Which was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary.
Article III. Which was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary.
These words, as they now stand, clearly distinguish the conception of Jesus from his nativity, attributing the first to the Holy Ghost, the second to the blessed Virgin; whereas the ancient Creeds made no such distinction, but without any particular expresse mention of the conception, had it onely in this manner, who1 was born by the Holy Ghost of the Virgin Mary; understanding by the word born, not only the nativity, but also the conception and generation. This is very necessary to be observed, because otherwise the addition of a word will prove the diminution of the sense of the Article. For they which speak onely of the operation of the Holy Ghost in Christs conception, and of the manner of his birth, leave out most part of that which was anciently understood under that one term of being born of the Holy Ghost, and of the Virgin Mary.
That therefore nothing may be omitted which is pertinent to expresse the full intent, and to comprehend the utmost signification of this Article, we shall consider three Persons mentioned, so farre as they are concerned in it. The first is He who was conceived and born; the second, He by whose energie or operation he was conceived; the third, She who did conceive and bear him.
For the first, the Relative in the front of this, carries us clearly back unto the former Article, and tells us that he which was thus conceived and born, was Jesus Christ the onely Son of God. And being we have already demonstrated, that this onely Son is therefore called so, because he was begotten by the Father from all eternity, and so of the same substance with him; it followeth that this Article at the first beginning, or by vertue of its connexion, can import no lesse then this most certain but miraculous truth, that He2 which was begotten by the Father before all worlds, was now in the fulnesse of time conceived by the Holy Ghost, and born of the Virgin Mary. Again, being by the conception and birth is to be understood whatsoever was done toward the production of the humane nature of our Saviour therefore the same Relative considered with the words which follow it, can speak no lesse then the Incarnation of that Person: and thus even in the entry of the Article we meet with the Incarnation of the Son of God; that great mystery wrapt up in that short sentence of S. John, The Word was made flesh.
Indeed this Pronoun hath relation not onely unto this but to the following Articles, which have their necessary connexion with, and foundation in this Third: for He who was conceived and born, and so made man, did in that humane nature suffer, die, and rise again. Now when we say this was the Word, and that Word was God, being whosoever is God, cannot cease to be so; it must necessarily follow, that he was made man by joyning the humane nature with the Divine. But then we must take heed lest we conceive, because the Divine nature belongeth to the Father, to which the humane is conjoyned, that therefore the Father should be incarnate, or conceiv’d and born. For as certainly as the Son was crucified, and the Son alone, so certainly the same Son was incarnate, and that Son alone. Although the humane nature was conjoyned with the Divinity, which is the nature common to the Father and the Son, yet was that union made onely in the person of the Son. Which Doctrine is to be observed against the Heresy of the Patripassians,3 which was both very ancient and farre diffus’d; making the Father to be incarnate, and becoming man to be crucified. But this very Creed was alwayes4 thought to be a sufficient confutation of that fond opinion, in that the Incarnation is not subjoyned to the first, but to the second Article; we do not say, I believe in God the Father Almighty, which was conceived, but in his onely Son our Lord, which was conceived by the Holy Ghost.
First then we believe that He which was made flesh was the Word, that He which took upon him the nature of man was not the Father, nor the Holy Ghost, nor any other Person but the onely begotten Son. And when we say that Person was conceived and born, we declare he was made really and truly man, of the same humane nature, which is in all other men, who by the ordinary way of generation are conceived and born. For the Mediatour between God and man, is the man Christ Jesus.5 That since by man came death, by man also should come the resurrection of the dead.6 As sure then as the first Adam, and we who are redeem’d are men, so certainly is the second Adam and our Mediatour man. He is therefore frequently called the Son of man, and in that nature he was alwayes promised: first to Eve, as her seed, and consequently her son;7 then to Abraham, in thy seed shall all the8 nations of the earth be blessed, and that seed is Christ,9 and so he is the Son of Abraham. Next to David as his son to sit upon his throne, and so he is made of the seed of David according to the flesh,10 the son of David, the son of Abraham,11 and consequently of the same nature with David and with Abraham. And as he was their son, so are we his brethren, as descending from the same Father Adam; and therefore it behoved him to be made like unto his brethren.12 For he laid not hold on the Angels, but on the seed of Abraham, and so became not an Angel, but a man.
As then man consisteth of two different parts, Body and Soul, so doth Christ; He assumed a body at his conception, of the blessed Virgin. Forasmuch as the children are partakers of flesh and bloud, he also himself likewise took part of the same.13 The verity of his body stands upon the truth of his nativity;14 and the actions and passions of his life shew the nature of his flesh.
