men.129
XXXIV. The Execution will immediately follow the pronouncing of the sentence. “And these shall go away into everlasting punishment, but the righteous into life eternal.”130 According to the order of the words of Christ, the execution of the sentence will begin with the ungodly; the pronouncing, with the godly. As the latter will augment the terror of the wicked, so the former will increase the joy of the righteous. “The righteous shall rejoice, when he seeth the vengeance.”131 Eternity is attributed to each; on the one side, an eternity of punishment; on the other, an eternity of life, which is truly life. The punishment will not only include the punishment of loss, but also of sense; for they shall “depart into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels.”132 The life will consist in the most perfect knowledge, love, and fruition of God, and in the joy arising from these. Both will be eternal; the one, without hope of intermission or abatement; the other, without fear of loss.133
XXXV. The Circumstances to be considered, are those of Place and Time. The Place is generally designated by the air and the clouds.134 And why is the judgment to be transacted there? 1st, That place, being exposed to the view of all, will form a spacious amphitheatre for the display of the Divine magnificence. “Behold, he cometh with clouds, and every eye shall see him.”135 2dly, The clouds are more than once represented as God’s royal throne, and the chariot in which he rides.136 Christ, therefore, when he comes in the clouds, will demonstrate, by that very circumstance, that he is the Lord of glory;137—of which glory there was a prelude at his transfiguration, when “a bright cloud overshadowed him.”138 3dly, The Son of God came in a cloud when he published the law.139 What then more fit and proper than that he should come again in a cloud, when he shall appear to pronounce sentence according to that law?
XXXVI. Not satisfied with this general designation of the place, human curiosity inquires farther, in what region of the earth all mankind are to be assembled for the last judgment, and presumes to point out as the spot chosen for that purpose, the valley of Jehoshaphat, which mount Olivet overhangs, whence our Lord ascended into heaven. The Papists have borrowed this conceit from the Jews, whose account of the matter they have somewhat embellished. The foundation of this opinion is the following prophecy of Joel: “I will also gather all nations, and will bring them down into the valley of Jehoshaphat, and will plead with them there.”140 And again: “Let the heathen be wakened, and come up to the valley of Jehoshaphat; for there will I sit to judge all the heathen round about.”141 To this Christophorus a Castro adds the words of the angels to the disciples: “This same Jesus, which is taken up from you into heaven, shall so come in like manner as ye have seen him go into heaven.”142 But Cornelius a Lapide appeals also to reason, and alleges it is just that Christ should display the majesty of his glory in the same place where he sustained the greatest ignominy, and judge on the very spot where himself was judged.
XXXVII. But none of these arguments is well-founded. To begin with the reasoning of Cornelius;—although it is our duty to attend to the procedure of Divine wisdom, so far as she unveils to us her counsels, in adjusting all things in such a manner that the last correspond to the first, yet it is altogether contrary to that modesty which becomes us to feign for ourselves certain resemblances and correspondences, according to which the works of God are to be conducted. Unless there be sufficient evidence regarding the will of God, it is an instance of temerity on our part, to have recourse to reasons of that sort. But nothing respecting the will of God as to this matter, can be concluded from the passages alleged. The words of the Angels in the Acts refer unquestionably, not to the place, but to the manner, of the coming of Christ.
XXXVIII. The inferences, deduced from the third Chapter of Joel, are also mere conjectures. 1st, It is uncertain whether the valley of Jehoshaphat be a proper name, or an appellative. The latter seems more consonant both to the subject, and to the enigmatic language of prophecy. 2dly, If it is allowed to be a proper name, it still remains uncertain, what part of the world is so called. Many think that this designation is given to the valley in which the enemies of Jehoshaphat perished, where Jehoshaphat himself blessed the Lord, and where he had said; “O our God, wilt thou not judge them?”143 But that valley is called “the valley of Berachah,”144 that is, of Blessing. Nowhere in Scripture, or in the writings of Geographers, is it denominated the valley of Jehoshaphat. It was situated too, it is certain, at a considerable distance from Jerusalem: for it was near the place where the overthrow of the enemies happened, that were assembled at Hazazon-tamar, which is Engedi,145 whither the Israelites went forth through the wilderness of Tekoa,146 which, according to Jerome, is twelve miles distant from Jerusalem; as likewise, after having obtained the victory, and rendered thanks to God, they began their march to return to Jerusalem.147 It is quite incredible then, that this valley is adjacent to Olivet. Others therefore imagine that it is a place betwixt Jerusalem and the mount of Olives, which might be called the valley of Jehoshaphat, either from the sepulchre of that King being situated in it; or from some of his buildings, suppose a triumphal arch, erected there to commemorate his victory. But this last suggestion of those writers is uncertain, and supported by no authority; and the former is utterly false; for Jehoshaphat was buried in the city of David,148 not in any valley without the precincts of Jerusalem. Cornelius a Lapide, besides, has committed a prodigious blunder,149 in maintaining that the valley of Jehoshaphat is the valley of Kidron, and at the same time asserting that it contains Gehenna, or the valley of the sons of Hinnom. The valley of Kidron, it is clear, was on the east of Jerusalem, betwixt the temple and Olivet; whilst the valley of the sons of Hinnom lay on the south.150 3dly, Wherever the valley of Jehoshaphat may be situated, and whatever may be the extent of the valley so called, it cannot be sufficient for the many thousands of myriads of mankind, that are to be summoned to judgment. As to the conjectures of Cornelius, that by means of levelling the places adjacent, that valley may be extended far and wide;—and then that the reprobate only are to be gathered together on the earth, and the saints to be assembled not on the earth, but in a more elevated region and nearer the Judge, to wit, in the air; where they are to sit together as in an aerial scaffold, some higher and others lower according to their merits,—these are the dreams of men disordered by a fever, or the ravings of madmen, not the discoveries of the Gospel.
