An Exposition of the Creed (1659), John Pearson · PDF

THE RESURRECTION OF THE BODY.

Article XI. THE RESURRECTION OF THE BODY.

This Article was anciently deliver’d and acknowledged1 by all Churches, onely with this difference, that whereas in other places it was express’d in generall terms, the Resurrection of the flesh, they of the Church of Aquileia by the addition of a Pronoune propounded it to every single believer in a more particular way of expression, the Resurrection of this flesh. And though we have translated it in our English Creed the Resurrection of the body; yet neither the Greek nor Latine ever delivered this Article in those terms, but in these, the Resurrection2 of the flesh; because there may be ambiguity in the one, in relation to the celestiall and spirituall bodies, but there can be no collusion in the other. Onely it will be necessary, for shewing our agreement with the Ancient Creeds, to declare that as by flesh they understood the body of man, and not any other flesh, so we, when we translate it body, understand no other body but such a body of flesh, of the same nature which it had before it was by death separated from the Soul. We see by dayly experience, that all men are mortall, that the body left by the soul the salt and life thereof, putrifieth and consumeth, and according to the sentence of old, returneth unto dust; but these bodies, as frail and mortall as they are, consisting of this corruptible flesh, are the subject of this Article, in which we professe to believe the Resurrection of the body.

When we treated concerning the Resurrection of Christ, we delivered3 the proper notion and nature of the Resurrection in Generall, that from thence we might conclude that our Saviour did truly rise from the dead. Being now to explain the Resurrection to come, we shall not need to repeat what we then delivered, or make any addition as to that particular, but referring the Reader to that which is there explained, it will be necessary onely to consider what is the Resurrection to come, who they are which shall be raised, how we are assured they shall rise, and in what manner all shall be performed. And this Resurrection hath some peculiar difficulties different from those which might seem to obstruct the belief of Christ’s Resurrection. For the body of the Son of God did never see corruption; all the parts thereof continued in the same condition in which they were after his most precious soul had left them, they were onely deposited in a Sepulcre, otherwise the grave had no power over them. But other mortall bodies, after the soul hath deserted them, are left to all the sad effects of their mortality; we may say to corruption, Thou art my Father, to the worm thou art my Mother and my Sister; our corps go down to the barrs of the pit, and rest together in the dust.4 Our death is not a simple dissolution, a bare separation of soul and body as Christ’s was; but our whole Tabernacle is fully dissolved, and every part thereof crumbled into dust and ashes, scattered, mingled, and confounded with the dust of the earth.

There is a description of a kind of Resurrection in the Prophet Ezekiel, in which there is supposed a valley full of bones, and there was a noise, and behold a shaking, and the bones came together, bone to his bone, the sinews and the flesh came up upon them, and the skin covered them above, and their breath came into them, and they liv’d and stood upon their feet.5 But in the Resurrection to come we cannot suppose the bones in the valley, for they are dissolved into dust as well as the other parts.

We must therefore endeavour to shew that the bodies of men howsoever corrupted, wheresoever in their parts dispersed, how long soever dead, shall hereafter be recollected in themselves, and united to their own souls. And for the more facil and familiar proceeding in this so highly concerning truth, I shall make use of this method; First to prove, that such a Resurrection is not in it self impossible. Secondly, to shew that it is upon generall considerations highly probable. Thirdly, to demonstrate that it is upon Christian principles infallibly certain. It is not in it self impossible, therefore no man can absolutely deny it; it is upon naturall and morall grounds highly probable, therefore all men may rationally expect it; it is upon Evangelicall principles infallibly certain, therefore all Christians must firmly believe it.

First, I confesse the Philosophers6 of old did look upon the Resurrection of the body as impossible, and though some of them thought, the souls of the dead did live again, yet they never conceived that they were united to the same bodies, and that their flesh should rise out of the dust that it might be conjoyned to the spirit of a man. We read of certain Philosophers of the Epicureans, and of the Stoicks, who encountred S. Paul, and when they heard of the resurrection they mocked him, some saying, that he seemed to be a setter forth of strange Gods because he preached unto them Jesus and the Resurrection.7 But as the Ancient Philosophers thought a Creation impossible, because they looked onely upon the constant works of nature, among which they never find any thing produced out of nothing, and yet we have already proved a Creation not onely possible, but perform’d; so did they think a Resurrection of corrupted, dissolved, and dissipated bodies to be as impossible, because they could never observe any action or operation in nature, which did or could produce any such effect; and yet we being not tyed to the consideration of nature onely, but estimating things possible or impossible by the power of God, will easily demonstrate that there is no impossibility that the dead should rise.

For, if the Resurrection of the dead be impossible, it must be so in one of these respects, either in reference to the Agent, or in relation to the Patient; either because it is a work of so much difficulty that there neither is nor can be any Agent of wisdome, power, and activity sufficient to effect it; or else because the soul of man is so far separated by death from the body, and the parts of the body so much dissolved from themselves and altered from their former nature, that they are absolutely incapable by any power to be united as they were. Either both or one of these two must be the reason of the impossibility, if the Resurrection be impossible; for if the body be capable of being raised, and there be any Agent of sufficient ability to raise it, the resurrection of it must be possible.

Now if the Resurrection were impossible in respect of the Agent which should effect it, the impossibility must arise either8 from an insufficiency of knowledge or of power; for if either the Agent know not what is to be done, or if he know it, but hath no power to do it, either he will not attempt it, or if he do, must fail in the attempt; but that, of which he hath perfect knowledge, and full power to effect, cannot be impossible in relation to the Agent endued with such knowledge, armed with such power.

Now when we say the Resurrection is possible, we say not it is so to men or Angels or any creature of a limited knowledge or finite power, but we attribute it to God, with whom nothing is impossible; his understanding is infinite, he knoweth all the men which ever lived since the foundation, or shall live unto the dissolution of the world, he knoweth whereof all things are made, from what dust we came, into what dust we shall return. Our substance was not hid from thee, O Lord, when we were made in secret, and curiously wrought in the lowest parts of the earth; thine eyes did see our substance, yet being imperfect, and in thy book were all our members written, which in continuance were fashioned, when as yet there was none of them.9 Thus every particle of our bodies, every dust and atome which belongeth to us, is known to him that made us. The Generation of our flesh is clearly seen by the Father of spirits, the augmentation of the same is known to him in whom we live, move, and have our being, the dissolution of our tabernacles is perceived by that God, by whom the very hairs of our head are all numbred, and without whom one sparrow shall not fall to the ground.10 He which numbreth the sands of the sea, knoweth all the scattered bones, seeth into all the graves & tombs, searcheth all the repositories & dormitories in the earth, knoweth what dust belongeth to each body, what body to each soul. Again, as his all-seeing eye observeth every particle of dissolved and corrupted man, so doth he also see and know all wayes and means by which these scattered parts should be united, by which this ruined fabrick should be recomposed, he knoweth how every bone should be brought to it’s old neighbour bone, how every sinew may be reimbroydered on it; he understandeth what are the proper parts to be conjoyned, what is the proper gluten by which they may become united. The Resurrection therefore cannot be impossible in relation to the Agent upon any deficiency of knowledge how to effect it.

And as the Wisedome is infinite, so the Power of this Agent is illimited; for God is as much Omnipotent as Omniscient. There can be no opposition made against him, because all power is his; nor can he receive a check against whom there is no resistance. All creatures must not onely suffer, but doe what he will have them; they are not onely passively, but actively obedientiall. There is no atome of the dust or ashes but must be where it pleaseth God, and be applyed and make up what and how it seemeth good to him. The Resurrection therefore cannot be impossible in relation unto God upon any disability to effect it, and consequently there is no impossibility in reference to the Agent, or him which is to raise us.