He was first born with a body which was prepared for him, of the same appearance with those of other infants, he grew up by degrees, and was so farre from being sustained without accustomed nutrition of our bodies, that he was observed even by his enemies to come eating and drinking, and when he did not so, he suffered hunger and thirst. Those plowers never doubted of the true nature of his flesh, who plowed upon his back, and made long furrows. The thornes which pricked his sacred temples, the nailes which penetrated through his hands and feet, the spear which pierced his sacred side, give sufficient testimony of the naturall tendernesse and frailty of his flesh. And lest his fasting forty dayes together, lest his walking on the waters and traversing the seas, lest his suddain standing in the midst of his disciples when the doores were shut, should raise an opinion that his body was not true and proper flesh; he confirmed first his own Disciples, feel and see, that a spirit hath not flesh and bones as you see me have.15
As therefore we believe the coming of Christ, so must we confesse him to have come in the verity of our humane nature, even in true and proper flesh. With this determinate expression was it alwayes necessary to acknowledge him: For every spirit that confesseth Jesus Christ come in the flesh, is of God, and every spirit that confesseth not Jesus Christ come in the flesh, is not of God.16 This spirit appeared early in opposition to the Apostolicall doctrine, and Christ who is both God and man, was as soon denied to be man, as God. Simon Magus17 the Arch-heretick first began, and many after followed him.
And certainly if the Son of God would vouchsafe to take the frailty of our flesh, he would not omit the nobler part, our soul, without which he could not be man. For Jesus encreased in wisdome and stature,18 one in respect of his body, the other of his soul. Wisdome belongeth not to the flesh, nor can the knowledge of God, which is infinite, encrease: he then whose knowledge did improve together with his yeares, must have a subject proper for it, which was no other then a humane soul. This was the seat of his finite understanding, and directed will, distinct from the will of his father, and consequently of his divine nature, as appeareth by that known submission, not my will but thine be done.19 This was the subject of those affections and passions which so manifestly appeared in him; nor spake he any other then a proper language, when before his suffering he said, My soul is exceeding sorrowfull, even unto death.20 This was it which on the crosse before the departure from the body, he recommended to the Father, teaching us in whose hands the soules of the departed are, For when Jesus had cried with a loud voice, he said, Father into thy hands I commend my spirit, and having said thus, he gave up the ghost.21 And as his death was nothing else but the separation of the soul from his body, so the life of Christ as man, did consist in the conjunction and vitall union of that soul with the body. So that he which was perfect God, was also perfect man, of a reasonable soul and humane flesh subsisting. Which is to be observed and asserted against the ancient22 Hereticks, who taught that Christ assumed humane flesh, but that the Word or his Divinity was unto that body in the place of an informing soul.
Thus the whole perfect and complete nature of man was assumed by the Word, by him who was conceived and born of a woman, and so made a man. And being the Divine nature which he had before, could never cease to be what before it was, nor ever become what before it was not; therefore he who was God before by the Divine Nature which he had, was in this Incarnation made man by that humane nature which he then assumed. And thus this third Article from the conjunction with the second, teacheth us no lesse, then the two natures really distinct in Christ incarnate.
For if both natures were not preserved complete and distinct in Christ, it must be either by the conversion and transubstantiation of one into the other, or by commixtion and confusion of both into one. But neither of these wayes can consist with the Person of our Saviour, or the Office of our Mediatour. For if we should conceive such a mixtion and confusion of substances as to make an union of natures, we should be so farre from acknowledging him to be both God and Man, that thereby we should professe him to be neither God, nor Man, but a Person of a nature as different from both, as all mixt bodies are distinct from each element which concurres unto their composition. Besides we know there were in Christ the affections proper to the nature of man, and all those infirmities which belong to us, and cannot be conceived to belong to that nature of which the Divine was but a part. Nor could our humanity be so commixed or confounded with the Divinity of our Saviour, but that the Father had been made man as much as the Son, because the divine nature is the same both of the Father and the Son. Nor ought we to have so low23 an esteem of that infinite and independent being, as to think it so commixed with, or immersed in the creature.
Again, as the confusion, so the conversion of natures is impossible. For first, we cannot with the least shew of probability conceive the divine nature of Christ to be transubstantiated into the humane nature; as those whom they call Flandrian Anabaptists24 in the Low Countryes at this day maintain. There is a plain repugnancy even in the supposition, for the nature of man must be made, the nature of God cannot be made, and consequently cannot become the nature of man. The immateriall, indivisible, and immortall Godhead cannot be divided into a spirituall and incorruptible soul, and a carnall and corruptible body, of which two humanity consisteth. There is no other Deity of the Father then of the Son, and therefore if this was converted into that humanity, then was the Father also that man, and grew in knowledge, suffered, and died, and for three dayes there was no living God. We must not therefore so farre stand upon the propriety of speech, when it is written, The Word25 was made flesh, as to destroy the propriety both of the Word and of the flesh.
