Dissertation XXVI. On the Resurrection of the Body, and the Life Everlasting
I. In the sacred records I find three kinds of Resurrection mentioned; of which we may call one Civil, a second Spiritual, and the third, the Resurrection of the Body.
II. A deliverance from any dreadful calamity and peril, or a restoration from a miserable to a more prosperous state, may be styled a Civil Resurrection; for as a calamitous condition is called death, so a happy one is termed life. A resurrection of this sort may be experienced, either by individuals, or by an entire society or state. We have an instance of the former in David; “O Lord, thou hast brought up my soul from the grave; thou hast kept me alive, that I should not go down to the pit:”1—In Hezekiah; “So wilt thou recover me, and make me to live:”2—And in Paul; “God who raiseth the dead, who delivered us from so great a death, and doth deliver; in whom we trust that he will yet deliver us.”3 A free constitution, under a just and legitimate magistrate, whom the Israelites were accustomed to call “the breath of their nostrils,”4—is the life of a State. The loss of a free government, is death; its restoration, is a resurrection. To this may be referred the following expression in Hosea:—“He hath torn, and he will heal us; he hath smitten, and he will bind us up. After two days will he revive us, in the third day he will raise us up, and we shall live in his sight.”5 The thirty-seventh Chapter of Ezekiel, too, is particularly worthy of notice. We have there a long and elegant allegory, setting forth the deplorable condition of Israel during the Babylonish captivity under the emblem of “an open valley, covered with dry bones,” and their happy restoration under the similitude of a resurrection. That passage, however, is also to be viewed as affording a type and a pledge of the general resurrection.
III. The Spiritual Resurrection, is the raising of men from the death of sin to the life of God. This, again, is the resurrection, either of individuals, or of the Church at large. Of the former, we read in the following words: “Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead,” that is, the dead in sin, “shall hear the voice of the Son of God,” to wit, the preaching of the Gospel, accompanied with the quickening energy of the Spirit of Christ, “and they that hear,” that receive the Gospel with the obedience of faith, “shall live.”6 Such a resurrection is ascribed to the Church at large, when she is blessed with a remarkable increase of spiritual life, as well with regard to the number of her living members, as with respect to the gifts of Divine grace with which they are enriched,—knowledge, holiness, joy, peace, and the like. Hence Paul informs us, that the receiving of the Jews will be to the Church as “life from the dead.”7 And the nature of the life which the Church is then to enjoy, is explained by Isaiah.8
IV. The Resurrection of the Body, is the raising to life of the same body which death had dissolved, by reuniting the soul to it. To this the following things are necessary. 1. The conservation in the hand of God, of the particles into which the dead body was resolved. 2. The conservation of the soul also, to be re-united to the body in due time. 3. The re-formation of the same body from those very particles of which it formerly consisted, and the preparation of it to be a suitable habitation for the soul. 4. The renewed union of the soul with the body thus prepared. 5. The life of the whole compound being, resulting from that union.
V. This resurrection of the body is that great mystery of Christianity, without which the Gospel is vain, and our faith and hope are vain, and the consolation of those who have undergone the severest sufferings for Christ, is either small indeed, or no consolation at all.9 Justly does Tertullian begin his book on the Resurrection of the body with the following words: “The Resurrection of the dead, is the support of Christians.”10 An article of our faith, therefore, so sublime and momentous, must be examined with the greatest attention. In treating it, we may observe the following arrangement. We shall show, First, That there will be a resurrection of bodies. Secondly, That there will be a resurrection of the same bodies, with regard to substance. Thirdly, That the resurrection will be universal, extending both to the righteous and to the wicked. Fourthly, We may inquire, further, whether the resurrection of all and of every individual is to take place at one and the same time; or whether the resurrection of believers, or at least of martyrs, is to precede the resurrection of others a thousand years. Fifthly, We shall speak, in fine, of that Life Everlasting, which will be the consequence of the blessed resurrection of the godly.
VI. In the Scriptures of the Old and New Testament, the God of truth affirms, that the resurrection of the body will certainly take place; and Reason, when divinely instructed, confirms the doctrine. The passages relative to this topic in the Old Testament, in conformity to the nature of the ancient dispensation, are indeed less perspicuous; yet they are convincing, and particularly so to us, to whom they are placed in a clearer light, by the interpretations of Christ and his Apostles. Let us hear our Lord himself reasoning from Moses: “As touching the resurrection of the dead, have ye not read that which was spoken unto you by God, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob? God is not the God of the dead, but of the living.”11 The words quoted by our Lord, it is to be observed, were spoken by God after the patriarchs had been long dead.12 Hence it is inferred, in the first place, that even when dead, they were living to God, at least with regard to the soul.13
Further, that covenant of grace, by virtue of which he calls himself their God, concerns not merely their separate spirits, but their whole persons, which God required to carry about the sign of the covenant even in the body; and therefore the life promised in the covenant extends also to the body, which must consequently be re-united to the soul that is now living with God, in order to partake of the same felicity. This demonstration brought forward by the Lord Jesus, was so powerful, that the multitudes were astonished at his doctrine, and the mouth of the Sadducees was stopped. And whatever the more ancient Hebrews may have seen, or not have seen here, the modern Rabbies, at least, acknowledge the force of this argument. Aben Ezra says that this declaration, “I am the Lord your God,” includes a promise of life in both worlds.14 Manasseh Ben Israel reasons as if from the mouth of our Lord.15 The following expressions, too, which occur in Midras Kōhelet,16 are not unlike his words. “The ungodly while living, are called dead; and the righteous are spoken of as living even after death.” Accordingly it is said;—“Unto the land which I sware unto Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.”1718
VII. Let us next attend to the profession of Job, Chap. xix. 25, 26, 27. That some weighty topic is there treated, appears as well from the sacred magnificence of the expressions themselves, as from the preamble introducing them; in which he utters an earnest wish, that his words were not only written in a book, but engraven with an iron pen upon the rock, to preserve the remembrance of them for ever. Having elsewhere discussed this argument at greater length, I shall here bring the matter within a short compass. One of two things is necessary: Job either predicted the restoration of his former happiness in this life, or foretold the resurrection of his body after death. He did not do the former, for he despaired of the return of temporal prosperity in this life.19 It follows, therefore, that he did the latter.20
VIII. Add to this Isaiah xxvi. 19. This verse, it is certain, contains the consolation of the Church against the calamities mentioned in the foregoing verses. But no consolation could be more efficacious than that which is derived from the resurrection of the dead; and this interpretation is supported by the plain meaning of the words. It is not indeed very evident, whether these be the words of the Church, or the Prophet in the name of the Church, speaking to God; or the words of God addressed to the Church. If the former view be preferred, they may be thus paraphrased. “Thy dead men shall live.” With regard to those, who from faith in thee, O Lord, and concern for thy glory, have, after incredible tortures, willingly submitted to death, and who being previously dead to the world, were appointed by thee to become a spectacle to others,—we firmly believe, that they shall be raised up at last to a happy life. We expect the same privilege to be conferred also on each of ourselves, and therefore add, “My dead body, shall they arise,” and not sleep for ever in the dust. Animated by this hope, we call upon our brethren, in language which all of us wish in due time to hear from thy mouth; “Awake and sing, ye that dwell in dust,”—ye who are one day to shake off that dust, and to come forth in glory. “For thy dew is as the dew of herbs.” As by the resistless and gentle energy of thy power, thou, O our God, causest herbs that are cut down to sprout again, why shouldest not thou, by the operation of the same power, cause our bodies, though dissolved by death, and sown in corruption, to spring forth again from the grave? The clause immediately following may be rendered; “And thou wilt make the giants fall prostrate on the earth.”21 Thou wilt abolish all power, and every thing that with gigantic audacity opposeth itself to thee.22 Or the phrase may be translated thus; “The earth shall cast forth the dead, as an abortion,” which it can no longer retain in its bosom.
But if we are to consider God as here addressing the Church, the words may be thus interpreted: “Thy dead men, O my much-loved people, shall live.” But why do I call them thine? They are rather mine—“my dead body.” I am the God even of the dead; and what is done to my servants, I regard as done to myself. Some, however, may choose to go still higher, and to refer the expression to the dead body of Christ, whose resurrection is at once the pledge and the cause of our’s. According to this interpretation, it is as if the Lord Jesus should say: It is as certain, O my Church, that thy dead men shall be raised, as it is certain that I, clothed with a human nature, shall one day be delivered up to death for the expiation of thy sins, and shall rise from death for the glory of the Father. The words which follow need not be repeated. Only let it be observed, that the dew of the Church, may denote that quickening and refreshing grace, with which God is pleased to favour her.23
IX. The testimonies to the resurrection which occur in the New Testament, are so many that it is difficult to enumerate, so perspicuous that it is unnecessary to explain them. Those referred to at the foot of the page, may serve as a specimen.24 The fifteenth Chapter of the first Epistle to the Corinthians, demands particular attention, as containing at once the strongest of all arguments and the amplest discussion of the subject.
X. To the testimony of God on this subject, human Reason not unwillingly lends her suffrage, when, being subdued to the obedience of faith, she has carefully attended to the perfections of God, and the works he has already performed. Amongst the perfections of God, his power, wisdom, goodness, and justice, chiefly come to be considered. It appears from his unbounded Power that he is able, and from his other perfections that he is willing, to raise the dead. Our Lord, when disputing with the Pharisees on this subject, called their attention to the Divine omnipotence, saying; “Ye do err, not knowing - - - the power of God.”25 Paul, too, when attacking the prejudices entertained against this truth, first of all employs the same argument: “Why should it be thought a thing incredible with you, that God should raise the dead?”26 The Wisdom of God seems also to require the resurrection of the body. Since it is his will that all other things which exist, should either remain entire, or should completely perish, is it proper that the human body, when once dead, should never revive, and that the soul should continue for ever in a separate, and, so to speak, a widowed state? The Goodness and the Justice of God lead us to the same conclusion. For as vice and virtue belong to the whole man, and not merely to one part of our nature, so it is reasonable that the appointed retribution, whether punishment or reward, should be allotted to the whole man, and not to a part of him only. And so in making use of this argument too, we but follow the Apostle, who says: “We must all appear before the judgment-seat of Christ, that every one may receive the things done in his body, according to that he hath done, whether it be good or bad.”27
XI. The Jewish Talmud28 contains an elegant apologue intended to illustrate this subject, which it will not be improper to subjoin to what has been said. On a certain occasion, Antoninus, we are told, had a conversation with Rabbi Jehuda Sanctus to the following effect. The body and the soul, said the former, may demand exemption from judgment. How? The body may say, it is the soul that sinned; for ever since it departed from me, behold, I have lain senseless in the grave, like a stone. The soul may say, it is the body that sinned, for no sooner was my connexion with it dissolved, than I began to fly through the air like a bird. To this the Rabbi replied, saying, I will tell you a parable. A certain King, having a delightful garden, the fruits of which were come to muturity, appointed two watchmen to take care of it; of whom the one was lame, and the other blind. The lame one, allured by the sight of the fruits, persuaded his blind companion to take him up on his shoulders, that himself might pluck them, and that thus they might regale themselves together. The lame man, accordingly, having taken his seat upon the neck of the blind, they plucked and devoured the fruits. Some time after, the proprietor of the garden came, and made inquiry concerning the fruits. The blind man alleged that he had no eyes to see them; the lame that he had no feet to go near them. But what measures did the owner of the garden adopt? He commanded the former to be placed on the shoulders of the latter, and judged and punished both of them together. Similar to this will be the procedure of God towards man: he will re-unite the soul to the body, and judge soul and body together.
XII. But another argument, equally powerful, may be added. It is surely reasonable that the reward which believers receive through Christ, who is the Head and Surety of the covenant of grace, the promises of which are represented as incomparably excellent, should not be inferior to that which was held out to Adam in the covenant of works. According to the tenor of that covenant, Adam, had he persevered in his integrity, would have enjoyed a blessed and an everlasting life, in his whole person, soul and body. The same happiness, therefore, must be considered as awaiting those who are Christ’s; for since Christ hath given the most ample satisfaction to the whole law in their room, it follows that “they who receive the abundance of grace, and the gift of righteousness, shall reign in life,” in a manner no less glorious than Adam was to have reigned.29
XIII. Further, the certainty of our resurrection appears, with irresistible evidence, from the resurrection of Christ. With this argument Job consoled himself in the days of old.30 With this argument, too, our Lord comforted his Apostles,31 and the Apostles other believers.32 But what is the nature of the connexion between Christ’s resurrection and our’s? It may be viewed in various lights. 1st, Christ, when he rose from the dead, became “the first-fruits of them that slept.”33 As therefore the first-fruits were offered to God on the second day of the Jewish passover, in the hope, and even for the consecration, of the harvest which was speedily to follow; so Christ, when he came forth from the sepulchre, and was exalted to the immediate presence of God, as the first-fruits of them that sleep, consecrated all his people to God, to secure their resurrection to the same immortal life, at the season of harvest, that is, at “the end of the world.”34 2dly, As Adam’s sin is the cause of an eternal death, to which the whole man, soul and body, was obnoxious; so, according to the reasoning of Paul,35 the resurrection of Christ must be the cause of eternal life to the whole man. Christ was “justified,”36 too, in his resurrection, having therein received a discharge from the Father, testifying, that the most complete satisfaction had been rendered to his justice. Hence it follows, that our resurrection is inseparably connected with the resurrection of Christ. 3dly, Christ, by rising from the dead, showed that he had conquered and triumphed over all our enemies. When God ariseth, his enemies are scattered.37 The last of all our enemies is death. Death must, therefore, be destroyed at the last;38 that, as it was unable, by all its bands and pains to detain the head in the chambers of the grave, so it cannot detain those who are the members of his mystical body. 4thly, From the union which subsists betwixt Christ and believers it follows, that Christ would not account himself completely alive, unless his people lived with him. The Apostle also intimates this, when he says, that God hath “raised Christ from the dead, - - - and given him to be head over all things to the Church, which is his body, the fulness of him that filleth all in all.”39
XIV. An argument no less conclusive, is derived from the Spirit’s inhabiting and sanctifying believers. Here again the Apostle is our guide: “If the Spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in you, he that raised up Christ from the dead, shall also quicken your mortal bodies by his Spirit that dwelleth in you.”40 This reason may be urged in several forms. 1st, By the inhabitation of the Spirit, the bodies of believers are sanctified for a temple to God.41 And who can suppose that the Spirit, who is equally powerful and good, will suffer his temple to remain through eternity a heap of ruins? When the first temple at Jerusalem was destroyed, God caused another to be built more glorious than the former.42 Why may we not hope for the same privilege with regard to our mortal bodies,—that though destroyed by death, he will rebuild them in glory? 2dly, This argument will receive additional force, if we rightly consider the nature of that holiness, which the blessed Spirit imparts even to the bodies of believers. It is not a mere relative, but also a real, holiness; and it includes a beautiful resemblance to God. It need not appear very surprising, that the temple of Jerusalem should be so destroyed as to remain eternally buried in its ashes; for the holiness with which the presence of God adorned the walls of that edifice, reached no further, so to speak, than the surface, and consisted merely in its relation to sacred purposes. But the holiness which the Spirit of God infuses into our bodies, penetrates to the affections, pervades our faculties, and actuates all our members. It is a purity which accords with the nature of the Spirit himself, and in fine, is of such a kind that we appear to become, in a sense, one with him; for Peter calls it “the divine nature.”43 Without doubt, then, he can by no means allow such tabernacles of his Divine majesty to perish eternally. 3dly, The Spirit who inhabits and sanctifies believers, is the Spirit of him that raised up Christ from the dead. Hence we reason thus. The Spirit of God was the cause of the resurrection of Christ your head, both by the efficacy of his unbounded power, and the personal property, so to speak, by which he is the immediate cause of life to all living,—and by the energy of that holiness with which he beautified the human nature of Christ, and preserved it from personal sin, the sole cause of death.44 If you, then, are partakers of the same Spirit, who with all the fulness of his gifts is in Christ as in the fountain, he will in the same manner produce similar effects upon you, as well by his mighty power, as by virtue of that sanctification with which you are blessed. Sanctification is the resurrection of the soul, and must necessarily be followed by the resurrection of the body; for indeed even in the present life the body is a partaker of the blessing of sanctification, receives its sacred seals, and exhibits its excellent fruits.
