Sacred Dissertations on What Is Commonly Called the Apostles’ Creed (1823), Herman Witsius · PDF

Dissertation VI. On Faith in a Three-One God

I. The Creed is usually divided into three parts; of which the first relates to God the Father, and the work of Creation; the second to God the Son, and the work of Redemption; the third to God the Holy Ghost, and the work of Sanctification. The most ancient formulary having consisted of a simple profession of the Trinity, our present Creed, which took its rise from that formulary, and in course of time was completed by the addition of various articles, is still so framed that these may all be referred to the Three Persons in the Godhead. This great doctrine remained as the Foundation of foundations, upon which the other articles were built.

II. When, however, his own distinct actions are ascribed to each of the Persons respectively, this must not be understood to intimate that either the power or the operation of the Persons is divided, or that any one of them accomplishes his work more immediately than another. As God is one, so the power and operation of all the Persons are one and undivided; and each person is the immediate and perfect cause of the whole work. The Son and the Holy Ghost created the world by the same power, and by the same act, with the Father. The manner of those works which respect our redemption, is, nevertheless, somewhat different. As a participation of the human nature was requisite to the performance of these, and as the Son alone assumed this nature into personal union with himself, these works, being the works of the God-man, are peculiar to the Son. Yet it is admitted that in so far as the Godhead was concerned, they are the works of the whole Trinity; and, accordingly, they are, in this view, attributed to the Father and the Holy Spirit equally with the Son.—To the Father: “Believest thou not that I am in the Father, and the Father in me? The words that I speak unto you, I speak not of myself, but the Father that dwelleth in me, he doth the works.”1—To the Holy Spirit: “I cast out devils by the Spirit of God.”2 The incarnation itself, and similar acts, though peculiar to the Son in respect that they terminate upon him only, are nevertheless, in regard to the agency by which they are effected, the works of the whole Trinity.3

III. But this distinction of the Divine works, has a respect, 1st, To the order of the Persons, which ought to be observed in their operation, as well as their subsistence. Thus, because the Father is the First person of the Godhead, and creation is the first external work of the Deity, as it is the beginning of all those things that are without God,4 it is justly ascribed, by special economy, to the Father, who, on this account, is called “Lord of heaven and earth.”5 Yet the agency of the Son,6 and the Holy Ghost,7 is not excluded from this work. 2dly, It is necessary, also, to attend to the terminating of an act upon some certain Person. For this reason, redemption is attributed to the Second person, for whom alone the human nature was prepared, in and by which the Godhead performed many acts relating to our salvation.8 The Father, however, is said to have “reconciled the world to himself,”9 and to have “made peace by the blood of the cross of Christ:”10 and we “are washed, sanctified, and justified, by the Spirit of our God.”11 Paul, in like manner, says of the living God, essentially considered, that he is “the Saviour of all men, especially of them that believe.”12 3dly, Some add that the distinction of the Divine works has a respect to the proximate and immediate principle of operation, and that, in this view, our sanctification should be ascribed to the Holy Ghost.13 We may be permitted, however, to call in question the solidity of this sentiment; for one Divine person doth not act by another, as an intermediate cause; and, as the power of all the persons is one and the same, each of them accomplishes an effect by the same immediate operation. A holy God, essentially considered, is the sanctifier of Israel.14 The Father and the Son perform this work not less immediately than the Spirit; for the power and the operation of all the three are the same. If, indeed, the order of operation amongst the persons be considered, the Father acts by the Son and the Holy Ghost. But, in this sense, all the works of God ought to be characterised as the immediate works of the Holy Ghost. This, however, is foreign to the purpose; for the Father acts no less immediately by the Son, than the Son himself acts; and the Father and the Son act no less immediately by the Holy Spirit, than the Holy Spirit himself acts. It is only where there is a diversity of essences and of operations, that the distinction betwixt a remote and a proximate, or betwixt a mediate and an immediate cause, can have any place.15 Why, then, is sanctification so uniformly ascribed to the third person? No reason occurs to me, at present, more satisfactory than the following. The sanctification of a sinner is the consequence of the grace and the merits of Christ:16 in the order of subsistence and operation amongst the three Divine persons, the Holy Spirit follows the Son, and hence he is called “the Spirit of the Son:”17 it appears, therefore, that the application of the merits of the Son, cannot be more properly attributed to any of the persons, than to him who is next the Son, who is sent by him, and who applies those blessings only, which belong to the Son, and which he receives from him.18

IV. It is of importance to examine this mystery more distinctly. I shall not now explain the terms made use of by the Church on this subject, which Gomar, according to his usual manner,19 has treated accurately, and John Gerhard more copiously.20 Nor shall I scholastically define what is intended by essence, existence, suppositum, and person. Such definitions may be learned from those systems which are in every one’s hand. I shall only state, with great simplicity, and in a manner adapted to the weakest capacities, what we ought to know and believe respecting this tremendous mystery. The true God, who is the Creator of heaven and earth, and the salvation of his chosen people, is one only,21 according to the most absolute unity.22 But, in perfect consistency with this unity, there are three Hypostases, or Persons distinct from one another; each of whom is the only true God, and who have the same common form,23 nature,24 or essence:25 for, “according to the holy Fathers, essence, and nature, and form are synonymous terms.”26 These three are the Father, the Word or Son, and the Holy Ghost; who are not three Gods, nor merely three names, or attributes, or powers of God; but three distinct Persons in one individual Godhead. It is sufficient for salvation to know what has just been stated, though one remain ignorant of the subtle refinements of the schools, which are often bold, and really presumptuous and unadvised.

V. This doctrine belongs to the number of those mysteries of our religion, which man, particularly in his corrupt state, cannot learn from nature alone, and of which Justin Martyr beautifully says: “They surpass all the understanding, all the language, in short, all the comprehension of a created nature. If, therefore, amidst your inquiries into them, any doubt arise in your mind, avail yourself of that which affords a ready solution of your doubts respecting the subject of inquiry,, to wit, faith.”27 Christ himself says in reference to this mystery, “No man knoweth the Son but the Father; neither knoweth any man the Father, save the Son, and he to whomsoever the Son will reveal him.”28 It is, therefore, only by the revelation of the Son, that the relation which exists between him and the Father is known. On this account, we cannot subscribe to the opinion of such of our theologians as have endeavoured to prove, to confirm, and by tedious similitudes to illustrate this mystery, by arguments derived from nature; which, after others, Bisterfeld has acutely and copiously attempted, in the Synopsis prefixed to his learned work against Crellius. It is much safer to keep within the bounds of Scripture alone, lest we involve ourselves in unnecessary difficulties. The testimonies produced from Orpheus, Zoroaster, Trismegistus, the Sibyls, and similar writers, are not genuine; and the clearer they are, they are the more to be suspected. It seems contrary to the sacred oracles, as Casaubon well argues,29 to imagine, that mysteries so profound were more clearly propounded to the Heathen, than to that people whom God Almighty was pleased to favour as peculiarly his own, and to instruct, by his own immediate voice, and by that of his faithful servants. The passages produced from Plato and his disciples, whilst they tally with this doctrine in words, differ from it in sense, and may be considered as borrowed either from the sacred writings which were then extant, or from tradition; the probability of which has been shown by Clement of Alexandria.30

VI. The Scriptures of the Old Testament, as well as of the New, abound with clear and striking testimonies respecting this mystery. It appears from both, 1st, That there are more Divine Persons than one; 2dly, More particularly, that they are three in number; 3dly, Still more particularly, that they are the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost.

The first of these assertions is proved, 1. From those passages of Scripture where God either addresses himself, or speaks concerning himself, in the plural number; such as those quoted at the bottom of the page.31 2. From those passages in which the Lord speaks of the Lord, or is distinguished from the Lord.32

The second assertion is confirmed by the places of Scripture where three distinct persons are mentioned.33

The third is proved from Mat. xxviii. 19. Rom. i. 4. 2 Cor. xiii. 14. 1 John v. 7.

To explain and vindicate all these testimonies might seem somewhat tedious, and it is foreign to our present design.34

VII. We have undertaken to show what it is to believe in a Three-one God. This implies, principally, three things. 1st, The knowledge of this mystery. 2dly, The acknowledgment of it, or an assent to it. 3dly, The calm and holy dependance of the soul upon God as a Three-one God.

VIII. With regard to the knowledge of this mystery, we deem it so necessary, that we cannot venture to assure any adult of salvation, without this knowledge. A distinction should be made, we allow, betwixt the degrees of knowledge, as more or less clear and distinct;—times, also, must be distinguished, for it is fit that knowledge should correspond with the measure of revelation afforded;—the different capacities of men should be distinguished, since some are far more capable of instruction than others;—knowledge existing in the mind, too, must be distinguished from the expression of it with the mouth;—we ought to take into consideration, in fine, the diversity of the ministry under which individuals live. We do not presume to determine the degree or measure of the knowledge required. This only we state, that it does not appear to us, that the man who is entirely ignorant of this mystery is in the way of salvation. The following arguments tend to confirm this opinion.