Secondly, we must not on the contrary invent a conversion of the humane nature into the divine, as the Eutychians of old did fancy. For sure the Incarnation could not at first consist in such a conversion, it being inimaginable how that which had no being should be made by being turned into something else. Therefore the humanity of Christ could not at the first be made by being the Divinity of the Word. Nor is the Incarnation so preposterously expressed, as if the flesh were made the Word, but that the Word was made flesh. And if the manhood were not in the first act of Incarnation converted into the divine nature, as we see it could not be, then is there no pretence of any time or manner in or by which it was afterward26 so transubstantiated. Vain therefore was that old conceit of Eutyches, who thought the Union to be made so in the natures, that the humanity was absorp’d and wholly turn’d into the Divinity, so that by that transubstantiation the humane nature had no longer being. And well did the Ancient Fathers, who oppos’d this Heresy, make use of the Sacramentall union between the bread and wine, and the body and bloud of Christ, and thereby shewed, that the humane nature of Christ is no more really converted into the divinity, and so ceaseth to be the humane nature; then the substance of the bread and wine is really converted into the substance of the body and bloud, and thereby cease to be both bread and wine. From whence it is by the way observable, that the Church in those dayes understood no such doctrine as that of Transubstantiation.27
Being then He which is conceived was the onely Son of God, and that onely Son begotten of the substance of the Father, and so alwayes subsisted in the divine nature; being by the same conception he was made truly man, and consequently assum’d an humane nature; being these two natures cannot be made one either by commixtion or conversion, and yet there can be but one Christ subsisting in them both, because that onely Son was he which is conceived and born; it followeth, that the Union which was not made in the nature, was made in the person of the Word: that is, it was not so made, that out of both natures one onely should result; but onely so, that to one Person no other should be added.
Nor is this Union only a scholastick speculation, but a certain & necessary truth, without which we cannot have one Christ, but two Christs, one Mediatour, but two Mediatours; without which we cannot joyn the second Article of our Creed with the third, making them equally belong to the same person; without which we cannot interpret the sacred Scriptures, or understand the History of our Saviour. For certainly He which was before Abraham, was in the dayes of Herod born of a woman; He which preached in the dayes of Noah, began to preach in the reign of Tiberius, being at that time about thirty yeares of age; He was demonstrated the Son of God with power, who was the seed of David according to the flesh; He who died on the Crosse, raised him from the dead who died so, being put to death through the flesh, and quickened by the Spirit;28 He was of the fathers according to the flesh, who was God over all blessed for ever.29 Being these and the like actions and affections cannot come from the same nature, and yet must be attributed to the same person; as we must acknowledge a diversity of natures united, so must we confesse the identity of the Person in whom they are conjoyned, against the ancient Heresy of the Nestorians,30 condemned in the Council of Ephesus.
1 Qui natus est de Spiritu Sancto ex Maria Virgine. Ruffinus in Symb. S. Aug. Ench. ad Laurent. c. 34 37. & 38. Natus de Spiritu S. & Maria Virgine, as also the Council of Francford in Sacrosyllabo. S. Aug. de Fide & Symb. Natus est per Spiritum S. ex Virgine Maria. S. Leo. Epist. 10. c. 2. Maximus Taurin. Chrysol. Etherius Uxam. Author Symbol. ad Catechum. Qui natus est de Spiritu S. ex Maria Virgine. So also Venantius Fortunatus. From whence Fulgentius de Fide ad Petrum Diaconum. Natum de Spiritu S. ex Maria Virgine, in Symbolo acceptum, & corde ad justitiam credit, & ore ad salutem S. Ecclesia confitetur. And Alcuinus l. 3. de Trinit. c. 1. Dicitur in Symbolo Catholicæ fidei, quod Christus de Spiritu S. & ex Maria Virgine sit natus. In the Ancient MSS. transcribed by the learned Archbishop of Armagh, τὸν γεννηθέντα ἐκ πνεύματος ἁγίου καὶ Μαρίας τῆς παρθένου. These words omitted in the Nicene Creed, were put in by the Council of Constantinople, upon the occasion of the Apollinarian Heresy, as was observed by Diogenes Bishop of Cyzicum in the Council of Chalcedon, Οἱ γὰρ ἅγιοι πατέρες οἱ μετὰ ταῦτα, τὸ ἐσαρκώθη, ὃ εἶπον οἱ ἅγιοι ἐν Νικαίᾳ πατέρες, ἐσαφήνισαν εἰπόντες, ἐκ πνεύματος ἁγίου καὶ Μαρίας τῆς παρθένου. In the severall expositions among the sermons de Tempore, falsly attributed to S. Aug. Qui conceptus est de Spiritu S. natus ex Virgine Maria. So Eusebius Gallicanus Homil. de Symbolo. And from thence it hath so continued, as we now read it, Which was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary.
2 Huic, quem dudum de Patre natum ineffabiliter didicisti, nunc à Sp. S. templum fabricatum intra secreta uteri Virginalis intellige. Ruff.
