BY THE HOLY GHOST.
Article III. Which was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary.
Having thus dispatch’d the consideration of the first Person concerned in this Article, and the actions contained in it so farre as distinctly from the rest they belong to him, we descend unto the other two concerned in the same, and first to him whose operation did precede in the conception, the Holy Ghost. Which second part some may think to require a threefold consideration, first, of the conception, secondly, of the person, thirdly, of the operation. But for the person or existence of the Holy Ghost, that is here onely mentioned obliquely, and therefore to be reserved for another Article where it is propounded directly. And for the Conception it self, that belongeth not so properly to the Holy Ghost, of whom the Act cannot be predicated. For though Christ was conceived by the Holy Ghost, yet the Holy Ghost did not conceive him, but said unto the Virgin, thou shalt conceive.1 There remaineth therefore nothing proper and peculiar to this second part, but that operation of the Holy Ghost in Christ’s conception, whereby the Virgin was enabled to conceive, and by virtue whereof Christ is said to be conceived by him.
Now when we say the Conception of our Saviour was wrought by the operation of the Spirit, it will be necessary to observe, first, what is excluded by that attribution to the Spirit; secondly, what is included in that operation of the Spirit.
For the first of these, we may take notice in the salutation of the Angel, when he told the blessed Virgin she should conceive and bring forth a son, she said How shall this be, seeing I know not a man?2 by which words she excludeth first all men, and then her self; all men by that assertion, I know not a man, her self by the question, how shall this be, seeing it is so? First, our Melchizedeck had no father on earth, in generall, not any man, in particular, not Joseph. ’Tis true his mother Mary was espous’d to Joseph, but ’tis as true, before they came together, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.3 We read in S. Luke, that the parents brought the child Jesus into the Temple,4 but these Parents were not the Father and Mother, but as it followeth, Joseph and his Mother marvelled at those things which were spoken of him.5 ’Tis true Philip calleth him Jesus of Nazareth the son of Joseph,6 and which is more, his Mother said unto him, Behold, thy Father and I have sought thee sorrowing.7 But this must be onely the reputed father of Christ, he being onely as was supposed, the son of Joseph, which was the Son of Eli.8 Whence they must needs appear without all excuse; who therefore affirm our Saviour to have been the proper son of Joseph, because the Genealogy belongs to him, whereas in that very place where the Genealogy begins, Joseph is called the supposed Father. How can it then therefore be necessary Christ should be the true son of Joseph, that he may be known to be the son of David, when in the same place where it is prov’d that Joseph came from David, it is denied that Christ came from Joseph? And that not onely in S. Luke where Joseph begins, but also in S. Matthew where he ends the Genealogy. Jacob9 begat Joseph the husband of Mary, of whom was born Jesus who is called Christ. Howsoever then the Genealogies are describ’d, whether one belong to Joseph, the other to Mary, or both to Joseph, it is from other parts of the Scriptures infallibly certain, not onely that Christ descended lineally from David according to the flesh, but also that the same Christ was begotten of the Virgin Mary, and not by Joseph.
Secondly, as the Blessed Virgin excluded all mankind, and particularly Joseph, to whom she was then espoused, by her assertion, so did she exclude her self by the manner of the question, shewing that of her self she could not cause any such conception. Although she may be thought the root of Jesse, yet could she not germinate of her self; Though Eve were the mother of all living, yet generation was founded on the divine benediction which was given to both together: For God blessed them and said unto them, Be fruitfull and multiply, and replenish the earth.10 Though Christ was promised as the seed of the woman, yet we must not imagine that it was in the power of woman to conceive him. When the Virgin thinks it impossible she should conceive, because she knew not a man, at the same time she confesseth it otherwise as impossible, and the Angel acknowledgeth as much in the satisfaction of his answer, For with God nothing shall be impossible.11 God then it was who immediately and miraculously enabled the blessed Virgin to conceive our Saviour; and while Mary, Joseph, and all men are denied, no person which is that God can be excluded from that operation.
