Sacred Dissertations on What Is Commonly Called the Apostles’ Creed (1823), Herman Witsius · PDF

Dissertation XXIII. On the Holy Ghost

I. The Holy Spirit of God is the Author of all human wisdom,1 and in particular, of that spiritual and saving knowledge, which makes us Christians;2 since we stand indebted to him both for the Scriptures, from which we know all things,3 and for the opening of the eyes of the mind, by which we know them.4 It would, therefore, be more than impious not rightly to know, and not devoutly to recognise the Spirit himself. He cannot be seen, however, but in his own light; he cannot be known or acknowledged, but by his own kind and gracious agency. It seems proper, then, to begin our present Dissertation with the same prayer with which Cyprian (or whoever is the Author of that Discourse) commences his Discourse on the Holy Spirit.

“Come, Holy Spirit, and descend from heaven upon us, who are looking up for thy benign influence. Sanctify the temple of our body, and consecrate it for a habitation to thyself; gladden, by thy presence, the souls that are longing for thee. Prepare a suitable abode for thyself; adorn thy chamber, and surround the place of thy rest with a sweet variety of virtues. Strew thy pavements with fair colours; let thy residence be beautified with sparkling carbuncles, and splendid jewels; and let the perfumes of all thy graces diffuse their savour within. Let the juice of balsam richly imbue thy apartment with its fragrance. Avert from it whatever is corrupt, whatever tends to waste or to defile; render this our joy stable and permanent; and let thy new creation be confirmed for ever in unfading beauty.”

II. It will be proper here to make some preliminary remarks, and then to prove distinctly several points. The preliminary remarks relate to three questions. First, In how many acceptations, with regard to Divine matters, the word Spirit occurs? Secondly, Why the third person is peculiarly called the Spirit? Thirdly, Why the epithet Holy is particularly attributed to him?

III. The term Spirit, when used with respect to God, is taken either essentially, or personally, or metonymically. It is taken essentially, when it is ascribed to God, in reference to the essence common to all the persons;5—personally, when it is attributed to some one person, whether the second,6 or the third;7—metonymically, when it denotes certain effects or gifts, as in John vii. 39. where “the spirit” signifies those gifts, the effusion of which had been predicted by Joel and other Prophets. Thus also the Jews are accustomed to say, that there was no Holy Spirit under the second temple. In the same sense I would understand that expression of the disciples of John; “We have not so much as heard whether there be any Holy Ghost.”8

IV. When the third Person is peculiarly denominated the Spirit, he is not so called in reference to that which is common to him with the Father and the Son, to wit, a most simple essence, intelligent, and exempt from all corporeal imperfection; but, 1st, On account of the mode of his procession. The term Spirit9 properly signifies a gale of wind;10 and the procession of the Holy Ghost, which to us is ineffable and incomprehensible, is compared to a breathing. He is styled “the breath of God’s mouth,”11 and “the breath of the Almighty.”12 To this corresponds the symbol which Christ employed, when “he breathed on the disciples, and said to them, Receive ye the Holy Ghost.”13 2dly, On account of his operations. Operations are ascribed to him, similar to those which are proper to wind, and air; as to move, to quicken, to refresh;14 and to cause us also to become spirit.1516

V. The epithet Holy is not particularly given to the third Person, to the exclusion of the other Persons; for it is expressly attributed to the Father,17 and to the Son.18 Nor doth he receive this designation even by way of eminence in any degree, as if the Spirit were more holy than the other persons; for it is equally ascribed to all of them;19 and the Divine holiness, being infinite, admits not of degrees of comparison. But the reason is, that, according to the economy of the Divine operations, the Sanctification of believers is usually attributed to the Spirit.20 Even this must not, however, be understood as if we are not sanctified both by the Father and the Son. Sanctification is in general, the work of God;21 and in particular, of the Father,22 and of the Son.23 But such is the order of the operations of God, that although they are effected by the common counsel of the same will, and by the same energy of the same power, yet some of them are appropriated to each person respectively. And those operations which result from the merit of the Son, as our Regeneration and Sanctification, are particularly attributed to the Holy Spirit, who is the Spirit of the Son, and the third Person in the Godhead.

VI. These observations being premised, there are three positions regarding the Holy Ghost, which must be distinctly proved. First, That he is a Person. Secondly,—A Divine person. Thirdly,—A Divine person, distinct from the Father and the Son.

VII. That the Holy Spirit is a Person, is proved, 1st, From the personal properties ascribed to him, namely, understanding and will. Paul attributes Understanding to the Holy Spirit in the following words: “The Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God;” “The things of God knoweth no man, but the Spirit of God.”24 The interpretation of the heretics, who transfer these expressions to a man endowed with the Spirit of God, is utterly unsound. For, as in other passages, the Spirit of God is distinguished from men endowed with him,25 so likewise here; “God hath revealed them unto us by his Spirit.”26 The Spirit of God, besides, is represented as having an access to the secrets of God, similar to that which the spirit of a man has to the thoughts of a man. But where is the exactness of the analogy, if we say, that what holds of a man with respect to the things of God, holds in the same manner of the spirit of a man with regard to the things of a man? Add to this, that, as we shall immediately prove in the proper place, so intimate and profound a knowledge of the deep things of God is too exalted a privilege to fall to the share of any mortal. In the same epistle to the Corinthians, notice is taken also of the Will of the Spirit: “All these worketh that one and the self-same Spirit, dividing to every man severally, as he will.”27 Let it be noted, that in the chapter containing these words, the Spirit is distinguished as a Giver from his gifts,28 in the same way, doubtless, as the Lord is distinguished from his administrations,29 and God who worketh all in all, from his operations.30 For we have here a clear intimation of a Trinity of persons, to wit, the Father, who is usually denominated God absolutely; the Son, who is called Lord;31 and the Holy Spirit.

VIII. 2dly, From his personal appearances. Jesus “saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove, and lighting upon him.”32 “The Holy Ghost descended in a bodily shape, like a dove, upon him.”33 Now, who can suppose that what comes from heaven, and appears in a bodily shape, is not a person? We often read in holy writ, that spiritual persons, namely, Angels, descended in this manner, and were seen in a mortal form. But nowhere do we find that any spiritual quality descended, or assumed a visible appearance. It has been objected, that things which are not persons are sometimes figuratively said to come down from heaven,34 and that such things may be adumbrated by some external appearance; as was done at that happy Pentecost, when the gift of speaking in various languages, and with powerful utterance, with which the Apostles were endowed, was shadowed forth by the appearance of cloven and fiery tongues.35 But this by no means weakens the force of our reasoning. For truly we do not deny that the gifts of God, which are not always persons, descend from heaven: we only urge, that nothing which is not a person, ever came from above clothed with a bodily shape. The divided tongues which sat on the Apostles like fire, did not directly and immediately denote the gift of tongues, but the person of the Holy Spirit, the Author of that gift, “who gave them utterance,” as it is explained in the fourth verse.

IX. 3dly, From personal operations attributed to him; of which we have numerous instances in Scripture.36 There is no weight in the exception of adversaries, that it is by the mere fiction of a person that such acts are ascribed to the Holy Spirit; as personal acts are elsewhere attributed to charity,37 to sin,38 or to the letter of the law.39 Not to mention, that those indications of that figure of speech which are obvious elsewhere, are not to be found in the passages relating to the Spirit;—God is sometimes at particular pains, so to speak, to guard us against imagining that there is any such fiction of a person, where the Holy Spirit is spoken of. Thus in 1 Cor. xii. Paul, after having in the ninth verse designated certain gifts by the term Spirits, yet straightway, verse eleventh, refers all to one Spirit, the distributor of those gifts, as to a real person. Nor, as I apprehend, will our antagonists ever be able to show, that operations of the kind mentioned in the places to which we have referred, as catching away a man;—saying, Separate me men for the work whereunto I have called them; and interceding for one,—are not characteristical of persons.40

X. 4thly, From his being joined in the same place and order with persons, without any mark of difference. Thus in Mat. xxviii. 19. the Apostles are enjoined to baptize in the name of the Holy Ghost, no less than of the Father and the Son. Now what is it to perform a deed in the name of any one, but to do it by his authority and command? The authority, too, of these three is here propounded as equal, or rather as one. As therefore the Father and the Son are, by this expression, declared to be the authors of baptism, the Holy Spirit is in the same manner designated the author of that institution. But if he were not a person, how could the ordinance of baptism be ascribed to him? Objectors indeed allege, that things which are not persons, are connected with persons in the same sentence, as in the passage where Paul commends the Church “to God, and to the word of his grace,”41 that is, the Gospel. They add, that even the names of what are not persons, are joined to the name of a person;—“I will write upon him the name of my God, and the name of the city of my God.”42 But we reply, 1. Nowhere is any thing said to be done in the name of that which is not a person. 2. Although “the word of his grace” elsewhere signifies the Gospel, it doth not necessarily follow, that the expression has the same meaning in Acts xx. 32. The signification of words often varies according to the variety of circumstances, and the diversified exigencies of the subject. We are not displeased with the observation of Francis Gomar, that the Word of the grace of God here refers to Christ, who, agreeably to the forms of instruction used by the ancient Hebrews, is in the writings of John denominated the Word; and who may be called the Word of grace from the effects which he produces, just as he is styled “the Word of life.”43 In the same manner, he adds, Peter speaks of “the God of all grace,”44 and Paul of “the Spirit of grace.”45 Christ may be called, in fine, says that writer, “the Word of the grace of God,” because, as Mediator, he has obtained and announced the favour of God towards us. The propriety and concinnity of the Apostolical diction lead us thus to understand these expressions of Christ, rather than of the Gospel. It appears far more proper for the Church to be commended to Christ, than to the Gospel; which is usually commended to the Church.46 If you wish, however, by all means to explain it of the Gospel, the meaning of this improper phrase will be, that believers are commended to God, in order that he may instruct and console them by the doctrine of grace. And thus the Gospel will be associated with God, as the instrumental with the principal cause;—to which there is nothing similar in the passage from which we are now reasoning.47 3. We do not urge, that every thing is a person, to which a name is attributed, or whose name is joined with the name of a person; but merely maintain the personality of that in whose name something is said to be done, and done in the same manner in which it is performed in the name of those who are undoubtedly persons.

XI. You may urge perhaps, ‘If that in whose name we are baptized, appear to be a person, that with which we are baptized cannot be a person; just as the water with which we are baptized cannot be affirmed to be a person. Since, it is said, therefore, that believers are “baptized with the Holy Ghost,”48 is it not sufficiently clear that the Holy Spirit is not a person?’ I reply, if there is any force in this argument, it will follow by parity of reason, that as the garment with which we are clothed, or the bread on which we subsist, is not a person, so neither is Christ a person, because we are commanded to put him on,49 and are nourished by him as the bread of life.50 What else is it to be baptized with the Holy Spirit, if we intend to express ourselves in proper terms, than to be enriched with the grace and the gifts of the Holy Spirit? And what should hinder us from esteeming him a person, whose grace and gifts are conferred on us? We do not even hold, besides, that whenever the term Holy Spirit occurs in the sacred volume, it always designates a person; since we readily confess, that it is sometimes used metonymically, to denote the gifts of the Spirit. If then we admit that such is the case here, when we are said to be baptized with the Holy Spirit, on what pretext will you thence conclude, that the same thing ought to be understood, when we are said to be baptized in his name, whilst the expressions are so very different?