XXXIX. But what is of the greatest weight, the passage in Joel referred to, doth not relate to the last judgment. To omit other arguments, the truth of this assertion is evident from the consideration, that the judgment spoken of by the Prophet, is succeeded by a description, which begins at the seventeenth verse, of the glorious state of the Church on earth. What then? This prophecy contains an account of some signal display of the Divine vengeance on the enemies of the New Testament Church, not unlike that which happened in the time of Jehoshaphat; for there is an allusion to that history, which may be thus explained. The Moabites, the Ammonites, and the children of mount Seir, undertook an expedition against Judea in the reign of Jehoshaphat, and came to the valley of Blessing, where, at the singing of the Israelites, as if struck with a kind of supernatural rage, they rushed against each other with mutual violence, and wounded and destroyed one another, so as clearly to manifest that Jehovah is the Judge, and the avenger of his people. God, in his adorable providence, is, in like manner, so to govern the affairs of the world, that nations which are in the vicinity of the Church, and somewhat connected with her in several respects, may take counsel against the Church which is separated from their communion, invade her boundaries, and reduce her to such extremities, that, like Jehoshaphat when he knew not what to do, the Church may confess she is unable to cope with so vast a multitude of enemies. In this juncture, however, God will suddenly defeat the counsel and frustrate the efforts of the nations, and set them at variance with each other, that they may mutually attack one another, and thus exhaust their strength. By this means he will demonstrate that he is Judge in the quarrel into which they wantonly entered with the Church, and which he will decide in her favour, that she may celebrate his praises in joyful songs.151
XL. With respect to the Time of the judgment, the following things are to be observed. 1st, God has determined a certain day;152 namely, the last day of the world, the day in which the resurrection of the dead and the consummation of all things will take place.153 2dly, It is unknown to men, and should not be inquired into. Christ has prohibited inquiries respecting it.154 Paul did not deem it necessary to write of it.155 It is not known even to the Angels in heaven; nor was it known to Christ himself, according to the human nature, in the state of humiliation.156 It has pleased God to conceal from us the day of judgment, that we might be always employed in devout and conscientious preparation for it.157
XLI. 3dly, The Apostles sometimes speak of the last day as if, even in their own time, it were already near at hand.158 Nay, in some passages the Apostle Paul seems to class himself amongst them whom that day shall find alive.159 Those expressions, however, are not to be understood, according to the comments of Grotius, as if the Apostles imagined the day of the last judgment was so near, that it would come whilst themselves were living. This interpretation is inconsistent with the infallibility of the sacred writings, which the Apostles did not compose at random, from their own conjectures; but with absolute certainty, under inspiration of the Holy Spirit. The Apostles, besides, delivered many predictions which they knew could not be accomplished within the space of their own life. They spoke also of their own death, and of events that were to happen after it.160 Paul, too, gave explicit notice, that the day of the Lord was not so very near, and that his words were not to be understood in that sense;161 although in his expressions he might sometimes personate those who shall be found alive in that day, and “in a figure transfer to himself,”162 the events which are to happen to them. See another instance of the same figure in 1 Pet. iv. 3. The Apostles’ speaking of the day of the Lord as so near, if it ought not sometimes to be explained as referring to the judgment of God on the rebellious nation of the Jews, seems to be owing to this; that in the Divine estimation, and when time is compared with eternity, “a thousand years are as one day.”163164
XLII. 4thly, Christ has announced in Scripture certain signs of the times; and given notice of certain remarkable changes in the Church, which are either more remotely or more immediately, to precede his last coming. Such are, 1. The exhibition of Antichrist in his rise, progress, and destruction. 2. The happy restoration of the nation of Israel. 3. A conversion of nations and kindreds perhaps more extensive and signal than any that has hitherto been seen. 4. The holy and glorious condition of the whole Church on earth. But these and other such signs, we must not now stop to illustrate particularly.