XV. Having now, we think, sufficiently established the truth of the resurrection, let us proceed to consider what body is to rise again, and in what manner the resurrection will be effected. To us it appears indubitable from the Scriptures, that the same bodies which we now have are to rise again; to wit, the same in substance, but endowed with qualities widely different. Let us demonstrate each of these assertions.
XVI. That the same bodies are to be restored to us, is manifest from the very term resurrection. For, according to the definition of Damascenus, what else is the resurrection45 than “a second standing, an erection, of that which hath fallen.”46 It is not the soul, besides, which rises again; for the soul doth not fall or die: nor is it properly and directly the man: but it is that part of our nature which is called the flesh, that is, the body, which in the present state is animal and mortal. The body only, therefore, is called πτωμα, a carcase, or a dead body fallen to the ground, because it is only the body which πίπτει, falleth. Accordingly, as we have seen above, Paul says, “he shall also quicken your mortal bodies.”47
XVII. The Scriptures, too, supply other express testimonies to the same effect. “In my flesh,” said Job, “shall I see God, whom I shall see for myself, and mine eyes shall behold, and not another.”48 And Paul affirms, that the same body shall be raised, which is sown in corruption, in dishonour, and in weakness, and sown a natural body; and that “this corruptible,” which we now carry about, “must put on incorruption.”49 He tells us, in fine, that Christ “shall change our vile body,”50—the same body, to wit, which lay in the grave.51
XVIII. We have a specimen of this in them that were raised from the dead by the Prophets, our Lord, and the Apostles. Were bodies created out of nothing, or brought down from heaven, for those persons? Or were not the same bodies restored, which death had formerly removed? “Many bodies of the saints which slept arose.”52 And what are these but beginnings and specimens of that which God will one day accomplish upon us?
XIX. The same thing is evident from the resemblance which our resurrection bears to Christ’s. “As we have borne the image of the earthy, we shall also bear the image of the heavenly.”53 That Christ’s resurrection is the pattern of our’s, who can doubt?54 Most cercertainly, however, Christ did not assume a different and an ascititious or supplementary body, nor did he represent himself as clothed with a new body brought down from heaven; but he brought back from the sepulchre his own proper body, which he showed to his disciples, bearing the print of the wounds he had received,—and which was carried up into heaven.55
XX. Christ will judge alike the quick and the dead. But in what body will the quick appear before the tribunal of Christ? In the same body, doubtless, which till then they had carried about, but, as the Apostle informs us, changed by the power of God.56 Why then should not the dead also resume their own bodies, that the condition of all may be the same, since the Scripture nowhere intimates, that the condition of those who shall be then living is to excel that of believers who have slept in Jesus? To imagine with regard to those men who shall be found living in the day of the Lord, that new bodies will miraculously descend from the upper regions, and be superinduced like garments on their original and proper bodies, in order to swallow up their mortality, to consume the entire matter of them, and remain themselves in their room,—what is this but to entertain an idle and presumptuous, I dare not say a pleasant, dream?
XXI. In fine, the justice of God, and the manner of his judicial procedure, require, that as well the living as the dead appear before him in the very same bodies. The actions to be judged are attributed, not to the body apart, nor to the soul as separate from the body, but to the whole person, consisting of body and soul. It is necessary, therefore, that the same body, as well as the same soul, be brought into judgment, that sentence may be pronounced on the actions of the whole person. Were not this to be done, the consequence would be, that, in the distribution both of punishments and of rewards, a great confusion, unworthy of the divine administration, would take place. In respect to punishments;—bodies which were subservient to sinful passions, being finally reduced to dust, would not be punished according to their desert; since punishment doth not consist in mere annihilation, but in eternal torments in the lake of fire and brimstone. On the other hand, bodies which are quite adventitious, and which have merited no evil, would be joined to ungodly souls, and most unjustly and cruelly participate in their miseries and plagues. The same disorder would ensue in regard to rewards. Those bodies which have ministered to the soul in fastings, prayers, praises, and other exercises of godliness, whose members have been presented as instruments of righteousness, and which, in some instances, have endured incredible tortures for the sake of Christ and religion, would remain altogether unrewarded, being either annihilated or dissipated into their own elements, and, in short, placed in the same state with the bodies of the wicked. The crown of righteousness would be conferred, at the same time, on other bodies, which had never approved themselves to God, either by works of faith, or exercises of holiness, or by a cheerful submission to sufferings for Christ’s sake. These things are diametrically opposite to the justice of God, and to the uniform doctrine of Scripture. “Always bearing about in the body,” says the Apostle Paul, “the dying of the Lord Jesus, that the life also of Jesus might be made manifest in our mortal body.”57 And when he concludes a long discussion relative to the resurrection of the dead, by exhorting the Corinthians to stedfastness, and constancy, and abounding always in the work of the Lord, he enforces his exhortation by adding, that their “labour shall not be in vain in the Lord.”58 But their labour would be entirely in vain, so far as their bodies are concerned, if these remained in dust and putrefaction, and other bodies were formed in their stead, to enjoy a reward obtained by labour in which they had no share.59
XXII. A considerable difficulty, I will not dissemble, arises from the barbarity of those, who, by feeding on human bodies, have changed part of them into their own substance. How can the same flesh, after having belonged to different men, rise again in different individuals, to be punished in some, and to be rewarded in others? What will become of the flesh which has been thus devoured? Whose will it be at the resurrection? Will it belong to the man that has devoured it, to whom it pertained last? Were this the case, it would necessarily follow, that the person devoured would be mutilated as to that part of himself, and that this part would undergo the punishment due to cruel and barbarous men. Or, will it be restored to the person devoured, to whom it originally belonged? If so, the cannibal would be denuded of part of his body, which, although it deserved to be severely tormented, will perhaps be glorified in the body of the other.
XXIII. But in fact this objection discovers a preposterous curiosity, and an immoderate love of refinement; which, however, it is not impossible to repress by satisfactory arguments. Even although we could find nothing more particular to say in reply, is it fit that we should bring forward our reason, so feeble, so diseased, so enveloped in thick darkness, and so defiled by numerous corruptions, to weigh and measure the wisdom and power of God, his faithfulness in his promises, and his admirable providence and incredible facility in removing the greatest possible difficulties? Truly that man cherishes most unworthy thoughts of God, who determines to believe him in nothing but what he is able to investigate and comprehend in its entire nature and mode, by the force of his own understanding. We make this remark, however, not because we have no other answer to return to the objection; but because, when human reason replies against God, it is useful again and again to inculcate, that nothing is more just and proper than that, in its inquiries into divine mysteries, it should lay aside all murmuring, and allow itself to be subdued to the obedience of faith.
XXIV. To come nearer therefore to the point: we observe, in the first place, that it is not requisite to the identity of the body, that it should consist entirely of all those parts of which it formerly consisted. Although some part of its matter be wanting, it does not on that account cease to be the same body. Who ever heard of cannibals that devoured the entire body of a man? Supposing, however, that they have literally done so, how small a part of the body consumed goes into the substance of the consumer! What a great proportion is discharged by sweat and various humours, by the grosser evacuations, and even by insensible perspiration! On this subject, naturalists and physicians may be consulted with advantage. The unbounded wisdom and power of God, therefore, are able so to preserve and collect the parts which are not devoured, or which, though devoured, have not passed into the substance of him who devoured them, as from them to raise the body of the dead man. And although the thousandth part of it possibly may belong to the man-eater, this circumstance will not be sufficient to destroy its identity.
XXV. Do you urge, that in the recompence allotted at least to that particle, the goodness or justice of God is obscured? I reply, you who have just contended, that although God were to form other bodies entirely, to receive rewards or punishments instead of the body deceased, he should do nothing unworthy of his attributes,—do you now demand such perfect accuracy, that you must be solicitous about so very small a particle? What? Do you deem it better, or even more probable, that the body, that essential part of man, should be wholly deprived of its own glory, and that another body should possess its reward, than that something of it, and that but a very small proportion, should perish, whilst the whole remaining mass is raised to immortality?
XXVI. But I would not have you to perplex yourself even about this small particle. Do you regard it as difficult for the omnipotent God to recover and restore it to its first and rightful possessor, and to return to the other, that part of his flesh which, a short time before he obtained possession of this, was somehow worn away? “The flesh in question,” as Augustine nobly observes, “shall be restored to the man in whom it first became human flesh. For it is to be considered as borrowed by the other man, and, like borrowed money, to be returned to him from whom it was taken: whilst the flesh belonging to the man who had been emaciated by hunger, shall be restored to him by that God who is able to recall those particles which have been dissipated into vapour.”60
XXVII. And indeed what necessity is there for supposing that any particle of the consumed human body passes into the substance of the cannibal; or that, if it does, it remains joined to his substance so long as he lives? No instance was ever found, I imagine, of a person who subsisted on human flesh alone. Is not that divine Providence, which happily adapts every thing to the purposes which it has in view, able to provide,—nay, doth it not actually provide, that the flesh of a man, though eaten and in various ways digested, should be emitted, and thus never incorporated with the bodies of those monsters; or even if incorporated, should be dissolved into vapour, by perspiration, labour, want of food, or some other means, and thus recovered from the unjust possessor, and reserved, for its own resurrection body, in the hand of an omniscient and all-powerful God? When these things are duly weighed, the whole difficulty arising from the horrid practice of cannibals, and devourers of other people’s flesh, will appear, I apprehend, to be satisfactorily solved.
XXVIII. But though, with regard to substance, the same bodies which died, are to rise again, yet after the resurrection, they will be endowed with very different qualities. With respect to the wicked, (for we will show immediately that they too are to be raised,) their bodies shall be so constituted, that, standing in no need of food, sleep, or other supports pertaining to this animal life, they will be capable of bearing eternally the torments of hell. In this world, the bodies of men are so formed, that sleep arises from labour, and refreshment from sleep;—that extreme pain renders the sensation less acute, or sometimes induces a swoon, which affords a kind of respite; or if the pain be exceedingly vehement, it cannot be of long duration, as it terminates in death. But in the world to come, the bodies of the wicked will be so strengthened and hardened for sustaining the most intense torments, that without any intermission of pain, or suspension of feeling, they will burn through eternity in the flames of divine wrath, and yet never be reduced to ashes. Christ informs us accordingly, that God “is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.”61
XXIX. But the Scriptures give us a more ample description of the change which is to take place on the bodies of believers. “So also is the resurrection of the dead: It is sown in corruption.”62 The body, which falls into the earth and is one day to come forth anew, previously to its fall, is perishable, liable to a continual waste of the sensible parts, and evaporation of such as are insensible—insomuch that, as it is elegantly expressed by Heraclitus, you can no more see and touch the same man twice than you can descend twice into the same river; and after it is sown in the earth, it putrifies, and dissolves into dust. “It is raised in incorruption;” it comes forth again from the grave, incorruptible, unfading, subject to no infirmity or decay. “It is sown in dishonour;” for when alive, it had its vileness and loathsomeness; and when dead, it is frightful and disgusting even to the most intimate friends. “It is raised in glory,” which includes the highest degrees of loveliness, beauty, and majesty. “It is sown in weakness:” after death it has no power to retain a consistency of parts; it is not a fit habitation for the soul; it has no use of any of its members or organs. “It is raised in power,” so that without the least fatigue, it affords the most prompt and perfect service to the soul in the glorious exercises of the celestial life. “It is sown a natural, animal, body:” its constitution was accommodated to the present life; it required meat, drink, and sleep for its support; it had various carnal appetites; in a word, it had the seeds and principles of the vegetable life. “It is raised a spiritual body.” This expression doth not signify, as the Socinians absurdly allege, “subtile, flexible, sprightly, capable, like the air or the wind, or rather like the spirit of Chemists, of penetrating through the narrowest passages.” But it is called “a spiritual body,” because, whilst it will stand in no need of any thing necessary to human sustenance in the present state, as food, sleep, or air for respiration, it will have the Holy Spirit for the principle of its life, by whom it shall be animated for the employments of heaven, and for the services which it must there perform to the soul.
XXX. Thus light is thrown upon another apostolical expression,—“Meats for the belly, and the belly for meats, but God shall destroy both it and them. - - And God hath both raised up the Lord, and will also raise up us by his own power.”63 The various kinds of food are created and intended for man, and given to him in this world to satisfy the belly: the belly also is intended and calculated to receive food. But God shall destroy both meats and the belly. As it respects individuals, this takes place at death. As it regards all mankind, it will be accomplished at the last day: after which there will be no meats, nor yet a belly, that is, a belly fit for receiving meats. The mutual relation of meats and the belly will cease. The bodies of men when raised from the dead, will not indeed be without that part of their frame; but that part of their frame, will not be devoted to any such use. And why? For “God hath both raised up the Lord” to a heavenly life, and “he will also raise up us” to a similar life, that our body may be “for the Lord,” as his glorious and everlasting residence.
XXXI. For the glorious change undergone by the body, is owing to communion with Christ and his Spirit. “And so it is written; The first “man Adam,” the natural and federal head of the rest of mankind, “was made a living soul.” The noblest thing he had within him, was a soul, the principle of animal life. “The last Adam,” Christ, the root of those that are to be saved, “was made a quickening Spirit:” He was conceived and born in such a condition, that he was truly man, but at the same time a Spirit possessed of a quickening power, by which he could both raise up himself after suffering death for the salvation of mankind, and also raise up his people from the dead.—“The first man is of the earth;” he was formed of the earth, he was created on the earth, and he inhabited the earth: “Earthy”—made of dust, it was possible for him to return to dust. “The second man is the Lord from heaven:” he came from heaven with regard to the manifestation of his special presence in forming and inhabiting the human body which he assumed; and therefore he is Lord of his own life, who was indeed capable of dying once, but rose to die no more. “As is the earthy, such are they also that are earthy;” in consequence of the natural and federal connexion, which subsists between our first father and his posterity. Suppose that Adam with his posterity had not sinned, in that case indeed no man would have died; yet they would have had in themselves the principles of at least a remote mortality, the force of which the Providence of God alone would have restrained, by constantly affording new strength to the body, and by averting all those misfortunes, which might have proved fatal to human life. But after Adam sinned, all his posterity being involved in the guilt of the same offence, became equally obnoxious to the same inevitable death. “And as is the heavenly, such are they also that are heavenly.” Believers have a communion with Christ in his grace and Spirit, to which not only their souls but also their bodies are admitted; and by reason of this communion, as Christ having died once is now alive for evermore, so our bodies, when raised again from the dead, shall be endowed with such vigour, that they will be secure from death, not by the external care of Providence, but by an internal vigour. “And as we have borne the image of the earthy, we shall also bear the image of the heavenly.”64 For without doubt, the dignity of Christ our head requires, that his members derive from him a far more vigorous and glorious life than that which Adam could impart to his posterity.
XXXII. But the Apostle also suggests a reason, for which it is necessary that our bodies should undergo so great a change. “Now this I say, brethren, that flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God.”65 “Flesh and blood” do not here mean human nature as corrupted by sin, but the very substance of the body, with those infirmities of the animal life which now attend it. This is a Hebraism of frequent occurrence, not indeed in the Prophets, but in the writings of the Rabbies; who call “flesh and blood,” a mere natural man,—such human bodies as are now produced on earth. Nor is it probable, that Christ and the Apostles used expressions in a sense different from that in which they were commonly understood. This interpretation, too, derives support from the uniform language of holy writ; for, as Gomar, Cappel, and other learned men have judiciously observed, this phrase is nowhere used in a moral, but always in a physical sense.66 Besides the passages referred to at the foot of the page, I know no place where it occurs except the one before us. And whatever may be its meaning elsewhere, it is evidently susceptible of no other signification here, than that which we have mentioned. It is not the disorders of the mind, but the state of the body, that is here intended; and thus the Apostle himself explains the expression, adding; “Neither doth corruption inherit incorruption.” The sum of the whole matter is as follows. Our bodies in their present condition, animal, mortal, corruptible, are not adapted to that celestial life with which God has determined to bless his people: partly because such bodies are unable to bear so great a weight of bliss, and partly because the dissimilarity betwixt them in their terrestrial state, subject as they are to natural infirmities, and the celestial mansions, is so exceedingly great, that they could not possibly suit one another. That nothing may be wanting, therefore, to that felicity which God has destined for his people, he has determined that our bodies shall undergo a change, with regard to those qualities, to which the designation of “flesh and blood” refers.
