Sacred Dissertations on What Is Commonly Called the Apostles’ Creed (1823), Herman Witsius · PDF

Dissertation XV. On Christ’s Suffering under Pontius Pilate

I. Nothing can be imagined more elegant, instructive, and impressive, than the emblems made use of in sacred writ; and that which occurs in Zech. iii. 9. has always appeared to me particularly beautiful. Our Saviour is there represented as a Stone laid by the hand of God before Joshua the High-priest, to which one Stone seven eyes are directed, and the engravings of which the Lord of hosts engraved, whilst by means of it he purposed to remove the iniquity of the earth in one day. The Stone signifies Christ, who is “the rock of our salvation,”1 and “the corner-stone, in whom the whole building of the church fitly framed together, groweth unto an holy temple in the Lord.”2 He is called “one Stone;” “for other foundation can no man lay.”3 God hath laid the Stone, namely, “God, who so loved the world that he gave his only-begotten Son.”4 He laid it, too, before Joshua, that he and the rest of the priests, and all the teachers of the mysteries of Divine revelation, might attend to it, might point it out to the people as the foundation of the whole system of revealed truth,—and on it might build themselves, and the people committed to their charge. This was accordingly done with great diligence, in particular, by the Apostles Peter and Paul.5 Upon this Stone are seven eyes;—to wit, the eyes of God, who beholds it with complacency, and protects it with care;6 and also the eyes of the church, which regards it with cordial and entire confidence, agreeably to the following invitation; “Look unto me, and be ye saved, all the ends of the earth.”7 But that this Stone might be distinguished from all other stones, it was necessary that it should be divinely engraved with “the engravings thereof,”—its own peculiar engravings. By this we understand “the name of God” impressed upon him as with a seal,8—that is, the splendour of the Divine Majesty shining forth in him and his works;9 and also those dreadful sufferings by which it became God to make perfect the Captain of our salvation.10 It was by means of those sufferings that the iniquity of the whole earth was taken away, and the world reconciled to God in one day, namely, the day on which his sacrifice was completed, and, so to speak, the last farthing of his satisfaction paid.11 Let us then take an accurate survey of this Stone with the engravings thereof, to wit, Christ and his sufferings. We shall speak, first, of the sufferings themselves, and then of the chief Judge in Judea, under whom the principal part of them befell him.

II. In discoursing aright on the Sufferings of Christ,—an expression, including amongst others, those which are afterwards expressly mentioned in the Creed,—five points fall to be explained. 1st, Who suffered. 2dly, What—3dly, When—4thly, For what end—5thly, For whom—he suffered.

III. Who suffered?—Christ the Mediator, God-man, made satisfaction by suffering, in his whole person; each nature contributing its own share. In strict propriety of speech, Christ suffered only in the human nature; since the adorable Divinity is equally incapable of the least increase or diminution of its glorious blessedness, and finds most amply in itself alone, and in the possession, knowledge, and enjoyment of its own perfections, all the treasures of that felicity which is worthy of the Supreme Being. “If thou sinnest, what dost thou against him? or if thy transgressions be multiplied, what dost thou unto him? If thou be righteous, what givest thou him, or what receiveth he of thine hand?”12 But that it is far from being true, that the Divinity contributed nothing at all towards this object, will appear from what is immediately to be said.

IV. As the whole man, both in soul and body, owed obedience to God; and as the whole man, soul and body, sinned and thus became obnoxious to eternal punishment; so it was necessary that Christ should suffer at once in soul and body, that he might glorify God in both parts of human nature, expiate human guilt, and sustain the punishment due to sin. The whole history of the Gospel speaks at great length, of the sufferings of his body; of those of his soul, he himself complained in the garden, saying; “My soul is exceeding sorrowful, even unto death.”13 That his sorrow was extremely vehement was sufficiently manifest, when “his sweat was, as it were, great drops of blood, falling down to the ground.”14 These expressions must not be so jejunely explained, as if the body were properly the subject of his suffering, and the soul suffered only by sympathy; for hitherto the body did not suffer, and the sufferings of the body constituted by far the least part of that punishment which it behoved the Surety of mankind to undergo.

V. The Divinity itself indeed suffered nothing; but it afforded strength to the suffering humanity, that it might be able to sustain the pressure of divine vengeance when afflicting it with the whole weight of its anger—not sinking under the load, but nobly overcoming it, and happily lifting up its glorious head. So great is the vehemence of the divine indignation when poured forth against sin in all its fierceness, that unless support is administered by more than human or any created strength, man must inevitably sink under it, and be everlastingly crushed by its power.15 Hence it follows that none but “the mighty God,” strong and valiant,16 was able to grapple at once with the infernal hosts, and with God himself avenging iniquity.

VI. But the Divinity of Christ was of importance in another respect. It was owing to the Divinity, that the person suffering was God-man, “in whom dwelleth all the fulness of the godhead bodily;”17—not mystically, as in believers—not symbolically, as in the sacraments—not typically and figuratively, as in the temple and the ark—but “bodily,” that is, really or personally; as the body is either opposed to the shadow, or designates a person. To the Divinity, in consequence, it was owing, that the suffering of one so great, namely, a Divine and infinite Person, could not fail to be regarded as possessing infinite worth; so that the sufferings of Christ, though of short duration, were equivalent to the eternal sufferings of the damned; and the sufferings of a single person sufficed for the redemption of the many myriads of the elect. Hence the Scripture so often recalls our attention to the Divine dignity of Him who suffered, that we may recognise the boundless value of the satisfaction of Christ. It affirms, that “God hath purchased the church with his own blood”18—that “the Lord of glory was crucified”19—that “Christ through the eternal Spirit offered up himself unto God”2021—that “the blood of Jesus Christ, the Son of God, cleanseth us from all sin.”22

VII. To impart this infinite worth to his sufferings, it was not necessary that the Divine nature itself, or that Christ as God should suffer. It was sufficient that he who is God, should suffer. All the actions and sufferings are the actions and sufferings of the person, and receive their value and denomination from the dignity of the person, as from the principium quod, although with respect to their condition, they are to be attributed to the nature from which they take their rise, as the principium quo.23