But what is included in the conception by the Holy Ghost, or how his operation is to be distinguished from the conception of the Virgin, is not so easily determined. The words by which it is expressed in Scriptures are very generall: first, as they are delivered by way of promise, prediction, or satisfaction to Mary, The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee;12 secondly, as they suppose the conception already past, when his Mother Mary was espoused to Joseph, before they came together, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost; and give satisfaction unto Joseph, Fear not to take to thee Mary thy wife, for that which is conceived in her, is of the Holy Ghost. Now being the expressions in the Scriptures are so generall, that from thence the operation of the Spirit cannot precisely be distinguished from the concurrence of the Virgin, much lesse shall we be able exactly to conclude it by that late distinction made in this Article, conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin, because it is certain that the same Virgin also conceived him, according to the prophecy, thou shalt conceive and bear a son; and therefore notwithstanding that distinction, the difficulty still remains how he was conceived by the Spirit, how by the Virgin. Neither will any difference of Prepositions13 be sufficient rightly to distinguish these operations. Wherefore there is no other way to bound or determine the Action of the Holy Ghost, but by that concurrence of the Virgin which must be acknowledged with it. For if she were truly and properly the Mother of Christ, (as certainly she was, and we shall hereafter prove) then is there no reason to deny to her in respect of him, whatsoever is given to other mothers in relation to the fruit of their wombe; and consequently, no more is left to be attributed to the Spirit, then what is necessary to cause the Virgin to perform the actions of a Mother. When the Scripture speaketh of Regeneration, or the second birth, it denieth all which belongeth to naturall procreation, describing the sons of God as begotten not of blouds, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God:14 And in the incarnation of our Saviour, we remove all will or lust of the flesh, we deny all will of man concurring, but as the blouds in the language of the Hebrews did signifie that substance of which the flesh was formed in the wombe, so we acknowledge in the generation of Jesus Christ, that he was made of the substance of his Mother.
But as he was so made of the substance of the Virgin, so was he not made of the substance of the Holy Ghost, whose essence cannot at all be made. And because the Holy Ghost did not beget him by any communication of his essence, therefore he is not the Father of him, though he were conceived by him. And if at any time I have said, Christ was begotten by the Holy Ghost of the Virgin Mary, if the Ancients speak as if he generated15 the Son, it is not so to be understood, as if the Spirit did perform any proper act of generation, such as is the foundation of paternity.
Again, as the Holy Ghost did not frame the humane nature of Christ out of his own substance, so must we not believe that he formed any part of his flesh of any other substance then of the Virgin. For certainly he was of the Fathers according to the flesh, and was as to that truly and totally the son of David and of Abraham. The Socinians, who will acknowledge no other way before Christ’s conception by which he could be the Onely-begotten Son of God, have been forced to invent a strange conjunction in the nature of Christ: one part received from the Virgin, and so consequently from David, and from Abraham, from whom that Virgin did descend; another framed16 by the Spirit, and conjoyned with it: by the one part of which humanity he was the son of man, as by the other part he was the son of God.
The belief of this is necessary to prevent all fear or suspicion of spot in this Lamb, of sin in this Jesus. Whatsoever our originall corruption is, howsoever displeasing unto God, we may be from hence assured there was none in him, in whom alone God hath declared himself to be well-pleased. Who can bring a clean thing out of an unclean? saith Job; a clean and undefil’d Redeemer, out of an unclean and defiled nature? He whose name is holinesse, whose operation is to sanctifie, the Holy Ghost. Our Jesus was like unto us in all things, as born of a woman; sin onely excepted, as conceived by the Holy Ghost. This originall and totall sanctification of the humane nature was first necessary to fit it for the personall union with the Word, who out of his infinite love humbled himself to become flesh, and at the same time, out of his infinite purity, could not defile himself by becoming sinfull flesh. Secondly, the same sanctification was as necessary in respect of the end for which he was made man, the redemption of mankind: that as the first17 Adam was the fountain of our impurity, so the second Adam should also be the pure fountain of our righteousnesse. God sending his own son in the likenesse of sinfull flesh, condemned sin in the flesh;18 which he could not have condemned, had he been sent in sinfull flesh. The Father made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin, that we might be made the righteousnesse of God in him;19 which we could not have been made in him, but that he did no sin,20 and knew no sin. For whosoever is sinfull wanteth a Redeemer, and he could have redeemed none, who stood in need of his own redemption. We are redeemed with the precious bloud of Christ: therefore precious, because of a Lambe without blemish, and without spot.21 Our atonement can be made by no other high Priest, then by him who is holy, harmelesse, undefiled, and separate from sinners.22 We cannot know that he was manifested to take away our sins, except we also know, that in him is no sin.23 Wherefore, being it is so necessary to believe the originall holinesse of our humane nature in the person of our Saviour, it is as necessary to acknowledge that way by which we may be fully assured of that sanctity, his conception by the Holy Ghost.