3 The Heresy of the Patripassians seems onely to have relation to the suffering of our Saviour, because the word signifies no more then the Passion of the Father. But it is founded in an errour concerning the Incarnation, it being out of question, that he which was made man did suffer. Epiphanius observes, Noetus was the first which taught this Heresy, who lived 130 yeares before him, and when he was questioned for it he denied it. διὰ τὸ μηδένα πρὸ αὐτοῦ ἐξεμέσαι ταύτην τὴν πικρίαν. But certainly this Heresy was ancienter then Noetus; for the Patripassiani are named by S. Cyprian, Epist. 73. and Tertullian his Master chargeth it upon Praxeas: Duo negotia Diaboli Praxeas Romæ procuravit, Prophetiam expulit, & Hæresim intulit; Paracletum fugavit, & Patrem crucifixit. Adv. Prax. c. 1. And expressing the absurdity of that opinion, Itaque post tempus Pater natus & Pater passus, ipse Deus Dominus Omnipotens Jesus Christus prædicatur. c. 2. And De Præsc. adv. Hæret. Post hos omnes etiam Praxeas quidam Hæresim introduxit, quam Victorinus corroborare curavit. Hic Deum Patrem omnipotentem Jesum Christum esse dicit, hunc crucifixum passumque contendit; mortuum præterea seipsum sibi sedere ad dexteram suam cum profana & sacrilega temeritate proponit. c. 53. After Praxeas Noetus taught the same, ἐτόλμησε λέγειν τὸν πατέρα πεπονθέναι, sayes Epiphanius, and being questioned for it, he answered, τί γὰρ κακὸν πεποίηκα; ἕνα θεὸν δοξάζω, ἕνα ἐπίσταμαι, καὶ οὐκ ἄλλον πλὴν αὐτοῦ γεννηθέντα, πεπονθότα, ἀποθανόντα. He thought the Father and the Son to be the same Person, and therefore if the Son, the Father to be incarnate. Υἱοπάτορα τὸν Χριστὸν ἐδίδαξε, τὸν αὐτὸν εἶναι πατέρα καὶ υἱὸν καὶ ἅγιον πνεῦμα. Epi. h. Anaceph. After the Noetiani followed the Sabelliani. So Philastrius, Sabellius Discipulus ejus, qui similitudinem sui Doctoris itidem secutus est, unde & Sabelliani postea sunt appellati, qui & Patripassiani, & Praxeani à Praxea, & Hermogeniani ab Hermogene, qui fuerunt in Affrica, qui & ista sentientes abjecti sunt ab Ecclesia Catholica. So S. Aug. Sabelliani dicti sunt quidam Hæretici, qui vocantur & Patripassiani, qui dicunt ipsum Patrem passum esse. Tract. 36. in Joh. This I confesse is denied by Epiphanius, who acknowledges Sabellius to have followed Noetus in many things, but not in the Incarnation or Passion of the Father. Σαβελλιανοὶ οἱ τὰ ὅμοια ἀνοήτως (l. ἀνοήτοις id est Νοητιανοῖς, vel ἀνοήτῳ, id est, Νοητῷ, as S. Aug. Novato.) δοξάζοντες, παρὰ τοῦτο μόνον· λέγουσι γὰρ μὴ πεπονθέναι τὸν πατέρα. This S. Augustine wonders very much at in Epiphanius, Sabelliani, inquit, similia Noeto dogmatizantes, præter hoc quod dicunt Patrem non esse passum; quomodo de Sabellianis intelligi potest, cum sic innotuerint dicere Patrem passum, ut Patripassiani quam Sabelliani sæpius nuncupentur? Aug. Hær. 41. Indeed the Latine Fathers generally call the Sabellians Patripassians, and not onely so, but Theodoret doth so describe them, as professing one Person, ἐν μὲν τῇ παλαιᾷ, ὡς πατέρα νομοθετῆσαι, ἐν δὲ τῇ καινῇ, ὡς υἱὸν ἐνανθρωπῆσαι. l. 2. c. 9. After the Sabelliani succeeded in the same Heresy the Priscillianistæ, as appeareth by Pope Leo, who shews they taught but one Person of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. Quod blasphemiæ genus de Sabellii opinione sumpserunt, cujus discipuli etiam Patripassiani merito nuncupantur, quia si ipse est Filius qui & Pater, crux Filii Patris est passio, & quicquid in forma servi Filius Patri obediendo sustinuit, totum in se Pater ipse suscepit. Ep. 93. c. 1. Thus the Patripassian Heresy beginning from Praxeas and Hermogenes, was continued by Noetus, Sabellius, and Priscillianus, and mingled with all their severall Heresies: the summe and substance of which, is thus well set down by Victorinus. Patripassiani Deum solum esse dicunt, quem nos Patrem dicimus; ipsum solum existentem & effectorem omnium, & venisse non solum in mundum, sed & in carnem, & alia omnia quæ nos Filium fecisse dicimus.