VIII. In vain, too, doth Socinus argue, that the dignity of the person contributes nothing towards the infinitude of the punishment, because “there is no respect of persons with God;”24 and that if this holds even when there is room for the exercise of his mercy, much more, when the infliction of punishment according to justice, or rather according to the dictates of the strictest severity, is in question. In reply to this cavil, we observe, 1st, That “the respect of persons” which God disclaims, is quite a different matter from the consideration of the worth of the person, in estimating his sufferings. The Greek term προσωπον does not signify a man himself, whom we call a person; but the outward condition or quality of a person or thing, which is unconnected with the cause, and has no concern in its merits. But here the dignity of the person suffering is not an outward quality unconnected with the matter, but more than any thing else contributes essentially to the weight and merits of the cause; for the worth of the person who takes something on himself, is a consideration of great moment. In short, it is one thing to accept the face,25—which is contrary to justice, and is with great propriety represented as impossible with God; and it is a widely different thing to respect the person26 properly so called,—which is just, and is rightly attributed to God. 2dly, The condition of a Surety must be distinguished from that of a sinner. Personal dignity might perhaps be of no avail to the guilty individual himself, when suffering the punishment of his own sins; because he possessed when sinning the same dignity which he possesses when suffering; and if it might be pleaded as a reason for diminution when viewed simply in relation to the punishment, it is, however, to be considered as an aggravation when viewed in relation to the offence. But personal dignity is available in a Surety, who makes satisfaction, not for his own transgressions, but for the transgressions of others.

IX. But what hath Christ suffered? In one word, he has suffered the wrath of God, which was kindled against the sins of the whole human race; for “the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men”.27 That wrath signifies a most holy detestation of sin, together with the just punishment of it; and accordingly “wrath and the revelation of the righteous judgment of God,” are joined together by the Apostle.28

X. God, who is holy, cannot but hate sin, and the sinner. “Thou art not a God that hath pleasure in wickedness—thou hatest all workers of iniquity.”29 Now the natural consequence of this hatred is punishment; for the hatred is most just, and is essential to him who has the right and the power to punish. Hence the Psalmist deduces the following conclusions: “Evil shall not dwell with thee; the foolish shall not stand in thy sight; thou shalt destroy them that speak leasing.”30

XI. There is in sin a wanton indignity and disparagement to the Divine majesty and glory; for whoever sins, acts as if there were no God whom he is bound to revere,31 or as if he were a God to himself, and the supreme governor of his own actions.32 And what is this but wantonly to insult the majesty and glory of God? But the glory of God is justly dear to himself; and he can no more suffer an indignity done to it to pass wholly unpunished, than he can become “altogether such a one as the sinner;” for so himself hath taught us to reason.33

XII. To this concern for his own glory, violated by the sinner, God has given a very significant appellation, namely, jealousy;34 which alludes to an honourable husband, who is greatly enraged at the least approaches to the violation of conjugal fidelity. “Jealousy is the rage of a man.”35 Now the necessary consequence of that jealousy, by which God secures the vindication of his own glory, than which nothing is dearer to him, is the punishment of sin. Hence the following expressions—“a jealous God, visiting iniquity”;36 “He is a holy God, he is a jealous God; he will not forgive your transgressions, nor your sins.”37

XIII. Nay, further, even when he “forgives iniquity, transgression, and sin, he will by no means clear the guilty.”38 But in that eminent act of his mercy, he demands also some demonstration of his justice. It is deserving of notice, that this sentiment is repeatedly inculcated in those passages, where the great clemency of God towards sinners is celebrated either by himself, or by his servants.39 Thus believers are apprized, that they must not expect, or even desire, the pardon of their sins, without some manifestation of the Divine severity against them. Now God gives a twofold display of his severity. 1st, By chastising sin in believers themselves, at the same time that he forgives them.40 Of this we read in Jeremiah,41 “I will correct thee in measure; yet will I not leave thee wholly unpunished.” 2dly, He displays it chiefly by punishing in the Surety, the sin which he forgives to believers; for he neither forgives, nor can forgive, but in a manner consistent with righteousness.

XIV. “It therefore became him, for whom are all things, and by whom are all things, in bringing many sons unto glory, to make the Captain of their salvation perfect through sufferings.”42 It was required by the το πρεπον, that is, by what is proper and becoming on the part of the Deity, that whilst he forgives sins, he should one day manifest his justice in demanding the blood of the Surety. The same truth is again clearly taught by the Apostle in the following passage: “Whom God hath set forth to be a propitiation through faith in his blood, to declare his righteousness—that he might be just, and the justifier of him that believeth in Jesus.”43 And truly never was God’s holy indignation against the sins of mankind more brightly demonstrated, than when it pleased him, whilst he forgives them to us, to punish them so severely in his beloved Son. Thus it appears that Christ sustained the wrath of God kindled against the sins of men.

XV. When did Christ suffer? He suffered from the beginning of his life, and principally towards the end of it. Sin rendered man obnoxious to misery through the whole course of his life, and made him worthy to experience, without intermission, the bitterness of his own transgression, and the galling scourge of the Supreme Judge; in conformity to the sentence pronounced upon man immediately after the commission of his crime: “Cursed is the ground for thy sake; in sorrow shalt thou eat of it all the days of thy life.”44 Christ, therefore, by becoming our Surety, voluntarily subjected himself to a whole life of abasement and sorrow, always bearing “the form of a servant,”45 and appearing “in the likeness of sinful flesh.”46 And since all those sufferings proceeded from the curse of God against sin, and were undergone by our Lord in virtue of his surety-undertaking for sin, it follows that they all jointly concurred, and were collected, so to speak, into one sum, to make up a perfect satisfaction.