XXXIII. In what respect, then, will there be a resurrection of the flesh?67 If you take the flesh as denoting merely the substance of the body, we have already shown that the same body which died shall rise again; and in this sense Job expressed his assurance, that “in his flesh he shall see God.”68 But if you consider the term as including the weaknesses of this animal life, there will be a resurrection of the flesh in a sense analogous to that in which there will be a resurrection of the dead. As we say that the dead are to be raised again, intending that they are now dead, not that they will be dead after the resurrection; so we affirm that they who were flesh previously to their death will rise again, not that they will be flesh after they shall have been recalled to life. The Apostle, in the same sense, denominates the time of Christ’s abode in this world “the days of his flesh,”69 in contradistinction to that celestial life which he now enjoys.70
XXXIV. But let us proceed to inquire, Who they are that shall be raised? Some Jewish Doctors contend that the righteous alone are to rise again, and that the wicked finally expire, and are buried in eternal darkness, never to revive. Socinus maintains, though covertly, the same opinion. Dreading the odium of the sentiment, and the offence which it would give, that subtle serpent so wraps himself up in his sophisms, that the reader is apt to find himself persuaded of the doctrine, ere ever he observe that he is urged to embrace it. His disciples have ventured to make an open profession of this heresy in the Short Summary of their Doctrine;71 as also in the Treatise concerning the state of the dead, taken from the Acts of the Racovian Conference.72 Volkelius, Schlichtingius, and others of that school, appear to have returned to more sober sentiments. But however the point may be doubted or denied by others, we hold it as one of the most certain and unquestionable truths, that there shall be a universal resurrection of all the dead, the wicked as well as the righteous, that every one may receive, both in soul and body, a reward according to his works. We shall not now industriously collect all that the Scriptures contain regarding this topic, but only attempt a vindication of the most remarkable testimonies.
XXXV. Let us first consider our Lord’s words in John v. 28, 29. “Marvel not at this: for the hour is coming, in the which all that are in the graves shall hear his voice, and shall come forth; they that have done good, unto the resurrection of life; and they that have done evil, unto the resurrection of damnation.” Here let the following things be observed.
1st, It is the resurrection of the body that is here treated. This is evident, 1. From the connexion; for after having ascribed to himself the raising of those who are spiritually dead to spiritual life,73 our Lord proceeds to speak of the raising of bodies, that by one divine and astonishing work he might confirm another. That he here enters on a different topic appears from the expression, “Marvel not at this.” As if he had said, I will give you notice of farther and still more illustrious displays of my power and majesty. I am not only able to raise the souls of men to a new and better life by the preaching of my Gospel, but I will also raise their bodies at last from the dust by my all-powerful word. 2. From the conjunction of the resurrection mentioned with the general judgment, which will immediately succeed the resurrection of the body.74 3. From the determination of the time. At the twenty-fifth verse he had said, “The hour is coming and now is;” because the spiritual resurrection there intended had its commencement at that time. But here he says merely, “The hour cometh,” that is, at the end of the world; he doth not add that it was then arrived. 4. From the description of the subjects of the resurrection, those “that are in the graves.” That this expression denotes those that are spiritually dead, is an assertion supported by no passage of Scripture.
2dly, By “the voice of the Son of man” is here meant, not the preaching of the Gospel, but that efficacious and all-powerful command of the Lord Jesus Christ of which we read in Mat. xxiv. 31. and 1 Thes. iv. 16. It is a voice that gives life to all who hear it, and causes them to come forth from their graves, but in very different circumstances. This however holds, neither in respect to that hearing of the Gospel which is merely the hearing of the bodily ears, nor as to that which is joined with the obedience of faith. For many of them whose ears hear the sound of the Gospel remain in a state of spiritual death, under the power of ignorance, error, and sin; and certainly none of those who receive the Gospel with an humble faith, shall experience the resurrection of condemnation.
3dly, The resurrection here described is universal. It is the resurrection of “all that are in the graves,” whether they have been Jews, or Barbarians, or Scythians; whatever their rank or age may have been; whether they have lived before or after the coming of Christ; and in short, whatever kind of death they may have died. There is none of these, which the universal term “all” doth not include. “And the sea gave up the dead which were in it; and death and hell delivered up the dead which were in them; and they were judged every man according to their works.”75
4thly, This universal resurrection is distinguished by its opposite results. As they who shall come forth from their graves consist of two classes, those that have done good, and those that have done evil; so the former shall come forth “unto the resurrection of life,” and the latter, “unto the resurrection of damnation.”
XXXVI. Adversaries would here confess themselves convinced, unless they had decidedly resolved to oppose the truth, however clear the light in which it might be presented to their minds. See what evasions they contrive. They affirm, that “the graves are ignorance, and the deplorable state of all men by nature; and that to come forth from the graves, is to have permission on the part of God to go forth.” They expound the doing of good and evil, as referring not to deeds which have preceded, but to deeds which follow the hearing of the voice of the Son of God, and coming forth from the graves. And their paraphrase on what our Lord says of them that have done evil is as follows. “They who have done evil, that is, after having come forth from the graves, after having been delivered on the part of God from a state of ignorance and misery by the announcing of the hope of immortality and eternal life—men of this description shall come forth to the resurrection of judgment; that is, even these shall be delivered as far as they can be delivered: but yet because they have not obeyed the Gospel, this deliverance will issue in their utter destruction.”
XXXVII. But truly this is not to interpret the Scriptures, but to pervert and expose them to ridicule. For, 1st, By what example do they prove, that the graves signify ignorance, and the deplorable state of the soul in this life? “To be in the grave,” signifies that the body is buried in the grave.76 Compare the words of Heman; “Free among the dead, like the slain that lie in the grave.”77 2dly, To “come forth,” is quite a different thing from having liberty on the part of God to go forth. The Son of God shall come “with a shout, with the voice of the Arch-angel, and with the trump of God.”78 This voice will not merely give permission to come forth; but on its being uttered, all the dead shall actually come forth. All shall hear it, and shall experience in themselves its power to recall them to life with an efficacy which cannot be resisted. All shall likewise come forth, whether they have been righteous or wicked. The same action is ascribed to both. What! Shall they who have done good receive only a permission on the part of God to come forth? Is nothing farther granted them? Are they not actually to come forth? Since Christ then uses the same expression with regard to both indiscriminately, who gave you authority, by so opposite an interpretation, to wrest it to a sense altogether different? 3dly, If the graves, according to your opinion, signify the deplorable condition of the soul, and if, as we have shown, to come forth from the graves must be understood not of permission granted on the part of God, but of the action of man coming forth at the command of God; how can it be conceived that deliverance from that deplorable condition is in order to a resurrection of condemnation? You say, “if after that deliverance he shall do evil.” But I reply; he who is once raised from spiritual death never sins again, so as to die eternally;79 and “he that heareth Christ’s word,” and hearing it arises from spiritual death, “hath everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation.”80 4thly, I appeal to every one that has even a moderate acquaintance with the Greek language, whether, if he any where read the expression ἐκπορευσονται ’οι ποίησαντες, they that have done shall come forth, he would not explain it so as to make ’η ποιησις, the doing, to precede ’η ἐκπορευσις, the coming forth. The phrase here is precisely of the same kind with that in a foregoing verse; “They that hear, shall live;”81 where the hearing intended, assuredly precedes the life. With regard to their assertion that the Aorist82 always refers to the tense of the verbs with which it is joined, nothing can be more opposite to all grammatical accuracy, and to the practice of those who speak correctly. The remarks of Beckman on this subject, deserve attention.83
XXXVIII. Let us attend, in the next place, to Dan. xii. 2. “And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake; some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt.” We dare not interpret this passage in any other way than as relating to the resurrection of the dead, for the following reasons. 1st, On account of the exact coincidence of these words with those of our Lord which we have just explained, with the exception of the single word “many,” instead of which Christ says “all.” Of this we are to speak presently. 2dly, On account of the connexion of this verse with what goes before it. In the first verse it is promised, that Michael, a great Prince, to wit, Christ, who is equal in dignity to the Father, the Lord of Angels, and the King of the Church, shall stand up for the children of Daniel’s people, that is, for the remnant of the Jewish nation.84 It is foretold, that after the cruel persecution of Antiochus, there shall again occur, “a time of trouble such as never was, since there was a nation even to that same time;”—a description which our Lord expressly applies to the time of the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans.85 Yet God is pleased to add, “And at that time thy people shall be delivered.” They shall not all perish; for the elect’s sake these days shall be shortened. There shall yet be a tenth in the land.86 A remnant shall be left for a seed; and a signal deliverance shall be wrought for “every one that shall be found written in the book”—for all those whom, in the covenant of grace, God hath, by an immutable decree, appointed heirs of eternal life. But that none may imagine that the grace of Michael extends merely to the living, it is immediately subjoined, that the dead are also to be raised by his power. 3dly, The words of the text all lead to the same interpretation. To “sleep in the dust of the earth,” is an expression descriptive of the dead; who are said to “sleep the sleep of death,”87—to “sleep a perpetual sleep and not wake,”88—and to “sleep in the dust.”89 Hence also sepulchres were usually termed cemeteries,90 that is, places for sleeping. And what can it be to “awake” from that sleep, but to be restored to life? In this sense surely it is used by Job, when he says; “So man lieth down and riseth not: till the heavens be no more, they shall not awake, nor be raised out of their sleep.”91 He affirms that none shall return from the dead, to perform the functions of animal life in this world.92 4thly, What follows serves also to confirm the same interpretation. For the third verse contains a description of the glorious state of them that are raised: “And they that be wise shall shine as the brightness of the firmament; and they that turn many to righteousness, as the stars for ever and ever.” This promise ought certainly to be compared with other passages of Scripture, where the glory of those that shall be raised from the dead is professedly treated, and illustrated by the same similitude.93
XXXIX. It should excite no scruple in our minds, that in this passage the Spirit of God has not employed the universal term all, but the word many, and even the expression, of them that sleep. To this objection it has been answered by a great number of writers after Augustine, that the word many is sometimes equivalent to all; and as an instance of this Rom. v. 19. is generally quoted. But not to urge this answer at present, I reply that “many of them that sleep” may signify that innumerable multitude of men which consists merely of the dead; and that this multitude is divided into two classes, so as to intimate that every individual must be referred to the one or the other. God here distributes the multitude of the dead in the same way in which Christ distributes το παν, the whole number—“all that are in the graves.”
XL. The twofold issue also of the resurrection, here pointed out, confirms this view of the passage. They “shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt.” This can with no propriety be understood of the restoration of the Jewish state and Church after the ravages of Antiochus. For while Antiochus was alive, the wicked and ungodly did not sleep in the dust, but lived and flourished, being treated with honour and esteem. And consequently, after the death of Antiochus, they were not raised from the dust, but were rather civilly and ecclesiastically dead; for some of them, as Grotius on this point well observes, were נדוי partially separated, and others חרם fully excommunicated. How could it be affirmed, besides, of those who, after having been long in exile for the sake of their religion, at last returned home, that they awoke “to everlasting life.” To understand this, with Porphyry and Grotius, of a long and happy life in the land of Canaan, is a meager interpretation, which falls far below the majesty of the words.
XLI. Our interpretation is supported by Josephus Jacchiades, who has the following paraphrase on the verse: “And then shall come to pass the miracle of the resurrection of the dead: for many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake; those who are holy, to everlasting life; but those who are wicked, to reproach and everlasting detestation. The design of the resurrection of the latter is, that they may openly confess that their faith is false, and that such as placed confidence in them followed after vanity, and became vain; and may acknowledge that their fathers inherited falsehood.” Manasseh Ben Israel94 proves in like manner that the wicked are to be raised again, because it is said in Daniel, “Many of them that sleep, &c.” “But if these many,” he observes, “were the righteous only, they would be few indeed, for not very many of this description are to be found. It immediately follows, however, some to shame and everlasting contempt, which certainly relates to the wicked and ungodly.”
XLII. But if there could be any dispute amongst Christians with regard to this topic, it is terminated by the following declaration of the Apostle Paul: “And have hope towards God—that there shall be a resurrection of the dead, both of the just and unjust.”95 Was it possible to use expressions on this subject more clear, or more decisive? Very possible, it has been said; for the words of the Apostle may, and even ought to be explained in a manner that will render them of no avail in this controversy. They may be so explained; for by “the just” we may understand those who in general lived righteously in the whole course of their life, and never sinned presumptuously or deliberately, as for example John the Baptist and his Parents; and by the “unjust,” those, on the contrary, who, after having led a wicked life, were at last converted; as the publican, and the thief on the cross. As instances of that figure of speech by which the Apostle calls himself and others of the same character unrighteous after they had become righteous, they refer to several passages of Scripture.96 Nay, say they, the words ought to be so explained. 1. Because the resurrection here spoken of is one of which the Apostle says he has the hope. And who does not see that it cannot be affirmed of any believer that he has the hope of the resurrection of the wicked? 2. Because the Apostle professes that he has the same hope with that of the ancient Hebrews. But that these did not believe the resurrection of the wicked, may be sufficiently gathered from that saying of the ancients which Rabbi Saadias Gaon, and Rabbi Moses Gerundensis,97 and others, have quoted: “The benefit of rain is common to good and bad; but the resurrection of the dead is the privilege of those only who have led a good life.”
XLIII. It will not be very difficult to expose these perversions of Scripture by the native evidence of truth. Nowhere in the Sacred Volume do we find that monstrous distribution which they make of true Christians into “the just and the unjust.” The Scripture, when it brings forward any such antithesis, never opposes believers to believers, but the wicked to believers. Hence the following expressions: “The evil and the good, the just and the unjust;”98—“the unjust and the saints;”99—“the godly and the unjust;”100—“the ungodly and the righteous.”101 In the proverb just quoted concerning rain and the resurrection, and every where in the Jewish writers, the same mode of speaking is observed. Where no such antithesis is intended, believers, we admit, are called unjust and ungodly, in reference to their former state. This is not, however, the denomination of one or another individual, by which he is distinguished from other believers; as of the publican, or of the thief on the cross. It is common to the whole body of believers, of whom at their first justification, “there is none righteous, no not one.”102
XLIV. The object of Paul’s hope was the general resurrection of all, in which he was certain he would obtain his own blessed share. All Christians in like manner hope for the coming of Christ to judgment, when both the righteous and the wicked will be recompensed according to their deeds. What should hinder Christians from even hoping for the resurrection of the ungodly? Although they take no pleasure in the misfortunes or calamities of any man, they cannot fail to applaud the manifestation of the divine glory in the just punishments of the wicked.103
XLV. The faith of the ancient Hebrews is to be learned from the prophetic writings, not from the jejune productions of the Talmudical Doctors. The most judicious of these, however, afford us their support. Here let us avail ourselves of the assistance of Manasseh, who is himself a Hebrew. “Something occurs,” says he, “in Ros a Sana, which gives confirmation to this opinion. The words are as follows: ‘Three kinds of men will appear in the day of judgment; one consisting of those who were perfectly righteous,104 that is, whose merits exceed their demerits; another, of those who were very wicked,105 whose demerits exceed their merits; and a third, of those who hold a middle place betwixt the two former,106 their merits and demerits being equal. If the day of judgment, then, be connected with the resurrection of the dead, and if these three kinds of men are to be judged on that day, it clearly follows that men of all sorts are to rise again.’ The following expression also is used by Rabbi Eliezer:107 ‘On the day of the resurrection all the dead shall rise again, except the generation of the flood.’” These writers, it is evident, erred in excluding some from the resurrection. But they agreed with the Apostle, so far at least as to hold that there shall be a resurrection of the wicked. As to the sentence respecting rain quoted above, Manasseh shows that the author intended to point out the difference betwixt rain and the resurrection—that whereas the former is beneficial alike to good and bad, and waters the fields as well of the profane as of the pious, the latter shall not be equally advantageous to the righteous, the wicked, and those of the intermediate class, but will prove a most intolerable misery to the wicked.
XLVI. There is no force in the objections drawn from those passages of Scripture, in which the resurrection is described as the privilege of the righteous, and of true believers.108 For since the Lord Jesus has taught us to distinguish betwixt the resurrection of life and the resurrection of condemnation, it is clear that only the former is intended in those passages where the consolation of believers arising from a blessed resurrection to eternal life is spoken of,—a consolation in which the wicked have neither part nor lot.
