Sacred Dissertations on What Is Commonly Called the Apostles’ Creed (1823), Herman Witsius · PDF

Dissertation XXIV. On the Church, and the Communion of Saints

I. It is truly impossible to mention or to conceive a conjunction, more beautiful, more close and intimate, or more endeared by mutual love, than that which subsists between God and his people, between Christ and the Church. Here beauty and comeliness appear in full perfection. In Christ indeed it shines with a transcendant lustre; and hence it is said in the Psalms, “Thou art fairer than the sons of men;”1 where the doubling of the radical letters in the Hebrew word rendered “fairer,” adds to the energy of the signification. But the beauty even of the Church is so great, that he whose province it is to judge, pronounces this eulogy upon her: “Behold, thou art fair, my love; behold, thou art fair, thou hast doves’ eyes.” Nay, “Thou art all fair, my love; there is no spot in thee.”2 Again, this union is so intimate, that hardly any similitude is sufficient to express its closeness. Marriage, as it exists amongst men, has been defined by lawyers, “a state in which two persons are indissolubly united in life.”3 According to the definition of Scripture, “two shall be one flesh;”4 than which expression, certainly, none more proper or vigorous could have been employed. But here is something farther. “He who is joined to the Lord,” is not only one body with him, “a member of his flesh, and of his bones,”5 but also “one spirit” with him.6 And who can doubt that, since Christ and the Church are so fair, and so closely united, the happy consequence must be a most delightful interchange of mutual love. Such an interchange of love doth in reality take place. “How fair, and how pleasant art thou, O love, for delights!”7 We must not, therefore, presume to disjoin in our meditations, subjects which are connected together by so many ties. But having treated of God and Christ, and the Spirit who proceeds from both, we must now speak of the Church, which the Father has elected, and the Son redeemed, and which the Spirit unites to Christ, and seals unto the day of complete redemption.

II. Four points fall to be explained here. First, The Name. Secondly, The Thing itself. Thirdly, The Epithets. Fourthly, The exercise of our Faith in relation to the Church thus described.

III. It is proper to take notice of three Greek terms which are very similar in meaning, namely, Συναγωγη, ’Εκκλησια, Πανηγυρις. Συναγωγη, Synagoga, corresponds to the Hebrew word עדה, and in the New Testament generally signifies the assemblies of the Jews, which were held here and there, in various places and cities, for religious purposes. And as the designation Curia, which at first was given to men that conjunctly conducted the affairs of the state, was transferred to the place where they met; or as amongst the Greeks Βουλη signifies not only the senate, but also the place in which the senate is held,—the word Synagogue has been applied in the same manner; as is evident from Luke vii. 5, and numberless other passages. It has been observed, however, by the learned, that there is scarcely a single passage in the sacred volume, where this term is employed to denote the Societies of Christians. Paul indeed exhorts the Hebrews “not to forsake” την ἐπισυναγωγην ἀυτων, “the assembling of themselves together.”8 But as he is there addressing the Hebrews, he accommodates himself to their forms of speech. Nor yet does he use precisely the same word, and the expression he employs is not of the same meaning with Church; for the Apostles are accustomed to speak of the Church of God, or of Christ, not of the Church of these or those persons. ’Επισυναγωγη, therefore, denotes the gathering together itself, or the assembling of believers, as in 2 Thes. ii. 1, where Beza has well rendered it aggregatio, “gathering together.” James alone uses the expression, ‘η συναγωγη, the synagogue of Christians.9 Whether he intends, however, the place of meeting, or the assembling or gathering together, or the assembly which meets, I shall not now scrupulously examine. But that Apostle also addresses himself chiefly to the Jews, to whom he thought it would be agreeable for him to adopt a term which among them was at once common and honourable.10

IV. Christ, and the Apostles after him, nevertheless, preferred ’Εκκλησια, Ecclesia;—a word, which, though originally borrowed from the Grecian customs, and afterwards applied to the institutions of the Jews, was at length peculiarly appropriated to Christians. In democratic states, an assembly of those of higher rank was styled συγκλησία, or βουλή; and the name Ecclesia, which is derived from ἐκκαλειν, to call out, was given to the assemblies of the people, who were called out by a public herald, and gathered into a certain place, in order to deliberate together. Conformably to this, the Greek Interpreters of the Old Testament gave the name Ecclesia, to the assembly of Israelites, which at certain stated seasons, was called together to one place from all parts of Judea, to celebrate the solemn festivals, and to perform public and important acts of religious worship. The corresponding word in Hebrew, is קהל. Now the word Ecclesia seemed to Christ and his Apostles more proper than any other to designate the community of believers, both because it was the most pertinent to signify the thing, and because they wished by this appellation to distinguish Christians from Jews, who chiefly assumed the designation of Synagogue. They were disposed, in fine, to accommodate themselves, in this instance, to the Gentiles, who were henceforth to constitute by far the greater part of the people of God: For while Synagoga was a word rarely used among the Greeks, Ecclesia was a term remarkably well known, very popular, and naturally calculated to conciliate the minds of men. It denotes a promiscuous multitude of men of all descriptions, not indeed confused and irregular, but of such a complexion that none is excluded from it on account of the meanness of his rank. To this effect are the following words of Paul: “For ye see your calling,11 brethren, how that not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble are called. But God hath chosen the foolish things of the world,” &c.12

V. We must not neglect to advert also to the word Πανηγυρις, Panegyris, which the Apostle uses in Heb. xii. 23, and which differs somewhat in meaning from Ecclesia. When the people were summoned to consult or determine about affairs relating to the commonwealth, the meeting, as we have remarked, was termed Ecclesia. But when they were invited to any solemn spectacle, as in the Panathenea, the assembly was then styled Panegyris; and a speech delivered at such a time was termed a panegyrical oration.1314 An assembly of believers, therefore, may be called Ecclesia, because they meet to consider the matters which pertain to the kingdom of God, that is, spiritual and heavenly things; they may be denominated Panegyris, as they are invited and admitted to by far the greatest of all spectacles; namely, that of the Divine perfections shining forth in Christ,—a sight which even celestial spirits contemplate for ever without satiety.

VI. Let what has been said suffice at present for an explanation of the terms. We now proceed to the thing itself. The Church may be defined, A Society of believing and holy men, called by God out of the world of mankind by the word of the Gospel, to a participation of the blessings of the covenant of grace which stands fast in Christ. That this definition contains nothing superfluous, will appear from an explication of the several expressions. When we call the Church a Society, we show that it is a multitude; “We being many,” &c.15—but a multitude of persons united together, “We being many, are one body.” “The body is not one member, but many:”16 “And the Church is the body of Christ.”17 We confine this community to men. Angels are indeed our “fellow-servants,”18 having the same Lord with us, and are sons of the same family,19 and sharers of the same felicity, which consists in fellowship with God; and hence it is said, “ye are come to an innumerable company of angels.”20 It is, however, quite in a different way, and by a different title, that angels are what they are. They are not redeemed by Christ, nor called by the Gospel, nor regenerated by the Spirit, nor partakers of the covenant of grace. These are the high privileges, and distinguishing characteristics of the Church; “For verily he took not on him the nature of angels, but he took on him the seed of Abraham.”21 We add, that it is a society of believing men, that is, of men who receive the doctrine of the Gospel, and recognise it as true. “Then they that gladly received his word, were baptized,” and added to the church.22 “Whose house are we, if we hold fast the confidence, and the rejoicing of the hope firm unto the end.”23 And we call it a society of holy men; “An holy nation;”24 “Called to be saints.”25 They are gathered together by God, who is therefore styled “he that calleth;”26 as they themselves are “the Church of “the living God.”27 This gathering is effected by the word of the Gospel; for although God in some respect invites men to himself by the works of nature,28 no invitation of that sort is sufficient for constituting the Church; but the word of supernatural revelation must be added. “For after that, in the wisdom of God, the world by wisdom knew not God, it pleased God, by the foolishness of preaching, to save them that believe.”29 The preaching employed for this purpose, is partly that of the Law, that the minds of men may be rightly prepared: “For Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth.”30 But the preaching of the Gospel is chiefly made use of: “This only would I learn of you, Received ye the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?”31 The invitation given by the Gospel is termed our Calling: “Them he also called.”32 Hence, too, the frequent designation of “the called,” and the very word Ecclesia, the Church. This form of expression seems, however, to be taken from Prov. viii. 1. “Doth not wisdom cry? and understanding put forth her voice?” &c. and from similar passages which elsewhere occur. This is a calling of persons out of the world of mankind; from which God first called the Israelites,33 and afterwards the Gentiles, according to Isaiah: “Behold, thou shalt call a nation that thou knowest not.”34 The end of the calling, in fine, is a participation of the blessings of the covenant of grace, which stands fast in Christ; which are thus figuratively ly described; “Whoso is simple, let him turn in hither; - - - Come, eat of my bread, and drink of the wine which I have mingled.”35

VII. But it ought to be carefully observed, that the form, or, if you please, the state and condition of the Church, is twofold; the one internal and spiritual, according to which God only judges with certainty concerning her members;—the other, external and more visible, which even men are empowered to discern.