XVI. Christ may be considered as undergoing his sufferings, at four periods. 1st, At the commencement of his life; where we find his emptying of himself by assuming the form of a servant, the meanness of his birth, and his circumcision on the eighth day;—in which we are to consider not only the pain with which that rite was attended, but also the obligation arising from it to fulfil the whole law, and the prelude it exhibited of Christ’s being at last cut off out of the land of the living for the salvation of his mystical body,—as in circumcision a small part of the skin was cut off for the preservation of the whole man. To these add, the persecution of Herod, the flight into Egypt, the murder of the infants of Bethlehem, and the consequent lamentation of so many sorrowful mothers. 2dly, In his private life; which he spent with his relations in obscurity, being regarded as a carpenter, and the son of a carpenter. 3dly, In his public life, from the thirtieth year of his age, during which he had to maintain a perpetual conflict with poverty, envy, malevolence, reproaches, calumnies, snares, persecutions, particularly those of the scribes and Pharisees, and rulers of the people. 4thly, At the end of his life, and on the last day of it, when tremendous sufferings of all sorts assailed him with incredible vehemence.

Here again we may distinctly consider, 1. What he suffered in the garden of Gethsemane, after eating the last passover, and also the supper, with his disciples, in which an affecting picture of his approaching sufferings was seen,—in the garden, I say, where he was afflicted with an extreme anguish and sorrow of spirit, sold and betrayed by Judas, apprehended by his enemies, and forsaken by his disciples. 2. What he suffered before the tribunal of the Jews, where he was falsely accused, unjustly condemned, cruelly derided, and, mean time, thrice denied by Peter, that highly favoured disciple. 3. What he suffered in the houses of Pilate and Herod, where, after new accusations were brought against him, Barabbas the robber was preferred before him by all the people—where he was torn with cruel scourges at the command of Pilate, obstinately demanded for the cross by his countrymen, and at last condemned by the judge, in defiance of the remonstrances of conscience. 4. In fine, what he suffered after his condemnation by Pilate till his death.

XVII. For what end did our Lord endure these sufferings? That he might reconcile elect sinners unto God, and restore them to the divine favour, in which life and happiness consist. Two things indeed may be considered in his sufferings;—the sorrow to which he submitted, when bearing the penalties due to our sins, in order to expiate their guilt;—and the noble ardour of love to his Father in heaven and to his brethren on earth, from which he exhibited a pattern of the most submissive obedience,47 in order to obtain for us the favour of the Father.

XVIII. This reconciliation, effected by the sufferings of Christ, is expressly and frequently mentioned in Scripture; as in the following passages. “When we were enemies, we were reconciled to God by the death of his Son.”48 “All things are of God, who hath reconciled us to himself by Jesus Christ.”49 “God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto himself, not imputing their trespasses unto them.”50 “It pleased the Father,—having made peace through the blood of his cross, by him to reconcile all things to himself.”51 The Scriptures contain many other testimonies to the same effect.

XIX. It must be remarked, however, that this reconciliation is attributed, but attributed in different respects, to God the Father, to Christ the Mediator, and sometimes to believers themselves. God the Father is said to reconcile us, as from eternity he decreed to restore to a state of favour some of mankind fallen by sin; and being himself reconcileable from his own philanthropy, and determining to be reconciled in a manner becoming his character, made all that preparation which was necessary for repairing the breach betwixt himself and sinners.52 Christ the Mediator reconciles us to the Father by his satisfaction and merit, which he exhibits to God, and upon beholding which all his anger is turned away; for he satisfied all the demands of the law, that God might be just in justifying the sinner. By his own blood, too, he purges the consciences of the elect from dead works, that they may not thenceforth fall into those offences, which would break the bond of reconciliation, but “serve the true and living God.”53 Believers, in fine, are said to reconcile themselves to God, as they embrace by an unfeigned faith the benefit appointed for them by God the Father, obtained for them by Christ the Mediator, and exhibited to them in the Gospel,—laying aside likewise all enmity on their part, and returning love to a God of love.54

XX. To obviate every doubt, that the sufferings of Christ are the meritorious cause of this reconciliation, the Scripture calls Christ “the propitiation,”55 and “the propitiation, the propitiatory, in his blood.”56 These expressions carry an allusion partly to the expiatory sacrifices of the Old Testament, where the ram which was offered in sacrifice is called “the ram of the atonement,”57 and the day on which an atonement used to be made for the sins of the people is denominated “the day of atonement:”58—and partly to the lid or covering of the ark, which the Hebrews call כפּורת and Paul ἱλαστηριον, “the mercy-seat.”59 The covering of the ark of the covenant was called the propitiatory, “the mercy-seat,” for several reasons. 1st, Because it covered the law, which was shut up in the ark, that it might not subject believers to condemnation for the crimes committed against itself and the covenant. 2dly, Because there, God was pleased to be pacified, and to become propitious to his people, through the sprinkling of the blood of victims, which was done towards this covering.60 3dly, Because, in consequence, he there exhibited himself to his people, propitious and reconciled, and sitting on the throne of grace, which was between the cherubim.

Now the Apostle, with great propriety, applies the name of the figure and shadow to the substance, and calls Christ “the mercy-seat;” for, 1st, It is he that covers our sins with his own perfect righteousness, that they may never come into God’s sight. He interposes himself as the medium between God and us; as the covering of the ark was a medium between the law laid up in it, and the majesty of God dwelling between the cherubim. 2dly, It is he that, by the sprinkling of his own blood, which Paul calls “the blood of sprinkling,”61 made full expiation to God for us.62 3dly, It is he, finally, in whom God hath erected a throne of grace, to which we are commanded to come, and in whom we receive gracious answers to our prayers.63

