Sacred Dissertations on What Is Commonly Called the Apostles’ Creed (1823), Herman Witsius · PDF

Dissertation XIV. On Jesus Christ, Conceived of the Holy Ghost, and Born of the Virgin Mary

I. Amongst the precious promises with which the God of heaven was graciously pleased to favour the people of Israel, that in which he assured them that he should “walk in the midst of them,”1 is entitled to hold a distinguished place. The Lord made good this promise in various ways, and by several steps. 1st, He caused the tabernacle of the congregation to be erected, and the ark of the testimony and covenant to be made, and gave them to Israel as symbols of his special presence. With regard to the tabernacle he said: “This shall be a continual burnt-offering throughout your generations, at the door of the tabernacle of the congregation, before the Lord; where I will meet with you to speak there unto thee. And there I will meet with the children of Israel, and the tabernacle shall be sanctified by my glory.—And I will dwell amongst the children of Israel, and will be their God.”2 And Jehovah himself marched in the ark, in the sight of the people, to search out a resting-place for them.3 2dly, Besides that symbolical presence, he showed that he was near them, by his special favour and liberality, and by his readiness to succour them in every time of need; of which we read in the following passages: “Is not the Lord in Zion? Is not her King in her?”4 “God is in the midst of her; she shall not be moved.”5 “Thy paths drop fatness.”6 3dly, The above promise, however, was most signally accomplished, when, he prepared for himself a human body, and graciously visited his people, walking among them through the land of Israel. In reference to this visit it is said; “Sing and rejoice, O daughter of Zion, for, lo! I come, and I will dwell in the midst of thee, saith the Lord.”7 Zacharias also says with respect to it; “The day-spring from on high hath visited us;”8 and John,—“The word was made flesh, and dwelt among us.”9 The meaning of the Greek expression is, he conversed among us in the flesh, as in his own habitation or tabernacle, just as the Divine Shechinah dwelt of old in the temple. This mystery was called by the Fathers, his coming in the flesh.10 And since it is the foundation of our hope, and the source of all our joy, it becomes us to consider it with close attention.

II. Long before the incarnation took place, various preludes of it were exhibited to the ancient Church. There were symbols, amongst which the most remarkable was the ark of the covenant; of which the gold signified the eternity, glory, and dignity of the Divine nature of Christ, and the wood prefigured the meanness of the human nature, in reference to which he is called “the fruit of the earth.”11 There were also extatic visions, such as those with which Ezekiel,12 and Daniel,13 were honoured; in which God presented himself to view in a human, but an uncommonly splendid form; not to give occasion of sinning to Anthropomorphites,14 and Iconoplasts,15 but to exhibit in a prophetic figure the mystery of the wonderful incarnation. It was adumbrated, in particular, by those appearances of God to Abraham and others, in which, having assumed the form of the human nature, he was seen by them face to face, hospitably received, and entertained at their table. To this the following words of our Lord may be applied: “Your father Abraham rejoiced to see my day, and he saw it and was glad.”16 “The day of the Lord,” is his coming in the flesh.17 Abraham, having received a promise of that day, earnestly desired to see it: and this desire he, in some respects, obtained. He not only contemplated the incarnate Jehovah, and made him in a manner present, by the eye of faith; but also beheld him at hand, eating, drinking, and conversing familiarly with him, in that human form which he condescended to assume. The Messiah appeared in like manner to Jacob in the similitude of a man wrestling with him;18 to Joshua in the form of an armed man;19 to Gideon under an oak in Ophrah;20 and to Manoah and his wife.21 These appearances paved the way for the prophecy: “Thy watchmen lift up the voice, with the voice together do they sing; for they behold before their eyes;22 that is, they behold him that speaks, saying, Behold it is I.”2324

III. We, however, to whom the matter is related as a fact which has actually taken place, are bound to examine it more distinctly. We may refer what concerns it to four heads. i. The subject of the incarnation. ii. Its mode. iii. Its cause. iv. The fruit and benefit arising from it.

IV. The Subject of the incarnation, or he who became man, is not the Father, nor the Holy Spirit, but the Son alone. “The Word was made flesh.”25 “God sent forth his Son, made of a woman.”26 “Jesus Christ is come in the flesh.”27 Although the essence and operation of the three persons in the godhead are the same, the flesh was not assumed by the divine essence, but by a certain person. It was at least assumed by the divine essence, only as it is characterised, and, so to speak, restricted, in the person of the Son. Neither the Father, nor the Holy Spirit, indeed, was unconcerned in the incarnation of the Son. The glory of the whole adorable Trinity is displayed in the human nature of Christ.28 But though the Father is in the Son, he is not therefore incarnate with the Son; he is only in his incarnate Son.29 A body was formed to be the future residence of the Deity, by that will which is common to the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. But whilst it was determined by the will of the Father and the Holy Spirit that that body should belong to the Son, the Son, by the same will, determined that it should be his own; and thus by the united consent of all the Three, it could be the body of none but the Son.30

V. As to the question, Why the Son, and not the Father or the Spirit, assumed the human nature, it cannot be answered in a more satisfactory manner than by resolving it into the good pleasure of the Divine counsel, which is always distinguished by the most consummate wisdom. Yet, in consequence of the manifestation of that counsel to us in the Gospel, faith observes without difficulty, that it is most suitable to the Divine perfections, and most worthy of them. It is proper, in particular, 1st, That man should be regenerated and created anew,31 by the same person by whom he was created at first.32 2dly, That he who is the personal Word of God,33 should publish to us those words of God in which he promised to address us in the last days, and which none but the Lord could speak.34 3dly, That he who is the Son of God by nature, should make us the sons of God by grace. 4thly, That the glorious image of God should be restored within us by him who is “the image” of the Father,35 and “the express image of his person.”36 In fine, the unbounded love of the Father could not be more brightly demonstrated, than by giving his only-begotten Son to us, and for us.37

VI. With respect to the Mode of the incarnation, let us, in the first place, attend to its truth. The Son of God did not become man merely in appearance, but in reality.38 He had all the essential parts of a man,—a soul,39 and a body,40 which is expressly opposed to a phantom and spectre;41—and the faculties and affections of each,—in body, extension and palpability,42 and increase of stature43—in soul, a finite and limited understanding,44 and a will distinct from the Divine will.45 He had also experience of hunger,46 of thirst,47 and of sorrow,48 which expressed itself by tears.49 In short, the Son of man came eating and drinking,50 and was found in fashion as a man.51

VII. Further, the incarnation of the Son of God was effected, 1st, Not by a change of the Divinity into humanity, for it is altogether incapable of change.52 Most absurdly have some inconsiderate men restricted this perfection to the Deity of the Father: for the Divine nature is one only; immutability is clearly ascribed to God the Son;53 and even after becoming man, he continued God.54 2dly, Not by the confounding of both natures into one; for in Christ each nature remains distinct, and has its own distinct properties.55 3dly, Not by the creation of a human nature out of nothing, or by its descending from heaven; for then he would indeed have been man, but not the son of man, nor our kinsman, nor one of the brethren; which, as we shall show immediately, it was necessary for him to become. 4thly, Nor, in fine, by a shortlived form and representation56 in a body not personally united to himself; such as that in which, as we have just mentioned, he appeared of old; and that in which the pious ancients supposed, and not without reason, that the Father and the Holy Spirit also appeared.5758

VIII. But the incarnation of the Son of God was accomplished, by the assumption of the human nature into the individual unity of the Divine person. The Holy Spirit himself makes use of the term assumption, Philip. ii. 7. “He assumed the form of a servant, and was made in the likeness of men.”59 “The form of a servant” does not indeed signify precisely human nature as such; for although, after his resurrection, he laid aside the form of a servant, and although, no longer concealing his majesty, he now manifests himself as equal to God, he still retains the human nature. But “the form of a servant” denotes the debased condition of humanity, or human nature in a servile state. This humble form was assumed by our Lord, when he emptied himself, and began to exist in the likeness of men; still remaining what he was from eternity, “being in the form of God,” that is, truly God, and manifested, known, and acknowledged as such. The word form denotes the real thing itself, and that made manifest.