IX. 1st, Since our Lord himself makes eternal life to consist in the knowledge of the Father, and of the Son whom he hath sent,”35 who will say that such knowledge is not necessary to eternal life? This would be equally absurd as if one should affirm, that that in which salvation itself consists, is not necessary to salvation. No one, it must also be remarked, knows the Father, who is ignorant that from eternity he had an only-begotten Son; nor does any one know the Son, who does not know He is the same God with the Father. “Jesus saith unto him, Have I been so long time with you, and yet hast thou not known me, Philip? He that hath seen me, hath seen the Father. - - - Believest thou not that I am in the Father, and the Father in me?”36 These words import a Trinity, at least a plurality, of persons in one godhead.

X. 2dly, It is admitted, that there is no hope of salvation without the knowledge of the true God. But he only is the true God, who, while he is One in essence, subsists in Three persons. Whoever entertains any other view of God than this, does not represent to himself the true God, but a figment of his own imagination, and an idol. “Whoever,” says Augustine, “thinks that God is such a being as he is not, entertains a conception, in reality, of another and a false God.”37 On this account, the heathen, who knew in general that there is some infinite Deity, but were ignorant of the Trinity, which is the foundation of the covenant of God with elect sinners, are said to have been “without God in the world.”38 The true God, whom Paul preached, was to them Unknown.39 “The Gentiles,” it is said, “knew not God;”40 that is, they did not know him as a Tri-une God. They knew, indeed, that there is some Supreme Being; and thus far, the same Apostle affirms that “they knew God;”41 but they were ignorant of what God is; as if one should know there is a certain King in the realm, but be unacquainted with the person of the King.

XI. 3dly, When the Trinity is not known, the necessary consequence is, that the principal foundations of our faith and comfort, are unknown. All the treasures of wisdom and knowledge, are hid in the mystery of God,42 and of the Father, and of Christ.43 I cannot know how God can show mercy to a sinner in a manner worthy of himself, unless I know he has a Son whom he could send to make satisfaction for sin, and a Spirit who can apply to me the merits of the Son. If I know not that the Father is God, I shall be ignorant that I am a Son of God,—which is the sum of our felicity. If I know not that the Son is God, I shall not form a right estimate of the love of the Father who has given him to me, nor of the grace of the Son, who, though possessing inconceivable majesty, humbled himself so wonderfully for my sake;—nor shall I be able to place a firm dependance upon his satisfaction, which could not be sufficient unless it were of infinite value, or to rely securely on his power, which cannot save me unless it be evidently omnipotent;—it will be impossible for me, in short, to regard him as my Saviour and my Chief Good, because none excepting the true God of Israel is Israel’s God and Redeemer.44 If, in fine, I am not sure that the Holy Spirit, to whose direction and government I ought to commit myself, is God, I shall not be able to esteem my subjection to him as true liberty, to maintain a holy acquiescence in his protecting care, or to rely on his testimony respecting my salvation as a most ample security. Christian faith is of so delicate a character, that it can firmly acquiesce in none but the Most High God. It must, then, be of the first importance and necessity for us to know a doctrine, on which the knowledge of so many necessary points depends. This argument is confirmed by experience; for, as we see in the Socinians, the same men who deny the Trinity, deny, also, the satisfaction of Christ, the invincible power of the Spirit in our regeneration and conservation, the certainty of salvation, and the full assurance of faith. The mystery of our salvation through Christ is so intimately connected with the mystery of the Trinity, that when the latter is unknown or denied, the former cannot be known or acknowledged.

XII. 4thly, It is indisputably manifest, that he who does not honour God the Father cannot be saved; for his own words are as follows: “Them that honour me, I will honour; and they that despise me shall be lightly esteemed.”45 No one, however, rightly honours the Father, who does not, also, honour the Son. “The Father hath committed all judgment unto the Son, that all men should honour the Son, even as they honour the Father. He that honoureth not the Son, honoureth not the Father who hath sent him.”46 Further, no man can honour the Son who does not know him, and who does not know him even in his true character as the Only-begotten, of the same substance with the Father, and, therefore, worthy of the same divine honour with the Father. For what is honour but a reverential acknowledgment of the excellency possessed by the person whom we honour? It follows, then, that without the knowledge of Christ as one God with the Father, there is no salvation.

XIII. 5thly, It is necessary to salvation, to know him of whom all that are about to be baptized according to Christ’s appointment, ought to make a profession. No one can profess what he does not know. But ever since the commencement of the Christian dispensation, it has been incumbent on believers to make a profession of that Trinity, into whose name they are baptized. To be baptized into the name of any one, is to surrender ourselves to him, in order to yield him such homage as is due to God. It, therefore, involves or supposes a confession of his Divinity. It is not, indeed, expressly mentioned in Scripture, that a confession to this effect was demanded in these very terms. But neither is it explicitly affirmed, that the Apostles baptized in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost: yet, without doubt, they observed the institution of our Lord with the most scrupulous exactness. When the Apostles, too, baptized in the name of Christ, which Luke, in his account of their labours,47 testifies that they did; the whole Trinity, as Ambrose ingeniously observes,48 is intended by that name: for when Christ, that is, the Anointed, is mentioned, the expression includes the Father, by whom he was anointed; Christ himself, who received the anointing; and the Holy Ghost, the oil with which he was anointed. In this remark Ambrose has followed Basil, whose words are these: “The naming of Christ is the confession of the whole; for this word denotes, at once, him who anoints, viz. God; the Anointed, viz. the Son; and the unction, viz. the Spirit.”49 Besides, when our Lord says, “He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved; but he that believeth not shall be damned,”50 what is more consonant to reason than that the object of faith to which he referred was that very doctrine which is delivered at baptism? Hence all the ancients, with hardly any exception, made a solemn recognition of the Trinity at the administration of baptism. “You were asked,” says Ambrose,51 “Do you believe in God the Father Almighty? You replied, I believe; and you were immersed, that is, you were buried. You were asked, in the second place, Do you believe in our Lord Jesus Christ? You said, I believe; and you were immersed, and thus buried together with Christ. - - - - You were asked, in the third place, Do you believe in the Holy Ghost? You answered, I believe; you were immersed52 a third time, &c.” “We ought,” says Basil, “to be baptized as we have learned, to believe as we have been baptized, and to honour the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost as we have believed.” See several other testimonies of the Fathers in Forbes;53 to which I here add the expressions of Nazianzen in the speech which he delivered in the Council of Constantinople, the 6th General Council, held in the year of our Lord 381. “We believe in the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Ghost, of the same substance and the same glory; in whom, also, baptism has its perfection: for in baptism, as thou who art initiated knowest, there is both in word and deed, a renunciation of atheism and a confession of the Deity.”54 Thus it appears that the pious ancients believed, that when a man makes a profession of the Trinity in baptism, he passes from atheism to an acknowledgment of the true God.

XIV. It will not be unseasonable here to inquire, whether the mystery of the Trinity was known to Adam in the state of innocence? Moses Amyrault, a celebrated divine, has thought proper to deny this, and to contend,55 that the economy which takes place among the Three persons of the Godhead, so peculiarly respects the redemption of mankind, that “the knowledge of it cannot pertain to the state of innocence, in which there was no place for salvation or redemption.” To us the matter appears in a different light; and we will explain and confirm our opinion by the following arguments.

XV. The doctrine of the Trinity, we confess, is a mystery, which man, how distinguished soever for wisdom and industry, could not discover by the mere consideration of himself and the creatures. We hold it, however, as unquestionably certain, that God revealed several truths to Adam in his original state of integrity, which unassisted nature was incapable of teaching him. Being the confederate, the friend, and a kind of vicegerent of the great God upon earth, it was essential to his happiness to enjoy communion with his God, and from time to time to receive such instruction from his lips as might serve to prepare him more thoroughly for rendering praise to his Creator. Whence, indeed, did he receive the command respecting the tree of knowledge; whence did he learn the signification of the tree of life,—if not by Divine revelation? How else, did he so well know the manner of the creation of his wife, though formed while he was asleep, as to declare that she was bone of his bone and flesh of his flesh?

Zanchius says,56 he has no doubt that God sometimes spoke to Adam, in an external and visible form, by his own Son, clothed with the appearance of a human body. To him it appears altogether improbable, that this privilege which God afterwards granted to a considerable number of men was withheld from the first man, who was the chief friend of God, and created in his perfect image. He affirms, too, that this was the opinion of the Fathers, of Justin, Irenæus, Tertullian, Eusebius, Ambrose, Augustine, and others. For my part, as I dare not determine any thing respecting the mode of revelation, beyond what is related in sacred writ, so I am persuaded that, from the instances which we have adduced, it cannot be questioned that several revelations were, in reality, made to Adam.