XXI. Further, for whom hath Christ made satisfaction by his sufferings? We do not deny that the sufferings of Christ, considered in themselves, and viewed in connexion with the character of the person that suffered, who, as we have frequently noticed already, is one of infinite dignity, are of so great value that they could suffice for the redemption even of the whole human race, and of many more myriads of mankind, on supposition their numbers were increased to that extent, if it had pleased God, and Christ, that he should become Surety for them all. Nor are we unwilling to admit, that Christ, as man, being subject to the law of charity, had a holy love to all mankind as his neighbours, heartily wished them well, and seriously lamented the ruin of those that perish; whilst yet, as God, he knew them to be reprobate, and, as Mediator, he had not undertaken for them:—the human affection, however, being in subjection to the divine appointment. We do not deny, besides, that, owing to the sufferings and satisfaction of Christ, many good things fall to the share of the reprobate. To the sufferings of Christ they stand indebted for the reformation of the world from its gross idolatry, and monstrous ferocity, by the preaching of the Gospel; also for many valuable though not saving gifts of the Holy Spirit; for their “escaping the pollutions of the world, through the knowledge of the Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ;” and for other similar advantages. They obtain those blessings, too, not accidentally, without the intention of God and Christ, but according to the determinate counsel of the Deity and the Saviour. At the same time we maintain, in conformity to holy writ, that, according to the will of God the Father and his own purpose, Christ did not become Surety or make satisfaction, and consequently did not suffer, for any but those whom the Father gave him, and who are actually saved. “I came down from heaven,” says Christ, “not to do mine own will, but the will of him that sent me.” And this is the Father’s will who hath sent me, that of all whom he hath given me I should lose nothing.64

XXII. This doctrine derives support from those passages of Scripture in which the sufferings of Christ are restricted to his “sheep,” to his “church,” to his “people,” and even “a peculiar people to himself.”65 All those passages tend to illustrate the distinguishing love of Christ towards his sheep for whom he laid down his life, towards the church which he purchased for himself with his own blood, and towards his people for whom he gave himself. But if the “sheep,” “the church,” “the people” of Christ have no peculiar interest and privilege in this matter, by which they are distinguished from all other men, is it possible to specify any probable reason why that unbounded love of Christ in laying down his life, shedding his blood, and giving himself, should be ascribed peculiarly to them? This subject, however, we have treated more largely elsewhere.66

XXIII. The compilers of the Creed have thought proper also to make mention of Pontius Pilate, as under his government our Lord completed his passion. They have done this, however, not to intimate that those sufferings only were meritorious which befell him after sentence was passed upon him by Pilate; for nothing can be more absurd, nothing more opposite to the whole tenour of the Christian doctrine than that notion. The name of the Roman Governor is mentioned, partly to facilitate the comparing of the epoch of Christ’s suffering with the Roman histories, as Luke mentions the enrolling for taxation which took place according to the command of Augustus at the epoch of Christ’s birth;—partly for other weighty reasons, which are to be explained immediately.

XXIV. It is proper to take notice of three things respecting Pilate. 1st, The temper and disposition of the man; of which Philo has given a lively description.67 He says, that “he was a man of an inflexible and severe disposition;” and a little after he charges him with “accepting bribes, with acts of injustice, rapacity, and violence, with oppressions, with frequent murders of persons uncondemned, and in fine, with the most insatiable and savage cruelty.” And truly it required a man of such a temper to resolve, in spite of the remonstrances of his own mind and conscience, to allow himself to act so barbarous a part towards the most innocent person, and the most perfect pattern of every virtue. But he also suffered the punishment due to his crimes; for he was first reprimanded, then deposed by Vitellius the Governor of Syria, and at last sent by him to Rome to plead his cause before Cæsar, and refute the charges preferred against him; and proving unable to do this, “he was condemned to perpetual exile at Vienne” in Gaul, “and there, by appointment of Caius, he was subjected to so severe restraints and distresses, that he laid violent hands on himself, thus seeking in death a speedy release from a train of protracted calamities.” These are the words of Ado, Bishop of the same city, in his Chronicle.68

XXV. 2dly, We must advert to the supreme power which he then possessed in Judea in the name of the Roman Emperor and people, and which Christ himself did not disdain to acknowledge as “given him from above.”69 It was proper that Christ should suffer under such a judge as had authority and power to take cognizance of the cause, and, after judicially examining its merits, to pronounce sentence. 1st, That the prophecy might be fulfilled: “He was taken from prison and from judgment.”70 2dly, That we might be fully certified of the innocence of Christ, which, although attacked by the basest arts, was, after a strict investigation of the cause and a regular discussion of the question, firmly recognised, and five times declared by the judge. Now the whole concern of our salvation turns upon this hinge; for what hopes could we entertain from Christ, unless it were manifest that he was condemned, not for his own, but for our crimes? 3dly, That being himself unjustly condemned by the chief judge in that land, he might deliver us from the righteous judgment of God, to which we were obnoxious. Pilate indeed acted unjustly in condemning, in compliance with the clamours of the people, a person whom himself had acquitted.71 But God, to whom the judgment belongeth,72 by the mouth of Pilate, rightly and lawfully condemned Christ, as loaded with our crimes, and bound to suffer in our stead, and thus by condemning our Surety, absolved us. “The chastisement of our peace was upon him, and with his stripes we are healed.”73

XXVI. 3dly, It must not be omitted that the power to which the Jews were then subject, was foreign and heathen. In his own name and that of the Roman people, Tiberius the Emperor of the Romans had intrusted Pilate with the government of Judea, and in the same name Vitellius the Governor of Syria dismissed him from his office; from which it appears that Judea was now a Roman province, and annexed to Syria. This circumstance is of no small moment to the whole cause of Christianity, as well as to the present subject. For, 1st, Hence it appears, that the appointed time of the Messiah’s advent had now expired; the sceptre having entirely departed from Judah, and the Prefect of Syria exercising authority over the Governor of Judea; which, as appears from sacred predictions,74 could not have happened previously to the coming of the Messiah. “The head of Syria is Damascus;” not the head of Judea, which will not depend upon Damascus or Syria, until a Virgin shall have conceived and brought forth a Son.75 The Jews themselves bore witness to their own degradation, when they said to Pilate, “It is not lawful for us to put any man to death;”76 and when they exclaimed, “We have no king but Cæsar.”77 Whether they had been deprived of the power of life and death by the Romans, as is generally thought, or had lost it through the negligence of the Sanhedrim itself, as Lightfoot contends at great length,78 it is not material to determine. 2dly, It was proper that the Redeemer of all, both Jews and Gentiles, whilst he suffered for all, should also suffer from all. “For of a truth, against thy holy child Jesus, whom thou hast anointed, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, with the Gentiles and the people of Israel, were gathered together.”79 3dly, It behoved him to suffer under a Gentile, that, according to the Roman custom, he might be nailed to the cross, which was a form of punishment unusual amongst the Jews. John himself makes the following observation: “The Jews therefore said unto him, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death, that the saying of Jesus might be fulfilled, which he spake, signifying what death he should die.”80 For had he been put to death according to the laws of the Jews, it is more probable that he would have been stoned than crucified.