XLIII. Let us proceed to the improvement. And, in the first place, the consideration of this article is useful to awaken men from their security, and to generate in their minds a salutary dread; that, trembling at the thought of so splendid and awful a day, they may turn with the whole heart unto God. Hear, and ponder these truths, ye secure sinners who have been hitherto asleep in your crimes, and caring only for the body, have emulated the profane manners of those Israelites, of whom we read in the book of Amos.165 The day will certainly come at last, in which your laughter shall be turned into mourning.166 Hear, ye profane mockers.167 Hear, ye carnal men, who refer these concerns to a distant season.168 Hear, ye unrighteous oppressors of the faithful.169 Hear, ye unprincipled hypocrites.170 Hear, ye slanderers of the brethren.171 Hear, ye unjust stewards.172 Hear, all ye, whoever you are, that have hitherto been disobedient to the Gospel.173 Hear, in fine, all ye wicked men, who have not made it your care to regulate your life according to the will of God. The day will at length come, in which you shall be obliged to render an account to God of all that you have done, and spoken, and thought. The Judge will be omniscient, the judgment exact, the condemnation terrible, the execution prompt. Be alarmed, therefore, be greatly afraid, tremble for fear.
XLIV. But as this day of judgment is dreadful to the ungodly, so to the godly it is no less desirable, and most devoutly to be wished. Here oppressed innocence sometimes languishes under the calumny of the wicked, but there it shall be brought forth into light.174 There they shall see the wicked that once lived in luxury, now delivered up to a just destruction, and shall rejoice in the judgments of the Lord;175 but to them it will be a day of consummate felicity. The mouth of their accusers shall be stopped.176 The Judge is their Friend, and Advocate, and Bridegroom; who was himself unjustly condemned in their stead, that they might never be justly condemned. Their sentence will be at once gracious and glorious in the highest degree. Come, let no fear, no consciousness of your sins, deter you; draw near with boldness:—Ye blessed of my Father, ye dear children of God, given to me by the Father, redeemed with my blood, and long ago enriched and adorned with numerous gifts of the Divine beneficence.—Inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world: Rise from that low state of servitude to glorious liberty; and as the partners of my kingdom, not merely enjoy its blessings, but sit together with me on the throne, encircled with a crown of never-fading glory. Let the world see what solid joy I have prepared for you; let them see, and pine away because they have lost it. Possess now that full and perfect happiness competent to human nature, which your enemies have so often exerted themselves to prevent, and your own expectation of which was once shaken within you by the incursions of so many doubts. See with what solicitude I have preserved it for you, in spite of your unbelief and of your weakness. Now let all your tears be wiped away, let all your sorrows be forgotten.—Enter ye into the joy of your Lord, a joy never again to be impaired by any mixture of grief. O delightful sentence, the mere anticipation of which by faith, produces “joy unspeakable.”177
XLV. The prospect of this day ought, in fine, to excite us to an assiduous cultivation of piety, and a careful attention to every part of our conduct. “The day of the Lord will come as a thief in the night, in the which the heavens shall pass away with a great noise, and the elements shall melt with fervent heat; the earth also, and the works that are therein, shall be burnt up. Seeing then that all these things shall be dissolved, What manner of persons ought ye to be in all holy conversation and godliness, looking for and hasting unto the coming of the day of God!”178 O were it continually present to our minds, that an account of all our actions must one day be rendered to God, with what solicitude should we guard against sin! With what diligence should we perform that which we shall at last wish we had done! With what conscientious care should we daily adjust our accounts, lest that day surprise us unprepared! “Watch therefore, for ye know neither the day, nor the hour, wherein the Son of man cometh.”179
Notes
Note XLVI. Page 275.
In applying Heb. xii. 26. to the manifestation of the glory of Christ at his second coming, unless a mere accommodation of the expressions be intended, our Author appears to depart in some degree from his accustomed accuracy. That passage is no doubt quoted from Hag. ii. 6, 7. a prophecy which indisputably relates to the appearance of the Messiah, “the Desire of all nations,” in the fulness of time, and to the wonderful changes effected amongst Jews and Gentiles by the introduction of the Christian economy. The Apostle has immediately in his eye the abolition of the ceremonial law, and the establishment of New Testament ordinances in its room. The shaking of heaven and earth is a metaphorical expression often made use of in Scripture, to denote the subversion of existing authorities and states, as in Is. xiii. 13. and Joel ii. 10. See Calvin, Owen, and Macknight, on Heb. xii. 26. Witsius himself elsewhere more correctly cites this passage with reference to the removal of the Mosaic ritual, and the establishment of the more durable institutions of the Gospel.180
Note XLVII. Page 276.