XVI. That the mystery of the Trinity was included amongst the subjects of divine revelation to our first father, may be proved thus. It is universally admitted, that the understanding of Adam was adorned with the most excellent wisdom. Now it is the principal branch of wisdom, to know God: Not, however, to know him in so general and indistinct a manner that one understands there is some Infinite Deity, from whom all other beings derive their existence; for such knowledge remained among the heathen, who, we all know, were blind and foolish, and destitute of the divine image. It is essential to a true knowledge of God, that you know distinctly what he is. If you apply those general notions which you have of a Deity to any other than to Him, who, while he is One in essence, subsists in Three persons, you must be considered, not as possessing the knowledge of the true God, but rather as substituting an idol, and a figment of your own imagination, in the place of the true God. But, since it is incongruous and almost blasphemous to impute this to Adam in his state of innocence, we must conclude that he had some knowledge of a Three-one God, who alone is the true God. Epiphanius,57 in the following expressions concerning Adam, employs the same argument: “He was not an idolater, but knew God the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Ghost; for he was a prophet, and knew that the Father said to the Son, Let us make man.” We are here taught by this writer, first, that revelations of a prophetical sort were given to Adam; and, then, that the mystery of the Trinity was one of the points revealed to him: which he proves by this consideration, that he was no idolater. He manifestly supposes, that he would have been an idolater, if he had entertained any other conception of the Almighty, than as a Three-one God.

XVII. In these words, too, Epiphanius suggests another argument, which we shall more fully illustrate. In the work of creation God evidently showed himself a Three-one God; for the Father made the worlds by the Son;58 the Holy Spirit moved upon the waters, and thus rendered them prolific; and the whole Trinity, by mutual excitation, prepared for the creation of man. It is incredible, therefore, that the Trinity was utterly unknown to the first man; unless we can suppose him to have been ignorant of his Creator. Since both the Son and the Holy Spirit created him, he could not have been ignorant of these Divine persons, without being ignorant of his Creator, and unable to praise or adore him aright. Truly it is not without emphasis and meaning, that in a considerable number of passages in which the Scripture speaks of the Creator of man, it makes use of the plural number. Thus where we read, “Thy Maker is thy Husband,” the words in the original literally signify, “Thy Makers are thy Husbands.”59 Again, “Let Israel rejoice in him that made him;” literally, “in his Makers.”60 Man is enjoined to attend to this, and even in early years, to engrave it on his mind; “Remember, now, thy Creator, Creators, in the days of thy youth.”61 It is represented as criminal in man to neglect this, and not to say, “Where is God my Maker, Makers, who giveth songs in the night?”62 Unless these expressions be referred to the Trinity, they might seem dangerous. It is absurd, too, to think that Adam was ignorant of a truth respecting his Creator, (I say Creator, because this is the character now pressed on our attention,) about which his posterity are not permitted to be ignorant. The absurdity is the more apparent, when it is considered that God created man to be a herald to proclaim himself and his attributes in the new-formed world; for unquestionably it tends to the glory of God, that man should particularly celebrate not only the Divine perfections, but also the manner in which these perfections are displayed in the distinct Persons of the Godhead, and in the mode and order of their operation.

XVIII. Hence it appears that the economy of the Trinity ought not to be so restricted to the plan of the redemption of mankind, as not to be observed in the first creation of the world and of man. The Gospel itself, while it unfolds this admirable economy as it respects the method of our salvation, leads back our thoughts at the same time to that economy, as it was discovered in the first formation of the world. It shows us, that in the old creation there was a certain type and figure of the new;63 and that the Son of God our Saviour is “the Beginning” (viz. in the active sense of the term) “of the creation of God;”64 by whom were made thrones, and dominions, things visible and invisible, “that in all things he might have the pre-eminence;”65 that is, that he might hold the pre-eminence as well in the works of nature, as in those of grace. It is, therefore, wrong to conclude that Adam had no knowledge of the Trinity, from the supposition that the economy of the Trinity is principally concerned in the work of redeeming sinners; since this work of redemption, which is a new creation, was shadowed forth by the first creation, in which the economy of the Three persons no less manifested itself.66

XIX. It is rashly asserted, too, “that in the state of innocence there was no room for salvation67 or redemption.” This, indeed, is true with regard to redemption, but with respect to salvation, it is false. The same salvation, the same eternal life, which we obtain through Christ, (as we have shown at large elsewhere,) was promised to Adam upon condition of his persisting in holiness.68 We have an evidence of this in the tree of life, which was, then, a symbol, though not of the Mediator as such, yet of the Son of God; for “In him was life.”69 This symbol would have been nugatory, if its meaning had been unknown to Adam.

XX. Thus far respecting the knowledge of this mystery. An assent to the doctrine, and an acknowledgment of it, after it has been explained to one from the word of God, are no less necessary. The condition of one who denies and impugns a fundamental truth which he knows, is evidently far worse than that of one who is simply ignorant of it. They who oppose the doctrine of the Trinity, I do not hesitate to declare with confidence, have no part in eternal salvation. The Apostle John expressly warns us, that “Whosoever denieth the Son, the same hath not the Father.”70 Now, that man denies the Son, who denies his Divinity, and who denies the Spirit of the Son,—who is of the same substance with the Son, and, without whom, no man can say that Jesus is Lord.71

XXI. When, therefore, men deny, oppose, and blaspheme the doctrine of the Trinity, as the modern Socinians do, we cannot acknowledge them as Christians and Brethren; we cannot offer them any Church communion, nor accept of it, if offered by them. How much soever they may attempt to recommend themselves by a specious appearance of piety, we boldly pronounce them perverters of Christianity, fighters against God,72 and gross idolaters; with whom we wish to have no fellowship in our Churches, and to whom, according to the injunction of an Apostle, we will not say, “God speed.”73 We applaud the zeal of Christopher Krainscius, who, when Smalcius, a Socinian leader, with his followers, troubled the Orthodox with an unreasonable demand of union, first in the Synod of Lublin, in the year 1612, and afterwards in the Synod of Belzo, honestly replied, “Sirs, begone, give us no trouble; for sooner may heaven enter into an agreement with hell, than we, the Evangelical, with you. Let the man who fears God, go out from this Church;” and instantly he himself went out. When the adversaries complained of Krainscius, as having by this conduct and language pronounced them unworthy of his company, Count Leszczinius rejoined, “I also fear God, and therefore, I will remove;” and no sooner did he utter the word than he went out, mounted his carriage, and departed. Thus the union demanded was refused.74 Whoever wishes to see more on this topic, may consult the learned Theses of the venerable Voet, on the necessity and utility of the doctrine of the Holy Trinity.”75

XXII. But what would a naked and merely speculative knowledge and acknowledgment of this mystery avail, unless to these were added the pious dependance of the soul upon a Three-one God? No sooner is the believer divinely instructed in this truth than he delights in it; rejoicing that now he knows and believes those mysteries relating to his God, which transcend all sense, all language, all understanding;—which are worthy of his incomprehensible infinitude;—and by which, in fine, he is distinguished from all the idols of the nations, and from those false Gods which every one, by his own perverse conceptions, has formed for himself. “I have found thee,” says Faith, “I have found, and I recognise thee, O my God, the Rock of my salvation, of whom the rest of the world are ignorant; and whom the Athenians, the wisest of mortals, confessed to be to them unknown. Thou art He;76 in the most absolute unity Three; in a distinct Trinity, One; Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. Thou alone art the ‘true God and eternal life.’

XXIII. Nor does faith stop here. But, acknowledging the Father as God, she confidently commits herself to his omnipotent power, his unsearchable wisdom, his unbounded goodness, and the inexhaustible riches of his all-sufficiency. Acknowledging the Son as God, she rests securely on his satisfaction as most ample, and as deriving infinite value from the dignity of his godhead. “Surely shall one say, In Jehovah have I righteousness and strength; even to him shall men come. - - - In Jehovah shall all the seed of Israel be justified, and shall glory.”77 Acknowledging the Holy Ghost as God, she firmly relies on his wise and holy guidance, and reposes an unsuspecting confidence in his testimony as infallible, and infinitely worthy of credit.78 Knowing, too, that these three are One, faith is not distracted in her operations, but devolves her whole weight on this Tri-une God;—assured from their unity of will, as well as of essence, that all the three persons harmoniously concur in promoting her salvation.