VIII. There is, accordingly, a twofold calling; the one external, merely by the word, “For many be called, but few chosen;”36—the other internal, by the Spirit, which is peculiar to the elect.37

IX. In correspondence to this twofold calling, there is a twofold Faith. The one is a common faith, which may be found even in reprobates, and by which they assent to evangelical truth, and feel a kind of transitory joy, arising partly from the novelty and extraordinary nature of the subject, partly from that presumptuous hope by which they boldly arrogate to themselves, the blessings of the Gospel, while they have no interest in them. “Then Simon himself believed also.”38 The other is a saving faith, “the faith of God’s elect,”39 “faith unfeigned,”40 “faith which worketh by love.”41

X. There is also a twofold Holiness. The one is merely relative, external, federal; and consists in a person’s being separated from the fellowship of the impure and profane world, numbered amongst the people of God, and having access to many promises. Thus the Israelites are called, “the holy seed, who have mingled themselves with the people of these lands, the people of the earth.”42 In the same sense Paul says; “For if the first fruit be holy, the lump is also holy; and if the root be holy, so are the branches;”43 that is, If the fathers were in covenant with God, their posterity are also to be regarded as in the same condition. Holiness of this sort is recognised, too, under the New Testament; for the whole body of Christians is opposed as holy to the heathen as unholy;44 and the unbelieving husband is said to be sanctified by the believing wife, and the unbelieving wife to be sanctified by the believing husband,45 so that the children of such a marriage are accounted holy, children of the covenant and heirs of the promises. But the other kind of holiness is internal, and absolute, peculiar to the regenerate, consisting in conformity to God, and the image of the divine purity. “Holiness becometh thine house, O Lord, for ever.”46

XI. In like manner, the participation of the covenant of grace is twofold. The one includes merely symbolical and common privileges, which have no certain connection with salvation, and to which infants are admitted by their relation to parents that are within the covenant;47 and adults, by a profession of faith and repentance, even though insincere. As all who make a profession of Christianity, and do not falsify it by a wicked life, do by this their profession enter into the covenant, the oath, and the curse, so they cannot be kept back from a participation of the sacraments by the rulers of the Church. And thus far they are really in covenant with God, and, in a certain sense, even branches ingrafted into Christ, although they do not bring forth fruit nor abide in him;48 who shall be punished not merely for the transgression of the precept, but also for the violation of the covenant, if they be found to lead a wicked life. The other participation of the covenant of grace, is the partaking of its internal, spiritual, and saving blessings, as the forgiveness of sins, the writing of the law in the heart, &c.49 Accordingly the Apostle makes a distinction betwixt the Jew outwardly and the Jew inwardly,—betwixt circumcision in the flesh and the letter, and circumcision in the heart and spirit;50 which, by analogy, may be transferred to Christianity.

XII. From all these remarks it follows, that the Church has a twofold aspect or form; the one visible, which is made out by a profession of faith and the performance of divine worship; the other spiritual, which owes its first origin to Divine election, and is completed by a living faith and true holiness. This distinction is suggested by John: “They went out from us,” that is, from the external community of those who profess Christianity in common with us; “but they were not of us,” they did not belong to the society of the elect and of true believers.51

XIII. If you look to the Church in its internal form, none but the elect belong to it; “Ye are a chosen generation:”52—Those who are inwardly and effectually called; “Holy brethren, partakers of the heavenly calling:”53—Those endowed with a true and living faith, and sanctified by the Spirit of God; “God hath from “the beginning chosen you to salvation, through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the truth:”54—Those, in fine, who enjoy spiritual communion with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ; “God is faithful, by whom ye were called unto the fellowship of his Son Jesus Christ our Lord;”55 “That ye also may have fellowship with us; and truly our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ.”56

XIV. The government of the Church, viewed in this form, belongs only to God in Christ: for he only has authority and power over the minds and consciences of men, and he only can admit whom he will to a participation of saving benefits. He alone, too, searches the heart, and has a certain knowledge of all the true members of the Church. “The Lord knoweth them that are his.”57 Such, however, is the nature of true faith and holiness, that they evidence themselves to men by their fruits, so far as is sufficient to justify a judgment of charity regarding our neighbour.58

XV. But if you consider the external form of the Church, God has appointed Stewards over it, who are intrusted with the dispensation of external privileges according to established rules.59 And really, none has a right even to these privileges, who is not renewed and sanctified; for they are the signs and seals of spiritual grace, which belongs to believers only, and are consequently profaned by unbelievers who venture to receive them. It is incumbent on the Stewards to give serious and faithful warning of this, to all, and to every individual, lest by rash and unhallowed approaches, they procure judgments to themselves. But since it is not their prerogative to know the heart, they are bound to demand a profession of faith and repentance from all who make application for communion with the Church; and if any make this profession with the tongue, and do not openly belie it by his practice, the office-bearers, so far as themselves are concerned, may safely admit him, without too scrupulous an inquiry into his spiritual state; the certain knowledge of which we read that God has reserved to himself, whilst it is nowhere affirmed that God requires it of the ministers of the Church.60 In primitive times indeed, Apostles and Evangelists were endowed with an extraordinary gift, which Paul styles “the discerning of spirits.”61 But it does not appear that, in admitting the members of the Church, they made use of that gift, to distinguish those who were truly regenerate from such as by their profession and external conduct made false pretensions to regeneration. Had they done this, how could Simon Magus have been admitted to the Church?62 And whence those scandalous persons at Corinth, whom the Apostle reproves?63

XVI. Since, then, it is impossible but that amidst so great a multitude of professors, some will falsely pretend to the Christian character, hypocrites and worthless men are never wanting in the visible Church. On this account the Church is compared to a floor, in which there is not only wheat, but also chaff;64—to a field, where tares as well as good seed, are sown;65—to a net, which gathers bad fish together with the good;66—to a great house, in which are vessels of every kind, “some to honour, and some to dishonour.”67

XVII. Let us now attend to the Epithets and honourable characters given to the Church; which are suitable to it in both forms, yet principally in its internal form. Three of these are mentioned in the Creed: Holy, Catholic, Christian.68

XVIII. The Church may be called Holy, 1st, With respect to doctrine; which, in soundness of principles, purity of precepts, excellence of examples, and efficacy of motives, infinitely surpasses whatever is commendable in all the admired institutions and maxims of lawgivers, or priests, or philosophers.69 2dly, With respect to life and manners. The Old Testament Church was distinguished by a certain typical holiness, which consisted in the separation of the people of Israel from the rest of the nations, that they might be consecrated to the worship of God, and in a certain external and corporeal purification, by which they were, so to speak, purged and sanctified.70 Corresponding to this, there is in the Gospel Church a real holiness, which consists in separation from the common condition of sinners to the performance of that spiritual Divine service which the New Testament prescribes,71 and in the purification of the mind by the blood and Spirit of Jesus Christ.72 The Christian Church, therefore, is called Holy, in contradistinction not merely to other nations, which were altogether impure and defiled;73 but also to the Jewish nation, to whose typical sanctity a true and substantial holiness is opposed.74 3dly, With respect to inviolability, or the sacred protection under which it is placed. “He suffered no man to do them wrong: yea, he reproved kings for their sakes, saying, Touch not mine anointed, and do my prophets no harm.”75

XIX. The epithet Catholic does not occur in sacred writ. The first whom we find using it is Ignatius in his Epistle to the Church of Smyrna, if indeed that expression was in reality written by Ignatius, and not interpolated by some unfair hand: “Wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.”76 But it occurs also in the Epistle of the Church of Smyrna, in which they give an account of the martyrdom of Polycarp, their Pastor; for that Epistle is inscribed to the Church of God at Philomelium, “and to all every where that belong to the holy Catholic Church.”77

XX. The appellation Catholic is taken in several senses. 1st, Very extensively, as comprehending all the diversities of places, times, persons, and states, and as denoting the whole family of God, whether now or formerly sojourning on the earth, and dispersed through all ages and quarters of the world. 2dly, More strictly, when it is ascribed to the New Testament Church in contradistinction to the Old. The middle wall of partition being broken down, the Gospel Church is not confined, as was the Church of old, to any place or people; but is scattered abroad throughout the whole extent of the world; and is the common Mother of men of all nations, nourishing all with the same milk, and cherishing all in the same bosom; making the whole world, so to speak, a common temple unto God. “She is called Catholic,” says Cyril of Jerusalem, “because she is diffused over the whole world from the one end of the earth to the other.”78 It was worth while also, by this characteristic, to distinguish the Christian Church from the Synagogue, in order to show that by the coming of Christ the truth of the ancient prophecies appears, in which it had been very often foretold that all nations without distinction should be invited to fellowship with God. This epithet, however, it is evident, has prevailed chiefly, since the Novatians, and afterwards the Donatists, presumed to restrict the Church to the narrow limits of Africa.79 To those men, the Orthodox then opposed the appellation Catholic, to distinguish the Church of Christ which subsisted in the whole world, from the conventicles of heretics and schismatics. 3dly, This appellation is used improperly, to denote a particular Church, which holds fellowship with the Church Universal, and is not separated from it by heresy or schism. Nay, it became customary to employ the term Catholic in the same sense with Orthodox. Hence we read in ancient writers, of “the Catholic Church in Smyrna, in Alexandria, in Constantinople, in Nazianzum,” and the like, without number.

XXI. In fine, the Church is also styled Christian, because she is the disciple of Christ,80 and Christ is her Master;81—because she is the Spouse of Christ, and Christ is her Bridegroom;82—because she is the body and the fulness of Christ, being necessary to the perfecting of his stature,83 and Christ is her Head.84 In short, she is so closely united with Christ, that she is even denominated Christ.85

XXII. It now remains, to consider the exercise of our Faith in relation to the Church. And here we must first attend to the repetition in the Creed of the expression Credo, “I believe;” and then to the alteration of the phrase: For whereas it was formerly said, “I believe in God the Father, &c.” “I believe in the Holy Ghost”—it is not here said in like manner, Credo in Ecclesiam, “I believe in the Church,” but Credo Ecclesiam, “I believe the Church.” The expression I believe, seems to be repeated of purpose, partly, to apprize us that we are entering on a new class of subjects, which differ widely from those previously mentioned; and partly, because, without that repetition, the construction of the words would render the sentence either obscure, or scarcely consistent with piety. Had the words run thus, “I believe in the Holy Ghost, the Holy Catholic Church,”86 it would have been difficult to connect the words “I believe” with “the Holy Catholic Church,” so as to suppress the particle in. This however was necessary; for our faith is exercised with regard to the Church in a manner very different from that in which it is exercised with relation to God. The Church, it is certain, is a society of creatures, in whom, whether considered individually or collectively, it is criminal to repose the confidence of faith.87

XXIII. When we affirm, therefore, that we believe the Church, we profess, that there has existed from the beginning of time, still exists, and will continue to the end of the world to exist, a society of men chosen by God to salvation, called by the Gospel and the Spirit, professing faith and piety with the mouth, and practising them in the conduct. We declare, also, that neither the machinations of the world that lieth in wickedness, nor the gates of hell, shall ever prevail against this society: For it is utterly impossible that the decree of God should fail;88—that the promises of God should come to nought;89—that the word of salvation should be preached in vain;90—that the prophecies respecting the perpetuity of Christ’s kingdom should fall to the ground;91—or that Christ should lose the reward of his labour,92 and become a Master without disciples, a King without subjects, a Bridegroom without a bride, a Head without a body.