XII. Adversaries object, that in the Sacred Scriptures the Holy Ghost is frequently called the power of God; as instances of which they produce Luke i. 35. xxiv. 49. compared with Acts i. 4, 5, 8. Chap. x. 38. and thence infer that he is not a person. But this reasoning is utterly inconclusive. Simon Magus was termed by his followers, “the great power of God;”51 and Christ is denominated “the power of God.”52 Nay, the Hebrews consider a word53 which signifies power, as one of the titles of God. Hence the following expression, “What did Moses answer in the presence of the Power,”54 that is, God? On this point Elias55 and Buxtorf56 may be consulted. Some are of opinion, that the following phrase in the Gospel of Mark, is conformable to the same mode of speaking; “Ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power.”57 It could furnish no solid objection, therefore, to the personality of the Holy Spirit, that he were sometimes called the power of God. But adversaries cannot even prove that he is so called. For if we mistake not, we shall see that in all the places alleged, the Holy Ghost and power are distinguished from each other. In Luke i. 35, we find ascribed to the Holy Ghost as a Divine person, “the power of the Highest,” as a property by which, and according to which he operates; for it is “the power of the Spirit.”58 So also in Luke xxiv. 49, “power from on high” doth not immediately denote the Holy Spirit, but that greatness of soul with which the Apostles were endowed; of which it is intimated that the Holy Spirit is the author, when it is said to come from on high. To this interpretation we are naturally led by what we read elsewhere: “But ye shall receive power, after that the Holy Ghost is come upon you;”59 that is, the power you shall obtain, is from the Holy Ghost descending on you. In like manner, in Acts x. 38, there is an intimation, first, of the cause, “God anointed Jesus of Nazareth with the Holy Ghost;” then, of the effect, “and with power.”

XIII. Nor is there greater weight in the cavil against the personality of the Holy Spirit, founded on the passages where he is said to be given to men, or to be received by them;60 for, 1st, Even God gives himself to us, as “an exceeding great reward;”61 and he is the “portion” or “inheritance” of believers.62 2dly, Christ is also said to be given by God,63 and received by believers;64 and even so as to “dwell in their hearts,”65 in exact conformity with what we read of the Holy Spirit. 3dly, In those very places where the Holy Spirit is spoken of as a gift, he is sometimes described as a person, and distinguished from his effects. Of this we have an instance in Rom. v. 5.—“The love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the Holy Ghost, who is given unto us.” The meaning of which expression is as follows. The Holy Ghost is given unto us, that he may be no less our’s than the Father or the Son is our’s, and that thus we may be rendered happy by the communion of the whole undivided Trinity. By the Holy Ghost, that is, by his influence and operation, we have “in our hearts,” or we feel and actually experience, “the love of God,” particularly his amazing love towards us, “shed abroad,” or most abundantly imparted. For it is the chief part of the consolation from which the Holy Spirit receives the title of the Comforter, that he causes us to taste and feel the love of God. In like manner in Gal. iv. 6, it is said of the person of the Holy Spirit, “God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son;” as, in verse fourth it is said of the person of the Son, “God sent forth his Son.” Besides, the Spirit whom God sends to dwell and to operate in our hearts, crieth; that is, so causeth us to cry, that our crying is his voice. He is here so evidently described as a person, that Crellius is obliged to betake himself to a personification; a parallel instance of which he alleges we have in Chap. iii. 8. “The Scripture foreseeing, &c.” But that passage bears no resemblance to this. The Scripture is said to foresee, because the Spirit, who dictates the Scripture, foresees. The figure there is a metonymy, not a personification.

XIV. It exceeds all absurdity, that they would have the Holy Spirit to mean the Doctrine of the Gospel, to which, by a prosopopœia, personal operations are attributed. They thus explain the following words of Paul: “Who also hath made us able ministers of the New Testament; not of the letter, but of the Spirit; for the letter killeth, but the Spirit giveth life.”66 To the same sense they pervert also that other expression; “No man can say, that Jesus is the Lord, but by the Holy Ghost.”67 As if the meaning of the Apostle were, that no man can rightly acknowledge Jesus as Lord, unless that truth be revealed to him by the Gospel; as likewise they who receive the Gospel, are said to be “in the Spirit.”68 But if we are disposed to speak the truth, what is it wantonly to wrest the Scriptures, if this is not an instance of such conduct? Let us examine each of the passages alleged. Were we to grant that in the former, the Spirit, by a metonymy, denotes the doctrine of the Gospel; what is improperly ascribed there to the Gospel as an exemplary cause, is properly to be attributed to the person of the Holy Spirit, as the principal efficient cause. Thus also that which is elsewhere ascribed to the letter of the law, is, by the same analogy, to be attributed to the person of the Lawgiver.69 But it does not seem necessary for us to make such a concession. The Apostle does not call the law “the letter;” or the Gospel “the Spirit:” but teaches that the letter is in the law, and the Spirit in the Gospel, so that they who minister to the law, minister to the letter; they who minister to the Gospel, to the Spirit. He calls that the letter, which is unable, at first, and by itself, to convert a man; or to give a sinner the hope of life, much less to quicken him. By the Spirit, he understands both the person of the Spirit, and his quickening grace; which is clearly disclosed, and rendered efficacious, by means of the Gospel. In a preceding verse, the Apostle undoubtedly distinguishes the Spirit from the doctrine, when he calls the Corinthians “the epistle of Christ, written not with ink, but with the Spirit of the living God.”70

As to the interpretation which they obtrude upon the third verse of 1 Cor. xii., it is a daring perversion. To speak by the Spirit, is to speak as the Spirit instructs and moves.71 In the whole of this Chapter, too, the Spirit denotes, not the doctrine of the Gospel, but Him by whom the word of wisdom, and the word of knowledge is given, and who is the Author of faith.72 And we are said to “live in the Spirit,”73 when, by the efficacious operation of the person of the Holy Spirit, we live a new and spiritual life. The form of expression is similar to that which is used with regard to the common blessing of nature, when we are said to live in God, because he giveth unto all life, and breath, and all things.74

XV. Having thus proved the Personality of the Holy Spirit, let us now proceed to show that he is a Divine Person, the true Jehovah, and the Most High God. And why should we not employ the same series of arguments by which divine truth has hitherto been nobly and successfully defended? It is the will of God himself, that we should acknowledge as the true God, one to whom Divine Names, Attributes, Works, and Divine Honour and Worship, are ascribed in the sacred volume. The Almighty is not so prodigal of his glory, as to share all the characters of divinity now mentioned with one that is not God. Nor indeed is it possible for him so to share them: For the attributes of God are not, in reality, distinct from his essence; his works are a kind of emanations, and living proofs of those attributes; and what is honour and worship but a devout recognition of that divine excellence which is displayed in such stupendous works? The name of God, in fine, and in particular the name Jehovah, comprises all these in its extensive import. Now there is none of these characteristics of Divinity, that doth not belong to the Holy Ghost.

XVI. To begin with Names: It is nowhere, we confess, said expressly and in so many words, “The Holy Spirit is the Most High God.” From a diligent comparing of the Scriptures, however, we conclude incontestably, that he who is in one passage called the Holy Ghost, is in the same, or in a parallel place, denominated Jehovah and God; and that those things which are indisputably affirmed of Jehovah, and cannot be affirmed of any that is not Jehovah, are asserted concerning the Spirit. Nor is it necessary that every doctrine, or even all the most important mysteries of theology, be declared in express terms; since we ought to obtain our knowledge by “comparing spiritual things with spiritual.”75

XVII. Let us, in the first place, examine the mysteries of the Ninety-fifth Psalm. None, I apprehend, will deny that he is the Supreme God, who says, verses 9th, 10th, and 11th, that he was tempted and proved in the wilderness by the fathers of the Jews, after they had seen his work;—who was grieved with that generation, and who sware that they should not enter into his rest. Yet he is the same person who says, verses 7th and 8th, “To-day if ye will hear his voice,” that is, the voice of the Son of God, who is our God, a great King above all gods, and the Chief Shepherd of souls,—“harden not your hearts.” For what we read from the last member of the seventh verse to the end of the Psalm, is related as the continued discourse of the same person. I now add, that the Holy Spirit is the author of the whole of this discourse; as is evident from the Apostle’s expression in the Epistle to the Hebrews: “Wherefore, as the Holy Ghost saith, To-day, if ye will hear his voice,” &c.76 And indeed it is the office of the Spirit to testify of Christ as King,77 and to glorify him.78 Hence it is inferred by inevitable consequence, that the Holy Ghost is that Jehovah whom the Israelites tempted in the desert, and who showed himself to be the God of Israel, by his magnificent works, and by the just punishments which he inflicted upon the rebellious. As to the objection of adversaries, that these words are ascribed to the Holy Spirit, not as if they were pronounced by his person, but by the person of David under the impulse of the Spirit; it is refuted by the whole scope and connexion of the discourse. The things spoken are not applicable to David, but to God only. Nor could David have uttered these sacred expressions by an impulse of the Spirit, unless the Holy Spirit were Jehovah. The authority of what is spoken by the prophets is entirely founded on him by whose impulse they speak; and since that authority is Divine, it can be founded upon none but God. Consider by all means the reasoning of the Apostle Peter in his second Epistle, where he founds the whole strength and authority of prophecy, by which we are laid under obligations to faith and obedience, on this consideration, that holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost.79

XVIII. Let us go on to another instance. Jehovah, and he alone, conducted the journey of Israel through the wilderness. “Jehovah alone did lead him, and there was no strange God with him.”80 We here speak, it is manifest, of supreme and sovereign leading; and let none object that Moses, as the servant of God, under Him, conducted the people out of Egypt. The Israelites, too, provoked that Jehovah by their rebellion.81 Now Isaiah ascribes all this to the Holy Spirit: “As a beast goeth down into the valley, the Spirit of the Lord caused him to rest;”82 and again, “They rebelled and vexed his Holy Spirit.”83 What can we infer from this, but that the Holy Spirit is that very Jehovah to whom the Israelites rendered so ungrateful a return for their deliverance, and to whom, nevertheless, the whole glory of it was due.

XIX. No less conclusive is the observation which we shall now offer. None will deny that he is the true and supreme God, whom Isaiah beheld sitting on a lofty throne, whilst the seraphim were standing above it;—whom he calls “the King, Jehovah of hosts;”—and from whose mouth he heard those words, “Go and tell this people, hear ye indeed, but understand not, - - - make the heart of this people fat,” &c.84 If therefore it shall be shown, that the Holy Spirit is the person who spoke these words to Isaiah, nothing further seems to be wanting to establish his Divinity. Now of this we are assured by Paul; “Well spake the Holy Ghost by Esaias the prophet unto our fathers, saying, Go unto this people and say, Hearing ye shall hear,” &c.85 Could any thing be spoken more expressly? Yes, say our adversaries; for Paul does not affirm that the Holy Ghost spoke these words to Isaiah, but by Isaiah to the fathers. But he could not have spoken these words by Isaiah, unless he had first spoken them to Isaiah. Nay, the expressions which the Apostle attributes to the Holy Spirit, “Go unto this people and say,” &c. were not addressed directly or immediately to the fathers, but to Isaiah. We have another instance of the same sophistry, when they allege, that by this manner of reasoning it is possible to show that the Holy Spirit is Christ, since, according to our interpretation, the same words are elsewhere attributed to him.86 Truly reason here abandons them entirely. By comparing these passages it may and ought to be shown, that the Holy Spirit is one and the same God with Christ: it cannot be proved, that he is the same person. What is here said, is of such a nature, that it cannot be affirmed of one that is not God; not such as can apply only to one person. Nay, that these are the words of a plurality of persons, who, nevertheless, are one God, is intimated by the very expression which the Lord uses in Isaiah; “Whom shall I send? and who will go for us?”87

XX. It is usual to adduce for the same purpose the last words of David: “The Spirit of Jehovah spake by me, and his word was in my tongue. The God of Israel said, the Rock of Israel spake to me, &c.”88 Here, according to the opinion of many, the same person who is first called the Spirit of Jehovah, is styled the God of Israel, and the Rock of Israel. We choose rather to expound this passage, however, in a manner somewhat different; which we may certainly do without offence. We do not think that the God and the Rock of Israel, mentioned in the third verse, are intended to denote the same person who is previously called the Spirit of Jehovah, in the second verse. It seems more proper to understand by the God of Israel, the Father;—by the Rock of Israel, Christ who upholds Israel, and who has undertaken that the Church shall be built on himself as the foundation;—by the Spirit of Jehovah, the third person. Thus we find the whole Trinity here, and something also relative to the Holy Spirit, which irrefragably proves his Deity. When David says, The Spirit of Jehovah spake to me, or in me, or by me, in whichever way you choose to render it, he shows that he has for the foundation of his confidence, not the words of Samuel, or of Nathan, or of Gad, who were employed as instruments, but the words of the Holy Spirit, who had not only spoken to him by them, but had also, with greater and truly divine power, entered into the recesses of his own mind, and caused him to speak to others from the full assurance of faith. Hence arises an argument as follows. He who principally spoke to David, in David, and by David, is the true and the Most High God. But the Holy Spirit so spoke. Therefore, the Holy Spirit is the true and the Most High God. Crellius himself has furnished us with the major proposition. The assumption is proved from David’s confessing that himself and his tongue were the instruments of the Spirit; and he whose instruments the prophets are, is himself the chief cause of divine revelations.