4 It appeareth plainly that Tertullian confuted Praxeas, by reducing him to these words of the Creed. For when he had first declared, Nos unicum quidem Deum credimus (which was the objection of Praxeas) sub hac tamen dispensatione, quam οἰκονομίαν dicimus, ut unici Dei sit & Filius sermo ipsius, qui ex ipso processerit, per quem omnia facta sunt, & sine quo factum est nihil. Then he subjoyneth, Hunc missum à Patre in Virginem, & ex ea natum hominem & Deum, filium hominis, & filium Dei, & cognominatum Jesum Christum. Hunc passum, hunc mortuũ, & sepultum secundum Scripturas, & resuscitatum à Patre, & in cœlos resumptum, sedere ad dextram Patris, venturum judicare vivos & mortuos. And that we may be assured that he used these words out of the Creed, it followeth, Hanc Regulam ab initio Evangelii decucurrisse, &c. This is yet further evident out of Epiphanius who tells us the Eastern Doctours confuted Noetus in the same manner, by reducing him to the words of the Creed. Ἕνα Θεὸν δοξάζομεν καὶ αὐτοὶ, (just as Tertullian, nos unicum quidem Deum credimus) ἀλλ’ ὡς οἴδαμεν δικαίως δοξάζειν· καὶ ἕνα Χριστὸν ἔχομεν, ἀλλ’ ὡς οἴδαμεν ἕνα Χριστὸν υἱὸν Θεοῦ, παθόντα ὡς ἔπαθεν, ἀποθανόντα καθὼς ἀπέθανεν, ἀναστάντα, ἀνελθόντα εἰς τὸν οὐρανὸν, ὄντα ἐν δεξιᾷ τοῦ πατρὸς, ἐρχόμενον κρῖναι ζῶντας καὶ νεκρούς. And when the Argument of Tertullian against Praxeas, and the Greeks against Noetus drawn from the Creed, did not sufficiently convince the Patripassians, the Church of Aquileia to exclude them wholly, added these two words to the first Article, Invisibilem, and Impassibilem. Invisibilem, to shew he was not incarnate, Impassibilem, to shew he was not crucified. So Ruffinus in the conclusion of his exposition upon these words Credo in Deum Patrem omnipotentem, addeth, His additur invisibilem & impassibilem; and then gives the reason, Sciendum quod duo isti sermones in Ecclesiæ Romanæ Symbolo non habentur. Constat autem apud nos additos hæreseos causa Sabellii, illius profecto quæ à nostris Patripassiana appellatur, id est, quæ Patrem ipsum vel ex Virgine natum dicit, & visibilem factum, vel passum affirmat in carne. Ut ergo excluderetur talis impietas de Patre, videntur hæc addidisse majores, & invisibilem Patrem atque impassibilem dixisse. Constat enim Filium, non Patrem, in carne & ex carne natum, & ex nativitate carnis Filium visibilem & passibilem factum.
5 1 Tim. 2.5.
6 1 Cor. 15.21.
7 Gen. 3.15.
8 Gen. 22.18.
9 Gal. 3.6.
10 Rom. 1.3.
11 Mat. 1.1.
12 Heb. 2.17.
13 Heb. 2.14.
14 Marcion ut carnem Christi negaret, negavit etiam nativitatem; aut ut nativitatem negaret, negavit & carnem, scilicet ne invicem sibi testimonium redderent, & responderent nativitas & caro. quia nec nativitas sine carne, nec caro sine nativitate. Tertull. de Carne Christi. c. 1.
15 Lu. 24.39.
16 1 Jo. 4.2, 3.
17 Simon Magus first made himself to be Christ, and what he feigned of himself, that was attributed by others unto Christ. Dixerat se in monte Sina legem Moysi in Patris persona dedisse Judæis, tempore Tiberii in Filii persona putative apparuisse. S. Aug. So S. Cyril represents him, οὐκ ἐν σαρκὶ, ἀλλὰ δοκήσει ὡς Χριστὸν Ἰησοῦν φανέντα. Catech. 6. From this δόκησις of his invention arose the Heresy of the Δοκηταί. For Saturnilus, or Saturninus, followed him with his putative tantum hominem, as Irenæus; and in phantasmate tantum venisse, as Tertullian speaks. After him Valentinus, and his followers, Epiphanes, Isidorus, and Secundus: then the Marcosians, Heracleonitæ, and Ophitæ, Cerdon, Marcion, Lucanus, and generally the Maniches. These were the Δοκηταὶ or Φαντασιασταὶ, all conspiring in this, that Christ was not really what he appeared, nor did truly suffer what he seemed to endure.