XXIV. Nor is it sufficient to believe and profess this in general. We must endeavour, in our meditations, to enter more deeply into the subject, that we may adore with reverence, and with a sort of holy amazement, the methods of God’s procedure in the government of the Church, and the displays which it affords of his perfections. From eternity he delineated in his own mind the whole state and condition of the Church, —wisely fixing her diversified fortunes in the different periods of time;—dispensing the word of his grace at sundry times and in diverse manners;—treating her at first more liberally in the families of the Patriarchs, then more strictly in the nation of Israel, and at length giving her ample liberty in an acceptable time and a year of grace;—sometimes chastising her with the rod of fatherly correction, at other times delighting her with a happy abundance of peace;—now adorning her with the flowers of a grateful spring, anon afflicting her with the wasting severity of the storms of winter. He has peculiarly exhibited his adorable wisdom in the New Testament Church; which he rescued from the yoke of the ancient ceremonies, and extended amongst the nations on every side; and to which, after she had nobly struggled first with the pertinacity of the Jews, and then with the ferocity of the Heathen, and with the wiles and artifices of Heretics, he gave the dominion of the world under Constantine the Emperor. From that period the connexion of the Beast with the Church commenced, Antichrist began gradually to prevail, and the people of God were led captive to Babylon; until by means of the blessed Reformation, the Church was indulged with more auspicious times;—hitherto indeed interrupted, and still to be interrupted, by intervals of declension,—but to issue in the happy conversion of the Jews, and in all the glories reserved for the Church in latter days, till, whilst religion is again declining, the Judge shall appear from heaven, and bring all things to their consummation. These varied scenes, which are often predicted in the prophetic books of Scripture, and accurately detailed in the sacred Revelation of John, but now in a great measure fulfilled in the events themselves, are presented to believers as the subject of pious meditation, for the glory of God, the confirmation of faith, and the exercise of hope. “The righteous shall see it, and rejoice; and all iniquity shall stop her mouth. Whoso is wise, and will observe these things, even they shall understand the loving-kindness of the Lord.”93 Nay, these are matters in which, “unto the principalities and powers in heavenly places, is made known by the Church, the manifold wisdom of God; according to the eternal purpose, which he purposed in Christ Jesus, our Lord.”94

XXV. But even this is not all that is necessary. We must also cultivate fellowship with the Church of Christ, by associating with her in the hearing of the word, in public prayer, in songs of praise to God, in the profession of the faith, and in the participation of the same bread and wine at the Lord’s table. We ought not merely to run, but even to “fly” together “as doves to their windows;”95 that in us, too, those prophecies may be accomplished, which describe in terms so magnificent, the joyful flowing together of the nations to the Church.96 “Behold, how good, and how pleasant it is for brethren to dwell together in unity! &c.”97

XXVI. Nor should we be deterred from this communion by some faults which may possibly be committed in the government of the Church, or by the sins of others, who do not duly regulate their practice according to the commandments. If only the truth of the Doctrine continue uncorrupted, if we are not obliged to approve of those faults, and if we are careful to have no fellowship with others in their sins, it becomes us to discover so much reverence for the institutions of God, and so much love for the faithful who belong to that society, as cheerfully and frequently to unite with them in the social exercises of religious worship; “Not forsaking the assembling of ourselves together, as the manner of some is, but exhorting one another.”98 In vain do we expect to see on the earth a Church without spot, a thrashing-floor without chaff, a field without tares, or a house in which are none but vessels unto honour. Nor let us imagine that we are to please God by any presumptuous conceit of our own sanctity, joined with contempt of others.—“Which say, Stand by thyself, come not near to me, for I am holier than thou. These are a smoke in my nose, a fire that burneth all the day.”99

XXVII. It is necessary, however, to take heed, that we associate only with a true Church, lest we embrace a prostitute and an adulteress instead of the chaste Spouse of Christ. Amidst so great a multitude of societies, which vie with each other in claiming to themselves the name of the Church, it appears an arduous task for a man concerned for the salvation of his soul, to determine which of them ought to be preferred. But there is in particular one characteristic, by which, without great difficulty, you may discriminate the true Church of Christ from an adulteress, to wit, the truth of the heavenly doctrine. If a society devoutly profess the truth, as it was delivered by Christ, and by the Prophets and Apostles, you may safely recognise it as a Church of Christ. For what is the Church but “the pillar and the ground of truth?”100 “Built upon the foundation of the Apostles and Prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner-stone, &c.”101

XXVIII. Such, too, is the nature of the heavenly doctrine, that it readily approves itself to the conscience. It is entirely and directly calculated to refer all things to the glory of God;102—powerfully to repress the arrogance of the human mind;103—sweetly to console the afflicted spirit in times of adversity and sorrow;104—and strongly to enforce the practice of the purest holiness.105 Whoever has considered these criteria of the truth, will easily perceive that, with regard to doctrine, what is usually called the Reformed Church holds a conspicuous place amongst others professing the Christian name. With that Church it is an object of the greatest solicitude, that God be recognised as the author and giver of whatever is good, as well in man as in every other creature;—that man, conscious of his nothingness,106 and divested of all confidence in his own powers and in his own merits, depend wholly on Divine grace; that trusting in no creature, but in the all-sufficiency of God in Christ, he may have a sure foundation of comfort under every perplexity;—that, in fine, stimulated by the amazing kindness of God towards man, and by the unmerited love of Christ, he may apply himself to the practice of an ingenuous holiness, which lays aside the mercenary baseness of self-love, and is habitually influenced by pure love to God, and an unfeigned concern to promote his glory. In all these spects, they who belong not to the society of the Reformed Church, are universally found exceedingly deficient.

XXIX. Nor should we suffer ourselves to be intimidated by the importunate clamours of the Romanists, who demand where that Reformed Church of our’s was before the appearance of Luther or Calvin. This puerile question is easily answered, and requires no tedious discussion. On both sides, surely, it is admitted, that there has always been a true Church of Christ: nor will the Romanists themselves affect to deny, that a Society which sincerely and stedfastly maintains all the doctrines delivered by Christ, and by the Prophets and Apostles, must be owned to be a true Church of Christ. Now that this is done by our Church, has been long since evinced in detail from the Scriptures. If the Romanists assert the contrary, let them point out a single article in which we deviate from the pole-star of Sacred writ. This is the surest, and the most compendious method. Let the pious inquirer be directed to prove all things by the touchstone of Scripture, and not to search the unwieldy volumes of those whom they style Fathers, and all the recesses of an obscure antiquity; the investigation of which has long since worn out the patience and baffled the ingenuity of men of even the most profound erudition.

XXX. Let it not be supposed, however, that we decline this ordeal. We are prepared to show, that in all ages not only learned men, but also whole communities, have professed the same truths with ourselves. 1st, The four first Centuries are in our favour. Jewel, Perkins, Raynolds, Mornay, Moulin, Rivet, Aubertin, Daillé, Blondel, Claude, and others, have demonstrated, by incontrovertible evidence, that the Justins, the Clements, the Ambroses, the Augustines, the Jeromes, the Chrysostomes, and all the Fathers of those ages, hold, in every thing essential, the same sentiments with us. 2dly, After the Papacy began to lift up its head, and the Church to degenerate gradually, there were some who, both by their discourses and writings, protested against the prevailing errors, and boldly defended sound doctrine. Lists of these have been compiled, by Flaccius Illyricus, the Ministers of Magdeburg,107 Mornay,108 Usher of Armagh,109 and others. 3dly, In the valleys of the Alps, a whole nation remained unpolluted by the devices of Antichrist, the hope and the seed of a better Church. 4thly, Where our Churches were, is asked with a bad grace, by men who so cruelly persecuted them in the Waldenses, the Leonists, and the Bohemian Brethren; and, with horrid barbarity, butchered so many myriads of holy martyrs, precious in the sight of God.110 5thly, We might advert, in fine, to the very numerous Churches in the East, who not only detested the arrogant pretensions and supercilious conduct of the Bishop of Rome, but also combated his many errors.

XXXI. But even though we may have found a true Church with which we can associate in profession and worship, the business is not yet completed. External communion with an approved Church, is not enough to sustain a solid hope of salvation. In vain do proud boasters exclaim, “The temple of the Lord, the temple of the Lord are these.”111 We must see that we belong to the internal and spiritual Church of Christ, and that, united to her by the secret bonds of the Holy Spirit and a living faith, we be assured in our own mind of that union. For this purpose we should examine the marks of election, the efficacy of the inward calling, the life of faith, the nature of Christian holiness, the evidences of Christ himself dwelling in the heart, and whatever other characteristics serve to distinguish the spiritual Church. These we have stated at some length in their proper places, particularly, in the Treatise on the Economy of the Covenants.