XXVII. Let us now attend to the Improvement of this article. Whatever is necessary to our instruction, our humiliation, our consolation, and, in a word, our salvation,—is to be seen in a suffering Christ, provided we contemplate him in the exercise of faith. The sum of saving wisdom, as appears from our catechetical summaries, is comprised in these three heads,—the knowledge of our misery, of our deliverance, and of the gratitude we owe;—which Paul also joins together in Romans vii. 24, 25. But we can attain from no other source a more clear or a more affecting knowledge of any of these points, than from the sufferings of Christ.

XXVIII. Our misery appears both from the evil nature of sin, and from its dreadful demerit. Take a view of each, O sinner, in the sufferings of Christ. Consider the hatred, the envy, the reproaches, the deliberate artifice and insidious designs, the cruelty, and, in fine, the diabolical fury, prompting them even to dreadful imprecations upon themselves and their posterity, with which both Jews and Gentiles pertinaciously pursued the most innocent and venerable person, and virtue herself invested with a human form; which had for a considerable period confirmed her celestial origin, by her admirable doctrine and her stupendous works and wonders, performed in the presence and proclaimed by the tongues of the people themselves, and which had laid the whole Jewish nation under singular obligations to herself by curing so great a multitude of the lame, the blind, the lunatic, and persons possessed with demons, and by raising up such a number of the dead;—consider these things, I say, and it will be strange if, in this glass, you do not clearly perceive the extreme depravity of a world altogether lying in wickedness. The same perverseness is natural to our own minds. Left to ourselves, we should have acted a similar part. Were Christ to make another visit to our world, it is likely that he would not meet with a more favourable reception. As bulls are said to be enraged at the sight of purple, so the natural man is exasperated at the sight of the most beautiful and splendid virtue. The more brightly it reflects the rays of the divine image, the more doth our corruption exert its rage against it, perceiving in such virtue its own condemnation, and regarding all the favours which it confers as nothing but an upbraiding of its own ingratitude.

Learn also how abominable the stain of sin is, and how deeply it is fixed in our souls, since it could be washed away, only by the dreadful sufferings, and the blood, of the Son of God.

XXIX. But besides, contemplate here, O sinner, the punishment due to thy crimes, namely, the wrath of God; who makes use of all creatures, and employs at once friends and enemies, in the execution of his vengeance. The severity of God may indeed be learned, in some degree, from the dreadful threatenings, with which he has fenced the law. It may be known, also, by the judgments which he has executed on some abandoned individuals, or on whole cities and nations, or even upon a whole world of ungodly men. Doubtless, too, it would appear to us still more terrible, were we permitted to approach the iron gates of hell; and to see the torments, and hear the howlings, of damned spirits. But never, at any time, or in any place, did the severity of God discover itself by a more striking and awful proof, than when he avenged the sins of mankind on his well-beloved and only-begotten Son. Here, here truly, we behold both what our crimes have deserved, and how fearfully God will visit them upon all those, for whom Christ has not made satisfaction. For “if these things be done in a green tree, what shall be done in the dry?”81 Come near, O daring sinner, do you not see Jesus, after having suffered inconceivable agonies of soul, betrayed by one of his attendants, apprehended and loaded with chains by his enemies, deserted by his friends, accused of numerous crimes, condemned, delivered up to death by the peremptory sentence of a judge,—his body torn with lashes, his mind with reproaches and scoffs,—and in all these sufferings bearing the curse of God, than which nothing is more bitter and intolerable! Imagine yourself in this situation, and know that the time shall one day arrive, when your awakened conscience will lash you with merciless severity, and your associates in crime will not only abandon but also betray you; and yourself, bound with the cords of your iniquities, will be summoned, perhaps from the bed of sickness, to the tribunal of God, to be sharply accused by men whom you have injured, by the Devil, by your own conscience, by Moses the lawgiver,—to be justly condemned by God,—to be bound with chains of darkness,—to be exposed to the derision of men and devils,82—and thus to be reserved in a dark and doleful prison unto the judgment of the great day, till the Judge of the universe, sitting not in Gabbatha or the Pavement, but in the clouds of heaven, by a decisive sentence consign you to everlasting torments. Behold in the suffering Redeemer, a representation, and not merely a representation, but also the seal and confirmation of all these awful realities. Behold, and tremble.