Secondly, the Resurrection is not impossible in relation to the Patient, because where we look upon the power of God, nothing can be impossible but that which involveth a contradiction, as we before have proved; and there can be no contradiction in this, that he which was, and now is not, should hereafter be what before he was. It is so far from a repugnancy, that it rather conteineth a rationall and apparent possibility, that man who was once dust, becoming dust, should become man again. Whatsoever we loose in death is not lost to God: as no creature could be made out of nothing but by him, so can it not be reduced into nothing but by the same: though therefore the parts of the body of man be dissolved, yet they perish not; they loose not their own entity when they part with their relation to humanity; they are laid11 up in the secret places, and lodged in the Chambers of nature, and it is no more a contradiction that they should become the parts of the same body of man to which they did belong, then that after his death they should become the parts of any other body, as we see they doe. Howsoever they are scattered, or wheresoever lodged, they are within12 the knowledge and power of God, and can have no repugnancy by their separation to be reunited when and how he pleaseth. The first dust of which man was made, was as far from being flesh, as any ashes now or dust can be; it was onely an Omnipotent power which could mould that into an humane body, and breathe into the nostrils of it the breath of life. The same power therefore, which must alwayes be, can still make of the dust returning from the bodies of men unto the earth, humane bones and flesh, as well as of the dust which first came from the earth: for if it be not easier, it is most certainly as easie to13 make that to be again which once hath bin, as to make that to be which before was not. When there was no man God made him of the earth, and therefore when he returns to earth, the same God can make him man again. The Resurrection therefore cannot be impossible, which is our first Conclusion.

Secondly, the Resurrection is not onely in it self possible, so that no man with any reason can absolutely deny it; but it is also upon many generall considerations highly probable, so that all men may very rationally expect it. If we consider the principles of humanity, the parts of which we all consist, we cannot conceive this present life to be proportionable to our composition. The souls of men as they are immateriall, so are they immortall, and being once created by the Father of spirits they receive a subsistence for eternity; the body is framed by the same God to be a companion for his spirit, and a man born into the world consisteth of these two. Now the life of the most aged person is but short, and many far ignobler creatures of a longer duration. Some of the fouls of the air, severall of the fishes of the sea, many of the beasts of the field, divers of the plants of the earth are of a more durable constitution, and out-live the sons of men. And can we think that such materiall and mortall, that such inunderstanding souls should by God and nature be furnished with bodies of so long permansion, and that our spirits should be joyned unto flesh so subject to corruption, so suddenly dissolveable, were it not that they lived but once, and so enjoyed that life for a longer season, and then went soul and body to the same destruction, never to be restored to the same subsistence; but when the soul of man which is immortall is forced from it’s body in a shorter time, nor can by any means continue with it half the years which many other creatures live, it is because this is not the onely life belonging to the sonnes of men, and so the soul may at a shorter warning leave the body which it shall resume again.

Again, if we look upon our selves as men, we are free agents, and therefore capable of doing good or evil, and consequently ordinable unto reward or punishment. The Angels which are above us, and did sin, received their punishment without a death, because being onely spirits they were subject to no other dissolution then annihilation, which cannot consist with longer suffering punishment; those which continued in their station were rewarded and confirmed for all eternity, and thus all are incapable of a Resurrection. The creatures which are below us, and for want of freedome cannot sin, or act any thing morally either good or evil, they cannot deserve after this life either to be punished or rewarded; and therefore when they dye, they continue in the state of death for ever. Thus those which are above us shall not rise from the dead, because they are punished or rewarded without dying, and where no death is there can be no resurrection from the dead. Those which are below us, are neither capable of reward or punishment for any thing acted in this life, and therefore though they dye, yet shall they never rise, because there is no reason for their Resurrection. But man by the noblenesse of his better part being free to do what is good or evil while he liveth, and by the frailty of his body being subject to death, and yet after that being capable in another world to receive a reward for what he hath done well, and a punishment for what he hath done ill in the flesh, it is necessary that he should rise from the dead to enjoy the one or suffer the other. For there is not onely no just Retribution rendred in this life to man, but considering the ordinary condition of things, it cannot be. For it is possible, and often cometh to passe, that one man may commit such sins as all the punishments of this life can no way equalize them. What is then more proper considering the providence of a most just God, then to believe that man shall suffer in another life such torments as will be proportionable to his demerits? Nor can we with reason think that the soul alone shall undergoe those sufferings, because the lawes which were given to us are not made in respect of that alone, but have most frequent reflexion on the body, without14 which in this life the soul can neither do nor suffer any thing. It is therefore highly probable from the generall consideration of humane actions and divine retributions, that there shall be a Resurrection15 of the flesh, that every one may receive the things done in his body, according to that he hath done, whither it be good or bad.

Furthermore beside the principles of which we consist, and the actions which flow from us, the consideration of the things without us, and the naturall course of variations in the creature, will render the Resurrection yet more highly probable. Every space of 24. hours teacheth thus much, in which there is alwayes a revolution amounting to a Resurrection. The day16 dyes into a night, and is buried in silence and in darknesse; in the next morning it appeareth again and reviveth, opening the grave of darknesse, rising from the dead of night; this is a diurnall Resurrection.

As the day dyes into night, so doth the Summer into Winter: the sap is said to descend into the root, and there it lyes buried in the ground; the earth is covered with snow, or crusted with frost, and becomes a generall sepulchre; when the Spring appeareth all begin to rise, the plants and flowers peep out of their graves, revive, and grow and flourish; this is the annuall Resurrection. The Corn by which we live, and for want of which we perish with famine, is notwithstanding cast upon the earth, and buried in the ground, with a design that it may corrupt, and being corrupted may revive and multiply; our bodies are fed with this constant experiment, and we continue this present life by a succession of Resurrections. Thus all things are repaired by corrupting, are preserved by perishing and revive by dying; and can we think17 that man, the Lord of all these things which thus dye and revive for him, should be deteined in death as never to live again? Is it imaginable that God should thus restore all things to man, and not restore man to himself? If there were no other consideration, but of the principles of humane nature, of the liberty and remunerability of humane actions, and of the naturall revolutions and resurrections of other creatures, it were abundantly sufficient to render the Resurrection of our bodies highly probable.

We must not rest in this School of Nature, nor settle our perswasions upon likelyhoods; but as we passed from an apparent possibility, unto a high presumption and probability, so must we passe from thence unto a full assurance of an infallible certainty. And of this indeed we cannot be assured but by the Revelation of the will of God; upon his power we must conclude that we may, from his will that we shall, rise from the dead. Now the power of God is known to all men, and therefore all men may infer from thence a possibility, but the will of God is not revealed unto all men, and therefore all have not an infallible certainty of the Resurrection. For the grounding of which assurance, I shall shew that God hath revealed the determination of his will to raise the dead, and that he hath not onely delivered that intention in his word, but hath also severall wayes confirmed the same.

Many of the places produced out of the Old Testament to this purpose will scarce amount to a Revelation of this truth. The Jews insist upon such weak18 inferences out of the Law, as shew that the Resurrection was not clearly delivered by Moses; and in the book of Job where it is most evidently expressed, they acknowledge it not, because they will not understand the true notion of a Redeemer properly belonging to Christ. The words of Job are very express, I know that my Redeemer liveth, and that he shall stand at the latter day upon the earth, and though after my skin worms destroy this body, yet in my flesh shall I see God.19 Against the evidence of this truth there are two Interpretations, one very new of some late Opinionists, who understand this of a suddain restitution to his former temporall condition; the other more ancient of the Jewes, who make him speak of the happinesse of another life without any reference to a resurrection. But that Job spake not concerning any suddain restitution, or any alteration of his temporall condition, is apparent out of the remarkable preface ushering in this expression, O that my words were now written, O that they were printed in a book! that they were graven with an iron pen and lead, in the rock for ever!20 He desires that his words may continue as long as his expectation, that they may remain in the rock, together with his hope so long as the rock shall endure, even to the day of his resurrection. The same appeareth from the objection of his friends, who urged against him that he was a sinner, and concluded from thence that he should never rise again; for his sins he pleadeth a Redeemer, and for his resurrection he sheweth expectation and assurance through the same Redeemer. It is further confirmed by the expressions themselves, which are no way proper for his temporall restitution: the first words I also know,21 denote a certainty and a community, whereas the blessings of this life are under no such certainty, nor did Job pretend to it, and the particular condition of Job admitted no community, there being none partaker with him of the same calamity, I know certainly and infallibly, whatsoever shall become of my body at this time, which I know not, but this I know that I shall rise; this is the hope of all which believe in God, and therefore this I also know. The title which he gives to him on whome he depends, the Redeemer22 sheweth that he understands it of Christ; the time expressed denotes the futurition at the latter day,23 the description of that Redeemer, standing on the earth, representeth the Judge of the quick and the dead, and seeing God with his eyes, declares his belief in the Incarnation. The Jewish exposition of future happinesse to be conferred by God, fails onely in this that they will not see in this place the promised Messias, from whence this future happy condition which they allow would clearly involve a Resurrection. Howsoever they acknowledge the words of Daniel to declare as much, and many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting confusion.24