XXI. Peter supplies us with a very powerful argument for the Divinity of the Holy Spirit in Acts v. 3, 4; where he uses an expression relating to the Holy Spirit, which served to show that the lie told by Ananias was a most abominable and heinous sin. Now, nothing tends more to aggravate that sin, than to observe, that it was not committed against mere men, such as the Apostles were, but against the Holy Ghost. Nothing, besides, is more adapted to prove that the lie told to the Holy Ghost is a most heinous sin, than this other observation, that he who lies to the Holy Ghost, lies to God himself. This reasoning of the Apostle, however, would not hold, if the Holy Spirit were not God. Adversaries urge two exceptions here. First, they allege “that it is said to Ananias, that he lied to God; it is not said that he lied to the Holy Ghost, but that he pretended to the Holy Ghost.”89 The words in the Greek,90 they add, may signify either to pretend to the Holy Spirit, as Erasmus and others render them, or to deceive the Holy Spirit, according to Piscator and others. And the change of the case in the original language, say they, is not accidental but intended, lest any should imagine that he who had just been styled the Holy Ghost, is called God. Their other objection is, that although our interpretation were admitted, it could no more follow from it, that the Holy Spirit is God, than it can be inferred that the Apostles are God, from the parallel reasoning of Paul in the first Epistle to the Thessalonians: “He, therefore, that despiseth, despiseth not man, but God.”91 To these objections we reply, 1st, The Greeks construe the word ψευσασθαι with a Dative or an Accusative indiscriminately.92 2dly, The exposition of Erasmus is quite foreign. Ananias, by keeping back part of the price, which is the matter referred to, could not pretend that he had the Holy Ghost. Peter himself, too, gives a different account of the matter, when he says, “How is it that ye have agreed together, to tempt the Spirit of the Lord?”93—To deceive the Holy Ghost, as Piscator chooses to interpret the expression, that is, to attempt to deceive, is either nothing else than to lie to him, or even something more. The scope of the Apostle’s argument, then, is as follows: Whoever attempts to deceive the Holy Ghost by lies, as thou Ananias art doing, is guilty of a most atrocious and truly diabolical sin; for he lies not to men, but to God. 3dly, It doth not indeed follow from the words of Paul to the Thessalonians, cited above, that the Apostles are God: but it is shown, that the contempt of the discourses which Apostles preached by inspiration of the Spirit of God, recoils upon God himself. So here, the lie of Ananias, by which he endeavoured to impose on the Apostles, ultimately redounded against the Holy Spirit, who, by consequence, is God. If Peter had intended to say that Ananias lied to the Apostles, through the Apostles to the Holy Ghost, and through the Holy Ghost to God—distinguishing the Spirit as a kind of medium or middle person, between God and the Apostles,—he would have said, Thou hast not lied unto men, nor unto the Holy Ghost, but unto God.94

XXII. Let us also notice briefly a few of the Divine Attributes, which the Scripture ascribes to the Holy Spirit of God. Here the first that falls to be mentioned is Eternity, of which Paul speaks in the following words; “Christ through the Eternal Spirit offered up himself without spot unto God.”95 To me it appears far more proper to explain the term Spirit here of the third person of the Godhead, than of the Divine nature of the Son.96 In this passage is distinctly designated, first, the Priest, who is Christ, principally according to the divine nature, or, to use the expression of our Apostle, “according to the power of an endless life;”97—then the victim, which also is Christ, principally according to the human nature in which he suffered and died;98—and in fine, the mystical fire, which is the Holy Spirit, by whom the victim is sanctified and rendered acceptable to God. On the sacred fire which descended from heaven, see Leviticus ix. 23, 24. It was the constant care of the priests, to preserve that fire burning on the altar, and to prevent it from being extinguished;99 and in this sense it might be called eternal, just as the Romans styled the fires of their Vesta eternal. Now, that sacred fire was a symbol of the Holy Spirit, who is called “fire;”100 who excites the flames of divine love;101 and, what chiefly merits attention here, who also renders all sacrifices acceptable to God. “That the offering up of the Gentiles,” says the Apostle, “might be acceptable, being sanctified by the Holy Ghost.”102 The eternity, too, which in the sacred fire was merely symbolical, is true and substantial in its antitype the Holy Spirit; not only because it is impious to quench him as to the operations of his grace,103 but principally because he is spoken of by Moses, as existing in the beginning.104

XXIII. After eternity, the attribute which comes next to be mentioned is Immensity. “Whither shall I go from thy Spirit?” says the Psalmist, “or whither shall I flee from thy presence?”105 I dare not explode the observation of the Anonymous Greek writer on this Psalm, “that by his Spirit is intended the Holy Spirit, and by his presence, or face, the only-begotten Son.”106 Let us see what can be said in support of this remark. That the presence of God sometimes denotes the Son, is abundantly evident. God had promised that he would give to the Israelites a Guide to keep them in the way, an “Angel in whom his name was.”107 Being afterwards provoked, however, by the base idolatry of the Israelites in making the golden calf, he refuses to go himself with them, and says that he will send an Angel, who should expel their enemies, the inhabitants of the promised land.108 But, in consequence of the earnest entreaties of Moses, he promises a second time that his presence shall go before them.109 And what else is the presence of God now promised, than the same Angel in whom is the name of God? Consider also the following passage in Malachi: “Behold, I will send my messenger,” that is, John the Baptist, “and he shall prepare the way for my presence.”110 But what is the presence or face of God, which is to succeed the forerunner? “The Lord whom ye seek, shall suddenly come to his temple, even the messenger of the covenant whom ye delight in.” For the sake of brevity, I omit other examples. With regard to the reason of this designation; it is evident that our Lord is so called, because that glory and beauty of God which are amiable in the eyes of a sinner, are clearly beheld only in Christ, agreeably to his own words, “He that hath seen me, hath seen the Father.”111 Now this observation is not impertinent: for if the presence of God is here to be taken personally, his Spirit ought surely to be understood in a similar manner. And so we are instructed concerning the immensity of the whole adorable Trinity, with regard to essence,112—knowledge,113—power, and effectual operation.

XXIV. To these attributes add Omniscience. “The Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God. For what man knoweth the things of a man, save the spirit of man, which is in him. Even so the things of God knoweth no man, but the Spirit of God.”114 Observe, 1st, That the Spirit of God knows “all things” absolutely. 2dly, That he knows even “the deep things of God,” the most hidden mysteries of his essence and perfections, and the secrets of the divine counsels. 3dly, That he knows them as exactly as if he had searched them with great care.115 4thly, That he knows the most secret counsels of God as his own counsels, just as the mind of a man knows the things of a man. 5thly, That all these are evidences of a knowledge entirely Divine. It is the prerogative of God only to know the deep things of the human heart;116 how much more to know the deep things of God?117

In fine, the Apostle, in a passage which we have explained above,118 attributes to the Spirit, the most sovereign will, and omnipotent power.

XXV. From Divine attributes, let us proceed to Divine Works. Of these, the first that demands our notice, is Creation. Creation doth truly claim God as its Author, since it is the work of God alone, and even his immediate work.119 It is ascribed, however, to the Holy Spirit, and that in reference both to the world in general, and to man in particular. With respect to the world in general, we find it written: “The Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters.”120 The metaphor is taken from birds, which brood upon their nests, and hatch their young by the genial heat they communicate.121 The Spirit of God thus brooded on the shapeless mass, and by his influence rendered it productive of so vast a multitude of beautiful creatures. “He warmed and quickened the face of the waters,” says Basil,122 “in a manner resembling that of a bird brooding on its nest.” The Talmudists express the same thing in the following terms:—“Like a dove which sits upon her young, nor injures, whilst she touches them.”123 Solomon Jarchi, too, has similar expressions on this passage. And the symbolical Theology of the Egyptians, which represents the world as proceeding from God, like an egg, perhaps took its rise from this metaphor. We read also in Job; “By his Spirit he hath garnished the heavens.”124

The creation of man, who has been termed the little world in contradistinction to the great world around him, is likewise ascribed to the Holy Spirit. “The Spirit of God hath made me,” says Elihu, “and the breath of the Almighty hath given me life.”125

XXVI. Regeneration is also the work of God only. It is a new creation accomplished by the command of his will;126 and as to real efficiency, it is likewise an immediate operation of God; for the means employed have only a moral influence. But this also is the work of the Divine Spirit. “Except a man be born of water, and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.”127 Here “water” either denotes the same thing with the Spirit of God,128 or baptism, which the Apostle calls “the washing, the laver, of regeneration;”129 and which, however, as its operation is only moral, derives all its virtue from the Spirit of God. Or perhaps “water” refers to natural generation, as in the following passage: “Hear ye this, O house of Jacob, which - - - are come forth out of the waters of Judah.”130 Beside that natural generation by which a man is born of water, another is necessary, namely, that supernatural one, by which a spiritual man is born of the Spirit. The scope of all these interpretations is the same. They all tend to show that the Spirit of God is the author of our regeneration. We read also of “the renewing of the Holy Ghost;”131 and it is said, “The Spirit giveth life.”132

XXVII. Sanctification, in like manner, is the work of God only.133 But this work also is ascribed to the Spirit: “And I will put my Spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes, and ye shall keep my judgments and do them.”134 “Ye are sanctified,” says the Apostle, “by the Spirit of our God:”135 and again, “God hath from the beginning chosen you to salvation, through sanctification of the Spirit.”136

And that none may imagine that the Spirit, like the word, is merely an instrumental cause of sanctification, let it be observed, that the Spirit sanctifies us in one respect, and the word in another; for the moral efficacy of the word depends entirely on the supernatural and efficacious operation of the Spirit. Hence the Spirit with his operations, is joined with the word, and yet distinguished from the word.137

XXVIII. In fine, to perform Miracles by his own power, is the work of God only: “Blessed be the Lord God, the God of Israel, who only doeth wondrous things.”138 But the Holy Spirit doeth such things by his own power; for the Apostle speaks of “mighty signs, and wonders, by the power of the Spirit of God.”139 Nay, whatever works of this sort Christ performed, he performed by the power of the Spirit, which is also his own power. “I cast out devils,” says he, “by the Spirit of God.”140

XXIX. We come next to treat of that Divine Honour and worship which is due to the Holy Spirit. And, first, let us take notice of that religious adoration of the Spirit, which, whatever may be alleged by others to the contrary, we find both enjoined and exemplified in the sacred volume. Accordingly the following precept occurs in the Gospel of Matthew:141 “Pray ye therefore the Lord of the harvest, that he will send forth labourers into his harvest.” The Lord of the harvest, who thrusts forth labourers, is the Spirit of God, as we learn from Acts xiii. 2. where we find an instance of obedience to this precept. “As they ministered to the Lord and fasted, the Holy Ghost said, Separate me Barnabas and Saul for the work whereunto I have called them.” An answer is returned by the Spirit to the prayers of the prophets and teachers of the Church of Antioch; and why so, but because he was invocated by them? The Spirit also, as Lord, declares by his own authority, what he would have Barnabas and Saul to do; and asserts that it is himself who has called them to the ministry.