XXX. But come thou, too, O believing soul, oppressed with the burden of thy sins, and behold, in a suffering Christ, thy deliverance infallibly secured. 1st, Admire that love, a greater than which cannot even be conceived. “Greater love,” as our Lord once observed, “hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends.”83 As this holds true amongst men, so our Lord himself has displayed a still greater love than that which he extolled as the greatest. For he “commendeth his love towards us, in that while we were yet sinners,” not friends, but altogether “enemies,” “he died for us.”84 2dly, Consider that Christ, by undergoing these sufferings, has cancelled thy debts; has not merely mitigated, but even taken away, the wrath of God against thee, nay, turned it into love; has stopped the mouth of all thine accusers; has secured thee from suffering those evils which himself hath suffered;—or if any of them befall thee, in order that thou mayest be conformed to his image, has entirely removed from them the curse of God, so that they are not the punishments of an angry Judge, but fatherly chastisements, exercises of faith and patience, trials of thy graces, and, in fine, sacred bitters, by which your soul may be healed, by which you may learn from experience how much you are indebted to Christ, and by tasting the bitterness of which beforehand, the consolations of the Spirit may prove the sweeter, and the joys of heaven the more delightful. As good faith does not permit the same debt to be demanded twice, Divine justice cannot allow that debt, which was paid by thy Surety, to be placed to thy account. 3dly, Consider also that these sufferings of Christ have opened for thee the fountain of the Divine favour and beneficence, from which alone proceeds whatever you receive in this, or a future life, that is good and desirable. If you have an habitation in which you dwell joyfully with a beloved partner and pleasant children; if you are clothed with decent apparel; if you are supplied with wholesome and delicious food; if when sick, neither the attention of domestics or friends, nor pleasant cordials furnished by our own country or by foreign lands, are wanting; if when fatigued in body, or perplexed in mind, you can recline upon a soft couch; and if you enjoy all these comforts not in the same way with the men of this world, but as the fruits of the love of God;—for this you are entirely indebted to a suffering Christ; who for your sake wandered as a poor man without a home, was suspended naked on the cross, received vinegar and gall to drink, and hung on the accursed tree, destitute of every comfort, and enduring the most excruciating pains, his hands and his feet being pierced with iron nails. If you are soothed with the consolations of the Holy Spirit, if you exult in afflictions, if you have free and abundant access to the throne of grace, if you have a tranquil conscience, if you venture to hope for heaven itself and life everlasting,—all this, too, is owing to no other cause than the sufferings of Christ; who for your sake was himself deprived, amidst his anguish, of the cheering manifestations of his Father’s love, complained of the sorrows of his soul, lamented that his prayers were not heard,85 and was girded and bound with the chains of death and hell. 4thly, Hence too you may form an estimate of the magnitude of that salvation and happiness, which the Son of God himself, to whom the value of every thing is well known, did not hesitate to purchase for his people with the inestimable price of his own sufferings.

XXXI. But what testimonies of Gratitude shall we render, in any measure corresponding to this unbounded love? 1st, Let all the hatred, indignation, and revenge of which our minds are capable, be turned wholly against sin, which was the sole cause of all the sorrows of Christ. Neither Judas, nor the scribes, or chief priests and rulers of the people, nor the Jewish populace, nor Herod or Pontius Pilate, could have done any thing against him; neither scourges, nor thorns, nor nails, would have been prepared to torment him; nor would the prince of darkness have attacked him with all his forces—unless he had taken upon himself our sins, which could not be expiated in any other way.86 Shall we not then deplore, with tears of the bitterest sorrow, the sins, which in time past (and Oh that I could say in time past!) we have committed?87 Shall we roll ourselves in that dirt and dung from which nothing but the blood of the Son of God was able to cleanse us? Shall we return to the service of former crimes, and to the vain conversation received by tradition from the fathers, from which we could not be redeemed but at so vast an expense? Shall we suffer the old man, the murderer of Christ, our Lord, Brother, and Husband, to live, to flourish, to maintain the ascendant in our souls? Far, very far, be an infatuation so base, from every generous breast. O our sins, O ye daughters of Babylon, devoted to destruction, happy may he be that rewardeth you, that taketh and dasheth your little ones against the rock of our salvation.88 2dly, Whatever, on the contrary, we know to be acceptable to our Lord, let us perform it with alacrity and diligence. Let us value him, who was sold by Judas for thirty pieces of silver, as infinitely more precious than all the treasures of the world. Let us closely and stedfastly follow him, who was forsaken by the disciples, whithersoever he may be pleased to lead us. With undaunted resolution, let us confess him, who was denied by Peter. Let us cheerfully accompany him, who was cast out of the city by the rulers, bearing his reproach; and let us receive him, with his word and Spirit, into the gates of our cities, into the doors of our houses, into the innermost recesses of our hearts, there to live and to reign for ever. When we find him still naked, or hungry, or thirsty in his poor members, let us supply him with clothing, meat and drink; instead of vinegar and gall, let us “cause him to drink of spiced wine, of the juice of the pomegranate.”89 In fine, let nothing in his worship and service seem too arduous, to be cheerfully done for his sake, who sustained far harder labours, and far more bitter sufferings, on our account.

Notes

Note VIII. Page 40.

The Author’s meaning in the last sentence of the 7th Section is so obvious, that the scholastic terms which he here employs, require little explanation. He represents the dignity of our Lord’s Divine person, as the principium quod, that is, the great principle which regulates the value of his labours and sufferings, and gives them their boundless worth; while his human nature is the principium quo, that is, the instrumental principle, by means of which they were accomplished.

Witsius justly teaches that Christ suffered both in soul and body—that his soul did not suffer merely from sympathy with his wounded and crucified flesh—that it smarted under the pressure of Divine vengeance, and that the sufferings of his soul were exceedingly severe, and such as none but the Mighty God could have endured. These too are the views of this interesting subject which are generally expressed in the writings of sound Theologians. Some of the readers of Dr Dwight’s Theology, however, have been sorry to find that that Author estimates the degree of our Lord’s sufferings at a very low rate. He holds, indeed, that “the peculiar agonies which preceded and attended the death of Christ, and in which the atonement made by him for sin peculiarly consisted, were chiefly distresses of mind, and not of body.” He even reasons strongly in favour of this doctrine, and confirms it by various cogent proofs. In illustrating the argument which he deduces from our Lord’s exclamation on the cross, “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me!” he has the following excellent passage. “The complacency of God, whose mind is infinite, and whose disposition is perfect, is undoubtedly the first of all possible enjoyments. The loss of it, therefore, and the consequent suffering of his hatred and contempt, are undoubtedly the greatest evils which a created mind can suffer; evils which will, in all probability, constitute the primary anguish experienced in the world of woe. Omniscience, and omnipotence, are certainly able to communicate, during even a short time, to a finite mind, such views of the hatred and contempt of God towards sin and sinners, and, of course, towards a Substitute for sinners, as would not only fill its capacity of suffering, but probably put an end to its existence. In this manner, I apprehend, the chief distresses of Christ were produced.”90