If these and other places of the old Testament shew that God had then revealed his will to raise the dead, we are sure those of the New fully declare the same. Christ, who called himself the Resurrection and the life, refuted the Sadduces, and confirmed the doctrine of the Pharisees as to that opinion. He produced a place out of the Law of Moses, and made it an Argument to prove as much, As touching the resurrection of the dead, have ye not read that which was spoken unto you by God saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob? God is not the God of the dead but of the living.25 With the force of which Argument the multitude was astonished and the Sadduces silenced. For under the name of God was understood a great benefactor, a God of promise, and to be their God was to blesse them and to reward them, as in them to be his servants and his people was to believe in him, and to obey him. Now Abraham, Isaac and Jacob had not received the promises which they expected, and therefore God after their death desiring still to be called their God, he thereby acknowledgeth that he had a blessing and a reward for them still, and consequently that he will raise them to another life in which they may receive it. So that the Argument of our Saviour is the same which the Jewes have drawn from another place of Moses, I appeared unto Abraham, unto Isaac and unto Jacob by the name of God Almighty, but by my name Jehovah was I not known to them. Neverthelesse I have established my Covenant with them, to give them the land of Canaan, the land of their pilgrimage, wherein they were strangers.26 It is not said to give their sons, but to give them the land of Canaan;27 and therefore, because while they lived here they enjoy’d it not, they must live again that they may receive the promise. And as our blessed Saviour did refute the Sadduces out of the Law of Moses, so did S. Paul joyn himself unto the Pharisees in this particular, for being called before the Council, and perceiving that the one part were Sadduces and the other Pharisees, one denying, the other asserting the resurrection, he28 cryed out unto the Council, Men and brethren I am a Pharisee, the son of a Pharisee of the hope and resurrection of the dead I am called in question; and answering before Felix, that they had found no evil doing in him while he stood before the Council he mentioned this particularly, except29 it be for this one voice that I cryed standing among them, Touching the resurrection of the dead, I am called in question by you this day. It is evident therefore that the Resurrection of the dead was revealed under the Law, that the Pharisees who sate in Moses chair did collect it from thence, and believe it before our Saviour came into the world, that the Sadduces who denyed it, erred, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God: that our blessed Saviour clearly delivered the same truth, proved it out of the Law of Moses, refuted the Sadduces, confirmed the Pharisees, taught it the Apostles, who followed him confirming it to the Jewes preaching it to the Gentiles. Thus the will of God concerning the raising the dead was made known unto the Sons of men; and because God can doe whatsoever he will, and will certainly effect whatsoever he hath foretold, therefore we are assured of a Resurrection by virtue of a clear Revelation.

Beside God hath not onely foretold, or barely promised, but hath also given such testimonies as are most proper to confirm our faith in this particular prediction and promise. For God heard the voyce of Eliah for the dead child of the widow of Sarepta, and the soul of the child came into him again, and he revived.30 Him did Elisha succeed, not onely in the same spirit, but also in the like power, for he raised the child of the Shunamite from death;31 nor did that power dye together with him; for when they were burying a dead man, they cast the man into the sepulchre of Elisha, and when the man was let down and touched the bones of Elisha, he revived and stood upon his feet.32 These three examples were so many confirmations, under the Law, of a resurrection to life after death; and we have three to equall them under the Gospel. When the daughter of Jairus was dead, Christ said unto her, Talitha cumi, Damsel arise, and her spirit came again, and straightway the Damsel arose and walked.3334 When he came nigh to the gate of the city called Naim, there was a dead man carried out, and he came nigh, and touched the bier, and said, Young man, I say unto thee, Arise; and he that was dead sate up and began to speak.35 Thus Christ raised the dead in the chamber and in the street, from the bed and from the bier, and not content with these smaller demonstrations, proceedeth also to the grave. When Lazarus had bin dead four dayes, and so buryed that his sister said of him, by this time he stinketh, Jesus cryed with a loud voice; Lazarus come forth, and he that was dead came forth.36 These three Evangelicall resuscitations are so many preambulary proofs of the last and generall Resurrection; but the three former and these also come far short of the Resurrection of him who raised these.

Christ did of himself actually rise, others which had slept in their graves did come from thence, and thus he gave an actuall testimony of the Resurrection. For if Christ be preached that he rose from the dead, saith S. Paul to the Corinthians, how say some among you that there is no resurrection of the dead?37 If it be most infallibly certain that one man did rise from the dead, as we have before proved that Christ did, then it must be as certainly false to assert that there is no resurrection. And therefore when the Gentiles did themselves confesse that some particular persons did return to38 life after death, they could not rationally deny the Resurrection wholly. Now the resurrection of Christ doth not onely prove by way of example, as the rest who rose, but hath a force in it to command belief of a future generall Resurrection. For God hath appointed39 a day in which he will judge the world in righteousnesse by that man whom he hath ordeined, whereof he hath given an assurance unto all men, in that he hath raised him from the dead. All men then are assured that they shall rise, because Christ is risen. And since40 by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead. For as in Adam all dye, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.

This consequence of a future Resurrection of the dead from that of Christ already past, either hath a generall or a particular consideration. In a generall reference it concerneth all, in a more peculiar way it belongeth to the Elect alone. First, it belongeth generally unto all men in respect of that Dominion which Christ at his resurrection did obtain. For to this end Christ both dyed and rose, and revived that he might be Lord both of the dead and living.41 Now as God is not the God of the dead, but of the living, so Christ is not the Lord of the dead, as dead, but as by his power he can revive them, and rule them when and in what they live. By virtue of this dominion obtained at his Resurrection he must reign till he hath put all his enemies under his feet, and the last enemy that shall be destroyed is death,42 and there is no destruction of death but by a generall Resurrection. By virtue of this did he declare himself after this manner to S. John, I am he that liveth and was dead, and behold I am alive for evermore, Amen, and have the keyes of hell and of death.43 Thus are we assured of a generall Resurrection, in that Christ is risen to become the Lord of the dead, and to destroy death.

Secondly, Christ rising from the dead assureth us of a Generall Resurrection in respect of the Judgement which is to follow. For as it is appointed for all men once to dye, so after death cometh judgement; and as Christ was raised that he might be Judge, so shall the dead be raised that they may be judged. As therefore God gave an assurance to all men that he would judge the world by that man, in that he raised him from the dead, so by the same act did he also give an assurance of the resurrection of the world to judgement.

Now as the Generall Resurrection is evidenced by the rising of Christ, so in a more especiall and peculiar manner the Resurrection of the chosen Saints and servants of God is demonstrated thereby. For he is risen not onely as their Lord and Judge, but as their Head, to which they are united as members of his body (for he is the Head of the body the Church, who is the beginning, the first-born from the dead;44) as the first-fruits, by which all the lump is sanctified and accepted, for now is Christ risen from the dead and become the first-fruits of them that slept.45 The Saints of God are endued with the Spirit of Christ, and thereby their bodies become the temples of the Holy Ghost; now as the promise of the Spirit was upon the resurrection of Christ, so the gift and possession of the Spirit is an assurance of the resurrection of a Christian. For if the Spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in us, he that raised Christ from the dead shall also quicken our mortall bodies by his spirit that dwelleth in us.46 Thus God hath determined, and revealed that determination, to raise the dead, and confirmed that revelation by the actuall raising of severall persons as examples, and of Christ as the highest assurance which could be given unto man, that the doctrine of the Resurrection might be established beyond all possibility of contradiction. Wherefore I conclude that the Resurrection of the body, is in it self considered possible, upon generall considerations highly probable, upon Christian principles infallibly certain.