XXXII. Let but a few of them be observed here. 1st, In the mystical Church of Christ, not merely the external voice of the Gospel is heard, but also the internal voice of the Spirit; which not only strikes the ear, but reaches the heart, and bends it to the obedience of faith. On this account, they are called “the epistle of Christ, written not with ink, but with the Spirit of the living God; not in tables of stone, but in fleshly tables of the heart.”112 Here, too, not merely are the seals of the Covenant of grace distributed, but the grace of God itself, in which the life of the soul consists, is exhibited, tasted, and enjoyed: “If so be ye have tasted that the Lord is gracious.”113 Here flow those admirable waters of the Spirit, which gradually increase, till they form a river that cannot be forded; and which, while they are constantly running, heal other waters that they touch, and give life and vigour to a vast multitude of fishes.114 A right, or access, to this grace, is not obtained by a mere verbal profession before men, but by that which the Apostle requires when he speaks of “a professed subjection to the Gospel of Christ.”115116

XXXIII. 2dly, The spiritual Church of Christ is truly holy,117 and surpasses other societies of men, and even nominal professors, in unblemished purity of conduct, as far as the temple of Jerusalem surpassed the ordinary houses of the citizens in splendour and magnificence of workmanship. No one, therefore, can justly consider himself a member of this Church, who doth not possess in his heart, and discover in his behaviour, the superior excellence of the Christian character.118

XXXIV. 3dly, This Church is far more glorious within than without; just like the tabernacle erected by Moses, which was covered without, with rams skins, and badgers skins; whilst within it was adorned with fine linen, purple, gold, and jewels.119 Our Lord aptly compares hypocrites to “whited sepulchres, which indeed appear beautiful outward, but are within full of dead men’s bones, and of all uncleanness.”120 The Spouse, on the contrary, is said to be “like the tents of Kedar,” whose appearance was mean; but also “like the curtains of Solomon,” in which the elegance of the workmanship vied with the extraordinary magnificence of the materials.121 The one expression refers to her external appearance, the other to her internal beauty.122 And truly “the King’s daughter is all glorious within;” and her adorning consists “in the hidden man of the heart, in that which is not corruptible, even “the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which is in the sight of God of great price.”123

XXXV. 4thly, Here the praises of God resound, and all things are referred to his glory. “In his temple doth every one speak of his glory.”124 “This people have I formed for myself; they shall show forth my praise.”125 Here then let every one investigate his own character, and if he find in himself the characters which have now been mentioned, he may conclude that he is a member of that Church, which is the Spouse of Christ, and the partaker of his blessings.

XXXVI. The sacred volume abounds with eulogies on the inexpressible felicity of the mystical Church. “Glorious things are spoken of thee, O city of God.”126 1st, This is a society of men, which God chose before the foundation of the world, by an immutable decree of which he will never repent, that he might be glorified and admired in them;127 and into whose mouth he puts this unspeakably delightful song: “Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who hath blessed us with all spiritual blessings in heavenly places in Christ; according as he hath chosen us in him, &c.”128 2dly, A society which, the Son of God, by undertaking the character of her Surety, has betrothed to himself, and to which he has betrothed himself; and which he has purchased at the expense of his own precious blood,—“having obtained eternal redemption.”129 This again is the subject of a new song.130 3dly, A society which he has called by his word and Spirit to his kingdom and glory.131 4thly, A society in the midst of which he dwells, by an inhabitation far more excellent, far more lasting, than that by which he dwelt of old in the temple of Jerusalem. “An habitation of God through the Spirit.”132 “Ye are the temple of the living God, as God hath said, I will dwell in them, and walk in them.”133 5thly, A society which he crowns with every blessing, and endows with the richest gifts of his Spirit. “I will abundantly bless her provision; I will satisfy her poor with bread; I will also clothe her priests with salvation, and her saints shall shout aloud for joy.”134 “Therefore they shall come and sing in the height of Zion, and shall flow together to the goodness of the Lord, for wheat, and for wine, and for oil, and for the young of the flock and of the herd; and their soul shall be as a watered garden, &c.”135 “And it shall come to pass in that day, that the mountains shall drop down new wine, and the hills shall flow with milk, and all the rivers of Judah shall flow with waters, and a fountain shall come forth of the house of the Lord, and shall water the valley of Shittim.”136 6thly, A society for which he bears so affectionate and tender a regard, that he prescribes no bounds or measures to himself in proclaiming her praises: “Thou hast ravished my heart, my sister, my spouse; thou hast ravished my heart with one of thine eyes, with one chain of thy neck. How fair is thy love, my sister, my spouse, &c.”137 And why do I select a part of this divine song, when the whole is to the same effect? 7thly, A society which he protects with so solicitous a care, that she is secure against the assaults of earth and hell, and amidst all adversities is more than a conqueror.138 8thly, A society which he will at last deliver from the tyranny of Antichrist, enlarge by the accession of the Jews and multitudes of the Gentiles, and render glorious by signal improvements in wisdom, holiness, consolation, and spiritual excellence of every kind. This is often promised in the prophecies of Scripture, and very expressly and copiously in the sixtieth Chapter of Isaiah, which relates entirely to the glorious state of the Church after the restoration of Israel to it, of which he had spoken in the Chapter immediately preceding.139 9thly, A society, in fine, which, after having discharged from all her contests on the earth, and rescued from the jaws of the grave, in which the bodies of the greater part had been detained, he will bless with everlasting felicity in heaven. “In Christ shall all be made alive. But every man in his own order, Christ the first-fruits; afterwards, they that are Christ’s, at his coming. Then cometh the end, when he shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father, &c.”140

XXXVII. Whilst all these privileges pertain to the whole body of the Church, every member of the mystical body individually, is blessed with a share of them, according to his own proportion. And since all believers are very intimately connected together by the bond of mutual love, each will regard what is given to the whole society, as conferred upon himself. Who that considers these things would not exclaim; “Blessed is the man whom thou choosest, and causest to approach unto thee, that he may dwell in thy courts; we shall be satisfied with the goodness of thy house, even of thy holy temple. By terrible things in righteousness, wilt thou answer us, O God of our salvation, who art the confidence of all the ends of the earth, and of them that are afar off upon the sea.”141

XXXVIII. But further, that faith which respects the Holy Church of Christ, requires and infers the offices of Charity towards her. How can we, without crime, be void of love to a society of men, who are the care of Angels, and the delight of Heaven? 1st, Let us beware, therefore, lest in any instance we ever injure the Church; all the injuries done to which, the Lord will avenge as done to himself; Acts ix. 4, 5. Who that ever engaged in any enterprize against her, has not had the worst possible success? “And in that day will I make Jerusalem a burdensome stone for all people; all that burden themselves with it, shall be cut in pieces, though all the people of the earth be gathered together against it.”142 On this subject instruction may be received from the ignominious and dreadful exits of Pharaoh, Sennacherib, Haman, Herod, and others without number, both in ancient and modern times. 2dly, Let us diligently inquire into the fortunes of the Church as detailed in the prophecies of Scripture, that, by a kind of holy ingenuity of faith, we may gather from the contests with which she has been already exercised, what she has further to fear or to hope for:—adoring on every occasion, the admirable ways of the Lord. “Blessed is he that readeth, and they that hear the words of this prophecy.”143 3dly, Let us tenderly sympathize with the Church in her adversities.144 4thly, Let us rejoice in her prosperity, congratulating her in affectionate terms; “The Lord bless thee, O habitation of justice, and mountain of holiness.”145—“That I may see the good of thy chosen, that I may rejoice in the gladness of thy nation, that I may glory with thine inheritance.”146 5thly, Let us promote the edification of the Church by all the means in our power, by discourses, by labours, by prayers. “For Zion’s sake will I not hold my peace, and for Jerusalem’s sake will I not rest, until the righteousness thereof go forth as brightness, and the salvation thereof as a lamp that burneth.”147 “For my brethren and companions’ sakes, I will now say, Peace be within thee; because of the house of the Lord our God, I will seek thy good.”148

XXXIX. This is a duty which all of every rank and condition are bound to perform. Let the princes of this world devote entirely to the enlargement of Christ’s kingdom, that sceptre, and that dignity, which they have received from Christ. “Kings shall be thy nursing-fathers, and their queens thy nursing-mothers.”149 Let rulers of Churches esteem it the sole business committed to them, to exert their abilities with unwearied diligence in promoting the interests of the Church. “I have set watchmen upon thy walls, O Jerusalem, which shall never hold their peace day nor night: ye that make mention of the Lord, keep not silence.”150 Let believers of the common people remember, that it is incumbent on them also, by holy conferences on religion, and by the example of an irreproachable life, to allure to the fellowship of the Church, and to confirm in her communion, first of all, their domestics; then their neighbours; and in fine, all of every description with whom they have intercourse. “Wherefore, comfort yourselves together, and edify one another, even as also ye do,” &c.151 And here I include even our wives,152 and our daughters, whom it no less becomes to lend their assistance in building the walls of the spiritual Jerusalem, than it became the daughters of Shallum of old to repair the walls of the earthly Jerusalem.153 And who is there, in short, that is not under indispensable obligations to offer up daily prayers on behalf of the Church? “Thy kingdom come.” “Do good in thy good pleasure unto Zion; build thou the walls of Jerusalem.”154 “Oh! that the salvation of Israel were come out of Zion! When the Lord bringeth back the captivity of his people, Jacob shall rejoice, and Israel shall be glad.”155

XL. The article in the Creed immediately following, namely, that of the Communion of Saints, is so closely connected with the one relating to the Holy Catholic Church, that it appears to be nearly the same. For what is the Church but a Society? What is a Society, but the union of persons possessing some privilege in common? Who are they, besides, that compose the Church, excepting the Saints? What is the Catholic Church, in fine, but the association of Gentiles with Jews in the paths of holiness? Hence also this additional article of the Communion of Saints, is not found in many of the ancient copies of the Creed. It is not in Jerome against the Luciferians,156 nor in Augustine on Faith and the Creed, nor in Rufinus, nor in Maximus of Turin; and many others, both in the East and West, have purposely omitted it. Yet as it is now received amongst all Christians, and as it expresses more explicitly some ideas which are rather implied in the article respecting the Church, we shall now briefly treat of it. Let us show, First, Whom we are here to understand by Saints. Secondly, In what the Communion of Saints consists. Thirdly, What is implied in believing the Communion of Saints.157

XLI. God is eminently, originally, and exemplarily Holy;158 for he is infinitely removed from all that is vile and impure. Rational creatures that are conformed to God’s image in purity, that is, who resemble him in the love and practice of truth, are also called holy. This honourable epithet, accordingly, is ascribed to Angels. We read of the “holy Angels;”159 and they are termed absolutely “Saints,” or “holy ones.”160 But it is attributed, likewise, to men, whether they still remain on earth, or have been received into heaven and crowned with perfection and glory. The Psalmist speaks of “the saints that are in the earth, and the excellent;”161 and the Apostle, of “the spirits of just men made perfect.”162

XLII. Communion is a certain relation subsisting between several persons, who by an undoubted title are in possession of the same privileges. Thus, there is a communion betwixt husband and wife, of persons as well as goods, by an equal right on each side, according to the rule, Ubi tu Caius, ego Caia.163 And truly it cannot be denied that there is a certain communion betwixt all that are called Holy. Believers have undoubtedly communion with God and Christ, as we have lately remarked from Scripture;164 for they are God’s portion, and at the same time have God for their portion,165 and consequently, whatever belongs to God, belongs also to believers.166 And Christ not only shares his good things with them,167 but took their evil things upon himself.168 There is also a communion of holy men with Angels, who cheerfully perform their ministrations for us,169 and are our patterns of piety towards God,170 our fellow-servants in obedience to the same Lord,171 and our associates in the same felicity.172 Hence Paul represents believers who are still on the earth, as having “come to an innumerable company of angels.”173 But what is chiefly intended in the Creed, is the communion which holy men have with one another.