XXIV. Nothing is more false than that calumny of the Remonstrants, by which they deny that the article of the Holy Trinity has any practical use. Every doctrine of “the truth, is according to godliness:”79 and shall this character not apply to a doctrine so conspicuous, so fundamental? This article is even the source of all genuine faith, of all true religion. He cannot have Christian faith, who doth not believe that a person in the Godhead could have been given, and has been actually given us, to be a successful Mediator with God; but this would have been impossible, if the Godhead had subsisted only in one person. He who does not adore the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, as equal in divine majesty, worships not the true God, but a creature of his own imagination. Go now, if you will, and boldly affirm, that this doctrine, which is absolutely essential to Christian faith and piety, is unprofitable in relation to practice. The Remonstrants are guilty of offending and dishonouring God, when, in order to flatter the Socinians, for whom they entertain too great a regard, they describe them as persons, “who so regulate their lives according to the rule of the Gospel, that they worship the Father in his Son, and, by devout and pious supplications, solicit from both, the grace of the Holy Ghost.”80 What sort of language, alas! shall we now have the unhappiness to hear? Do they regulate their lives according to the rule of the Gospel, who, by denying the satisfaction of Christ, overthrow the Gospel? Do those worship the Father in the Son, who slanderously affirm that the eternal Son of God is a mere man,81 and who, whilst they adore him as such, make him an idol? Do those men, by pious supplications, implore the grace of the Holy Spirit from the Father and the Son, who blasphemously allege, that the Spirit is only an attribute of God, or a creature, or at least, a person of some intermediate dignity betwixt God and a creature? How much more justly does Ignatius say,82 “Whosoever declares that God is one only, in such a sense as to rob Christ of Divinity, is a devil, and an enemy of all righteousness.”83

XXV. Let us now point out the more special uses of this article. The doctrine of the Holy Trinity is profitable, in the first place, for Instruction, and that in a two-fold respect. 1st, Our understanding is informed in what manner it ought to be exercised in its meditations concerning God. Not confining its views merely to his One essence with its attributes, it must ascend to the Wonderful Trinity. Rightly to know God, is, unquestionably, an important part of piety;84 and a more excellent object of contemplation cannot be presented to the mind, than this tremendous mystery, the intuitive and perfect knowledge of which, will complete its felicity in the light of glory. 2dly, From this incomprehensible mystery, which surpasses all sense and reason, we learn that we must renounce our own wisdom in divine matters, and reduce every thought into captivity to the obedience of faith. No one is prepared to form right views of this mystery, who has not risen above the low sphere of the senses and human reasonings; and soared to the sublimer region of faith; where, relying solely on God’s own testimony respecting himself, he believes what he is able neither to see with his eyes, nor comprehend with his mind,—stopping at that precise point, beyond which divine revelation doth not conduct him. “You hear,” says Gregory Nazianzen, “of the generation of the Son; be not inquisitive with respect to its mode. You hear that the Spirit proceeds from the Father; beware of curiously inquiring into the manner of this procession.”85

XXVI. Secondly, This doctrine is conducive to Consolation. 1st, O how delightful is it to behold in the very intimate union, or rather unity, of the Three Divine persons, a pattern and representation of our own union with Christ, and, through Christ, with God! This astonishing idea is suggested by our Lord’s prayer,—“That they all may be one, as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee; that they also may be one in us; - - - that they may be one, even as we are one; I in them, and thou in me.”86 2dly, O how pleasant is it to believe that the Father, who has adopted me for a son, is God; who, being himself Lord of all, is able to make me an heir of all things;—to reflect that the Son, to whom my soul is betrothed, is, equally with the Father, God, and the King of glory;—to know that the Holy Spirit, by whom I am sealed unto the day of complete salvation, is, in like manner, God, and, consequently, truth itself!87 3dly, O how delightful is it for me, when meditating on the mystery of the Sacred Trinity, to behold in the face of the eternal Father, the kindness of his unbounded love towards me;—in the face of the co-eternal Son, the endearing familiarity of the purest brotherly love;88—and in the light of the Holy Spirit, the bonds of my union with God!

XXVII. In the third place, it is useful for Admonition.89 It serves to admonish us, 1st, That we Christians, who ought to “be followers of God, as dear children,”90 should live together in perfect harmony, being “of one accord, of one mind;”91 “endeavouring to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace.”92 2dly, That we should reverence the divine majesty of our Father;—that we should, with alacrity, throw open the doors of our hearts to the Son, the king of glory;—that we should not “grieve,”93 nor “vex,”94 nor “quench,”95 the Holy Spirit, who is a person of the same divine dignity with the Father, and the Son; but consecrate our whole selves to him as temples sacred to his honour,96—solicitously avoiding all approaches to that sin against Him, which shall never be forgiven, neither in this world, nor in the world to come.97

I conclude with the words of Synesius, in his third Hymn.98

“I praise thee as One; I praise thee as Three.
While Three, thou art One; while One, thou art Three.”

Notes

Note XXX. Page 124.

“The sanctification of a sinner is the consequence of the grace and merits of Christ.” In this, and in some other passages, as in the 11th section of this Dissertation, our Author, when referring to our Lord’s meritorious obedience and satisfactory sufferings, doth not scruple to make use of the expression the merits of Christ.99 The same expression is employed also by many other evangelical writers. But, although it may not deserve to be entirely erazed from the vocabulary of orthodox Divines, and for the sake of variety may sometimes be employed, it is by no means so precise and unequivocal as some other phrases they are accustomed to use on that interesting topic. The remarks of Mr Hervey on this expression, however scrupulous and antiquated they may appear, are worthy of attention. In a controversial performance, written with considerable ability and spirit,100 after having quoted the following question proposed by Mr Wesley, “Is justification more or less than God’s pardoning and accepting a sinner through the merits of Christ?” he expresses his willingness to acquiesce in this definition, “if somewhat explained and a little improved.” - - - “The merits of Christ,” he adds, “will certainly comport with Popish or with Socinian notions. It abounds in writers of the former sort, and it is to be found in the latter. Therefore, to be more explicit: By pardoning, I mean God’s acquitting a sinner from guilt of every kind and of every degree. By accepting, I mean still more, God’s receiving him into full favour, considering and treating him as righteous, yea, perfectly and gloriously righteous. By the merits of Christ, I would always be disposed to signify his active and passive obedience, all that he wrought and all that he suffered for the salvation of mankind.” “The merits of Christ,” he subjoins in a Note, “is an ambiguous phrase, and what I can by no means admire. But as it occurs in Mr Wesley’s Letter, and in many valuable writers, I have, led by their example, occasionally used it in the following debate, understanding it and still using it in the sense explained above.” After a few sentences in the text, Mr Hervey has this additional note. “To gratify Mr Wesley, I have admitted his phrase the merits of Christ, though as it is a phrase of dubious import, and what almost any sect or heresy will subscribe, I should much sooner choose to abide by Aspasio’s language. And why should we not all speak with the Scriptures? Why should we not use the expressions of the Apostle? He says, ‘justified by the blood of Christ;’ he says, ‘made righteous by the obedience of Christ.’ When therefore we say, sinners are pardoned and accepted through the blood and through the obedience of Christ, we have a warrant for our doctrine which is indisputable, and a precedent for our language which is unexceptionable.”

Note XXXI. Page 127.

The good sense of the Author appears in the conciseness and simplicity with which he has treated the doctrine of the Trinity. Nor is it the design of the Translator, either to bring forward those “subtle refinements of the schools,” which are justly stigmatised by Witsius as bold and presumptuous; or, what indeed, if executed with propriety, might prove a more rational and profitable service,—to illustrate and vindicate particularly those passages of Scripture which establish this momentous article of the Christian faith. It seems right, however, to suggest a few hints on a topic so sacredly important, though keenly controverted.

Amongst the numerous publications that have appeared in defence of this doctrine, few perhaps are more satisfactory, or at least more useful, than the small Treatise by the Rev. William Jones, entitled “the Catholic doctrine of the Trinity proved by above an hundred short and clear arguments, expressed in the terms of the Holy Scripture.” This little work is warmly recommended by the Rev. John Newton in one of his letters; and the sentiments with which he accompanies the recommendation are so instructive, and so worthy of the Author as a friend and pattern of evangelical and vital religion, that it would be almost a crime to omit the opportunity of quoting the whole passage.

“It gave me great comfort,” says that excellent man to a pious correspondent, “to find that what I wrote concerning the Divine character of Jesus as God manifest in the flesh, met with your approbation. This doctrine is, in my view, the great Foundation-stone upon which all true religion is built. But, alas! in the present day, it is the stumbling-stone and rock of offence, upon which too many, fondly presuming upon their own wisdom, fall and are broken. I am so far from wondering that any should doubt of it, that I am firmly persuaded none can truly believe it, however plainly set forth in Scripture, unless it be revealed to them from heaven; or in the Apostle’s words, that ‘no one can call Jesus Christ Lord, but by the Holy Ghost.’ I believe there are many who think they believe it, because they have taken it for granted, and never attentively considered the difficulties with which it is attended in the eye of fallen reason. Judging by natural light, it seems impossible to believe that the title of ‘the true God and eternal life’ should properly belong to that despised man who hung dead upon the cross, exposed to the insults of his cruel enemies. I know nothing that can obviate the objections the reasoning mind is ready to form against it, but a real conviction of the sinfulness of sin, and the state of a sinner as exposed to the curse of the holy law, and destitute of every plea and hope in himself. Then the necessity of a Redeemer, and the necessity of this Redeemer’s being Almighty, is seen and felt, with an evidence which bears down all opposition; for neither the efficacy of his atonement and intercession, nor his sufficiency to guide, save, protect, and feed those who trust in him, can be conceived of without it. When the eyes of the understanding are opened, the soul made acquainted with and attentive to its own state and wants, he that runs may read this truth, not in a few detached texts of a dubious import, and liable to be twisted and tortured by the arts of criticism, but as interwoven in the very frame and texture of the Bible, and written, as with a sun-beam, throughout the principal parts both of the Old and New Testament. If Christ be the Shepherd and Husband of his people under the Gospel, and if his coming into the world did not abridge those who feared God of the privileges they were entitled to before his appearance, it follows by undeniable consequence that he is ‘God over all blessed for ever.’ For David tells us, that his Shepherd was Jehovah; and the Husband of the Old Testament Church was the Maker and God of the whole earth, the Holy One of Israel, whose name is the Lord of Hosts. Psalm xxiii. 1. Isaiah liv. 8. with xlvii. 4. I agree with you that, among the many attempts which have been made to prove and illustrate the scripture-doctrine that the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit are one God, there have been many injudicious, unwarrantable things advanced, which have perplexed instead of instructing, and of which the enemies of the truth have known how to make their advantage. However, there have been tracts upon these sublime subjects, which have been written with judgment and an unction, and I believe attended with a blessing. I seem to prefer Mr Jones’s book on the Trinity to any I have seen, because he does little more than state some of the scripture-evidence for it, and draws his inferences plainly and briefly; though even he has admitted a few texts, which may perhaps be thought not quite full to the point; and he has certainly omitted several of the most express and strongest testimonies. The best and happiest proof of all, that this doctrine is true in itself and true to us, is the experience of its effects. They who know his name will put their trust in him; they who are rightly impressed with his astonishing condescension and love, in emptying himself and submitting to the death of the cross for our sakes, will find themselves under a sweet constraint to love him again, and will feel a little of that emotion of heart which the Apostle expresses in that lively passage, Gal. vi. 14.”101