But as it is necessary to a Resurrection that the flesh should rise, neither will the life of the soul alone continuing amount to the reviviscence of the whole man, so it is also necessary that the same flesh should be rais’d again; for if either the same body should be joyned to another soul, or the same soul united to another body, it would not be the resurrection of the same man. Now the soul is so eminent a part of man, and by our Saviours testimony not subject to mortality, that it never entred into the thoughts of any man to conceive that men should rise again with other souls. If the spirits of men departed live, as certainly they doe, and when the Resurrection should be perform’d, the bodies should be inform’d with other souls; neither they which liv’d before then should revive, and those which live after the resurrection should have never bin before. Wherefore being at the latter day we expect not a new creation but a restitution, not a propagation but a renovation, not a production of new souls, but a reunion of such as before were separated, there is no question but the same soules should live the second life which have lived the first. Nor is this onely true of our souls, but must be also made good of our bodies, those houses of clay, those habitations of flesh: as our bodies while we live are really distinguished from all other creatures, as the body of every particular man is different from the bodies of all other men, as no other substance whatsoever is vitally united to the soul of that man whose body it is while he liveth, so no substance of any other creature, no body of other man shall be vitally reunited unto the soul at the Resurrection.

That the same body, not any other, shall be raised to life which dyed, that the same flesh which was separated from the soul at the day of death shall be united to the soul at the last day, that the same tabernacle which was dissolved shall be reared up again, that the same temple which was destroyed shall be re-built, is most apparent out of the same Word, most evident upon the same grounds upon which we believe there shall be any Resurrection. Though after my skin wormes destroy this body, saith Job, yet in my flesh, (in flesh shewing the reality, in my flesh shewing the propriety and identity) shall I see God, whom I shall see for my self, and mine eyes shall behold, and not another or a stranger eye.47 He that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken our mortall bodies;48 after the Resurrection our glorified bodies shall become spirituall and incorruptible, but in the resurrection of our mortall bodies, those bodies, by reason of whose mortality49 we dyed, shall be revived. For this corruptible must put on incorruption, and this mortall must put on immortality.50 But this corruptible and this mortall is the same bodie which dyeth, because mortall, and is corrupted because corruptible; the soul then at the resurrection of that man which is made immortall must put on that body which putteth on incorruption and immortality.

The identity of the body rais’d from death is so necessary, that the very name of the Resurrection doth include or suppose it; so that when I say there shall be a Resurrection of the dead, I must intend thus much, that the bodies of men which lived and are dead shall revive & rise again. For at the death of man nothing falleth51 but his body, the spirit goeth upward, and no other body falleth but his own, and therefore the body, and no other but that body, must rise again to make a Resurrection. If we look upon it under the notion of Reviviscency, which is more ordinary in the Hebrew52 language, it proves as much, for nothing properly dyeth but the body, the soul cannot be killed, and nothing can revive but that which dyeth. Or to speak more punctually, The man falleth not in respect of his spirit but of his flesh, and therefore he cannot be said to rise again but in respect of his flesh which fell; man dyeth not in inference to his soul, which is immortall, but his body, and therefore he cannot be said to revive, but in reference to his body before depriv’d of life; and because no other flesh fell at his death, no other body dyed but his own, therefore he cannot rise again but in his own flesh, he cannot revive again but in his own body.

Again, the description of the place from whence the Resurrection shall begin is a sufficient assurance that the same bodies which were dead shall revive and rise again. They which sleep in the dust of the earth,53 they which are in the graves shall hear the voice and arise:54 the sea shall give up the dead which are in it, and death and the grave deliver up the dead which are in them.55 But if the same bodies did not rise, they which are in the dust should not revive; if God should give us any other bodies then our own, neither the sea nor the grave should give up their dead. That shall rise again which the grave gives up; the grave hath nothing else to give up but that body which was laid into it; therefore the same body which is buried at the last day shall be revived.

The immediate consequent of the Resurrection proveth the identity of the dying and rising body. We must all appear before the Judgement seat of Christ, that every one may receive the things done in his body, according to that he hath done whither it be good or bad.56 That which shall be then received is either a reward or punishment, a reward for the good, a punishment for the evil, done in the body; that which shall receive the reward, and be lyable to the punishment, is not onely the soul but the body; it stands not therefore with the nature of a just57 retribution, that he which sinned in one body should be punished in another, he which pleased God in his own flesh should see God with other eyes. As for the wicked, God shall destroy58 both their soul and body in hell: but they which glorifie59 God in their body and their spirit which are God’s, shall be glorified by God in their body and their spirit, for they are both bought with the same price, even the bloud of Christ. The bodies of the Saints are the members60 of Christ, and no members of his shall remain in death: they are the temples of the Holy Ghost, and therefore if they be destroy’d they shall be rais’d again. For if the Spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in us, as he doth, and by so dwelling maketh our bodies temples, he61 which raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken our mortall bodies, by his Spirit that dwelleth in us.

Furthermore, the identity of the dying and the rising body will appear by those bodies which shall never rise because they shall never dye. Those whom Christ shall find alive at his coming, he shall not kill but change; the dead in Christ shall rise first, then they which are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and so shall ever be with the Lord.62 If those which are alive shall be caught up as they are alive with the same bodies, onely changed into glorified and spirituall bodies, that is with the same bodyes spiritualized and glorified; certainly those which were dead shall rise out of their graves to life in the same bodies in which they lived, that they may both appear alike before the Judge of the quick and the dead.

Lastly, those examples which God hath bin pleased to give us to confirm our faith in the Resurrection, do at the same time perswade us that the same body which dyed shall rise again. For whether we look upon the three Examples of the Old Testament or those of the New, they all rose in the same body before it was dissolved: if we look upon those which rose upon our Saviour’s death; it is written, that the graves were opened, and many bodies of Saints which slept arose and came out of their graves,63 certainly the same bodies which were layed in. If then they were to us examples64 of the Resurrection to come, as certainly they were, then must they resemble in their substance after they liv’d again the substance in which all the rest shall rise. And being Christ himself did raise his own body, according to his prediction Destroy this Temple and in three dayes I will raise it up,65 and declared it to be his own body, saying Behold my hands and my feet that it is I my self,66 being he shall change our vile bodies that they may be fashioned like unto his glorious body,67 it followeth that we shall rise in the same bodies as our Saviour did, that every particular person at the Resurrection may speak the words which Christ then spake, Behold it is I my self.

Having hitherto proved the Certainty of this Article, that there shall be a Resurrection, and declared the Verity and Propriety of it, that it shall be the Resurrection of the same body which was dead; we may now proceed further to enquire into the Latitude of the same, to whom the Resurrection doth belong. And here we find a great difference between the Revelation of this truth under the Law and under the Gospel; Christ proved out of the Law that there should be a Resurrection, but by such an argument as teacheth no further then unto the people of God, because it is grounded upon those words, I am the God of Abraham, of Isaac and of Jacob. Job speaketh most expresly of the Resurrection, but mentioneth no other then his Redeemer and himself. The place of Daniel, which was alwayes accounted the most evident and uncontradicted testimony, though it deliver two different sorts of persons rising, yet it seems to be with some limitation, Many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake. From whence the Jewes most generally have believed that some men should live again and some should not, because it is written Many shall awake, but it is not written All shall awake. Nay some of them have gone so far by way of restriction, that they have maintained a resurrection of the Just alone, according to that ancient saying accepted amongst them, that the Sending68 of the Rain is of the just and unjust, but the Resurrection of the dead is of the just alone. Against which two Restrictions by the light delivered in the Gospell we shall deliver the latitude of this Article in these two Propositions. First, The Resurrection of the dead belongeth not unto the just alone, but to the unjust also. Secondly, The Resurrection of the dead belongeth not onely to some of the just, but to all the just, not to some of the unjust onely, but to all the unjust, even unto all the dead.

For the first it is most evident not onely out of the New but also out of the Old Testament. The words of Daniel prove it sufficiently, for of those many which shall awake, some shall rise to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt. But it is most certain that the just shall never rise to shame and everlasting contempt; therefore it is most evident that some shall awake and rise beside the Just. The Jewes themselves did understand and believe thus much, as appeareth by S. Paul’s Apology to Felix, But this I confesse unto thee, that I have hope towards God, which they themselves also allow, that there shall be a resurrection of the dead both of the just & unjust.69 The just shall rise to receive their reward, the unjust to receive their punishment; the first unto a Resurrection, called in reference unto them, the Resurrection of life; the second unto a Resurrection, named in relation unto them, the Resurrection of damnation.70 For as there is a Resurrection of the just,71 so there must also be a Resurrection of the unjust: that as Christ said unto the charitable person, Thou shalt be blessed, for thou shalt be recompensed at the resurrection of the just; so it may be said to the wicked and uncharitable, thou shalt be accursed, for thou shalt be recompensed at the Resurrection of the unjust. For there shall be a Resurrection that there may be a Judgement, and at the Judgement there shall appear sheep on the right hand of the Son of man, and goats on the left, therefore they both shall rise, those that they may receive that blessing, Come ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdome prepared for you from the foundation of the world,72 these that they may receive that sentence, Depart from me ye cursed into everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his Angels.73 At that Resurrection then which we believe there shall rise both just and unjust.