XLIII. This again may be considered in three different views. 1st, As the Saints in heaven hold fellowship with one another. 2dly, The Saints that are on earth, with the blessed in heaven. 3dly, The Saints on earth, with each other. That those parts of the Church which are in heaven, are joined together by a mutual communion, which is even more intimate than the fellowship betwixt them and the blessed Angels, no one, I suppose, entertains a doubt. They are at once members of the same mystical body, and enjoy the same glory and felicity, whilst they behold the face of the same God, are blessed through the merit of the same Redeemer, join with perfect harmony in the same songs of praise to God, and love one another with the most ardent affection. But since the Scripture says very little on this subject, and since the Creed contains principally such articles as are both most certain and most necessary, and appears to have been intended for the use of Catechumens, who, when about to be admitted to baptism, were examined concerning the faith,—it is not likely that the compilers of the Creed, in framing this article, had much in their view, that communion which the spirits of the faithful have with one another in heaven.

XLIV. The Scripture more expressly teaches the communion of saints on earth with the blessed spirits above. Paul at least makes mention of “the gathering together in one of all things in Christ, both which are in heaven, and which are on earth.”174 The original expression signifies the gathering together into one sum, as in computation, all the particulars are united and mixed together in one complete sum. It is said to be the gathering together “of all things,” not surely of all creatures, or even of all mankind, but of all believers,—of all that are in Christ. “Both which are in heaven, and which are on earth:” for those in heaven are very closely joined to one another, and bound together “in the bundle of life,” of the living,175 much more than when they were in the body; and those that are on earth, are associated with the blessed in heaven. “Ye are come,” says Paul, “unto mount Zion, - - to the general assembly and church of the first-born which are written in heaven, - - and to the spirits of just men made perfect.”176 Now this communion consists in the following things. 1st, That having one God and one Saviour, and animated by the same Spirit, they constitute one body, whose parts are indeed widely separated from each other with regard to distance of local situation, but maintained in close mutual connexion by the same Spirit of Christ. 2dly, That the souls of the blessed, although they be entirely ignorant of the particular persons of believers on earth, and of their necessities,177 yet by their earnest prayers unite with us in soliciting, and, so to speak, accelerating, the day of the complete redemption of the Church;178 whilst the saints on earth are associated with those in heaven, in spirit, affection, and desire, having their conversation in heaven.179

XLV. But we are chiefly to attend to the communion which believers have with each other on the earth. This includes three heads. 1st, That intimate union, by which, how far removed soever as to place, they are mutually joined together by the Spirit; not merely as brethren, but, what we have already often inculcated, as members of one mystical body.180 2dly, Their enjoyment in common, of the most invaluable blessings. “There is one body, one Spirit, even as ye are called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all.”181 3dly, The reciprocation of offices of kindness, which they perform to one another. This may be viewed as consisting of three parts. 1. Sympathy in evil things:182 by which every one condoles with his neighbour in afflictive evils, and hastens to his relief, no less than if himself were visited with the same adversities;183—and in moral evils, far from treating a fallen brother with cruelty, every one endeavours to restore him in the spirit of meekness.184 2. The communication of good things;185 as well temporal,186 as spiritual.187 We have a mutual dependance on each other; which the Apostle nobly urges and illustrates.188 3. The devout offering up of prayers for one another, as to those matters in which it is not in our power to avert evil from our brethren, or to confer on them what is good.189

XLVI. That Faith which we profess regarding the communion of Saints, implies principally the three following particulars. 1st, That we recognise and celebrate the admirable power of our God, which unites believers of every nation, age, condition and sex, often separated from one another by such vast intervening spaces of land and sea, of such dissimilar capacities and tempers, and engaged in such diversified pursuits; and so closely conjoins them by one Spirit, that they most harmoniously concur in the same sentiments and feelings respecting God and Christ, and in the same devout prayers and praises, and discern in each other, with mutual congratulation and applause, the same effects of the same Divine grace; so that, even at their first meeting, a most delightful interchange of love often arises.

XLVII. 2dly, That we regulate our life and conduct in a manner becoming the communion of Saints. 1. That we promote, as far as possible, the unity of the Church, and carefully take heed, not to disturb the peace of this sacred society by unnecessary controversies, hot disputations, ambitious projects, or perverse passions of any kind; but, making many allowances for human infirmity, and for those imperfections under which we all labour,—to cultivate assiduously that harmony which Christ so earnestly inculcates upon us, and promote it to the utmost of our power, by fervent prayers, and by a Christian moderation of spirit.190 2. That we edify one another by the communication of spiritual gifts. This is the duty not merely of Pastors, but of believers of every class. This includes, administering reproof to an offending brother;191 which, when guided by prudence, and dictated by love, obtains, in the issue, greater favour than the fulsome compliments of flattering lips:192—The instruction of the ignorant:193—Mutual excitement to pious zeal:194—Holy conferences, with fellowship in prayers and hymns.195 The communion of Saints ought, doubtless, to flourish not only in churches, but also in private houses. And it is lamentable, that in the present state of Christianity, these exercises of social piety are become so antiquated, or are sometimes so injudiciously performed, that they are even hateful and odious to many. 3. That we comfort the poor, the sick, the afflicted in mind and body, by our conversation, our prayers, our kind offices.196 It is wonderful, and in these days almost incredible, how admirably the primitive Christians expressed their love for one another. From numberless instances of this, I may now select one, which Eusebius relates.197 At the time when a dreadful pestilence and famine prevailed, after Maximin had issued against the Christians his cruel decrees, “the heathen every where beheld a striking proof of the piety and universal benevolence of the Christians. Amidst calamities so numerous and so severe, they alone exhibited in substantial deeds, the offices of mercy and humanity. They daily employed themselves, partly in protecting and burying the bodies of the dead, (for innumerable multitudes, of whom no person took care, died every day;) and partly in distributing provisions to all the indigent in the whole city that were pining for hunger, whom they collected for that purpose. The consequence was, that this was extensively talked of and divulged, and all men highly extolled the God of the Christians, and confessed that they alone had approved themselves in deed and in truth the sincere worshippers of God.”

XLVIII. 3dly, That we seek in this communion the solace of our souls. What can be more delightful than the mutual fellowship of brethren, mingled together, as Tertullian expresses it, in spirit and soul!198 What more amiable than the reciprocal offices of love, and the holy familiarity of the friends of God, edifying, admonishing, and comforting one another, and uniting in the same supplications and spiritual songs! How refreshing is it to the soul of an afflicted saint, if at any time he becomes languid in prayer, to encourage himself by the thought, that there are so many myriads of believers making intercession for him with our common Father! With what cordial congratulation does he rejoice in the gifts of the Divine liberality towards his brethren, which he knows are granted for this purpose, that they may prove subservient to the general good, and that their salutary fruit may extend to himself also, as a part of the whole community! For of so ingenuous a nature is Christian charity, that, on account of the gathering together of all things in Christ, she considers what belongs to each of the brethren as her own. In this communion of Saints, in fine, there is a kind of prelude of heaven, where there will be no private or separate interest, but one God shall be all in all.

Notes

Note LXII. Page 348.

The term Συναγωγη, synagogue, is sometimes used to signify a public assembly of any description, or the place where any public meeting is held.199 Most generally, however, it means a Jewish assembly for worship, or a building where the Jews met for public prayer and the reading of the Scriptures. The greater part of interpreters, in common with our Author, allow, that in one passage, namely, James ii. 2.200 it is employed to denote a Christian place of worship, or else an assembly of Christians. “The word συναγωγη,” says Dr Macknight, “sometimes denotes an assembly of persons, sometimes the house in which such an assembly is held. Here, your synagogue, does not mean a Jewish synagogue, but the house or room where the Christians assembled for worship. And as the Jews held courts of judicature in their synagogues (See Vitringa De veter. Synag. lib. 3. part. 1. c. 11. p. 174. Luke xxi. 12.) and there also punished offenders by scourging, (Mat. x. 17. Acts xxi. 11.) it is probable that the first Christians, after their example, held courts for determining civil causes in the places where they assembled for public worship, called here, Your synagogue. For that the apostle speaks not of their assembly, but of the place where their assembly was held, is evident from his mentioning the litigants sitting in a more honourable, or in a less honourable place of the synagogue.”201

Hammond and Whitby also consider the Apostle as referring in this passage, not to the worshipping assemblies of Christians, but to meetings for civil judicature. Whitby, however, after assigning several reasons for this opinion, adds; “Yet, because the Jewish Christians had then no distinct churches of their own, much less any with such distinct seats for men of rank as the Jews had (Mat. xxiii. 6.) - - - but rather assembled still in the Jewish synagogues, where there was a Beth-din, a house of judgment, - - - the assembly here mentioned might be a Jewish synagogue. Moreover, the Jews living among Gentiles retained the jurisdiction over men of their own nation and religion - - - and so Jewish Christians might be drawn before their judgment-seats (verse 6.) this being long after forbidden by a law of Honorius and Theodosius.”

Note LXIII. Page 350. line 4.