Theologians are divided in sentiment, with regard to the proper application of the term Archangel, 1 Thes. iv. 16. That there are various classes of angels, differing from each other in power and dignity, is generally agreed; and it is not uncommon to suppose, that the Apostle here intends some created angel of exalted rank. This appears to have been the opinion of Calvin.181 Alphonsus Turretine remarks, that when the Lord shall descend from heaven, “he will make use of the ministry of angels, nay, the chief among angels, who are called archangels, as Michael and Gabriel: For, though we know not particularly what relates to the orders of angels, it cannot be questioned, that some of them are superior to others, and are hence in the Scriptures denominated archangels.”182 Witsius thought, on the contrary, that the Scripture speaks only of one Archangel, and that this is Christ himself, the Lord of all. The same opinion was held by Cloppenburgh, Vogelsangius, Pierce, and others, of former times; and of late, it has been strenuously supported by Bishop Horsley. The Bishop agrees with our Author, too, in thinking, that the Michael we read of in Daniel, Jude, and Revelation, is no other than the Son of God. If the learned reader is disposed to investigate this point, he may consult Horsley’s Sermons, and the Exercitatio De Michaele by Witsius.183 At the close of that Dissertation, it is stated by the Author, that some writers apprehend the name Michael to be given to our Saviour in Rev. xii. but to a created angel in Dan. x. and Jude 9. With his usual candour, he adds, that while he himself believes Christ to be intended wherever we read of Michael, he was not inclined to urge his opinion with great pertinacity or confidence, since the arguments adduced on the opposite side are not destitute of force. “On such questions,” he says in conclusion, “I am much better pleased with the modesty of a dubious mind, than with a rash disposition to form a peremptory judgment.”184
Note XLVIII. Page 283.
Our Author denies more decidedly than might have been expected, that 1 Cor. vi. 2, 3. as well as Mat. xix. 28. has any reference to the transactions of the last day. Whitby and Macknight agree with him in combating the doctrine, that the saints will be assessors with Christ in the judgment; but they differ from each other in their manner of interpreting 1 Cor. vi. 2, 3. The former adopts a sense somewhat similar to the one proposed by our Author; and with regard to judging angels, he affirms, that “all the Greek scholiasts say, that this the Christians did gloriously, by expelling evil angels from their seats and their dominions, and forcing them to confess before their votaries, they were only devils.” The views of the latter are briefly expressed in his Paraphrase thus.
“Verse 2. Do ye not know that the inspired teachers among you judge the world, by the laws of the Gospel, which they promulgate? And if the world is thus judged by you, are you, who are so well enlightened, unworthy to fill the least seats of judicature? Verse 3. Do ye not know that we declare the judgment of evil angels, whereby we are strongly impressed with a sense of the justice of God?”——
This learned expositor, however, notwithstanding what he says in his Note 2. on verse 2d, where he refers to Col. i. 26. cannot be justified in limiting the sense of the term saints to inspired teachers. “Know ye not,” says Paul, “that we shall judge angels?—obviously including true Christians at large, as well as men that were endowed with inspiration. And to translate the word κρινουσι in the 2d, and κρινουμεν in the 3d verse, which are both confessedly in the future tense, as if they were in the present, was to take a most unwarrantable liberty. The passage is indeed somewhat obscure; but, beyond question, it must relate to some judgment posterior to the date of that Epistle; and, on the whole, it seems most natural to refer it to the saints’ judging the world and judging evil angels, in the day of final retribution. In this view it is understood by an host of able and judicious interpreters, including Calvin, Beza, Hammond, Guyse, and Doddridge. Most of these writers do not hesitate to speak of the saints as assessors with Christ at the judgment. The saints, it is true, are to stand before his tribunal, and receive their sentence from him. But, although they are themselves to be judged, it is not impossible for them, after having received a blessed sentence of acquittal, to appear as assessors with Christ; not indeed to give him counsel, but to concur with him in the judicial sentence he shall pronounce on devils and ungodly men—or, in other words, to express their assent to that sentence.
“Why should their assent be necessary,” asks Macknight, “more than the assent of holy angels?” The assent neither of the one nor the other, we reply, is strictly necessary. The rectitude, and validity, of the sentence, are quite independent of the plaudits of men, or of angels. But if the Scriptures do teach us, though merely in one or two passages, that the saints shall thus judge the world, it becomes us to believe it, without reasoning on the subject. Whether the holy angels are expressly to give their assent, we are not informed. But can we forget, that the Son of God assumed the human, not the angelical nature; that in the day of judgment he will gloriously appear in the same nature in which he expired on Calvary; and that, in consequence, certain peculiar honours are allotted to redeemed men, in which elect angels have no share? Is it not also particularly fit and proper, that the saints, in that day of victory and triumph, should solemnly express their acquiescence in a sentence which will not only display the majesty and justice of the Judge, but secure their own complete and final deliverance from a combination of numerous and powerful enemies, by whom they had been long and dreadfully annoyed?—See Horne on Psalm cxlix. 6–9.
Witsius himself, while he understands the expressions quoted from 1 Cor. vi. and Mat. xix. as relating to other topics, candidly allows, that the saints will be assessors with Christ in a certain improper sense of the term, and that they will judge and condemn the wicked, not merely by the example of their virtues, but also “by their approbation of Christ’s sentence.”
On Mat. xix. 28. let it suffice to refer to Doddridge’s Paraphrase and Note.185
Note XLIX. Page 291.