Whilst the New Testament unquestionably supplies more ample testimonies to the doctrine of the Trinity than the Old, the latter furnishes evidence more abundant and decisive than some are willing to admit. The passages in Genesis, the Psalms, and the Prophets, referred to by Witsius, and many other texts that might be produced from these ancient books, are sufficient, at least when taken in connexion and allowed to shed light on each other, to show that there are in reality more than one Person in the godhead, and even that the Persons are Three in number. In several places of the Old Testament, as in Isaiah ix. 6. xl. 3, 4, 9. Jerem. xxiii. 6. Zech. xiii. 7. and Mal. iii. 1, the true divinity of the Messiah is expressly and copiously declared. This indeed is a principle pervading the whole system, or, to use Mr Newton’s expression, “interwoven in the very frame and texture,” of ancient predictions and promises. And if the divinity of the Son of God, the promised Redeemer, was so clearly and fully taught in the days of old, who can suppose that the sublime doctrine of Three in one was entirely unknown to the Old Testament Church? On this subject, Bishop Horsley’s Sermon from Mal. iii. 1.; Dr Dick’s Sermon from Isaiah ix. 6, in which he shows that the ancient Church expected a Divine person in the character of Messiah, and that none but a Divine person could have realized the hopes of the Church; and Dr Wardlaw’s Discourse102 on the Unity of God and the Trinity of Persons in the Godhead, are highly worthy of attention. The reader may also consult, with much advantage, Dr Dwight’s Sermon entitled, “Testimonies to the Doctrine of the Trinity from the ancient Christians, Jews, and Heathens.”103 When quoting the sentiments of ancient Jews, Dwight states, that Philo, who flourished in the first century, calls the Logos “the eternal Logos, or God;” and says, “he is necessarily eternal, and the image of the invisible God.” He shows, too, that similar expressions were employed by the Chaldee Paraphrasts, and other Jewish commentators. They hold, it appears, that “there are three degrees in the mystery of Aleim or Elohim;” and these degrees they denominate “persons.” They affirm of them,—“they are all one, and cannot be separated.” R. Judah Hakkados, who lived in the second century, uses the expression “God the Father, God the Son, God the Holy Spirit,—three in unity, one in trinity.”

Of the four passages in the New Testament Scriptures, cited by Witsius to show that the three Divine persons are the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, two are at once clear and indisputable, namely, Mat. xxviii. 19. and 2 Cor. xiii. 14. The other two are Rom. i. 4. 1 John v. 7.

With regard to Rom. i. 4, it unquestionably makes mention of Christ as the Son of God, and thus alludes also to the first person in the godhead under the character of the Father. But if the worthy Author intended to intimate, that the expression “according to the Spirit of holiness” refers to the third person, usually called the Holy Spirit, the accuracy of his interpretation may certainly be questioned. Calvin, Doddridge, and several other respectable interpreters indeed, have adopted the same view of this phrase. Many judicious writers, however, are of opinion, that it refers, not to the Holy Spirit, but to Christ’s own divinity; which is contrasted with the flesh, or human nature, mentioned in the preceding verse. Such were the sentiments of, at least, Tertullian and Ambrose among the ancients. The same interpretation is embraced by a large proportion of modern critics and divines, including Paræus, Erasmus, Cameron, Hammond, and the continuators of Pool. Beza reasons powerfully and successfully in its defence. Dr Macknight translates the verse thus—“But was declared the Son of God with power, with respect to his holy spiritual nature, by his resurrection from the dead.” Dr Guyse, in fine, has the following Note on this verse: “If the Spirit of holiness is here considered as expressive of the sense in which Christ was the Son of God, it evidently signifies his own Divine nature, in opposition to what he was according to the flesh; and so the antithesis is very beautiful between (κατα πνευμα) according to the Spirit here, and (κατα σαρκα) according to the flesh, ver. 3. But if we consider it as the principle of the power by which Christ was raised from the dead, for demonstrating him to be the Son of God, it may signify either his own divine nature, or the Holy Spirit, the third Person in the adorable Trinity. And yet, unless his own divine power concurred in raising him from the dead, his resurrection, abstractly considered in itself, no more proved him to be the Son of God, than the resurrection of believers by the power of God, and by his Spirit, who dwells in them, (Rom. viii. 11.) proves any of them to be so.”

With respect to the other distinguished text referred to, to wit, 1 John v. 7, its authenticity has been warmly disputed. Dr Mill, Bengel, Pool in his Synopsis Criticorum, Dr Hammond, Sloss, Whitby, Brown, and many more, zealously contend that it is genuine; whilst Michaelis, Griesbach, and others, no less strenuously urge that it is spurious.104 The doctrine of the Trinity, it is of importance to remark, by no means hangs on this, or any other single verse of Scripture; and although its spuriousness were established by irrefragable proofs, the believer in the Sacred Three has no just cause of alarm.

The laws of candour, too, it should be noted, strictly forbid us to consider one’s doubting or even denying the genuineness of this controverted text, an unequivocal evidence of heresy. Luther would never admit it into his German translation of the Scriptures; and Calvin, in his Commentary on the passage, while he expresses an inclination to retain it, yet, on account of its being omitted in many Greek Manuscripts, intimates a doubt of its authenticity in these words, “Vix quicquam asserere audeo,” i. e. “I can hardly venture to make a positive assertion on the subject.” The orthodoxy, nevertheless, both of Luther and Calvin, with regard to the true divinity of Christ and the Holy Spirit, is completely indubitable. The learned Griesbach himself, though, in consequence of his Diatribe on 1 John v. 7, 8, and several other critical discussions of a similar nature, some have rashly regarded him as a patron of Socinian errors, most solemnly professes his persuasion of the Saviour’s divinity, in a passage which has been thus translated,—“I publicly declare, and appeal to God for my sincerity, that I never doubted of the truth of the doctrine of the divinity of Christ. There are, indeed, arguments and passages of Scripture in its support so numerous and so satisfactory, that I am at a loss to conceive how any person who admits the authority of Scripture, and adopts a fair method of interpretation, can call it in question. That single passage, John i. 1–3, is itself so plain, and so free from every just exception, that the boldest efforts of interpreters and critics will be found incapable of wresting it from the hands of the defenders of the truth.”105

From the manner in which Witsius refers to 1 John v. 7. it appears that he was one of those who consider this verse as forming a part of the inspired record; and his Translator, though he does not pretend to be very thoroughly acquainted with the numerous writings on the question, will take the liberty to say, that he has not yet seen sufficient reason to embrace the contrary opinion. It gives him pleasure also to find, that, although it has now become very fashionable to abandon the defence of this text, its spuriousness is by no means universally admitted by the learned. Bishop Horsley supports its authority with his usual decision. Milner seems to have viewed it in the same light, and adduces an historical argument on its behalf, of considerable weight. “It deserves to be noticed,” says he, “that in their exposition of the Apostles’ Creed, the Waldensian Reformers give us the well known text in 1 John v. 7. as a proof of the doctrine of the Trinity. They were, it seems, perfectly satisfied of its authenticity, and most probably, at that time, had never heard of any suggestions to the contrary.”106 Dr Macknight also, whilst he declines “passing any judgment on a matter which hath been so much contested,” makes the following remarks in its favour. “1st, That this verse, properly interpreted, instead of disturbing the sense of the verses with which it is joined, rather renders it more connected and complete. 2dly, That in verse 9th the witness of God is supposed to have been before appealed to; If we receive the witness of men, the witness of God is greater. And yet, if verse 7th is excluded, the witness of God is nowhere mentioned by the Apostle.”107

On the whole, amidst the difficulties arising from an acknowledged deficiency in the proofs from ancient copies, versions, and quotations, and amidst the jarring accounts which learned critics, in some instances, have given of the reading in the same Manuscript, the internal evidence for the genuineness of the text is considerably powerful. Notwithstanding the attempts which have been made to account for the insertion of the 7th verse by a mystical interpretation of the 8th having been inserted in the margin, and at last introduced into the text, still greater probability appears to attach to the conjecture, that, owing to the similarity of the beginning of the 7th and 8th verses, or to some other cause, a transcriber might incautiously slip over the seventh. Were we to entertain the harsh and improbable supposition, that, on one side or other, unhallowed liberties have been wilfully taken with the apostolic record, it admits of no doubt, as it is expressed by Dr Guyse, that “the Trinitarians had less occasion to interpolate this verse, than the Anti-trinitarians had to take it out of the sacred Canon.”