XXX. Nor are examples wanting. That of Paul is well known,142 where he solicits grace from the Lord Jesus Christ, and love from God the Father, and in like manner, his own communications from the Holy Ghost. To the same effect is the prayer of John: “John to the seven churches which are in Asia: Grace be unto you, and peace from him which is, and which was, and which is to come; and from the seven Spirits which are before his throne; and from Jesus Christ, who is the faithful witness,” &c.143 In order to illustrate this passage, we must show, first, what the seven Spirits denote; and secondly, in what manner John calls upon them. By the seven Spirits are not here intended any created spirits, either angelical or human, but the third person of the Godhead; which we infer from the consideration of the ancient symbol alluded to, as well as from the style of the sacred book of the Apocalypse. There is an allusion to the golden candlestick with its seven lamps in the tabernacle of Moses. This is plainly suggested by the following words; “There were seven lamps of fire burning before the throne, which are the seven Spirits of God.”144 The tabernacle, be it observed, was a figure of the Church; and the candlestick, of the Holy Spirit, to whom the Church is indebted for all her light. The candlestick, though one in itself, had seven distinct lamps. The person of the Holy Spirit, too, is one; but his grace is most abundant and most perfect; for the number seven is a symbol of multitude and of perfection. The seven lamps were formed of one continued beaten work, proceeding from the candlestick itself.145 And the graces of the Holy Spirit are, so to speak, essential to him, and proceed from the all-sufficiency of his godhead. For this reason he is denominated from them, “The Spirit of wisdom and understanding, the Spirit of counsel and might,” &c.146 But the very style of the Apocalypse leads us also to this interpretation. These seven Spirits are called “the Spirits of God;”147 and I can recollect no passage in holy writ, where any created Spirit is called by this name. The seven Spirits are placed betwixt the Father and the Son, as of the same dignity. They are also called the horns and the eyes of Christ.148 The Holy Spirit, to wit, is “the Spirit of Christ.”149 He is exhibited under the emblem of horns, because of the power of the Spirit which is often celebrated; and under the emblem of eyes, either on account of his knowledge, or because the look of Christ is a look of love, and his love appears in the gift of the Spirit.150 In fine, we nowhere read that these seven Spirits worship God, which is done by the living creatures, and the elders. But on the contrary, they are invocated by John—an honour which doth not belong to created spirits.151 And in what manner doth John call upon them? In the same manner, with the same worship, as that with which he calls upon the Father and the Son, adoring the Spirit without any mark of distinction, as equally with the Father and the Son, the Author of grace and peace.

XXXI. Another instance of the ascription of Divine honour to the Spirit, is that we are baptized in his name.152 This is clearly a Divine honour; for, 1st, He in whose name we are baptized is recognised as the true God, the author of the sacraments, the Lord and Lawgiver of the Church,—characters which are peculiar to Jehovah.153 2dly, We confide in him as one able to impart and perform the thing signified by the sign. This also is competent to God only; for who that is not God, can afford us the grace, the fellowship, the enjoyment of God, which are sealed by the sacraments? 3dly, In this sacrament we surrender ourselves to him in whose name we are baptized, to serve and obey him; for in baptism there is “the answer of a good conscience towards God.”154 This again is an honour too high to fall to the share of any creature. And hence Paul disclaims it with great warmth; “Were ye baptized in the name of Paul?”155

XXXII. Add to this, that we are consecrated as a Temple to the Holy Spirit. “Know ye not that ye are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you?”156 “Know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost, which is in you?”157 Now a temple is the house of God only, “an house built unto the name of Jehovah,”158 “the sanctuary of Jehovah,”159 “a glorious high throne;”160 and in a temple religious worship is performed to God alone.161 Nor is there any ground for the objection, that it is only metaphorically that believers are called a temple; for although that were true, the analogy must still be preserved. As therefore the house erected by Solomon was a temple on account of the indwelling of the Divinity, which the Hebrews call Shechinah,162 so believers are the temple of the Spirit, because he is in them and inhabits them as God. But in truth, believers are a temple in a far more strict and proper sense than the temple of Jerusalem; as that was merely a figure, of which the substance is primarily in Christ, and secondarily in believers.163

XXXIII. We must not overlook, in fine, the religious obedience which the Apostle urges us to render to the Holy Spirit. “Wherefore, as the Holy Ghost saith, To-day if ye will hear his voice, harden not your hearts, as in the provocation, in the day of temptation in the wilderness, when your fathers tempted me,” &c.164 The Spirit of God was justly offended, because that sacred obedience which was an honour due to his Majesty, had not been rendered to him. But we find also that a certain sin is mentioned in sacred writ, which is in a peculiar manner committed against the Spirit and his office, and which is so heinous in the sight of God that it is declared unpardonable above every other sin.165 Now, if the Holy Spirit be not the Supreme God, what reason can be assigned why a sin committed against him should be held so dreadful and atrocious? From this, however, we are not to infer, that the Holy Spirit is a greater Divine person, or entitled to higher honour, than the Father or the Son. That he is truly God, we justly conclude, because it is possible to sin against him peculiarly and signally. That he is greater than the Father or the Son, we cannot infer, as the infinitude of the godhead excludes all disparity. That the sin committed against him is never forgiven, is not owing to his being worthy of higher honour than the Father or the Son, but to the nature of the sin, by which that grace of God without which there is no salvation, although exhibited, known, and acknowledged, is wantonly and pertinaciously rejected; and resistance is maliciously given to those operations of the Holy Spirit, by which only he brings sinners into a state of saving relation to God.166

XXXIV. And thus, we think, we have abundantly confirmed the Supreme Deity of the Holy Ghost. It now remains to show, that he is a Divine person, distinct from the Father and the Son. This appears, 1st, From the distinct mention of these adorable persons. Haggai ii. 4, 5, “I am with you, saith the Lord of hosts, with the Word,—and my Spirit remaineth among you.167168 2dly, From the enumeration of Three that bear record in heaven.169 3dly, From an express term of distinction: “I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for ever, even the Spirit of truth.”170 To this learned men refer also an expression in Zechariah, which they thus render; Even to-day will I restore unto thee another Teacher or Revealer.171 The Holy Spirit may be called a Revealer, because it is his office to disclose deep mysteries;172 and another Revealer, to distinguish him from Christ, who was sent before him, and who is mentioned in a preceding verse.173 He may be said to be restored, partly because the extraordinary mission of the Holy Spirit was suspended from the times of Zechariah to Christ; partly because he was to be given in the room of Christ, who is gone to the Father.

The distinguishing properties of the Holy Spirit, are as follows. 1st, Passive procession from the Father and the Son. 2dly, The third place in the order of subsistence. 3dly, The third place in the order of operation. Compare what is said on this topic in the Seventh Dissertation.

XXXV. These truths relating to the Spirit ought to be rightly known, and most devoutly acknowledged. Something more, however, is included in that faith in the Holy Ghost of which we make a profession in the Creed. This faith doth not rest satisfied with a frigid contemplation of his Divine Person, but goes forward to consider his mysterious indwelling in believers, and the secret efficacy which he exerts in their hearts. It will now be proper for us to discourse a little further on these points, that we may penetrate to the marrow and the kernel of the doctrine before us. It is the privilege of believers, then, that they have received the Spirit from God, and enjoy his presence as a much loved Inhabitant in the innermost chambers of their souls. “Now we have received not the spirit of the world, but the Spirit which is of God, that we might know the things which are freely given to us of God.”174 And so universally doth this hold, that, “If any man have not the Spirit of Christ, he is none of his.”175 As many of us, too, as are made partakers of the Spirit, should be solicitous to know that he dwelleth in us. “What! Know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost, which is in you, which ye have of God?”176 Whilst we remain ignorant of this, it is impossible for us to be sure that we have that union with God and Christ, which is the hinge on which the whole of our salvation turns. “Hereby know we that we dwell in him and he in us, because he hath given us of his Spirit.”177 Now there is no way in which this can be known with greater certainty, than by carefully observing those operations, by which the Spirit manifests himself to the conscience, as the Spirit of grace, and the Spirit of Christ. Thus also we shall learn the unspeakable excellence and value of this gift of God.

XXXVI. Those operations of the Spirit to which we have alluded, are chiefly the following. As by moving on the waters at the beginning of the world, he infused into them the principles of a new life, whence the regular vicissitudes of nature, and the diversified species of creatures proceeded; so, after having entered the minds of the elect, he becomes in them the author of a new, spiritual, and divine life. “It is the Spirit that quickeneth.”178 The beginning of this life seems to be a new light kindled by the Spirit in the mind,179 by which we know ourselves with all the atrocity of our sins and the guilt which they involve,—the vanity of the world lying in wickedness, and the insufficiency of all creatures to make us happy,—the divine certainty of the truths revealed by the Gospel,—and what is of the first importance, the universal sufficiency of the Lord Jesus Christ to perfect our salvation,—the amiableness of God in Christ,—and in fine, the inexpressible beauty of holiness, which is the image of God. But as there is a very intimate connexion betwixt the understanding and the will, the same Spirit by his gracious agency excites motions in the will corresponding to those ideas of the understanding. He excites, in particular, deep self-abasement before God, sorrow for the offences we have done as opposite to the divine holiness, contempt of the world, a holy despair of happiness from ourselves and from all creatures, a living faith of the Gospel, hunger and thirst after Christ and that grace which is in Christ alone, a vehement love to God in Christ, and an ardent desire of holiness, that we may as closely as possible resemble God. All these fruits of the Spirit, too, while they exert their influence in the mind, cannot fail to communicate their virtue even to the members of the body; which present themselves as instruments and servants of righteousness unto holiness.180 And thus, so to speak, a new world of grace is produced by the Holy Spirit in the man, who, henceforth governed by more excellent rules of conduct, and full of vital vigour, discovers by his pure and heavenly deportment, that he is led by the Spirit of God.181

XXXVII. Further, the Spirit produces also this effect, that believers are not only one amongst themselves, but one with Christ. “For by one Spirit are we all baptized into one body,”182 namely, that body which the Apostle had just affirmed to be Christ. The Spirit of Christ, by his sweet and yet invincible, or, to express it more precisely, will-conquering power, draws our Spirit towards Christ, to apprehend and embrace him. Christ also comes down to us by the communication of his grace; and by this delightful reciprocation of mutual love, a mystical and spiritual union and conjunction takes place, so that the believing soul, in a manner, dissolves and melts in the Lord Jesus, and becomes “one Spirit” with him.183184 The Spouse boasted of old that she was her beloved’s, and that her beloved was her’s.185 But, behold something greater here than mine or thine. Through the medium of the Spirit there is not only a union, but even a unity—a unity so joining us to Christ, that it bears some resemblance to the most perfect unity of the Three persons in the same Divine essence. “That they all may be one; as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee, that they also may be one in us.”186 O stupendous miracle of Divine love, shining forth in this operation of the Holy Spirit!