Although our Author justly states, that no one is excluded from the Christian church on account of the meanness of his rank, and although he would have been entitled to confirm this assertion by referring to the worldly circumstances of the Apostles of Christ, it may be questioned whether the text which he immediately produces, namely, 1 Cor. i. 26, has any reference to the external condition of the private members of the church. According to our common English version, indeed, it runs thus: “For you see your calling, brethren, how that not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble are called.” But the reader must observe, that there is an ellipsis in the original, and that the expression are called is a supplement. This supplement, indeed, has been approved of by the generality of expositors. Dr Hammond, for instance, has the following paraphrase on the verse: “You may observe who the men are among you that are wrought on, or converted by the Gospel, not principally the learned politicians, the great or noble families.” But Dr Whitby suggests another interpretation of these words;—“Not many noble are either called by, or made use of to propagate, the Gospel:” and Dr Macknight refers the passage exclusively to those who were employed in the propagation of the Gospel. In his translation of the verse he substitutes the expression call you in place of are called, and subjoins the following Note:

“Verse 26. Call you. These words I have supplied from the first clause of the verse. Our translators have supplied the words are called, which convey a sentiment neither true, nor suitable to the apostle’s design. It is not true: for even in Judea, among the chief rulers many believed on him, John xii. 42. particularly Nicodemus and Joseph of Arimathea. - - - John iv. 53. Acts vi. 7. - - - At Ephesus, many who used the arts of magic and divination were called, and who were men of learning, as appears from the number and value of their books which they burned after embracing the Gospel, Acts xix. 19. And in such numerous churches as those of Antioch, Thessalonica, Corinth and Rome, it can hardly be doubted that there were disciples in the higher ranks of life. There were brethren even in the emperor’s family, Philip iv. 22. - - - And on the other hand, though it were true, That not many wise men, &c. were called, it did not suit the apostle’s argument to mention it here. For surely God’s not calling many of the wise, &c. joined with his calling the foolish ones of the world to believe, did not put to shame the wise and strong, &c. Whereas, if the discourse is understood of the preachers of the Gospel who were employed to convert the world, all is clear and pertinent. God chose not the learned, the mighty, and the noble ones of this world to preach the Gospel, but illiterate and weak men, and men of low birth; and by making them successful in reforming mankind, he put to shame the legislators, statesmen, and philosophers among the heathens, and the learned scribes and doctors among the Jews, who never had done any thing to purpose in that matter.”202

It is unnecessary to add much to what the Author has said regarding the import of the term ἐκκλησια, ecclesia. This word is employed, as Schleusner remarks,203 to signify any kind of assembly, confused or regular, political or sacred. The observation of Witsius, that it is used in the Septuagint to denote an assembly of Israelites, which was called together to one place from all parts of Judea to celebrate the solemn festivals, might easily be confirmed by producing instances of this application, as in Deut. iv. 10. xviii. 16. Neh. xiii. 1. In this sense, too, it is used by Stephen, Acts vii. 38.204 But in the New Testament, it is generally applied to the Christian church, and her assemblies. That it sometimes designates particular communities of Christians, as when we read of the church at Jerusalem, Acts viii. 1. and the church at Corinth, 1 Cor. i. 2. is commonly admitted. But whether it is ever employed in holy writ to signify a meeting of the rulers or directors of a religious society, has been the subject of keen dispute. Schleusner mentions collegium presbyterorum, a college of presbyters, as one of its senses, and refers to Walæus. In his note on Mat. xviii. 17. Dr Campbell affirms, that it would be contrary to all the rules of criticism to suppose that our Lord used this term to denote only a few heads or directors. This opinion, however, has been ably, if not successfully, combated in some learned and ingenious papers, subscribed T. T. which appeared in the Christian Repository.205

Note LXIV. Page 350. line 14.

The word Πανηγυρις, Panegyris, occurs nowhere in the New Testament except in Heb. xii. 23, where it is employed with beautiful propriety. “This word,” says Macknight, “signifies a great concourse of people drawn together from all quarters on some public and joyful occasion, such as a religious festival; annual games; a great market or fair.”206 “Both the words here used,” says Dr Owen, “πανηγυρις and ἐκκλησια, are borrowed from the customs of those cities whose government was democratical, especially that of Athens, whose speech was the rule of the Greek language. Πανηγυρις was the solemn assembly of all persons of all sorts belonging unto the city, where they were entertained with spectacles, sacred festivals, solemnities, and laudatory orations. Λογος πανηγυρικος (a panegyrical speech) is a commendatory oration. Hence is the word used for any great general assembly, as we here translate it, with respect to praise and joy. In these assemblies no business of state was transacted.”207

These remarks of Owen and Macknight correspond with our Author’s explanation of the term. The Panathenea, which he specifies as an example, were festivals held at Athens, at certain stated times, in honour of Minerva. On occasion of these festivals, races, gymnastic exercises, and contentions for the prizes for music and poetry, were succeeded by a general procession of persons of each sex and of every age and class, in which the warlike actions attributed to that goddess were celebrated, and the verses of Homer sung. For a particular account of the Panathenea, see Rollin’s Ancient History.208

Note LXV. Page 358.

The Author adverts to the qualities Holy, Catholic, and Christian, as ascribed to the Church. Of these three, Holy appears to be the character, most anciently mentioned in the Creed. The appellation Catholic, that is, universal, seems however to have been added at a considerably early period. It was contained in the Creed of Cyril, Bishop of Jerusalem, who died in the year 386; and in that of Alexander, Bishop of Alexandria.209 Augustine, when speaking of the true Church as Catholic or Universal, says; “It is not like the churches of heretics, confined within certain places and provinces, but large by the splendour of one faith, from the rising of the sun to the going down thereof.”210

To the epithets Holy and Catholic, the copy made use of by Witsius seems to have added Christian. Of this, accordingly, he gives a short explication in Section 21st; nor having, in a preceding part of the work, made the designation Christians the subject of a whole Dissertation, was it requisite for him to insist largely on this character of the church. In this article of the Creed, considerable diversity of expression has prevailed in the different copies; nor are these three, the only qualities expressed in some of them. In the Creed of Constantinople it is said, “I believe one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church;” and Alexander, Bishop of Alexandria, has thus expressed it,—“the one and only Catholic and Apostolic Church.”211

Note LXVI. Page 360.

Our Author here repeats an observation which he had occasion formerly to make212—that the epithet Catholic was intended to distinguish the Church of Christ from heretics and schismatics, such as the Novatians and the Donatists.—The Novatians derive their name from Novatian, a presbyter of the church of Rome, a man of uncommon learning and eloquence, but of an austere and rigid character. He strenuously opposed the restoration to fellowship with the Church, of any of those who had apostatized, during the persecution set on foot by Decius. In this he differed from Cornelius, another eminent presbyter of the same church, who was chosen to succeed Fabianus in the see of Rome. About the middle of the third century, Novatian separated himself from the jurisdiction of Cornelius, and became the founder of a new society, which subsisted till the fifth century. In point of doctrine, there was no difference betwixt the Novatians and other Christians. Their chief distinction was their refusing to admit to communion, notwithstanding the most satisfactory appearances of penitence, those who, after baptism, had committed any heinous crime. They assumed the title of Cathari, that is, pure; and obliged all that came over to them from the general body of Christians to submit to a second baptism.213

The Donatists were a sect which arose near the beginning of the fourth century. They owe their name to Donatus, Bishop of Casæ Nigræ in Numidia, a vehement opposer of Cæcilianus, Bishop of Carthage; and probably also to another Donatus, the successor of Majorinus, who was chosen Bishop of Carthage in opposition to Cæcilianus, and surnamed the Great. The controversy between the friends and the opponents of Cæcilianus was brought under the consideration of two successive assemblies of Bishops, and ultimately submitted to Constantine the Emperor; by all of whom the Bishop was acquitted, and the Donatists condemned. The Donatists, however, complained loudly of injustice, and were in consequence treated with great severity. Their liberties were restored by Julian, on his accession in the year 362; and towards the conclusion of the fourth century, they had no less than four hundred Bishops. But at the commencement of the fifth century, their strength was considerably weakened by means of the efforts of Augustine, who zealously opposed them in his discourses and writings. They gradually declined till the sixth century, after which no traces of them are to be found. Like the Novatians, they agreed in doctrine with other churches, and distinguished themselves chiefly by an excessive rigour. In their estimation, all churches that held communion with the followers of Cæcilianus were corrupt; and sacred institutions administered among them, void of efficacy. This schism was almost entirely confined to Africa.214

Note LXVII. Page 362.

To distinguish between the exercise of faith with regard to the Divine Persons, and its exercise with reference to the Church, and the other articles recognised in the concluding part of the Creed, is by no means unnecessary. That supreme and implicit confidence which is due to God, cannot be safely or innocently transferred to any creature, or number of creatures, whatever excellencies they may possess. “In this holy catholic Church,” says Archbishop Secker, “our Creed professes belief. But the meaning is not, that we engage to believe all things without exception, of which the majority of the church, at any time, shall be persuaded: and much less, what the rulers of it, or, it may be, a small part of them, who may please to call themselves the church, shall at any time require: for then we must believe many plain falsehoods, uncertainties without number, and contrary doctrines, as contrary parties prevail. - - - As believing in God means only believing that there is a God; and believing in the resurrection, means only believing that there shall be a resurrection; so believing in the holy catholic church, means only believing that by our Saviour’s appointment there was founded, and through his mercy shall ever continue, a society of persons, of what nation or nations is indifferent, who have faith in his name, and obey his laws: not indeed without being deformed and disfigured, by mixtures both of sin and error; but still, without being destroyed by either.”215