The objections urged against the doctrine of the Trinity, though repeated very frequently by its enemies with an air of triumph, have often received satisfactory answers. Nothing can be more unjust, as well as uncandid, than the reiterated attempts which are made to convict Trinitarians of holding a contradictory doctrine. Did they affirm, indeed, that the Father, Son, and Spirit are three in the same sense in which they are one, and one in the same sense in which they are three, they might be justly accused of self-contradiction. But this is by no means their doctrine. They assert that the Divine Persons are three in a certain respect, and one in another respect; whilst they frankly acknowledge their incapacity fully to comprehend or explain the manner in which these Three subsist in the same uncreated and undivided essence. On the testimony of God, who no doubt possesses a perfect and infallible knowledge of himself, and who cannot possibly lie or deceive, they believe a sublime and, to fallen mankind, a deeply interesting fact relative to the Divine being, while the modus of the fact confessedly surpasses the comprehension of mortals. And why, it may be boldly asked,—why should such believing be deemed preposterous, or irrational? “We may be unquestionably sure of many things as to their existence,” says Bishop Wilkins, “and yet we may not be able to explain the nature of them. No man in his wits can make any doubt whether there be such things as motion, and sensation, and continuity of bodies: and yet these things are commonly esteemed inexplicable. So that our not being able to see to the bottom of things, and to give a distinct account of the nature and manner of them, can be no sufficient cause to doubt of their being.”108—Reason has its mysteries as well as Revelation. That the Almighty existed from eternity, is unquestionably a doctrine of Natural Religion. “The invisible things of Him from the creation of the world, are clearly seen, being understood by the things which are made, even his eternal power and godhead.” Yet every one capable of reflecting on the subject, must be sensible, that it is no less impossible for us to form an adequate conception of the doctrine of God’s existing from eternity, than of his subsisting in three distinct persons. No man, therefore, who admits the one doctrine notwithstanding its mysteriousness, and rejects the other because it exceeds his comprehension, can be successfully vindicated from the charge of gross inconsistency. But instead of prosecuting this subject farther, suffice it to refer the reader to Wardlaw’s Discourse on the Unity of God mentioned above, and to an enlightened and able “Review of the Socinian and Unitarian Controversy” in the Christian Instructor.109

Note XXXII. Page 130.

“All the treasures of wisdom and knowledge,” says the Author, “are hid in the mystery of God, and the Father, and of Christ.” In the authorised English Version of the Bible, we read, Col. ii. 3. “In whom (i. e. in Christ) are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge.” The original expression, however, ἐν ὡ, rendered “in whom,” is equally capable, as is obvious to every one at all acquainted with the Greek language, of being translated “in which;” and might, therefore, be referred to the mystery mentioned in the 2d verse. Our Translators have done well in referring it to “Christ;” but Witsius is not singular in applying it to “the mystery.” Dr Hammond decidedly refers it to the mystery “of the Gospel, or Christianity;” “that is,” he adds, “of the course which hath more obscurely been taken by God the Father under the Old Testament, and more clearly now by God in Christ under the New, to bring sinners to salvation. Verse 3. In which course is wrapt up all the depth of wisdom imaginable.” Dr Whitby’s opinion is, that it refers to the person of Christ, and in support of this interpretation he quotes Philip. iii. 8. compared with verses 11, 12. and also Col. ii. 8, 9. Yet he allows, “that there seemeth to be no great difference between referring this to his person, and referring it to his doctrine.” Calvin, too, in his Commentary on the passage, while in common with the most of writers, he prefers applying it to the person of our Lord, admits that there is little difference betwixt the two applications. Compare Dissert. xii. Sect. i.

Note XXXIII. Page 133.

To entertain the reader with minute and acrimonious discussions relative to those minor points with regard to which a diversity of sentiment and practice prevails among serious and intelligent Christians, is by no means the design of these Notes. A decided persuasion in one’s own mind, regarding such matters, is not at all inconsistent with candour towards them who embrace a different view of the subject; or with admitting that the arguments employed in defence of the contrary tenet, though not conclusive, do possess such a degree of weight or of speciousness, that, in this imperfect state, it is not wonderful men of integrity should acquiesce in them as fully satisfactory. When Christians shall have learned to avoid irritating expressions, and to manifest towards each other the true spirit of forbearance and charity, and, at the same time, calmly and impartially to investigate the truth, determined, with the docility of children, to acquiesce in the will of Christ,—a much greater unity of sentiment will assuredly be attained.

“It must be confessed on all sides,” says Mr Bradbury, “that good people have been intemperate with one another, and argued with a warmth that has done little service to the cause; first, about the subject of baptism, whether it may be administered to infants or no; and secondly, about the manner of performing it, whether by sprinkling or plunging. I dare say there are many of both opinions, who bewail the excesses that have come into the controversy, and could wish that the disputants were Christians as well as orthodox; that in maintaining the truth they would not grieve the good Spirit of God, but that all bitterness and wrath, partiality, noise, clamour, and evil-speaking, be put away, with all malice; that “the arguments may be as gentle as the cause it maintains.”110

The reign of bitterness and wrath, it may be hoped, is rapidly hastening to an end. Every man ought, meanwhile, in the spirit of Christianity, to embrace proper opportunities of stating those sentiments which appear to him to be consonant to Scripture. On this principle, and in order to prevent misapprehensions of our Author’s meaning, it seems right to observe, that although, when discoursing on the doctrine of the Trinity, he quotes with approbation a passage from Ambrose, in which that venerable writer speaks of Christians having been immersed at their baptism, we ought not to conclude that immersion or plunging is essential to the ordinance, or that Witsius looked upon it in this light. His views on this topic appear to have coincided with those which the compilers of the Westminster Confession of Faith have very cautiously and judiciously expressed in the following terms—“Dipping of the person into the water is not necessary; but baptism is rightly administered by pouring or sprinkling water upon the person;”111—and agreeably to which, also, the definitions of Baptism in the Larger and in the Shorter Catechism, represent this Christian rite under the general notion of “a washing with water.” Without entering further into this contested point, or adverting to the numerous publications in which it is discussed, it may suffice to cite a passage from our Author’s work on the Covenants, where he states his views of the subject at large.112

Having proposed the question, “Whether baptism is rightly administered only by immersion, or whether it may be done also by pouring water from a vessel, or by sprinkling?”—he admits, in reply, that both John the Baptist and our Lord’s disciples usually baptized by immersion, and that the native signification of the Greek terms βαπτειν and βαπτιζειν is mergere, tingere, to plunge, to dip.

Yet, after having made these and some other concessions, in which the advocates for sprinkling are far from being universally inclined to acquiesce, he thus proceeds. “It must not, however, be supposed, that immersion is so necessary to baptism, that it cannot be rightly performed by pouring or sprinkling. The following arguments in favour of pouring and sprinkling, are of considerable force. 1. If we find that the Apostles did baptize by immersion, it doth not follow that they uniformly observed this method. It is more probable that the three thousand who were baptized in one day (Acts ii. 41.) had water poured or sprinkled upon them, than that they were immersed. It is not likely, that the Apostles, being completely occupied in preaching the Gospel, could have found leisure to accomplish a work which must have required so much time and labour, as immersing so many thousands. Nor is it probable that Cornelius, and Lydia, and the Jailor, who were baptized in private houses together with those of their household, had baptisteries at hand, in which they could be entirely immersed. Vossius113 has produced instances of sprinkling from antiquity, which Josua Arndius114 has related in the same order, without acknowledging his obligations to Vossius. 2. Although βαπτιζειν properly signifies mergere, to immerse, it is used more generally to denote any kind of washing, as Luke xi. 38. Dominicus a Soto115 has well observed, ‘That in baptism there is something essential, as washing, agreeably to the expression Ephes. v. 26. where the Apostle calls baptism a washing with water; and something accidental, namely, whether the washing be done in this way or that.’ 3. The thing signified by baptism is expressed by pouring and sprinkling, both in the Old and New Testament. On pouring, or affusion, see Isaiah xliv. 3.; on sprinkling, see Isaiah lii. 15. Ezek. xxxvi. 25. Heb. xii. 24. 1 Pet. i. 2. In these places of Scripture, there is an allusion, I admit, to the Levitical sprinkling; yet from this it is evident, that the application of the blood and Spirit of Christ, which believers under the New Testament experience, was properly represented by the rite of sprinkling. This is expressly suggested by the Apostle, Heb. ix. 13, 14. ‘For if the blood of bulls and of goats, and the ashes of an heifer sprinkling the unclean, sanctifieth to the purifying of the flesh, how much more shall the blood of Christ - - - purge your conscience from dead works?’ 4. Add to this, that the whole genius of the New Testament dispensation, being distinguished by liberality and gentleness, seems to preclude the necessity of stripping and immersing feeble infants when baptized, particularly in northern climates.”—After some further remarks, the Author observes, that, from what he had said, it follows, “that those Greeks, who in the council of Florence pronounced the Latin Christians unbaptized, because they had not been immersed in water, acted an exceedingly rigorous, and, at the same time, an unreasonable part.”