Secondly, as no kind of men, so no person shall be excluded: whosoever dyeth is numbred with the just or unjust. Adam the first of men shall rise, and all which come from him. For as in Adam all dyed, so in Christ shall all be made alive.74 Christ is the Lord of the dead, and so hath a right by that dominion to raise them all to life: it is called the Resurrection of the dead indefinitely, and comprehendeth them universally. By man came death, by man came the Resurrection of the dead,75 and so the Resurrection adequately answereth unto death. Christ shall destroy death, but if any one should be left still dead, death were not destroyed. The words of our Saviour are expresse and full, The hour is coming in the which all that are in the graves shall hear his voice, and shall come forth, they that have done good, unto the Resurrection of life, and they that have done evil unto the Resurrection of damnation.76 In the description of the Judgement which followeth upon the Resurrection, when the Son of man shall sit upon the Throne of his glory, it is said that before him shall be gathered all nations.77 We shall all stand before the Judgement seat of Christ,78 and if so, the dead must all rise, for they all are fallen. We must all appear before the Judgement seat of Christ, that every one may receive the things done in his body according to that he hath done, whether it be good or evil;79 and before we all appear the dead must rise that they may appear. This is the latitude of the Resurrection; the Resurrection of the dead is the Resurrection of all the dead.

Now this Resurrection, as an object of our faith, is yet to come; and we are obliged to believe the futurition of it.

There were Hereticks in the Apostles dayes who acknowledged a Resurrection, but yet destroyed this Article, by denying the relation of it to the time to come, as Hymeneus and Philetus, who erred concerning the truth. saying that the Resurrection is past already, and so overthrow the faith of some.8081 To believe it already past is to deny it, because it cannot be believed past but by such an interpretation as must destroy it. As they which interpret this Resurrection of the likenesse of Christ’s Resurrection; that as he dyed and rose again, so we should dye unto sin and live again unto righteousnesse, attributing all to the renovation of the mind, must deny the resurrection of the body.

Now as we know the doctrine of the Resurrection was first delivered to be believed as to come; so we are assured that it is not yet come since the doctrine of it was first delivered, and is to be believed as to come to the end of the world; because, as Martha called it, it is the Resurrection at the last day.82 Job who knew that his Redeemer lived, did not expect that he should stand upon the earth till the latter day; Christ hath no otherwise declared his Fathers will, then that of all which he hath given him, he should loose nothing, but should raise it up at the last day.83 The corn is sown and laid in the ground, and the harvest is the end of the world.84 We must not expect to rise from the dead till the last trump.85 The Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of an Archangel and with the trump of God86 before all that are in the graves shall hear his voice.87 God shall judge the world,88 and therefore shall raise the world: but he will not raise them to that judgement till the end of the world.

Thus having demonstrated that the will of God hath bin revealed that there should be a Resurrection; that the Resurrection which was revealed is the Resurrection of the body; that the bodies which are to be raised are the same which are already dead or shall hereafter dye, that this Resurrection is not past, but that we which live shall hereafter attain unto it; I conceive I have declared all which is necessary by way of explication and confirmation of the truth of this Article.

The Value of this Truth, the Necessity of this doctrine will appear; First, in the illustration of the Glory of God, by the most lively demonstration of his Wisdome, Power, Justice, and Mercy. God first created all things for himself, and the Resurrection is as it were a new Creation. The wisedome and power of God are manifested in this acknowledgement, in as much as without infinite knowledge he could not have an exact and distinct comprehension of all the particles and individuall dusts of all the bodies of all men, & without an infinite power he could not conjoyn, cement, conglutinate and incorporate them again into the same flesh. The Mercy and Justice of God are declared by the same profession; the Mercy, in promising life after that death which we had so justly deserved, the Justice, in performing that promise unto all true believers, and in punishing the disobedient with everlasting flames. When ye see this, saith the Prophet, your heart shall rejoyce, and your bones shall flourish like an herb; and the hand of the Lord shall be known towards his servants, and his indignation towards his enemies.89

Secondly, it is necessary to professe the belief of the Resurrection of the body, that we may thereby acknowledge the great and powerfull work of our Redemption: confessing that death could not be conquered but by death, and that we could never have obteined another life had not the Saviour of the world abolished death and brought life and immortality to light through the Gospell.90 If Christ were not the life, the dead could never live: if he were not the Resurrection they could never rise. Were it not for him that liveth and was dead, and is alive for evermore, had not he the keyes of hell and of death, we could never break through the barrs of death, or passe the gates of hell. But he hath undertaken to vanquish our enemies, and our last enemy to be destroyed is death: that the prophesie may be fulfilled, Death is swallowed up in victory,91 and we may cry out with the Apostle, Thanks be to God, who giveth us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ.92

Thirdly, the Belief of this Article is necessary to strengthen us against the fear of our own death, and immoderate sorrow for the death of others. The sentence of death passed upon us for our sins cannot but affright and amaze us, except we look upon the suspension, relaxation, or revocation of it in the Resurrection; but when we are assured of a life after death, and such a life as no death shall follow it, we may lay down our fears arising from corrupted nature upon the comforts proceeding from our faith. The departure of our friends might overwhelm us with grief, if they were lost for ever; but the Apostle will not have us ignorant concerning those which are asleep, that we sorrow not even as others which have no hope.93

Fourthly, the belief of the Resurrection hath a necessary reflexion upon this life by way of preparation for the next, as deterring from sinne, as encouraging to holinesse, as comforting in afflictions. How can any man commit a deliberate sin while he thinks that he must rise and stand before the Judgement seat, and give an account, and suffer for ever the punishment due unto it? What pleasure can entice him, what inclination can betray him for a momentany satisfaction to incurre an eternall rejection? How can we defile that body which shall never be raised to glory hereafter except it here become the Temple of the Holy Ghost? S. Paul who hath delivered the doctrine, hath taught us by his own example what work is expected to be wrought upon our souls by it. I have hope, saith he, towards God that there shall be a resurrection of the dead, both of the just and unjust. And herein do I exercise my self to have alwayes a conscience void of offence toward God and toward man.94 This is the proper work of a true belief and a full perswasion of a resurrection; and he which is really possessed with this hope, cannot chuse but purifie himself; alwayes abounding in the work of the Lord, forasmuch as he knoweth that his labour is not in vain in the Lord.95 This encourageth all drooping spirits, this susteineth all fainting hearts, this sweetneth all present miseries, this lighteneth all heavy burdens, this encourageth in all dangers, this supporteth in all calamities.

Having thus discovered the truth of this Article; we may easily perceive what every man is obliged to believe, and understood to professe, when he confesseth a belief of the Resurrection of the body; for thereby he is conceived to declare thus much, I am fully perswaded of this as of a most necessary and infallible truth, that as it is appointed for all men once to dye, so it is also determined that all men shall rise from death, that the soules separated from our bodies are in the hand of God and live, that the bodies dissolved into dust, or scattered into ashes, shall be recollected in themselves and reunited to their souls, that the same flesh which lived before shall be revived, that the same numerical bodies which did fall shall rise, that this resuscitation shall be universal, no man excepted, no flesh left in the grave, that all the just shall be raised to a resurrection of life, and all the unjust to a resurrection of damnation, that this shall be performed at the last day when the Trump shall sound; and thus I believe the resurrection of the bodie.

1 Cum omnes Ecclesiæ ita sacramentum Symboli tradant, ut postquam dixerant peccatorum remissionem, addant carnis resurrectionem; sancta Aquileiensis Ecclesia ubi tradit carnis resurrectionem, addit unius pronominis syllabam; & pro eo quod cæteri dicunt, carnis resurrectionem, nos dicimus, hujus carnis resurrectionem, Ruffin. Apol. advers. Hieron. Satis cauta & provida adjectione fidem Symboli Ecclesia nostra docet, quæ in eo quod à cæteris traditur, carnis resurrectionem, uno addito pronomine tradit, hujus carnis resurrectionem, Id. in Symb.