The view taken by Witsius of that representation of the general judgment which we have in Mat. xxv. seems, in general, correct. It may be questioned, however, whether the reason he assigns for the prominent place given in that Chapter to the offices of Christian charity, be the cause to which it ought to be ascribed. Even admitting that it was in accordance with our Lord’s practice to avail himself in his discourses of those forms of instruction, which had anciently been prepared by devout and intelligent, though uninspired, teachers, and which were commonly made use of in the Jewish Church; and supposing that he had paid particular attention to the Chaldee Paraphrase;—the real importance he attached to the performance or neglect of the labours of love towards his necessitous and afflicted brethren for his name’s sake, seems a far more probable cause of the prominence he assigns to those labours, than a readiness to assimilate his instructions to what was useful in the Jewish formularies.
The venerable Author, who had attained great proficiency in Jewish and Oriental literature, was perhaps immoderately attached to the idea, that Christ discovered his prudent condescension in conforming his manner of teaching to the modes generally adopted by the wise men among the Jews. His fondness for this notion appears not only here, but also in other parts of his works. He defends it, for instance, at some length, in his Dissertations on the Lord’s Prayer.186 He there states it as his conviction, that the phrases, and almost all the petitions of that Prayer, are derived from the approved forms of the Hebrews. It is exceedingly improbable, he imagines, that so striking a similarity of expressions and petitions as has been pointed out by Drusius, Lightfoot, and others, could ever have happened by accident. Either the modern Jewish Doctors must have borrowed them from the Gospel, or our Saviour must have taken them from the authorised formularies of his time. The former supposition he deems quite unlikely. “It seems more probable,” says he, “that Christ, willing to accommodate himself to the taste and customs of the people, in so far as this could be done in consistency with the dictates of wisdom and piety, applied to his own purpose whatever valuable sentiments and proper expressions he found among them, as precious remains of ancient faith and hope. This he did, that he might not seem unduly fond of innovation, and that the instructions he delivered might be the more readily understood and embraced, when it was seen that he presented a collection of the choicest jewels that yet remained in the treasury of the Jewish Church.” The keen opposition this notion has met with from Dr John Owen,187 is next adverted to; but our Author states, “with all becoming deference to so distinguished a Theologian,” that Owen’s arguments are far from shaking his opinion. “Nor does this observation,” he adds, “derogate in the least from the excellence of our Lord’s Prayer. It was not proper that it should commend itself by the charm of novelty, but by the excellence of its matter, the fulness of its petitions, the exactness of its arrangement, and the conciseness of its diction. And indeed in all these respects it is so admirably superior, that nothing equal or similar can any where be found.”
Note L. Page 292.
Our Author affirms, without scruple, that the punishment of the wicked will be eternal. On this, as well as on every other point, to which Divine revelation relates, we ought to guard against the influence of our own reasonings and feelings, and humbly to acquiesce in the testimony of “God, who cannot lie.” “If any person inclines,” says the profound and amiable M‘Laurin, “to doubt of the eternity of future punishment unless he saw it, that person seeks such a way of being satisfied about it as the nature of the thing does not admit: For, though a man saw the place of punishment with his eyes, he could not see that it is eternal, unless he saw the end of eternity, which is impossible; so that a man can never have evidence of this by sight, if he refuse to give faith to God’s word, which is surely the best evidence in the world.”188
Notwithstanding the many bold attempts which have been made to impair the energy, and pervert the sense, of those passages of Scripture that relate to this awfully interesting topic, it will be difficult, by the most imposing arts of criticism, to persuade any considerate and candid reader, that the Bible does not clearly and fully teach the eternity of the torments of hell. What can be more unequivocal, than the verses quoted by our Author from the 25th chapter of Matthew? In that passage, the Saviour and Judge himself represents the sentence passed on the wicked as consigning them to “everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels;” and he concludes the account of the judgment thus: “And these shall go away into everlasting punishment; but the righteous into life eternal.”189 In these words, the future state of the wicked, and that of the righteous, are directly contrasted with each other in respect to continuance; and we are expressly taught that the duration of both is of the same extent. In the original language, as many writers have remarked, it is precisely the same term that is employed in the first part of the sentence with regard to the one, and in the second part with regard to the other. To deny, therefore, that the misery of the wicked is of the same endless duration with the blessedness of the righteous, is in reality, however undesignedly, to cast the most odious reflexions upon the great Prophet of the Church. On that supposition, Christ must either have wonderfully misunderstood, or deliberately misrepresented, the matter. But can we dare to impute either error or deceit to Him who possesses “all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge,” and is “the Amen, the faithful and true Witness?” Is it possible or credible, that he who is Truth itself, and whose whole speech and conduct were characterised by the most guileless sincerity, would ever, and even when illustrating a subject of incalculable moment to mankind, have allowed himself to employ the same word in one sentence, in two senses so widely different from each other, as first to denote a limited period, and then an endless duration, without giving the most distant hint that the expression was to be thus variously understood?