XLVII. We now proceed to inquire, in the Fourth place, whether the general resurrection of all men is to happen at one and the same time; or whether the resurrection of believers, either all of them, or at least some of the most distinguished, and in particular Confessors and Martyrs, is to take place a thousand years prior to the raising of the wicked. In elucidating this question, if we attend, as we certainly ought, to the whole tenor of Scripture, it is scarcely possible for us to doubt that all are to be raised at the same time. Christ designates one hour, in which all that are in the graves, as well the righteous as the wicked, shall hear his quickening voice.109
XLVIII. Nor has the Saviour promised to raise believers before the last day. “This is the Father’s will who hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day.”110 Here let the universal term all, and the repeated specification of the same time in this and several subsequent verses, be carefully noted. Paul in like manner connects the resurrection of those that are dead in Christ with the Lord’s descending from heaven with a shout, and with those that are alive and remain being caught up in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air.111 Elsewhere the same Apostle very emphatically says: “But every man in his own order; Christ the first-fruits; afterward they that are Christ’s, at his coming.”112 See here the order of the resurrection. “Christ” is the first in order of time and of efficacy; for none was ever raised before him to the possession of the celestial life, and none shall ever be thus raised but by his merits and power. “Afterwards they that are Christ’s.” But are they to be raised at different times? No. All are to be raised “at his coming.” “In a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trump; for the trumpet shall sound, and the dead shall be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed.”113 All these events are to take place at the same time.
XLIX. Neither Christians of singular eminence nor Martyrs shall be raised before the great body of believers. Paul was at once a most distinguished Apostle and Martyr. Yet in the same place where he speaks of his approaching martyrdom, he professes that he does not expect the crown of righteousness, before that day in which, he affirms, the Lord is to confer it, not upon himself only, but upon “all them also that love his appearing.”114 And what advantage, in fine, could the Martyrs gain by thus anticipating the general resurrection? How blessed soever you may suppose the condition of the Church on earth in those times to become, it will assuredly be far inferior to the glorious state of the inhabitants of heaven; and without doubt, the glory of Christ will never shine more brightly amongst mortals, than it now shines amongst the spirits of just men made perfect. Is it not therefore better, and much more desirable for deceased believers, even for Prophets, Patriarchs, Apostles, and Martyrs, to enjoy with entire satisfaction the pure bliss of heaven, and mean time to wait with assured hope for the resurrection of their bodies on that day, in which they shall see all things purged from every stain and remainder of iniquity, and fashioned in a manner nobly conducive to the glory of God—is not this far more desirable, than to be recalled from the joys of heaven, even to the happiest state on this earth—in order to dwell among those who, though saints, are not yet perfectly sanctified; and to inhabit a world, where they should see many things calculated to afford them the greatest pleasure, but some things too, I apprehend, which they would choose rather not to see.
L. These sentiments are clearly deducible from the constant and unvarying doctrine of the Scriptures, and from sound reason. They who think differently, however, have something to produce as the ground of their opinion. They found it in particular, on Rev. xx. 4–6, where John gives an account of a certain period of the Church in which “the Devil and Satan is to be bound a thousand years.” “And I saw thrones,” he adds, “and they sat upon them, and judgment was given unto them: and I saw the souls of them that were beheaded for the witness of Jesus, and for the word of God, and which had not worshipped the beast, neither his image, neither had received his mark upon their foreheads, or in their hands; and they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years. But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection. Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection;—they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign with him a thousand years.” From this prophecy it may be urged, 1. That there is here a promise, not of a spiritual resurrection from the death of sin to the life of grace, but of the resurrection of saints, confessors, and martyrs, who were beheaded for the testimony of Jesus. 2. That a resurrection is promised, the immediate result of which is not the glory of heaven, but a reign with Christ on earth. 3. That this resurrection will not fall to the share of all; for others are expressly excluded, who are not to live again till after the completion of the thousand years. 4. That in fine, such a resurrection is here promised as is first in order,—an expression which clearly refers to another that is to succeed.
LI. I will not deny that this passage is attended with very considerable difficulty. Let us try, however, whether the difficulty may admit of a solution. I begin by observing in general, that what is said of the time of the resurrection in the passages which we have just produced from the doctrinal discourses of Christ and writings of Apostles, is expressed in plain and proper language; but what is brought forward from the prophetical and mystical book of the Apocalypse, is enveloped in obscure and enigmatical terms. Now, whether is it more proper, and more consonant to reason, to wrest plain and explicit declarations from the native signification of the words, that they may agree with notions which we think we have collected from the intricate enigmas of the prophecies;—or, in investigating the sense of such mysterious parts of the sacred oracles, to proceed with cautious steps, and to beware of imagining that we discover any thing in them contrary to those doctrines of faith which are elsewhere clearly stated?
LII. But, if we rightly examine the several parts of the context now before us, we shall find that it contains no such sentiment as that which these men suppose they discover in it. John does not affirm that he saw “the souls of them that were beheaded,” much less that he saw the martyrs themselves that were beheaded, sitting upon thrones. He says only, that he saw thrones, and those who sat upon them, not determining who they were. Nay rather, he determines that this is not to be understood of souls; for such an interpretation doth not suit the gender of the words in the original language.115 I will not deny that the erection of the thrones here relates to the Church subsisting on earth, and that it is intended, that believers, at least without molestation or impediment from civil rulers, and even with their countenance and support, shall hold their assemblies, for preaching and hearing the word of God, for governing the Church by the power of the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and for condemning and triumphing over pernicious heresies. The persons who sit on these thrones, therefore, are not men long since departed, but saints alive at the period here described.
LIII. He does not say, too, that he saw that the men who were beheaded lived again, far less that the bodies of the beheaded lived again on the earth. He asserts merely, that he saw the souls of them that were beheaded, not living again, but living, that is, filled with unceasing joy, as Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob “live to God;”116—and reigning with Christ, to wit, in the kingdom of glory, where they reap the fruit of their labours and death, whilst they behold the enlargement of the Church during these thousand years. For, owing to the communion of all believers with Christ, and owing to the communion of the Church militant with the Church triumphant, every accession that is made to the kingdom of Christ either on earth or in heaven, proves an accession to the kingdom of the saints in heaven.117 Thus far we have no mention of the resurrection of bodies, or indeed of any resurrection at all.
LIV. But if we even grant, that ἐζησαν, lived, has here the same meaning with ἀνεζησαν, lived again, in which sense the word is thought to be used in Rev. ii. 8.; since this reviving, if you will have it so, is ascribed to the souls of them that were beheaded, it remains to be inquired, in what that reviving of souls consists. In my apprehension, the meaning is as follows. Those who, under the reign of Satan and the Beast, murdered the servants of Christ, at the same time calumniated them, in their sentences, decrees, and writings, as ungodly, cursed, hateful to God, enemies to Christ, slaves of the Devil, and men whose crimes a single hell was scarcely sufficient to expiate. Thus these pious men, while punished with death, were, as to their souls, more than dead in the estimation of the princes of the world, and of the credulous multitude who were imbued with the same errors. But afterwards, in happier times of the Church when the light of the Gospel shone forth more clearly, the same believers that were formerly loaded with so many reproaches, were publicly known and recognized as the friends of God and of Christ, who reign with him in glory. Then it was found, believed, and proclaimed, “that those whom human tribunals had condemned to death, are living with God in heaven.”118 The Scriptures furnish many examples of a thing being said to happen or to be, when it is discovered and acknowledged.119 Nor is it a contemptible accession to the glory of the saints, that the grace of God towards them is celebrated by the inhabitants of the earth.
LV. Besides the souls of those that were beheaded whom he had seen in heaven, John saw on the earth “those” (observe, it is not the souls of those, but the persons themselves) “who had not worshipped the beast, nor his image, &c.” that is, those who, adhering stedfastly to Christ, determined to have no fellowship with the kingdom of Antichrist. These also “lived,” enjoying a blessed peace of conscience, and a rich abundance of spiritual consolation;—“and reigned with Christ,” victorious over Satan and the world, and partaking of the Redeemer’s glorious grace. They thus lived and reigned with Christ, “a thousand years.” Not that their lives, as individuals, extended to a thousand years; for this never was, and never will be the lot of any mortal: but men of that description reigned during many successive ages, till the appointed period. And if you strongly urge their living again, this may be affirmed of these also; for they lived again, inasmuch as under the tyranny of the Beast, that description of men had been lately harassed, oppressed, reduced to a small number, and involved in such difficulties and privations that they scarcely lived or discovered any principle of vitality at all: but now, the face of affairs being changed, their numbers are increased, and breathing a freer air, they move all their members with ease and spirit. Nor ought it to seem harsh and unnatural, that one and the same word is employed to designate the life and reign of souls in heaven, and of others on earth. Those of each class, it is evident, live and reign only where they exist. As heaven is the habitation of those souls whom John saw in a state of separation from their bodies, they must live and reign with Christ in heaven. The earth being the abode of other believers, who are not naked spirits, these must live and reign on earth. In reference to both classes, the life and reign are limited to a thousand years in the sense already explained. And here again we find nothing relative to an anticipated resurrection of confessors and martyrs.
LVI. “But the rest of the dead lived not again.” “The rest” are those who received not the testimony of Jesus and worshipped the Beast, that is, those who persisted in their infidelity, or instead of sound doctrine embraced the errors of the Antichristian Church. These are certainly to rank amongst the dead, since nothing but death reigns in every kingdom which stands opposed to the kingdom of Christ. And these “lived not again:” they did not become partakers of spiritual life, nor had they any part in the felicity of that blessed state to which the true Church of Christ is advanced at that period. This again is to be understood not so much of particular persons, as of a certain kind of men; and it serves to show, that they who adhere to the Antichristian profession and heresies even when detected and exposed, are utterly excluded from a participation of that felicity which is promised to the Church.—“Until the thousand years were finished.” Throughout the whole period of time, during which Satan is bound, they still continued under the power of spiritual death. How much more, when Satan is again loosed?
LVII. “This is the first resurrection.” The resurrection from which the enemies of the kingdom of Christ are excluded, must correspond to their death; and since the one is spiritual, it necessary follows that the other also is spiritual. This appears too, from the addition of the word first. A twofold resurrection is promised to the Church, whose condition John narrates; the one in this world, the other in the world to come. The resurrection in this world is spiritual, and consists in the glorious enlargement of the Church by the successful preaching of the Gospel, and the renovating energy of the Holy Spirit. This is termed the first resurrection, in contradistinction to the other—the second, which is a resurrection of bodies, and relates to the world to come. The first, however, extends to several periods. It includes the first promulgation of the Gospel of the kingdom among Jews and Gentiles, accompanied by the conversion of multitudes; the public renunciation of heathenism in the Roman empire, under Constantine; and the Reformation of the Church by the exposure of the Antichristian system. To this prophecy of a thousand years must also be referred all the favourable changes which are yet to be expected, at whatever seasons the dates of their commencement or termination are to be fixed. It is not our present business, however, to discuss this subject.
LVIII. “Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection.” This expression stands opposed to the false glorying of the followers of the Beast, who, in consequence of the superstitious and idolatrous canonizations of the Pope, honour their partizans with the titles of Saints and Blessed.120 “On such the second death hath no power.” They are secured from apostacy, from impenitence, and from the lake of fire and brimstone. “But they shall be priests of God and of Christ.” They shall have free access by faith and hope to the holy places of the sanctuary, and offer sacrifices well-pleasing to God.
To explain more fully what remains of the passage, is foreign to our present purpose. Let it now suffice to have shown, what we undertook to demonstrate, that this prophecy contains nothing which obliges us to conclude, that a happy resurrection of bodies is to take place prior to the last day.121
LIX. The consequence of the Resurrection hoped for, is the Life Everlasting; which is often the subject of promise in holy writ.122 It is mentioned last in order in the Creed, because it is in reality “the end of our faith,”123 the ultimate object of our hope, the completion of our salvation, and the final issue and consummation of the whole scheme of redemption.
LX. The term Life doth not here signify the bare existence of the person living; for in that respect even the wicked live, whom, nevertheless, Divine justice has consigned to everlasting death. We are to understand by this expression, a state of the highest felicity. To live is not merely to exist, but to be happy.124 In this sense the word is often used in the Scriptures. Thus we read; “Let my lord king David live;”125 “Your heart shall live for ever;”126 “The humble shall see this, and be glad; and your heart shall live, that seek God.”127
LXI. This life is called Everlasting, in contradistinction to the present animal life. Even from the beginning, animal life was capable of being terminated by death, in the event of the entrance of sin; and after the commission of sin, its termination by death became indispensable. But the life which follows the resurrection, shall have no bound or termination, because all sin will be removed at the utmost distance; because the body itself will be endowed with such qualities as shall repel every kind of corruption; and, in fine, because it will be conferred on man, not as the former life for the probation of his constancy, but as a recompence for well-doing, and as a reward due to the satisfaction which Christ has made in our room. Hence the distinction which the Apostle states betwixt “the life that now is,” and “that which is to come.”128
LXII. The life everlasting, as it is here mentioned in the Creed, is the life of the whole man, and includes the highest felicity of soul and body inseparably united together. But the nature and extent of this life can neither be conceived by the human mind in the present imperfect state, nor expressed by mortal tongues. “It doth not yet appear what we shall be.”129 To this subject the following words of Paul are generally accommodated: “Eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither have entered into the heart of man, the things which God hath prepared for them that love him.”130 And the accommodation is very proper; for although these words of Paul, quoted from Isaiah, immediately respect the mysteries of the Gospel which were unknown to the ancient people of Israel, yet the situation of Christians in reference to the things now concealed from our view which shall be disclosed at the last day, exactly resembles the condition of the ancient Israelites in relation to those things which were then hid, and were at last to be unveiled in the fulness of time.
LXIII. It has pleased God, however, to favour us with a partial discovery, in order to serve, in a manner, for a taste. And at least a general and indistinct knowledge of what he has revealed, is necessary to give stability to our faith, and vigour to our hope, and to enable us to relish the sweetness of the promises. We may therefore attempt a rude and imperfect delineation, such as our present capacity admits, of the life everlasting. The Life Everlasting is a most blessed state of the whole man, in which he rejoices in the immediate presence, the contemplation, and the glorious enjoyment of God in heaven, and is thus conformed to him as far as possible, in both soul and body, without the least interruption or diminution of his happiness to all eternity.
LXIV. As in the creation of this visible world, the method which the wisdom of God adopted, was to begin with things more rude and imperfect, and to proceed gradually in a course of successive days till his work attained a perfection in which it was worthy of his attributes to rest; so in exalting his people to the summit of felicity, he causes them to ascend by certain regular steps. In the present life, he gives them the first-fruits of the promised bliss. He reserves greater things for the soul after its departure from this vile body, till, at the resurrection, it recover the body, wonderfully changed and improved. Then at last they shall be put in possession of the greatest and most consummate felicity.
LXV. It pleased God to cause a cluster of grapes to be brought from Canaan to the Israelites in the wilderness, that from this they might form a judgment regarding the fertility of the promised land. In like manner, whilst believers are prosecuting their journey through the howling deserts of this world to the heavenly country, he grants them some anticipation of those joys, to the full possession of which he will admit them in due season. The design of this indulgence is, partly that they may be comforted in the day of adversity; partly that by judging of the full harvest from the first-fruits, they may infer the excellence and greatness of the felicity reserved for them in heaven; but principally, that by the prelibation of that glorious reward which they expect, they may be animated to persevere with increasing alacrity in their course of faith and holiness.