2 The Greeks alwayes σαρκὸς ἀνάστασιν, the Latines carnis resurrectionem. And this was to be observed because, being we read of spirituall bodies, some would acknowledge the resurrection of the body, who would deny the resurrection of the flesh. Of this S. Jerome gives an account, and withall of the words of the Creed. Exempli causa pauca subjiciã, Credimus, inquiunt, resurrectionem futuram corporum. Hoc si bene dicatur, pura confessio est; sed quia corpora sunt cœlestia, & terrestia, & aër ille & aura tenuis juxta naturã suã corpora nominantur, corpus ponunt, non carnem, ut Orthodoxus corpus audiens carnẽ putet, Hæreticus spiritum recognoscat. Hæc enim eorũ est prima decipula; quæ si deprehensa fuerit, instruunt alios dolos, & innocentiã simulant, & malitiosos nos vocant, & quasi simpliciter credentes ajunt, Credimus resurrectionem carnis. Hoc vero cũ dixerint vulgus indoctum putat sibi sufficere, maxime quia idipsũ & in Symb. creditur, Ep. 55. ad Pam. & Oceã.

3 Pag. 515.

4 Job 17. 14, 16.

5 Ezek. 37. 1, 7, 8. 10.

6 Pliny reckoning up those things which he thought not to be in the power of God, mentions these two, mortales æternitate donare, aut revocare defunctos, lib. 2. cap. 7. And Æschylus though a Pythagorean, yet absolutely denies it to be in the power of God, for so he makes Apollo speak to the Eumenides, Πέδας μὲν ἂν λύσειεν, ἔστι τοῦδ’ ἄκος, Καὶ κάρτα πολλὴ μηχανὴ λυτήριος. Ἀνδρὸς δ’ ἐπειδὰν αἷμ’ ἀνασπάση κόνις Ἅπαξ θανόντος, οὔτις ἔστ’ ἀνάστασις. Τούτων ἐπωδὰς οὐκ ἐποίησεν πατὴρ Οὐμὸς, τὰ δ’ ἄλλα πάντ’ ἄνω τε καὶ κάτω Στρέφων τίθησιν, οὐδὲν ἀσθμαίνων μένει. Æschyl. Eumenid. Uti anima interire dicatur, ab Epicureis observatur: Ut carnis restitutio negetur, de una omnium Philosophorum schola sumitur, Tertull.

7 Act. 17. 18.

8 Τὸ ἀδύνατόν τινι γιγνώσκεται κατ’ ἀλήθειαν τοιοῦτον ἢ ἐκ τοῦ μὴ γιγνώσκειν τὸ γενησόμενον ἢ ἐκ τοῦ δύναμιν ἀρκοῦσαν μὴ ἔχειν πρὸς τὸ ποιῆσαι καλῶς τὸ ἐγνωσμένον. Ὁ γὰρ ἀγνοῶν τι τῶν γενέσθαι δεόντων οὐκ ἂν οὔτ’ ἐγχειρῆσαι οὔτε ποιῆσαι τὸ παράπαν δυνηθείη ὅπερ ἀγνοεῖ· ὅτε γινώσκων καλῶς τὸ ποιηθησόμενον, καὶ πόθεν γένοιτ’ ἂν καὶ πῶς, δύναμιν δὲ ἢ μηδ’ ὅλως ἔχων πρὸς τὸ ποιῆσαι τὸ γινωσκόμενον ἢ μὴ ἀρκοῦσαν ἔχων οὐκ ἂν ἐγχειρήσειε τὴν ἀρχὴν, εἰ σωφρονοίη καὶ τὴν ἰδίαν ἐπισκέψηται δύναμιν, ἐγχειρήσας δὲ ἀπερισκέπτως οὐκ ἂν ἐπιτελέσειε τὸ δόξαν, Athenagoras de Resurrectione.

9 Ps. 137.15,16.

10 Mat, 10.29,30.

11 Non sola anima seponitur, habet & caro suos sinus interim, in aquis, in ignibus, in alitibus, in bestiis; cum in hæc dissolvi videtur, velut in vasa transfunditur, Tertull. de Resurrectione carnis, cap. 68. Tu perire Deo credis si quid oculis nostris hebetibus subtrahitur? Corpus omne sive arescit in pulverem, sive in humorem solvitur, vel in cinerem comprimitur, vel in nidorem tenuatur, subducitur nobis, sed Deo elementorum custodi reservatur, Minutius Felix in Octavio. Omnia quæ discerpuntur, & in favillas quasdam putrescunt, integra Deo sunt, in illa enim elementa mundi eunt unde primo venerunt, S. August. in Psalm. Enarrat. 62.

12 Absit autem ut ad resuscitanda corpora vitæque reddenda non possit Omnipotentia Creatoris omnia revocare quæ vel bestia vel ignis absumpsit; vel in pulverē cineremque collapsum, vel in humorem solutum, vel in auras est exhalatum. Absit ut sinus ullus, secretumque naturæ ita recipiat aliquid subtractum sensibus nostris, ut omnium Creatoris aut lateat cognitionem, aut effugiat potestatem, S. August. de Civitate Dei, lib, 22, cap. 20.

13 Recogita quid fueris antequam esses, utique nihil. Meminisses enim si quid fuisses. Qui ergo nihil fueras priusquam esses, idem nihil factus cum esse desieris, cur non possis esse rursus de nihilo, ejusdem Authoris voluntate, qui te voluit esse de nihilo? Quid novi tibi eveniet? Qui non eras, factus es, cum iterum non eris, fies. Redde, si potes, rationem qua factus es, & tunc require qua fies. Et tamen facilius utiq; fies quod fuisti aliquando, quia æque non difficile factus es quod nunquam fuisti aliquando, Tertull. Apolog. cap. 48. Utique idoneus est reficere qui fecit. Quanto plus est fecisse quam refecisse, initium dedisse quam reddidisse; ita restitutionem carnis faciliorem credas institutione, Idem de Resur. carnis, cap. 11. Difficilius est id quod non sit incipere, quam id quod fuerit iterare, Minutius Felix in Octavio. Utique plus est facere quod nunquam fuit, quam reparare quod fuit. Quomodo ergo impossibile esse dicis, ut Deus qui hominem formavit ex nihilo reformet? Quomodo nos suscitare non potest conversos in pulverem, qui etiamsi in nihilum rediremus, facere poterat ut essemus, sicut effecit nos esse, cùm antea nunquam fuissemus, S. August. de Verbis Apost. Serm. 19. To the same purpose the Jewes, דלא חוו הוו דהוו לא כל שכן:

14 Quod congruet judicari hoc competet etiam resuscitari, Tertullian. de Resurrectione carnis, cap. 14. Negent operarum societatem ut merito possint mercedem negare. Non sit particeps in sententia caro, si non fuerit & in causa. Sola anima revocetur, si sola decedit. At enim non magis sola decedit, quam sola decucurrit illud unde decedit, vitam hanc dico, Ibid. cap. 15. Cum omnis vitæ nostræ usus in corporis animæque consortio sit, resurrectio autem aut boni actus præmium habeat aut pœnam improbi, necesse est corpus resurgere cujus actus expenditur. Quomodo enim in judicium vocabitur sine corpore, cum de suo & corporis conturbernio ratio præstanda sit? S. Ambros. de Fide Resur.

15 2 Cor. 5. 10.

16 Dies moritur in noctem, & tenebris usquequaque sepelitur. Funestatur mundi honor, omnis substantia denigratur, Sordent, silent, stupent cuncta; ubique justitium est, quies rerum: ita lux amissa lugetur. Et tamen rursus cum suo cultu, cum dote, cum sole, eadem & integra & tota universo orbi reviviscit, interficiens mortem suam noctem, rescindens sepulturam suam tenebras, hæres sibimet existens, donec & nox reviviscat, cum suo & illa suggestu. Redaccenduntur enim & stellarum radii, quos matutina succensio extinxerat. Reducuntur & siderum absentiæ, quas temporalis distinctio exemerat. Redornantur & specula Lunæ quæ menstruus numerus adtriverat, Tertullian. de Resurrectione carnis, cap. 12. Lux quotidie interfecta resplendet & tenebræ pari vice decedendo succedunt, sidera defuncta vivescunt, tempora ubi finiuntur incipiunt, fructus consummantur & redeunt, Idem Apol. cap. 48. Δύνει ἡ ἡμέρα καὶ νεκρῶν αἰνιττόμεθα τὸν τρόπον κοιμισμὸν αἰνιττομένης, ἀνατέλλει ἡ ἡμέρα ἡμᾶς διϋπνίζουσα καὶ ἀναστάσεως ὑποδεικνύουσα τὸ σημεῖον, Epiphan. in Ancorato.