18 Luk. 2.52.
19 Luk. 22.42.
20 Mat. 26.38.
21 Luk. 23.46.
22 Of this kind two severall sects were most remarkable, the Arians, and the Apollinarians. Arius taught that Christ had nothing of man but the flesh, and with that the word was joyned. Ἄρειος δὲ σάρκα μόνην πρὸς ἀποκρυφὴν τῆς θεότητος ὁμολογεῖ. ἀντὶ δὲ τοῦ ἔσωθεν ἐν ἡμῖν ἀνθρώπου, τουτέστι τῆς ψυχῆς, τὸν Λόγον ἐν τῇ σαρκὶ λέγει γεγονέναι. Athan. de Adv. Christi. Eunomius followed him in this particular. Ἄρειος δὲ καὶ Εὐνόμιος σῶμα μὲν αὐτὸν ἔφασαν εἰληφέναι, θεότητα δὲ ψυχῆς ἐνηργηκέναι τὴν χρείαν. Theodo. l. 5. cont. Hær. c. 11. Apollinarius distinguished between the soul and the mind, the ψυχὴ and the νοῦς, and acknowledged that the Word assumed the body and the soul or ψυχὴ of man, but not the mind or spirit, or the Νοῦς, but the Word it self was in the place of that. Apollinaristas Apollinaris instituit, qui de anima Christi ab Ecclesia Catholica dissenserunt, dicentes sicut Ariani, Deum Christum carnem sine anima suscepisse. In quæstione testimoniis Evangelicis victi, mentem qua rationalis est anima hominis, non fuisse in anima Christi, sed pro hac ipsum Verbum in ea fuisse dixerunt. This was then the clear difference betwixt the Arian and Apollinarian Heresy. Apollinaristæ quidem carnis & animæ naturam sine mente assumpsisse Deum credunt, Ariani vero carnis tantummodo. Facundus l. 9. So that two things are to be observed in the Apollinarians, their philosophy and their Divinity; their Philosophy in making man consist of three distinct parts, the body, the soul, and the mind; their Divinity in making the humane nature of Christ to consist but of two, the body and the soul, and the third to be supplied by the Word. Which is excellently expressed by Nemesius, de Nat. Hom. in respect of his Philosophy. Τινὲς μὲν, ὧν ἐστὶ καὶ Πλωτῖνος, ἄλλην εἶναι τὴν ψυχὴν, καὶ ἄλλον τὸν νοῦν δογματίσαντες, ἐκ τριῶν τὸν ἄνθρωπον συνεστάναι βούλονται, σώματος, καὶ ψυχῆς, καὶ νοῦ. Οἷς ἠκολούθησε καὶ Ἀπολλινάριος ὁ τῆς Λαοδικείας γενόμενος ἐπίσκοπος, τοῦτον γὰρ πηξάμενος τὸν θεμέλιον τῆς οἰκείας δόξης, καὶ τὰ λοιπὰ προσωκοδόμησε κατὰ τὸ οἰκεῖον δόγμα. and by Theodoret in respect of his Divinity, Σαρκωθῆναι δὲ τὸν θεὸν ἔφησε λόγον, σῶμα καὶ ψυχὴν ἀνειληφότα οὐ τὴν λογικὴν, ἀλλὰ τὴν ἄλογον, ἣν φυσικὴν, ἤγουν ζωτικὴν, τινὲς ὀνομάζουσι. τὸν δὲ νοῦν ἄλλο τι παρὰ τὴν ψυχὴν εἶναι λέγων, οὐκ ἔφησεν ἀνειλῆφθαι, ἀλλ’ ἀρκέσαι τὴν θείαν φύσιν εἰς τὸ πληρῶσαι τοῦ νοῦ τὴν χρείαν.
23 Absit ita credere, ut conflatili quodam genere duas naturas in unam arbitremur redactas esse substantiam, hujusmodi enim commixtio partis utriusque corruptio est. Deus enim qui capax est non capabilis, penetrans non penetrabilis, implens non implebilis, qui ubique simul totus, & ubique diffusus est per infusionem potentiæ suæ, misericorditer naturæ mixtus est humanæ, non humana natura naturæ est mixta divinæ. Leporius Libel. Emend.
24 Teste Episcopio Inst. Theolog. l. 4. c. 8.
25 In that proposition ὁ λόγος σὰρξ ἐγένετο there hath been strange force used by men of contrary judgements, and for contrary ends, as to the word ἐγένετο. The Socinians endeavouring to prove, it can have no other sense then simply fuit, the word was flesh. These Flandrian Anabaptists stretching it to the highest sense of factum est. The Word was made flesh. It is confessed that the verb γίνεσθαι in the use of the Greek language is capable of either interpretation: it is also acknowledged that the most ancient Interpreters were divided in their renditions. For the Syriack rendred it ומלתא בסרא הוא. Et verbum caro fuit. The Ancient Latine, Et Verbum caro factum est. It cannot be denied but in the Scriptures it hath been used indifferently in either sense. And the same old Vulgar Translation in some places renders it, as the Syriack does here. Mat. 10. 16. γίνεσθε οὖν φρόνιμοι ὡς οἱ ὄφεις, Estote ergo prudentes sicut serpentes. and 25. Ἀρκετὸν τῷ μαθητῇ ἵνα γίνηται ὡς ὁ διδάσκαλος αὐτοῦ, Sufficit discipulo ut sit sicut magister ejus. From whence ’tis evident that they placed not the force in the signification of the word γίνεσθαι, but in the circumstance of the matter in which ’twas used. Howsoever neither of these interpretations prove either of these opinions; for if it be acknowledged that the Word was flesh, and it hath been already proved, and presupposed by S. John in his precedent discourse, that the Word had a former being antecedent to his being flesh; it followeth, that He which was before the word, and was not flesh, if after he were flesh, must be made such. And so the Socinian observation falls. Again, if he which was made flesh was the Word, and after he was made such was still the word, as certainly he was, and is still the same; then his being made or becoming flesh, can no way evacuate that nature in which he did before subsist. And so the Flandrian interpretation is of no validity.