LXVI. Even here, we know, God brings his chosen to himself, “causes them to approach unto him,”131 and allows them to see his glory,132 in holy meditation, in prayer, and other devotional exercises. He gives them a kind of taste and experience of his goodness.133 Even here he favours them with the kisses of his love, and brings them into his chambers, and into his banqueting-house, displaying over them his banner of love.134 Even here he allows them so to possess and enjoy him as their portion,135 that their soul most delightfully relies on him as their treasure, is enriched by his riches, nourished by his abundance, guarded by his power, directed by his wisdom, refreshed by his goodness, and, in fine, replenished by his all-sufficiency. Even here he indulges them with “the riches of the full assurance of understanding,”136 with the strongest assurance of possessing consummate felicity in due season,137 with peace of conscience and tranquillity of mind,138 and as the natural result of so many invaluable blessings, with “joy unspeakable and full of glory.”139
LXVII. But how exalted soever these enjoyments are, they are but inconsiderable, in comparison of those which await the souls of believers, after their release from their bodies. We ought ever to hold it as an indubitable truth, that the soul subsists after the termination of the natural life.140 The Apostle would otherwise have in vain desired “to depart and to be with Christ;”141 for no man that has altogether ceased to be, can be with Christ. He would have falsely affirmed, too, that we are come “to the spirits of just men made perfect,”142 if no such spirits exist. What is the purpose of the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, but to inform us of the existence of separate souls, and of their different conditions even before the day of general judgment?143 Since Christ was in all things made like unto his brethren, sin only excepted, is not our soul of the same nature with Christ’s soul?144 But did his soul at his departure vanish into air, so that after death he became absolutely nothing! What Christian breast does not tremble at so blasphemous a thought; especially when it is considered, that our Lord, when about to leave the body, commended his spirit, as an invaluable deposit, into the hands of his heavenly Father?145
LXVIII. Nor does the soul merely subsist after the dissolution of the body; it also lives, understands, and feels. It is affirmed by our Saviour that the Patriarchs, after they had been long in the state of the dead, were still “living to God,” that is, enjoying communion with him in glory.146 And Paul impressively says; “If Christ be in you, the body is dead because of sin; but the Spirit is life because of righteousness.”147 Remark, 1. That by the body and the spirit are here intended, as in several other passages of Scripture,148 the two constituent parts of man. 2. That by the death of the body is understood the dissolution of animal life,—the death from which the body is to be raised.149 3. That the spirit is represented not only as living, but as life; partly on account of the excellence and abundance of the spiritual life referred to; but principally because the spirit contains the source of that blessed life which is to be imparted in due season even to the body: for the future felicity of the body is incontestably inferred from the present felicity of the soul. 4. That this life is ascribed to the spirit, even whilst the body is dead. For the Apostle assigns two periods to it, the one before the resurrection, the other after it; the one mentioned in this verse, the other in the verse immediately following.
Further, was not Moses, whose death and burial are related in the book of Deuteronomy,150 seen with Christ at his transfiguration on the mount, conversing, and speaking of things to come?151 Whatever may have been the nature of the body that appeared, and from whatever quarter he derived it, is not this at least certain, that Moses, with regard to his soul, then survived, lived, and possessed the powers of understanding? And what gain, pray, could Paul have derived from the hastening of his death, if believers are not permitted to enjoy the glorious presence of Christ before the last day?
LXIX. What, too, is the meaning of that celestial eulogy: “Blessed are the dead which die in the Lord from henceforth; yea, saith the Spirit, that they may rest from their labours, and their works do follow them?”152 To whatever the expression from henceforth153 may refer, all the circumstances clearly show, that the state in which the dead remain previously to the end of the world, is here described. Grotius in reality trifles, when he applies this remarkable passage to the condition of the saints in the present life. “As among the Hebrews,” says he, “the word מות, death, signifies a great affliction, so מתים, νεκροι, the dead, signifies those that are grievously afflicted, those to whom life is not life, Col. iii. 3. ’Οι ἐν Κυριῳ ’αποθνησκοντες, they ‘that die in the Lord,’ are those who encounter the perils of death for Christ’s sake. ’Αποθνησκειν is thus understood in 1 Cor. xv. 31. These shall not only be blessed hereafter in another life, but even in the present life. They labour indeed; but amidst their labours they have rest, that is, peace of conscience. And their works follow them, that is, peace ariseth from the consciousness of “their good works.” To this we reply, 1st, Such interpretations tend to reduce all the expressions of sacred writ, however grand and magnificent, to a very poor and trivial sense: and, by this very culpable method of proceeding, both the meaning of Scripture, and the consolation of believers, are essentially injured. 2dly, To die in the Lord may denote two things, the one of which is common to all believers, and the other peculiar to martyrs. The first respects the state of the dying—that they are in the Lord, united to him by faith, and abiding constantly in him till death.154 See in particular 1 Thes. iv. 16. where by “the dead in Christ,” we are not to understand martyrs as opposed to other believers, but all that have died in the faith of Christ, in opposition to believers that are still living. The other interpretation refers to the cause of death, as if it were said, for Christ’s sake. In this sense the expression sometimes occurs.155 Now we do not deny that this passage was principally intended for the consolation of martyrs; but at the same time we consider it as containing truth which applies in general to all the godly. 3dly, That those who lead an afflicted life are called νεκροι, Grotius unhappily attempts to prove from Col. iii. 3. where neither the word, nor the thing, is to be found. The word there is ’απεθανετε, and the meaning is, ye have professed in your baptism that you have put off your former life. It is admitted that in 1 Cor. xv. 31. Καθ’ ἡμεραν ’αποθνησκω, I die daily, signifies a person subjected to great affliction. But how absurd is it, to restrict to those alone who are called confessors, that consolation which is expressed in terms which in their proper and natural signification denote martyrs? 4thly, By this mode of interpretation, the place, the time, and the state of labour and rest—of the contest and the triumph, are improperly confounded. The Scripture carefully distinguishes these things, assigning labour to this life, “labour and patience;”156 and rest to that which is to come.157 Nay, in this very context, the Spirit ascribes “patience” to the living,158 and “rest” to the dead. 5thly, When works are spoken of as following men, the expression denotes the reward of their works, and particularly the recompence they enjoy after having ceased to labour. And since it is chiefly in the future state that believers are rewarded, why should we confine their reward within the narrow limits of the present life?
LXX. There is another passage in the Apocalypse which ought not to be omitted. “I saw under the altar,” says John, “the souls of them that were slain for the word of God and for the testimony which they held; and they cried with a loud voice, saying, How long, O Lord, holy and true, dost thou not judge and avenge our blood on them that dwell on the earth? And white robes were given unto every one of them: and it was said unto them that they should rest yet for a little season.”159 The souls which survived death, and survived in a state of rest, are seen “under the altar,” to intimate that the martyrdom of those believers was a libation of blood, highly acceptable to God.160 The blood of the victims used to be sprinkled on the foot of the altar in the temple.161 Put there, as if in the immediate view of the holy place, it, in a manner, gave notice to God of the offering of the sacrifice. Much more did the souls of the martyrs exhibit a memorial of the sacrifice. To this remark it may be added, that to be under the altar amounts here to the same thing as to be under the special protection of Christ. He is our altar, who renders our prayers, and all our devotional exercises, and martyrdom itself, well-pleasing to God.162 Whoever is under this altar, enjoys the gracious presence and the powerful protection of Christ. David accordingly says; “He shall hide me in his pavilion; in the secret of his tabernacle shall he hide me.”163 The souls are also here represented as in the condition of suppliants, and therefore as prostrating themselves at the base of the altar. Their crying denotes their ardent desire, that God would display his justice, in the vindication of a truly good and righteous cause; for it is not unworthy of the inhabitants of heaven, to desire and solicit from God, those things which are righteous,164 and for which they render thanks to his name.165 The “white robes given to them,” signify celestial glory, and perhaps a pre-eminent degree of glory, corresponding to the sufferings which they endured for Christ, and serving to celebrate their triumph over their vanquished enemies. This distinguished glory was also a pledge, that their cause would at last prevail in the world, and that persecutors would be effectually restrained. From all this we deduce the following argument. They are possessed of life, intelligence, and feeling, who after death are under the blessed protection of Christ, and in the condition of suppliants;—who devoutly solicit the just punishment of enemies;—and who are invested with robes of glory and triumph. All these things, however, are affirmed regarding the souls of the deceased. The deceased are possessed, therefore, of life, intelligence, and feeling.166
LXXI. But we are further to believe, that the souls of the righteous, when released from the body, are admitted into celestial habitations and joys. The same heavenly Jerusalem, which contains myriads of Angels, and Jesus the Mediator of the new covenant, numbers among its inhabitants, “the spirits of just men made perfect.”167 The Apostle directs us to hope that when the earthly house of this tabernacle shall be dissolved, we shall inhabit “a building of God, an house not made with hands, eternal in the heavens.”168 And as the soul of Lazarus was carried by angels to Abraham’s bosom, that at the celestial banquet he might occupy the nearest place to that venerable patriarch;169 so Christ promised to the penitent malefactor, that on the very day of crucifixion he should be with him in paradise.170
LXXII. The blessedness which the souls of the righteous enjoy in heaven, so far as it can be learned from Scripture, consists in the following things. 1st, They enjoy the glorious presence of God and Christ.171 2dly, They see God clearly in the light of glory.172 They behold him as he discovers himself in those works of glory which are exhibited in heaven, and which, by their superior lustre, eclipse the works of nature in the world, and the works of grace in the militant Church. They see him also “in the face of Jesus Christ.”173 And in fine, they see him more immediately in himself, since man has intercourse with God, not, as now, “through a glass darkly, but face to face.”174 3dly, Thus knowing God perfectly, they love him most ardently, with a love not merely of desire, but of delight, arising from that full fruition for which they had formerly longed.175 4thly, They are conformed to him in holiness and glory. For if the face of Moses shone with an extraordinary radiance, after he had enjoyed fellowship with God on the holy mount;176 and if the contemplation of the Lord Jesus Christ by faith, and in a glass, transforms us into the same image;177 how shall not the conformity of the soul to the Divine purity and glory, be the effect of that intimate communion with God, to which the saints are admitted in heaven? 5thly, As the result of all these blessings, they possess “fulness of joys.”178179
LXXIII. Although these felicities are truly excellent, they do not exhaust that plenitude of bliss, for which the Gospel teaches us to hope. And hence the consummation of our happiness is often spoken of as deferred till the coming of our Lord.180 It remains, therefore, to inquire in what manner our happiness is to be increased and completed at the last day.
LXXIV. Here it must be considered, in the first place, that whereas till then the soul alone is the subject of the heavenly blessedness, this blessedness shall from that time extend to the whole man. The bodies of believers, being raised up in glory, shall be restored to their souls; and the bodies of those whom that day may find alive, shall be transformed into glory, that, together with their souls, they may be capable of perfect felicity. Here the almost incredible benignity of God is admirably displayed. He had determined to bless as well our bodies, as our spirits, with a participation of the heavenly felicity. But since they are unable, as now constituted, to bear so great a weight of glory, what measures will he adopt? Will he diminish the glory of heaven, that our bodies may be admitted to a share of it? By no means. He will rather change the qualities of the human body. Though once animal, he will make it spiritual; though once earthly, he will make it heavenly; that it may possess a proper meetness for the glory with which it shall be blessed. Thus Christ “shall change our vile body, that it may be fashioned like unto his glorious body, according to the working whereby he is able even to subdue all things unto himself.”181 Thus, even in the corporeal part of our nature, we shall “shine forth as the sun in the kingdom of our Father.”182 The soul, too, owing to its natural affection for the body, cannot fail to perceive, with inexpressible pleasure, the great glory with which the body is adorned when re-united to itself.
LXXV. Further, God will in that day most amply display his transcendant glory in very glorious works. Then we shall see this vast universe delivered from the bondage of corruption into the glorious liberty of the sons of God; and a new heaven and a new earth, wherein only righteousness dwelleth; and the general assembly of all the elect that have ever existed from the beginning of the world to the last day, clothed with renovated bodies, and shining with astonishing brightness. And since in all these things the saints will admire nothing but the reflected beams of the Divine glory sparkling on every side, may it not be said that, whilst seeing these, they shall see God himself in the most conspicuous manner? Hence says the Apostle John: “We know that when he shall appear, we shall be like him, for we shall see him as he is.”183 “As for me,” says the Psalmist also, “I will behold thy face in righteousness; I shall be satisfied when I awake” from the sleep of death, “with thy likeness.”184 The object will then be represented in the clearest manner, and its influence on the mind will be highly efficacious, and such as we cannot now explain: and at the same time the subject will be excellently suited to discern every thing in God and relating to God, that is calculated to perfect its felicity.
LXXVI. Their enjoyment of God, too, who is the Chief Good, will then be far more perfect and more immediate than all that they had formerly experienced. The remains of sin, with which even the holiest men have always to struggle in the present life, will no more be found. Nor shall any effects of sin continue, such as those that are to be seen in the bodies of the pious dead, whilst they remain under the power and in the territories of death:—effects, of which the glorified saints cannot be ignorant, and which serve, it must be acknowledged, to prevent their joy from rising to the highest degree. So long as there are any of the remains or effects of sin in the elect, God holds communion with them only through the intervention of the Mediator. But by the resurrection, death itself “shall be destroyed,”185 and “cast into the lake of fire;”186 and henceforth shall have no power except against the enemies of God and his people. There shall be nothing in the whole church which will not be perfectly holy, and entirely subject to God. And there will be nothing to hinder God from holding communion with the redeemed, as he doth with holy Angels, most intimately and immediately, without the intervention of a Mediator, whose economy shall then entirely cease. “When all things shall be subdued to him, then shall the Son also himself be subject unto him that put all things under him, that God may be all in all.”187188
LXXVII. What crowns their felicity, however, is, that it will be Everlasting. It is not only life, but “life eternal.”189 The subject of this blessedness will be for ever capable of enjoying it, and the blessedness itself will never be taken away. The soul is, by the constitution of its nature, immortal. The body also will be entirely exempt from sin, which is the immediate cause of corruption: nor will it resemble those bodies which consist of a certain composition of the elements, and may be resolved into them; but, as we have already shown, it will be spiritual, heavenly, and incorruptible. Owing, besides, to the everlasting efficacy of the merits of Christ, and to the quickening power of the Holy Spirit, by whom both parts of the human nature are prepared for glory, the connexion subsisting between soul and body will remain for ever indissoluble. The blessedness itself, too, will be no less permanent. The inheritance reserved for us in heaven, is “incorruptible, and undefiled, and fadeth not away.”190 We are encouraged to wait for “a crown of glory that fadeth not away.”191
LXXVIII. And indeed if it is a real and solid blessedness, it must of necessity be permanent. Consider the matter in itself: when other circumstances are alike, any good is valuable in proportion to its duration; and the chief good, therefore, must be eternal. Attend to the impression of the matter in the human mind: how great soever any good may be, the thought of its coming to an end is distressing; and however long be its continuance, if it must be ended, it is impossible to avoid the thought of its termination. Nay, although it were never to end, whilst we have no assurance of its perpetual duration, it is hardly possible for us not to be seized with the fear of losing it. And wherever there is fear, there cannot be that fulness of joy which perfect happiness requires. Hence it appears that both the eternity of blessedness, and the full assurance of that eternity in the minds of the blessed, are essential to perfect felicity.
It would be easy to illustrate these things at greater length, and the pleasantness of the subject is very alluring. But as we have elsewhere discoursed more fully on these topics, it may suffice to have here briefly adverted to the principal heads.192
LXXIX. Since this is a discussion peculiarly calculated to make a deep impression on the human mind, we must take care that it seem not to terminate only in frigid speculations. And first of all, the doctrine of so exalted a felicity tends to convince us of the Divine origin of the Gospel, by which it is revealed and exhibited. Examine the most ingenious discourses of Philosophers; consult the Koran of the Mahommedans; ask the modern doctors of the Jews. What have they to produce, which can at all be confronted with the felicity promised in the Gospel? Ever since our first parents lost their original happiness by the fall, the memory of that happiness is so worn out amongst their posterity, that they are capable of forming only an obscure and confused idea of the chief good; and, till they are enlightened by the Gospel, they universally embrace ashes instead of a treasure, shadows for substance, and nothings for realities.193 They seek, they search, they run, they pant; but they know neither for what, nor how they should strive. And when they flatter themselves that they have attained an object which will at last satisfy their eager mind, they soon find that their thirst is rather augmented than extinguished. For either they are deprived of the good things which they have long sought, after having possessed them for a short time; or their precarious felicity is destroyed by enjoyment itself, injures the possessor, and inflames the mind with new and equally tormenting desires.194
LXXX. The wisest among the heathen rather supposed and conjectured, than knew, something about the subsistence of the soul after the termination of the present life. A few of them, by a vague tradition, had heard of the resurrection of the body; the meaning of which they saw as through a mist, having no solid argument by which they could establish, to their own satisfaction, the truth of so wonderful a doctrine. But whereas the Philosophers employed themselves in anxious inquiries relating to the chief good; whereas Epicurus with his followers denied the immortality of the soul, while with much wavering and hesitation it was defended by Socrates and Plato, and held only as an uncertain conjecture by the Brahmins of India and the Druids of Gaul; and whereas the Poets enveloped the whole doctrine of a future state in numberless fables;—the glories of eternity are now clearly and certainly revealed in the Gospel, that we may not only believe, but so anticipate them in our own souls, that from what we now possess, perceive, and taste, our faith may rise to full assurance.