IX. The same truth is intimated Heb. ii. 14. “Forasmuch then as the children are partakers60 of flesh and blood, he also himself, likewise, took part of the same.”61 Christ has the same flesh and blood which the children have, but not in the same way with them. They are partakers of it; they possess the human nature in common, and have no other nature. But Christ took part of it; after he began to have flesh and blood like them, he possessed their nature in union with another nature which he had from eternity. He existed prior to that nature into the participation of which he then came; for he was “in the beginning, when the foundation of the earth was laid.”62

X. Nor did the Apostle intend any thing else, when he said, 1 Tim. iii. 16. “God was manifest in the flesh.” That is, he who is God, and could not cease to be what he was, was seen and heard, and handled in the flesh, in a human body actuated by a rational soul, which, as Athanasius expresses it, “he appropriated to himself as an instrument personally united to him,”63 with whose eyes he might see, with whose ears he might hear, with whose hands he might act, with whose feet he might walk among his people, and in which he might both suffer and be glorified, both die and revive: So that, on account of the very intimate union of that human nature with God the Son, the actions performed by it might be no less the actions of God than the creation or government of the universe, and it might be justly said of him when exhibited to view; “Lo! this is our God, we have waited for him, and he will save us; this is Jehovah, we have waited for him, we will be glad and rejoice in his salvation.”64 This expression of the Apostle corresponds with the language of the Prophet, “And the glory of the Lord shall be revealed.”65 To this prophecy John also alludes, when he says; “We beheld his glory.”66

XI. John i. 14. is to the same effect. “And the Word,” which was from the beginning, which was with God, and was God, “was made flesh,”67 began to be man: Not by a transmutation of the Divinity into humanity, but by so close a union of human flesh with himself, that that person who hitherto was nothing else than God, now also became man. A similar phrase occurs in the account of the creation of the first man;—“And man became a living soul:”68 which the Apostle renders thus, “The first man Adam was made a living soul.”69 Man had previously been a piece of dust; but after God had breathed into him the breath of life, “he was made a living soul,” not casting off the nature and qualities of dust, but receiving a soul. After the same manner, if we may compare human with Divine things, the Word was made flesh; not ceasing to be what he was, but receiving a human nature which he had not formerly possessed. The force of this expression did not escape the notice of the ancient Doctors. Tertullian observes that, “in particular, the very preface of John the Evangelist shows what he, who was pleased to be made flesh, had formerly been.”70

XII. Socinus urges that the expression should be translated, “And the Word was flesh.” This clause was added, he contends, lest any should infer from the metaphorical language John had employed when describing the dignity of the Word, that the Word was an incorporeal substance, or a divine and eternal nature. He alleges that the Evangelist plainly confesses he was flesh, a weak, despised, and sorrowful man, in order to obviate every doubt that might arise in the minds of his readers. And that none might think it strange that ἐγενετο, was made, is explained by ἠν, was, he adduces the expression, ὁς ἐγενετο ἀνηρ προφητης, which he renders, “who was a prophet.”71

XIII. But here, reason entirely abandons the heretic. John had not described Christ as a metaphorical divinity, but as “the true God,”72 and on that account distinct from all “that are called Gods.”73 Nor was it necessary for him to correct his expressions in any degree, to prevent us from forming too exalted sentiments of Christ; for all human thoughts, and all human language, fall far short of the dignity of Him, “who is over all, God blessed for ever.”74 Had he entertained any such intention, too, as that which Socinus ascribes to him, he would not have made use of a term which, without question, generally and properly signifies was made, or began to be, and which therefore supports that doctrine which the heretic brands as an error; but would have said in clear language, ὁ λογος ἠν σαρξ, the Word was flesh. Besides, although perhaps γινεσθαι, to be made, sometimes occurs in Greek writers instead of ἐιναι, to be, yet, as a laborious Interpreter has observed from Moschopulus, that sense of the word is rather uncommon, poetical, and improper. Nor can an instance of that signification be easily produced from the sacred volume. The passage mentioned by Socinus, is not in point. The term γινεσθαι, indeed, is often employed to signify, to show one’s self such, to conduct one’s self as such, to be found such:75 and this is the sense in the passage referred to.76 The meaning is, he was found to be a Prophet, and showed himself such before God and all the people. And the words may be explained by the following expression of Peter:—“A man approved of God among you by miracles, and wonders, and signs.”77

XIV. Let us now proceed, as we promised, in the third place, to inquire into the Causes of the incarnation. Here we must, first of all, give glory to God himself, the principal Author of so wonderful a thing. “The Lord hath created a new thing in the earth, A woman shall compass a man.”78 A certain woman, in whom nothing but her sex comes to be considered here, shall compass, not by embracing, but by conceiving in her womb, a man, that is, a man-child.79 And this compassing of a man by a woman, is the work of God alone,—not the consequence of her having associated with a husband, or any man. The Lord performs or “creates it,”80—effects it by the mere command of his will,—as “a new thing,” to which nothing equal or similar was ever seen. It is now seen, however, “in the earth,” or in the land, namely, the land of Israel, to which God repeatedly promised that he would come, to dwell in the midst of his people. This explication is plain, consonant to the analogy of faith and to the proper sense of the words, and also very well adapted to the scope of the Prophet’s discourse. He is here recalling the virgin of Israel, a backsliding daughter, to that right and sure way which her believing fathers had trodden. Now, it is certain, that the great and capital error of backsliding Israel is this, that she does not acknowledge the Messiah, whom God has given her. He had in the preceding chapter foretold his birth, saying,—“Their Governor shall proceed from the midst of them.”81 In this same chapter, he had related particularly one of its concomitant circumstances, namely, the slaughter of the infants of Bethlehem.82 He now adds another sign, the creation of a new thing in the earth, a birth from a virgin;—expostulating with Israel in these words, “How long wilt thou go about” in devious paths, which lead thee away from thy God, from happiness, and from the ways of the ancient fathers,—“O thou backsliding daughter,” carried about with divers errors; listen to what I am about to say; an extraordinary thing has taken place in the earth, which has not been heard of from the beginning, which yet the fathers expected, “A woman shall compass a man.” Believe me, the reparation of thy loss, the refreshing of thy wearied soul, and the replenishing of thy sorrowful soul, depend on this mystery, and on the acknowledgment of it.

XV. The whole adorable Trinity concur in this work; and hence it is ascribed to each of the persons; to the Father,83—to the Son,84—and to the Holy Ghost. It is said, “The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee;”85 also, “She was found with child of the Holy Ghost;”86 and again,—“That which is conceived in her, is of the Holy Ghost.”87 It is much more natural to refer these expressions to the third person of the Godhead, than to the Son according to the Divine nature. But with regard to the manner of the Spirit’s operation on the Blessed Virgin, it is far more consistent with prudence and chastity, to cover it, after the example of God himself, with a veil of sacred silence, than to determine with audacious mind, or to presume to explain it with the tongue or the pen. Let it suffice to know, that the work of the Holy Spirit was distinguished by a double miracle, 1st, The fructifying of the virgin’s womb; 2dly, The sanctification of the fruit of the womb, which the virgin conceived and brought forth.

XVI. This conception, however, although attributed in a special manner to the Holy Ghost, doth not make him the Father of Christ; for there is an obvious difference betwixt forming any thing of matter derived from another quarter, and generating from one’s own substance. We do not deny, that God is metaphorically called the Parent of all men, because he creates and preserves them; and that, in a similar sense, the Holy Spirit might be termed in some respect the Father of the human nature of Christ. Yet since generation does not properly terminate on a nature but on a person, since the person of Christ is not begotten by the Holy Spirit, and since the Holy Spirit is no where called the Father of Christ in sacred writ, we, too, ought scrupulously to avoid that expression.

XVII. This event took place according to an agreement between the Father and the Son, or, as it is expressed by Zechariah,88 according to “the counsel of peace,” which was between “the Lord of Hosts,” the Father, and “the man,” the Son, who was to become man, “whose name is the Branch,” being raised up by God,89 and being the new root of a new family, or of the sons of God according to the Spirit. This Branch “shall grow up out of his place;90 that is, as Aben Ezra understands it, of himself,91 by his own proper power, without sowing, without human agency; since he was to be born of a virgin. “And he shall build the temple of the Lord, even he shall build the temple of the Lord.” Here the repetition of the same words directs our thoughts to more than one temple. He builds the temple of his natural body,92 “in which dwelleth all the fulness of the Godhead bodily.”93 This he built, in the first instance, when by his own will he became man, and, afterwards, when he rose again from the dead; and by means of both he became “a Sanctuary” to his people.94 He builds also the temple of his mystical body, that is, the Church.9596

XVIII. But whilst we are considering the Causes of the incarnation, Mary must not be entirely overlooked. Three things chiefly respecting her, are worthy of notice. 1st, Her pedigree, being of the seed of Abraham, of the nation of Israel, of the tribe of Judah, of the house of David. 2dly, Her condition, as in a state of spotless virginity. 3dly, Her relation to Christ, as his true mother.

XIX. It was necessary, according to the prophecies, that the Messiah should be “the seed of Abraham;”97—of the posterity of Israel, who is represented as the heir of the promise made to his grandfather;98—of the tribe of Judah, to which the same inheritance was restricted;99—and of the house of David,100 from whom indeed he was to spring when the posterity of Jesse were to be as a decayed trunk,101 without blossom, leaf, branch, or ornament.102 All these circumstances were united in Mary. She was of the tribe of Judah, for “it is evident that our Lord sprang out of Judah;”103—and of the house of David; for the expression “of the house of David,” in the gospel of Luke,104 must be referred to Mary no less than to Joseph. And in how depressed and degraded a state that family then was, appears from the circumstance, that in Joseph, to whom Mary was betrothed, it was reduced to the axe and the hatchet of the carpenter. It is accordingly affirmed in ecclesiastical history, that Domitian derided the near relations of Christ for their poverty, and for having hands brawny with labour.