It would be easy to adduce a great number of other passages of Scripture, equally explicit and decisive. This doctrine, too, it might be shown, is intimately connected with many other branches of the Christian system. What is taught us, for instance, in sacred writ, respecting the malignity and demerit of sin, the purity, justice and veracity of God, and in particular the Deity and atonement of Christ, serves mightily to confirm the eternity of future punishment. Those who set aside the perpetuity of the miseries of hell, have accordingly proceeded, in general, to question, and sometimes to revile with the utmost virulence, the proper divinity and the atoning sacrifice of our blessed Redeemer. “Eternal punishment,” says an adventurous writer, “may trouble old women; but a bloody atonement and eternal punishment correspond not with the exalted ideas we ought to entertain of God.”190—But the reader who wishes to examine this subject minutely, and to see satisfactory replies to the various objections which have been urged against the eternity of future punishment, may consult Pearson,191 M‘Laurin,192 Dr Watts,193 Dwight,194 and especially Lampe,195 and Edwards.196
The Creed, as we now have it, contains no explicit notice of the endless misery of the wicked. But the article respecting the general judgment was more largely expressed in some ancient copies. In Tertullian’s Creed, for example, it is affirmed, that Christ “shall come in splendour to receive the saints into the fruition of eternal life and the heavenly promises, and to adjudge the profane to everlasting fire.”197 In the Athanasian Creed, too, it is expressly said: “They that have done good shall go into life everlasting; and they that have done evil into everlasting fire.” The opposers of this doctrine have appealed to antiquity, and have attempted in particular to shelter themselves under the authority of Origen. But that celebrated Father, though a man of extraordinary learning and diligence, was, in many instances, betrayed by his predilection for the Platonic philosophy, and embraced a variety of unscriptural tenets. Lampe, and others, have clearly shown, that the eternity of future punishment was taught by Clement of Rome, Irenæus, Polycarp, and almost all the Fathers both before and after the age of Origen.
Suffice it only to add, that, if the everlasting misery of the unbelieving and impenitent forms a part of the counsel of God, it should not be suppressed by the teachers of the Christian religion. The subject indeed is tremendous, and ought always to be approached with much reverence, solemnity, and affection. But utterly to keep back, or very rarely and slightly to notice a topic, so plainly revealed, so frequently brought forward by Jesus and his Apostles, and so powerfully calculated to inspire every mind with a salutary dread of sin, to rouse the sinner from a state of dangerous security and recommend the Saviour to his acceptance, and to inflame the heart of the Christian with fervent gratitude to Him who, at the expense of his own blood, “delivered us from the wrath to come,”—seems quite incompatible with every just idea of ministerial fidelity.
Note LI. Page 297.
Witsius, with great propriety, endeavours to repress that presumptuous and vain curiosity, by which men are prompted to determine the circumstances of the last judgment, more particularly than the Scriptures warrant. With regard to the Place of judgment, it should suffice us to know, as he observes, that “it is designated by the air and the clouds.” Many grave and judicious Theologians have considered themselves authorised to conclude, that, whilst the righteous are assembled in the air, the ungodly will remain upon the earth. “The elect,” says Boston, “being caught up together in the clouds, meet the Lord in the air (1 Thes. iv. 17.) and so are set on his right hand; and the reprobate left on the earth (Mat. xxv. 40.) upon the Judge’s left hand.”198 “All wicked men and devils,” President Edwards observes, “shall be brought before the judgment-seat of Christ. These shall be gathered to the left hand of Christ, and, as it seems, will still remain upon the earth, and shall not be caught up into the air, as the saints shall be.”199 But whatever probability may attach to this opinion, Witsius justly condemns the fancies detailed by Cornelius a Lapide respecting the valley of Jehoshaphat as the place of judgment, the extending of that valley, &c. The view which our Author presents of the scope and connexion of the 3d Chapter of Joel, appears to be right. Very probably, indeed, it relates, in the first instance, to certain remarkable deliverances wrought for the ancient Church, as those which took place at the destruction of Sennacherib’s army, and the overthrow of Antiochus. But the connexion seems to justify the conclusion, that this prophecy refers ultimately to “some signal display of the Divine vengeance on the enemies of the New Testament Church, not unlike that which happened in the time of Jehoshaphat.”
Several observations regarding the valley of Jehoshaphat, similar to those of our Author, may be seen in Dr Wells’ Geography of the Old and New Testament.200
Note LII. Page 298.
Our Author very laudably exposes the notion of Grotius, which has been adopted by Whiston and others, that the Apostles in reality apprehended, that the day of the last judgment was to arrive in their own age. Independently of other considerations, it is truly strange, that men of learning should have hazarded this opinion, after the Apostle Paul’s explanation in 2 Thessal. ii. From this passage indeed it is not unreasonable to infer, that some Christians at Thessalonica had rashly considered several expressions in his First Epistle to them, as intended to excite or encourage an expectation of the second coming of Christ before the conclusion of the apostolic age. But Paul shows them plainly, that they had completely mistaken his meaning, and that after a very considerable lapse of time, a grand apostacy was to happen in the Church, prior to the glorious appearing of the Son of man. He reminds them, too, that, when he was yet with them, he had given them intimations relative to that “falling away,” the careful recollection of which would have served to obviate the misapprehensions they had latterly entertained. On this subject, see Hammond,201 Doddridge,202 and particularly Whitby.203
Debita sceleri noxia pœna:\
At perversi resident celso\
Mores solio; sanctaque calcant\
Injusta vice colla nocenteis.\
Latet obscuris condita virtus\
Clara tenebris; justusque tulit\
Crimen iniqui.