LXXXI. Mahommed, when he intends to point out the highest rewards which he teaches his followers to expect, speaks of nothing but carnal enjoyments. The splendid mansions of Paradise; chambers containing couches of gold, and strewed with silk, tapestry, and precious stones; an unknown abundance of silver and gold; waters whiter than snow and sweeter than honey, and nigh them as many crystal glasses as there are stars in heaven; a table of adamant, with chairs of gold and silver; oranges to be presented to each of the guests, which they no sooner smell, than straightway, the most beautiful virgins burst forth from them to embrace the followers of Mahommed;—these, and other things of the same sort, or still more absurd, which it would be tedious and disgusting to detail, are the remunerations which that impostor proposes.
LXXXII. Nor do the Jews discover a greater share of wisdom and sobriety, when they talk of the magnificent feast of their Messiah, consisting of a woodland ox formed and fattened for the purpose, of the fish Leviathan, of the bird Bar Juchna, and of wines of the most delicate flavour produced in paradise, and reserved in Adam’s cellar till the last day. Their ravings about these things are so ridiculous, that Manasseh himself was ashamed of them, and laboured strenuously, how unsuccessfully soever, to convert them into allegories. They entertain opinions wretchedly erroneous with regard to the condition of separate souls; which they represent as wandering about their own corpses, prompted by the love they bear for them, for a whole year after death; and as frequently employed for performing magical arts, by Demons that infest the air. The metempsychosis also, or the transmigration of souls into other bodies, was believed by the ancient Pharisees; and it is still maintained by the modern Cabbalists. They debase, too, the doctrine of the resurrection, by a multitude of fables, such as that which they tell of an incorruptible small bone in the chine-bone of the back, from which alone, after the rest of the body shall have been consumed, it may be entirely recovered and restored; and of a certain celestial dew, by which that bone is to be mollified and extended, like leaven which diffuses itself through the whole mass;—to pass over the fable of the rolling of bodies through secret passages of the earth to Palestine, that they may be raised up in that country. All these notions are equally contrary to the dictates of sound reason, and the doctrine of sacred writ.
LXXXIII. How much more noble and sublime is the divine doctrine of the Gospel, which teaches us that the happiness of man is not to be sought in created objects, far less in those gross and animal pleasures which gratify his bodily appetites; but in the pious contemplation, the delightful enjoyment, and the holy resemblance of the Supreme Being:—that, through the grace of God and of Christ, the beginnings of these felicities are imparted to true believers even in the present life, and are more richly conferred on the souls of the godly at death, that, released from the body of sin, they may rejoice in the embraces of God and the Redeemer, till, at last, being re-united to their bodies, which shall be raised up to glory, they experience God, without the intervention of any medium, to be to them “all in all.” These blessings are truly sufficient to fill and satisfy the soul that is desirous of the highest good; and beyond these, is nothing desirable, which it either knows or seeks. And who can question the truth and Divinity of that doctrine, which so clearly teaches, and so strongly assures us of, so great a felicity! Who would not rejoice that, after the reign of the grossest darkness, this Gospel has been so extensively preached, known, and embraced! Who would not cordially exult in it, as a treasure of inestimable value!195
LXXXIV. It is necessary for us, however, to take heed, lest amidst a general knowledge of these glories, we rest satisfied with a hope of them that is either precipitate or not well founded. Every exertion must be made to obtain solid and convincing evidence, that we are entitled to hope for this glorious felicity. It is proper, therefore, to inquire, with the greatest possible solicitude, both what is essential to the character of those whom God, in his testament, constitutes heirs of these blessings; and also whether those marks of Divine grace are to be found in us.
LXXXV. We ought, in the first place, to regard it certain and indubitable, that all are not to be admitted to a participation of eternal blessedness; nay, that this will not be the privilege of many, but of very few, compared with the multitudes that perish.196 They are a “little flock.”197 In Noah’s ark, “few, that is, eight souls were saved by water.”198 A still smaller number escaped the burning of Sodom, which amongst all its numerous inhabitants had not ten righteous persons. Of the six hundred thousand Israelites that departed from Egypt, only two entered Canaan. So here, “many are called, but few are chosen.”199 The awful admonition of Chrysostome to his hearers at Antioch is well-known: “How many do you suppose there are in our city, that shall be saved? What I am about to say, is indeed unpalatable; yet I will say it. Among so many thousands, not a single hundred can be found that shall be saved: and I even doubt if the number be so large.” It is not our province indeed, presumptuously to determine the number of those that perish and of those that are saved; much less to pronounce a rigorous sentence respecting our neighbour, who is perhaps no worse, or even better than ourselves. Yet according to the example of our Saviour himself we earnestly press it on the attention of men, that by far the smallest proportion of them are to inherit the life everlasting. Were this duly considered, would not every one anxiously inquire; “Lord, do I belong to the number?”200
LXXXVI. Further, notwithstanding this warning of our Lord, there are very many that deceive themselves. Poor vain mortals! we are so blinded by self-love, and so void of understanding, that when asked what hope of future happiness we cherish in our breast, we generally class ourselves, with great confidence, among the few of whom our Lord speaks as walking in the way that leadeth unto life; and perhaps none will reply with hesitation, except the man who has the surest title to that felicity. Truly amazing, and never to be sufficiently deplored, is that supine indifference, which induces us, although so often and so faithfully warned, to suspend that incalculable weight of glory upon the slender thread of a proud imagination, and so to speak, upon a spider’s web. Who is there that, though he bends his attention with energy to the most unimportant of his other affairs, yet doth not flatter himself most stupidly in this highly momentous concern, on which all depends,—and doth not presume to affirm that he has a title to heaven, although he be possessed of no evidence, and can produce no proof of his title. Are we so absolutely lost to all rationality, as thus to trifle with our life, with our soul, with our salvation? We hear that salvation is obtained by few. And are we all bold enough to number ourselves amongst the few? For what reason? On what ground? None at all, but that we think proper to do so. But why do we think proper to entertain that view of our state? We know not; and we have no reason for our confidence to assign to our own mind, much less to others, much less to God. Oh what folly! what madness! what frenzy! What term sufficiently strong can I find, to stigmatize such deplorable supineness!
LXXXVII. Let us at length shake off this fatal lethargy, and know at least in this our day the things which belong to our peace. Let us no longer suffer ourselves to be deceived by the vain illusions of dreams, but “lay up in store for ourselves a good foundation against the time to come.”201 Let us esteem it an inviolable maxim, that vain are all our hopes of living eternally in glory, unless we now possess the beginnings of glory in true holiness, and that none can attain the blessed resurrection of the body, whose soul has not first been raised from the death of sin. For in this sense too, these words in the Apocalypse hold true: “Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection; on such the second death hath no power.”202 It is certain, that “except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.”203 Let every one, therefore, examine himself, whether he finds the Spirit dwelling in him as the author of a new life, by which he is dead to sin, the world, and himself, and lives to God. Let him inquire, whether he lives a kind of life, which is widely different from the ordinary course of mankind; which far excels the moral probity of Philosophers, the false religious zeal of Pharisees, the feigned sanctity of hypocrites, and the most splendid virtues, which men of any description can acquire by the unassisted powers of nature. Let him see if he possesses a life that elevates the mind above the vanishing enjoyments of this world, and keeps it fixed upon God, in contemplating, loving, praying to and praising him, and in imitating his excellencies;—a life, in fine, that exhibits evident traces of the life of God, and of that which Christ led on the earth. Since the prize under our consideration is of unbounded value, and since it is bestowed on very few, it is natural to conclude, that something peculiarly excellent must distinguish the character of such as are entitled to rank among those on whom it shall be conferred. “For I say unto you, that except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the Scribes and Pharisees, ye shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven.”204205
LXXXVIII. And assuredly that man is unworthy of everlasting life, who is not determined to prefer it to all other things, and to submit to any labour or exertion, how great soever, which the Divine wisdom has prescribed as a mean of attaining it. There is a story related by Marco Paulo the Venetian,206 which, although strange, is well fitted to illustrate the present subject. The substance of it is as follows. A certain Tyrant in the country of Mulete, whose name was Aloadinus, formed a band of assassins, and availing himself of their unbridled ferocity, committed such ravages that he soon became a terror to all. To induce this execrable band of soldiers to hold themselves in readiness for whatever service he required, he had recourse to the following artifice. He had planted a garden for himself, situated in a most delightful valley, surrounded with lofty mountains, and furnished with every kind of pleasure, so as exactly to resemble the paradise of Mahommed, whose doctrines were held by himself and his subjects. The entrance was guarded by a well fortified castle, secured by a strong garrison; and there was no other way of entering or departing from the garden. Now pretending that God had intrusted him with the key of paradise, the Tyrant caused those whom he wished to render thoroughly obsequious to his orders, to be first intoxicated with a kind of poisonous liquor, and when by this means overcome with sleep, to be conveyed unconsciously into his enchanting garden, that when they awoke and found themselves in the midst of such extraordinary pleasures, they might imagine they were caught up into the paradise of God. But when they had scarcely begun to taste the numerous delights around them, being stupified by the same liquor, they were carried out of the paradise. After returning to their sober senses, they could not help lamenting that they had lost so great a felicity, and were perfectly willing to suffer death for the sake of being exalted to the perpetual enjoyment of such a life. The Tyrant thus imposed on simple young men, that, prepared to exchange the present life for that felicity, they might be prodigal of their blood, and might not shrink from the most hazardous enterprize. But if so gross a deception had so powerful an effect on the minds of men, to what noble efforts ought not we to be stimulated by the certain hope and the undoubted first-fruits of a solid and substantial felicity?
LXXXIX. God indeed has freely promised that future bliss to his people. It is “the gift of God through Jesus Christ our Lord.”207 Our title to eternal life is not founded on any merit of our own works, but solely on the satisfaction which Christ hath made in our stead. Let none, however, expect to obtain the possession of it otherwise than in the way of good works. The Apostle’s earnest exhortation to all is, “Work out your own salvation with fear and trembling.”208 The attainment of so great a felicity is no easy or common matter. “The righteous” himself “is scarcely saved.”209 We must “strive to enter in at the strait gate.”210 The heavenly Jerusalem must be taken by a holy violence, nor can it be otherwise obtained. “The kingdom of heaven suffereth violence, and the violent take it by force.”211 God “will render to every man according to his deeds”; and he will adjudge eternal life to none but “them who by patient continuance in well-doing, seek for glory, and honour, and immortality.”212 Now since a reward of such inestimable value is proposed, who can consider any labour undergone in the service of God, either excessive or fruitless? “Therefore, my beloved brethren, be ye stedfast, unmoveable, always abounding in the work of the Lord; forasmuch as ye know that your labour is not in vain in the Lord.”213
XC. How can that labour be in vain, to which the Divine veracity has annexed a glorious reward, which the Divine goodness will bestow? Who that attends to these things would not exclaim with delight; “Oh! how great is thy goodness, which thou hast laid up for them that fear thee; which thou hast wrought for them that trust in thee before the sons of men!”214 How great the consolation which the sure hope of this felicity is naturally calculated to administer to afflicted souls! If they are stripped of worldly wealth by the fraud and violence of unrighteous men; thanks be to God that the happiness of the Christian by no means consists in possessions which moth or rust doth corrupt, and which are exposed to the rapacity of thieves. What does he lose, from whom are taken away perhaps some small and naturally perishing things, to which he had given a place in his house, but not in his heart; whilst he retains the invaluable pearl of Divine grace unhurt by enemies, and is certain that the substantial treasures of glory are deposited, and kept safe for him with God, in the sacred treasury of the heavenly temple, nay, in the bosom of the Deity himself?215 If afflictions assail him, and particularly if he suffer for the sake of Christ and of righteousness, let it not seem hard to “suffer with Christ, that we may be glorified together. For I reckon, that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us.”216 If the body be chastened with grievous diseases or pains, if the soul be harassed with sorrowful thoughts, if even the terrors of death approach, let the noble mind of the Christian look earnestly forward to futurity. Let him by faith anticipate those times, or rather those everlasting ages, in which the body, freed from all the pains of sickness, raised from the dust of death, and conformed to the glorious body of Christ, shall shine forth as the sun in the kingdom of his heavenly Father; in which the soul, delivered from all the conflicts of temptation, shall rejoice in God and the Lamb. Let him anticipate those ages, when he shall see, possess, and enjoy, without measure, and without satiety, all those felicities, which here, amidst the numerous troubles of life, and in spite of the rage and malice of the Devil, he believed, expected, and very imperfectly tasted. Then resuming his courage, let him boldly say, Ye diseases and pains, thou death, or thou Satan, with all thy infernal forces, do you expect to cast me down from my happy state? It is long since I knew you, and by faith stripped you of your mask. Without the will of my heavenly Father you can do nothing, you cannot injure one hair of my head. Ye pains, ye diseases, you will slay the old man, you will destroy the body of sin. Death, thou wilt terminate my miseries, and open wide to me the gate of heaven. And thou, O Satan, how unwillingly soever, shalt become to me a teacher of humility, and after a contest of short continuance, I will conquer, seize, and bind thee, and will trample and bruise thee under my feet: Whilst thou shalt be tormented with eternal flames, I shall be honoured with a triumph that will never end. “For which cause we faint not; but though our outward man perish, our inward man is renewed day by day. For our light affliction which is but for a moment, worketh for us a far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory; while we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen; for the things which are seen are temporal, but the things which are not seen are eternal.”217
XCI. Since such treasures of glory are laid up and reserved for the Christian, with what magnanimity ought he to contemn the fading enjoyments of the world, and to consider as loss and dung, far beneath his regard, all those vanities which the unthinking multitude admire and adore! Shall a candidate for heaven, shall a son of the resurrection, occupy himself in laborious exertions to gather, preserve, and accumulate things of nought, things which render no man happier, since they render no man wiser, holier, or liker to God; and which generally become incitements to vice? Shall he be elated at the increase of such trifles, or discouraged at their loss? Shall he suffer himself to be ensnared by the allurements, or depressed by the calamities of the present life? Shall he contemplate with an envious eye the uncertain prosperity of them, “who have their portion in this life, and whose belly,” not whose soul, “God fills with his hid treasure; whose children are filled,218 and leave the rest of their substance to their babes:” whilst he “shall behold God’s face in righteousness, and be satisfied, when he awakes, with his likeness.”219
What expressions of the liveliest gratitude, in fine, will he not acknowledge himself bound to render to Jesus Christ his Saviour, who by his own death has rescued him from so deep an abyss of complicated misery, and advanced him to so great a height of felicity! “I thank God,” says the Apostle, “through Jesus Christ our Lord.”220
Notes
Note LXXVIII. Page 411.
The Resurrection of the Body is an article distinctly expressed in the most ancient copies of the Creed, which have reached our times. The vigorous opposition made to this doctrine, both by Pagans and Heretics, as well as its intrinsic importance and utility, served to fix on it the eager attention of Christians, and to inflame their zeal in its defence.221
The precise meaning of Mat. xxii. 31, 32. and the force of the argument for the resurrection, founded on that passage, would form a proper subject of critical inquiry. But minute discussions are, now in particular, quite incompatible with the limits of these Notes. Let it suffice, therefore, to state, that Whitby, on the passage, illustrates this argument particularly, and is at great pains to prove that the resurrection is directly intended; while Dr Campbell takes a quite different view of the verses. The expression rendered in our English Bible, Which say that there is no resurrection,222 is translated by this eminent Critic, Who say that there is no future life; and he vindicates this version in a very ingenious Note.
Note LXXIX. Page 412.
Our Author appeals, without scruple, to the profession of Job, ch. xix. 25–27. as a signal proof of the resurrection of the body. When he speaks of having elsewhere discussed this argument at greater length, he seems to refer to his Economy of the Covenants.223 Several different views which the critics have taken of the sense of this contested passage, were briefly stated in a preceding Note.224 Whoever wishes to prosecute the subject, may consult the Critical Dissertation of Peters, and other writers.—Dr Magee, in two of his Explanatory Dissertations,225 subjoined to his Discourses on the Atonement, has favoured his readers with a comprehensive general account of the history, antiquity, and book, of Job.