XX. It is not inconsistent with this genealogy, that Elizabeth is said to have been “the cousin” of Mary,105 and at the same time one of the daughters of Aaron.106 There is nothing to hinder Mary’s mother from having been of the tribe of Levi, and of the family of Aaron; and some of the ancients affirm, that she was sister to Elizabeth. It was also possible for the mother or grandmother of Elizabeth to have been of the tribe of Judah, and thus very nearly related by blood to the father of Mary, while her father or grandfather was of the tribe of Levi. But according to the rule of genealogy most commonly observed amongst the Jews, a family is reckoned, not from the mother, but from the father. The objection brought forward by some, that it was unlawful for the Israelites to take a wife, or to marry, without the limits of their own particular tribe, is assumed gratuitously. Such marriages were, at least, not universally unlawful. In the sacred records, we find no prohibition, but, on the contrary, several examples, of such connexions. Aaron, a Levite, married Elisheba, daughter of Amminadab, sister of Naashon,107 who was “prince of the children of Judah.”108 If it is objected that that marriage took place before the law, behold another example after the giving of the law. Jehoiada, a priest, consequently a Levite, and a descendant of Aaron, took to wife a daughter of king Jehoram, of the tribe of Judah, of the house of David.109 If you insist, that greater liberty was allowed the priests and Levites than other tribes, I shall not at present demand evidence, as I justly might of their possessing this privilege. I only remark, that the instance now produced is sufficient for removing the difficulty under our consideration; for according to your own hypothesis, it was possible for the father of Elizabeth, being a descendant of Aaron, to take to himself a wife of the family of David, and thus related by her parents to Mary. But we see the same liberty taken by other tribes. David, at least, who belonged to the tribe of Judah, had a daughter of Saul, a Benjamitess, for his wife. Nor do we find any law to the contrary; for in Numbers xxxvi. 6. we have the determination of a special case relating to young women that are heiresses,110 on whom the whole inheritance devolves, all the male issue being dead, whose marriages were limited to men, not merely of their own tribe, but also of their own family. A special determination of that sort, however, serves rather to confirm, than to destroy, the liberty which was generally enjoyed. Besides, it is really not improbable that Mary was one of those young women to whom that determination referred, and therefore espoused to Joseph, as her nearest kinsman. It is not our intention to involve ourselves at present in other genealogical difficulties, which are sufficiently perplexing. Learned men have given very satisfactory replies to the cavils of impious mockers of the Scriptures.

XXI. That the Messiah should be born of a Virgin, was foretold in Isaiah vii. 14.111 On this passage the blind and infatuated Jews contend to no purpose about the signification of the word עלמה, than which none stronger is furnished by the Hebrew language to denote a female of unspotted virginity. Mary professes before the Angel, that she was a female of this description;112 nor does the Angel accuse her of falsehood. Joseph, too, was informed by an Angel, that the woman whom he had espoused, was found with child, not from the knowledge of a man, but from the power of the Holy Ghost.113 And who would now presume to question that a virgin conceived, that a virgin brought forth; since even the most inveterate enemies of Christ, amidst the numerous reproaches which they cast upon him, never ventured to upbraid him with the least disgrace attached to his mother’s bed; since nothing would have been easier, had she been guilty of adultery, than to convict and punish her, the law requiring this, and her husband not objecting; and since they might have been able, at a single stroke, to ruin the whole glory of the Son, by the ignominious punishment of the mother? How, too, could it have come into the mind of any woman not entirely lost to modesty, to pretend that when a Virgin she had brought forth a child? How could she believe such a thing of herself? How could she expect or require, that others should give her credit? How, in particular, could a woman of low rank and in indigent circumstances, hope to obtain credit to a story, which would not have been believed from the lips of a Queen in her kingdom, or palace? Truly unless the testimony of her conscience, the invincible force of truth, the miracle of the overshadowing Spirit, and the assurances of Angels, had obliged her to profess her virginity, what effrontery is sufficiently bold and shameless to induce her to make pretensions so utterly incredible?114

XXII. With these particulars relating to the blessed Virgin, derived from the sacred records of the Gospels, we rest satisfied, exploding the tales which inconsiderate writers of fables have added about her extraordinary birth and education in the temple, or even in the Holy of Holies, and her vow of perpetual virginity, and the examination of her chastity by the priest and by a female named Salome, and other impertinent stories of the same kind, taken from the spurious Gospel of James,115116 from Nicephorus, and from other injudicious authors. Baronius, amidst all the light of this literary age, has not been ashamed to repeat, and, in a great measure, to countenance those ridiculous fables. Xavier the Jesuit, too, more impudent than he, has detailed them in the History of Christ which he has composed in the Persian language, and obtruded them on the nations of the East, as if they were of the same certainty with the divine and infallible records of the Gospel; for which he has been justly chastised by Ludovicus de Dieu. The curious will find a specimen of the Gospel of James in Boxhorn’s Universal History.117

XXIII. Let us now go on to show that Mary was, in reality, the Mother of Christ. It is certain that she is often called his Mother.118 But she could not have been so, unless Christ had taken his human nature from her substance.119 Accordingly it is said that he was “made of a woman,”120—that he was “the fruit of Mary’s womb,”121—and “the seed of the woman.”122

XXIV. These expressions overthrow the opinion of certain Anabaptists, who assert that Christ brought down his human nature from heaven, that it was formed of the essence of the Father or the Holy Ghost, or of the dew of the eternal godhead, or of celestial, starry, or elementary matter; which, however, passed through Mary, as water through a pipe, or as the beams of the sun through glass. Such sentiments are truly impertinent and absurd, since the Scripture affirms, that, by the power of the Holy Ghost, Mary conceived Christ, that she bore him in her womb, and that, like other mothers, she brought him forth at the stated time; all which assertions are directly contrary to those bold unauthorised similitudes.

XXV. That we often read in the Scriptures that Christ “descended from heaven,”123 we do not deny. But this expression is not to be understood precisely of the human nature, but of the person of the Son of God; who is said to have descended from heaven, because he showed himself present among men in a singular manner, appearing in human flesh personally united to himself. Nor is there greater weight in the argument drawn from the following words: “I am the living bread, which came down from heaven;—and the bread that I will give, is my flesh.”124 For these expressions teach us, that the Son of God, in order to become the Author of a true life to sinful men, manifested himself in the flesh which he assumed; and that, not by the labour or care of men, but by a Divine and heavenly appointment and agency, that flesh was prepared to be spiritual food, the cause of a true and blessed life.

XXVI. This controversy ought not to be deemed of small moment, as if it concerns us nothing to know whence Christ hath his flesh, provided it be evident that he has real flesh. It was necessary that the Messiah should not only be man, but also our Kinsman and our Brother, the seed of Abraham, and the fruit of David’s loins. They who give us any other representation of the Messiah, feign one different from him who was promised by the prophets, and expected by the fathers.

XXVII. Let it not be thought that the Apostle sets aside or derogates from the necessity of this knowledge, when he says,—“Yea, though we have known Christ after the flesh, yet now henceforth know we him no more;” that is, according to the flesh.125 In that passage, the expression “according to the flesh” is not connected with Christ, as in some other places,126 but with our knowledge; in reference to which a distinction is made between the knowledge which is according to the flesh, or carnal, and the knowledge which is according to the Spirit, or spiritual. Knowledge according to the flesh, consisted either in the sight of the bodily eye, on account of which some who had seen or touched Christ in the flesh, and particularly after his resurrection, pronounced themselves happy, or were pronounced happy by others;—or in consanguinity, for which the Jews, as the natural branches, were esteemed more happy than the Gentiles. The Apostle renounces such boasting as carnal and frivolous; as the celebrated Cloppenburg, who once adorned the University of Friesland, has learnedly remarked.127

XXVIII. Let us now inquire, in the last place, what Fruit accrues to us from all these things. We may consider distinctly, what advantage we receive, 1st, From Christ’s being Man. 2dly, From his being taken from among men. 3dly, From his being born of a Virgin.

XXIX. The Son of God having become Man, he is also our Mediator, thoroughly adapted for the whole work. Paul, therefore, intending to set forth the Mediator, mentions expressly that he is man.—“There is one Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus.”128 He might have called him God; he might at least have omitted calling him man, as he omitted calling him God. But he employed the most effectual means to afford us suitable relief and encouragement under our weakness, by familiarly exhibiting the Son of God as one of us. It was requisite that for our sake the Son of God should become Immanuel, God with us. It was even necessary that, by a mutual conjunction, his divinity and humanity should be closely united; otherwise the relation would not have been sufficiently near, nor the tie sufficiently strong, to inspire us with the cheering persuasion, that God dwelleth with us.

XXX. But another reason must also be stated. It was incumbent on our Surety to perform what the law demanded from us, that its righteousness might be fulfilled,129 and that we might be saved in consistency with the old covenant. Now the law which was given to men, could not be satisfied but by a man—either with regard to its commands, which require the spirit, soul, and body, to be kept pure and devoted to God;—or with regard to its threatenings, by which the death it requires, is denounced both against soul and body. Hence it was necessary that our Surety should be truly man, that he might “fulfil all righteousness” in soul and body;130 and that by suffering death in both, he might deliver his people from death.131

XXXI. Hence the Apostle couples these two inseparably together,—“made of a woman, and made under the law;”132 intimating that the immediate design of Christ’s incarnation, was that he might be subjected, in his human nature, to that law which was first given to man.