17 Omnia pereundo servantur, omnia de interitu reformantur. Tu homo, tantum nomen, si intelligas te vel de titulo Pythiæ discens, dominus omnium morientium & resurgentium ad hoc morieris ut pereas? Tertull. Apolog. cap. 48. Revolvuntur hyemes & æstates, & verna aut autumna cum suis viribus, moribus, fructibus. Quippe etiam terræ de cœlo disciplina est arbores vestire post spolia, flores denuo colorare, herbas rursus imponere, exhibere eadem quæ absumpta sunt semina, nec prius exhibere quam absumpta. Mira ratio de fraudatrice servatrix, ut reddat intercipit, ut custodiat perdit, ut integret vitiat, ut etiam ampliet prius decoquit. Siquidem uberiora & cultiora restituit quam exterminavit: revera fœnore interitu, & injuria usura, & lucro damno: semel dixerim, universa conditio recidiva est. Quodcunque conveneris fuit, quodcunque amiseris nihil non iterum est: omnia in statum redeunt cum abscesserint, omnia incipiunt cum desierint: ideo finiuntur ut fiant, nihil deperit nisi in salutem. Totus igitur hic ordo revolubilis rerum testatio est resurrectionis mortuorum. Operibus eam præscripsit Deus ante quam literis; viribus prædicavit antequam vocibus. Præmisit tibi Naturam magistram, submissurus & Prophetiam, quo facilius credas prophetiæ discipulus naturæ; quo statim admittas cum audieris, quod ubique jam videris, nec dubites Deum carnis etiam resuscitatorem, quem omnium noris restitutorem. Et utique omnia homini resurgunt cui procurata sunt, porro non homini nisi & carni, quale est ut ipsa depereat in totum propter quam & cui nihil deperit? Idem de Resur. carnis, cap. 12.

18 They produce severall places out of Moses, which when the Resurrection is believed may in some kind serve to illustrate it, but can in no degree be thought to reveal so great a Mystery. As because in the formation of man Moses useth the word וייצר with two jods, and in the formation of beasts ויצר with but one; therefore the beasts are made but once, but man twice, once in his generation, and again in his Resurrection. They strangely apprehend a promise of the Resurrection, even in the Malediction, Dust thou art and to dust thou shalt return; תלך לא נאמר אלא תשיב, it is not thou shalt goe to the dust, but thou shalt return. As if he had said, thou art now dust while thou livest, and after death thou shalt return unto this dust, that is, thou shalt live again, as now thou dost. So from those words Exod. 15. 1. אז ישיר משה, they conclude the resurrection, upon this ground שר לא נאמר אלא ישיר, it is not said he sang, but he shall sing, viz. after the resurrection in the life to come. With these and the like Arguments did the Rabins satisfie themselves, which was the reason that they gave so small satisfaction to the Sadducees; while they omitted that pregnant place in Job.

19 Job 19. 25 26.

20 Job 19. 25,26.

21 ואני ידעתי:

22 גאלי:

23 אחרון:

24 Dan. 12. 2. The Jewes collect from hence the Resurrection, as Rabina in Sanhedrin. and in the Midrash Tillim, Psal. 93. 3. א״ר רחמן ישני עפר הם המתים שנ׳ ורבים משנו אדמת עפר יקיצו וגו׳: Rabbi Rachmon said, that the sleepers in the dust are the dead, as it is written, Dan. 12. 2. Many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, &c. And this is onely denyed by the Gentiles; for Porphyrius referreth it onely and wholly to the times of Antiochus, whose words are thus left unto us translated by S. Hierome, Tunc hi qui quasi in terræ pulvere dormiebant, & operti erant malorum pondere, & quasi in sepulchris miseriarum reconditi, ad insperatam victoriam de terræ pulvere resurrexerunt, & de humo elevaverunt caput, custodes legis resurgentes in vitam æternam, & prævaricatores in opprobrium sempiternum, where it is to be observed that he gives a probable glosse of the former part of the verse, but none at all of the latter, because it is no way consistent with his exposition of the former, for they which did rise from the burden of the pressures under Antiochus, did neither rise from thence to an eternall life, nor to an everlasting contempt.

25 Mat. 22. 32.

26 Exod. 6. 4.

27 לתת לכם לא נאמר אלא להם מכאן לתחיית המתים מן התורה: It is not said to give you, but to give them, whereby the Resurrection of the dead appeareth out of the Law, R Simai in Perek Helek. And therefore the Jewes hold the Resurrection for one of the foundations of the law of Moses, ותחיית המתים קאערה מן קואער שריעה משא: Moses Maim. Expl. cap. 10. Tract. Sanedrin.

28 Act. 23. 6.

29 Act. 24. 21.

30 1 King 17. 22.

31 2 King. 4.

32 2 King 17.21.

33 Mar. 5.41, 42.

34 Luc. 8. 55.

35 Luc. 7. 12, 14, 15.

36 Joh. 11. 39, 43, 44.

37 1 Cor. 15. 12.

38 There were not onely certain persons under the Law & among the Jews who were raised to life; but there were also Histories amongst the Gentiles of severall who rose to life after death. We mentioned before one out of Plutarch pag. 528. who rose the third day, and Plato mentioneth another who revived the twelfth day after death, Ἀλλ’ οὐ μέντοι σοι, ἦν δ’ ἐγὼ, Ἀλκίνου γε ἀπόλογον ἐρῶ, ἀλλ’ ἀλκίμου μὲν ἀνδρὸς, Ἠρὸς τοῦ Ἀρμενίου, τὸ γένος Παμφύλου, ὅς πότε ἐν πολέμῳ τελευτήσας ἀναιρεθέντων δεκαταίων τῶν νεκρῶν ἤδη διεφθαρμένων, ὑγιὴς μὲν ἀνηρέθη, κομισθεὶς δὲ οἴκαδε μέλλων θάπτεσθαι δωδεκαταῖος ἐπὶ τῇ πυρᾷ κείμενος ἀνεβίω, Plato de Repub. l. 10. vide Plin. lib. 7. cap. 52. De his qui elati revixerunt.

39 Act. 17. 31.

40 1 Cor. 15. 21, 22.

41 Rom. 14. 9.

42 1 Cor. 15.25, 26;

43 Rev. 1. 18.

44 Coloss. 1. 18.

45 1 Cor. 15. 20.

46 Rom. 8. 11.

47 Job 19.26, 27.

48 Rom. 8. 11.

49 Ἵνα μὴ ἀκούσας τις ὅτι σὰρξ καὶ αἷμα βασιλείαν Θεοῦ οὐ κληρονομήσει, νομίση τὰ σώματα μὴ ἀνίστασθαι, ἐπήγαγεν, ὅτι δεῖ τὸ φθαρτὸν τοῦτο ἐνδύσασθαι ἀφθαρσίαν καὶ τὸ θνητὸν τοῦτο ἐνδύσασθαι ἀθανασίαν, φθαρτὸν δὲ τὸ σῶμα, καὶ θνητὸν τὸ σῶμα· ὥστε τὸ μὲν σῶμα μένει, αὐτὸ γάρ ἐστι τὸ ἐνδυόμενον· ἡ δὲ θνητότης καὶ ἡ φθορὰ ἀφανίζεται, ἀθανασίας καὶ ἀφθαρσίας ἐπιούσης αὐτῷ, S. Chrysost. ad locum. Ὁρᾶς τὴν ἀκρίβειαν, τὸ θνητὸν τοῦτο

50 1 Cor. 15. 53. ἔδειξε δεικτικῶς ἵνα μὴ ἄλλης νομίσης σαρκὸς ἀνάστασιν, Theodoretus ibid. Oportet enim corruptivum istud induere incorruptionem, & mortale istud induere immortalitatem. Quid mortale nisi caro? quid corruptivum nisi sanguis? Ac ne putes aliquid aliud sentire Apostolum providentem tibi, & ut de carne dictum intelligas laborantem, cum dicit istud corruptivum & istud mortale cutem ipsam tenens dicit. Certe istud nisi de subjecto, nisi de comparenti pronuntiasse non potuit: demonstrationis corporalis est verbum, Tertull. de Resur. carnis, cap. 51. Sed & Apostolus cum dicit, Oportet enim corruptibile hoc induere incorruptionem, & mortale hoc induere immortalitatem: numquid non corpus suum quodammodo contingentis & digito palpantis est vox? Hoc ergo quod nunc corruptibile corpus est, resurrectionis gratia incorruptibile est, & nunc quod mortale est immortalitatis virtutibus induetur, Ruff. in Symb. Quod dicit Apostolus Corruptibile hoc & mortale; hoc ipsum corpus, id est, carnem, quæ tunc videbatur ostendit. Quod autem copulat Induere incorruptionem & immortalitatem; illud indumentum, id est, vestimentum, non dicit corpus abolere quod ornat in gloria, sed quod ante inglorium fuit efficere gloriosum, S. Hieron. Epist. 61. ad Pammachium.