Ambrose, in the quotation from him to which this Note refers, alludes, the reader will observe, to a three-fold immersion, which seems to have been customary in his age. It is proper, therefore, to add, that our Author adverts to this practice in the same chapter of the Economy of the Covenants,116 from which we have just quoted these remarks in favour of sprinkling. It is of small moment, in his opinion, whether immersion or sprinkling be done once or thrice. Amongst the early Christians, he concedes, from the idea that a three-fold immersion or sprinkling implied a marked confession of the adorable Trinity, and also of our Saviour’s rising from the dead on the third day, the rite was generally performed three times. About the beginning of the seventh century, however, the Arians in Spain, having begun to pervert this practice, for the support of their own errors in dividing the godhead, it was determined, as our Author states, at the fourth Council of Toledo, that both forms are irreprehensible in the Church of God, and the application of water once only was pronounced the more eligible mode.

Note XXXIV. Page 138, line 15.

Although the Author affirms, that “the economy of the Three Persons manifested itself no less”117 in the first creation, than in the new creation, or work of redemption, his meaning must have been, that the discovery of the Three Persons in the former was equally certain as in the latter, not that it was equally ample and bright. If the wisdom, power, goodness, and other attributes of the Deity as one God possessing infinite perfection, are more illustriously displayed in the new creation than in the old, and if angels, in consequence, sing “Glory to God in the highest,” it is at the same time evident, that redemption exhibits the clearest and most impressive manifestation of Jehovah as Three in one. The distinct characters sustained by the Father, Son, and Spirit, and the distinct parts which they respectively fulfil in the plan of our recovery, most assuredly place this glorious mystery in a new point of light, inexpressibly more conspicuous and interesting than that in which it appeared at the original creation of man.

The whole passage in this Dissertation, relative to Adam’s knowledge of the Trinity, has its parallel in the Author’s Treatise on the Covenants,118 where the same topic is discussed with some varieties of thought and expression. Amyrald’s assertion, that the doctrine of the Trinity so peculiarly respects the redemption of mankind, “that the knowledge of it cannot pertain to the state of innocence,” was unquestionably rash; and the arguments brought forward by Witsius in opposition to that sentiment, it must be allowed, are at once ingenious and considerably satisfactory. To suppose that a revelation of the Three persons in the godhead was made to our first parents in Paradise involves, at least, nothing absurd or incongruous; and it is of great importance to maintain, that the personal distinctions in the Divine nature are not voluntary but necessary, and that these distinctions existed from all eternity.

Note XXXV. Page 138, line 23.

The venerable Author affirms, that “the same eternal life, which we obtain through Christ,” was promised to Adam on condition of his perseverance in holy obedience; and refers his reader to another work, in which he has proved his assertion at large. He intends, no doubt, his Economy of the Covenants,119 where he treats particularly of the promises and seals of the covenant of works, and shows that everlasting happiness in the enjoyment of God was promised to Adam as the reward of perfect obedience. No one, however, can reasonably question, that Witsius, while he held that the life thus promised to Adam was in substance the same as that which we receive through Christ, would have cheerfully admitted, that the one falls short of the other in various respects. The very circumstance that the eternal life conferred upon fallen man is strictly an eternal salvation, creates a wonderful difference. Past experience of misery gives a double zest to happiness. The redeemed of the human race, having tasted the wormwood and the gall, their “soul hath them still in remembrance;” and the constant recollection of former guilt and wo cannot fail to make them, through eternity, drink, with a lively additional relish, of “the pure river of the water of life.” The brighter the demonstrations, too, we receive of the love of God, and the stronger the motives we have to love him in return, and to repose an unsuspecting confidence in him, our felicity must be proportionally the greater; and redemption certainly exhibits at once more glorious demonstrations of the love of God to us, and more powerful motives to love him and trust in him, than any that were presented to Adam before the fall; or that could have been expected, although he had preserved his integrity, and been confirmed in bliss. By Christ’s assuming our nature, in fine, a foundation was laid for a more intimate union and fellowship with the Supreme Being, than we could have otherwise obtained. The Son of God is become our Brother, “bone of our bone, and flesh of our flesh;” and through him we have also access to the Father under new and most endearing relations. “Go to my brethren,” said Jesus to Mary, “and say to them, I ascend unto my Father and your Father, and to my God and your God.” On this topic, the profound Edwards has some excellent remarks in his Sermons on the Wisdom of God in Redemption; and it is judiciously illustrated by the Rev. John Robson in a Discourse from Rom. v. 15.120

Note XXXVI. Page 142.

The expressions of our pious Author, as well as those of Ignatius, whom he quotes with approbation, relative to persons who deny the true divinity of the Son and Spirit, may to some readers appear harsh and uncandid. To others, however, they will seem capable of a fair vindication, from the awful rebuke of the Apostle Paul to Elymas, Acts xiii. 10.—from the solemn declarations of the Apostle John in his first Epistle, ii. 22, 23, and second Epistle 9–11.—and from various other passages of Scripture. The late Dr Witherspoon discovers a similar zeal, when he says; “As to Socinians and Pelagians, - - - I never did esteem them to be Christians at all.”121 Not merely those whom some would stigmatise as “vulgar Theologians,” but Divines who did not embrace the most evangelical sentiments, and who have been amply eulogised for superior gentleness of temper and moderation of conduct, have often, when employed in defending doctrines which they deemed fundamental, adopted a tone of equal severity in reference to those audacious inquirers, by whom they are denied. Bishop Wilkins, for example, a man of excellent temper as well as distinguished erudition, employs the following expressions with regard to those who deny the existence of God:—“And it were well if they might not only be reckoned among beasts (as they are by the Psalmist where he styles them brutish) but driven out among them likewise, and banished from all human society, as being public pests and mischiefs to mankind, such as would debase the nobility of our nature to the condition of brute creatures, and therefore are fit only to live among them.”122 If the benevolent and philosophical Bishop, from the impulse of a laudable zeal for the doctrine of the being of a God, expressed himself in such severe terms respecting its opposers, is it strange that Ignatius and Witsius, impelled by a similar zeal for the proper Divinity of the Son and Spirit of God, allowed themselves to represent the determined enemies of that important doctrine as blasphemers, and devils, or false accusers?

It is indeed with emotions of unfeigned sorrow that the Christian sees men rejecting essential articles of revealed religion; and “the wisdom which cometh from above” will teach him to guard against expressions calculated rather to irritate than to convince or reclaim them. It is much to be wished, that the friends of the Christian doctrines, while “contending earnestly for the faith once delivered unto the saints,” were, in every instance, found, at the same time, “in meekness instructing those that oppose themselves, if God peradventure will give them repentance to the acknowledging of the truth.” Indifference to truths of the first importance, however, it is to be regretted, not unfrequently assumes the sacred name of charity, and the fair semblance of meekness; and the decided enemies of the Christian Revelation are sometimes spoken of in such soothing and complacent terms as most unhappily tend to confirm their fatal security in the path of error, and to encourage others to adopt the same pernicious course. How unguarded, for instance, is the following sentence, which occurs in an extensive literary work of distinguished celebrity: “The sound Theist, who worships the same God, and cherishes the same hopes as the Christian, is a character whom no man ought rashly to condemn.” No man, it is right to admit, ought to be accused or even suspected of infidelity without sufficient ground; and candour requires us to make a distinction betwixt those unbelievers whose outward morals are correct and who do not outrage society by a preposterous spirit of proselytism, and “the avowed infidel, who insults the public feeling by his views, or shakes the public faith by his outrageous zeal.” But to represent the Theist who rejects revelation, whether secretly or avowedly, as “worshipping the same God and cherishing the same hopes with the Christian,” is obviously inconsistent with that reverence for the doctrine and authority of Sacred Writ which every “sound” Christian is bound to entertain. Every true Christian is fully aware, that the conceptions of God which the mere Theist entertains, if not totally different, at least come far short of those views of the Divine nature and character which the Scriptures supply; and that the vague, baseless, and self-righteous hopes of immortal felicity which are cherished by the votaries of Theism are quite dissimilar from the expectations of the followers of Jesus, and inexpressibly inferior in value, sweetness, purifying influence, and consoling energy, to that “good hope through grace,” which anticipates the blissful presence and everlasting enjoyment of a Three-one God—rests on the sure basis of an infallible testimony—and springs from an humble dependance on that Divine Saviour, who “was dead, and is alive for evermore, and has the keys of hades and of death.”

Note XXXVII. Page 144.