XXXII. The same truth is figuratively suggested by our Lord in the Psalms of David, when he says, “Mine ears hast thou opened;”133 which the Apostle thus explains, “A body hast thou prepared me.”134 The expression carries an allusion to Exodus xxi. 2–6. Although the Hebrew servant was otherwise of the same origin and dignity with his master, yet, if from love to his master, and from love to his wife, though a servant, and to his children, though born in a state of servitude, he voluntarily chose to continue in the service of his master beyond the space of seven years,—his ear, according to the injunction of the law, was to be bored through with an awl at the door, or one of the door-posts of his master. Christ transfers this to himself. Being in other respects equal to God his Father, “he took upon him the form of a servant,” and from love to God the Father,135 to his spouse,136 and to children born under the servitude of the law,137 he came under engagements to a voluntary and lasting service. This was signified by the boring not of one ear only, but of both ears:138 which, as done to the Messiah, points out his great alacrity and promptitude in serving, expressed by himself in the fortieth Psalm;139—and, as the action of the Father, represents the Father’s peculiar satisfaction in the voluntary subjection of the Son. Both the one and the other were openly declared, when, according to the will of the Father and the Son, a body was prepared for Christ, in which he might accomplish that voluntary service. Hence we read, “And now saith the Lord that formed me from the womb to be his servant.”140

XXXIII. It was requisite, farther, that our Mediator should be from among men,—“the Son of man;” that he might be our Kinsman and Brother, and thus our Goel,141 or our Redeemer by the right of propinquity.142 It was becoming,—it was worthy of God, that “he who sanctifieth and they who are sanctified, should be all of one,”—of one blood,143 that they might call each other brethren; for it was necessary that the Mediator should be subject to the law of love to our neighbour and our brethren. “Wherefore it behoved him in all things to be made like unto his brethren.” “For verily he took not on him the nature of angels, he undertook not the redemption of angels,144 but he took on him the seed of Abraham.”

XXXIV. The Hebrew word Goel, as attributed to Christ, is of rich and extensive import; and deserves, therefore, to be here explained a little more particularly. In the Goel of the ancient Hebrews, three things chiefly fall to be considered: 1st, His Person; 2dly, His duties; 3dly, The manner of performing those duties. As to the Person of the Goel or Redeemer, it behoved him to be the nearest relation, or failing him, some kinsman.145 To such a one, in virtue of his relationship, a fourfold right belonged; or if you please, a fourfold duty was incumbent upon him. 1. That of redeeming possessions of his brother or kinsman, which had been sold or alienated, as a house or land.146 2. That of obtaining his freedom, if he were a captive or a servant.147 3. That of avenging him, if murdered; hence he was called “the avenger of blood.”148 4. That of marrying the wife of a deceased brother or kinsman, to raise up seed to him;149 as a pledge of which, he spread over her the skirt of his garment;150 for, amongst the Jews, this was a symbol of conjugal duty, love, and protection.151

With regard to the manner of performing these offices, three things are observable. 1. That sometimes a price was to be paid, as in the redemption of property that had been sold. 2. That on some occasions power and force were to be employed, as in the avenging of blood. 3. That sometimes kindness was to be shown to a widow, as in the case of marrying a deceased brother’s wife. These, when taken together, include almost every thing relative to the Goel, of which we are informed by the Mosaic law.

XXXV. Christ was called Goel before the institution and beyond the sphere of the Mosaic polity;152 and perhaps some rights pertaining to the Goel prevailed in the families of the patriarchs; among whom, some traces at least, of the right of a husband’s brother, occur.153 But the prophets that flourished after Moses, sometimes distinguish our Saviour by the same name.154 And all things which the law required in the Goel are found united in Christ.

XXXVI. With respect to the person,—Christ, by assuming our nature, became our Brother and Kinsman, that being already possessed of the right of propriety, as God, he might obtain the right of propinquity, as our Relative.155 Indeed he is in a peculiar manner related to the Jews, as from them he sprung.156 On this account he is said to have taken on him the seed of Abraham,157 and from this Paul gathers that the Jews shall one day be restored.158 But in a more general view, Christ is also the brother of other men, without distinction of nations;—not indeed of all mankind and of every individual, but of those that belong to “the seed of the woman,” who are so called according to the promise, and opposed to “the seed of the serpent.” The Israelites, then, are related to the Messiah at once by paternal and maternal extraction,—by their descent as well from mother Eve as from father Abraham; for to him also, a promise of the blessed seed was made. The Gentiles are related to the Messiah, at least, by maternal descent. On both sides we ought to consider not the mere carnal alliance, but the divine promise, which is the source of a true and beneficial relation.159

XXXVII. By virtue of this right of propinquity, Christ has claimed us to himself; of which we have a form in the following words: “But now thus saith the Lord that created thee, O Jacob, and he that formed thee, O Israel; Fear not, for I have redeemed thee; I have called thee by thy name; thou art mine.”160 Christ too has omitted none of those duties that could be expected from a Goel; for, 1st, By his meritorious righteousness he has recovered our lost possessions, and that heavenly inheritance which we had forfeited by our demerit;161—“having obtained eternal redemption.”162 2dly, He hath delivered us who were captives, and in a state of bondage to the devil.163 3dly, He has taken vengeance on our enemies, who had murdered our souls.164 4thly, He has dissolved our connexion with our former husband, to wit, the law and covenant of works, and joined us to himself in an everlasting and indissoluble marriage, according to the covenant of grace.165 For the confirmation of this union, too, he has spread over us the garment of his most perfect righteousness;166 which is shadowed forth in Ezekiel,167 by a naked and polluted female, over whom it pleased God, having entered into a marriage-covenant with her, to spread his skirt.168

XXXVIII. Nothing is omitted even as to the manner of performing these offices; for, 1st, He has redeemed us by paying a most ample price.169 2dly, He has rescued us from the slavery of the devil by the most signal exertions of might and power.170 3dly, He has displayed incredible love in betrothing and purchasing the church to himself.171 See copious illustrations of these points by James Alting.172

XXXIX. With respect to our Lord’s being born of a Virgin, this is an evidence of a holy and immaculate conception and birth: For these two consequences follow from his mother’s virginity. 1st, That our Surety was not represented in Adam’s covenant, since he was not born according to the law of nature, and consequently was not liable to the imputation of Adam’s sin.173 2dly, That he could not be considered as existing in Adam, when Adam sinned; for he was not born by virtue of that blessing which God pronounced on marriage before the fall, and which was annexed to the old covenant, “Be fruitful and multiply;”—but by virtue of a new promise subsequent to the fall, in which he is denominated “the seed of the woman,” and appointed the second Adam, the root and head of the new creation.

XL. This immaculate holiness of the conception and nativity of Christ, or, which is the same thing, this original purity of our Lord’s human nature, tends without doubt to our advantage. It is a counterpart to that impurity and depravity of our nature in which we were conceived and born, and is intended to cover it. In other words, it forms a part of that perfect righteousness of Christ, by which, in the capacity of Surety, he satisfied all the demands of the law in our place, and which is ours in all its extent. The law declares that no man is worthy of eternal life, but one that is holy in nature as well as in conduct. Since sin consists wholly in contrariety to the law, that corruption of nature which is born with us will not be sin, unless it be contrary to the law. But it will not be contrary to the law, unless the law, by a precept opposed to it, require holiness of nature in every rational creature as soon as born. Besides, Christ, as our Surety, performed every thing that the law of righteousness demanded on our account. For our sake, therefore, it behoved him to be born righteous and holy, according to the demand of the law; that he might cover our original sin with his original righteousness, and supply our want of original righteousness.

XLI. This assertion is not, as some have imagined, a novel opinion, or an error springing from our ignorance and temerity. The most eminent men in the Church, have formerly, according to holy writ, taught the same doctrine. We read in the Palatine Catechism, Quest. xxxvi. “What benefit do you derive from the holy conception and birth of Christ? Ans. That he is our Mediator, and that, by his innocence and perfect holiness, he covers my sins in which I was conceived, that they may not appear in the sight of God.” Gomar says;—“Of whose righteousness, namely that of Christ, there are two parts, a habitual and original righteousness of nature, and an actual and perpetual righteousness of life. The former of these is opposed to our original, and the latter to our actual unrighteousness; and covers it in its own way, not by removing guilt, which is done by his sufferings, but by supplying the want of an unblemished righteousness, which both the perfect justice of God and the condition of obtaining eternal life require from us; as our Catechism rightly teaches in the answer to the thirty-sixth Question.”174 I do not dissemble, that the accurate Gomar distinctly ascribes the removal of the guilt of original sin to our Lord’s sufferings. Yet to cover sin, which Gomar, after the Catechism, refers to the original righteousness of Christ, is to forgive it.175 To forgive, is to remove guilt. In popular language, too, that which supplies the want of original righteousness, removes, at the same time, the guilt of original sin. If we are truly willing, in fine, with the celebrated Gomar, to speak correctly, we shall say, that the immaculate nativity of Christ did not take place without an emptying of himself, in which suffering is involved. Cloppenburg also contends for the same opinion in the following words: “We have said, too, that this holiness of the human nature, which was perfect from its conception, and exactly holy according to the divine law, interposes, by its merit, betwixt an offended and infinitely holy God, and sinful man, alienated from the life of God. For it appears that it is not without respect to this inherent holiness of Christ’s conception and birth, which is the primary part, and the foundation, of his whole righteousness, that the Scripture pronounces the following propositions: that he is ‘made of God to us righteousness;’176 and that ‘we have put on Christ;’177 so that we are ‘one in him,’ that is, ‘one new man.”178 And after exhibiting the words of the Catechism at the thirty-sixth Question, he adds the following remark: “This answer is either not adapted to the Question, or it speaks of the holiness of the conception and birth of Christ. The latter supposition is most conformable to truth.”179

XLII. These sentiments in no degree preclude the necessity of the death of Christ in order to the expiation of sin, as well original as actual; which the Catechism elsewhere inculcates, and which we also devoutly maintain. We by no means intend, that this holy conception and nativity of Christ can suffice to cover the impurity of our nature, separately from the other parts of his obedience and righteousness. But we consider it as the first part of the entire righteousness of Christ; the efficacy of which, (if all the parts of the righteousness of Christ may be contrasted with the different parts of our misery,) ought to be referred immediately to our original sin, and to the supply of our want of original righteousness.