Yet in the same Sermon the Doctor makes the following assertion. “The degree of suffering which Christ underwent in making this atonement, was far inferior to that which will be experienced by an individual sufferer beyond the grave.” “It will not be supposed,” he adds, “as plainly it cannot, that Christ suffered in his Divine nature. Nor will it be believed, that any created nature could, in that short space of time, suffer what would be equivalent to even a slight distress, extended through eternity.”91

To imagine that Christ suffered in his Divine nature, would indeed be absurd. But why should it be deemed absurd or incredible that a “created nature,” personally united to the Divine, was capable of infinitely greater suffering than any other created nature? Is there sufficient ground to affirm, with the tone of perfect confidence, that it was impossible that “the man Christ Jesus,” supported by his omnipotent Divinity, could sustain, within a limited period, the whole wrath due to millions of sinners, or even the punishment due to a single sinner, through eternal ages? Is it quite certain, that “the Lion of the tribe of Judah,” was unable to bear “what would be equivalent to even a slight distress extended through eternity?” Can any one who holds the true Divinity of Christ allow himself to suppose, that the Son of God was incapable of enduring in the human nature a greater load of suffering than a mere man, whether supported by natural fortitude or superior aid? Some Divines may have expressed themselves in too peremptory terms with regard to the precise amount of the sufferings of Christ; and no doubt it ought to be remembered that “his atonement, great as his distresses were, did not derive its value principally from the degree in which he experienced them; but from the infinite greatness and excellency of his character.” Nevertheless, whilst Prophets, Apostles, and Evangelists employ the strongest expressions which language could supply to describe the bitterness of those sorrows to which the Messiah submitted as the Substitute of sinners, and whilst our Lord’s own expressions and behaviour in the day of his Father’s anger manifestly tend to convince us that there is no sorrow like his sorrow, and that his sufferings corresponded in their measure to the vast extent of the imputed guilt which he bore,—it sounds very strange in a Christian’s ear, to be told that “the degree of suffering which Christ underwent, was far inferior to that which will be experienced by an individual sufferer beyond the grave.” With all becoming deference to the learned and highly respectable writer, it may be affirmed that this assertion seems neither well-founded, nor fitted to serve any valuable purpose. High conceptions of the severity of our Lord’s sufferings and the depth of his abasement, as well as a firm persuasion of the dignity of his person and the excellence of his character, are calculated to impress the mind with a sense of the efficacy of his atonement, the unparalleled greatness of his love, and the horrid malignity of sin.—The judicious Dr Witherspoon, in his Sermon on Isaiah lxiii. 1. makes a few cursory but valuable remarks on the deep distress of our Lord’s soul in the garden and on the cross.92

Note IX. Page 48.

The Author, agreeably to Scripture, represents it as the design of the sufferings of Christ, to reconcile sinners unto God. This reconciliation too, he remarks, is ascribed, but in different respects, to the Father, to Christ, and to believers themselves. That it is attributed in a certain sense to believers, is evident from 2 Cor. v. 20. “We pray you in Christ’s stead, be ye reconciled to God.” These words, however, do not mean that we at all make satisfaction to the justice of God, or procure his favour by our obedience in any form; but that, by the faith which is of divine operation, we accept of pardon and peace, as obtained by him who, though he knew no sin, was made sin for us, and as freely exhibited to us in the Gospel. This acceptance of forgiveness through the cross of Christ, never fails to be accompanied with a renunciation on our part of that enmity against the divine character and government which we naturally cherish.

It has been alleged by the disciples of Socinus, that the reconciliation of men to God means nothing more than their repentance or conversion, and that it does not at all imply the removal of the divine anger from them. Nothing, however, is more contrary to Scripture than this assertion. Mutual reconciliation betwixt God and men is indeed effected by the death of Christ. But it is clear that when we read of our being reconciled to God by the sufferings and death of Christ, the principal thing intended is the turning away of God’s judicial wrath from us, and the procuring of our acceptance in his sight. Accordingly, we read in the 19th verse of the Chapter just referred to; “God was in Christ reconciling the world unto himself—not imputing their trespasses unto them.” On this question, too, the following passage in the Epistle to the Romans,93 is completely decisive; “Much more then, being now justified by his blood, we shall be saved from wrath through him. For if, when we were enemies, we were reconciled to God by the death of his Son;94 much more, being reconciled, we shall be saved by his life. And not only so, but we also joy in God through our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom we have now received the reconciliation.”95 In these verses, it is obvious, the Apostle continues his discussion with regard to the blessed effects of justification by faith in the blood of Christ. The 9th and 10th are connected by the particle for; and if the Apostle’s reasoning has any force, justification by the blood of Christ, must at least be included in reconciliation to God by the death of his Son. In reconciliation, we are admitted into a state of favour with the Most High, of whose displeasure we were formerly the objects; in justification, we receive a sentence of absolution from our Judge, who heretofore condemned us. By the one, we are delivered from that just indignation to which we were obnoxious; by the other, we are set free from the curse of the violated law. In both, the benefit conferred is essentially the same, but differently expressed according to the different views which may be taken of that misery from which we are relieved. This interpretation is incontestably confirmed by the expression at the close of the 11th verse; which when literally and most correctly translated runs thus,—“by whom we have now received the reconciliation.” That is, by faith in Christ, who has fully satisfied offended justice and brought in everlasting righteousness, we have now received the inestimable blessing of the restored favour and friendship of God.

The reader who wishes to see this point more fully discussed, may consult Wardlaw96 and Magee,97 and also the writers to whom the latter refers.

Note X. Page 52.