In this passage, indeed, Secker affirms, that “believing in God means only believing that there is a God.” But that our Author understood the expression, “I believe in God,” as including much more than a mere persuasion of the existence of the Deity, we have seen at large in his fifth Dissertation. The same remark applies to our believing in Jesus Christ, and in the Holy Ghost; with regard to each of whom as well as the Father, the preposition ἐις in the Greek, and in in the Latin are distinctly made use of in the Creed.216 Witsius considers the careful omission of this particle, when the holy catholic Church falls to be mentioned, as intended to intimate, that our faith is not exercised with respect to the Church, in the same manner as with respect to God. In this opinion he agrees with some of the Fathers, as Augustine and Rufinus. “The Creed obligeth us,” says Augustine, “to believe the church, but not in the church; for the church is not God, but the house of God.”217 Rufinus illustrates the matter more particularly thus; “It is not said, in the holy church, nor in the remission of sins, nor in the resurrection of the body; for if the preposition in had been added, it would have had the same force with what went before. But now in these words where our faith in the Deity is declared, it is said to be in God the Father, and in his Son Jesus Christ, and in the Holy Ghost; but where the Creed speaks of creatures and mysteries, in is not added. - - - By this preposition, therefore, the Creator is distinguished from the creatures, and Divine things separated from human.”218

Bishop Pearson, however, it may be mentioned, attaches no importance to the use or omission of this preposition. “Credo sanctam Ecclesiam,” says he, “or Credo in sanctam Ecclesiam, is the same; nor does the particle in, added or subtracted, make any difference.” He shows also that this particle was used in connexion with the church, and the succeeding expressions in the Creed, by Cyril, Cyprian, Jerome, and some other Fathers.219 In the English version, too, of this ancient summary of the Christian faith, authorised by the Churches both of England and Scotland, the expression I believe is not repeated immediately before the clause relating to the Church; nor is any solicitude discovered to avoid the phrase I believe in the Church: For we read, “I believe in the Holy Ghost, the holy catholic Church,” &c. Though no intelligent Christian is in danger of being misled by this mode of expression, the conscientious scrupulosity shown by our Author is entitled to respect.

Note LXVIII. Page 368.

The history of those faithful men, who, from the first rise of Popery, have successively borne witness to the pure doctrines and institutions of Christ, amidst innumerable perils and sufferings, is particularly useful and interesting. To this branch of ecclesiastical history, the attention of the Christian public has of late years been directed by respectable writers, as Milner, Jones, and several expositors of the book of Revelation. Amongst other authorities of former times, Witsius mentions the Centuriatores of Magdeburgh, whose laborious details are characterized by Mosheim as “an immortal work, which restored to the light of evidence and truth, facts relating to the rise and progress of the Christian church, which had been covered with thick darkness, and corrupted by innumerable fables.” The reader will find a succinct account of many important facts relative to Christ’s two witnesses, in Bishop Newton’s Dissertations on the Prophecies.220 Suffice it to quote here the few following sentences, in which that learned writer explains the names by which they have been known:—

“The true witnesses, and as I may say, the Protestants of this age,” namely, the twelfth century, “were the Waldenses and Albigenses, who began to be famous at this time, and being dispersed into various places, were distinguished by various appellations. Their first and proper name seemeth to have been Vallenses, or inhabitants of the valleys; and so saith one of the oldest writers, Ebrard of Bethune, who wrote in the year 1212; ‘They call themselves Vallenses, because they abide in the valley of tears,’ alluding to their situation in the valleys of Piedmont. They were called Albigenses from Alby, a city in the southern parts of France, where also great numbers of them were situated. They were afterwards denominated Valdenses or Waldenses, from Peter Valdo or Waldo, a rich citizen of Lyons, and a considerable leader of the sect. From Lyons, too, they were called Leonists; and Cathari from the professed purity of their life and doctrine, as others since have had the name of Puritans. As there was a variety of names, so there might be some diversity of opinions among them; but that they were not guilty of Manicheism, and other abominable heresies which have been charged upon them, is certain and evident from all the remains of their creeds, confessions, and writings.” The Bishop then proceeds to detail their sentiments, their progress, and “the horrid murders and devastations” that were employed to suppress them.

Note LXIX. Page 370. line 3.

The Author is quite correct, when he intimates that the expression in 2 Cor. ix. 13. rendered in our common English version “your professed subjection to the gospel of Christ,” implies more than a verbal profession before men; for it means a real subjection of heart to the Gospel, corresponding to the outward profession that is made. Dr Doddridge, accordingly, renders the phrase, that subjection to the Gospel of Christ which you profess; and subjoins the following Note: “Ἐπι τη ὑποταγη της ὁμολογιας ὑμων ἐις το ἐυαγγελιον, expresses not merely a professed subjection to the Gospel, but a real subjection to the Gospel which was professed; which sense I thought it necessary to preserve by a change in the version.”221 The subjection of your confession, or profession, is the literal rendering of the original phrase. But, as Beza remarks, this is a Hebraism for that subjection which you profess. The Apostle stimulates the Corinthians to the work of beneficence by the consideration that their necessitous fellow-Christians, whose wants they supplied, would glorify God on their behalf, when they saw this satisfactory proof of their undissembled faith and obedience of the Gospel.

Note LXX. Page 370. line 26.

It is of importance to consider, that true Christians, notwithstanding that external obscurity and deformity which often conceals the excellence of their character from the carnal eye, are spiritually beautiful; and beyond question, their spiritual beauty consists chiefly in “the hidden man of the heart.” Yet the holy principles and dispositions within never fail to produce corresponding effects on the external behaviour; and when the Church represents herself as resembling “the curtains of Solomon,” she probably refers to those beauties of holiness which adorned both her heart and her conduct.—“I am black,” says she, “but comely; as the tents of Kedar, as the curtains of Solomon.” According to Harmer, “curtains” are to be understood here as synonymous with “tents;” for in the East curtains were not commonly used in beds, and eastern princes often caused elegant tents to be prepared for their residence during the heats of summer. In this verse, then, the Bride acknowledges, that, owing to her swarthy complexion occasioned by the burning rays of the sun, she was black like the tents of Kedar, or of the wild Arabs, whose tents were made of black goat’s hair. She asserts, nevertheless, that she is comely as the curtains of Solomon’s tents, which were no doubt singularly magnificent.222 The Church of Christ is comely through his comeliness put upon her: for she is not only invested with that robe of righteousness which he wrought out for her justification; but also sanctified in heart and life, and beautified with a rich variety of graces, by the power of his Holy Spirit.

Note LXXI. Page 337. line 1.

The Luciferians were the followers of Lucifer, Bishop of Cagliari in Sardinia, a man of prudence, austerity, and courage, who was banished by the Emperor Constantius for having defended the Nicene doctrine concerning the three Persons in the godhead. They scrupulously avoided all fellowship with those Bishops that had declared themselves in favour of the Arians, and even with those who consented to the absolution of such as repented of their error. Their firmness in maintaining the true Divinity of Christ against the oppugners of that essential doctrine was highly laudable; but Jerome deemed it requisite to chastise the overflowings of their zeal.223

Note LXXII. Page 377. line 12.

The Author’s observations relative to the coincidence of the article of the Communion of Saints with the one immediately preceding, appear to be just. It is also an undoubted fact, that several centuries had elapsed before this article was inserted in the Creed. A more particular account of its not appearing in ancient Creeds than that given by Witsius, may be found in Pearson.224 It was introduced, as ecclesiastical historians suppose, about the end of the fourth Century; and it is a probable conjecture, that its introduction was occasioned by the deplorable schism of the Donatists, of whom some short notices were given above.225 This conjecture is expressed in Lord King’s History of the Creed.—The same author mentions the following, as some of the methods anciently employed for maintaining mutual fellowship and intercourse between the several churches and congregations of the faithful.226 1st, Communicatory letters—including the letters which Bishops mutually exchanged, recognising each other in their official capacity; and letters of recommendation given to travelling Christians, which procured their admission to communion with all the churches through which they passed. These last are called by Tertullian, the communication of peace, the title of brotherhood, and the common mark of hospitality. 2dly, Several practices relating to discipline. Notwithstanding differences in minor points among the churches, a regard to harmony and good order, in general, so far prevailed, that whoever was baptized or ordained in one church, was not required to be re-baptized or re-ordained, when, in providence, he was obliged to become a member of another. Besides, whoever was legally and justly censured by any one church, was not schismatically countenanced and supported by others.

Our Author’s illustration of the Communion of Saints, though concise, is pleasant and instructive. Pearson, too, has good remarks on this subject. He adverts to the communion which the saints have with the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, with holy angels, with saints on earth, and saints in heaven. The communion which saints have with each other in this world, is no doubt the topic principally intended; and it were much to be wished that the faith of Christians respecting this point increasingly appeared in their brotherly love to one another, and in their readiness to discharge the important duties arising from the intimate and endearing bonds by which they are united. A number of plain, but very judicious and useful hints on this subject are contained in Boston’s Discourses on “The Unity of the Body of Christ, and the Duties the Members owe to one another.” It was not intended to introduce here any discussion of the keenly agitated questions relative to the extent to which Christians ought to hold church-fellowship with each other, in the various institutions of religion.

1 יפיפית מבני אדם Ps. xlv. 2.

2 Song iv. 1, 7.

3 Individua vitæ societas.

4 Gen. ii. 24.

5 Ephes. v. 30.

6 1 Cor. vi. 17.

7 Song vii. 6.

8 Heb. x. 25.

9 James ii. 2.

10 See Note LXII.

11 Την κλῆσιν, from which the word Ecclesia is derived. 1 Cor. i. 26.

12 See Note LXIII.

13 Πανηγυρικὸς λόγος.

14 See Note LXIV.

15 1 Cor. x. 17.

16 1 Cor. xii. 14.

17 Col. i. 18.

18 Rev. xix. 10.

19 Job i. 6.

20 Heb. xii. 22.

21 Heb. ii. 16.

22 Acts ii. 41.

23 Heb. iii. 6.

24 1 Pet. ii. 9.

25 1 Cor. i. 2.

26 Rom. ix. 11.

27 1 Tim. iii. 15.

28 Acts xvii. 27. Rom. ii. 4.

29 1 Cor. i. 21.

30 Rom. x. 4.

31 Ἐξ ακοῆς πίστεως. Gal. iii. 2.