26 This was the proper opinion of Eutyches, as appeareth by his own confession in the Council of Chalcedon. Ὁμολογῶ ἐκ δύο φύσεων γεγενῆσθαι τὸν Κύριον ἡμῶν πρὸ τῆς ἑνώσεως, μετὰ δὲ τὴν ἕνωσιν μίαν φύσιν ὁμολογῶ. Act. 1. Two distinct natures he confessed at first, but when the union was once made, he acknowledged but one. But when that union was made he expressed not, nor could his followers agree, some attributing it to the conception, some to the resurrection, others to the Ascension. Howsoever when they were united, his opinion clearly was, that the humane nature was so absorpt into the divine, so wholly made the same, that it ceased wholly to be what it was, and so there was but one, that is the divine nature remained. This is sufficiently expressed by S. Leo who was the strongest opposer of him, and speaketh thus of his opinion, Ser. 8. de Nativ. Hic autem recentioris sacrilegii profanus assertor, unitionem quidem in Christo duarum confessus est naturarum; sed ipsa unione id dixit effectum, ut ex duabus una remaneret, nullatenus alterius existente substantia. And the Eranistes in the Dialogue of Theodoret disputing in his name, being urged to declare whether in that union one nature was made of them both, or one remaining the other did not so; Answered plainly, Ἐγὼ τὴν θεότητα λέγω μεμενηκέναι, καταποθῆναι δὲ ὑπὸ ταύτης τὴν ἀνθρωπότητα.
27 There can be no time in which we may observe the Doctrine of the Ancients so clearly, as when they write professedly against an Heresy evidently known, and make use generally of the same Arguments against it. Now what the Heresy of Eutyches was, is certainly known, and the nature of the Sacrament was generally made use of as an Argument to confute it. Gelasius Bishop of Rome hath written an excellent book against Eutyches De duabus naturis in Christo. In which he propoundeth their opinion thus. Eutychiani dicunt unam esse naturam, id est, divinam. And sola existente Deitate, humanitas illic esse jam destitit. That then which he disputes against, is the Transubstantiation of the humane nature into the divine. The Argument which he makes use of against it, is drawn from the Eucharist. Certe Sacramenta quæ sumimus corporis & sanguinis Christi divina res est, propter quod & per eadem divinæ efficimur consortes naturæ: & tamen esse non desinit substantia vel natura panis & vini. Et certe imago & similitudo corporis & sanguinis Christi in actione mysteriorum celebrantur. Satis ergo nobis evidenter ostenditur, hoc nobis ipso Christo Domino sentiendum, quod in ejus imagine profitemur, celebramus, & sumus, ut sicut in hanc, scilicet, in divinam transeant; S. Spiritu perficiente substantiam, permanentes tamen in suæ proprietate naturæ, sic illud ipsum mysterium principale, cujus nobis efficientiam virtutemque veraciter representant, ex quibus constat propriè permanentibus, unum Christum quia integrum verumque permanere demonstrant. In which words ’tis plain he affirmes the union of the Humane nature of Christ to be the principall mystery, the representation of that mystery to be in the Sacrament of the Eucharist; he concludes from thence, that as in the representation, the substance of the bread and wine remaineth in the propriety of their own nature, so the humane nature of Christ in the greater mystery doth still remain. In the margin of this place in the Bibliotheca Patrum there is printed Cautè, as if there could be any danger in observing the sense of the Fathers, when they speak so expresly and considerately. In the same manner we find a Disputation between an Heretick and a Catholick in the second Dialogue of Theodoret, where Eranistes as an Heretick asks Orthodoxus, by what names he calls the bread and wine after consecration, who answers, the Body and Bloud of Christ; From whence Eranistes argues, Ὥσπερ τοίνυν τὰ σύμβολα τοῦ δεσποτικοῦ σώματός τε καὶ αἵματος, ἄλλα μέν εἰσι πρὸ τῆς ἱερατικῆς ἐπικλήσεως, μετὰ δέ γε τὴν ἐπίκλησιν μεταβάλλεται καὶ ἕτερα γίνεται, οὕτω τὸ δεσποτικὸν σῶμα μετὰ τὴν ἀνάληψιν, εἰς τὴν οὐσίαν μετεβλήθη τὴν θείαν. As the Symbols of the body and bloud of Christ are one thing before consecration, and after that change their name and become another, so the body of Christ after his ascention is changed into the divine substance. To this Orthodoxus answers, Ἑάλως αἷς ὕφηνες ἄρκυσιν. You are taken in your own nets. Οὐδὲ γὰρ μετὰ τὸν ἁγιασμὸν τὰ μυστικὰ σύμβολα τῆς οἰκείας ἐξίσταται φύσεως, μένει γὰρ ἐπὶ τῆς προτέρας οὐσίας, καὶ τοῦ σχήματος καὶ τοῦ εἴδους, καὶ ὁρατά ἐστι καὶ ἁπτὰ, οἷα καὶ πρότερον ἦν. The bread and wine even after consecration leave not their own nature, but remain in their former substance, shape, and form. In the same manner, καὶ ἐκεῖνο τὸ σῶμα τὸ μὲν πρότερον εἶδος ἔχει καὶ σχῆμα καὶ περιγραφὴν, καὶ ἁπαξαπλῶς εἰπεῖν, τὴν τοῦ σώματος οὐσίαν. The body of Christ hath the same form, figure and shape, and indeed the same bodily substance. And when Eranistes still objects, that the bread is called the body and not bread, Orthodoxus answers that he is mistaken. Οὐ γὰρ σῶμα μόνον ἀλλὰ καὶ ἄρτος ζωῆς ὀνομάζεται, οὕτως αὐτὸς ὁ Κύριος προσηγόρευσε, καὶ αὐτὸ δὲ σῶμα θεῖον ὀνομάζομεν σῶμα. For it is not onely called the body, but also bread of life, and the body it self we call the divine body. Who sees not then that Theodoret believed no more that the bread is converted into the body, then that the body is converted into the divinity of Christ? Who perceives not that he thought the bread to be as substantially and really bread after the consecration, as the body of Christ is really a body after his ascension? The same Argument is used by S. Chrysostome upon the same occasion against the Apollinarians in his Epistle ad Cæsarium, not yet published in Greek, and by Ephraimus in Photii Bibliotheca against the Eutychians. As therefore all the μεταστοιχείωσις of the Sacramentall elements maketh them not cease to be of the same nature which before they were, so the humane nature of Christ joyned to the divine looseth not the nature of humanity, but continueth with the Divinity as a substance in it self distinct, and so Christ doth subsist not onely ex but in duabus naturis, as the Council of Chalcedon determined against Eutyches.