51 Περὶ δὲ σαρκὸς ἀναστάσεως πῶς οὐχὶ σαρκὸς ἔσται ἀνάστασις, ὡς ἐθελόσοφει Ἱέρακας, Αὐτὴ γὰρ ἡ ὀνομασία τῆς φράσεως δείκνυσι τὴν δύναμιν. Ἀνάστασις γὰρ οὐ καλεῖται τοῦ μὴ πιπτωκότος· ποῖον δέ ἐστι τὸ πεσόν; ποῖον τὸ ταφέν; ποῖον τὸ λυθὲν, ἀλλ’ ἢ τὸ σῶμα; καὶ οὐχ ἡ ψυχὴ, ψυχὴ τοίνυν οὐ πίπτει οὔτε θάπτεται, Epiphan. Hær. 67. §. 6. Nam & ipsum quod Mortuorum Resurrectio dicitur exigit defendi proprietates vocabulorum. Mortuorum itaque vocabulo non est nisi quod amisit animam, de cujus facultate vivebat. Corpus est quod amittit animam, & amittendo fit mortuum; ita mortui vocabulum corpori competit. Porro si resurrectio mortui est, mortuum autem non aliud est quam corpus, corporis erit resurrectio. Sic & Resurrectionis vocabulum non aliam rem vendicat quam quæ cecidit. Surgere enim potest dici & quod omnino non cecidit, quod semper retro jacuit. Resurgere autem non est nisi ejus quod cecidit. Iterum enim surgendo quia cecidit resurgere dicitur. Re enim syllaba iterationi semper adhibetur., Tertull. advers. Marcion. lib. 5. cap. 9. Sed & ipsum Resurrectionis vocabulum significat non aliud ruere, aliud resuscitari; & quod adjicitur Mortuorum carnem propriam demonstrat; quod enim in homine moritur hoc & vivificatur, S. Hieronym. Epist. 61.

52 The Rabbins use sometimes תקומה which is properly resurrection ἀνάστασις, according to that of our Saviour Talitha cumi: but more often they make use of תחיה, which is reviviscentia or ἀναβίωσις. And though they make a distinction somtimes between them, attributing the first to the wicked, the second to the just, yet it must not so be understood as if there could be a Reviviscency without a Resurrection, a תחיה without a תקומה, but that there is to the wicked a תקומה, which cannot so properly be called תחיה, because they rise not to the happinesse of eternall life.

53 Dan. 12. 2.

54 Joh. 5. 28.

55 Rev. 20. 13.

56 2 Cor. 5. 10.

57 Quam absurdum, quam vero & iniquũ, utrumque autem quam Deo indignum, aliam substantiam operari, aliam mercede dispungi, ut hæc quidem caro per martyria lanietur, alia vero coronetur: item è contrario hæc quidem caro in spurcitiis volutetur, alia vero damnetur? Nonne præstat omnem semel fidem à spe Resurrectionis abducere, quam de gravitate atque justitia Dei ludere, Marcionem pro Valentino resuscitari? Tertul. de Resurectione Carnis, cap. 56.

58 Matth. 10. 28.

59 1 Corinth. 6. 20.

60 1 Corinth. 6. 15, 19.

61 Rom. 8. 11.

62 1 Thes. 4. 16, 17.

63 Mat. 27. 52, 53.

64 Post dicta Domini facta etiam ejus quid sapere credamus de capulis, de sepulchris mortuos resuscitantis? cui rei istud? si ad simplicem ostentationem potestatis, aut ad præsentem gratiã redanimationis, non adeo magnum illi denuo morituros suscitare. Enimvero si ad fidem potius sequestrandum futuræ resurrectionis, ergo & illa corporalis præscribitur de documenti sui forma Tertul. de Res. car. c. 38. At ego Deum malo decipere non posse, de fallacia solummodo infirmũ; ne aliter documenta præmisisse quam rem disposuisse videatur, imo ne si exemplum resurrectionis sine carne non valuit inducere, multo magis plenitudinem exempli in eadem substantia exhibere non possit. Nullum vero exemplum majus est eo cujus exemplum est. Majus est autem si animæ cum corpore resuscitabuntur in documentum sine corpore resurgendi, ut tota hominis salus dimidiæ patrocinaretur; quando exemplorum conditio istud potius expeteret quod minus haberetur, animæ dico solius resurrectionem, velut gustum carnis resurrecturæ suo in tempore, Ibidem.

65 Joh. 2. 19.

66 Luc. 24. 39.

67 Phil. 3. 21.

68 This is recorded in the Bereshit Rabba. Vide Maimonidis Expl. 10. cap. Tract. Sanhedrin.

69 Act. 24 15.

70 Joh. 5. 29. Ἀνάστασις ζωῆς, & Ἀνάστασις κρίσεως. The first is called ἀνάστασις δικαίων, and therefore the second may as well be called ἀνάστασις ἀδίκων.

71 Luc. 14. 14.

72 Mat. 25. 34.

73 41.

74 1 Cor. 15. 22.

75 21.

76 Joh. 5. 28.

77 Mat. 25. 32.

78 Rom. 14. 10.

79 2 Cor. 5. 10.

80 2 Tim. 2. 18.

81 Nonnulli attendentes verba quæ assidue dicit Apostolus, Quia & mortui sumus cum Christo, & resurreximus cum eo; nec intelligentes quatenus dicatur, arbitrati sunt jam factam esse resurrectionem, nec ullam ulterius in fine temporum esse sperandam. Ex quibus est, inquit, Hymenæus & Philetus, qui circa veritatem aberraverunt, dicentes resurrectionem jam factam esse Idem Apostolus eos arguens detestatur, qui tamen dicit nos resurrexisse cum Christo, S. Aug. Epist. 119. ad Januarium. This was the Heresie of the Seleuciani or Hermiani, as the same Aug. testifieth, Hær. 59. Resurrectionem non putant futuram, sed quotidie fieri in generatione filiorum. Thus Tertullian relates of some Hereticks in his time, who made the Resurrection wholly Allegoricall, and yet pretended to believe a Resurrection in the flesh, but understood it in this life, at the Baptismall renovation, and so past when they professed to believe. Exinde ergo Resurrectionem fide consecutos cum Domino esse, cum eum in Baptismate induerint. Hoc denique ingenio etiam in colloquiis sæpe nostros decipere consueverunt, quasi & ipsi resurrectionem carnis admittant. Væ, inquiunt, qui non in hac carne resurrexit, ne statim illos percutiant, si resurrectionem statim abnuerint: tacite autem secundum conscientiam suam hoc sentiunt. Væ qui non, dum in hac carne est, cognoverit arcana hæretica, hoc enim apud illos resurrectio, Tertull de Resurrect. Carnis, cap. 19.

82 Joh. 11. 24.

83 Joh. 6. 39.

84 Mat. 13. 39.

85 1 Cor. 15. 52.

86 1 Thess. 4. 16.

87 Joh. 5. 28.

88 Act. 17. 31.

89 Isai. 66. 14.

90 2 Tim. 1. 10.

91 Hos. 13. 14.

92 1 Corinth. 15. 54, 57.

93 1 Thess. 4. 13.

94 Act. 24. 15, 16.

95 1 Cor. 15. 58.