Our Author has no less clearly than concisely shown, that the sublime doctrine of the Trinity is not a point of barren speculation, but of vital importance to the comfort and sanctification of the Christian. Its enemies, indeed, have often boldly affirmed that, although it were true, it could be of no practical utility. But independently of other considerations, are there not certain devout regards and religious services due to the Son and Spirit as Divine Persons, if they are in reality Divine? Our duty consists in conducting ourselves in a manner corresponding to those relations in which we stand to every one, and to the claims which every one has upon us, whether arising from his own dignity and excellence, or from the benefits he has conferred. Supposing, therefore, a man were to acquit himself faithfully of all other obligations, and at the same time habitually and pertinaciously, in spite of inspired instructions and warnings on the subject, to withhold that confidence, reverence, gratitude, and love, and those various acts of religious homage which are due to the Son and Spirit, would not this criminal neglect entitle him to the character, and subject him to the doom, of a wilful transgressor? This is a consideration which merits the particular attention of those who profess indifference to doctrines but zeal for the commandments, and found all their hopes of salvation upon the careful performance of their duty.

The importance of the Trinity in a practical light has been amply illustrated by many writers, whose “praise is in the churches.” Fuller’s masterly performance on the comparative moral tendency of the Calvinistic and Socinian systems is well known. Dr Jamieson’s “Vindication of the Doctrine of Scripture and of the primitive Faith concerning the Deity of Christ,”123 contains an able refutation of Dr Priestley’s objections to the Trinity as a useless mystery. Suffice it to add, that Dr Owen’s treatise on “Communion with God, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost,” has long been blessed as a guide to the exercise and a helper of the joy of those, whose supreme concern it is, that they may be able to say with the beloved disciple, “Truly our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ.”

1 John xiv. 10.

2 Matth. xii. 28.

3 Heb. x. 5. Luke i. 35.

4 Extra Deum.

5 Matth. xi. 25.

6 Heb. i. 10.

7 Gen. i. 2.

8 Matth. i. 21.

9 2 Cor. v. 19.

10 Col. i. 20.

11 1 Cor. vi. 11.

12 1 Tim. iv. 10.

13 2 Thess. ii. 13.

14 Ezek. xx. 12.

15 Vid. Forbes. Instruct. Histor. Theol. lib. i. cap. 10.

16 See Note XXX.

17 Gal. iv. 6.

18 John xvi. 14.

19 In Thesibus.

20 In Locis Communibus, loc. iii. cap. 2.

21 Unus et unicus.

22 1 Cor. viii. 6. 1 Tim. ii. 5.

23 Μορφη.

24 Φυσις.

25 Ὀυσία.

26 Damascen. Isag. cap. 1.

27 Confut. Græcar. Quæst. p. 304.

28 Mat. xi. 27.

29 Exercit. i. ad Apparatum Annalium, Num. xviii. p. 53. See, in particular, Amyrault’s Dissert. de Myster. Trinit. p. 112, 117, et seq.

30 Strom. lib. ii. p. 103. See John Gerhard’s Loc. Comm. p. 329, and Lipsius’s Manuductio ad Philos. Stoic. lib. ii. diss. 19. This subject has been discussed professedly and at the greatest length by Christianus Schotanus, in his Triumphus Biblicus, lib. iii. cap. 7.

31 Gen. i. 26. iii. 22. xi. 7. Isaiah vi. 8.

32 Gen. xix. 24. Ps. xlv. 6. comp. Heb. i. 8. Ps. cx. 1. comp. Mat. xxii. 43, 44. Dan. ix. 17. Hos. i. 7. Prov. xxx. 4.

33 Ps. xxxiii. 6. Isaiah lxi. 1. comp. verse 8, from which it appears that Jehovah is the speaker in that passage. Isaiah lxiii. 9, 10. Hag. ii. 5, 6, 7. Mat. iii. 16.

34 See Note XXXI.

35 John xvii. 3.

36 John xiv. 9, 10.

37 Quæst. 29. in Josuam.

38 Ἀθεοι ἐν κοσμω. Ephes. ii. 12.

39 Acts xvii. 23.

40 1 Thes. iv. 5.

41 Rom. i. 21.

42 See Note XXXII.

43 Col. ii. 3.

44 Is. liv. 5.

45 1 Sam. ii. 30.

46 John v. 22, 23.

47 Acts ii. 38. viii. 16. xix. 5.

48 Lib. i. De Sp. S. cap. 3.

49 De Spir. Sanct. Vide Vossium de Baptismo, p. 51.

50 Mark xvi. 16.

51 Lib. ii. De Sacramentis, cap. 7.

52 See Note XXXIII.

53 Instruct. Histor. Theol. lib. i. cap. 17.

54 Orat. xxxii.

55 Dissert. de Mysterio Trinitatis, p. 121, and at greater length p. 158, et seq.

56 De Creatione Hominis, lib. i. cap. i. sect. 12.

57 In Panario, p. 8.

58 Heb. i. 2.

59 בעליך עשיך Is. liv. 5.

60 ישמח ישראל בעשיו Ps. cxlix. 2.

61 זכר את בוראיך Eccles. xii. 1.

62 איה אלוה עשי Job xxxv. 9.

63 2 Cor. iv. 6.

64 Ἀρχη της κτίσεως θεοῦ. Rev. iii. 14.

65 Col. i. 16, 18.

66 See Note XXXIV.

67 The Latin word salus cannot, perhaps, be well rendered here by any other English term than salvation. Let it be observed, however, that though salvation is commonly understood as necessarily including deliverance from evil, salus signifies, in general, health, life, safety. T.

68 See Note XXXV.

69 John i. 4.

70 1 John ii. 23.

71 1 Cor. xii. 3.

72 Θεομαχοι.

73 2 John, verse 10.

74 Lætus in Compendio Hist. Univers. cap. xxxv. p. mihi 508.

75 De necessitate et utilitate Dogmatis de SS. Trinitate.

76 אתה הוא

77 Is. xlv. 24, 25.

78 Ἀυτοπίστος.

79 Tit. i. 1.

80 Apol. fol. 53.

81 Ψιλὸς ἄνθρωπος.

82 See Note XXXVI.

83 Epist. ad Antioch.

84 Jer. ix. 24.

85 Orat. xxix.

86 John xvii. 21, 22, 23.

87 Ἁυτοαλήθεια.

88 Φιλαδελφία.

89 See Note XXXVII.

90 Ephes. v. 1.

91 Phil. ii. 2.

92 Ephes. iv. 3.

93 Ephes. iv. 30.

94 Isa. lxiii. 10.

95 1 Thes. v. 19.

96 1 Cor. iii. 16. vi. 19.

97 Matt. xii. 32.

98 Υμνῶ σε μονὰς, Υμνῶ σε τριὰς. Μονας εἶ τριας ὤν. Τριὰς εἶ μονας ὤν.

99 Meritum, and sometimes merita Christi.

100 Aspasio Vindicated, pp. 47–49.

101 Cardiphonia, Vol. ii. p. 10. et seq. See a similar passage on the same subject in Letter 2d to the Rev. Mr S—— Vol. i. pp. 138, 139.

102 Discourses on the Socinian Controversy, Disc. i.

103 System of Theology, Ser. lxxi.

104 According to these writers, all that is genuine in verses 7th and 8th is thus expressed in English,—“For there are three that bear record, the Spirit, and the water, and the blood; and these three agree in one.”

105 This faithful translation of Griesbach’s words is copied from a Review of Dr Jack’s useful “Lectures in vindication of some of the most important doctrines of the Christian Religion,” which appeared in the Christian Repository, Vol. ii. pp. 159, 160, where the original Latin is also quoted from the Preface to Griesbach’s 2d vol. of the Greek Testament, which he published in 1775. It is to be regretted, that in the Preface dated 1806, prefixed to the 2d vol. of the work, as printed at London 1818, this interesting declaration respecting the divinity of Christ is omitted.

106 Milner’s History of the Church of Christ, vol. iii. p. 467. 3d edit.

107 Macknight’s Literal Translation of the Apostolic Epistles, with a Commentary and Notes, in loc.

108 Principles and Duties of Natural Religion, Book i. ch. 3. sect. 3.

109 Vol. 12th, pp. 28, 176, 323, 386, et seq.

110 The Duty and Doctrine of Baptism, in thirteen Sermons, p. 4.

111 Chap. xxviii. sect. 3.

112 Book iv. ch. 16. sect. 13, 14.

113 Disput. i. De Baptism. Th. 9.

114 Lexic. Antiq. Eccles. p. 66.

115 Distinct. iii. Quæst. un. Art. 7.

116 Sect. 15.

117 His expression is,—“In qua non minus se manifestavit Trinitatis œconomia.”

118 Book i. ch. 2. sect. 5–8.

119 Book i. ch. iv. 6, 7.

120 Discourses by Ministers of the (late) General Associate Synod, vol. ii. p. 180 et seq.

121 Essay on Justification, page 75, note.

122 Principles and Duties of Natural Religion, Book ii. ch. i. p. 292.

123 Vol. i. pp. 551–567.