XLIII. Without doubt, we should intermeddle preposterously with these sacred mysteries of Christian philosophy, were we not by pious and holy meditations to turn them to our own benefit, and to the glory of God in Christ. And, in the first place, we hence learn in general the divinity of our holy religion, which alone shows us that Mediator between God and sinners, in whom the conscience oppressed with the weight of its iniquities, and exhausted by the vain pursuit of remedies in other quarters, may acquiesce with security and pleasure. What human or angelical sagacity could have been able to discover things so hidden, so sublime, and so far surpassing the grasp of all creatures;—that the eternal Son of God should be born in time and become man, that he might be in condition to fulfil the law which was given to men, and, as their Surety, to undergo the punishment due to the offences of men;—that he should even become one of mankind, that he might love and redeem them as his brethren and kinsmen;—yet born of a virgin, who knew no man, that he might contract nothing of that filth of human depravity, which is communicated by ordinary generation to posterity! How adorable do the wisdom, the holiness, the truth, the goodness, and the philanthropy of God appear, in devising, admitting, providing, and perfecting this method of our recovery! How do these mysteries satisfy the soul, thirsting after salvation, yet justly despairing of relief from all that could be done by itself, or by any other amongst men or angels! Here, here, at last, it perceives, what is to be found no where else in heaven or in earth, a way of reconciliation worthy of the perfections of the Deity, and safe for man. These, these are the tremendous mysteries of Christianity, which “eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, and which have not entered into the heart of man;”180 which were “kept secret since the world began, but now are made manifest, and by the Scriptures of the prophets, according to the commandment of the everlasting God, made known to all nations for the obedience of faith.”181

XLIV. In the second place, we ought to be dissolved in this unbounded love of Christ towards us. Who doubts that the excellence of the human race, even when the comparison is most favourably made, must yield to the dignity of celestial spirits. But, behold, angels sinned, and man, in like manner, sinned. Yet God, whilst he leaves angels to suffer the punishment due to their transgression, and consigns them to eternal misery, has compassion upon men, and that he may show them his compassion, becomes a partaker of the same nature with them. For he took not on him the nature of angels, but the seed of Abraham. How great the height of love in this humiliation of Christ! The ill-advised inhabitants of Lystra of old, indulged in a tumultuous joy, when they beheld the miracles of Paul and Barnabas. “The Gods,” said they, “are come down to us in the likeness of men.”182 What they rashly presumed, we may truly affirm,—that God has made a visit to us from heaven in the form of a man, praising him in these words, “What is man that thou art mindful of him, and the son of man, that thou visitest him?”183 Is it not the most incredible of all miracles, that the eternal Son of God, the Lord of glory, veiling the rays of his majesty, became a creature;—and among creatures, not one of the seraphim or cherubim, but a man (and how little is man to be accounted of!) and among men, not a king or a monarch, but “a servant of rulers.”184 Truly he was pleased to converse familiarly with us, and to live in a condition which might obtain for us the name of brethren.185 “In all things” he was “made like unto us, that he might be a merciful and faithful High-priest in things pertaining to God, to make reconciliation for the sins of the people.”186 “For we have not an High-priest who cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities, but was in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin.”187 In short, he submitted to the lowest degree of our vileness, that he might exalt us above the rank of men, and make us partakers of his own, that is, of “a divine nature.”188 O compassion! O almost incredible vehemence of love! O how far doth this love exceed the tenderness of a brother’s or a father’s affection! With what emotions of gratitude wilt thou be acknowledged! With what returns of love wilt thou be recompensed! What heart is so cold and frozen as not to be dissolved, warmed, and kindled into flames, by the ardours of so boundless a love!

XLV. It must, however, be observed, further, that if we wish to have a solid foundation for our joy in the incarnation of Christ, it is necessary that the same person who was once fashioned in the womb of the Virgin after the likeness of a man, be formed also in our hearts,189 that he live there, that he be nourished there, that he grow up there “unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ.”190 Since he was conceived by the power of the Holy Ghost, it is not for us to pretend to be his brethren, unless we give evidence by a holy course of life, that we are renewed by the same Spirit after the image of God. And as he would not be conceived by any but a virgin, we too must embrace him with a pure and chaste mind, which detests every appearance of a whorish attachment to the world, and is animated with a virgin love to God alone.

XLVI. In fine, as at his birth, choirs of heavenly Angels praised the incarnate Son of God in joyful strains,191 it is incumbent upon us to celebrate that great mystery of godliness, and God the author of it, with devout and unceasing praises. The blessed Angels begin the song; let us follow them with the voice and the heart. “Glory to God in the highest,” who has exhibited a brighter display of his admirable perfections in this illustrious work, than he did of old in the creation of the whole universe! Glory to the Father, who has raised up, admitted, and given us such a Surety! Glory to the Son, who clothed himself with human flesh, and so cheerfully accomplished his surety-undertaking on our behalf! Glory to the Holy Spirit, the revealer and witness of so deep, so momentous, so precious a truth; and the earnest of so invaluable and longed-for a salvation! Hosanna, blessed Jesus, thou true and eternal God, thou true and holy man! In the unity of thy person, we recognise both natures, each possessing its own distinct properties. Thee we acknowledge. Thee we worship. From thy hand alone we expect salvation. May the whole world of thine elect unite with us in knowing, acknowledging, and adoring thee, and thus be saved through thy blessed name! Amen.

Notes

Note I. Page 4.

The venerable Author very properly adverts to those preludes of his intended advent which the Messiah was pleased to give, by appearing in a human form to Abraham, Jacob, and others. These appearances, he adds, prepared the way for the prediction in Isaiah lii. 8. “Thy watchmen lift up the voice; with the voice together do they sing; for they behold before their eyes”—or as the expression might possibly have been better rendered, for they see face to face; or as it is in the common version, they shall see eye to eye. At all events, the Author considers these words, and those which he immediately quotes from the 6th verse of the same Chapter, as referring to that manifestation of the Son of God in human flesh, of which these ancient appearances were remarkable anticipations. The whole passage of which these verses are a part, without doubt, relates, in the first instance, to that striking display of Jehovah’s presence, power, and goodness, which the watchmen and other friends of Zion had the happiness to behold, at the restoration of the Jews from their Babylonish captivity. It ought, however, to be ultimately referred to a more glorious salvation than that temporal deliverance; and whilst the expression “they shall see eye to eye,” may justly be applied to those clear spiritual discoveries of the character of the Messiah, and of the glory of the Divine perfections, as manifested in him and his work, with which the watchmen of Zion were to be blessed in latter days, it cannot well be deemed unnatural to include those opportunities of seeing and conversing with Christ in his human nature on the earth, which were granted to Apostles and some other primitive preachers of his Gospel. These holy men saw the King of Zion with their own eyes, and were permitted to eat and drink with him, not only during his abasement, but even after his resurrection from the dead. Being eye and ear-witnesses of his words and works, they were the better prepared to “lift up the voice” with confidence; and their testimony was the more valuable and satisfactory. See John i. 14. Acts iv. 20. 1 John i. 1.

The Hebrew expression translated eye to eye, occurs also in Numb. xiv. 14. though rendered differently in that passage. It may be compared with Jer. xxxiv. 3. We read also of seeing face to face in Gen. xxxii. 30. and Exod. xxxiii. 11. and of speaking mouth to mouth Numb. xii. 8. Jer. xxxii. 4. The expression under consideration, as Parkhurst remarks, may be rendered eye with eye, i. e. with both eyes, agreeably to the Targum, and to the French translation de leur deux yeux. It denotes, at any rate, clear vision, or familiar and distinct knowledge. See Pool’s Synopsis and Annotations, Vitringa on the place, and Parkhurst’s Hebrew Lexicon on ענה.

Note II. Page 7.

Whatever veneration be due to the ancient writers of the Christian Church, and however excellent and useful their works may be in many respects, it cannot be denied that these Fathers often exhibit marks of human infirmity; and that their comments on Scripture are sometimes more fanciful than just. This remark seems fairly to apply to the notion to which our Author here refers in too favourable terms, that the three Angels, who, as we read in Gen. xviii. appeared to Abraham in the plains of Mamre, were the three persons of the sacred Trinity. That one of these Angels was the Angel of the covenant, the second person of the Trinity, agreeably to the views of Calvin and many other judicious Interpreters, is indeed highly probable, if not incontestably evident. For that Angel, in the course of his interview with the Patriarch, ascribed to himself Divine characters and works, and also received and answered Abraham’s earnest supplications on behalf of Sodom. It is sufficiently manifest, however, from the narrative itself, that the other two who accompanied him in his visit to Abraham, and then proceeded by themselves to the habitation of Lot, were only created Angels.—Since neither the Father nor the Spirit was to become incarnate, it might not have been so proper that these Divine persons should appear even for a little in a human shape.