1 Heb. vi. 2.
2 Gen. iii. 8, &c.
3 Gen. vi. 3.
4 Gen. xi. 5, 6, 7.
5 2 Tim. iv. i.
6 Eccles. ix. 2.
7 Ps. lxxiii. 3.
8 —— Premit insonteis\
9 Mal. iii. 16–18.
10 Rom. ii. 15. 1 John iii. 20.
11 Eccles. xi. 9.
12 Eccles. xii. 14.
13 Rom. ii. 5.
14 Heb. xii. 23.
15 James iv. 12.
16 Rom. ii. 6.
17 Ch. xvi. 5.
18 Is. xxxiii. 22.
19 אשר לו המשפט Ch. xxi. 27.
20 Chap. v. 1.
21 Ps. lxxii. 1.
22 למלכא משיחא בריה דדויד מלכא.
23 See Acts xvii. 31. Rom. ii. 16. 2 Cor. v. 10. 2 Tim. iv. 1.
24 John v. 22.
25 John viii. 15.
26 Verse 50.
27 John v. 43.
28 Verse 19.
29 Acts xvii. 31.
30 Rom. ii. 16.
31 2 Cor. iii. 9.
32 John iii. 17.
33 John viii. 16.
34 Verse 28.
35 John v. 27.
36 Rev. xix. 11.
37 Mat. xxvi. 64.
38 Serm. lxiv. de Verb. Dom.
39 Rev. i. 7.
40 Lib. i. de Trinit. cap. 13.
41 Is. xlv. 23.
42 Rom. xiv. 10, 11.
43 Ubi supra.
44 Exod. xix. Deut. xxxiii. 2.
45 Heb. xii. 26.
46 See Note XLVI.
47 Mat. xxv. 31.
48 Mat. xvi. 27. Mark viii. 38.
49 Δὸξα ἀυτου και τοῦ Πατρὸς, Luke ix. 26.
50 1 Pet. v. 1.
51 Mat. xxvi. 64.
52 Mat. xxiv. 30.
53 Ἐν κελεύσματι, 1 Thes. iv. 16.
54 מלאך האדון Mal. iii. 1.
55 Col. ii. 10.
56 Col. i. 16.
57 Heb. i. 6.
58 1 Pet. iii. 22.
59 See Note XLVII.
60 John v. 28.
61 Mat. xxiv. 31. 1 Cor. xv. 52.
62 Exod. xix. 16.
63 Josh. vi. 5.
64 Exod. xix. 16. John xii. 29.
65 Mat. xxv. 6.
66 Num. x. 1, 2.
67 Lev. xxiii. 24. Num. x. 10.
68 Jude ver. 14.
69 2 Thes. i. 7.
70 Mat. xxv. 31.
71 Luke ix. 26.
72 Mat. xxiv. 31.
73 Mark xiii. 27.
74 2 Thes. ii. 1.
75 Mat. xiii. 49.
76 Mat. xiii. 41, 42.
77 1 Thes. iv. 17.
78 Luke xvi. 22.
79 1 Cor. vi. 2, 3.
80 Comp. Ephes. ii. 6. Rev. ii. 26, 27.
81 Rev. xix. 1, 2.
82 Mat. xii. 41, 42.
83 Heb. xi. 7.
84 Dan. vii. 26, 27.
85 Rev. xii. 10, 11.
86 Mark ix. 29. xvi. 17.
87 See Dissert. xi. sect. 36. T.
88 Mat. xix. 28.
89 Is. lxv. 17.
90 2 Cor. v. 17.
91 The noun מדינה (Medinah) is derived from the verb דון (dun) to judge, and is often employed to signify a government or province, as in Est. iv. 3. 1 Kings xx. 14. T.
92 Chap. xxii. 30.
93 Comp. Rev. iv. 4.
94 Vat. Lib. ii. cap. 5.
95 Dissert. iii. quæ est de omnibus Evangelii periochis. cap. 2.
96 Comp. John xii. 48. Rom. ii. 16.
97 See Note XLVIII.
98 2 Pet. ii. 4. Jude 6.
99 James ii. 19.
100 Mat. viii. 29.
101 Rev. xx. 10.
102 2 Cor. v. 10. See also Jude 14. Rom. xiv. 10–12.
103 Gen. xviii. 25.
104 Acts xvii. 31.
105 Eccles. iii. 17.
106 Rev. xx. 12.
107 Acts x. 42. 2 Tim. 4, 1.
108 Eccles. xii. 14.
109 Rom. ii. 6. 2 Cor. v. 10. Rev. xx. 12, 13.
110 Mat. xii. 37.
111 Verse 36.
112 Jude 15.
113 1 Sam. ii. 3.