Again, it hath been observed,24 that by this manner of Christ’s conception is declared the freedome of the grace of God. For as the Holy Ghost is God, so is he also called the gift of God: and therefore the humane nature in its first originall, without25 any precedent merit, was formed by the Spirit, and in its formation sanctified, and in its sanctification united to the Word: so that the grace was coexistent, and in a manner connaturall with it. The Mystery of the Incarnation is frequently attributed in the Scriptures to the love, mercy, and goodnesse of God. Through the tender mercy of our God the day-spring from on high hath visited us.26 In this the kindnesse and love of God our Saviour toward man appear’d.27 And though these and such other Scriptures speak properly of the love of God and mercy to man alone, offer’d unto him in the Incarnation of our Saviour, and so directly exclude the merits of other men onely; yet because they speak so generally with reference to Gods mercy, they may well be thought to exclude all merit universally. Especially considering the impossibility of merit28 in Christ’s humanity, in respect of his conception; because all desert necessarily precedeth its reward, and Christ was not man before he was conceived, nor can that merit which is not.
Thirdly, whereas we are commanded to be holy, and that even as he is holy: by this we learn from what fountain this holinesse must flow. We bring no such purity into the world, nor are we sanctified in the wombe: but as He was sanctified at his conception, so are we at our regeneration. He was conceived not by man, but by the Holy Ghost; and we are born29 not of bloud, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God. The same overshadowing power which formed his humane nature, reformeth ours; and the same30 Spirit assureth us a remission of our sins, which caus’d in him an exemption from all sin. He which was born for us upon his incarnation, is born within31 us upon our regeneration.
All which considered, we may now tender a clear explication of this part of the Article, whereby every person may understand what he is to professe, and expresse what is the Object of his Faith, when he saith, I believe in Jesus Christ, which was conceived by the Holy Ghost. For hereby he ought to intend thus much; I assent unto this as a most necessary and infallible truth, that the onely-begotten Son of God, begotten by the Father before all worlds, very God of very God, was conceived and born, and so made man, taking to himself the humane nature, consisting of a soul and body, and conjoyning it with the divine in the unity of his person. I am fully assured that the Word was in this manner made flesh, that he was really and truly conceived in the wombe of a woman, but not after the manner of men; not by carnall copulation, not by the common way of humane propagation, but by the singular, powerfull, invisible, immediate operation of the Holy Ghost, whereby a Virgin was beyond the law of nature enabled to conceive, and that which was conceived in her was originally and completely sanctified. And in this latitude I professe to believe in Jesus Christ, which was conceived by the Holy Ghost.
1 Luk. 1.31.
2 Luk. 1.34.
3 Mat. 1.18.
4 Luk. 2.27.
5 Lu. 2.33.
6 Joh. 1.45.
7 Lu. 2.48.
8 Lu. 3.23.
9 Mat. 1.16. Indeed in our translation whom may relate to both as well as one, and to Joseph as well as Mary, but in the Originall it evidently belongs to Mary. τὸν Ἰωσὴφ τὸν ἄνδρα Μαρίας, ἐξ ἧς ἐγεννήθη Ἰησοῦς.