Some writers have endeavoured to find a mystery in Abraham’s bowing himself towards the ground before the Angels at their first appearance, Verse 2. and alleged that, while he adored one of the three, he by faith discerned Three Persons in one God. But Calvin justly remarks, that this idea is frivolous, and obnoxious to the scoffs of adversaries; and adds, that Abraham was not immediately aware that these “strangers” were more than men, and that his bowing himself was only an expression of civil respect.192 The notion that the Father and the Holy Spirit were, at all, two of the three Angels who appeared to Abraham in a human form, seems equally ill-founded, and equally calculated to expose the truth to the ridicule of enemies.

Note III. Page 14.

The passage in Zech. vi. 12, 13. relative to “the man whose name is the Branch,” is one of the most pleasant and most remarkable Old Testament predictions. That the Messiah is in reality its subject, few have ventured to deny. Some of its clauses, however, have been variously understood by various Interpreters. The most obvious sense of the expression, “he shall grow up out of his place,” seems to be, that, whatever difficulties might intervene, and whatever improbability might attach to the event, the Son of God should certainly appear in human nature at the appointed place of his birth—that, however low might be the state of the Jews, and however hopeless the condition to which the family of David might be reduced, this glorious Branch should spring up in due season in the land of Canaan, and in Bethlehem the city of David. This interpretation is justified by comparing the original with the same and similar expressions, as in Exod. x. 23. xvi. 29. Lev. xiii. 23. Josh. v. 8. The interpretation, at the same time, which the Author quotes with approbation from Aben Ezra, and which is adopted too by Calvin and Drusius,193 cannot be considered as either unjust or unnatural. The expression may fitly be rendered de sub se, ex seipso, that is, of himself, by his own proper power; and in this view it may be referred to his miraculous conception. From this comment of Aben Ezra, too, we may remark in passing, it appears that even posterior to the publication of the Christian religion, it has been admitted by some learned Jews, that the Messiah was to be born of a Virgin. On this point compare Doddridge’s Paraphrase and Note upon John vii. 27.

Witsius, as the reader will observe, understands that part of the prediction in Zech. vi. which foretells the building of the temple, as relating both to the temple of his natural body, and the temple of the Church. It refers, no doubt, in the first instance, to the building of the second temple at Jerusalem, a work which Zerubbabel could never have accomplished, without aid and support from above. The chief design of the prophecy, however, was to cheer the hearts of the pious with the prospect of the erection of a still more important and glorious edifice, of which the ancient temple was a type. There is some respect, it may be admitted, to the human nature of Christ, which the temple of Jerusalem unquestionably prefigured, and which our Lord himself, in John ii. 19. expressly denominates a “temple.” The building of the New Testament Church seems, however, to be the subject chiefly intended here; and the repetition of the words, “He shall build the temple of the Lord, even He shall build the temple of the Lord,” may have been intended to intimate, that the building of this spiritual temple is a work of unparalleled difficulty—that none but Christ could dare to undertake it—that He is fully equal to the arduous enterprize—and that in due time he should accomplish it with signal and glorious success.

For some farther illustration of this striking prophecy, and in particular for an explanation and defence of the true meaning of its concluding part, “the counsel of peace shall be between them both,” the reader may consult Witsius on the Covenants.194

Note IV. Page 15.

That the Messiah was not only to belong to the family of David, but to appear at a season when that royal house should have exchanged its splendour for a state of indigence and obscurity, is very properly observed by the Author. The sense which he attaches to the expression, rendered by our Translators “the stem of Jesse,” (Isaiah xi. 1.) when he represents it as denoting “a decayed trunk,” truncus succisus, is quite just, and is supported by the authority of eminent critics. Though the Septuagint and Jerome somewhat improperly render it by the same term, ῥιζα and radix, by which they translate a different Hebrew word, rendered roots, at the end of the Verse; the term truncus, or truncus succisus, or concisus, is adopted by Calvin, Tremellius and Junius, and by Vitringa. Parkhurst195 also renders it “the stump or stock of a tree that hath been cut down.” Vitringa regards the use of the same expression in Job xiv. 8. and Isaiah xl. 24. as decisive in favour of this interpretation; and Parkhurst adds in its support, that the same word in Arabic used as a Verb, signifies to cut, cut off. Bishop Lowth understands the term in precisely the same sense, and accordingly he renders the first part of the verse in question; “But there shall spring forth a rod from the trunk of Jesse.” In his Note on the place, the Bishop clearly points out the beauty and force of the expression, as well as its connexion with the preceding context.

“The Prophet,” says this elegant Critic, “had described the destruction of the Assyrian army under the image of a mighty forest, consisting of flourishing trees, growing thick together, and of a great height; of Lebanon itself crowned with lofty cedars; but cut down, and laid level with the ground by the ax wielded by the hand of some powerful and illustrious agent: In opposition to this image, he represents the great Person who makes the subject of this Chapter, as a slender twig shooting out from the trunk of an old tree, cut down, lopped to the very root, and decayed; which tender plant, so weak in appearance, should nevertheless become fruitful and prosper,” &c.

This and other predictions, as Amos ix. 11. relative to the depressed state of the family of David at the time of the Messiah’s coming, as our Author shows, were remarkably fulfilled. The treatment which he represents some near relatives of Christ as having experienced from Domitian the Emperor, if it really took place, was a striking illustration of the change of circumstances which that family had undergone. The story is related by Eusebius; and the learned Mosheim, in the first Volume of his “Commentaries on the affairs of Christians before the time of Constantine the Great,” expresses his conviction that it was not at all improbable in itself that that tyrannical Emperor, knowing that Jesus of Nazareth was honoured by his followers as their Lord and King, began to suspect that his surviving Relatives in Palestine might claim a temporal sovereignty, and summoned them to appear before him to give him satisfaction with regard to their views and intentions. Perceiving that he had no cause to entertain any serious apprehensions of danger from such plain and humble individuals as he found them to be, he deemed it sufficient to gratify his arrogance and malignity, by making the indications of their poverty the subject of his mirth.

Note V. Page 18.

That the Messiah was to be born of a Virgin was obscurely intimated even in the first promise, Gen. iii. 15, and plainly foretold in subsequent predictions, particularly those in Isaiah vii. 14, and Jer. xxxi. 22, to which our Author refers. Unless the birth of Jesus had corresponded in this respect to ancient prophecy, the evidence of his Messiahship would have been materially defective. Those chapters of the Gospels by Matthew and Luke, therefore, which narrate the circumstances of our Lord’s conception and birth, are highly interesting and important; and nothing can be more awkward and absurd than the attempts which have been made to unsettle the faith of Christians regarding the authenticity of these portions of Scripture. The modern Socinians, in what they are pleased to style An improved Version of the New Testament, have thought proper to print the 1st chapter of Matthew from the 17th verse to the end, and the whole of the 2d chapter, and the whole of the 1st and 2d chapters of the Gospel by Luke, in Italic characters, in order to denote that the authenticity of all these passages is doubtful. In support of this strange Improvement, they can plead no higher authority than that of Ebion and Marcion, two early heretics, and avowed mutilators of the Scriptures. These Chapters are found in all the ancient Manuscripts and Versions now extant. They are referred to as a part of the inspired record by the early writers of the Church; and even several of the cavils of Celsus against the Christian faith are founded on the contents of these chapters. Their authenticity is also strongly supported by internal evidence. See Dr Campbell’s Notes on Mat. ii. 23.² and Luke iii. 23.² and the appropriate remarks of Dr Magee on this subject.196

The miraculous conception of Christ, though questioned by some, and horribly derided by others, exhibits to the pure and enlightened mind, a display of Divine wisdom and power, in perfect accordance with all the other parts of the scheme of redemption. It was highly expedient that this extraordinary personage should come into the world in an extraordinary manner; and if it was necessary that the Saviour of sinners should himself assume their nature, and at the same time continue completely free from moral defilement, why should it seem incredible that a miracle was wrought for the purpose of securing his exemption from that original guilt and corruption, which is inherited by all the other descendants of Adam? If “the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters” at the beginning of the world, to produce, by his mighty influence, life, order and beauty, where all was darkness, confusion and inanity, what impropriety can be shown in the same Spirit’s “creating a new thing upon the earth” in the fulness of time? In this miraculous operation, the Deity did nothing more unworthy of his character than when he formed Adam of the dust of the ground, and Eve of a rib taken out of Adam’s side. See Bishop Horsley’s Sermon on the Miraculous Conception; and also some judicious remarks on this topic by Dr David Hunter of St Andrews, whose useful and well-written book on the History of Christ ought not to be consigned to oblivion.197

Note VI. Page 19.