XXXVIII. Hence also it follows, that being made partakers of Christ, we are at the same time partakers of all his benefits. If through the Spirit we are Christ’s, whatever belongs to Christ, belongs also to us.187 He took upon himself what was our’s, while we had nothing but sin and misery,188 that he might make us sharers of what is his, to be conferred on us by the Spirit, who takes of the things that are Christ’s and gives them to us.189 Christ says to us, as the father said to the son in the parable, “Son, thou art ever with me, and all that I have is thine.”190 Lord Jesus! All thine our’s! Shall we poor insignificant men become partakers of all thy treasures, and of the unbounded riches of thy grace! Why not, Lord? If through thy Spirit, thou thyself art our’s, why not also the things which are thine?

XXXIX. The Spirit, too, is the Comforter of believers, and that in various respects. 1st, As he is the seal of the divine love to them. “After that ye believed, ye were sealed with that Holy Spirit of promise.”191 He is called “the Spirit of promise” with a peculiar emphasis, not merely because himself is the subject of promise, but principally because it is his province to intimate the promises of the Gospel to believers, and to inscribe and seal them on their hearts. And as sealing is the stamping of the likeness that is in the seal on the thing sealed, by which it may be distinguished as the property of him whose mark it bears, or by which ample credit may be secured to an instrument,—what else shall we understand by the sealing here mentioned, than the effectual communication of that divine light, purity, holiness, righteousness, goodness, and joy, which are in the Holy Spirit; by which it is evinced that certain persons are the property of God, whom he will preserve sacred and inviolable for himself; and by which they are assured of the performance of the other divine promises, whether of grace or of glory. “Now he which stablisheth us with you in Christ, and hath anointed us, is God; who hath sealed us, and given the earnest of the Spirit in our hearts.”192 2dly, And this is another way in which the Spirit comforts us, that he is “the earnest of our inheritance.”193 An earnest is a part of the price given beforehand, as a token that the whole is to follow. There is here an allusion, probably, to the rite of betrothing, in which the Bridegroom gives a piece of money or a ring to the bride, in testimony of her common interest with him in all his goods. In the Holy Spirit, we have, then, not only the “seal,” but also “the first fruits;”194 which exhibit not merely the hope, but the foretaste of the full harvest. 3dly, The Spirit cheers us also in another form, by causing us to “know the things that are freely given us of God.”195 This he doth by secretly witnessing to our spirit, and with our spirit.196 And truly it is the voice of the Spirit only, that is able to raise up the soul bowed down under the weight of its sorrows. Although a person should speak with the tongues of men and of angels, whilst the internal operation of the Spirit doth not concur, he will prove a miserable comforter. But a single word of the Spirit has greater efficacy than a thousand discourses addressed to the outward ear by all the Prophets, Evangelists, and Apostles, nay, by the Lord Jesus himself, unaccompanied by the inward teaching of the Spirit. 4thly, In fine, as deeds are far better and more powerful than words, the Spirit of God doth not leave himself without witness from them also. He takes hold of believers as if by the hand, and introduces them to the chambers and embraces of the King, or even to the banqueting-house, where the banner over them is love; and soothes them with sweet celestial delights, such as earthly minds neither relish nor receive, and which are elegantly represented as hidden manna, for this among other reasons, that no man knows them but he by whom they are tasted.197

XL. Nor is it very difficult for believers, provided they give due attention and diligence, to distinguish these operations of the Spirit from the illusions of the flesh or of a malignant demon, or even from those common operations of the Spirit which are unproductive of holiness. This appears from the words of our Lord: “Even the Spirit of truth whom the world cannot receive, because it seeth him not, neither knoweth him; but ye know him, for he dwelleth with you, and shall be in you.”198 These operations are discerned, both from their very nature, when separately considered; and from the order in which they are wisely connected, and the relation which they bear to one another. In each of them there is a brightness, majesty, and efficacy, so conspicuous and striking, that the light of noon-day doth not more clearly discover the sun, than these operations discover the Spirit as their author. Whilst he sanctifies believers, he inspires them with the desire of a purer virtue than any probity known amongst the heathen, or than that pretended sanctity which characterised the Pharisees. Pagan probity and pharisaical sanctity, having self-love for their principle, meanly terminate on man himself. The Spirit so actuates the souls of believers, on the contrary, that they no longer wish to be their own; but denying the lusts of the deceitful flesh, they remember that they belong to God, and desire that every part of their conduct may be regulated according to his will and example, and redound to his glory. Whilst the Spirit comforts believers, too, he enters into their minds with a certain sweetness, which, as it is incomparably delightful, so is free from the smallest mixture of earthly dregs, and instead of loading or enervating the mind, renders it more clear and alert, and prepares it for serving God with the utmost alacrity. Even when the soul becomes most languid and remiss, the Spirit still protects and sustains the spiritual life amidst the numberless snares of malignant spirits and the deadly poison of sin; and supplies such vital influence to believers, that even in the greatest weakness they do not yield the victory to the enemy, but though cast down, renew the contest on their knees. Such is the efficacy of the Spirit, in short, in all these operations, that he gives a noble elevation to their mental faculties, and makes them capable of views, desires, efforts, and achievements, which evidently exceed the capacity of those who are destitute of the Spirit. The order in which he operates, too, is such, that he imparts his comforts only to those who are contrite in heart, and seriously grieved for their sins;199 and he never cheers their minds with his sweet consolations, without inciting them, at the same time, to the love of God, to fervent gratitude, and to the practice of the most conscientious piety. When these things are connected in this manner and order, a man has no cause to doubt of the Spirit’s having been imparted to himself.

XLI. It serves also in no inconsiderable degree to heighten the value of this gift, that it cannot be lost. “I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for ever.”200 The presence of the Lord Jesus was exceedingly dear and precious to the Apostles. But how dear soever it was, they were at last to be deprived of it. Nay, it was expedient for them that their Lord should go away, that he might give place to that Comforter and Advocate, who should both do greater things than Christ’s bodily presence had done, and was never to depart.201 And why should he depart? Because he is expelled by force? He is the Spirit of God, against whom the spirit of the world and the spirit of hell cannot prevail. Or because he meets with ungrateful treatment from believers? He is sometimes grieved indeed by their sins: but then he also grieves them in his turn, that having excited them to a salutary penitence, he may continue to seal them unto the day of redemption.202 With regard to the infusion of his consolations, and the communication of alacrity in the spiritual life, he withdraws, we admit, for a time; yet he remains for ever as the fountain of life, and the bond of union with Christ. He is “the anointing which abideth,”203 and “a well of water springing up to everlasting life.”204205—All these considerations serve clearly to demonstrate the inexpressible greatness of the love of God in giving us his Holy Spirit.

XLII. But we ought also to consider the duties which we owe to this Spirit of God. 1st, Since the Spirit is the Most High God, let us treat the Scriptures given by his inspiration with profound reverence, no less than if we heard a present God, addressing us immediately from heaven. Every affront that is done to the Prophets and Apostles, strikes against the Spirit of God.206 2dly, Let us receive with becoming reverence his internal reproofs, counsels, and convictions; neither daring to make the least resistance, nor presuming to linger when he stimulates. This were to grieve the Holy Spirit, by giving him ground of offence, and causing him to withhold his accustomed delights, and to cease for a time to operate as a Spirit of consolation and joy.207 3dly, Let us carefully watch over this sacred fire, that it be not extinguished either in ourselves or in others,208 but rather stirred up.209 4thly, Let us consecrate ourselves as temples to the Spirit, and preserve them holy and pure.210

Notes

Note LIII. Page 305.

It is scarcely necessary to remark, that the terms Spirit and Ghost are entirely synonymous. “The name of Ghost or Gast,” says Pearson, “in the ancient Saxon language, signifieth a Spirit.”211 “Ghost,” says Secker to the same effect, “in the ancient use of our language, denoted the same thing, which Spirit doth now; a substance different from body or matter. Indeed we still use it in expressing the departure of the spirit from the body, which we call giving up the ghost; and in speaking of supposed apparitions of the spirits of persons after their decease.”212

Our Author does not stop to inquire into the various senses of the word spirit, when employed with reference to creatures; but confines himself to a short statement of its different acceptations with regard to what is strictly Divine.—The proper meaning of this term, and of the corresponding words in Hebrew and Greek, according to Parkhurst,213 is “air in motion,” or, as Witsius expresses it, “a gale of wind.” Our Author considers this designation as given to the Spirit, not merely on account of the resemblance that may be traced between his agency on the human soul and the agency of air and wind in the material creation, but also on account of the manner of his eternal and incomprehensible procession. In this view, it may be noticed, he agrees with Dr Owen; who, in his elaborate Treatise on the Holy Spirit, when explaining the import of the term, has the following remark: “As the vital breath of a man has a continual emanation from him, and yet is never separated utterly from his person, or forsaketh him; so doth the Spirit of the Father and the Son proceed from them by a continual divine emanation, still abiding one with them.”214

We have no cause to be offended at the figurative language regarding the Divine Persons, which occurs in sacred writ. It becomes us, on the contrary, to adore the goodness of God in “using similitudes,” relative to those high points which far surpass our comprehension, but some imperfect knowledge of which is of great value and importance. If the terms Father and Son, which the Scriptures apply to the First and Second Persons in the Godhead, carry an allusion to a certain interesting human relation, we need not think it strange, that the designation by which the Third Person in the Trinity is known, and which seems to refer to the eternal relation subsisting between Him and the other two adorable Persons, alludes to a gale of wind, or rather to the human breath. In both cases, the metaphor falls infinitely short of the sublime topic which it is employed to illustrate: and we must guard against abusing the divine condescension, by entertaining gross, unworthy, and erroneous conceptions, which those figurative expressions were never intended to convey. It is necessary, for example, to fortify our minds against every idea repugnant to the true personality of the Holy Spirit. Were any one to allege, that, because the Father is called a rock, a shield, and a consuming fire, a doubt is cast on the Father’s personality; or, that, because the Son is represented as the Word of God, the light of the world, a foundation, and a vine, the personality of the Son is uncertain,—it would be universally acknowledged, that the allegation is utterly false and absurd. But to draw any conclusion hostile to the real personality of the Holy Spirit from those passages of Scripture in which material and irrational objects, as wind, breath, water, oil, a seal, and a dove, are made use of to illustrate his character and operations, would be equally preposterous.

Note LIV. Page 309.

The Personality of the Holy Spirit was denied at an early period of the Christian Church. In the fourth Century, the sect of the Pneumatomachians, or Macedonians, was formed by Macedonius, Bishop of Constantinople, an eminent Semi-arian Doctor, who taught that the Holy Spirit is “a divine energy diffused throughout the universe, and not a person distinct from the Father and the Son.” This error was solemnly condemned by the council of Constantinople, in the year 381.215

Our Author establishes the personality of the Spirit by solid arguments concisely expressed, and makes satisfactory replies to the most important objections of adversaries. That personal characters and operations are often attributed to the Spirit in the sacred volume, is quite undeniable; but the enemies of the doctrine very boldly and speciously allege, that this is done merely by the figure of speech called personification. The futility of this exception is briefly pointed out by Witsius; and those who are desirous to see a more minute refutation of it may consult Dr Owen,216 and also Dr Wardlaw’s comprehensive Sermon on the Divinity and Personality of the Holy Spirit.217 The learned reader will find an interesting argument for the personality of the Spirit, in Dr Middleton’s Note on Mat. i. 18.218 from which the following is a short extract.