10 Gen. 1.28.
11 Luk. 1.37.
12 Luk. 1.35.
13 As conceptus de Spiritu S. natus ex Maria Virgine. S. Aug. indeed hath delivered a distinction between De and Ex, after this manner, speaking to those words of the Apostle, Quoniam ex ipso, & per ipsum, & in ipso sunt omnia. Ex ipso non hoc significat quod de ipso. Quod enim de ipso est, potest dici ex ipso, non autem omne quod ex ipso est, recte dicitur de ipso. Ex ipso enim cœlum & terra, quia ipse fecit ea; non autem de ipso, quia non de substantia sua. Sicut aliquis homo si gignat filium, & faciat domum; ex ipso filius; ex ipso domus; sed filius de ipso, sicut domus de terra & ligno. De Nat. Boni. adv. Manich. c. 27. This distinction having no foundation in the Latine tongue, is ill made use of for the illustration of this Article, because in the Greek language of the Testament there is no such diversity of Prepositions; for as we read of Mary ἐξ ἧς ἐγεννήθη ὁ Ἰησοῦς, so also of the Holy Ghost, εὑρέθη ἐν γαστρὶ ἔχουσα ἐκ πνεύματος ἁγίου, and τὸ ἐν αὐτῇ γεννηθὲν ἐκ πνεύματός ἐστιν ἁγίου. It is therefore said as well ἐκ πνεύματος as ἐκ Μαρίας. Again, the Vulgar observeth no such difference, as rendring for the one de qua natus est Jesus, and for the other in utero habens de Spiritu S. Correspondently in the Greek Creeds συλληφθέντα ἐκ πνεύματος, γεννηθέντα ἐκ Μαρίας, or as in the Nicene, ἐκ πνεύματος καὶ Μαρίας. And the Latine not onely de Spiritu S. ex Maria Virgine, but sometimes de Sp. S. & Maria Virgine, and de Maria Virgine. Chrysol. and S. Aug. often de Trinitate. Wherefore in vain have the Schools first accepted of S. Augustines distinction, and then applied it to Christs conception; first taking the preposition de to signifie no lesse then a procession from the substance of the cause, and then acknowledge Christ so begotten of the Holy Ghost, because the eternall Son who was so begotten, was of the same substance with the Holy Ghost. Thus Thomas Aquinas has delivered the subtilty. Sum. p. 3. q. 32. a. 2. In Spiritu S. duplex habitudo consideratur respectu Christi. Nam ad ipsum Filium Dei qui dicitur esse conceptus, habet habitudinem consubstantialitatis; ad corpus autem ejus habet habitudinem causæ efficientis. Hæc autem præpositio De utramque habitudinem designat, sicut cum dicimus hominem aliquem esse de suo patre. Et ideo convenienter dicere possumus Christum esse conceptum de Sp. S. hoc modo quod efficientia Sp. S. referatur ad corpus assumptum, consubstantialis vero ad personam assumentem. But this distinction of consubstantiality and effective causality can make nothing for the propriety of the Phrase; for the Preposition De signifieth the materiall cause as well as the efficient, it must do so in respect of that which is the effect; if require that the thing which is made, be made of the substance of that de quo est, then must Christ according unto that which is made, be made of the substance of the Holy Ghost; or to speak in the words of the Scripture, Quod in ea natum est, de Spiritu Sancto est. where either that which was conceived in the Virgin must be acknowledged of the substance of the Holy Ghost, or else the Preposition De must not be taken in S. Augustine’s sense. Howsoever being there is but one Preposition ἐκ common to both in the Originall Greek; being the Vulgar Translation useth De indifferently for either; being where they have distinguished De and Ex, they have attributed Ex which doth not signifie consubstantiality, to the Virgin, of whom they confesse he did assume the substance of his body; and De, which signifieth, (as they say consubstantiality) to the Holy Ghost, of whose substance he received nothing: it followeth, that the difference in the Prepositions can no way declare the different concurrence of the Spirit and the Virgin in Christ’s conception.
14 Joh. 1.13.
15 As Chrysologus Serm. 57. Ubi Spiritus generat, Virgo parturit, totum divinum geritur, nihil humanum. & Serm. 62. Stupenti mundo solus aperi quid est, quod Spiritus generat, Virgo concipit, Virgo parit.