The Protevangelium of James is one of those spurious writings which, under the name of Gospels, Epistles, Acts and Revelations, have made pretensions to a place in the sacred canon of the New Testament. It coincides, in general, with a work entitled The Gospel of the Birth of Mary, and is thought to have been written in the third or perhaps the second Century by some Hellenistic Jew. In common with the other apocryphal books, it was never acknowledged as authentic by the primitive Christians; and notwithstanding the bold assertions of a late writer, it was not frequently alluded to by the ancient Fathers, nor did it gain a general reception in the Christian world. The idle and impertinent stories indeed with which this and the other spurious Gospels abound, and which render them extremely unlike the sacred details of the inspired evangelists, afford sufficient internal evidence that they have no just claims to divine inspiration.

The attempts which the enemies of Christianity have made to sap the credit of the New Testament, by confronting it with these “silly and drivelling forgeries,” could not fail to prove utterly abortive.—Dr Leland, in the 1st Volume of his View of English Deistical Writers, takes notice, in his account of Toland, of a book published by that Author 1698, entitled Amyntor, in which he strives with great zeal to invalidate by this means the authority of the New Testament;—and he refers to the satisfactory answers which Toland received from Dr Samuel Clarke, Mr Stephen Nye, and particularly recommends Mr Richardson’s “Canon of the New Testament Vindicated”—“A new and full method of settling the canonical authority of the New Testament,” in three Volumes, by Mr Jones—and the voluminous and excellent work of Dr Lardner, entitled, “the Credibility of the Gospel History.” On this point the reader might also consult Horne’s “Introduction to the critical study and knowledge of the Holy Scriptures,”198 and a late article in the Quarterly Review.199

Note VII. Page 28.

What our Author here says respecting the consequences of Christ’s being born of a Virgin may be compared with his remarks on the same topic in his Treatise on the Covenants.200 He justly affirms, that since our Lord was not born according to the law of nature, he was not represented in the covenant made with Adam, and consequently was not liable to the imputation of Adam’s sin. It is shown also, agreeably to what was hinted in a preceding Dissertation,201 that the original purity of his human nature “forms a part of that perfect righteousness of Christ, by which, in the capacity of Surety, he satisfied all the demands of the law in our place.” On this point, Witsius vindicates himself from the charge of singularity, by referring not only to the works of Gomar and Cloppenburgh, but also to the Palatine or Heidelberg Catechism, which was composed by Zachary Ursin, a celebrated Professor of Theology at Heidelberg, has been long made use of in most of the Reformed Churches, and was adopted by the Church of Scotland till it was superseded by the excellent Catechisms prepared by the venerable Assembly which met at Westminster. The same views, it may be added, are maintained by the Rev. Thomas Boston in his Treatise on the Covenant of Grace.202

Whilst our venerated Author teaches that Christ was not liable to the imputation of Adam’s sin, the expression obviously implies, that, in common with the greater part of evangelical Divines, he considered the guilt of Adam’s first sin as imputed to “all mankind descending from him by ordinary generation.” It is to be regretted that this doctrine has been impugned by a late Author, no less distinguished by cordial attachment to many of the peculiar doctrines of the Gospel, than by the vigour and originality which pervade his writings.203 Although he sincerely contends for the doctrine of original depravity, and considers that depravity as the consequence of Adam’s apostasy, he seems to deny that Adam represented his posterity in the covenant of works, and that they were involved in the guilt of the first transgression. As the work referred to has obtained an extensive circulation, it were desirable that some Master in Israel would particularly advert to the mistaken statements of Dr Dwight, refute his arguments at length, and place the subject in a scriptural light. The Church indeed is already possessed of a valuable antidote in the Treatise by President Edwards on Original Sin; and in some instances the masterly pen of the venerable Grandfather supplies a sufficient refutation of the reasonings of the respectable Grandson. For example, Dwight’s objections founded on Ezek. xviii. 20. and also on the word impute, are obviated in that celebrated Treatise.204

The only argument against the concern of Adam’s descendants in the guilt of his first sin, which shall be noticed here, is that which is founded on a new translation of 1 Cor. xv. 22, “As in Adam all die, so in Christ shall all be made alive.” “The words in the original,” says Dwight, “are ἐν τῳ ’Αδαμ, and ἐν τῳ Χριστῳ. The Greek preposition ἐν signifies very often, as any person acquainted with the language must have observed, exactly the same thing with the English phrase by means of. The passage would therefore have been explicitly and correctly translated; As by means of Adam all die, even so by means of Christ shall all be made alive. Adam is therefore only asserted here to be an instrumental cause of the death specified, &c.” Now, that the preposition ἐν does not unfrequently signifiy by means of, or simply by, as Dr Macknight has thought proper to render it in this same verse, is readily admitted. But the native and ordinary sense of this preposition is confessedly in; and it should be inquired whether the connexion of the words, and the scope of the passage, do not render it more probable that the preposition ought to be rendered so in this verse, than that it should be translated either by, or by means of. That ἐν when connected with τῳ Χριστῳ, and with other names and characters of the Saviour, should in no case be rendered by means of, we shall not affirm. But “any person acquainted with the language” of the New Testament “must have observed,” that in a vast majority of instances where ἐν is thus joined with Christ, it would be highly improper to render it in any other way than by the English preposition in. A few expressions from the Epistles to the Corinthians may suffice for examples: “But of him are ye in Christ Jesus”—“Babes in Christ”—“My ways which be in Christ”—“If any man be in Christ, he is a new creature”—“I knew a man in Christ.”205 The expression ἐν Χριστῳ occurs even in the 18th, and again in the 19th verse of the same Chapter with the verse under consideration; and in both places it is justly rendered by our translators “in Christ.”—“Then they also which are fallen asleep in Christ are perished.” “If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable.” It is unquestionably better to say “fallen asleep in Christ,” and thus extend the expression to all who have died in a state of union with Christ, than to render it, as Macknight has done, “fallen asleep for Christ,” and thus unnecessarily and gratuitously confine it to those “who have suffered death for believing the resurrection of Christ.” “Hope in Christ,” too, is fully as proper as “hope by Christ.” The preposition ἐν sometimes signifies concerning, with respect to, as in Rom. xi. 2. Gal. i. 24. and accordingly the 19th verse might be correctly translated thus; “If with respect to this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable.” Why then ought we not to retain the 22d verse as it stands in the common version; “For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive?” The Apostle had said in the verse immediately preceding; “For since δι ἀνθρωπου, by man came death, δι ἀνθρωπου, by man came also the resurrection of the dead.” He had thus already taught that by, through, or by means of man death came, and also the resurrection of the dead. He had already shown that Adam is “an instrumental cause of the death specified,” and that “the man Christ Jesus,” the Son of God in human nature, is the author of that blessed resurrection which awaits the just. When he proceeds to his next sentence, he changes the preposition in both its parts. In place of δια, by, by means of, he says ἐν, in. That he alters the preposition merely for the sake of variety of expression, ought not readily to be conceded. Is it not much more probable that the design of the Apostle, and of the Spirit by whom he was inspired, was to throw additional light upon the subject, and to suggest something relative to the manner in which death comes by the one man, and the resurrection by the other? Is it not clearly intimated, that Adam was not merely “an instrumental cause of death,” but that we died in Adam as our common root and federal representative, in whom we sinned, and so became liable to death; and that Christ, in like manner, is not only the cause of the glorious resurrection of believers, but that this resurrection is the consequence of their relation to him as their spiritual Head and Representative, who fulfilled all righteousness in their room, and rose again from the dead on their behalf? This view of the meaning divests the passage of every appearance of tautology. It tallies best, too, with what the Apostle states in the progress of the chapter, verses 45–49, respecting the first man, and the second man, whom he contrasts together in the public capacity sustained by each. It is powerfully confirmed, in fine, by the doctrine of the same Apostle in Romans v. 12–21, a passage which incontrovertibly establishes at once the imputation of Adam’s first disobedience to his posterity, and the imputation of Christ’s meritorious righteousness to all believers—two important points which must stand or fall together.

The difficulties with which this subject is attended, ought not to prevent us from acquiescing in the declarations of infinite wisdom. “What we can know,” says that eminent Author, whose views on this subject we have taken the liberty to combat, in the same discourse to which we have referred,—“it is our duty and our interest to know. Where knowledge is unattainable, it is both our duty and interest to trust humbly and submissively to the instructions of Him who is the Only Wise.”—Amongst the numerous writings on this topic, the serious inquirer might read with profit the remarks of Witsius in another work,206 an “Essay on Original Sin,” by the Rev. Thomas Walker of Dundonald,207 and President Dickinson’s Discourse on Rom. v. 12.208

1 Lev. xxvi. 12.

2 Exod. xxix. 42, 43, 45.

3 Num. x. 33, 35. Exod. xxv. 22.

4 Jer. viii. 19.

5 Ps. xlvi. 5.

6 Ps. lxv. 11.

7 Zech. ii. 10.

8 Luke i. 78.

9 Ἐσκηνωσεν ἐν ἡμιν. John i. 14.

10 Ἐνσαρκος ἐπιδημία.

11 Is. iv. 2.

12 Ezek. i. 26.

13 Dan. vii. 13.

14 Heretics who attributed a human shape to God. T.

15 Makers of images.

16 John viii. 56.

17 Mal. iv. 5.

18 Gen. xxxii. 24–31.

19 Josh. v. 13.

20 Judges vi. 11.

21 Judges xiii. 3.

22 כי עין בעין יראו Is. lii. 8.