Note LXXX. Page 414.
Whether the beautiful passage quoted from Isaiah, chap. xxvi. 19, ought to be viewed as referring directly to the blessed resurrection of the saints at the last day, or as a metaphorical description of the restoration of the church from a depressed to a prosperous state, it is not unaptly brought forward by the Author. Bishop Lowth, in his Note on this verse, makes the following pertinent remarks.
“The deliverance of the people of God from a state of the lowest depression, is explained by images taken from the Resurrection of the dead. In the same manner the Prophet Ezekiel represents the restoration of the Jewish nation from a state of utter dissolution, by the restoring of the dry bones to life, exhibited to him in a vision, chap. xxxvii. which is directly thus applied and explained, ver. 11–13. And this deliverance is expressed with a manifest opposition to what is here said above, ver. 14, of the great lords and tyrants, under whom they had groaned;
‘They are dead, they shall not live;
They are deceased tyrants, they shall not rise:’
that they should be destroyed utterly, and should never be restored to their former power and glory. It appears from hence, that the doctrine of the Resurrection of the dead was at that time a popular and common doctrine: for an image which is assumed in order to express or represent any thing in the way of allegory or metaphor, whether poetical or prophetical, must be an image commonly known and understood; otherwise it will not answer the purpose for which it is assumed.”
The Bishop, it may be noted, translates the last part of ver. 19. thus; “But the earth shall cast forth, as an abortion, the deceased tyrants;” which nearly coincides with the second rendering proposed by Witsius. The disputed word רפאים, Rephaim, seems to be used in Scripture in at least three acceptations, giants, ghosts, the ghosts of the wicked. In this chapter it is rendered tyrants by John Knox,226 as well as by the Bishop of London. But on the etymology and meaning of this term, the learned reader may consult Leigh, Parkhurst, and Dr Magee.227
Note LXXXI. Page 424.
Our Author does not hesitate to represent the saints as receiving in the world to come the rewards of those works of faith and exercises of holiness which they performed on the earth. These rewards, indeed, are wholly of grace; but they are justly styled rewards,—because they are conferred after the labours of their pilgrimage are ended,—because a certain, though gracious, connexion is established between a holy life and a happy eternity—because the joys of immortality will more than compensate for all the toils and sacrifices attending the Christian race—and because there will be a correspondence and proportion, both in kind and degree, betwixt what the believer sows here and what he reaps hereafter. Some writers, as Dr Gill, and Mr Gib,228 strenuously oppose the doctrine of different degrees of future glory proportioned to the different measures of holiness and usefulness which, through grace, have been attained in this world. But see our Author’s defence of this doctrine in his Economy of the Covenants.229 See also Fuller’s Sermon on the Christian Doctrine of Rewards, and Russell’s Letters.
Note LXXXII. Page 433.
The expression made use of in the Creed, it must be observed, is σαρκος ἀναστασιν, carnis resurrectionem,230 which literally signifies the resurrection of the flesh. The modern French translation, accordingly, makes it La resurrection de la chair. The author of the Critical History of the Creed expresses his wonder that our English translators did not render σαρκος flesh, but employed the more general term body. There is a particular force and emphasis, he remarks, in the word flesh. Whereas some admitted the resurrection, but denied the reviviscence of the same body, it was in opposition to this notion, and to prevent equivocating evasions on the part of its abettors, that this article was expressed by the resurrection σαρκος, of the flesh, and not σωματος, of the body. Rufinus, who was accused of this error, alleged, in his own vindication, that to remove all suspicion of his being tainted with it, he had frequently affirmed, that not merely the body, but the flesh, should rise again. From the writings of the Fathers it appears, that they generally understood that by this form of expression they distinctly declared their belief, that there will be a resurrection of the same body which we now have—the same with regard to its substance, though very different with regard to its qualities.231
Our Author’s comments on the Apostle’s expressions in 1 Cor. vi. 13, 14. and xv. 42–49. seem correct and instructive. It might be useful to compare them with the remarks of Beza, Pareus, Doddridge, and other expositors. Beza has a very excellent annotation on these words; “It is sown an animal body, it is raised a spiritual body.” Macknight, in the middle of a long note on this subject,232 has injured the truth by the unwarrantable concession; “that, if the glorified body of the saints is to have such members and organs of sensation as their new state requires, and if these members are to be of similar form and use with the members and organs of our present body, it will really be the same body, whether its flesh be made of the matter which composed the body laid in the grave, or of any other matter.” See an able discussion of this topic in a Sermon on the Resurrection of the dead, lately published.233 The writer of that discourse, indeed, in illustrating the spirituality of the glorified body of the saints, may possibly have indulged his imagination somewhat to excess; but, in other respects, he has done great justice to the subject, and treated it in a manner equally scriptural and rational.
Note LXXXIII. Page 439.
The Author’s opinion relative to Michael has been already adverted to.234 In applying Dan. xii. 2. to the general resurrection of the bodies of men in the great day, he is certainly correct. To his conclusive reasoning on this point here, he adds some further arguments in his Economy of the Covenants.235 The same interpretation of the verse, too, is decidedly embraced, and concisely supported, by Bishop Newton in his Dissertations on the Prophecies.236
Note LXXXIV. Page 455. line 1.
With much reason, doth our candid but conscientious Author characterize the Canonizations of the Pope as superstitious and idolatrous. To convince every reader of the propriety of these epithets, it may not be improper to give the following authentic instance, as related in Beausobre’s History of the Reformation.237
The subject of this canonization was Francis (Martolilla) de Paule, (that is, of Paula, a small town in Calabria,) who was the Founder of the religious Society of the Minims, and celebrated for his pretended miracles. At the solicitation of Francis I. he was canonized by Pope Leo X. on the 1st of May 1519, about twelve years after his death. The decree was solemnly pronounced by the Pope, in the presence of his Cardinals, in the following terms.
“To the honour of God Almighty, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, for the exaltation of the Catholic faith, for the progress of the Christian religion, and for the comfort and advancement of the order of Minims, under the authority of our Lord Jesus Christ, of the blessed Apostles Peter and Paul, and of our own, we decree and determine, by the advice and with the consent of our brethren the Cardinals, that Francis de Paule, of blessed memory, has been received among the Blessed of the heavenly Jerusalem, and is possessed of the eternal glory which has been given him, and that he ought to be placed in the rank of Saints, as we do place him from this day; ordering that he be hereafter worshipped in public and private, and that his festival be celebrated by the universal Church on the 2d of April, (the day of his death,) and declaring that believers may implore his intercession and hope for it, he being worthy that all the honours should be paid to him that are due to saints.”
This decree having been thus pronounced, Te Deum was sung: a Cardinal began the invocation of the new Saint, and the Pope addressed this prayer to God:
“We render to thee, O Lord, the obedience that is due unto thee; we pray thee, by the intercession of the Blessed Francis de Paule, to increase thy gifts upon us, and to preserve us from all evil, through Jesus Christ our Lord.”
Was not this, in reality, a superstitious and idolatrous canonization? Could such canonization, or the consequent acts of idolatry, be regarded by them who have indeed been numbered among the Blessed in the heavenly Jerusalem with any other emotions than those of indignation or of pity?238 Is any real dignity conferred by such idolatrous and impious, though solemn, decrees? When, in consequence of these decrees, we ascribe the title of Saints to Apostles, Evangelists, Martyrs, and Fathers, do we show an acceptable or becoming mark of respect for their memory? Those Protestants who choose to speak of Saint Peter, Saint Paul, Saint Luke, Saint Augustine, &c.239 are surely far from intending to express their approbation of these canonizations. Yet, if Popish errors are renounced, propriety and consistency seem to require the abandonment of Popish modes of expression, to which those errors gave rise. So fascinating, however, is the power of custom, that the members of some Reformed Churches are apt to suppose, that the venerable Apostles, and other distinguished Christians who have been canonized, are disrespectfully treated, unless, at almost every turn, the appellation of Saint be prefixed to their names. These obsequious Protestants, indeed, do not expect to hear of Saint Abraham, Saint Moses, Saint Isaiah.—But their ears must be gratified with the constant repetition of Saint Peter, Saint Matthew, &c. Whence this marked difference betwixt the worthies of the Old Testament, and those of the New? Does not this gratuitous distinction carry the appearance either of a culpable and servile deference for the authority and decrees of the Pope, or of a tame and inconsiderate acquiescence in long established phraseology, received by tradition from the fathers?
Note LXXXV. Page 455. line 13.
Our Author’s interpretation of that difficult passage which we have in Rev. xx. 4–6. appears, on the whole, to be just; and he seems to make good his position, that there is to be no literal resurrection of Apostles, martyrs, or other saints, prior to the last day. The notion of a literal resurrection is held by some respectable modern writers, as Mede and Bishop Newton. But the great majority of expositors explain the passage in a manner similar to Witsius. See Durham’s Lectures on Rev. xx. and Whitby’s Treatise on the Millennium. See also Dr Bryce Johnston’s Commentary on the Revelation, Mr Culbertson’s Lectures, and Fraser of Kirkhill’s Key to the Prophecies. On Rev. xx. 4. Dr Johnston has the following expressions: “Some have understood these words as a prediction that the martyrs, who were slain under heathen and papal Rome, shall be raised to life from their graves at the commencement of the Millennium, and shall personally reign with Christ on earth for a thousand years. Even if the language of this passage had been much stronger in favour of a real resurrection of the martyrs at that time than it is, there are so many unanswerable objections against such a resurrection at that time, that it would not be easy to make candid and intelligent men to understand the words in that sense, if they could possibly bear any other.”240 Culbertson states particularly a number of strong objections against the doctrine of a literal resurrection of saints at that time.241 Fraser, after an interesting account of the different opinions entertained even by those who have agreed in contending for a literal resurrection, proves that the first resurrection is a figurative expression; and judiciously replies to the objections to this interpretation, which have been founded on several terms in verse 5th.242
Since the Author did not regard it as his “present business” to discuss the commencement and termination of the thousand years during which Satan is to be bound and the saints are to live and reign with Christ, or of the different periods of which that term may be composed, the Translator will not be expected gratuitously to undertake the investigation, far less the decision, of matters which have been so long and so keenly disputed. The most important point relating to the duration of the Millennium, on which diversity of sentiment now prevails, is no doubt the question; Whether the thousand years are to be understood in a civil or prophetical sense? i. e. Whether that glorious period is to last only for a thousand years in the usual and proper sense of the expression, or to continue for three hundred and sixty thousand, or perhaps three hundred and sixty-five thousand years? The first sense is preferred by Bishop Newton and Dr Johnston, as well as by Guyse and Doddridge. But the last interpretation, though comparatively new, and somewhat romantic in its appearance, has been adopted by some grave and respectable authors. It is strenuously defended, for example, by Mr Culbertson;243 and it is more than twenty years since an aged and eminent Minister of the Gospel in Nova Scotia ably contended for the same interpretation, in the first of three lively papers on the Millennium, which appeared in a periodical work.244 Suffice it now only to remark, that this topic merits further inquiry; and that, whatever may be the speciousness or the force of the arguments which have been adduced in favour of the prophetical sense, they seem scarcely sufficient finally to decide a question of such magnitude, or to command an unwavering assent.
Note LXXXVI. Page 465.
That the souls of men not only continue after death, but live, understand, and feel, is sufficiently proved by the Author in this Dissertation, sections 67–70. But he treats this important subject more fully in his work on the Covenants.245 The reader might also consult Secker,246 and Dr Watts.247 The beautiful papers of Addison on the Immortality of the soul are well known.248
Note LXXXVII. Page 466.
What the Author here says respecting the felicity to which the righteous are admitted immediately after death, is an abridgment of his remarks in the Treatise just mentioned.249
Archbishop Secker’s refutation of the doctrine of Purgatory, in his Lectures on the Creed,250 is so concise, as well as instructive, that it may be right to introduce it here.—“As to the pretence of Purgatory,” says that learned writer, “where the greatest part of good persons are to suffer grievous temporal punishments, after death, for their sins, though the eternal punishment is remitted: it hath no ground in the least. Our Saviour’s saying, ‘that the blasphemy against the Holy Ghost shall not be forgiven in this world, or that which is to come,’251 is merely saying, it shall not be forgiven at all, but punished both here and hereafter. ‘The prison, out of which,’ he saith, the person who agrees not with his brother, ‘shall not come till he hath paid the last farthing;’252 is either a literal prison of this world, or the prison of hell in the next, out of which the contentious and uncharitable shall never come, for they can never pay the last farthing. ‘The spirits in prison,’ to whom St Peter saith, ‘Christ by his Spirit preached,’ he saith also, were ‘the disobedient in the days of Noah,’253 with whom ‘his Spirit strove,’254 whilst they were on this earth: and who for their disobedience were sent, not to purgatory, but to a worse confinement. When St Paul bids men ‘take heed how they build on the foundation’ of Christianity; adding, ‘that the fire shall try every man’s work; and if any man’s work shall be burnt, he shall suffer loss; but still shall be saved, yet so as by fire;’255 he means, that persons must not mix doctrines of their own invention with the gospel of Christ, which in this instance, amongst others, those of the church of Rome have done: for when ‘the Lord Jesus shall be revealed from heaven in flaming fire,’256 to judge the world, such notions will not stand the trial; they that hold them will be losers by them; and though still they may be saved, it will be with difficulty and danger; as a person escapes, when his house is burning. When, lastly, many of the ancient Christians prayed for the dead; besides that they had no warrant for so doing, it was only for the completion of their happiness, whom they apprehended to be already in paradise: it was for the apostles, saints, and martyrs; for the blessed virgin herself: whom they certainly did not think to be in purgatory. And observe, if they prayed for them, they did not pray to them. Purgatory, then, is nothing but an imaginary place, invented by men, to give bad persons hope, and good persons dread of being put into it; that they may get what they can from both, by pretending to deliver them out of it again. Fear not therefore such vain terrors.”
Note LXXXVIII. Page 474.
It is beyond question one of the brightest glories and most endearing recommendations of the Christian revelation, that it firmly establishes the doctrine of “life and immortality,” and places it in a perspicuous and most interesting point of view. Witsius justly affirms, that the wisest among the heathen were not only ignorant of the resurrection of the body, but also, that they “rather supposed and conjectured, than knew, something about the subsistence of the soul, after the termination of the present life.” The immortality of the soul was not taught by Confucius, or Aristotle; nor was it included amongst the tenets of the Stoics. The insufficiency of the light of nature to satisfy the serious inquirer with regard to this momentous topic, strikingly appears from the vacillation and uncertainty, which, notwithstanding all the probable arguments they were able to collect, the most eminent and judicious philosophers who favoured the doctrine, still discovered. Socrates, for example, concluded his apology to his judges with these remarkable words: “It is now time to depart hence. I am going to die; you shall continue to live: but which of us shall be in a better state, is unknown to all but God.” Plutarch speaks of “the fabulous hope of immortality;” and Cicero, after long reasoning on the immortality of the soul, has the following expression: “Which of these opinions is true, is certainly known only to the gods: which of them is the more probable, is a hard question.”257
Numerous errors and absurdities, besides, were blended with the doctrine of immortality, by those ancient philosophers, who professed to teach it. They almost universally maintained the pre-existence of the soul, as the ground of its deathless nature. Some of them affirmed that the spirit of man is a portion of the Divine essence, and on that account immortal; whilst the irrational and degrading tenet of transmigration extensively prevailed. Future happiness, too, was considered as nearly the exclusive privilege of those few individuals who are exalted to high distinction in this world, or whose minds have been cultivated by philosophy and science. The rewards of Elysium were regarded as a prize too great for the vulgar and illiterate; and whether a felicity strictly eternal was thought to be prepared even for the noblest or the most enlightened and refined seems at least exceedingly doubtful. Their views, in fine, of future misery, were extremely incorrect. Even those who assigned a future state of rewards to the virtuous, appear to have considered the doctrine of future punishment as little better than a fable, engendered by superstitious fears, embellished by the luxuriant fancies of the poets, and supported for political purposes by legislators and judges. It is by the Scriptures alone that the whole doctrine of a coming and eternal world, in which the righteous are for ever happy, and the wicked for ever miserable, is justly stated, incontestably confirmed, and rendered truly efficacious for impressing the mind and influencing the conduct. The death, resurrection, and ascension of the Son of God in human nature, have dispelled the darkness which covered the tomb; and exhibited the realities of a future state of existence, both as to soul and body, in a light equally satisfactory to the judgment and consoling to the heart. On this subject, see the copious and forcible statements of the laborious and intelligent Leland.258
Note LXXXIX. Page 478.