114 Dan. vii. 25. xi. 36.
115 Ps. xii. 3–5.
116 Eccles. xii. 14. Rom. ii. 16. 1 Cor. iv. 5.
117 Is. xliii. 25. Jer. xxxi. 34.
118 Is. xxxviii. 17.
119 Mic. vii. 19.
120 Ἱλαστήριον, Rom. iii. 25, which corresponds to the Hebrew word כפורת a covering.
121 1 John ii. 1.
122 Prov. x. 12.
123 Ephes. v. 27.
124 Mal. iii. 5. John ii. 25. Heb. iv. 13.
125 1 Cor. iv. 5.
126 2 Tim. i. 18.
127 Rom. ii. 12.
128 Rom. ii. 5, 6, 12.
129 See Note XLIX.
130 Mat. xxv. 46.
131 Ps. lviii. 10.
132 Mat. xxv. 41. Comp. Rev. xiv. 11. xx. 10.
133 See Note L.
134 1 Thes. iv. 16, 17. Mat. xxiv. 30.
135 Rev. i. 7.
136 Ps. civ. 3.
137 Mat. xxvi. 64.
138 Mat. xvii. 5.
139 Exod. xix. 9.
140 Ch. iii. 2.
141 Verse 12.
142 Acts i. 11.
143 2 Chron. xx. 12.
144 Verse 26.
145 Verse 2.
146 Verse 20.
147 Verse 27.
148 2 Chron. xxi. 1.
149 Error Tartessia muræna grandior.
150 Josh. xv. 8.
151 See Note LI.
152 Acts xvii. 31. Rom. ii. 5.
153 1 Cor. xv. 23, 24. 2 Pet. iii. 10, 12.
154 Acts i. 7.
155 1 Thes. v. 1.
156 Mat. xxiv. 36.
157 Mat. xxiv. 42.
158 1 Cor. x. 11. Philip. iv. 5. James v. 8, 9. 1 Pet. iv. 5. 1 John ii. 18.
159 1 Cor. xv. 52. 1 Thes. iv. 15.
160 Acts xx. 24. 2 Tim. iv. 6. 2 Pet. i. 14.
161 2 Thes. ii. 2.
162 1 Cor. iv. 6.
163 2 Pet. iii. 8.
164 See Note LII.
165 Chap. vi.
166 James v. 1–5.
167 2 Pet. iii. 4–10.
168 1 Thes. v. 3.
169 Mat. xxiv. 48–51.
170 Rom. ii. 16.
171 Ps. l. 20, 21.
172 Luke xvi. 2.
173 2 Thes. i. 8. Heb. ii. 2, 3.
174 Mic. vii. 9, 10.
175 Ps. lviii. 10, 11. Rev. xvi. 5, 6, 7.
176 Rom. viii. 33, 34.
177 1 Pet. i. 8.
178 2 Pet. iii. 10, 11, 12.
179 Mat. xxv. 13.
180 Diss. xix. sect. 22.
181 Comment. in loc.
182 Comment. in Epist. ad Thess. p. 111.
183 Miscel. Sacra, Tom. ii. Exer. 4.
184 In talibus quæstionibus magis mihi placet hæsitantis ingenii modestia, quam inconsiderata determinandi pervicacia.
185 Family Expos. Vol. ii. Sect. 137. Note i.
186 Exercit. in Orationem Dominicum, Ex. vi. sect. 32–39.
187 Theolog. Lib. v. Digress. 1.
188 Sermons and Essays, Ser. I. p. 84. 2d edit.
189 Και ἀπελευσονται ὁυτοι ἐις κολασιν ἀιωνιον· ὁι δε δικαιοι ἐις ζωην ἀιωνιον, v. 46.
190 These are the expressions of Nicolai in his life of Nothanker, 2d part, p. 6, as quoted by Dr Erskine in his Sketches of Church History, Vol. i. p. 73.
191 Expos. of the Creed, Art. 12. pp. 390–394.
192 Sermons and Essays, pp. 163–179.
193 The World to come, Disc. 13.
194 Theology, Vol. ii. Ser. 167.
195 “Theological Dissertation concerning the endless duration of Punishment,” translated from the Latin, and printed at Edinburgh, 1796.
196 Remarks on important Theological Controversies, Ch. ii.
197 Lord King’s Critical Hist. chap. v. p. 313.
198 Human Nature in its Fourfold State, State iv. Head 4.
199 Hist. of Redemption, Period iii. Part 2. sect. 2.
200 Vol. ii. ch. 2. No. 19.
201 Paraph. and Annot. 2 Thes. ii. Note c.
202 Family Expos. 1 Thes. iv. 15. Note e.
203 Paraph. and Annot. Notes on 1 Thes. iv. 15, and 2 Cor. v. 1, 9. Also “a Discourse by way of inquiry, whether the Apostles in their writings spoke as conceiving the day of judgment might be in their days, and accordingly suited their phrases and exhortations.”—In this discourse, Whitby adverts to Whiston’s erroneous statements on this point in his Essay on the Revelation of John, and demonstrates the futility of that writer’s arguments.