“It may here be briefly noticed, that in the passages, which, from their ascribing personal acts to the πνευμα ἁγιον, are usually adduced to prove the Personality of the Blessed Spirit, the words πνευμα and πνευμα ἁγιον invariably have the article. See particularly Mark i. 10. Luke iii. 22. John i. 32. Acts i. 16. and xx. 28. Ephes. iv. 20. Mark xiii. 11. Acts x. 9. and xxviii. 25. 1 Tim. iv. 1. Heb. iii. 7. &c. The reason of this is obvious; for there being but one Holy Spirit, he could not be spoken of indefinitely. In Matt. also xxviii. 19. where the Holy Spirit is associated with the Father and the Son, the reading is του ἁγιου πνευματος.” The ingenious writer goes on to show, that, where πνευμα means not the Person of the Spirit, but his influence or operation, “a remarkable difference may be observed with respect to the Article.” “Though the Holy Spirit himself be but one, his influences and operations may be many: hence πνευμα and πνευμα ἁγιον are in this sense anarthrous,” (i. e. without the article,) “the case of renewed mention or of reference being of course excepted. The expressions of being ‘filled with the Holy Ghost,’ ‘receiving the Holy Ghost,’ ‘the Holy Ghost being upon one,’ &c. justify this observation.”

Note LV. Page 311.

It is perhaps somewhat difficult to determine the precise meaning of that expression in Acts x. 32, “The word of his grace.” Henry and Guyse seem inclined to apply it both to Christ and to the Gospel: Beza and Doddridge understand it to mean simply the Gospel: but Gomar219 and our Author are quite decided in referring the expression to our Saviour. This interpretation is supported by Witsius, not only here, but also in a separate Dissertation on the Logos.220 In that Dissertation, his concluding argument is thus expressed:—

“The succeeding words of the verse cannot be referred to God, without imagining an unnecessary hyperbaton;221 and they do not suit the Gospel, which neither builds us up on a foundation, nor gives us an inheritance, but is the instrument by which Christ builds us on himself, and by which the inheritance and the way of obtaining it are revealed. But these expressions are perfectly applicable to Christ; for he builds the church on himself, and preserves it, Matt. xvi. 18. Heb. iii. 3. and also gives us an inheritance, Col. iii. 24.”

Our Author at the same time shows, that, though it were conceded, that not our Saviour, but the Gospel, is intended by “the word of his grace,” the passage where this phrase occurs cannot invalidate his argument from Matt. xxviii. 19, in favour of the personality of the Holy Spirit.

Note LVI. Page 324.

To the Author’s able illustration and defence of the argument for the Divinity of the Spirit, founded on Acts v. 3, 4, the following excellent quotation from a living writer, relative to the same topic, may fitly be subjoined.

“The conduct of Ananias was farther aggravated by the dignity of the person against whom it was an offence. Thou hast not lied unto men, but unto God. He had indeed lied unto men, in attempting to deceive the Apostles; but Peter means that he had not lied only to them. It is observable that, whereas he affirms in the preceding verse that Ananias had lied to the Holy Ghost, he now charges him with having lied to God. It follows that the Holy Ghost is not a creature, nor a rhetorical name for a divine operation or influence, but a person possessed of proper Divinity. It is to no purpose to object to this inference, that an equivalent phrase is used where it is manifest that the same conclusion cannot be drawn from it. When the Israelites murmured for want of flesh against Moses and Aaron, they are said to have murmured against God, Exod. xvi. 8. The instances are not parallel. In the latter case, the Israelites were guilty of murmuring against God, because they fretted at Moses and Aaron his ministers; but in the former, Ananias is said not only to have lied to the Holy Ghost because he lied to the Apostles who were inspired by him, but to have lied to God in lying to the Holy Ghost; a charge which would not have been true, unless both designations had belonged to the same person. In this then consisted the greatness of his sin, that it was an insult offered to the Spirit of truth and holiness, speaking and acting in the ambassadors of Christ. Every lie which is told to men is an offence against God, of whose law it is an express violation; but the proper object of this lie was the Holy Ghost, who was present with the Apostles in a manner totally different from the mode of his presence with any other person.”222

Witsius, with great candour, admits that in Scripture “it is no where said expressly, and in so many words, The Holy Spirit is the Most High God.”223 Yet surely, whoever reads with attention Acts v. 3, 4, must acknowledge, it is not without cause that Dr Owen, when proceeding to illustrate the argument which that passage supplies, says of the Spirit, “He is expressly called God—;”224 nor is it altogether unjustly, that Mr Jones225 combats the assertion of Dr Clarke in his Scripture Doctrine of the Trinity, “that the Person of the Holy Ghost is no where in Scripture expressly styled God.” The Divinity, as well as Personality, of the Spirit is proved at large by Dr Owen in the valuable work already referred to. Both these points, too, are ably treated by Bishop Pearson,226 and by Dr Barrow.227

Note LVII. Page 335. line 18.

The argument for the Divinity of the Spirit, which our Author derives from the representation given in Scripture of the unpardonable sin, is at once cogent in itself, and very judiciously stated. The Personality, also, of the Spirit, is obviously confirmed by the same argument. On this point, Theologians have properly noticed the use of the same expression with reference to the Son and Spirit. “When the sin of blasphemy is said to be committed against the Holy Spirit,” says Dr Barrow, “just in the same form of speech as against the Son, it is signified that the Holy Spirit is in the same manner a Person as the Son is a Person; otherwise the comparison would not seem to be well framed.”228

The subject does not render it necessary to attempt any discussion of the various questions that have been agitated relative to the blasphemy against the Holy Spirit.—Many writers, as Gouge,229 Pool, and Tillotson,230 have thought that our Lord, in Matt. xii. and Mark iii. represents the Pharisees as having at that time actually incurred the guilt of this crime, by perversely ascribing his miracles to diabolical agency. But Dr Whitby, in an elaborate Appendix to the 12th Chapter of Matthew, has endeavoured to prove that Christ intimates, this sin could not be committed till after the commencement of that dispensation of the Spirit which was to succeed his ascension, and that he only gave the Pharisees a necessary warning against the commission of it. In these views, Whitby has been followed by Guyse231 and Doddridge.232

Many have supposed, that it was only during the age of miracles, that men could involve themselves in the guilt of this unpardonable sin against the Spirit. This seems to have been the opinion of Secker.233 The remarks of Pool, on the other side of the question, are worthy of attention.234 Yet it is much to be regretted that, owing to bodily disorders or strong temptations, serious persons have often exceedingly distressed their minds by the rash and ill-founded conclusion, that they had themselves committed the sin against the Holy Ghost, and that consequently their condition was utterly desperate. Peace be to the man, whose benevolent and judicious efforts are exerted to convince such unhappy individuals of their error, to dispel the clouds which obstruct their peace, and to administer that consolation which the rich promises and gracious invitations of the Gospel are calculated to impart! The reader who is disposed to study this subject may consult, beside the writers already mentioned, Owen’s Exposition of the Hebrews, Ch. vi. 4–6. x. 26–29, and Maestricht’s Theology.235

Note LVIII. Page 335. line 26.

In the authorised English Translation, the passage quoted by our Author from Hag. ii. 4, 5, is thus expressed: “I am with you, saith the Lord of Hosts. According to the word that I covenanted with you when you came out of Egypt, so my Spirit remaineth among you.” The version given by Witsius, however, is equally agreeable to the original; and it corresponds with the manner in which the words are rendered by Tremellius and Junius, who translate them thus: “I am with you, saith Jehovah of hosts, with the Word, by whom I covenanted with you when you came out of Egypt, and with my Spirit remaining among you.”236 By giving the term Word in capital letters, these Translators, without doubt, intended to intimate that they consider it as meaning the Messiah; and on this subject, Junius makes the following remarks: “Whoever interpret this passage otherwise, are obliged either to introduce a most unpleasant confusion237 into these two verses quite foreign to the scope of the Prophet, or to do violence to the particle which the Prophet here makes use of. For our part, knowing that, with the progress of time, the mysteries of God were more and more clearly discovered to the Prophets and declared to the church, we maintain, agreeably to the obvious meaning of the expression and the scope of the argument, that God the Father promises his presence to the church, with Christ, and with the Holy Spirit.”238

Witsius himself particularly vindicates this interpretation elsewhere. “The Son,” says he, “is truly the Word in whom God covenanted with the Israelites when they came out of Egypt. The expression אשר ברת is capable of being translated two ways; either in whom or of whom he covenanted.239 If we choose the first, it will be signified that he is the Word, by whose mediation God covenanted with the Israelites when they came out of Egypt. This indeed is the Angel who appeared to Moses in the bush, who called himself the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, Exod. iii. 2, 6. and whose good-will is mentioned by Moses as the source of every blessing, Deut. xxxiii. 16. But if we prefer the last explanation, the sense will be, that this is the Word whom God by a sure covenant promised to send to his people. The expression, too, may then be compared with Exod. xxiii. 20, and Deut. xviii. 19, where God promises to send to Israel the Angel, in whom is his name; and to raise up to them a Prophet, in whose mouth he should put his words. Whichever of these two ways of rendering the words be adopted, the expression still refers to the Son of God, by whose mediation, and concerning whom, God spoke of old to the people; and who came to that temple of which Haggai speaks, and remained with his Spirit in the midst of the people.”240

Note LIX. Page 339.

The vital and mystical Union formed between Christ and believers, is one of the most remarkable and happy effects of the Spirit’s agency. Although the Author here directs our attention to the “delightful reciprocation of mutual love,” probably he did not intend to represent the mystical union as consisting properly and directly in mutual affection. “There is a moral union,” says a venerable writer, “of mutual affection between him and believers; which is more properly communion, John xiv. 21.”241 By the mystical union, a most intimate relation is constituted betwixt Christ and the persons of his people. The proper bond of this union, on our part, is faith, that faith which firmly credits the divine testimony respecting him, and receives him with all his blessings. Yet it must not be forgotten that “faith worketh by love,” and that a blessed fellowship of love is the never-failing consequence of this real and important, though mysterious, union.

Our Author passes over in silence the various natural and artificial conjunctions from which illustrations of this spiritual union are borrowed in sacred writ, and only takes notice of its resemblance to the union of the Three Persons in the same Divine essence. In some respects, indeed, it widely differs from that incomprehensible and glorious union. The three Divine Persons are eternally and necessarily one; but this relation between Christ and his people, though appointed from eternity, is formed in time, and is the effect of the good pleasure of the divine will. The persons in the godhead, besides, are one essentially, having one common essence or nature; whereas the union betwixt Christ and the faithful is by no means an essential union. It makes no change on his or on their essence; for though they are transformed into his image, and advanced in due season to a seat with him on his throne, they still continue men, and he continues Immanuel, God with us. Our Lord’s expression, nevertheless, in John xvii. 21. appears to intimate that the union subsisting betwixt himself and all his genuine followers, doth, in fact, bear some resemblance, in point of nearness and perpetuity, to the union between the Father and Him; and that the reciprocal love which the Redeemer and the redeemed exercise towards each other, how far soever from equalling, doth, in reality, resemble the mutual love which the Divine Persons unceasingly entertain for one another.

On the reality, nature, and importance of the union between Christ and believers, the reader may consult Maestricht,242 the excellent Letters of Dickinson,243 and the lively remarks of M‘Ewen.244

Note LX. Page 342.

In accordance with the practical tendency and design of all his Dissertations on the Creed, Witsius not merely demonstrates the Personality and Divinity of the Holy Spirit, but points out the vast importance of the Spirit’s indwelling in Christians, and of his gracious operations on their hearts and conduct.