28 1 Pet. 3.18.
29 Rom. 9.5.
30 This Heresy doth most formally contradict these words of the Creed, because it immediately denies this truth, that the eternall Son of God was conceived and born. And in vain did Nestorius seek not onely to avoid it in the Nicene Creed, but to make use of the words of the Creed even against the Unity of the Person of Christ. S. Cyril had well objected the series, order and consequence of that Confession. Ἔφη ἡ ἁγία καὶ μεγάλη Σύνοδος αὐτὸν τὸν ἐκ Θεοῦ Πατρὸς κατὰ φύσιν υἱὸν μονογενῆ, τὸν ἐκ Θεοῦ ἀληθινοῦ Θεὸν ἀληθινὸν, τὸ φῶς τὸ ἐκ τοῦ φωτὸς, τὸν δι’ οὗ τὰ πάντα πεποίηκεν ὁ Πατὴρ, κατελθεῖν, σαρκωθῆναί τε καὶ ἐνανθρωπῆσαι, παθεῖν, ἀναστῆναι τῇ τρίτῃ ἡμέρᾳ, καὶ ἀνελθεῖν εἰς οὐρανούς. The strength of this objection lies in this, that Christ the onely-begotten Son, begotten of the Father before all worlds, was incarnate. The answer of Nestorius was in this manner. Πιστεύομεν εἰς τὸν Κύριον ἡμῶν Ἰησοῦν Χριστὸν, τὸν υἱὸν αὐτοῦ τὸν μονογενῆ. σκόπησον ὅπως Ἰησοῦς, Χριστὸς, καὶ μονογενὴς, καὶ υἱὸς πρότερον θέντες, τὰ κοινὰ τῆς θεότητος καὶ ἀνθρωπότητος, ὡς θεμελίους, ὀνόματα, τότε τὴν τῆς ἐνανθρωπήσεως, καὶ τοῦ πάθους, καὶ τῆς ἀναστάσεως ἐποικοδομοῦσι παράδοσιν. And the strength, or rather the weaknesse thereof is this: that first the Council placed the name of Jesus, Christ, and the onely-begotten Son, names common to the divinity and humanity of Christ, and then upon them built the doctrine of his Incarnation. Whereas it is evident that, supposing the onely-begotten a terme common to the humanity and divinity, yet the Council clearly expounds it of the eternall generation, adding immediately, begotten of his Father before all worlds; neither is there any word between that exposition and the Incarnation, but such as speak wholly of Christ as God. Therefore that onely-begotten Son, who was begotten of his Father before all worlds, descended from heaven and was incarnate. Thus S. Cyril in his second Epistle to Nestorius, and Nestorius in his second to him. Which mistake of his seemes yet more strange to me, when I consider in the same Epistle of Nestorius that fundamentall truth asserted, which of it self sufficiently, nay fully, confutes his Heresy. For he acknowledgeth the name Christ to be ἀπαθοῦς καὶ παθητῆς οὐσίας ἐν μοναδικῷ προσώπῳ προσηγορίαν σημαντικὴν, and consequently Christ himself to be a single Person in a double nature, passible and impassible: which once granted, it evidently followeth, that he which was born from eternity was also born in time, for by those severall nativities, he had those severall natures; that he which was impassible as God, might and did suffer as man, because the same Person was of an impassible and a passible nature, impassible, as God, passible, as man. Wherefore by that which Nestorius hath confessed, and notwithstanding that which he hath objected, it is evident out of the Nicene Creed, that the Son of God, begotten of his Father before all worlds, was incarnate, and made man; and as evident out of the Apostles Creed, especially expounded by the Nicene, that the same onely-begotten Son was conceived by the Holy Ghost, and born of the Virgin Mary.