16 Deus ipsemet ad sanguinem Mariæ addidit aliam materiam, ex quibus deinde Christus conceptus & natus est. Smalcius De vero & Naturali Dei Filio, c. 2. Verum manet generationem & hanc dici posse, quatenus in Deum ea cadere potest, si ad sanguinem Mariæ addita sit ex parte Dei materia, ex qua cum sanguine Mariæ juncta natus sit Christus. Ib. c. 3. What this was thus added to the substance of the Virgin, he elsewhere explaines: Nos Dei virtutem in Virginis uterum aliquam substantiam creatam vel immisisse aut ibi creasse affirmamus, ex qua, juncto eo quod ex ipsius Virginis substantia accessit, verus homo generatus fuit. This he doth not onely, without any authority, affirm, but ground upon it the Sonship of Christ. For so it follows, Alias enim homo ille Dei Filius à conceptione & nativitate proprie non fuisset. And again, Necessitas magna fuit ut Christus ab initio vitæ suæ esset Deo Filius, qualis futurus non fuisset, nisi Dei virtute aliquid creatum fuisset, quod ad constituendum Christi corpus una cum Mariæ sanguine concurrit. Thus while they deny the eternall generation of the Son they establish a temporall in such manner as is not consonant with that Word which they pretend wholly to follow, and have made a body of Christ partly descending from the Fathers, partly not: and whereas as man he is like to us in all things, sin onely excepted, they have invented a body partly like ours, partly not, and so in no part totally like. Indeed some of the Ancients did speak so as to make the Holy Ghost the semen Dei: as Tertullian; Ergo jam Dei filius ex Patris Dei semine, i. e. Spiritu, ut esset hominis filius, caro ei sola erat ex hominis carne sumenda sine viri semine. Vacabat enim viri semen apud habentem Dei semen. De carne Christi c. 18. And S. Hilary calls it Sementivam ineuntis Spiritus efficaciam, l. 2. de Trin. But in this they onely understood the Operation of the Spirit, loco seminis. And whosoever spake of any proper semen, they abhorr’d; as appeares by the 191 Sermon de Tempore. Nec, ut quidam sceleratissimi opinantur, Spiritum S. dicimus pro semine fuisse, sed potentia & virtute Creatoris operatum. I know not whether be the greatest folly; to make the Holy Ghost the Father, as these men have done, by creating part of his body by way of seminall conjunction; or to make the same Spirit Mother of Christ, as the Nazareans did. In Evangelio Hebræorum quod lectitant Nazaræi, Salvator inducitur loquens, Modo me arripuit Mater mea, Spiritus Sanctus. There is onely this difference, that one is founded upon no authority of Scripture, the other upon the authority of a pretended, but no Scripture: the one maketh the H. Ghost a partiall, the other a totall mother.
17 Illud unum peccatum, quod tam magnum in loco & habitu tantæ felicitatis admissum est, ut in uno homine originaliter, atque, ut ita dixerim, radicaliter totum genus humanum damnaretur, non solvitur ac diluitur, nisi per unum Mediatorem Dei & hominum, hominem Christum Jesum, qui solus potuit ita nasci, ut ei opus non esset renasci. S. Aug. Ench. c. 48.
18 Rom. 8.3.
19 2 Cor. 5.21.
20 1 Pet. 2.22.
21 1 Pet. 1.19.
22 Heb. 7.26.
23 1 Jo. 3.5. In quo non est peccatum, ipse venit auferre peccatum. Nam si esset in illo peccatum, auferendum esset illi, non ipse auferret. S. Aug.
24 By S. Augustine. Ex hoc, quod de Sp. S. est secundum hominem nativitas Christi, quid aliud, quam ipsa gratia, demonstratur? Ench. c. 37.
25 Modus iste quo natus est Christus de Sp. S. non sicut filius, & de Maria virgine sicut filius, insinuat nobis gratiam Dei, qua homo nullis præcedentibus meritis, in ipso exordio naturæ suæ quo esse cœpit, verbo Dei copularetur in tantam Personæ unitatem, ut idem ipse esset filius Dei qui filius hominis, & filius hominis qui filius Dei: ac sic in humanæ naturæ assumptione fieret quodammodo ipsa gratia naturalis, quæ nullum peccatum posset admittere. Quæ gratia propterea per Sp. S. fuerat significanda, quia ipse proprie sic est Deus, ut etiam dicatur Dei Donum. Id. c. 40.
26 Luk. 1.78.
27 Tit. 3.4.
28 Cum ad naturam Dei non pertineat natura humana, ad personam tamen unigeniti Filii Dei per gratiam pertinet humana natura; & tantam gratiam, ut nulla sit major, nulla prorsus æqualis. Neque enim illam susceptionem hominis ulla merita præcesserunt, sed ab illa susceptione merita ejus cuncta cœperunt. S. Aug. Tract. 82. in Johan.
29 Joh. 1.13.
30 Eâ gratiâ fit ab initio fidei suæ homo quicunque Christianus, quâ gratiâ homo ille ab initio suo factus est Christus. De ipso Spiritu & hic renatus, de quo est ille natus. Eodem Spiritu fit in nobis remissio peccatorum, quo Spiritu factum est ut nullum haberet ille peccatum. S. Aug. de Prædest. Sanct. c. 15.
31 Nolite desperare; quod semel natum est ex Maria, quotidie & in nobis nascitur. Hiero. Comm. in Psal. 84.17.