The agency of the Divine Spirit in the work of redemption is extensive and diversified. What he did immediately with regard to the Saviour himself, in forming his holy human nature in the womb of the Virgin, furnishing him with every requisite endowment, and resting on him during the whole period of his abasement to animate and strengthen him in the prosecution of his arduous work; and what he has done, and continues to do, with reference even to the external means of salvation, in the inspiration of the Scriptures, in calling, qualifying, and directing Prophets, Apostles, and ordinary teachers, and in the various outward confirmations by which he establishes the truth,—is highly deserving of attention. On these subjects, and other points connected with them, which are not included in the plan of our respected Author in this Dissertation, much solid instruction is contained in Dr Owen’s excellent Treatise on the Holy Spirit.245—On the reality and necessity of the influences of the Spirit, and their salutary effects in the regeneration, and the progressive holiness and comfort of the elect, see Owen, M‘Laurin,246 and Wardlaw.247

In the Section to which this Note is annexed, the Author speaks of the Spirit as a Comforter, and mentions several ways in which he discharges this office. The Greek word rendered Comforter,248 it is well known, generally signifies an Advocate in the classic writers; and the term is, with propriety, thus translated in 1 John ii. 1. where it is applied to our Saviour, who pleads the cause of sinners with his Father. In those passages of Christ’s consolatory discourse to the disciples (John xiv. xv. xvi.) where it is used with reference to the Holy Spirit, Beza has thought proper to render it Advocatus. Whitby, in a Note on John xvi. 7. explains it, when applied to the Spirit, as meaning both an Advocate and a Comforter. But Dr Campbell, in an excellent Note on John xiv. 16. strongly objects to the rendering of the word in that passage an Advocate; and whilst he considers the term Comforter, which our translators have employed, as preferable, he adduces apparently cogent arguments to show, that it should be rendered a Monitor, instructor, or guide.

Our Author states, that the Spirit comforts believers, 1st, as he is the seal of the divine love to them; and 2dly, as he is the earnest of their inheritance. These characters are explained somewhat more fully in his work on the Covenants;249 and the remarks of Dr Owen on the same topics may be compared with those of Witsius. He observes, 3dly, that the Spirit comforts the saints by secretly witnessing with their spirits. On this subject also he dwells more particularly in the work just referred to.250 It is treated largely by President Dickinson, in a Sermon entitled, the Witness of the Spirit.251 The celebrated Walker, too, avows his sentiments on this topic in the following terms:252 “Believers have not all of them an equal assurance of their salvation. Though they are all persuaded that he who believeth shall be saved, yet every one cannot say for himself, I am persuaded that I believe, and therefore I shall be saved. Before a person can say this, there must be a farther work of the Spirit of God, even a divine light shining upon our faith and other graces, and making them visible to ourselves. We may derive a good ground of hope253 from a strict and careful examination of our own temper and practice, but cannot arrive at a full assurance, till, as the Apostle expresses it, Romans viii. 16, ‘the Spirit himself bear witness with our spirits, that we are the sons of God.’ But when this divine Witness concurs with his testimony, irradiating his own workmanship within us, and discovering to our own minds such lineaments of the new creature as plainly evidence that we are born of God, then our assurance is full and complete.” Even Whitby has the following expressions with regard to the consoling operation of the Spirit: “In respect of the apostles and the faithful, he also did the part of a Comforter, as being sent for their consolation and support in all their troubles, filling their hearts with joy and gladness, and giving them an inward testimony of God’s love to them, and an assurance of their future happiness, Rom. viii. 15, 16.”254—Witsius remarks, 4thly, that the Spirit, in fine, takes hold of believers as if by the hand, and introduces them to the chambers and embraces of the King. But these expressions, it is evident, must not be literally understood. They no doubt refer to that efficacious operation of the Spirit, which accompanies the spiritual light he imparts, and by which the saints are happily determined to receive the heavenly consolations brought near them in Christ and his ordinances. The Scripture itself represents the children of God as led by the Spirit.

It is matter of sincere regret, that the doctrine of the sanctifying and comforting operations of the Holy Spirit has ever been disfigured, or exposed to suspicion and obloquy, by the ridiculous notions and enthusiastical extravagances with which it has sometimes been blended.255 No man of intelligence, however, will reject the wheat, because it has been mingled with chaff. Those “hard speeches” and contemptuous sneers relative to the Spirit and his work, in which some professed Christians have indulged, are truly deplorable.

Whether men are pleased to believe or disbelieve, to approve or revile the doctrine, the gracious and sovereign agency, as well as divinity and personality of the blessed Spirit, must rank among the most undoubted and essential articles of our holy faith. Let every individual, who feels the least concern respecting his own eternal interest, be solicitous to obtain the presence and saving operations of the Holy Ghost; and let it be the earnest and unceasing prayer of the pious, that the Spirit of God may be “poured out upon all flesh.” It is delightful to think, that the attention of Christians has of late been more than usually directed to the character and agency of this Divine Person, and that they have united to a great extent, in presenting their fervent supplications at the throne of grace for a copious effusion of his influence, to accompany the generous and active exertions now happily employed for the propagation of Christianity throughout the earth.

Note LXI. Page 344.

The Author’s illustration of the impossibility of the true Christian’s utterly losing the invaluable gift of the Holy Spirit, clearly shows his belief of the doctrine, that all genuine saints are effectually preserved from total and final apostasy. This topic is discussed at some length in his Economy of the Covenants.256 Specious objections have been urged against the final perseverance of believers; but they have all received satisfactory replies.257 The conscientious vigilance against apostasy discovered by eminent saints, and the cautions against it contained in the Scriptures, have in vain been referred to by the opposers of this doctrine. The Apostle’s expression in 1 Cor. ix. 27. seems to be quoted by a distinguished writer on the truth of Christianity as “a full answer out of the mouth of Paul himself,” to the evidence which his writings afford in support of immutable election and final perseverance.258 But Paul’s meaning, we presume, has been mistaken. Although he says, “I keep under my body, and bring it into subjection, lest that by any means when I have preached unto others, I myself should be a castaway,” his words are far from implying that he lived under continual apprehensions of total apostasy and final reprobation. Paul, on the contrary, maintained the cheering persuasion, that nothing whatever could separate him from the love of God in Christ.259 The words intimate merely, that the Apostle knew that the practice of true holiness, and the possession of future happiness, are graciously and inseparably connected; and that there is a connexion equally inseparable between living under the dominion of corrupt propensities on earth, and suffering the miseries of hell; and that he was aware of the necessity of due self-control as an appointed means of escaping the doom of the impenitently wicked. In this high concern, Paul only conducted himself on principles similar to those which influenced his behaviour in less momentous affairs. While he was a prisoner in the castle of Antonio at Jerusalem, the Lord assured him in a vision by night, that as he had testified of him in Jerusalem, so he should bear witness also at Rome. Yet, when he received information that forty men had bound themselves by a dreadful oath that they should neither eat nor drink till they had killed him, he employed his nephew to communicate the intelligence of this black conspiracy to the chief captain, and used every proper means in his power for the preservation of his life.260 Thus, in matters relating both to this world and the world to come, Paul, while he firmly relied on God’s absolute promises, did not neglect the proper means of safety. But the strong terms in which he expresses his holy vigilance, involve nothing prejudicial to the doctrine of final perseverance.

Nor is a shadow of doubt thrown upon this doctrine by the numerous exhortations to constancy, and cautions against apostasy, contained in the Scriptures. Many of those exhortations and cautions refer to the partial falls and temporary declensions to which true Christians are in reality liable, and against which a regard to the glory of God, as well as their own comfort, should induce them strictly to guard. But even when total apostasy is referred to in such passages, let it be observed, that all these cautions proceed on the principle, that while the decree and promise of God infallibly secure the perseverance of real Christians, there are nevertheless instituted means of perseverance, which must be carefully improved. In the gracious purpose and promise of Jehovah, as has been often observed, the means and the end are inseparably connected. The continued activity of Christians themselves in prosecuting a course of faith and holy obedience, in humble dependance on the powerful aids of the Spirit, is the proper and appointed means of perseverance.

Angels in heaven are confirmed in holiness, and assured that they cannot sin; yet it is still their indispensable duty to persist with care in their course of obedience; and were it possible for them to lay aside this care, that very security would effect their destruction. Our Lord himself discovered a holy solicitude to accomplish the work which the Father gave him to do on the earth. Who will dare to affirm, that the perseverance of Christ was, in any degree, uncertain? His unwearied fidelity was infallibly secured by his personal dignity, by the Father’s promises,261 and by the Spirit that rested upon him without measure. So certain was his perseverance, that, on the ground of his honourably finishing in due time the work of redemption, thousands were justified and glorified before his coming in the flesh. Yet what activity and zeal did the Saviour discover in offering up prayers and supplications to his Father; in resisting the numerous temptations to which he was exposed from devils and men; in exercising faith and patience; in short, in making every exertion to persevere to the end and finish his work! In like manner, though the final perseverance of real converts is absolutely certain, it is incumbent upon them, after the example of their Lord, to watch and pray, and make a diligent use of every mean of perseverance. And since this is their unquestionable and necessary duty, it is highly proper that they should be earnestly and repeatedly excited to perform it, by such cautions and exhortations as those that have now been referred to.

It is not intended, however, to prosecute the subject further. The replies to objections which have just been given, by way of specimen, are in a great measure due to Edwards.

1 Job xxxii. 8.

2 1 Cor. ii. 10.

3 2 Pet. i. 21.

4 Ephes. i. 17.

5 As John iv. 24.

6 Mark ii. 8. 1 Cor. xv. 45. Rom. i. 4. 1 Tim. iii. 16. 1 Pet. iii. 18, 19.

7 Mat. xxviii. 19. 1 John v. 7.

8 Acts xix. 2.

9 רוח, πνεῦμα, spiritus.

10 Gen. viii. 1. John iii. 8.

11 Ps. xxxiii. 6.

12 Job xxxiii. 4. Comp. Is. xi. 4. 2 Thes. ii. 8.

13 John xx. 22.

14 John iii. 8. Acts ii. 2.

15 John iii. 6.

16 See Note LIII.

17 John xvii. 11.

18 Luke i. 35. Acts iv. 27.

19 Is. vi. 3.

20 1 Cor. vi. 11. 2 Thes. ii. 13.

21 Exod. xxxi. 13. Ezek. xx. 12. xxxvii. 28.

22 John xvii. 17. Comp. verse 11.

23 1 Cor. i. 30.

24 1 Cor. ii. 10, 11.

25 1 Pet. i. 11. 2 Pet. i. 21.

26 1 Cor. ii. 10.

27 Ch. xii. 11.

28 Verse 4.

29 Verse 5.

30 Verse 6.

31 1 Cor. viii. 6.

32 Mat. iii. 16.

33 Luke iii. 22.

34 James i. 17.

35 Acts ii. 3.

36 Acts viii. 39. xiii. 2. Rom. viii. 26. and elsewhere passim.

37 1 Cor. xiii.

38 Rom. vii. 11.

39 2 Cor. iii. 6.

40 See Note LIV.

41 Acts xx. 32. Comp. chap. xiv. 3.

42 Rev. iii. 12.

43 1 John i. 1.

44 1 Pet. v. 10.

45 Heb. x. 29.

46 1 Tim. i. 18. 2 Tim. ii. 2.

47 See Note LV.

48 Mat. iii. 11. Acts i. 5. 1 Cor. xii. 13.

49 Rom. xiii. 14. Gal. iii. 27.

50 John vi. 51.

51 Ἡ δύναμις Θεοῦ ἡ μεγαλη, Acts viii. 10.

52 1 Cor. i. 24.

53 הגבורה

54 מה השיב משה לפני הגבורה Cod. Sabbat.

55 Tisbi at the word גבר.

56 Lex Talm.

57 Ch. xiv. 62.

58 Luke iv. 14.

59 ’Αλλα λήψεσθει δύναμιν ἐπελθοντος του ἁγίου πνευματος ἐφ’ ὑμάς, Acts i. 8.