That the general character of Pontius Pilate corresponded with that instance of glaring injustice of which he was guilty in condemning Jesus to the cross, notwithstanding his firm conviction of his innocence, cannot admit of a doubt. Even the Evangelist Luke seems incidentally to intimate, that he was a man of no humanity or principle:98 For admitting that the Galileans, by their political sentiments or conduct, had incurred the displeasure of the Roman government, yet to “mingle their blood with their sacrifices”—to seize the opportunity of their attendance on the solemnities of religious worship, to apprehend and slay them in the most summary manner, was an act of savage barbarity. Josephus, too, as well as Philo, represents his character in the most odious light, and mentions two instances of impiety and gross imprudence, which took place at the commencement of his administration; namely, his causing some bucklers, on which images of Cæsar were stamped, to be brought into Jerusalem by night, and his laying out the sacred money of the temple upon expensive aqueducts;—both of which deeds were extremely offensive to the Jews, and occasioned great disorders.99

One design of the insertion of Pilate’s name in the Creed, without doubt, was to fix the date of our Lord’s sufferings, and thus to show the exact accomplishment of ancient predictions, relative to the time of the Messiah’s appearing and death. The compilers of the Creed, however, probably expected also that this circumstance would excite inquiry respecting our Saviour, and in particular respecting the testimony which the Roman Procurator bore to his innocence. Beside the solemn and repeated declarations which he made on this point to the Jews, when Jesus stood as a pannel at his bar, it is affirmed by ancient writers that Pilate gave ample testimony to our Lord’s innocence, both in an express written to Tiberius and presented by that Emperor to the Senate, and in records which, conformably to custom, he kept of important transactions which occurred during his government.

“Had the trial of Jesus ended,” says an Author formerly quoted, “where it began, before the Highpriest and council of the Jews, it would have been less interesting to the world, and less satisfactory in the issue. But he was tried by a Roman judge; and his innocence, nay his dignity, stands attested, by the person who through weakness condemned him.” “I am inclined to believe,” he adds in a note, “that the compilers of the Creed, commonly called the Apostles’ Creed, must have had this circumstance under their eye, as much as to fix the chronology of the death of Jesus. His suffering under Pontius Pilate would determine many to inquire into the particulars of the event, whom mere curiosity would not prompt, or who might have been restrained by their antipathies and indifference.”100

A considerably full account of Pilate may be seen in Pearson on the Creed.101

1 Deut. xxxii. 15.

2 Ephes. ii. 20, 21.

3 1 Cor. iii. 11.

4 John iii. 16.

5 1 Pet. ii. 4–6. 1 Cor. iii. 10.

6 Zech. iv. 10.

7 Is. xlv. 22.

8 Exod. xxiii. 21. Heb. i. 3.

9 John i. 14.

10 Heb. ii. 10.

11 Heb. x. 14.

12 Job xxxv. 6, 7.

13 Mat. xxvi. 38.

14 Luke xxii. 44.

15 Ps. xc. 11. Nah. i. 6.

16 אל גבור Is. ix. 6.

17 Col. ii. 9.

18 Acts xx. 28.

19 1 Cor. ii. 8.

20 Heb. ix. 14.

21 See Vol. I. Note XXXVIII.

22 1 John i. 7.

23 See Note VIII.

24 Rom. ii. 11.

25 Προσωπον.

26 Ὑποστασις.

27 Rom. i. 18.

28 Rom. ii. 5.

29 Ps. v. 4, 5.

30 Ibid. and ver. 6.

31 Ps. x. 4. xiv. 1.

32 Ps. xii. 4.

33 Ps. l. 21.

34 קנאה

35 Prov. vi. 34.

36 Exod. xx. 5.

37 Josh. xxiv. 19.

38 Exod. xxxiv. 7.

39 Num. xiv. 18. Jer. xxx. 11. xlvi. 28.

40 Ps. xcix. 8.

41 Ch. xlvi. 28.

42 Heb. ii. 10.

43 Rom. iii. 25, 26.

44 Gen. iii. 17.

45 Philip. ii. 7.

46 Rom. viii. 3.

47 John xiv. 31. xv. 13. Philip. ii. 8.

48 Rom. v. 10.

49 2 Cor. v. 18.

50 Verse 19.

51 Col. i. 19, 20.

52 2 Cor. v. 19. Col. i. 20.

53 Heb. ix. 14. 1 Pet. ii. 24.

54 See Note IX.

55 Ἱλασμος, 1 John ii. 2.

56 Ἱλαστήριον ἐν τῶ ἁίματι, Rom. iii. 25.

57 Κριος ἱλασμοῦ, Numb. v. 8.

58 Ἡμερα ἐξιλασμοῦ, Lev. xxiii. 27.

59 Heb. ix. 5.

60 Lev. xvi. 14.

61 Heb. xii. 24.

62 Heb. i. 3. ix. 12.

63 Heb. iv. 16.

64 John vi. 38, 39.

65 John x. 15. Ephes. v. 25. Acts xx. 28. Tit. ii. 14.

66 The Author here refers, without doubt, to his discussion on this point in his Treatise on the Covenants, Book ii. chap. 9. T.

67 In Legatione ad Caium.

68 See Note X.

69 John xix. 11.

70 Is. liii. 8.

71 Luke xxiii. 24.

72 Deut. i. 17.

73 Is. liii. 5.

74 Gen. xlix. 10. Is. vii. 8.

75 Is. vii. 8. comp. ver. 14.

76 John xviii. 31.

77 John xix. 15.

78 On John xviii. 31. and Mat. xxvi. 3.

79 Acts iv. 27.

80 John xviii. 31, 32.

81 Luke xxiii. 31.

82 Jer. xv. 17. Ps. lii. 7.

83 John xv. 13.

84 Rom. v. 8, 10.

85 Ps. xxii. 1, 2.

86 Is. liii. 5–7.

87 Zech. xii. 10.

88 Ps. cxxxvii. 8, 9.

89 Song viii. 2.

90 Sermon lvi. Head vi. obs. 5th.

91 Head v. obs. 2d.

92 Works, Vol. iii. Ser. 3.

93 Chap. v. 9, 10, 11.

94 Κατηλλαγημεν τῷ Θεῳ δια του θανατου του ὑιου ἀυτου.

95 Δι ’ου νῦν την καταλλαγην ἐλαβομεν.

96 Discourses on the Socinian Controversy, pp. 154–156.

97 Discourses and Dissertations, &c. Vol. i. Diss. 20.

98 Luke xiii. 1.

99 Wars of the Jews, Book ii. chap. 9.

100 Hunter’s Observations on the History of Christ, Vol. ii. chap. 12. sect. 4.

101 Art. iv. pp. 193–198.