32 Rom. viii. 30.

33 Ps. cxlvii. 19, 20.

34 Is. lv. 5.

35 Prov. ix. 4, 5.

36 Mat. xx. 16.

37 Rom. viii. 30. Gal. i. 15, 16.

38 Acts viii. 13. Comp. Mat. xiii. 20, &c.

39 Tit. i. 1.

40 1 Tim. i. 5.

41 Gal. v. 6.

42 Ez. ix. 2.

43 Rom. xi. 16.

44 1 Cor. vi. 1, 2.

45 1 Cor. vii. 14.

46 Ps. xciii. 5.

47 Gen. xvii. 7. Acts ii. 39.

48 John xv. 2, 6.

49 Heb. viii. 10–12.

50 Rom. ii. 28, 29.

51 1 John ii. 19.

52 1 Pet. ii. 9.

53 Heb. iii. 1.

54 2 Thes. ii. 13.

55 1 Cor. i. 9.

56 1 John i. 3.

57 2 Tim. ii. 19.

58 2 Thes. ii. 13. James ii. 18.

59 1 Cor. iv. 1.

60 Mat. iii. 6. Acts viii. 37.

61 Διακρισις πνευματων, 1 Cor. xii. 10.

62 Acts viii. 13.

63 1 Cor. xi. 18, 21.

64 Mat. iii. 12.

65 Mat. xiii. 24. et seq.

66 Verse 47. et seq.

67 2 Tim. ii. 20.

68 See Note LXV.

69 Deut. iv. 6–8. Rom. vii. 12. 1 Tim. vi. 3. Tit. i. 1. ii. 11, 12.

70 The Author’s words here are lustratus ac februatus, which, in their primitive import, relate to certain periodical purifications by sacrifice observed amongst the Romans. See Kennet’s Antiquities of Rome, Part II. Book ii. ch. 2. and Book iii. ch. 7. T.

71 Gal. i. 4.

72 Tit. ii. 14.

73 1 Cor. vi. 11.

74 Heb. ix. 12–14.

75 Ps. cv. 14, 15. Comp. Zech. ii. 8. Gen xii. 3.

76 Ὅπου ἄν ᾗ Χριστος Ἰησους, ἐκει ἡ καθολικη ἐκκλησία.

77 Και πασαις ταῖς κατα παντα τοπον τῆς ἁγιας καθολικῆς ἐκκλησιας παροικιαις. Euseb. Hist. Lib. iv. cap. 11.

78 Cateches. xviii.

79 See Note LXVI.

80 Acts xi. 26.

81 Mat. xxiii. 8.

82 John iii. 29.

83 Comp. 1 Sam. xxviii. 20. מלא קומתו, the fulness of his stature.

84 Ephes. i. 22, 23.

85 1 Cor. xii. 12.

86 Credo in Spiritum Sanctum, Sanctam Ecclesiam Catholicam.

87 See Note LXVII.

88 2 Tim. ii. 19.

89 Mat. xvi. 18.

90 Is. lv. 10, 11.

91 Ps. xlv. 6. Dan. ii. 44. Luke i. 33.

92 Is. xlix. 5, 6.

93 Ps. cvii. 42, 43.

94 Ephes. iii. 10, 11.

95 Is. lx. 8.

96 Is. ii. 2, 3. Jer. xxxi. 12. Zech. viii. 20–23. and elsewhere passim.

97 Ps. cxxxiii.

98 Heb. x. 25.

99 Is. lxv. 5.

100 1 Tim. iii. 15.

101 Ephes. ii. 20, 21.

102 Ps. cxv. 1.

103 Gal. vi. 3.

104 Is. xl. 1.

105 Tit. i. 1.

106 Οὐδενεια.

107 Magdeburgens. Centuriæ.

108 Mysterium Iniquitatis.

109 De Successione et Statu Ecclesiarum.

110 See Note LXVIII.

111 Jer. vii. 4.

112 2 Cor. iii. 3.

113 1 Pet. ii. 3.

114 Ezek. xlvii.

115 Ὑποταγη της ὁμολογίας ἐις τὸ Εὐαγγέλιον Χριστοῦ, 2 Cor. ix. 13.

116 See Note LXIX.

117 Ephes. v. 26, 27.

118 Mat. v. 20.

119 Exod. xxxvi.

120 Mat. xxiii. 27.

121 Song i. 5.

122 See Note LXX.

123 Ps. xlv. 13. 1 Pet. iii. 4.

124 Ps. xxix. 9.

125 Is. xliii. 21. Comp. 1 Pet. ii. 9.

126 Ps. lxxxvii. 3.

127 2 Thes. i. 10.

128 Ephes. i. 3–6.

129 Heb. ix. 12.

130 Rev. v. 9, 10.

131 1 Thes. ii. 12.

132 Ephes. ii. 22.

133 2 Cor. vi. 16. See John xiv. 23. Rev. iii. 20.

134 Ps. cxxxii. 15, 16.

135 Jer. xxxi. 12–14.

136 Joel iii. 18.

137 Song iv. 9, 10.

138 Rom. viii. 35–39. Is. lx. 18.

139 Is. lix. 20. Comp. Rom. xi. 26.

140 1 Cor. xv. 22–24.

141 Ps. lxv. 5, 6.

142 Zech. xii. 3.

143 Rev. i. 3.

144 Nehem. i. 3, 4. Ps. cii. 14. Amos vi. 6.

145 Jer. xxxi. 23.

146 Ps. cvi. 5.

147 Is. lxii. 1.

148 Ps. cxxii. 8, 9.

149 Is. xlix. 23.

150 Is. lxii. 6.

151 1 Thes. v. 11, 14.

152 1 Pet. iii. 1.

153 Neh. iii. 12.

154 Ps. li. 18.

155 Ps. xiv. 7.

156 See Note LXXI.

157 See Note LXXII.

158 Lev. xi. 44. Is. xli. 14.

159 Mat. xxv. 31.

160 Deut. xxxiii. 2. 1 Thes. iii. 13. comp. 2 Thes. i. 7.

161 Ps. xvi. 3.

162 Heb. xii. 23.

163 1 Cor. vii. 4.—Caius and Caia were names deemed fortunate by the Romans. At the celebration of marriage, when the bride first entered the bridegroom’s house, being asked by him who she was, she replied, Ubi tu Caius, ibi ego Caia: i. e. Ubi tu Dominus, ibi ego Domina, “Where you are Master, I will be Mistress.” See Adam’s Roman Antiquities, pp. 465, 466. T.

164 1 John i. 3. 1 Cor. i. 9.

165 Jer. x. 16.

166 1 Cor. iii. 22.

167 1 Cor. i. 30.

168 Is. liii. 4, 5, 6.

169 Heb. i. 14.

170 Mat. vi. 10.

171 Rev. xix. 10.

172 Mat. xxii. 30.

173 Heb. xii. 22.

174 ’Ανακεφαλαίωσιν τῶν παντων τῶν ἐν Χριστῷ, τῶν τε ἐν τοις ’ουρανοῖς καὶ τῶν ἐπι της γῆς, Ephes. i. 10.

175 בצרור החיים, in fasciculo viventium. 1 Sam. xxv. 29.

176 Heb. xii. 22, 23.

177 Is. lxiii. 16.

178 Rev. vi. 9, 10, 11.

179 Philip. iii. 20.

180 1 Cor. xii. 12, 13.

181 Ephes. iv. 4–6.

182 1 Cor. xii. 26. Gal. vi. 2.

183 Heb. xiii. 3.

184 Gal. vi. 1.

185 Philip. ii. 4.

186 Rom. xii. 13. Acts iv. 32.

187 Rom. i. 11.

188 1 Cor. xii. 21–23.

189 1 Tim. ii. 1. Ephes. vi. 18.

190 Ps. cxxii. 6. Philip. ii. 1–3. iii. 15, 16.

191 Lev. xix. 17.

192 Prov. xxviii. 23.

193 Rom. xv. 14.

194 Heb. iii. 13.

195 Ephes. iv. 29. v. 19. Col. iii. 16.

196 2 Cor. viii. 1–5.

197 Hist. lib. ix. cap. 8.

198 Ps. cxxxiii.

199 See Parkhurst’s Greek Lex. on συναγωγη I.; and Dr Hammond on Matt. vi. Note d.

200 Ἐαν γαρ ἐισελθη ἐις την συναγωγην ὑμων—“For if there enter into your synagogue”——.

201 Comment. and Notes on the Apost. Epistles, in loc.

202 Comment. &c. Vol. i. in loc.

203 Greek Lexicon, on the word.

204 See Doddridge’s Note on that verse, Vol. iii. sect. 15.

205 Vol. ii. pp. 461–465, 542–545, 724–731.

206 Commentary, in loc.

207 Exposition of the Hebrews, in loc.

208 Vol. i. p. 33. 9th edit.

209 Pearson on the Creed, Art. ix. p. 334.

210 Sermons on Time, 181. as quoted in King’s Hist. of the Creed, p. 326.

211 King’s Hist. of the Creed, p. 326.

212 Diss. i. Sect. 14.

213 Mosheim’s Eccles. Hist. Cent. iii. p. 2. ch. v. Sect. 17, 18.

214 Mosheim’s Eccles. Hist. Cent. iv. Part 2. ch. v. sect. 1–8. Cent. vi. Part ii. ch. v. sect. 2. On this subject, that learned historian refers, amongst other Authors, to Wits. Miscel. Sacr. Tom. i. lib. 4. p. 742.

215 Works, Vol. iv. pp. 329, 330.

216 See the copies of the Creed, Vol. i. Note 1.

217 Sermons on Time, 181. as quoted in King’s Critic. Hist. p. 322.

218 Ruf. in Symbol. quoted Ibid. p. 320.

219 Expos. of the Creed, Art. ix. p. 335.

220 Dissert. xxiv. Analysis of the Rev. Ch. 11.

221 Fam. Expos. in loc.

222 Harmer’s Outlines of a Commentary on Solomon’s Song, Part iii. p. 186. et seq.

223 See Mosheim’s Eccles. Hist. Cent. iv. Part 2. chap. 3.

224 Art. ix. p. 351.

225 Note LXVI.

226 Chap. vi. p. 341. et seq.