60 Luke xi. 13. John xiv. 16, 17. Rom. v. 5. John xx. 22.

61 Gen. xv. 1.

62 Lament. iii. 24. Jer. x. 16.

63 Is. ix. 6. John iii. 16.

64 John i. 12. Col. ii. 6.

65 Ephes. iii. 17.

66 2 Cor. iii. 6.

67 1 Cor. xii. 3.

68 Rom. viii. 9.

69 James iv. 12.

70 Verse 3.

71 Comp. Acts ii. 4.

72 Verses 8, 9.

73 Rom. viii. 9.

74 Acts xvii. 25, 28.

75 1 Cor. ii. 13.

76 Chap. iii. 7.

77 John xv. 26.

78 John xvi. 14.

79 2 Pet. i. 19, 20, 21.

80 Deut. xxxii. 12.

81 Ex. xvii. 7.

82 Is. lxiii. 14.

83 Verse 10.

84 Is. vi.

85 Acts xxviii. 25, 26.

86 John xii. 41.

87 Is. vi. 6.

88 2 Sam. xxiii. 2, 3.

89 Ananiæ dici quod mentitus sit Deo, non dici quod mentitus sit Spiritui Sancto: sed quod mentitus sit Spiritum Sanctum.

90 Ψεύσασθαι σε το πνεῦμα το ἅγιον.

91 Chap. iv. 8.

92 Of many examples that might be given, let the four following suffice. Is. lvii. 11. Τίνα ἐυλαβηθεῖσα ἐφοβήθης καὶ ἐψεύσω με. Euripid. in Iphigen. ‘Ημας δ’ ὁ φοῖβος, μαντις ἀν, ἐψεύσατο. Joseph. Antiq. lib. iii. cap. 10. Ψευσαμένη τὸν ἄνδρα ἐπι τοῖς γαμοις, και τὸν Θεόν ἐπι τοῖς ὁρκοις. Herodian, lib. ii. cap. 10. Πρὸς δε των ἐκει στρατιωτῶν, ‘ους ἐψεύσατο, ὀυκ ἔτι πιστεύεται. In all these quotations, the word in question is construed with the Accusative, and can have no other signification than to lie, or to impose upon.

93 Verse 9.

94 See Note LVI.

95 Heb. ix. 14.

96 See Vol. I. Note XXXVIII.

97 Heb. vii. 16.

98 Heb. x. 10.

99 Lev. vi. 12.

100 Dan. vii. 10.

101 Song viii. 6, 7.

102 Rom. xv. 16.

103 1 Thes. v. 19.

104 Gen. i. 2.

105 Ps. cxxxix. 7.

106 Anonym. in Catena Græca.

107 Exod. xxiii. 20.

108 Ex. xxxiii. 2, 3.

109 Verse 14.

110 לפני Mal. iii. 1.

111 John xiv. 9.

112 שם אתה, “thou art there,” verse 8.

113 Verses 3, 4, 5.

114 1 Cor. ii. 10, 11.

115 Comp. Jer. xvii. 10. Ps. vii. 11.

116 1 Kings viii. 39.

117 Rom. xi. 33.

118 1 Cor. xii. 11.

119 Is. xl. 26, 28. xliv. 24. Job ix. 8.

120 Gen. i. 2.

121 Comp. Deut. xxxii. 11.

122 Συνεθαλπε και ζωογονει την τῶν ὑδατων φυσιν, κατα την εἰκονα της ἐπωαζουσης ὀρνιθος. Hexaem. Homil. ii.

123 Chagiga, cap. ii. fol. 15.

124 Job xxvi. 13.

125 Job xxxiii. 4.

126 James i. 18.

127 John iii. 5, 6.

128 See Is. xliv. 3.

129 Tit. iii. 5.

130 Is. xlviii. 1.

131 Tit. iii. 5.

132 2 Cor. iii. 6.

133 Ezek. xx. 12. xxxvii. 28.

134 Ezek. xxxvi. 27.

135 1 Cor. vi. 11.

136 2 Thes. ii. 13.

137 Is. lix. 21.

138 Ps. lxxii. 18.

139 Rom. xv. 19. See also 1 Cor. xii. 9, 10.

140 Mat. xii. 28.

141 Chap. ix. 38.

142 2 Cor. xiii. 14.

143 Rev. i. 4, 5.

144 Rev. iv. 5.

145 Exod. xxv. 31.

146 Is. xi. 2.

147 Rev. iv. 5.

148 Rev. v. 6.

149 Gal. iv. 6. Rom. viii. 9.

150 Rom. v. 5.

151 Rev. xix. 10. xxii. 9.

152 Mat. xxviii. 19.

153 Is. xxxiii. 22.

154 1 Pet. iii. 21.

155 1 Cor. i. 13.

156 1 Cor. iii. 16.

157 Chap. vi. 19.

158 1 Kings v. 3, 4.

159 Is. lxiii. 18.

160 Jer. xvii. 12.

161 Ps. xxix. 9.

162 שכינה

163 2 Cor. vi. 16. Ephes. ii. 21, 22.

164 Heb. iii. 7, 8, 9.

165 Mat. xii. 31, 32. Heb. x. 26, 29.

166 See Note LVII.

167 See also Mat. xxviii. 19. 2 Cor. xiii. 14.

168 See Note LVIII.

169 1 John v. 7.

170 John xiv. 16, 17.

171 גם היום מגיד משנה אשיב לך Ch. ix. 12.

172 John xiv. 26. xvi. 13.

173 Verse 9.

174 1 Cor. ii. 12.

175 Rom. viii. 9.

176 1 Cor. vi. 19.

177 1 John iv. 13.

178 John vi. 63.

179 2 Cor. iv. 6.

180 Rom. vi. 19.

181 Rom. viii. 1. Gal. v. 25.

182 1 Cor. xii. 13.

183 1 Cor. vi. 17.

184 See Note LIX.

185 Song vi. 3.

186 John xvii. 21.

187 1 Cor. iii. 22, 23.

188 Is. liii. 4.

189 John xvi. 14.

190 Luke xv. 31.

191 Ephes. i. 13.

192 2 Cor. i. 21, 22.

193 Ephes. i. 14.

194 Rom. viii. 23.

195 1 Cor. ii. 12.

196 Rom. viii. 16.

197 See Note LX.

198 John xiv. 17.

199 Is. lvii. 15.

200 John xiv. 16.

201 John xvi. 7.

202 Ephes. iv. 30.

203 1 John ii. 27.

204 John iv. 14.

205 See Note LXI.

206 Acts vii. 51. Is. lxiii. 10.

207 Ephes. iv. 30.

208 1 Thes. v. 19.

209 2 Tim. i. 6, 7.

210 1 Cor. iii. 16, 17. vi. 19, 20.

211 Expos. of Creed, Art. viii. p. 308.

212 Works, Vol. iv. Lect. 13. pp. 317, 318.

213 Hebrew Lex. on רוח, and Greek Lex. on πνευμα.

214 Book i. ch. 2. sect. 9.

215 Mosheim’s Eccles. Hist. Cent. iv. chap. 5. sect. 20.

216 Discourse on the Holy Spirit, Book i. chap. 3.

217 Discourses on the Socin. Controv. pp. 205–207.

218 Doctrine of the Greek Article, &c. pp. 165–170.

219 Pool’s Synopsis, in loc.

220 Miscel. Sac. Tom. ii. Exercit. iii. περι του λογου, sect. 39.

221 A Hyperbaton is a figure of speech, by which the words are transposed from the plain grammatical order. T.

222 Dr Dick’s Lectures on the Acts, Vol. i. Lect. vi. p. 129.

223 Sect. 16.

224 Treatise on the Spirit, Book i. ch. 3. sect. 31.

225 Catholic Doctrine of the Trinity, p. 37.

226 Expos. of the Creed, Art. viii.

227 Works, Vol. ii. Ser. 34. pp. 358–371. 3d edit.

228 Works, Vol. ii. p. 363.

229 Treatise on the Sin against the Holy Ghost, subjoined to the Whole Armour of God, p. 607.

230 Vol. i. Ser. 17.

231 Paraph. on Matt. xii. 31, 32. and Mark iii. 29.

232 Fam. Expos. Vol. ii. Sect. 61. Note p.

233 Works, Vol. iv. p. 324.

234 Annot. on Mat. xii. 32.

235 Lib. iv. cap. 3. sect. 16, 17.

236 —Sum enim vobiscum, dictum Jehovæ exercituum, Cum Verbo, quo pepigeram vobiscum exeuntibus vobis ex Ægypto, et Spiritu meo stante in vobis.

237 Συγχυσιν durissimam.

238 Pool’s Synopsis, in loc.

239 As in John i. 46. Ὁν ἐγραψε Μωσῆς, “of whom Moses wrote,” and Exod. xxxiii. 1.—“Unto the land אשר נשבעתי, of which I sware.”

240 Miscel. Sac. Tom. ii. Exercit. iii. sect. 19.

241 Brown’s Compendious View, Book v. chap. i. p. 380.

242 Theolog. lib. vi. cap. 5.

243 Familiar Letters to a Gentleman, Let. 17.

244 Select Essays, &c. pp. 36–40. 7th edit.

245 Book ii.

246 Sermons and Essays, p. 271. et seq.

247 On the Socinian Controversy, Diss. x. and xi.

248 Παρακλητος.

249 Book iii. ch. 13. sect. 34–37.

250 Book iii. ch. 11. sect. 24–39.

251 Sermons and Tracts, pp. 299–322.

252 Sermons on Practical Subjects, Vol. iv. Ser. 15. pp. 270, 271.

253 By a good ground of hope, the Preacher, it is clear, intended only good evidence of vital Christianity, or good reason to hope that we belong to the family of God.

254 Note on John xvi. 7.

255 Several instances of such enthusiasm are produced by Dr Magee in his justly celebrated work on the Atonement. He quotes, for example, (Vol. i. p. 160.) the following expression of the late Rev. John Wesley from Hampson’s Life of Wesley. “God doth now, as aforetime, give remission of sins, and the gift of the Holy Ghost to us, and that always suddenly, as far as I have known, and often in dreams and in the visions of God.” But how reprehensible soever these and similar statements may be, and of whatever importance it is to refute them by scriptural and solid arguments, it is lamentable that Dr Magee could suffer himself to feel or express regret, that the system of the Methodists “has not met with more effectual resistance from those who may be supposed to take an interest in the well-being of the establishment.” If by “those who may be supposed to take an interest in the well-being of the” episcopal “establishments” of England and Ireland, are meant the civil rulers of the empire, and if by “more effectual resistance” for checking the progress of Methodism in those countries, is intended stronger measures of a compulsory nature than any that have been resorted to, it is beyond measure sad and mortifying, to find a defender of the Christian atonement, so eminent for ability, learning, and worth, capable of entertaining such illiberal sentiments towards any class of Dissenters, whose character, as peaceable members of society, is most irreproachable. This, however, is not the only instance in which it has appeared, that an excessive zeal for the prosperity of civil establishments of religion “blindeth the eyes of the wise, and perverteth the words of the righteous.”

256 Book iii. ch. 13. On Conservation.

257 See Elisha Cole on God’s Sovereignty; Edwards’ Remarks on Important Theological Controversies, ch. v.; Dickinson’s Sermons and Tracts, pp. 273–296; Dwight’s Theology, Vol. i. Ser. 87, &c.

258 Lord Lyttelton’s Observations on the Conversion and Apostleship of St Paul, p. 24. Note.

259 Rom. viii. 30–39. 2 Cor. v. 1–8. 2 Tim. i. 12.

260 Acts xxiii. 11–22. See a similar instance, Ch. xxvii. 23–32.

261 See, for example, Psalm cx. 7. Isaiah xlii. 1, 4, 6. xlix. 3. lii. 13.