Our Lord’s solemn declaration in Mat. v. 20. respecting a better righteousness than that of the Scribes and Pharisees, has been understood by some interpreters as referring to the necessity of an interest in that justifying righteousness, which Christ, as the Surety of his people, wrought out by his obedience unto death. Dr Guyse, for instance, suggests this interpretation in his Paraphrase on the place, and subjoins the following Note: “As it was prophesied that the Messiah should make reconciliation for iniquity, and bring in everlasting righteousness, (Dan. ix. 24.); and our Saviour, in the two next foregoing verses but one, had spoken of his coming to fulfil the law and the prophets; I do not see why what he here says about the righteousness which exceeds that of the Scribes and Pharisees, may not refer back to all those verses, and so take in the righteousness of justification as well as of sanctification, to give a hint of what was afterwards to be more fully explained of his being the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth; and the righteousness of God being by faith of Jesus Christ unto all and upon all them that believe, Rom. iii. 22. x. 4.
There is some force in these remarks of the evangelical Guyse. But probably, according to our venerable Author’s interpretation, the verse more immediately relates to that personal righteousness, which is the undoubted characteristic of all those, who by faith are “admitted to the blessings of the kingdom of grace here, or of the kingdom of glory hereafter.” Witsius indeed does not represent our own righteousness, however superior it may be to that partial and external righteousness which was taught and practised by the Scribes and Pharisees, as in any degree the ground of acceptance, or the proper condition of eternal life. In the 89th Section, he states expressly that the heavenly inheritance is the subject of a free promise, and the gift of God, and that our title to eternal life is founded not upon our own works, but upon the satisfaction of Christ. Yet he justly considered it proper earnestly to inculcate the cultivation of true and distinguished holiness, as a necessary preparation for the everlasting kingdom.
Note XC. Page 483.
In the common English version of Psalm xvii. 14. we read;—“They are full of children, and leave the rest of their substance to their babes.” According to our Author, the sense is,—“Whose children are filled, and leave the rest of their substance (their excellency) to their babes.” The original expression is susceptible of either interpretation; and which of the two is the more correct, it may be difficult, and it is not of great importance, to determine. Witsius has here copied the Latin of Tremellius and Junius.259 Our translators have followed the Septuagint.260 Yet they have mentioned the other sense, in the margin, in these words; their children are full: on which Pool has the following comment; “Their children are filled or satisfied, as well as their parents. There is abundantly enough both for them and for their children, and to spare for their children’s children.”261
1 Ps. xxx. 3.
2 Is. xxxviii. 16.
3 2 Cor. i. 9, 10.
4 Lam. iv. 20.
5 Hos. vi. 1, 2.
6 John v. 25. See also Eph. ii. 5. Col. ii. 12. iii. 1.
7 Rom. xi. 15.
8 Ch. lix. 21. lx. 1.
9 1 Cor. xv. 13–19.
10 Resurrectio mortuorum, fiducia Christianorum.
11 Mat. xxii. 31, 32.
12 Exod. iii. 6.
13 Luke xx. 38.
14 חיי בשני עולמות ad Levit. xviii. 4.
15 De Resur. Mort. lib. i. cap. 10.
16 Cap. ix. 3.
17 Exod. xxxiii. 1.
18 See Note LXXVIII.
19 Job vi. 8, 9, 11. vii. 7, 8. x. 20, 21. xvi. 22. xvii. 1, 15. xix. 10.
20 See Note LXXIX.
21 ארץ רפאים תפיל
22 Comp. 1 Cor. xv. 24.
23 See Note LXXX.
24 Luke xiv. 14. John v. 28, 29. vi. 39, 40, 44, 54. xi. 24–26. xiv. 19. Acts iv. 2. xvii. 18. xxvi. 8. Rom. viii. 11. 1 Cor. vi. 14. 2 Cor. i. 9. iv. 14. 1 Thes. iv. 14. 2 Tim. iv. 1. Heb. vi. 2. 1 Cor. xv.
25 Mat. xxii. 29.
26 Acts xxvi. 8.
27 2 Cor. v. 10.
28 Gemara Sanhedrim, cap. xi.
29 Rom. v. 17.
30 Chap. xix. 25.
31 John xiv. 19.
32 1 Cor. vi. 14. xv. 12.
33 1 Cor. xv. 20.
34 Mat. xiii. 39.
35 1 Cor. xv. 21, 22.
36 1 Tim. iii. 16.
37 Ps. lxviii. 1.
38 1 Cor. xv. 26.
39 Ephes. i. 20, 22, 23.
40 Rom. viii. 11.
41 1 Cor. iii. 16. vi. 19.
42 Hag. ii. 9.
43 2 Pet. i. 4.
44 Ps. xvi. 10. Acts ii. 24.
45 ’Αναστασις.
46 Δευτὲρα του πεπτοκότος στὰσις.
47 Rom. viii. 11.
48 Job xix. 26, 27.
49 1 Cor. xv. 42, 43, 44, 53, 54.
50 Philip. iii. 21.
51 John v. 28.
52 Mat. xxvii. 52.
53 1 Cor. xv. 49.
54 Rom. vi. 11. viii. 11.
55 John xx. 27.
56 1 Cor. xv. 51.
57 2 Cor. iv. 10. comp. 2 Thes. i. 4, 5, 6.
58 1 Cor. xv. 58.
59 See Note LXXXI.
60 De Civitat. Dei, lib. xxii. cap. 20.
61 Mat. x. 28.
62 1 Cor. xv. 42–44.
63 1 Cor. vi. 13, 14.
64 1 Cor. xv. 45, 47–49.
65 Ibid. verse 50.
66 See Heb. ii. 14. Mat. xvi. 17. Ephes. vi. 12. Gal. i. 16.
67 Σαρκὸς ἀναστασις.
68 Job xix. 26.
69 Heb. v. 7.
70 See Note LXXXII.
71 Doctrinæ Compendiolum, cap. viii. sect. 1.
72 Acta Colloquii Racoviensis, 1607.
73 Verse 25.
74 Verse 27.
75 Rev. xx. 13.
76 John xi. 17. Mat. xxvii. 62. and in other places passim.
77 שכבי קבר Ps. lxxxviii. 5.
78 ’Εν κελεύσματι, ἐν φωνῆ ἀρχαγγέλου και ἐν σαλπιγγι Θεοῦ, 1 Thes. iv. 16.
79 1 John iii. 9.
80 John v. 24.
81 ’Οι ἀκουσαντες ζησονται, Verse 25.
82 The English reader will observe, that by the Aorist, or Indefinite, is meant a certain tense of the Greek Verb—the tense in which the expression rendered they that have done occurs. T.
83 Exerc. Theolog. vi. ad Joh. viii. 18.
84 See Note LXXXIII.
85 Mat. xxiv. 21.
86 Is. vi. 13.
87 Ps. xiii. 3.
88 Jer. li. 39, 57.
89 Job vii. 21.
90 Κοιμητήρια.
91 Job xiv. 12.
92 Comp. 2 Kings iv. 31. Ps. xvii. 15.
93 Mat. xiii. 43. 1 Cor. xv. 40–42.
94 De Resurr. Mort. lib. ii. cap. 8.
95 Acts xxiv. 15.
96 1 Tim. i. 15. Rom. iv. 5. 1 Pet. iii. 18. Mat. xx. 15.
97 The celebrated Jewish author, who is usually called Maimonides.
98 Mat. v. 45.
99 1 Cor. vi. 1.
100 2 Pet. ii. 9.
101 Ps. i. 6.
102 Rom. iii. 10.
103 Comp. Ps. lii. 6, 7. Rev. xvi. 5–7.
104 צדיקים גמורים
105 רשעים גמורים
106 בנוניים
107 In Pirke.
108 Luke xiv. 14. xx. 36. 1 Cor. xv. 23. Philip. iii. 11. John vi. 39, 40, 44, 54. 1 Thes. iv. 14.
109 John v. 28.
110 John vi. 39, 40, 54.
111 1 Thes. iv. 16, 17.
112 1 Cor. xv. 23.
113 Verses 51, 52.
114 2 Tim. iv. 6–8.
115 The Greek expression is καὶ κρίμα ἐδόθη ἀυτοῖς, “and judgment was given unto them.” But if this referred to τας ψυχας, “the souls,” the word should rather have been ἀυταῖς.
116 Luke xx. 38.
117 Heb. xii. 22, 23.
118 Cœlo vivere, quos forum peremit.
119 See 1 Kings viii. 24. Rom. iii. 3, 4. 2 Cor. iv. 7.
120 See Note LXXXIV.
121 See Note LXXXV.
122 John iii. 16, 36. Rom. ii. 7. Tit. iii. 7. and elsewhere passim.
123 1 Pet. i. 9.
124 Non est vivere vita, sed valere.
125 1 Kings i. 31. where the Chaldee Paraphrast says יצלח Let him be happy, Let him prosper.
126 Ps. xxii. 26.
127 Ps. lxix. 32.
128 1 Tim. iv. 8.
129 1 John iii. 2.
130 1 Cor. ii. 9.
131 Ps. lxv. 4. lxxiii. 28.
132 Ps. lxiii. 2.
133 Ps. xxxiv. 8.
134 Song i. 2, 4. ii. 4.
135 Jer. x. 16. Ps. xvi. 5, 6.
136 Col. ii. 2.
137 2 Tim. iv. 8.
138 Philip. iv. 7.
139 2 Pet. i. 8.
140 Animam remanere post animal.
141 Philip. i. 23.
142 Heb. xii. 23.
143 Luke xvi. 19. et seq.
144 Heb. ii. 17. iv. 15.
145 Luke xxiii. 46.
146 Luke xx. 38.
147 Rom. viii. 10.
148 Eccles. xii. 7. 1 Cor. vi. 20. 1 Thes. v. 23.
149 Verse 11.
150 Ch. xxxiv. 5, 6.
151 Mat. xvii. 3.
152 Rev. xiv. 13.
153 ’Απαρτι.
154 Comp. John xv. 4–7. Rom. viii. 1. xvi. 7.
155 Rom. xvi. 2, 12. Ephes. iv. 1.
156 Rev. ii. 2.
157 Heb. iv. 9.
158 Verse 12.
159 Rev. vi. 9–11.
160 Philip. ii. 17. 2 Tim. iv. 6.
161 Lev. i. 5. iii. 2, 8.
162 Heb. xiii. 10.
163 Psalm xxvii. 5.
164 2 Thes. i. 6.
165 Rev. xvi. 5–7.
166 See Note LXXXVI.
167 Heb. xii. 23.
168 2 Cor. v. 1.
169 Luke xvi. 22.
170 Luke xxiii. 43.
171 John xii. 26. xvii. 24. Philip. i. 21.
172 Mat. v. 8.
173 John xvii. 24.
174 1 Cor. xiii. 12.
175 1 Cor. xiii. 8.
176 Exod. xxxiv. 29.
177 2 Cor. iii. 18.
178 Psalm xvi. 11.
179 See Note LXXXVII.
180 2 Tim. i. 12, 18. iv. 8. 1 Pet. i. 5. v. 4. Col. iii. 4. 1 John iii. 2.
181 Philip. iii. 21.
182 Mat. xiii. 43.
183 1 John iii. 2.
184 Psalm xvii. 15.
185 1 Cor. xv. 26.
186 Rev. xx. 14.
187 See Vol. I. Note LXI.
188 1 Cor. xv. 28.
189 Mat. xxv. 46. Rom. ii. 7.
190 1 Pet. i. 4.
191 1 Pet. v. 4.
192 The Author seems to refer to his work On the Covenants, book iii. chap. 14. T.
193 Comp. Is. lix. 10.
194 Comp. Is. xxix. 8.
195 See Note LXXXVIII.
196 Mat. vii. 13, 14.
197 Luke xii. 32.
198 1 Pet. iii. 20.
199 Mat. xxii. 14.
200 Mat. xxvi. 22.
201 1 Tim. vi. 19.
202 Rev. xx. 6.
203 John iii. 5.
204 Mat. v. 20.
205 See Note LXXXIX.
206 Itiner. lib. i. cap. 28.
207 Rom. vi. 23.
208 Philip. ii. 12
209 1 Pet. iv. 18.
210 Luke xiii. 24.
211 Mat. xi. 12.
212 Rom. ii. 6, 7.
213 1 Cor. xv. 58.
214 Ps. xxxi. 19.
215 Heb. x. 34.
216 Rom. viii. 17, 18.
217 2 Cor. iv. 16–18.
218 See Note XC.
219 Ps. xvii. 14, 15.
220 Rom. vii. 25.
221 King’s Crit. Hist. of the Creed, chap. vii. p. 389.
222 Ὁι λεγοντες μη ἐιναι ἀναστασιν.
223 Book iii. ch. 2. sect. 19–24.
224 Note xxxvi.
225 Vol. i. No. 41. Vol. ii. No. 61.
226 Sermon on Isaiah xxvi. 13–21. subjoined to the History of the Reformation of the Church of Scotland, p. 103. printed in the year 1644.
227 Discourses and Dissertations, Vol. i. No. 41.
228 Sacred Contemplations, &c. Covenant of Grace, Period iii. sect. 2.
229 Book iii. ch. 14. sect. 39, 40.
230 See Vol. i. Note I.
231 Lord King’s Crit. Hist. Ch. vii. pp. 397–404.
232 On the Apostolical Epistles, 1 Cor. xv. 43. Note 2.
233 Sermons by Ministers belonging to the (late) Associate Synod, Ser. 14. by the Rev. Robert Balmer, Berwick-upon-Tweed.
234 Note XLVII.
235 Book iii. ch. 2. sect. 25–30.
236 Vol. i. Diss. 17. pp. 390, 391. 9th edit.
237 Macaulay’s Translation, Vol. i. p. 234. et seq.
238 See Mat. iv. 10. Acts xiv. 13–15. Rev. xix. 10. xxii. 8, 9.
239 Our worthy Author himself has adopted this form of expression in a few instances, as in Dissert. I. sect. 4. where he speaks of Beatus Augustinus, the Blessed or Saint Augustine. Yet wherever he has occasion to mention the Apostles and Fathers, he generally avoids this appellation.
240 Comment. on the Rev. Vol. II. chap. xx. p. 331.
241 Lectures on the Rev. Vol. II. Lect. 70. p. 426. et seq.
242 Key to the Prophecies, Part iii. chap. 7. sect. 2.
243 Lect. on the Rev. Vol. ii. Lect. 70. pp. 429–437.
244 The Christian Magazine, Vol. iv. for the year 1800, pp. 337–343. The signature is J. M‘G. being the initials of the Rev. James M‘Gregor, Pictou, Nova Scotia.
245 Book iii. chap. xiv. sect. 12–22.
246 Works, Vol. iv. Lect. 16. pp. 342–347.
247 “An Essay towards the Proof of a Separate State of Souls between Death and the Resurrection,” prefixed to the Discourses on the World to come.
248 See these papers subjoined to the Evidences of the Christian Religion, pp. 213–259.
249 Book iii. chap. 14. sect. 23–32.
250 Works, Vol. iv. Lect. 16. pp. 347–349.
251 Mat. xii. 31, 32.
252 Mat. v. 26.
253 1 Pet. iii. 18–20.
254 Gen. vi. 3.
255 1 Cor. iii. 10–15.
256 2 Thess. i. 7.
257 Harum sententiarum quæ vera sit, deus aliquis viderit: quæ verisimillima, magna quæstio est. Tusc. Disput.
258 The Advantage and Necessity of the Christian Revelation, Part iii. Ch. 1–9.
259 “Quorum filii satiantur, et excellentiam suam relinquunt nepotibus.” Pogninus in like manner says; “Saturantur filii, et demittent residuum suam parvulis suis.”
260 Ἐχορτασθησαν ὑιων.
261 Annot. in loc.