23 Verse 6.

24 See Note I. at the end of this Volume.

25 John i. 14.

26 Gal. iv. 4.

27 1 John iv. 2.

28 John xiv. 7, 9. John i. 18. 2 Cor. iv. 6.

29 John xiv. 10.

30 Heb. x. 5.

31 Ephes. ii. 10.

32 John i. 3. Col. i. 16.

33 John i. 1.

34 John iii. 34.

35 Col. i. 15.

36 Heb. i. 3.

37 John iii. 16.

38 Heb. ii. 14, 17.

39 Is. liii. 11. Mat. xxvi. 38.

40 Mat. xxvi. 12.

41 Mat. xiv. 26, 27.

42 Luke xxiv. 39.

43 Luke ii. 40.

44 Luke ii. 52. Mark xiii. 32.

45 Mat. xxvi. 39.

46 Mat. iv. 2.

47 John xix. 28.

48 Mat. xxvi. 37.

49 John xi. 35. Luke xix. 41.

50 Mat. xi. 19.

51 Philip. ii. 8.

52 Mal. iii. 6. James i. 17.

53 Ps. cii. 27, comp. Heb. i. 12.

54 Rom. ix. 5.

55 Rom. i. 3, 4. 1 Tim. iii. 16.

56 Κατα παραστασιν.

57 Gen. xviii. 1, 2.

58 See Note II.

59 Μορφην δουλου λαβων, ἐν ὁμοιωματι ἀνθρωπων γενομενος.

60 Κεκοινωνηκε.

61 Μετέσχε τῶν αὐτῶν.

62 Heb. i. 10.

63 Ὀργανον ἐνυποστατον ἰδιοποιησε.

64 Is. xxv. 9.

65 Is. xl. 5.

66 John i. 14.

67 Σαρξ ἐγενετο.

68 ויהי האדם לנפש חיה Gen. ii. 7.

69 Ἐγενετο ὁ πρῶτος ἄνθρωπος Ἀδαμ ἐις ψυχην ζῶσαν, 1 Cor. xv. 45.

70 Contra Praxeam, cap. xxi.

71 “Qui fuit vir Propheta,” Luke xxiv. 19.

72 1 John v. 20.

73 1 Cor. viii. 5, 6.

74 Rom. ix. 5.

75 See Mat. v. 45. 1 Thes. ii. 5, 7, 10. Rom. iii. 4.

76 Luke xxiv. 19.

77 Acts ii. 22.

78 Jer. xxxi. 22.

79 Rev. xii. 5.

80 ברא

81 Chap. xxx. 21.

82 Verse 15.

83 Heb. x. 5.

84 Philip. ii. 7.

85 Luke i. 35.

86 Mat. i. 18.

87 Mat. i. 20.

88 Zech. vi. 12, 13.

89 Is. iv. 2. Mal. i. 11.

90 מתחתיו

91 מאליו à semetipso.

92 John ii. 21.

93 Col. ii. 9.

94 Is. viii. 14.

95 1 Cor. iii. 16. 2 Cor. vi. 16.

96 See Note III.

97 Gen. xxii. 18. comp. Gal. iii. 16.

98 Gen. xxviii. 14.

99 Gen. xlix. 8, 10.

100 Ps. cxxxii. 11. comp. Acts ii. 30.

101 גזע truncus succisus. Is. xi. 1.

102 See Note IV.

103 Heb. vii. 14.

104 Luke i. 27.

105 Luke i. 36.

106 Verse 5.

107 Exod. vi. 23.

108 1 Chron. ii. 10.

109 2 Chron. xxii. 11.

110 Ἐπικληροι.

111 Comp. Mat. i. 21.

112 Luke i. 34.

113 Mat. i. 20.

114 See Note V.

115 Jacobi Protevangelium.

116 See Note VI.

117 Boxhornii Histor. Univers. p. 49.

118 Mat. i. 18. Luke i. 43. John ii. 1. and in other places passim.

119 Ex illius substantia, sive semine ac sanguine.

120 Gal. iv. 4.

121 Luke i. 42.

122 Gen. iii. 15.

123 John vi. 33. 1 Cor. xv. 47, 48. Ephes. iv. 9, 10.

124 John vi. 51.

125 2 Cor. v. 16.

126 Acts ii. 30. Rom. ix. 5.

127 De Instaur. Hom. laps. Disput. iii. Sect. 9, 10.

128 1 Tim. ii. 5.

129 Rom. viii. 4.

130 Matt. iii. 15.

131 Heb. ii. 14.

132 Gal. iv. 4.

133 Ps. xl. 6.

134 Heb. x. 5.

135 John xiv. 31.

136 Ephes. v. 25.

137 Gal. iv. 5.

138 אזנים

139 Verses 7, 8.

140 Is. xlix. 5.

141 גואל, ἐπιληπτωρ.

142 Heb. ii. 10, 11, 16, 17.

143 Comp. Acts xvii. 26.

144 Ὀυ γαρ δηποῦ ἀγγελων ἐπιλαμβανεται.

145 Lev. xxv. 25, 48, 49.

146 Lev. xxv. 25.

147 Lev. xxv. 47, 48.

148 גואל הדם Num. xxxv. 19. Deut. xix. 6.

149 Deut. xxv. 5.

150 Ruth iii. 9.

151 Deut. xxii. 30. Ezek. xvi. 8.

152 Gen. xlviii. 16. Job xix. 25.

153 Gen. xxxviii. 6–8.

154 Is. xliii. 14. lix. 20.

155 Heb. ii. 11, 14.

156 Rom. ix. 5. Heb. vii. 14.

157 Heb. ii. 16.

158 Rom. xi. 26.

159 Ephes. iii. 15.

160 כי גאלתיך Is. xliii. 1.

161 Tit. iii. 7.

162 Heb. ix. 12.

163 Luke i. 71.

164 Col. ii. 15. Heb. ii. 14.

165 Rom. vii. 4. Ephes. v. 25, 26.

166 Gal. iii. 27.

167 Chap. xvi. 8.

168 In the first Edition, the Author here refers to Turretin. de Satisf. Christ. Disp. iii. Sect. 30, 31.

169 Job xxxiii. 24. Mat. xx. 28. 1 Tim. ii. 6.

170 Is. xl. 10. Mat. xii. 29. Luke xi. 21, 22.

171 Ephes. v. 29, 30.

172 In Commentariis ad Rom. xi. 26. et in quarta Heptade Dissertationum, Dissert. iv. Sect. xv. et Dissert vi.

173 See Note VII.

174 Disput. xxvi. Sect. 16. He expresses the same sentiments Disput. xxv. Sect. 22.

175 Ps. xxxii. 1.

176 1 Cor. i. 30.

177 Gal. iii. 27.

178 Gal. iii. 28, comp. Ephes. iv. 24. Col. iii. 10.

179 De Instaurat. Hom. laps. Disput. iii. sect. 20.

180 1 Cor. ii. 19.

181 Rom. xvi. 25, 26.

182 Acts xiv. 11.

183 Ps. viii. 4.

184 Is. xlix. 7.

185 Heb. ii. 11, 12.

186 Verse 17.

187 Heb. iv. 15.

188 2 Pet. i. 4.

189 Gal. iv. 19.

190 Ephes. iv. 13.

191 Luke ii. 13, 14.

192 Calvin. Commentar. in Gen. xviii.

193 See Pool’s Synopsis on the place.

194 Book ii. chap. 2. sect. 7, 8.

195 Heb. Lex. on the word גזע

196 Discourses and Dissertations on the Scriptural Doctrine of Atonement and Sacrifice, Vol. ii. pp. 441–443.

197 Observations on the History of Jesus Christ, serving to illustrate the propriety of his conduct and the beauty of his character, Vol. i. ch. 1. sect. 1. “Of the mysteriousness of his Birth.”

198 Vol. iv. pp. 687–704. 3d edit.

199 Vol. xxv. pp. 347–365. The Article referred to is a Review of “the Apocryphal New Testament,” printed in London 1820;—which is represented in that Review, and not without probable grounds, as originating in hostility to the New Testament, and an insidious design to destroy its credit. At the close of the Review, too, the writer gives a sufficient specimen of these pretended Gospels, in some ridiculous fictions they contain relative to what happened during our Saviour’s youth.

200 Book ii. ch. 4. sect. 10, 11.

201 Dis. ix. sect. 28. Comp. also the Treatise on the Covenants, Book iii. ch. 8. sect. 29.

202 Head iii. Art. 1. Holiness of Nature.

203 See Dr Timothy Dwight’s Theology Explained and Defended, Ser. 32.

204 Part iv. ch. 3. pp. 397–399, and ch. 4. pp. 414–416, 4th edit.

205 1 Cor. i. 30. ii. 1. iv. 17. 2 Cor. v. 17. xii. 2.

206 Economy of the Covenants, book i. ch. 2. sect. 14–18. ch. 8. sect. 30–35.

207 Essays and Sermons on Doctrinal and Practical Subjects, pp. 1–87.

208 Sermons and Tracts, pp. 164–212.